HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation ReportCOR8POSlTESCORES
RFP 678364
Employee Benefit Consulting Services
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
SELECTION PROPOSERS MaKiMUM Maximum Total Trion Group, a Marsh USI Insurance
CRITERIA P0111tq Per Points AON Consulting, Inc. Bolton Paitners, Inc
Member (5.rnetnbors) & McLennan Agency Services, LLC.
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifiCatiOnS, alld 35 175 1513.50 152-95 111.90 160.50
past performance
Relevant experience avid qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel that will be 10 so 45.50 48.70
assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation arid ability to meet 3D 150 13B.60 124.70
schedules
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS T5 375 342.60 32635
Proposer's Propused Price 25 125 luo-00 86.75
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(r erhincat P, Pf tca if)*,ylpove) 100 500 442.60 413.10
RA I
SIGNATURE: PRINT NAME.
771
Chairpeoso
Reviewed �k,
4`.4o
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 878384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Anislca Elliott (City of Miami)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
i
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
and past performance
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
that will be assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
AON Trion Group,
Maximum Consulting, Bolton a Marsh & USI Insurance
Points Partners, Inc McLennan Services, LLC
Inc. Agency
35 35.00
10 10.00
30 1 27.00
35.00
10.00
26.70
31.50
:It
21.00
35.00
10.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 75 72.00 71.70 60.50 75.00
Proposer's Proposed Price 25 20.00 15.00 25.00 15.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS 100 02.00 86.70 85.50 90.00
(Technical & Price rows above)
5717!2017
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Jair Espinoza (City of Miami)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Trion Group,
Maximum
AON
Bolton
a Marsh $
USI Insurance
Points
Consulting,
partners, Inc
McLennan
Services, LLC
Inc.
Agency
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
35
33.25
30.45
30.80
33.95
and past performance
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
10
9.50
9.70
9.40
9.70
that will be assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
30
27.90
28.50
25.80
29.40
schedules
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75
70.65
68.65
69
73.05
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
22.75
21.75
22.25
22.25
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
100
93.4
90.4
91.25
95.3
(Technical & Price rows above)
511712017
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Rarnona White (Miami -Dade County)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Trion Group,
Maximum
AON
Bolton
a Marsh &
USI Insurance
Points
Consulting,
Partners, Inc
McLennan
Services, LLC
35.00
Inc'
Agency
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
35-00
30.00
20.00
35.00
and past performance
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
10.00
8.00
10.00
9.00
10,00
that will be assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
30.00
30.00
20.00
25.00
30.00
schedules
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75.00
73.00
60.00
54.00
75.00
Proposer's Proposed Price
25.00
25.00
15.00
10.00
25.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
100.00
98.00
75.00
64.00
100.00
(Technical & Price rows above)
511, 7,'2017
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Daniel Gonzales (Miami -Dade County)
SELECTION ----
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Trion Group,
Maximum
AO
Bolton
a Marsh & USI Insurance
Points
Consuulting,
Partners, Inc
McLennan Services, LLC
Inc.
Agency
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
35.00
22.00
33.00
17.00 24.00
and past performance
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
10.00
9.00
9.00
8.00 9.00
that will be assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
30.00
27.00
27.00
26.00 24.00
schedules
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75.00
58.00
69.00
51.00 57.00
Proposer's Proposed Price
25.00
10.00
20.00
25.00 15.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
100.00
68.00
89.00
76.00 72.00
(Technical & Price rows above)
5117UN7
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Sandra RCIiZ (City of Miami Gardens)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Trion Group,
�
Maximum
AON
Bolton
a Marsh &
USI Insurance
Points
ConInc. ' Partners, Inc
McLennan
Services, LLC
Inc_
33.25 24.50
Agency
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
35
12.60
32.55
and past performance
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
10
9.00 10.00
7.00
9.00
that will be assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
30
26.70 22.50
16.50
29.40
schedules
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75
63.95 57.00
36.10
70.95
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
22.25 15.00
18.00
22.25
100
91.2 72
54.1
93.2
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(Technical & Price maws above)
5117)29 17