The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutCRA-R-19-0015 Signed Award Recommendation MemoTit of 4llTiami ANNIE PEREZ, CPPO Director of Procurement March 7, 2019 All Responding Proposers (see Distribution List) EMILIO T. GONZ,4LEZ, Ph.D. City Manager SUBJECT: RFP 830382, Mural Advertising, Miami Entertainment Complex, EUE Screen Gems Studio Dear Proposers: Evaluation of proposals tendered in response to the above cited solicitation has been completed. The Omni/Midtown Redevelopment District Community Redevelopment Agency ("CRA") Executive Director has recommended award as shown in the attached document. This notice is provided in accordance with Section 1.20 of the solicitation, and Sections 18-74 of the City of Miami Code. Our provision of this notice also serves to confirm the lifting of the Cone of Silence from this procurement action as dictated by Section 18-74 (d) (2) of the City of Miami Code. We appreciate the participation of all proposers which responded to the subject action. If you have any questions, please contact me at (305) 416-1949 or pbethel(a�miamigov.com. Since r ly r. P •curenhent Contracting Manager Distribution List: Becker Boards Miami, LLC OUTFRONT Media Miami, LLC Pearl Media of Miami, LLC Enclosure: CRA Executive Director's Award Recommendation Memo c: City Clerk Rafael Suarez -Rivas, Chief Assistant City Attorney Annie Perez, CPPO, Director, Procurement CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM ro : FROM : Jason Walker, DATE . March 5, 2019 Executive Director, Omni/Midtown CRA Annie Perez, CPPO, Director Procurement /4f rn_E SUBJECT : Mural Advertising Miami Entertainment Complex, EUE Screen Gems Studio, Recommendation of Award for Request REFERENCES : for Proposal (RFP) 830382 ENCLOSURES: Recommendation to Negotiate Memo, Score Sheets Based on the findings below, the Department of Procurement ("Procurement") hereby recommends approval for award of a contract for the provision of Mural Advertising Services, pursuant to RFP 830382 to Becker Boards Miami, LLC ("Becker"). The awarded vendor, contract terms, and revenues are shown below. RFP No./Title: RFP 830382, Mural Advertising Miami Entertainment Complex, EUE Screen Gems Studio Project Amount: $335,000 Minimum Annual Guarantee plus 21% Percentage of Total Monthly Gross Receipts Contract Terms: Five (5) years with an option to renew for one (1) additional five (5) year period. Recommended Vendor: Becker Boards Miami, LLC Background: On April 11, 2018, Procurement issued RFP 830382 under full and open competition, on behalf of the Omni/Midtown Redevelopment District Community Redevelopment Agency ("CRA"), to obtain proposals from experienced and qualified proposers to provide Mural Advertising Services. Proposers were required to meet the minimum qualification requirements established in the RFP to be deemed qualified to provide the services. Three (3) proposals were received in response to the RFP. All Proposers were deemed responsive. On May 31, 2018 the Evaluation Committee ("Committee") met to evaluate and score the proposals submitted following the guidelines published in the solicitation. On June 6, 2018 a request to negotiate with the highest ranked Proposer, Becker Boards Miami, LLC ("Becker") was submitted. On June 11, 2018 the request to negotiate was approved. On August 8, 2018 negotiations were conducted with Becker, and after successful negotiations, an award recommendation was issued and approved on October 2, 2018. On October 8, 2018 the City received an intent to protest letter in response to the award recommendation to Becker, by OUTFRONT Media Miami, LLC ("OUTFRONT") and on October 15, 2018 an official protest and filing fee were submitted. OUTFRONT'S protest raised concerns regarding the evaluation of the price proposals and pro forma discussions conducted by the Committee Members. Procurement and the City Attorney's office subsequently reviewed the concerns and felt it in the best interest of all involved to rescind the recommendation to award and reconvene the Committee to hold oral presentations for further clarification. On November 13, 2018 the rescission of the October 2, 2018 award recommendation was sent to all Proposers. On December 5, 2018, OUTFRONT withdrew its protest without prejudice, and the filing fee was returned. On January 14, 2019 an email was received from Pearl Media of Miami, LLC ("Pearl") to rescind its offer and not participate in the RFP. The Committee met on January 15, 2019 to hold oral presentations, and evaluate the proposals following the guidelines published in the solicitation. The Committee completed the review and evaluation of the proposals and determined that Becker was the most qualified, responsive, and responsible proposer. Fiscal Impact: Negotiations were conducted with Becker on February 7, 2019. As a result of successful negotiations, the City was able to increase the proposed Minimum Annual Guarantee ("MAC") of $324,999,96 to a MAG of $335,000.00 which equates to an additional'$10,000.04 annually or a 3.077% increase, in addition to the 21% proposed for the percentage of monthly gross receipts. Furthermore, the MAG will be adjusted upward at the end of each Agreement Year, at a rate consistent with the latest Consumer Price Index (CPI), this CPI adjustment will be based on the CPI Index -All Urban Consumers, Miami -Fort Lauderdale, FL, All items. Due diligence was conducted by Procurement to determine responsibility, including verifying corporate status. There were no performance or compliance issues, and no adverse findings related to Becker. Becker has demonstrated that the firm has the necessary qualifications, relevant experience, and demonstrated past performance, in providing the requested services. Approval of this recommendation is requested. Your signature below will indicate approval of this recommendation. Approved: / �tii Jason tIke ,W Executive Director AP:pb Date: 7 C 19 c: Sandra Bridgeman, CPA, Assistant City Manager, Chief Financial Officer Rafael Suarez -Rivas, Chief Assistant City Attorney Yadissa A. Calderon, CPPB, Assistant Director, Procurement CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM Jason Walker Executive Director, Omni/Midtown CRA Annie Perez, CPPO Director, Procurement January 23, 2019 DATE : Report of Evaluation Committee for SUBJECT RFP No. 830382, Mural Advertising, Miami Entertainment Complex, EUE Screen Gems Studio REFERENCES: EWCL05,ur, Evaluation Committee Score Sheets Recommendation: Based on the findings below, the Procurement Department ("Procurement") hereby request approval to negotiate with the highest ranked responsive and responsible firm, Becker Boards Miami, LLC ("Becker") pursuant to Request for Proposals ("RFP") No. 830382, Section 2.21, Evaluation/Selection Process and Contract Award Background: On April 11, 2018, Procurement issued RFP830382 under full and open competition, on behalf of the Omni/Midtown CRA ("CRA"), to obtain proposals from experienced and qualified proposers for the purpose of providing Mural Advertising Services. Proposers were required to meet all of the minimum qualification requirements established in the RFP in order to be deemed qualified to provide said services. Three (3) proposals were received in response to the RFP. All Proposers were deemed responsive. Other information: On May 31, 2018 the Evaluation Committee ("Committee") met to review and evaluate proposals submitted following the guidelines published in the solicitation. On June 6, 2018 a request to negotiate with the highest ranked Proposer, Becker Boards Miami, LLC ("Becker") was submitted. On June 11, 2018 the request to negotiate was approved. On August 8, 2018 negotiations were conducted with Becker, and after successful negotiations, an award recommendation was issued and approved on October 2, 2018. On October 8, 2018 the City received an intent to protest letter in response to the award recommendation to Becker, by OUTFRONT Media Miami, LLC ("OUTFRONT") and on October 15, 2018 an official protest and filing fee were submitted. OUTFRONTS protest raised concerns regarding the evaluation of the price proposals and pro forma discussions conducted by the Committee Members. Procurement and the City Attorney's office subsequently reviewed the concerns and felt it in the best interest of all involved to rescind the recommendation to award and reconvene the Committee to hold oral presentations for further clarification. On November 13, 2018 the rescission of the October 2, 2018 award recommendation was sent to all Proposers. On December 5, 2018, OUTFRONT withdrew its protest without prejudice, and the filing fee was returned. On January 14, 2019 an email was received from Pearl Media of Miami, LLC ("Pearl") to rescind its offer and not participate in the RFP. Below are the pre and post oral scores. Memo to Jason Walker Chairperson Report for RFP No,830382, Mural Advertising, Miami Entertainment Complex, EUE Screen Gems Studio Summary of Scores: Pre -Orals • Proposer Total Combined Technical and Price Score (max. 600) Proposed Revenue Minimum annual Guarantee Percentage of Total Monthly Gross Receipts 1 Becker Boards Miami, LLC 466 $324 990,96 21% 2 OUTFRONT Media Miami, LLC 455 $360,000,00 20% 3 Pearl Media of Miami, LLC 384 $275,000,00 1 % The Committee met on January 15, 2019 to hold oral presentations, and evaluate the proposals following the guidelines published in the solipitatlon. The final post oral scores and proposed revenues are as follows; Summary of Scores: Post Orals Proposer Total Combined Technical and Price Score (maxi, 600) Proposed Revenue Minimum Annual Guarantee Percentage of Total Monthly tress Recei • is 1 Becker Boards Miami LLC 467 $324 999,96 21% 2 OUTFRONT Media Miami, 11.0 462 . $360,000,00 • 20% 3 Pearl Media of Miami, LLC Rescinded Proposal Negotiations; The Committee recommends that the City on behalf of the CRA enter into negotiations with Becker, the highest ranked responsive and responsible proposer. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Committee further reoommends and requests approval, that In the event the City and Becker are unable to reaoh an agreement, negotiations with Becker will be terminated, and the City will begin negotiations with the next highest ranked responsive and responsible proposer, OUTFRONT, This negotiation process will oontlnue until an agreement, acceptable to the CRA, has been reached, The following Individuals will participate in the negotiations, Pearl P, Bethel, Sr, Procurement Contracting Manager, Procurement Department Islaa Jones, Chief Legal Officer, Omni/Midtown ORA Anthony Balzebre, Assistant Director, Omni/Midtown CRA Consensus Statement; The Committee reoommends Becker for the following primary reasons; 1) The firm provided a proposal that was vary detailed and olear on how they would provide the services requested In the RFP; 2) The firm has the relevant experience, capability, and excellent past performance In providing the requested services; 3) The firm provided a pro -forma that was detailed and clear; and 4) The firm hes a good local presence, Although Becker's proposed Minimum Annual Guarantee ("MAG") is lower than the second ranked firm, the MAG and Percentage of Total Monthly Gross Receipts will be negotiated in the best Interest of the CRA, Page 2 of 3 Memo to Jasoh Walker Chairperson Report for RFP No.830382, Mural Advertising, Miami Entertainment Complex, EUE Screen Gems Studio Copies of the score sheets are attached for each Committee member, as well as a composite score sheet. Approved: Jason Wive Director AP: pb co: Joseph Napoli, Deputy City Manager 'Sandra E3ridgeman, CPA, Assistant City Manager/Chief Financial Officer Rafael Suarez -Rives, Sr. Assistant City Attorney Yadlssa A. Calderon, °PPR Assistant Director, Proourement Page 3 of 3 'SELECTION CRITERIA COMPOSITE SCORES RFP No- 835382 Mural Advertising, Miami Entertainment Complex, FOE Screen Gems St d o- EVALUATION OF P_ROPOSALS PrROPOS.� irrrurc Prc? Per Member FrE HNIcAL CRITERIA tD POINTS Proposer's and its sul oliiectors relevant experience,. �a.-f.ca~tions, and past performance -Ire providing the ape of services described it the soliciL Gon, including I 30 treievant experience and gualit .cdons of key pe sonnet, ire ding key personnel. of sub-cn a Lo s' a vvill he .assigner to this project - • Proposer's management approach and an. to :providing the services requested in the soiicitation, cinc udiing Master Plan, Installation and Maintenance .an, and sharing of sp for CP,. adverEsernents_ _Proposer`s financial chi -Ps, € ro-fonna s ernent: :Minimum Annual Guarantee, and Percent -doe of Monthly ;Gross Recefcs- t Maximum Ti oin€s (5 Members) Becker Boards Vrtani, LLC otEEs1u.ti Mecfiaa &it3mi, u-c LLC Pearl Heck a€llliaas, 150 139 -F34 128 TOTAL POINTS • S:CNA.TURE Chairperson Rc viat d $v 1 OD 150 5co PP.... N.ME J 139 134 125 188 46- 1 455 384 EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No. 83W.82 MURAL ADVERTISING, MIAMI ENTEEzi MM‘IT OMPLXy EDE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Daniel Newhof (atm, of Elam Staff Analyst Principal, Parks and Recreation) SYG'�L{C��SION PRO i •�1 CRITERIA eoA .F p�h3 e"+.'r"..�l�aYte47��m 'Gib ;...44l, � � Irsi Ills ire ..3�J .. .k..x" -1'__!51 '- ` 'F ^� ^' .l, Y��•yy�FH1� F .i 3vs.= 't„ ' BecKe Gilip��rp�c t ��a+.' i, i� ^t!^ r +ri `',. "h �£, 1 i t --, JLL..{ - `�r%' .� ` .y.,Rtn4 ttFr let N al l.`+r`n _ZjV',ht7"'',?Jti A ''i-} .m—,_ "' .`9 �r �z� �'9ie.n % R '!'!' �i'• FeadMledla.e M,ea�i �✓rYti"'4X4. 'L+• "�+ :., _ Ct 'T.,,14 1 wi. 4Y. - �' 'i.T( fit' J.cR R EEC CAL CM-1-1-A. AND POINTS ��s TECHNICAL �$3 Ei S end its 5�36�z=c or [E"c tors relevant exPerien , gm -°a€ ZiQsns, and E o n�:e in cro�dr the £ €� #�ESoC"aI2is s`Y$'£hS ` pipe g $ofrch ony including ri a !LA..sni's. and qu`aimc eons of 1 p:Soir eI, including key personnel os-€aa-cc: a rs ate be ass this 3r ect. ., ••8u"^3 ^^.{a-.. •-y » ."k �' ` " i s� (� 4 .� ,,, `T }`-,-,s ;s° rs'" ,- '3,�r,S+ 1 � •�- RR "z4r,� �$ •.4a,"A f.: L J5 ;^� ,••,„ r , t ,4 _ 'fi'S 2 x� ;5 v ` p y l? w .; ,.� F-`^ ;y :. . :` ". t...�,. „ . ,4 a �i"s�',�, 4'r,:'i:', . �3�'-r`S.."�''�3�',`�_"R;�^ ,�m 'Ks� ,, IF.", Pro is rna. el'[<; approach- card plan providing the sea^ ces req ed :n the solir o! c1uding Plan,ill C at o and MaintenanceY Plan, and sharing of s cs—or CRA advertserne , � t .'tea 7,.+ � ` 1.+ 4 , .. jr.,., � 3 •; .*�• ay. ��ss �wV ki . ,..c.,is^^s�dso- Ao c� y _ x- �w s " sb l }" � - �C'Yw*.2.� : � .,��"�3e '�'"��" �j�,^".f Proposer`s financial capabilities, P_ o sraennent, aranteEy and i""srrf entoge of Monthly Gross 1R1onth y rose R �.�: i f F,. a ,!4". d. °�Gt- F° % � V i..- w„y r,• � "" p' ��'��` �' �" " iy' 19?'ffY 4Na.."1_ F.. .x . Y 4h .'Ti Y _ d ! �G? Cam- ''',4'..,: �yrL a :i" �. `b 24 ,f+ �q a TOTALPOINTS '-' ,4' eg lr � : .Y -s x M Y. 1"' ,art. .�• .._ EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RrFP No. 330 MURAL RT SiYG, MUNI ENTERTAINMENT CO 'LE,.., EUE SCR s-' GOIS STUD C Andrew Schimmel (City of Mama, Senior Project Representative, Deparianent of Real Estate and a Management) S'-'E FriION PROPOSi .. ',:. - ,,,"�- arc.. Ints s" z's74 _ �iJs ux u 35i4�. ri x y"sj- " a'I� ",¢�.�.C, ✓"Y"n ��}ic»..i�tl ig a'*yY[t '�,�"+�'u`rfit..x 6E`CT( CB"o8 •_ r C � y a'z. `. 'a;,, '`�-amr .r..rr; �C'��"s"s"'`��.ah� y e r r;'1' rfi, .t .1•:: , '�'.'"�i1.�� OtdEtont.1N fans. : % .1 e�xgs7 E3.. _ r 3' , .. .3r L ^`�vt 7.,:- tC, �'LGI' "'G. '5..�.)� �'PeaitM ..,�sl �iUGa90 �Le it s W 'f``�.�g4., r�,. OR irERIA.i _j tEv CAL CRl€RRBIAAN i PO N S r '"''r 1 ^� � ��2�t» — F� 11.15S -* ''yµ' „ k Y.a.`.r 'a4: �', `� » Z4 1 -115 + '-�Fe'" s> cry ^sis } •A 4' 3'iw'.�'' * � irk : �k r � .. � �"�� S - a 3 s4E�' �Trr.,.`Rt�V'ti,..C.iP.y,. _x� �� .. YcaY rtr `S , a rzEy� ,�£.c � a+ ` sn a ' f� ��^� rflposer`S and i$S S relevant"ems experiencequ«tfc ens and past peforna tx r$ s L�1Res described }�r.�}i�Y the type of sa `tc�.eS desc thed �a�r iii.'�'. salic sn, including relevant experience a;3Ei gJa�icat[ons of key personnel, k drug keyx personnel sub-ccee: tors be assign this Lta3S oroEec project- . ` '_7-�.,,` `k'b*ti "` 4'wy. ik ' k „wM1wS; T f = — rxit+.2?.•,..c Proposer's management approach and pan to prevWing to ser ces requested in the sel c a n, i_ncltreng Master Plate, installation and Matntena� ��,} ..¢� teqa( Shark Plan, and Shar ng of c 2' -.ace for CRA advertisements.. x [ , ' :-;;. $ : �` :'lL+ncW'�+�i. &� � .pi } S?..-, ,r_ ' 5 ,. "�, 4 4� ; r 4' ' 'i '•�' k h M ,.t 'r F �.,,y�.,(O . �' '„gym' . �n a ProposeF S finanoia ab e.Ss Pro -forma 2man . M ,y . u+ 4[.� * A en , tw - �. 3 . , RMin .. um Annual Guarantees�y,..and Percentage of Mon hlY Gii.3:: ReeeiPt i�'�� , �.. . ;'" ` - y ;St: +D�itEeAi' ' . -.."`IR-w 3. ' �a,�l � ';.:ec L.T....a, klia .....' . TOTAL POINTS { ��rrrr''� , a �'- .'' '_-.ma's- �` EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No. 83O32 MURAL ADVERTISING, MAN ENTERTAINMENT COMPLEX, EUE SCRBEN GEMS STUDIO De_rnys Gonzalez (lliarni-Dade County Aviaons Sens Aviation Property Manager) SELECTION PROPOSERS r h iaaamp r.,c. '. '�- ~: r3 t'.w �cl 2.- +c• sL'C`^ .r�`,•s,�'l�mm��-'�`r�'t�w.. 'F 3� . 5 4� kttz,, btl edict gtrA x' ` YELC.x `,i' -, ,.S�' '--i. ,-...�. 'F" ""f ems"' -� . ..eartlligdwoiiiaam `� . -f- sY iFF1..."e,.`y `TS r ;g .% _ : •; "., c-, 'M iT^c..->, n ,c- - ' S-'rr.`,tw " . •'$i,�":_ A r" i`S" `. t 2''ti�i�r'.�c"'' .r..:ff.`:i'''+iAL=-u a wi3 ��".sl?,''....h�£iz.�c�'.°3.? l;it�.�,� TECHNICAL CRITERIA�yi F.v�I"31 ICA CRI S ERIA' AND C Va!'tt : S �,.. x "'."' a*.tic*.,� � J g:��"� r-:�uvr'�.+s fT"�k� +T�* a��'`z :p�.�_.1 .1f ieiril r'.3�Q .+ -K': :.4i�i..., 9 "'£. w i - 3"~ �L; � i �-�ttom�.. t "C..Fi*i t fi"+ '. �` ,y . , e %, a -#`^' -+«'d ,, ,t• 'v ,1,-- G' .rlrnC .� " ,_c�, # v,7 � F� `'' +..p 3 59. G 1 .Fs-. .a�,,�^+ a . r ` 'ar` 4 .��e.�.:',i e�Lt hr eX r,* P,.. 5 r34, x^ �`r . a .: 7) ? 3 :� 1 r� P s anti Its sub— :ontra ors' relevant nerves oEia fitf"a'(Lons, and SE performance i providing the type services described the :�p+ ^Cc.'•�, �'��.. Yy' 41,2...,at ,xY ., i. F x'E:r..sa •r�r W � 1 p� Fy , - - hy, S, ':ei.^w ._r.:.�n....3c'a._ : n`! tk. snick iion Including relevantexper�,e�a a'I? quaff-P -0ns of key personnel, including key iinnel of sub -contractors' C i will be assigned to [-this p o" .t 3.M•jiC.w7�Wr�.R ' e-E44 3'" i' '_P".C- .. a 23� . e� �,�G� �5» Y kM1V�,' .Y +K .'�,. ie-)n4 r , p 7u / 1 p - .. k: .. 'w _ d - ..1 ...f c. viSo Y.. ee:r. .•~F :'3F ^i+S. eat L'i C�1?' Yti ay.eS P oposes s lenient approach and plan to proving a Se requested n the 5� �+ ri S inciFic ing ter Pis 3� on aril Maintenance [ Plan a sharing of Space for2 'e'"'� _Iiieaai _ .;fir.- a«, �. rs ,F t F x� �� 5 _ i-:_ 3�e"+' a � w � " � t" 'kf"C �._._ . zr , } t G-A3,1:7 AP ..' ' x '1,,ttx ; N �,: 3 k '# "a r A. '�3'A:wa plc y -^ `� "-�` .+ ra , a : r .. rttl9a s ' `- Pm; oser's financial capabsa es Pro -forum statement, MIIIImarn Annual GEIaran#ee and Percentage of Mon Gross Receipts. ?' � '�x . n y �p . a" s €; dc� ' !yx'i GCS ¢ T M1 z .. c i� � {� � r r8• rx �7�..-^ Par,* - ilk C `as5 TOTAL POINTS : � @ ,n � -- , - �, -. EVALUATION OF PROPOiAL RFP No_ 1 MURAL A3i�TISING, EN RT JN a9 NT C3OP`zc ; EUE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Doris a7acPilerson fanalni-Dade County of Mann - mid iget, Revenue Devsar eri ..:.cal€ ..S E.T'ON PROPOSERS �� i sT +�td2�.iT".v....C' ^ �3^ .�. 3^�DiM:'. ...1.d'r 5.=.5' {`fit t x 7 ��s_ ' a r .�.Z .... '.1L�+'G" 1"k - '. 'i` 1 ii • � �.w`'�CG'' d'""l�5 J}.' ,11 -r"`."µ...L ,:,- Y .yy i Y' '1 TECHNICAL C ITERIAJ POINTS Prroposer's and t`ssub-Coif acto ' relevant experience, {}U2I.i _cations and past pe f*r c't in �Sc'c' nd:niC, j the zype of S%rd'v�eS. desc in 'a I"ic�on, �€I: d ng eeie� expe �sce • `ff ,5c1i ' 9 � tF, `,,i++� K `5. � a �1 r M � 1 . ^`s,. 1.� �''4, � a n �y t a Y ..„ti< `3r y a u :.s--.F-. ; `' � s r �aA� s �+x � ea I ct �^ t L 4 N.I .� ,�-- q,`' P. S i' } . N,+` • "' k+'; . 41.\� :-• .aF. ,. .0'" ", j'- /es. 'i ',�-.y d'. ;� .. �'. Cf'sxi : of key SSEis'dit E� IEid Rg i0 �.L�� -ma/ of sub-cOuf[eiCA-a `' Y_': he anseFsfe :o this pro.IeE.€'. ., ', 'y `yam" iiati/L' yr�� •C'.0 �aYTi - ; L • 3�...._.. .,' z: '3hw: X'� l ; ..,i.,+z -.:CG�w.... E�SF w�... .9.Y+.. •.rx.,kt�.ypn v'C; .b. _aL P roposer's management rc eh and .. % pr€sy ixding h reams I ; scffca4 on, roof �*. +K+.wr x i k.t z' r m � .", 1'' ' I z w v ' `i' - r.l ��L,4.» �' t �se.cec inciudmg L42aste Plan iL�iden and fga te�1aFncs Plan, and sharing oPs e,e for CR i ad:=esrase€cien . A r L ri Si L ;(ti e '% '� x�^ ."'.4v1., .:."".,�` ..`t,. iw... .._%i+w • Mt.., i.eS-a li:„-- f.-- .3E'S..x! ^_4:3 lus3f ..._ � Ci ��= uF• ^q 4t""4... ' sK.v a+eK Fi.. 6'' -4 ..�2.4 ] "t `f aim ._ "y ' w-. #' vNN.ir ,..x uvy ;¢�A'.�..si. r'x roi.i'i� :;.�w r F ... �Ti�W✓St.^c-`^ '"Al;-2 '�"' }p . s�� 3 cif bt capab p� es ;fro a to s.� ini aaFYt A}; n Ga__aran ae, an Pei ertage of Monthly Gross 34 4A . ra t' ry ." 'rO:ALPOISTv .w EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No.. 830382 ?AURAL AI3 ERTISIlSifs, f•AIAMI ENIERTAINMOIITc PL Y _LIE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Rosy: Acton -(`hare -Dade Co , Capin Improvements P o ec- Analyst) ISiN ?ROPOSERS L�R!E 3 . —� :Tj "roc > _ 7a ..,.ih4� .3XRIICRCK 51. —k f5 ,e .,b ?",:7i`Z•�'S�4x•" Lim' C 'n'�idF"'V`.T.3.' `' u' `a te '��„^'. <`rox �.-L 1'OlfiBlai S. a ai►�, 4,1ss . E* •- ,ate•. s k^�-.. L: f.,. e�:.C,1 PP271� l2 ] � .u"r• t. t3 �,ra'G�= SSecfcer CL r ...sr-" 613,- ram , i TECHMCAL. CRiTERIA. AND POINTS Pr S 3 C € E; ,,�'+ r� �,,;.^ r�� s =L.'Z.Lf.itl e. ors relevant EXeFf9izE:e, qFZciz�Sc4G'EIS, �Tf in y �V� Jr it � '`bCKWiYi";^ s ".•'� Ryry s^ , 3 xs�" `a �' < ' u s ar l y 4 h G „ sv "ksi '�• £a �rv,5".r..�r4 .,'[✓.w� w SCR* »T '..s• past performance providing the type of seances f$escrlbed i the song -A -ion: InclucEng relevant emergence a q a1i1Icca o s of key personnel, If`ich d FE key • • g w5 y, *r , '4 u ��u " gym` m� k , " ; s z � E , a� 7— ' i 5-ca ' s s, � t -4's-- - x ; mwH' r-,tz"' -' ". t j322Sv^�332P. SFB�S-E:43Pt idE GrS4 :ct� !< be assignedto fr r a ` I ..4 , Prop c's Eanagement approach and plan to pr �.�4ddng the=.nrces requested in the sohcrat-on_ E+rt.�i x y ry rt a � i..^"y!a` '---zo , P.� "" K'� f . Y�{Y�i �.'��' '�q[F1.'L a - * , F 4 i.iw including Master Plan, Insiai:a €�r and. Wen Plan and sharing of space for C adverrlsea 6iz5S. rT _ �.zL' '�. .S_ V..; �C `hnce�. ,.��,.�` ��.G. $�T+1 (,. ¢�Proposers SEnenc ai cyaer�p tits. , Pro- osGa.C.sI—Ene-it, M1 LET ndi_Annual Guarantee, nPermniage of Monthly Gross Receipts. �< p*�' r �� ,. em s .. n M .=a S..M.+sY -..p 5s. d {1Y i y� ��, 'S. �Sn 'i {�'A _¢�.kgira'.k 1'tiv'l tT yt. s/�. '`a"Y:`' tt , ? - }4 ;�� 0-4 s s .'�u yY �� .`�� SELECIION CRITERIA COMPOSITE SCORES�� RFP No. 83 382 RALS Mural Advertising, a: Eriierialr ea_t Complex, ELIF. Scree Gems S Rio EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS PROOS TECHNICAL CRITERIA . AND POINTS Proposers and i sub -contractors' relevant experience, qualifications, and past performance in providing the type of servi d scribeed in the so ic! ,n_, budng relevant experience and qt a€ cations of key personneF, including key personnel of sub -contractors' that will Ise assigned to this ps olect. Proposer's management approach and plan to proving the services requested in the solicitation, including ItIaSter Pam, ias alIaton and aintenance Plgin.. and sharing of space for CRA adverrdsemea6. Proposer's financial capabxEities, Pro -forma staftment, ties€ Annual Grantor , and Percentage of Monthly Gross Receipts. SIGMA cb2i TOTAL POINTS RANKENG.. By V PRINT. NAME: • V; C S� j vi C.?Irctic-to 4 .a EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No. 830382—OR S MURAL ADVERTISING MIAMI ENTERTAINMENT MPLEX. EUE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO O Roslyn AIic-Batson-(Mia Dade County MD, Capes Improvements Projects Analyst) SELECTION SELECTION aT O c.i` � �[+�p4.-� Y!� P'- e� K w, 5 , Ci^ .c5". .. "r . ' =t A' r`P L.1 L. i." crs ��'wr 'YY�"H":!' "- x'n� ii. K4�' �'Y `'�'' w..-'L.: s FK+t. Urfa sY ,.,� f+'- "1, 7 kr a s i YS�r......} »n bw +.. t r .J � 4 Ii '{ate' 'xl .C{S'YEw -F Y h 'iv ...t.� i'i-i`� L S ..,-, -- -r edla k i .-, 'Y .... . 4. l Y°L-V . '":' .t� s "..,•,.. '�'. ac: et=775Y",✓:i�'. 1 aci w �oWe� Cl. �f . i�i fix• 5 '' k3 ''+S 21 i - .4, , �+ �u.c �r 9 u- "`lfL„yn y t.-+ i }-�v .:-- !,,i �� f" .» . 3i 1..M:z' 1 y�yC'�O :Q(i E* -`W ' 'ai+.p S..ih�l,i! "+ FD...sG}�' a'...�r�.�.'i «ri�a ''Sa� 3 i ^.'..j. ..'i5 "' S £ ii C'3t' Att#F.r� IVC Miami V �. c i4+�) h.. �' ". y •+.uk:.a 1 z ,rr ° .�Sa LEYi u•+S MT, .V ' `s- j' `�L., ^3. ' +-fG L Y� J=ci ...1�iKaW„1 ., "i; ".+z' x•- alumir**rf=- .. y.'. „ - L�aV "f�"Y " ^'^;Wgiia*'�°• i37.ibG .: TECHNICAL GRITER AND POINTS 4 Prop is and Its sub-�cornfrac ors relevant * ��i �+gj� ��e �ygq ��{_• ps in experience, �b:Qllfica ions�.'3 andpastpa S��La aSl providingthe t e of services described u the d- type ',. � '�j `- e , "' = � "i{-. fIt-k t S � j �'kY. 1 ...-Rin," �" .G - �r 'Y, '''': i1TFe3 d� `i� T� 4 S ^I'� h' ilh-4 •?�'?�' ya.-Grt s �y .0 �.✓ tit. "� 3 ,� �i f T«'faiS 3. y..r... lay, �{..YJ:s"-'y.'� %5F-+;5 r".i-S'C' 3 1+1•�."'..1 i -Y �t i L.l .law M" Y+i L^? § 2z'tn` i. },C.1 ^"L 4•.y�^¢''t+.�-y�-j+-, ''-c"...+a'v...5'".2Y'...'¢3.�^is_'"rg�isxr,..,�,, �3 y fi t L L dt �,; * r ^'A' ..�, .J Y-W. .SY K � 7 3i v':=....., ,4 �e�+S % .N�''1"�'I`} .F,ki�-'L_.:3 x �y � y � � . .. Kt;. �i'4.c. r �p ''-^:- r-a .nW-[ t T s T¢'i" ^5 .3-. „v.+ -ux n '212 —" "3 r..Gt' c� "'.• 1" '' ft b'3—W'V>.1 . .1 .., r!' µ.(.3.+:11 6C, ,� 4t -.` `"33'-'�..f"J.� i�.3 3 A.c w�a.wEL'*..+V;•y'9'1... a+..-� �( ..�' �� `^� K...� L f d� %I ° ."eR' �' y. ' 7 ?''','�' 7 7'" � • . �-,- . T•i. i. ;.�T.T- x-.4 it � soIca ror including relevant experience and �+ �gg�� ,�,�^^, /��gy�yyg�a of r pia including �Siia fi +6iL ons key personnel,inc1 lB i g ker l b� n d t... ys that personnelsub-contractors' /eAJV{GnGE ofJi�di+'-61VSYLr� ®i �; will i ®,xe6Y 8'S� SQL V it EsiSg'...r8aR�E+3`+fS'++_. � �. � k�.� ..(h*4-. s4`.4 i.}{i 3 KK1'�a''''^.PS '. �� n �. .. w�.y� d" ? dce"�`^^ y . {.Yu. ��x:i �b� Y 4 s4[Y� i -cd:ta+�� 1�+ n,�s g 7� P po e s managementap approach and pia to pro idin(� the services requested m the solicitation, I"' �+ `�1 3 ueX including Master Plan, Installation and Maintenance Plans and sharing of space for CRAadvertisements. •.•.`'...f... l- ° w- .y� "`.#'a` �""'^ .'" ,• yu+ ` na s....w -'�.-Lt; �".F�...'X„ t,�.s�%� `' S t'' ."/ ^`.C� 1 L �-. s "5` f-- Jq an i�,�`rh �` ,- a taw' 4 I.SR K'-� R• - �� E�'+ "'°. `a ° �` � � 'sa '' tin ram ' S"I �v -- w'" +� s.. 3 ,};. < - �' ' 4,4. ''``"`2_i`Kw,c+'�L� z-c{,' �, +A$a+�.:C",1..ri`i '.'�5....L'.' �� - --��,� ,. ..---.opm .2 rr . �2.is'.. i 3.T,,,,'� • t7E'�."�."y' R ` i . - . - 'Y,' 1 .'W3).•'PYt+~ T `i1`SfEr1� a"b-•it ,•,, -i..C' ��33a-iS•i�-T it 3; 3 .> ...,.. +�-^`7'�- "'hL T .Rdo-.-1Y'a%'e.' t 4'„�,.,t�.. Y. , ^E s.d..�... ,.�` -� t Proposer°s � E E financial r at es, Pro -forma statement, MinimumAnnual Guarantee, and Percentageof Monthly Gross , . ;�, 5Y L�a -s--,.. ,: K _ �. - .,?'n rya'' � a-- S 4 t Receip - ar C h:.^- ."%_ _ is- . TOTAL POINTS i{a ''W f ,'4 an\..`'fiis. 'z4 +v "'� • ^' "s-w .z".0 ..Fa' -t a. ,;- aa.r'� :.�a.... •ca rum' -.cam ""'�yg �` - d`".'v. .;,cv via.' Q. 111712019 EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RIP Non 830382 ' ° S MURAL ADVERTISING, MIAMI ENTERTAINMENT COMPLEX, EUE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Doris MacPherson (Miami -Dade County Office of Manag-e? nenf and Budget, Revenue Development Coordinator) SELECTION TION PROPOSERS An v i [s.tttr4 CRITERIA p.' '""j . 9 ..�.Z 4 .Sa n l-r � `a��r..k -^ �p,��, �*a" fi a ��7� �' 7 1''.Z� � S.R` y/vi .i 7'..."x....w ... •cam �_,+y 45`r 'j } ac.1.47; y�'..,.`�'' <. " .'4 '+'L.i$i "� .."y4 y 3 < '`` ✓ ,.. mLm, 12 a. ".i � A , ^ 7 Seckb cards aznc L CT �, sus tc $+?� 'S, r7 ��wq .. �,, n"$v �etS.+.1'�uf `2 v�,w � 4 . ' ,.,T.�+'�....{r�'-Y .,- 2:1 .,�.A i 0,..L� a M.. W '.-4-:-, v ✓ Jr...'5'...3„ 2 '�. d'"v..F* . p• '1 0 x .maws. *P E IfiediaofMIarm h /r `".�-.dry:ri..L r� f rY A 1 y WvV''"Mbr' v' , M'. , u_i :-4�Jp+'7. ...... wra . '4*"-.. . 4 �S+'{� � \ ��...�• aiP iyr► Ip+ $ CRITERIA Yo 36.r ANDPOINTS v� _s��y�y�1.- Tyf�.t}y �}�s y' and its p��,'q i.�, relevant Il opose2 ssub-contra ¢ Ie §Tani n experience, Ld rcations and performance 3 j+" providing the type of service described in the sohcitatio including reie ant experience and �� /�yS -�}-{iy+ a;may_ ;y�� cations Lia! caflons of key personnel,mciuYi includingkey �! x..c li. "2 ,�^..,� �,�'+�.' .�-S'"�'q"w."e�wt`3. y�n4N.F' `xi2an y9 � �J Y �'S. Y"rr^'�"" �!!yy,,zzLiVa,.^�^.'•siX'S .KwX� A �ri � � Y:.4 .,.. .'�' - w3i , �$ ". 1^ � +h � .Z..�J"U • _� -` y„n '2 , ..a, a ::4: Z y ,..; AiLJ y k.5 u" k �`.ks.:' yyiY y trYc S y`; b.>E��"� i L{ � .f� F .!r tt ial M. s .s� . f rt'Rc't".• ii'i4'S-Nti �vu `^ ♦ ^C� '$v.GCF .y .l 4 - �"' Lt.." `71a ��5� t �l' �L .� .L f (.t'•%M" .M'�l.' � k i,�` .. F ..?+' - �, Y ^'^b• Ss�,'�tYiuni Y k.. n'F 's �M�li!lillti'fk �3 _, i4% '^mi+ x r 1�+z Jyry' J r ..}f i. ,. ,,.. X�+.' 'iL .sY.. �t �} =ikFp.... J � 4 n % ri , ..$' 'S... :. .a T +ei.* L... t fi z - Ste" r` y. -} iAA , . wit^^ t '^5'� ^M mt-Ye.2I. s}' -,.„,-„,-,,,wet,,,,,, L.{ .L1�` T 4 +Y .? � L%s ri•3.'.`F"'' ...., '4. --r+.; ..afi we'..-- ' 'f�'EAr"'., 'i w M9na` 1`T4 e.,y"✓, . -- - 't"§ `.$' �. 'v*,- ^ yz`sv-c -i vk y �-. �� it .'�i'` h^ �.kt"''i +^� .+`� GC_ . x1 T.'?� � d ..�.i.'j�M M-y 'nwn '� J..� � C`s' } " °� '.i'�` T k�" W � re- ., !S"c°"^..i'xat3- ' s:a.{-.t?'"�„7i.,"T.R--�i k,� .1 personnel of sub -contractors' that will be assigned to this.�a5' project. i� '�- .'` - �Ti... a.....1a .A 1E^y�iY YMY1. .i%✓� ' ,e" 'y.4 . r 5 C " -' Proposal S management approach # roach and plan to providing the services requested in the solicitation, including• Master Plan, Installation and Maintenance Plan, �y pp�y� + and S�Ial'iYa space for �+� ��¢5� advertisements. 4af�K RLX 9'�iE 6iJeia2T.Y36Na ,}„ t X ..r 4 .._ ., !urT'� .:.k ;,... o ,_ , _•- Y -1 ;P:o 14,1 " .. at "ia �3 nr 5 L� ;� r � i""" r "lT " ^fit I. } =--. s^ � °l L n 7-fr.,--.. ^�` 1.'��i, ,,r. q. u i.� s , t _ � � s t� S * " � „,> }�� S� hn'�w - �� u t'4't �.. t..., ,V, flw • A 3 "�`�' ''S^' t,. "eLi4a' i..f'. _.--.,$ FS r^ aso ` ,,"' £ 7,. .a�� T+BJ��Y�t.. rra .rkk :.L5..� ,�' i �Tu"'" Proposer's financial capabilities, Pro -forma. staterneent, �`a ryp�=4'p Guarantee, Minimum i2121n um r5l■S ual and Perce''LJtag e of andPercentage Monthly Gross Receipts.�. ts.a. �' `i Y�' y.. SF`.il� 3"=�?%`#f• i . �� rz ..,o . � ...Z.."'°.:4 .riiv�^'.'.,? ' S- fi � w � tr :�Xi .:+��* ^�o""' W" 2 ..-F,a,:t" �„ .a .. s {'��. sc i, { yh3^�L -2� rim t '� , _� " ?J cMn`� Y .w'. y... >:A^ 8at'ie" 'S '°yx'7='d ., Ev-^+.K ' , �--,`,�R ;�� s '_ � ��rs, V ibtY�a�+Pe 1L+ T. ��4�MIG6C £' ma, �. d", wa..w�-t- e4at...: _- I ¢'� . jF _ i :�' Jr 7 ..':n'rle rt ...Ke..,.� Y kca ^ ." Y ,, + a.ni' i• mas" '�..... ......2,m. 6: ._, r-.-r ,.. ""'.cf -YX,'.r�---"�.N- ,;,� +,Y `i' A recr/c^ n '�"L.c - w.. .l'<Y"O'" +,. w(.w' K � '+C `.'-.� -- rys� / rh - � .�5`3.F3L ..0 s"weer `- EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No. 2-ORALS MURAL ADVERTISING, SAE ENTERTAINMENT COMPLY ELFE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Dennys Gonzalez (Miami -Dade County Aviat on, Senior Av= at on Property Manager) SELECTION d'tSVPQv7S •X'7t`�ir�.i '.'L yid,. r.;y• "W � 3• ,,'4^ii "t �• - y+- rvt •PYYe�Cw'Y'..,.�..�. � s'*erre> - F `f"+r -� ~/. 3r #ar s"�Becce oar �"�L,., .i" •.�,� p' l«.Z'.'�.6 -.� 4_arl.wr.v. C »� � ixi f .7„"�..�•1• `� lia�ss, y -J• e. .rrn•A' Y'4W.;:.t' {W [�Y .� M4�. L• 'o+X • G 'AS.PT �"' . 5` "�.:Y� +-a .,, •. ,r3 T..k or Ilia a lBliarm ,, �.. i n}rfY`rSr '� '.�•5rw'k .�`.`."wr k �IiY ''Px ,.i C• . `i" 7 H '1 r "Peas Rrteda�f 31 ,� '�3 • -. N +C «. •L' A.•}' Y Vlt CRITERIA. sY� p'r"f 4 j t —�• 4 � c �� ,Ke-,a "b`C "SW ':^1 a °A'"J x-FsYx Ytti ...._ i+^^G.:M^t TT r r `rs,SEr. i tvVllr�d�1 l<C £ - TECHNICAL CRITERIAAND POINTS Proposers andits sub -cant -actors.' relevant @3Pa�ieetP feL; qualifications, and s performance F€ providing the type of s described in the pgp`� 7*;,j��y y k . � `� ..' u,`- 1 -'a.. y,f. � z i .1 t om. ay tS �w..R ia4.x . ,t ^ *yy� "rss � `a.. z._ _, ',Lk- uli�. ... -. U x x va .r 7.it2.. 3n i r- r • •ti...-5.''xte ti €- y+.F�Js Li� t'n� �z b r -h arts Sax N t ti s �' kc ` s- t ` �t �� i l� t K. ..+<. 2 a ;' f `;a. ,lr .lt YT at v,a a•.f U a 4 n"1.� F' �r' •.r x ;� >_ Y $ x TY.I ix 3•• Pi'yu` .� \� .� �;.. s.' �e""C fT `^lj, ri `A Cu. 1r.'+-i. � #' _ c T'y t S K'" '�E. ' •� t i cac. L. ' y t„i' }e.� '"" � f ja }‘ s� �¢ �a and Soh iieraion mcIudi' l eleV aide experience i nce relevant quaIfical ons of key personnel including key L 4 x r. . ii+ Zx2Y tk 3 ...� -'. t rm « �. �� R yRc� eef sub -contractors' that ! personnelI assigneda this prolec. µ.. .»fa+4FS�fi\;��+C�. ... ,�, -�c 3 a \ � BtK s.vi`sc,�-4a.4.•i.j. ....% .'1Lyi`�" �T'c't..KbW 3.4-`T�2 .I,F'.:x�...EL..--.5' .%.t.,i.r �q �, y,, to f .�se$ management ent approach -oC �rll andplan r®clinthe ser` requestedin the solicitation,: including Master mans Installation and Maintenance Plan, and sharing of space for CRA advertisements. $mac . ,. ..i> � .f33 �� F'� W' iSi'� m 'k 3 Y . � •�y. ,..'C"k u -+s x , r 4, 'u t „cr;�'.+.xsY1�s Z<�"...A.— S „ " F J'� ..,�_�, a. ' .vv"�" „r.�'$u.r>v�. .t�.'' Y _ q' .`( r-tb .^�� ,S �ti � r1.3� 2ts � �, K `V a. ` tiac.,,, �. ° hz 5 .+ Cy n.:-� ''1 , . 5 -w.0 � i R..� �1 4 1G,_J'" � �,;,� max,;,, is,5.'�Y""-�t'Si, Y •- -�7r 5 n£.r�.icay ,..t 1� . ,,,,-. t tea+ �� ^^�,'�.�k`agY1i� c�FF 7 °§T�` � �f �� ";rh5'IJ4 �.a 3r IA 2.1fi Proposers financial capabilities, Pro-form statement,Y Minimum Annual Guarantee, and Percentage of Monthly Gross Receipts. 1��W �^.�rcy� Sk� � •�, �, S. =4: r r� ;� 5_ � � T .�.,: � s TOTAL POINTS .. r a a ;r am ,, � r v17ezass EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No. 830382-ORALS MURAL ADVERTISING, MIAMI ENTERTAINMENT COMPLEX,ELE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Andrew Schimmel (City of Milan*, Senior Project Representative, Department of Real Estate and Asset Management) SELECTION ��99�T�jj! CRITERIA •;« .•�«. R y.-P �'fr�, L b L x.}.i+�.i$-.1 . G Y A 71 r'.3 Si e 31.u�� L, �• ,,.-,,,,. �-� GaaecB'O3rdS►)lyF 7�L11.i 'vy t 7Y'" 4f;M fo ri c z -7' our r,„ ? .Y� ..� .F ' is- ter» 1. �. .,,..._ Me sa '' y y} '" ie�' Y:d' 1. •y,,,,z '; x e+'p r+ l-. >t t { �,�, r rs } *,� MM. ia,at 1, yx Y 3 ?.�„ feu y E r .•.� , Kr Z 4 y „� '. .• may' S'v^�,y.i L° +n3�'J,ky' iy� -maax-4-1,4�4.,,, t" it .�,� ` ' �atirT. ,, ,, '�t-`�yw..t_."*yam >.: ..Pi�..v104, '�. �.,,s,,,_.a'a.'Ti ... "}- ± x.OfitEro tih�if;MiamaG re+i r �v,+� gy —� } y - -a, ,,., Yi <,1.?!S rt c, ^4 t4 i ]rY - `..4,.. .:i2'e'�."7i»L�.: 5. � r�"�. . TECHNICAL CRITERIA AND POINTS Proposers and its sub -contractors' ntractors' relevant _ q'�� /� /�pmq��9,y�es� g�+ yy ��99,Af�� ¢¢��..r,��.., {a p�� s E�f� and experience, ufica ofts and past performance iii �'N S F-' providing �e type of sen ces described in the itation, solicIio<i -a inn including relevant experience and _ qIjar of I1epersonnel, including e keykey personnel sub -contractors' a €II be assigr to thisnrolect. =7 - x y Cw� 7p� . `+ate � C t � t.. 'Y 1 -c .- Est a, ry�"o+r .r, �° w ?s t , Yas+r.Mw., � n2 -> yY� a:-f: ES.Y� .i5 rL �,� reL ^"r C 4T` dY i G �,,,„.p K �, ; 5 >Y. Y .2 bN `,><'yy �.t ; , eS F..."'i' R..,.2., `n34rt••--.a� w -Az Gs C5 'Gr ^LjO 4 ,.J�.%� G yJ" bC{ 1 .Ha� M' T , "4 sr ET n^ n F '' CT ,3g1.�'+'�+.�.. MO.$',: ..s, -,,,, 'xs:wis-�'^ ,-v.... -+"` '" ... � '. ^ . .i.. �` �� j a�.:.4�}$ SN CS •Jv'.^. ; - is ' '... d!, �•e�eq a 5 , -��.ye '[�k i.` g . ' ,t-`i -".,, ' ys r 'P %RE L' N 4 � f �"'. �:LS-+�YS...�"iJ`&n.._ � , - ` r-+a�.Yr� s �> `4 0 R f een ua =.4- .. S'. , 4,00 .V,+ „ ig " .. 77 ', F..'.2x�rcrw�aT"sY'uiaFf..r.' �z eLrr., F ¢ iinr� ' ,, - '' '.tay�, .n`2. �"Y'-wu p �- ;� r i'"" �.�,-i�'R+a..U.ap�; �� k: 'i_. prop er=managementapproach and plan to providing the services requested in the solirl including Master Plan, Installation and Maintenance Plan, and sharing of space for CIA advertise nts= �-, A 3k .s �� 4,44.... x .'`" L - .� .w � sf } �r� a.? `^ "' `rn.r cx � y,.�_,y� 3`- 2k'S.. 4: 421 � < try ..s r t_ ��c r` f" .: .i,• 1g `�',' iGir. � eY2 uy� �+f9.S�'2FLr n.G'•'}+n.. ` �z2.- .,c' ,_ ``" '' i.,•• �:<:r . " z _ °h"' �� ,G..Yv..- z�s .'R Lm �"�T"'!.'3 'Y+TLU.0 } 1 tl hY'-c.vc2i.a:Idrt Proposers financial capabilities, Pro -forma statement, 2 niYGuarantee, 6iG 1>�sOi and Percentage LG fi Minimum Annual 9 o f Monthly�'±.� �.�.L,, 2'#fia+ i sl $ Grose RCs�+en ts< _ - . - � - � yy � �S _ ''""""'. �J 'S ki-'-� `° w Y� � 'a „t,J. � .�� ~ 1r 6' ., Sg,�^ � .. :�C Y, 5 • 1. �w....ec?r;x s .:4 w��~ A . - ya s (.1E ,.Z� j-' 4 '.,�,„ '' . g-3,:, :ta'.;':.p' ..ad,.! � .er r. .'.� i`:O'? tt s • • -" TOTALPOINTS !.: 1: is y,(r'-"r M 3sw, G� L YLIY" M.t,,.-.f%. si^. ..,..._Rz,�G ',.• C Yz tl3 mil 1I17I2cii9 EVALUATION OF PROPOSAL RFP No. 830382-ORALS MURAL ADVERTISING, MIAMb ENTERTAINMENT COMPLEX, EUE SCREEN GEMS STUDIO Daniel Newhoff (City of Miami, i Analyst Principal; Parks and Recreation) SELECTION PROPOSERS '° f i' O�� .: x.- w"� r.c •. r .0 ' ``A.^� ra+ y�y� x„-'�-^.r jis '`.Ft,.,a'.,,:.�e, Y ow.. r rl) d + 1GLi'.e-.�^•yxa-,. t w ti"s+r ... e' „' "s=+ �" K x i ,, L , �� x .s-, i s F3y,1 ', ', rk . J t - r" .. ^ O `' 1 At FF '7i��c1i ,. iamb h ,, LttiE 1 w L'T - y"'r^'S' "TRs-..,.. ..x..4'�e.t} „f, c w I WR&'4„. t tr *..r ... f'` xi YTS - p"3`ti Y^te .^t.l�ea�a a �, 3Vliam�L 8. 2 t w ��jj CRITIii�. +ww� ,y„ r ,` .aS.'e,�w'Sr �r .Y .✓°r Sah 7 -,. - :.``ii a tar / ''t"�".'. •''s'�-f' �°f c�""'Sav^X"r ...• �SeskesoadsnEEc --� = h ,MyY D 1 Nh�cs .... p��'� 'At "1- ,y x , �,� T' I '�y- "y --a--i- �;+�. y. = ,5t;t"i'r"`y»�e ,., iR'S(-,t'T'y'"e,� �1 ,.. 'U. F•••-ro.? A,l.�c..IT' "'.�" ti Tit IR1y �: L ,'•441 '""i'' J".�'- .+�.»!. `"2wa f ,,k{"t" '1'�au�'+. 4T' TECHNIC -al, CR ERLR de 3 `�S 14Y CRITERIA �_p`y AND POINTS �y pq,�/��T t Proposer's s andits sub -contractors' re relevant F-�,g g., and r experience,�.YCi3 1 �'i�€6��Sg �.�3"s performance i ss� k provi. a� the type of services described in the .aff ��,� including solicitation, /fie■ 5��$, sy p.� and sollLi{�Ctii®r�i iiIlcIudin relevant Y� experience qualifications of Ivey personnel, 1�4a r�esg including g key3 !S,Sm personnel of Sub -contractors that will be assigned to -' r '' 7yx"13, "' �tS iV� V.S �i.�1+`��,t�O45""i3 X "a ,5^' Fox'`1 Qy- N'" avi .Ij• bC CP�ii(j�"S �+y. ! 'Yp 'v" ! TA.+�.C. a-" t K� ' C } i L„ ^Ydidtr s7' I cam., ...✓.ZS .c s,^ .a�` £ 3 , ✓ fir, c .1 +4o' 'Yf�",.e ' if '�t+*�r,.• kc. ' ��-.3.}^^.-�. . "= ri -� u uFa'~l 53';�Ps7. �-4r'.r'p •�j-t"" F' 4 yq it '(.vim+.L' *.ii a. .v t ..s.'ST.:r ...„. ', z... t '`., `,S. 6, `Y•-a L.� i�,_`Y, -i tP� �4^._.aa_.'^ #^. z s z , , j t� v t ` x x ; ^ � ,� h-F vat Axe l' i... i' Fy M4 r`ay �" % x ' '"'<L}.� Fk� «.46. d a l^ .�'co, f'. x y 31c ta3h -, 'c...-1. W •,4, =�^T {33.4 rt,�"i a¢ "k5fi&,n, ''LY''��'- ChJ S x r '4. .armor: `- yet YK ^..Ya - b � F h -`'.1 1 3'�iF 'ka +xr -. Z Z.Y'_ y ! p �i:4{'0�' ,r , Ii "+xro "i. '�'4 `hyc '!^ ,�q'+R:: ..:Yi, �+ ^rt fzgy LPL { � �� k"tr R. --., bM'-J'-( -, , L.-- s .k S'�.,,xt..'I'I"''+.�'q` ai s4 -.., l� ` 4'$. £"rdl-, Xi.. v -,i y� "�.`'+�k .,• a sr s- y_? ma+ *"ce& ., 'u., ;It L `r^ ;w��r��tt,'F,'y.¢.�.. FX this Gk 41S VLv ie ` '(�14 "�;��t716YbYC ', Pro serrs management approach and plan to yjg�,,�� .^ �� i ��g iEl�". services requested ted in the solicitation. including MasterPlan, �q p� gp andg�-L��_yp� y� iiDYdi.1'6[li1 . Maste6 E Ian5 insta L� � a PLC Maintenance r sharing g gt g �s,� �rt3 a�� `1 space 4r/.$`i C�i'3=F.�'��r •"�' '';' � "",' `"7fi 'v' �'4,p'"G' °" ri T: 1 �, fn�', .£''.i.;-. s- t"'r �s _' ^„, � ��; -_ 453� 5 4. 'S^"'S 5 ' "*'6CLeTh.:l 7;'� .s. 9'r%.,Y • -- '_ .��' � 111kr.'•/ r+•`:)•"G L.. :.5v �,1fiL.S;v 3` s y.,:." `'';y+. e.?+a� ci,:s 'v �w .+..s '4..i'. - d �,.f" .L ,'"' Mi 'ice = r_ ii Errat41. *s-�/.'�/^y,'''.�4A..„ r i ��"'� by �� i k �' <' ,z -,`. � a ".. �" £ ?�^7q .h ^�'�rtrj { "i fit•- �xx"Fa.x' .3-".`G..- ,6 ^gyp 'i. "%r `; '[^ n b5'�id ;� v es =y . ,y GAG' . `"...F .��y"' 'efi :W i3v.i, f"" ,5g >; ' ��,g-,.'7.,,.tsa..�. S+. CNi .,o j,"��.�s,,..a+b �j-... i P3t`'t`YY!snr"av +' 'roh'd-6++ k$F'N+."Y.atkx"+i�1�'i'[i+'Ni>qe�,i#':`FY,i•tMi,.Y�,.�y'Ylii�y`f;(�','M�a.".e�'�`w�,-iti Proposer s financial capabilities, Pro-fonna Siatemer�f 11Y1S1S111�71! V'✓.!:w'4 ��yy�q ,�y��y■��g/��11 Minimum Guarantee, and Percentage of Monthly Gross Receipts. ice. t3 fl { :� �.&.. V r� �� Sid 4 � ��' �v. �l .} M,^�r�.' .^•� ✓�`: tX• g ' it i r t .�; :e sE.. _ ., • og�{��Qy+�.'.... T.•POINTS TOTAL 2.�E� S� •{• i' aX'�+ ti"6.?' �.�_.tj .�}.,+„' x.�+...,'�:v'�>S�• .`�.7n^ 1£,'.,,• ,. YiY•' 4,,,k,-.4�yQ J".';.M^'. .A' r%� �' • t^ ,�, ^ ems+-2'3,tC ' „('� Kh.�.�„,: .-4 ... ..+3" r _ ,M .a- }`^7-` / .i „. iw .mot" 6 .' �x2" .rRs. '10 0 a �`v d'_....'.8 Y'-oar_•- '''' .' �c�'YY..ar. ..�¢? �r ,,f'i'Y...i:+,.�.....-.c.?'Y.!'. ..y J rr--weev flT/2n9