HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRA-R-18-0009 Back upSOUTHEAST OVERTOWN/PARK WEST
COMMUNITY REDEVELOPMENT AGENCY
INTER -OFFICE MEMORANDUM
To Cornelius Shiver Date: January 4, 2018
Executive Director, SEOPW CRA
Subject RFP 17-02
From: Brian Zeltsman, RA " References:
Director of Architecture & Development,
SEOPW CRA
File:
Enclosures: Selection Committee Scoring Sheets
On July 26th, 2017 the Southeast Overtown/Park West Community Redevelopment Agency ("SEOPW
CRA") issued Request for Proposal ("RFP") No. 17-02 for the disposition and development of Block 55,
a 3.44 acre land parcel located at 249 NW 6th Street, Miami, Florida 33136. On September 26th 2017,
the CRA received a total of two (2) responses to RFP No. 17-02 from the following proposers:
1. Downtown Retail Associates, LLC (Sawyer"s Landing)
2. Adler Group (Lancelot Miami River, LLC)
On December 8, 2017, a selection committee consisting of: Ultrina Harris, Keon Williams, David Wilson,
Renee Jadusingh and myself, held an orientation meeting to review the subject RFP and to accept the
two (2) responses.
On January 4, 2018, the selection committee met to evaluate the aforementioned proposals, and ranked
the proposals as follows:
1. Downtown Retail Associates, LLC (Sawyers Landing)
2. Adler Group (Lancelot Miami River, LLC)
Cc: Ultrina Harris
Keon Williams
David Wilson
Renee Jadusingh
Selection Committee Scoring Sheet
Project:
Bid Number:
Development of Block 55 Plat
Book "B" Page 41-249 NW 6th
St
RFP No. 17-02
Score Criteria
Sawyers Landing
Lancelot Miami River, LLC
Development Concept (Max 20
points)
I3
' (
/
Feasibility of the financing plan
and reafistic abillity to complete
the project within the proposed
schedule and with the fewest
financial contingencies (Max 20
points)
r 5
i f
Qualification & Experience of
Development Team, including
experience with projects of
similar scale & complexity (Max
20 points)
7 u
,J
Fulfilment of SEOPW CRA
Redevelopment goals; quality
and sensitivity of design and
compatibility with Overtown and
immediate surroundings (Max 30
points)
25
j'
r
Financial capability of the
Proposer (Max 10 points)
-)
.
�
Total Score (max 100)15
55
Scored by (print) :
Scored by (sign) :
Date:
//9/xy
Selection Committee Scoring Sheet
Project:
Bid Number:
Development of Block 55 Plat
Book "B" Page 41-249 NW 6th
St
RFP No. 17-02
Score Criteria
Sawyer's Landing
Lancelot Miami River, LLC
Development Concept (Max 20
points)
IS
it
Feasibility of the financing plan
and realistic abillity to complete
the project within the proposed
schedule and with the fewest
financial contingencies (Max 20
points)
Qualification & Experience of
Development Team, including
experience with projects of
scale & complexity (Max
20 points)
20
2-0similar
Fulfilment of SEOPW CRA
Redevelopment goals; quality
and sensitivity of design and
compatibility with Overtown and
immediate surroundings (Max 30
points)
Y
l
1
Financial capability of the
Proposer (Max 10 points)
! b
1
Total Score (max 100)211
71
Scored by (print) :
Scored by (sign) :
Date:
iA2,44 awAsi1/4)
Selection Committee Scoring Sheet
Project:
Bid Number:
Development of Block 55 Plat
Book "B" Page 41-249 NW 6th
St
RFP No. 17-02
Score Criteria
Sawyers Landing
Lancelot Miami River, LLC
Development Concept (Max 20
points)
} —1
} 0
Feasibility of the financing plan
and realistic abillity to complete
the project within the proposed
schedule and with the fewest
financial contingencies (Max 20
\7
Qualification & Experience of
Development Team, including
experience with projects of
similar scale & complexity (Max
7f1 nnints)
- C
2 0
Fulfilment of SEOPW CRA
Redevelopment goals; quality
and sensitivity of design and
compatibility with Overtown and
immediate surroundings (Max 30
nnintsl
J 0
2.0
Financial capability of the
Proposer (Max 10 points)
5j
Total Score (max 100)
610
`7
Scored by (print) :
Scored by (sign) :
Date:
���
Selection Committee Scoring Sheet
Project:
Bid Number:
Development of Block 55 Plat
Book "B" Page 41-249 NW 6th
Sr
RFP No. 17-02
Score Criteria
Sawyer's Landing
Lancelot Miami River, LLC
Development Concept (Max 20
points)
1 g
is
Feasibility of the financing plan
and realistic abillity to complete
the project within the proposed
schedule and with the fewest
financial contingencies (Max 20
points)
/ 8
1,5
Qualification & Experience of
Development Team, including
experience with projects of
similar scale & complexity (Max
20 points)
) V
1 0
Fulfilment of SEOPW CRA
Redevelopment goals; quality
and sensitivity of design and
compatibility with Overtown and
immediate surroundings (Max 30
points)
O
�1
/ V
Financial capability of the
Proposer (Max 10 points)
/
! Q
Total Score (max 100)
11 i
6 ef
Scored by (print) :
Scored by (sign) :
Date:
Selection Committee Scoring Sheet
Project:
Bid Number:
Development of Block 55 Plat
Book "B" Page 41-249 NW 6th
St
RFP No. 17-02
Score Criteria
Sawyers Landing
Lancelot Miami River, LLC
Development Concept (Max 20
paints)
r/.4
Feasibility of the financing plan
and realistic abillity to complete
the project within the proposed
schedule and with the fewest
financial contingencies (Max 20
points)
r7
/ i
j(
Qualification & Experience of
Development Team, including
experience with projects of
similar scale & complexity (Max
20 points)
.0
/
Fulfilment of SEOPW CRA
Redevelopment goals: quality
and sensitivity of design and
compatibility with Overtown and
immediate surroundings (Max 30
points)
2 ;I
Q
Financial capability of the
Proposer (Max 10 points)
�}
`�
17—
Total Score (max 100)
99 „
6
Scored by (print) :
Scored by (sign) :
Date: