Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSubmittals at PZAB Mtg (9.20.2023)9/20/2023 RECEIVED SEP 2 0 2023 3o 7Lt Comprehensive Plan Amendment & Rezoning BVM Development (Upper Buena Vista) Design District Studios By: Javier E. Fernandez, Esq. 1 2 ATTORNEYS SMGQLAW.coM 1 9/20/ Fig. 1 - 160 NE 3O 'Terrace Fig. 3 -17 NE 50' Street Fig. 2 - BVM - 50th Terrace Fig. 4 - B VM - NE Corner 3 4 2 9/20/2023 Applicant's Request • The Property consist of 1.33 acres; however, only 0.98 are the subject of the requested FLUM amendment. • The applicant is requesting the following: • FLUM amendment from "Single -Family Residential" and "Medium Density Multifamily Residential" to "Medium Density Restricted Commercial" and "Restricted Commercial; and • Rezone from "T4-L" General Urban Zone — limited, "T4-R" General Urban Zone — Restricted and "T3-L" Sub -Urban Zone -Limited to "T5-0" Urban Center Transect — Open, "T5-L" Urban Center Zone — Limited, and "T4-L" General Urban Zone." 5 Applicant's Request Applicant has presented this request as it believes the project represents one of the best local examples of quality, fined -grained, urban infill development the City seeks to encourage through Miami 21 and stands in sharp contrast to other recent proposals for the surrounding area that are less contextually appropriate and complementary in scale. Approval of the requested FLUM and Transect Designation changes will provide the Applicant with the opportunity to introduce new Uses to its existing mix, incorporate needed off-street parking, and allow the applicant the necessary flexibility to complete the transformation of NE 2nd Avenue Corridor on the subject Block. 6 3 9/20/2023 Proposed FLUM of Property Address Folio Existing FLUM Proposed FLUM 160 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120883 Single -Family Residential Medium Density Restricted Commercial 162 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120820 Medium Density Multifamily Residential Medium Density Restricted Commercial 170 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120810 Medium Density Multifamily Residential Medium Density Restricted Commercial 184 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120780 Medium Density Multifamily Residential & Restricted Commercial Medium Density Restricted Commercial& Restricted Commercial 183 NE 50 Street 0131240150030 Medium Density Multifamily Residential Medium Density Restricted Commercial 177 NE 50 Street 0131240160040 Medium Density Multifamily Residential Medium Density Restricted Commercial 169 NE 50 Street 0131240150050 Medium Density Multifamily Residential Medium Density Restricted Commercial 7 Future Land Use Map Existing FLUM Proposed FLUM 8 4 9/20/2023 Proposed Rezoning of Property Address Folio Existing Zoning Proposed Zoning 160 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120883 T3-L T4-L 162 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120820 T4-R T5-L 170 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120810 T4-R T5-L 184 NE 50 Terrace 0131240120780 T4-L/T4-R T5-L/T5-0 183 NE 50 Street 0131240150030 T4-R T5-L 177 NE 50 Street 0131240150040 T4-R T5-L 169 NE 50 Street 0131240150050 T4-R T5-L 5010 NE 2 AVE 0131240150200 T4-L T5-0 5040 NE 2 AVE 0131240120770 T4-L T5-0 9 Rezoning Maps Existing Miami 21 Transect Zone Proposed Miami 21 Transect Zone T T4 &zzi3O 7:00/0":7#01) TSL '.� l ■ 111111 L IIllIIP Ti.1 J.0 5 9/20/2023 Advances Goals, Objectives, & Policies of the MCNP Policy LU-1.1.7: Land development regulations and policies will allow for the development and redevelopment of well -designed mixed -use neighborhoods that provide for the full range of residential, office, live/work spaces, neighborhood retail, and community facilities in a walkable area and that are amenable to a variety of transportation modes, including pedestrianism, bicycles, automobiles, and mass transit. • The application would serve to further reinforce the positive trend seen along the NE 2nd Avenue Corridor (the "Corridor") of facilitating development redevelopment of well -designed neighborhoods containing a full range of uses that are amendable to a variety of transportation modes. • In the instant case, the Applicants have introduced food & beverage and micro -retailing uses to a portion of the Buena Vista neighborhood previously devoid of such uses. • The change will continue to provide the Applicant with the needed flexibility to further evolve such uses on the Property and provide additional parking on -site in support of the same. 11 Advances Goals, Objectives, & Policies of the MCNP Objective LU-1.3: The City will continue to encourage commercial, office and industrial development within existing commercial , office and industrial areas,... encourage the development of well -designed, mixed -use neighborhoods that provide for a variety of uses within a walkable area in accordance with neighborhood design and development standards adopted as a result of the amendments to the City's land development regulations and other initiatives;... • Objective LU-1.3 is advanced by the subject application as will permit the continued evolution of neighborhood serving commercial uses within a walkable area consistent with applicable neighborhood design guidelines and development standards. 12 6 9/20/2023 Advances Goals, Objectives, & Policies of the MCNP Policy LU-1.3.6: The City will continue to encourage a diversification in the mix of industrial and commercial activities and tenants through strategic and comprehensive marketing and promotion efforts so that designated Neighborhood Development Zones (NDZ), the Empowerment Zone, the Enterprise Zone...and other targeted areas are buffered from national and international cycles. Policy LU-1.3.14: The City will continue to enforce urban design guidelines for public and private projects which shaft be consistent with neighborhood character, history, and function, and shall be in accordance with the neighborhood design and development standards adopted as a result of the amendments to the City's land development regulations and other initiatives. 13 Advances Goats, Objectives, & Policies of the MCPN • The Property is located within both the state Enterprise Zone 1 and the recently authorized federal Opportunity Zone. • Approval of the requested FLUM amendments and rezoning will further permit the diversification of commercial activities and commercial activities within these zones designated by the state and federal governments for revitalization through directed and tax -advantaged investment. Policy LU-1.3.14 is also advanced by the Applicant's request through development of a scale and character consistent with the architectural character of the adjoining historic neighborhood and recently approved changes to the FLUM and zoning transect designations of neighboring properties to the immediate North and recommended changes to properties to the North and East. 14 7 9/20/2023 Advances Goals, Objectives, & Policies of the MCNP Objective TR-2.7: Encourage transit -supportive development patterns that promote walkable, mixed -use neighborhoods that help to increase transit ridership, reduce automobile trips, and provide increased mobility for al! people. Policy TR-2.7.1: The City will preclude land uses within 7 mile of transit corridors...that are not conducive to public transit ridership...Conversely, the City will support the expanded development and design of a transit system that helps shape the desired land use patterns. 15 Advances Goals, Objectives, & Policies of the MCNP Approval of the Applicant's request would serve to encourage the co -location of neighborhood -serving commercial uses along a Transit Corridor thereby reducing automobile trips from residents in the surrounding areas which would otherwise need to seek similar services elsewhere. The uses resulting from the approval of the Applicant's request will also prove conducive to supporting public transit ridership serving the corridor, whether that be bus service along the Corridor or future commuter rail service on the FECI right-of-way. 15 8 9/20/2023 Justification for Proposed Change Given Changed Conditions In recent years, the trend of development has markedly changed in this subarea. Recent development orders have been approved by the City Commission, like the Miarni Jewish Health System Special Area Plan ("CH SAP"), or have received a recommendation of approval from the Planning Department ("Department"), like the Sable Palm Special Area Plan, which have/will significantly alter the residential character of NE 50th Terrace and the low -density commercial character of NE 2nd Avenue in the immediate vicinity of the Property. Such approvals (or pending approvals) represent a significant increase in density and proposed scale/envelop of structures or buildings that can be erected on those neighboring sites. 17 Justification for Proposed Change Given Changed Conditions Surrounding zoning and land uses: Miami 21 MCNP / Density Existing Use Future Use North T5-O / T6-8-OMiami Jewish Systems SAP Major Institutional, Public Facilities, Transportation and Utilities Miami Jewish Health - Hospital Miami Jewish HealthHospital - Hotel - Commercial - Public Areas South T4-L Restricted Commercial f Medium Density Multifamily Residential • Doctor's practice • Vacant lot • Doctor's practice • Avenues School Registration Center East CI Major Institutional, Public Facilities, Transportation and Utilities Under construction Avenues School Campus West T3-L Single Family Residential Single-family residential, duplex residential Single-family residential, duplex residential 18 9 9/20/2023 Renderings of Upcoming Developments Miami Jewish Health 19 20 10 9/20/2023 Preservation of the Miami 21 Goals The applicant's request will advance the following goals of the Miami 21 Code; (i) Growth strategies should encourage Infill and redevelopment (s. (ii) Transportation Corridors should be planned and reserved in coordination with land Use (s. 2.1.3.1.d.); (iii) The ordinary activities of daily living should occur within walking distance of most dwellings, allowing independence to those who do not drive (s. 2.1.3.2.c.); (iv) Appropriate building Densities and land uses should occur within walking distance of transit stops (s. 2.1.3.2.f.); and (v) Commercial activity should be embedded in Mixed -Use urban centers, not isolated in remote single -use complexes (s. 2.1.3.2.g.). 21 Neighborhood Outreach • The Applicants reached out to 10 Neighborhood Associations and held numerous video/phone/face-to-face meetings with 6 Associations' leaders. • A Letter of Support was secured from Buena Vista West Neighborhood Association, the largest Neighborhood Association in the Buena Vista area. The Applicants conducted door-to-door outreach between June and August, answering questions and collecting feedback, securing 350 Letters of Support from individuals and representing 405 properties. 50 Letters of Support secured within the permitters of Buena Vista East (Historic), and 26 in the smaller boundaries (49th- 52nd street) of Upper Buena Vista. • Miami Jewish Health and Avenues School, two businesses immediately surrounding the property, expressed support. 22 11 23 Closing The applicant believes that the requested change is consistent with the evolving character of the sub -area as evidenced by the City's approval of development orders (or recommendations for approval thereof) for neighboring parcels. The requested modifications will further support the continued vitality of the neighborhood - serving retail on portions of the Property while allowing for the future introduction of complimentary uses and needed off-street parking. 24 9/20/2023 VIDEO version (vimeo.com) 25 26 13 ADDRESS ZIPCODE 4949 NE 2 AVE 71 NE 51 ST 33137 5060 NE 2 AVE 33137 5246 NE 2 AVE 33137 5200 NE 2 AVE 33137 4730 NE 2 AVE 33137 220 NE 43 ST 33137 4582 NE 2 AVE 33137 4670 NE 2 AVE 33137 4740 NE 2 AVE 33137 4730 NE 2 AVE 33137 58 NE 45 ST 33137 44 NE 51 ST 33137 67 NE 50 ST 33137 30 NE 50 ST 33137 10I NE 49 ST 33137 137 NE 49 ST 33137 175 NE 49 ST 33137 11 NE 51 ST 33137 50 NE 49 ST 33137 20 NE 49 ST 33137 4030 NW 1 AVE 33127 112 NW 47 ST 33127 140 NW 41 ST 33127 144 NW 41 ST 33127 50 NW 41 ST 33127 401 NW 40 ST 33127 224 NW 40 ST 33127 40 NW 34 TER 33127 58 NW 34 TER 33127 99 NW 33 ST 33127 545 NW 52 ST 33127 LEGAL OWNER LEGAL OWNER AVE FL I OPERA LAND TRUST MIA JEWISH HOME & HOSP FOR AGED MIAMI JEWISH FOR THE AGED INC MIA JEWISH HOME & HOSP FOR AGED MIA JEWISH HOME & HOSP FOR AGED NEIMAN VENTURES LLC HELM EQUITIES BAKER AND BARISTA RFIF LLC SHOKUDO LLC 4730 NE 2ND AVENUE LLC BRETT POLLAK NE 45TH PROPERTY LLC YEHCIR INVESTMENT GROUP LLC LEONSOPHIA LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC ALEXIS SCHLOETER LVR INVESTMENTS LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC 11 NE 51 ST STREET VENTURE LVR INVESTME WILLIAM RIOS UNION CA INVESTMENTS LLC SC1 1 GV LLC BUENA VISTA CA PROPERTIES 1 SA'RAHA INVESTMENTS LLC SARAHA INVESTMENTS LLC ISNARD JEAN L MARIE NICOLE JOSPETRE JTRS LM 26 EXPRESS LLC BJSJ LLC BJSJ LLC BJSJ LLC SFP 2, 0 2023 AL.OVINES.SIGNER NW 52ND PROPERTY LLC STEPHEN R. HANON JEFFREY P FREIMARK JEFFREY P FREIMARK JEFFREY P FREIMARK JEFFREY P FREIMARK KENNY WEINBERGER AYAL HOROVITS CLARA BAIO HARRY BENITAH YOKO TAKARADA KENNY WEINBERGER JEAN SIMONIAN WILLIAM RIOS ILAN SITT WILLIAM RIOS ALEXIS SCHLOETER WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS LUIS A. MARIN CUADRADO WILLIAM RIOS MARIA PALACIO JULIEN LE MARIA PALACIO MARIA PALACIO MARIA PALACIO JULIEN LE JULIEN LE JULIEN LE JULIEN LE JULIEN LE JACK MELKI JEAN SIMONIAN TYPE METHOD BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-S1G BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG BUSINESS OWN E-SIG COMPANY OWl~ E-SIG COMPANY OWI1 E-SIG COMPANY OW1, E-SIG COMPANY OW'Is E-SIG COMPANY OWI, KIM COMPANY OWI` E-SIG COMPANY OWI' E-SIG COMPANY OWI' E-SIG COMPANY OWL' E-SIG COMPANY OWI' E-SIG COMPANY OWP E-SIG COMPANY OWr E-SIG COMPANY OWl* E-SIG COMPANY OWP E-SIG COMPANY OWP E-SIG COMPANY OWI E-SIG COMPANY OWI' E-SIG COMPANY OWP E-SIG COMPANY OWI` E-SIG COMPANY OWI' E-SIG COMPANY OWI E-SIG 501 NW 46 ST 400 NW 40 ST 45 NW 38 ST 53 NW 38 ST 121NW38ST 151 NW 38 ST_ 4031 NW I ST 76 NW 44 ST 75 NW 42 ST 43NW42ST 53 NW 41 ST 118 NW 45 ST 215NW42ST 229 NW 42 ST 235 NW 42 ST 243NW42ST 269 NW 45 ST 254 NW 46 ST 413 NW 46 ST 400 NW 49 ST 245NW49ST 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 33127 4520 N MIAMI A 33127 73 NW 45 ST 33127 63 NW 47 ST 33127 63 NW 4 1bR 33127 4780 N MIAMI A 33127 5016 NW 2 AVE 33127 5001 NW 5 AVE 33127 221NW51 ST 33127 408 NW 52 ST 33127 414 NW 52 ST 33127 54 NW 53 ST 33127 62 NW 53 ST 33127 5300 NW 1 AVE 33127 NW 46TH PROPERTY LLC DAVID DINGLE LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC BUENA VISTA HOMES 2 LLC BUENA VISTA HOMES 2 LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC PRIORITY 1 RETIREMENT LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC BUENA VISTA HOMES LLC BUENA VISTA HOMES LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC JEAN SIMONIAN JEAN SIMONIAN WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW1 E-SIG COMPANY OW1 E-SIG COMPANY OW' E-SIG COMPANY OWI` E-SIG COMPANY OW1 E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW1` E-SIG COMPANY OW1, E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/. E-SIG COMPANY OW1 E-SIG COMPANY .OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/. E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OWr E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY O WT E-SIG COMPANY OWT' E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW? E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW)' &SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG COMPANY OW/ E-SIG 169 NE 53 ST 33137 531 NW 40 ST 3894 NW 3 AVE 5030 NW 2 AVE 5040 NW 2 AVE 169 NE 48 ST 81 NE 48 ST 29NE48 ST 153 NE 47 ST 92 NE 48 ST 65 NE 47 ST 23 NE 46 ST 31 NE 46 ST 59 NE 46 ST 71NE46ST 144NE47 ST 111 NE 46 ST 100NE46 ST 70 NE 46 ST 60 NE 46 ST 44NE46ST 32 NE 46 ST 29NE45 ST 169NE44ST 119 NE 43 ST 26 NE 44 ST 2NE44ST 43 NE 43 ST 7NE42 ST 17 NE 42 ST 80 NE 42 ST 111 NE 42 ST 33127 33127 33133 33133 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 33137 4742 NE MIAIVII 33137 22 NE 51 ST 61NE50TER 69 NE 50 TER 120 NE 50 11 R 114 NE 50 TER LVR INVESTMENTS LLC BUENA VISTA HOMES 2 LLC LVR INVESTMENTS LLC ARMADA HOLDINGS LLC ARMADA HOLDINGS LLC ALEXIS SCHLOETER FRANCES TROD LEYDEN RODRIGUEZ ALBERT FRANK REM ANDREW 1 REM MARINELI JENNIFER L PERSON ANDREAS SCHI KHANH PHAM ZEV PASTERNA VERED SHAMIR PASTERNAK ARNON MAGAL MARISABEL MAGAL TRILATERAL LIVING TRUST VANESSA CORE GUILLERMO FIKSMAN DIAGO DEVIN GRIEF CARLY ROTHLEIN SEAN DORSEY NICOLE DORSEY ANDREAS ULRI SAMANTHA SURLES ANGELIKA ROTHKEGEL DICKSON RICHARD DONALD HARREL JUSTIN TYLER OATES MANUEL E MUNOZ STACY RICHMAN ELIANA ELLER2 ELIANA ELLERN I R JONATHAN M NEUMAN OSVELD DANIS &W HEUREUSE RICHARD RAIM CAROL C ROSE BRETT MCMAN ELISE MCMANAMAN JEFFREY T JERNIGAN JEFFREY T JERNIGAN 80 NE 42ND STREET LLC DAVID BRACHA &W JOAN ROBERT LINDOR WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS WILLIAM RIOS ALEXIS SCHLOEI'ER FRANCES TROMBLY ALBERT FRANKLIN SAVILLE CHAIM LEIBERPERSON KHANH PHAM ZEV PASTERNAK ARNON MAGAL MICHAEL TATE GUILLERMO FIKSMAN DIAG( CARLY GRIEF SEAN DORSEY SAMANTHA SURLES ANGELIKA ROTHKEGEL DICKSON RICHARD DONALD HARREL JUSTIN TYLER OATES MANUEL E MUNOZ STACY RICHMAN JOSHUA ELLERN JONATHAN M NEUMAN OSVELD DAMS RICHARD RALMANN BRETT MCMANAMAN LESLY JERNIGAN JEFFREY T JERNIGAN EFRAIN ZAPATA JAKE BRACHA ROBERT LINDOR 33137 RAYMOND EST RAYMOND & LI LISA ESTIME TI LISA ESTIME 33137 CAMILO PALACIO CAMILO PALACIO 33137 EUGENE SAINT JEAN EST OF 33137 MANI AZERI VANESSA GARCIA 33137 VANESSA GARCIA EUGENE SAINT JEAN EST OF MANI AZERI VANESSA GARCIA COMPANY OWls E—SIG COMPANY OW1, E—SIG COMPANY O WT. E—SIG COMPANY OWI`. E—SIG COMPANY OW1' E—SIG HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER . KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER DAVID HOMEOWNER KIM HOMEOWNER E—SIG HOMEOWNER .. DAVID HOMEOWNER DAVID HOMEOWNER DAVID 10 NE 50 TER 33137 7 NE 50 ST 33137 84 NE 50 ST 33137 145 NE 49 ST 33137 53 NE 49 ST 33137 495 BRICKELL L 33137 720 NE 80 ST 33138 327 NW 45 ST 33127 565 NE 66 ST 2 33138 203 NE 44 ST 33137 54 NW 48 ST 33127 101NE44ST 33137 160NE44ST 33137 160NE44ST 33137 143 NE 43 ST 33137 143NE43 ST2 33137 71NE43ST 33137 80 NE 43 ST 33137 76NE43 ST 33137 136NE43 ST 33137 117 NE 48 ST 33137 101 NE 48 ST 33137 95 NE 48 ST 33137 137NE47ST 33137 101NE47ST 33137 11INE47ST 33137 4726 NE 1 CT 33137 40NE47ST 33137 4NE47 ST 33137 176 NE 46 ST 33137 24NE46ST 33137 138 NE 50 ST 33137 138NE501ER 33137 35 NE 50 TER 33137 45NE50TER 33137 177 NE 50 ST 33137 177 NE 50 ST 33137 166 NE 54 ST 33137 JOSEPH ST HILAIRE &W DIEULA PRIORITY HOLDINGS LLC JUAN JOSE GOI' ALEXANDRA GONZALEZ SHAI YITZHAKI JUAN F ARANGUIZ DORIT NORGAARD JACK H MELKI ROBERT J POWERS FAIDHERE BOYER & EDWIDGE ARNOUX ABRAHAM SCOTT HENDLER OCEAN DESIGN 160 LLC OCEAN DESIGN 160 LLC MEDFORD 143NE LLC MEDFORD 143NE LLC LANDBIRD LLC ROGER GALLAGHER D AND E DIDIER INVESTMENTS LLC DAWN DENARO ANIL & ASSOCIATES LLC LORENA WILLIAMS FRANCISCO ALTIDOR &W WAKENA LLC BYUNG KYU CHOI COREY RYAN SILVERMAN ELLARNORA JOSEPH EVELON BERNADIN MARK A S 1'EPHAN LANDBIRD LLC MAGDA A GRANADA & MAGDA S GRANDA FRANCISCO JAVIER DE PABLO ALICE S M HURLSTON GERENOT MAZARD LE MARIE M MOREL &H DESIGN DISTRIr C/O M & M DESIGN DISTRIr CIO M & M 164 174 NE 54 LLC ROBERT ST HILAIRE WILLIAM RIOS JUAN J. GOMEZ SHAI YITZHAKI JUAN F ARANGUIZ S ILPHANIE SCHULTZ DORIT NORGAARD JACK MELKI ROBERT J POWERS FAIDHERBE BOYER ALEX ABRAHAM LUIS R KATHERIN SCHULTZ ERICK ESPINAL GIANCARLO RUTGER SASKIA MONTEVERDE IVAN PARRONE MICHAEL HOFFMAN JOSE FARINEZ GARY STYE S I'LPHEN SHAW A T GILES PEERZE A MATTHEW OHASHI MADOLYN GEBHART HEATHER N CAROLYN BRADLEY EDDY MICHEL JULIO FUENMAYOR AARLY ZETLON MAYRA GONZALEZ RODNEY BATICHON REM TERESA L MARLENE PIERRE DIEUDONNE DRICE DONALD DOUGLAS DENISE ORELANA MERU S BENOIT HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER HOMEOWNER DAVID LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE E-SIG LONG-TERM RE E-SIG LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-1 ERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE KIM LONG-TERM RE DAVID LONG-TERM RENTER LONG-TERM RENTER LONG-TERM RENTER LONG-TERM RE E-SIG LONG-TERM RE DAVID LONG-TERM RE DAVID KIM E-SIG KIM E-SIG E-SIG E-SIG E-SIG E-SIG KIM DAVID 34 NE 54 ST 33137 60 NW 44 ST 33127 5421 NW 1 AVE 33127 UNKNOWN 8400 NE 2 CT 33138 125NE32AVE 133137 425 NE 22 ST 2904 422 NE 22 ST 121 NE 34 ST 4106 1 ST 313NE59ST 33137 1090 NE 129 ST 350 NE 51 ST 4 161NE23ST10 275 NE 18 ST 33132 489 NE 62 ST 2020 N BAYSHO 33137 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 2000 N BAYSHORE DR 2121 N BAYSHORE DR 1720 BAYSHORE 1717 N BAYSHORE DR 3831 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 3804 1756 N BAYSHORE DR 261 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 1756 N BAYSHORE DR 1900 N BAYSHO 33132 130 NW 69 ST 3126 NW 3 AVE 1831 NW 5 PL 33136 1301 NW 3 AVE 160NW52ST 125 NW 62 ST 33150 1 BISCAYNE TOWER 29 ST 2802 BISCAYNE BLVD 459 NE 25 ST 3252 NE 1 AVE 26 NE 54TH STREET LLC 60NW44ST THE USUAL SUSPECTS LLC PABLO REYES SOCRATES PLATIDES MARK SCHORNITZ AJAYPAL SARAN J1MMY JOSEPH VANESSA PORVAS BORKA. GAMERO LAURA PRICLE PAULIN ANTHONY CAROLINE BORGEN DAVID PERALTA OPRAN BROOKS PETER TAPIR OLEJANDRO OLFARO ALISHA THIAGO GUENRA BENJAMIN GOVBLV RICKEY ARMSTRONG AUBREY SUCREN BONITA GNOSH ALEC RYAN DALY DIANA ECHAVERA JULIANA MUNERA REY THOMAS PARKS SUSANA FERNANDEZ XIOMARA AEONSO MICHAEL KIELTSCH LUIS SABOGAL WILMER MARTINEZ PIERRE POWL LAKYA RISBY GIENNE QUILOTLE JEFFERY FUAROSTO JESSICA STADEMEN MONICA OCROBA DAVID DUHART LAURA JIWARER LONG-TERM. RE DAVID LONG-TERM RE DAVID LONG-TERM RE DAVID E-SIG DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID 129 NE 80 TER 8200 NE 2 AVE 150 NE 79 ST 33138 160 NE 79 ST 33138 128 NE 22 ST 128 NE 22 ST 2600 NE 2 AVE 7600 ABBOTT AVE 520 NE 76 ST 5365 NE 3 AVE 120 NE 71 ST 1786 BISCAYNE 33132 374 NE 80 ST 33138 3027 N MIAMI AVE 850 N MIAMI AVE 5804 NE 2 AVE 33137 20 NW 93 ST 415 NW 50 ST 159 NE 54 ST 313NE59ST 33137 263NB51 ST 265 NE 51 ST 5184 NE 3 CT 4 180 NE 17 ST 33137 237 NE 80 1'ER 33138 150 NE 79 ST 33138 7316 NE 2 AVE 7100NE2AVE 33138 150 NE 79 ST 16(33138 150 NE 79 ST 150 150 NE 79 ST 40! 33138 150 NE 79 ST 29 NE 76 ST 7350 NE 2 AVE 1 33138 150NE79ST50I33141 1553 NW 50 ST 275 NE 18 ST 201 33132 36 NE 61 ST 33137 ANNA MARTIN KELLY FRAGS HENRY LEAL ANDRE LICENCIER JAZLYN FLETCHER JASON GONZALEZ ALEX HAYES LEYLA ESCOBAR ALBA MARIA LORENA QUIJANO FELIPE CAMPUZANO CARLOS ALUS VALERIE ROJAS.PEREZ CHATI TERUSE KEVIN PUSKOR ROBERT ZIEHM TODD HEADLEY RUSKIN PASSARO KEVIN GUILLAUME DAVID PERALTA DAYANA FERNANDEZ DIETER KAFKA DANIEL CHERUBIN FRITHO HILAIRE JOSHUA FERREIRA HARRY DEROLUS VIESOU BURIN HONAL CANTON FRANCISCO SANTIAGO PADRON CLINTON FORBES ANNETTE SMITH IHOR WELYCZKOWSKY RICHARD FAYAD CARLOS ENCARACIOS EVA MARIA HAMILTON ORIANNE TAIRIIMI DREAM EDGERTON DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID 150 NE 79 ST 33138 150NE79ST30S33138 150 NE 79 ST 501 150 NE 79 ST 33138 150 NE 79 ST 150 NE 79 ST 33138 150NE79ST50;33138 150 NE 79 ST 50i 33138 90 NE 56 ST 5700 NE 2 AVE 5857NE2AVE 33137 7835 NE 2 AVE F 33138 150 NE 79 ST 1608 150 NE 17 ST 601NE36ST 275 NE 18 ST 2001 BISCAYNE BLVD 3635 NE 1 AVE 814 488NE18ST. 615NE22ST708 7597 BISCAYNE 33132 493 NE 19 ST 2200 NE 4 AVE 87 NE 93 ST 33130 1566NE110ST 25 NW 24 ST 132 NW 36 ST 13735 NW 4 PL 174 NW 26 ST 3252 NE I AVE 106 2405 NW 43 ST 1209 NW 36 ST 33142 1386NE38ST 33142 532 NW 35 ST 1233NW44ST 403 NW 49 ST 33127 490 NW 36 ST 1280 NW 67 ST, = 33147 JEAN FRITZ MAIKEL FRAILES JOSE SAUCHEZ GAUCHO LUIS R MONRO SORNAN MORALES RAFAELA PINORA MARLENIS KATERINA PENA OSYH JEAN BAPTIS I'E JEAN CADOT JOHN HICKEY GERARDO H. KYLE MAJORIE FRANCEIS GOBASWY HOOCHELO ANDRE MENGES SEBASTIAN LAUB SUZY RICOTTI LUCIJA LAFLEUR M BRIAN GORMAN ORFIA BENI1'EZ BUNKORA DUDMILA DARA SCHUPP DARIO TORRENTE JAMES QUINAZ ANDREW HANSINGER GIOVANNI WEST SANDEA GARTIO NORMA LINARTE DANTE WILLIAMS ABINARL FREITOS JANE WHITE JOHNNY SILVA JOHN MAGALLANES ROSALINA FONI'ES JUAN PELAES FIDES LOPEZ CASTRO ARRON DRIVER LUCIE RETAMAR DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID 1384 NW 29 1ER 460 NW 89 ST 33135 500 NW 31 ST 3501 NW 17 AVE 7620 NW 2 AVE 4 3325 NW 87 TER 8050 NW MIAMI CT 1031 NW 44 ST 33127 1041 NW 44 ST 33127 2311 NW 57 ST 33142 1021 NW 44 ST 33127 1051NW44ST 1169 NW 45 ST 1041 NW 44 ST 33127 6925 NW 28 AVE 33147 6925 NW 28 AVE 33147 6925 NW 28 AVE 33147 1041 NW 44 ST 33127 5150 NW 1ST 1 33142 6828 NW 3 AVE 144 NW 36 ST 4000 NW 36 ST S 33142 7061 NW 29 AVE 33147 9196NW4AVE 33150 2313 NW 57 ST 8 33142 1603 NW 7 AVE 33136 1256 N BAYSHORE DR 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 1800 N BAYSHO 33132 1150 NW 79 ST 638 NW 62 ST 5471 NW 1 AVE 131 NW 77 ST 5455 NW 1 AVE 767 NW 97 ST 33127 146 NW 56 ST 2150 N BAYSHO 33137 2000 N BAYSHORE DR 1110 JORGE L MARTINEZ LULEA PALESE EMMANUEL PIERRE AROJNES ARIAS RICKEY LUCAS PAISLEY SAYLOR ANOLAN MALTET HUGO F JUAREZ BARBARA CASTELLANOS ROJSHREE DOOBAY ELENA MONCADO CHAUNCY JOHNSON STENLY JEANNOT ALFREDO ORTIZ MIGUEL CANELAS TATIANA MARTINEZ GUSTAVO CAS 1ELLON GORMAN AGUILAR LUIS RIVERA BRYAN TORRES ROY ECHEVERRIE DOMINIQUE LOUIS BERNARD HOLLEY ANTHONY PLANED NERVE FROSIER JOSEPH WOMOCHIL VIKTORIJA GOSLIN ANDRES VALDES AMANDA SINGLETEN BRIA RUDOLPH GINA PALLIS S 1'EFAN SENSO PIERRA CASSEUS CAROLUE MUTHIS JULIAN MONTALRO CHRISTOPHER KEY EMILY HIPP MARLENE SERPA DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID 5845 NE 10 ST 301 NW 82 ST 33150 101 W FLAGLER ST 299NW72TER 8324 NW 84 ST 405 NW 10 AVE 6570 SW 37 ST 1629SW4ST 11436 SW 32 LN 33165 8754 W 24 ST 401 SW 6 ST 1717 N BAYSHO 33132 100 BAYSHORE DR 1800 N BAYSHORE DR 1756 N BAYSHO 33132 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 1717 N BAYSHO 33132 1717 N BAYSHO 33132 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 1900 N BAYSHO 33132 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 1408 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 1756 N BAYSHO 33132 2890 NE 207 ST i 33180 2890 NE 207 ST E 33180 1449 ADAMS ST 1145 E MAGNOI 33/115 1531 DAYTONIA RD 488 NE 18 ST 488 NE 18 ST 33132 500 NE 36 ST 150 NE 79 ST 17C 33138 154 NE 76 ST 33187 150 NE 79 ST 33138 7637 NE 1 AVE 33138 DEVON COLLEMON LARRY MARCH FRANCISCO VELK ARNEY ARAGUVER DARREN JULIOUS CECIL ZAPATA ADEJANCHO TIRODO JESUS ZAPATA ARMANDO ROGUE PEDRO MENDEZ GUTIMIO DARIAS DANIDA OSORIO OV MARNI BRUCATO JOSE RODRIQUEZ NINA MASPONS TERINYA DELAROSA JIRI SIHOR ASHANTI JONES RAMPES CARMEN JONES DARIA CHRISTOPHER LEE NATALIA ORREGO BEN THOMGON VANESSA STRACHEN VALERIA ARANIO CARSA CROUGHTON ROMAELLO SFRENCO FRANK GONZALEZ AIMEE JONES DIETHILDE GOMES KRISTEN MILS CECELIA/LILIA ZINGER GREGORIA FRANCISCO ANALIA. LUJAN VANESSA ALTAMIRANO OALA HAMILTTON SHANDIZ SOTO DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID 150NE79ST 33138 145 NE 78 ST 150 NE 79 ST 488NE18ST51[33132 58NE14ST 33132 58 NE 14 ST 33132 300 NE 50 ST 121 NE 34 ST 33127 121NE34ST 625 NE 1 AVE 33157 121 NE 34 ST 245 NW 14 ST 33132 435 NE 23 ST 2900 NE 2 AVE 33137 58 NE 14 ST 1570 58 NE 14 ST 2212 150NE79 ST 2900 NE 2 AVE 273 3701 NE 1 AVE 2209 3131 NE 1 AVE 1 33137 3131 NE 1 AVE 33137 3131 NE 1 AVE 33137 2901 NE 1 AVE 33137 1420 NE MIAMI 33132 3131NE1AVE 33137 3131NE1AVE 33137 3000NE2AVE 60 NE 14 ST 33132 3131 NE 1 AVE 2 33137 2222 NE 2 AVE 156 NE 78 ST A 150 NE 79 ST 15[ 33138 58 NW 14 ST 33132 58 NE 14 ST 33132 1607NE2AVE 1424 NE MIAMI PL 1424 NE MIAMI 33132 58 NE 14 ST JORDAN HAMMER EMANUEL FIGARO CHRIS BENNETT PAULA ALEJANDRO RUEDA NIKIFOROS BARDOUTSO REDGE IVARABLE TOL KUH / TZVIKAH VASILIOS RMATIKIS FRANKLIN LISOSUO HEATHER SMITH NICOLE POLITO ROXANA ROMENO FERNANDEZ JACQUELINE RODRIGUEZ KYLIE TORRES AUISON SANCHEZ ANOIES JIMENEZ MARTA LOPEZ THOMAS MCAULEY GOLVA MELODY VELIUS ANDREA TRAVERSA CHERYL WITINER CAMILA GAS SINGERA ANDRES ASCANA PAULINA GONZALEZ THOMAS WALSH TOMISLAS PAVIS MIRANDA TOSSONA JUSTIN BIANCHINI ALANNA STONE GILBERT FILOAIMO JEFFERY T JACKSON YAIMER JAMES ALEXLY FEBRES NELSON P ERNESTO GONZALEZ ALEJANDRO ROLILS SARAH VINGERBOEDT DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID 58 NE 14 ST 1315 NE MIAMI 33132 60 NE 14 ST 1810 NE 1 AVE 60 NE 14 ST 1123 225 NE 23 ST 275 NE 18 ST 58NE14ST 245 NW 14 ST 33132 150 NE 79 ST 33138 1322 NE 116 TER 169 NE 29 ST 150 NE 79 ST 1005 1800 BAYSHORE DR 1750 N BAYSHORE DR 4504 1756 N BAYSHORE DR 1717N BAYSHO 33132 1900 N BAYSHORE DR 4901 2020 N BAYSHORE DR 2607 1750 N BAYSHO 33132 240 NW 25 ST 33127 233 NW 20 TER 133127 995 NW 84 TER 33150 503 NW 10 ST 390 NW 2 ST 33124 177 NW 32 ST 33127 10750 NW 66 ST 20 N MIAMI AVE 1501 BISCAYNE BLVD 1951 NW S RIVER DR 1100 BISCAYNE BLVD 1500 NW N RIVE 35125 27 NW 60 ST 33127 1758 N BAYSHORE DR 1113 JOHN SUMMIT JARLYN ALVAREZ PABLO LOPEZ GIAMRRANEO RENZUILLI OCEANA ZELENKO NATHANIEL CAS 1'ELLANOS MEALA RIBA SALOAUAR ROJAS RIN FRUGE ENDANIEL MARTEZ JOHN MARTINEZ ERIC WICKRAMASURIYA MICHEL ANDREW SPHAR MARYSE SAFFLE ALEXANDER NAKOS MILLIE SANCHEZ LUCIANO MIRANSA ANN MARIE LASTARNIA ANDY WASIELEVSKI SLABESTANE GABRIEL REZENDO SHIRLEY V GOLDMAN ELIZABETH TEREZ CARLA DURANDISTE VIRGINIA PENA MARIO NANAWJO EILEEN MARTOS MARCO DINEUSUL CARLOS GONZALES NATALIA NOUIKOR MAX LORIA HANNAH VANDERHAFF FEUUA ALCAIDE VIKORYN NIRAULA DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID DAVID AREA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST OTHER OTHER OTHER BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST UPPER BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA WEST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA OTHER OTHER BUENA VISTA WEST OTHER BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST BUENA VISTA EAST UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA UPPER BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA BUENA VISTA EAST -WEST BUENA VISTA OTHER FORM 8B MEMORANDUM OF VOTING CONFLICT FOR COUNTY, MUNICIPAL, AND OTHER LOCAL PUBLIC OFFICERS AST NAME —El RST NAME —MIDDLE NAME MAILING ADDRESS 2©0CVet p 2 V CITY ECUNTY • #U . 1S r 31 DATE ON WHICH VOTE OC URRED NAME OF BOARD, COUNCIL, COMMISSION,AUTHO, L ITY, OR COMMITTEE i'O.V) THE BOARD, COUNCIL, COMMISSION, AUTHORITY OR OMMITTEE ON 'WHICH I SERVE IS A UNIT OF: „'CITY ❑ COUNTY `NAME OF POLITICAL SUBDIVISION, MYPOSi10 iS © OTHER LOCAL AGENCY U ELECTIVE APPOINTIVE WHO MUST FILE FORM 8B This form is for use by any person serving at the county, city, or other local level of government on an appointed or elected board, council, commission, authority, or committee. It applies to members of advisory and non -advisory bodies who are presented with a voting conflict of interest under Section 112.3143, Florida Statutes. Your responsibilities under the law when faced with voting on a measure in which you have a conflict of interest will vary greatly depending on whether you hold an elective or appointive position. For this reason, please pay close attention to the Instructions on this form before completing and :filing the form. INSTRUCTIONS FOR COMPLIANCE WITH SECTION 112,3143, FLORIDA STATUTES A person holding elective or appointive county, municipal, or other local public office MUST ABSTAIN from voting on a measure which would inure to his or her special private gain or loss. Each elected or appointed local officer also MUST ABSTAIN from knowingly voting on a measure which would inure to the special gain or loss of a principal (other than a government agency) by whom he or she is retained (including the parent, subsidiary, or sibling organization of a principal by which he or she is retained); to the special private gain or loss of a relative; or to the special private gain or loss of a business associate. Commissioners of community redevelopment agencies (CRAs) under Sec. 163.356 or 163.357, F.S., and officers of independent special tax districts elected on a one -acre, one -vote basis are not prohibited from voting in that capacity. For purposes of this law, a "relative"• includes only the officer's father, mother, son, daughter, husband, wife, brother, sister, father-in-law, mother-in-law, son-in-law, and daughter-in-law. A "bUslness associate" means any person or entity engaged in or carrying on a business enterprise with the officer as a partner, joint venturer, coowner of property, or corporate shareholder (where the shares of the corporation are not listed on any national or regional stock exchange). ELECTED OFFICERS: In addition to abstaining from voting In the situations described above, you must disclose the conflict: PRIOR TO THE VOTE BEING TAKEN by publicly stating to the assembly the nature of your interest in the measure on which you are abstaining from voting; and • WITHIN 15 DAYS 'AFTER THE VOTE OCCURS by completing and filing this form with the person responsible for recording the minutes of the meeting,.who should incorporate the form in the minutes, * * APPOINTED OFFICERS: Although you must abstain from voting in the situations described above, you are not prohibited by Section 112.3143 from otherwise participating in these matters. However, you must disclose the nature of the conflict before making any attempt to influence the decision, whether orally or in writing and whether made by you or at your direction, IF YOU INTEND. TO MAKE ANY ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE THE DECISION PRIOR TO THE MEETING AT WHICH THE VOTE WILL BE TAKEN: • You must complete and file this form (before making any attempt to influence the decision) with the person responsible for recording the minutes of the meeting, who will incorporate the form in the minutes. (Continued on page 2) CE FORM 813 - EFF. 1112013 PAGE 1 Adopted by reference in Rule 34-7.010(1)(f), F.A.C. APPOINTED OFFICERS (continued) • A copy of the form must be provided immediately to the other members of the agency. • The form must be read publicly at the next meeting after the form is filed. IF YOU MAKE NO ATTEMPT TO INFLUENCE THE DECISION EXCEPT BY DISCUSSION AT THE MEETING: • You must disclose orally the nature of your conflict in the measure before participating. • You must complete the form and file it within 15 days after the vote occurs with the person responsible for recording the minutes of the meeting, who must incorporate the form in the minutes. A copy of the form must be provided immediately to the other members of the agency, and the form must be read publicly at the next meeting after the form is filed. DISCLOSURE OF LOCAL OFFICER'S INTEREST I, Ai` 4-10t 1 o ct t' , hereby disclose that on •15 , 20 : (a) A measure came or will come before my agency which (check one or more inured to my special private gain or loss; inured to the special gain or loss of my business associate, inured to the special gain or loss of my relative, inured to the special gain or loss of , by whom I am retained; or inured to the special gain or loss of , which is the parent subsidiary, or sibling organization or subsidiary of a principalwhich has retained me. (b) The measure before my agency and the nature of my conflicting interest in the measure is as follows: `off � 6 o 1 v P 1-- ff Ut 60.1 1)1,51-6 dC U01 c ds- U1 C l ACM I--tt-v113cv ' A C/ r .:,. If disclosure of specific information would violate confidentiality or privilege pursuant to law or rules governing attorneys, a public officer, who is also an attorney, may comply with the disclosure requirements of this section by disclosing the nature of the interest in such a way as to provide the public with notice of the conflict. / �21 Z? Dat5 File NOTICE: UNDER PROVISIONS OF FLORIDA STATUTES §112.317, A FAILURE TO MAKE ANY REQUIRED DISCLOSURE CONSTITUTES GROUNDS FOR AND MAY BE PUNISHED BY ONE OR MORE OF THE FOLLOWING: IMPEACHMENT, REMOVAL OR SUSPENSION FROM OFFICE OR EMPLOYMENT, DEMOTION, REDUCTION IN SALARY, REPRIMAND, OR A CIVIL PENALTY NOT TO EXCEED $10,000. CE FORM 8B - EFF. 11/2013 Adopted by reference in Rule 34-7.010(1)(f), F.A.C, Th PAGE 2 (31 qzo