HomeMy WebLinkAboutSubmittal-Mel Meinhardt-PowerPoint PresentationSubmitted into the pub
Coconut Grove has been a unified government district since before Miami recor for i em(s) _ s.
on - City Cler
CORAL
GABLES
{
L'
COCONUT GROVE
BIRD
ROAD
A �
%/
FL, Ea. Con.t
Railway Station
GRAND Ave.
BUSINESS
CENTEQ .4
Clifford H. Reeder.
Dr. Peyton H. Hoge--
PUBLIC
c
IRVINGTON-► 0
Cal. Cr.wFord Lalale�—i
POINCIANA AYE,
1
4 Christian Science Church --...LEAFY /�
b A WAY -r f V/,-
��J/
p I. J. Thomas ]
4 lY Kirk Munro✓" K,p
• 0.1 • Tkr Sumhine ReaIl F.asre'
W o• : - UTOPA �
Co.-
-*
4 J rto aD e
ed. Bott _ \\ F,.nklln C. Bushes
erl S. Foae. \ �-
11 wi[hl Cuticr��,2,Hush Mrtbewrr�/1U
0
4
1
3
0
0
TH EATRE
Irvine J. Thomnn Co.
Realtors ---
UNION CONGREGA-
TIONAL CIIURCH
R. C _Mf EKER
.CH CROKEE
1.0011
Ruth Bryan Owen `vt
v
F.
am
N
DKEYR
PAN•AMERICAN
SEAPLANE
DASE
!�
Capt. Richard Carney
j •Leland Hynor
CIVIC CENTER'
Charles W. Emerson
A. B. Gardner
ommodnre R. Munroe
Poole Estate
'Albert Swetland
John B. Semple
FLORIDA ADIRONDACK
SCHOOL
Chauncy McCormick
Matron, Matheson
�yHarry 5. Black E.t.te
Dr. Leo H. Baekeland
Adelaide 8indley D.yid.on
Arthur Curtis James
THE MOORINGS
CYRUS WIC NPR FRANK J. SARMI ENTO
Gustave E. Flips E. NAL WHITNEY
Mrs. Jesse M. Moore FRANK SPENCER,
Henry C. Shimp
E. M. Trimble J
Mrs. Helen Baldwin
Homer Saint Gaudens
Fred Curti.
A. J. Cummins.
Dr. Frank E. Cam
Dr. David F.o kild
Robert H. Schutz
O. E. C. Robinson
i
Mdrs. 5. ooeDal
-Frankrnslin
O
ACo LES
WATERWAY
COCOPLUM
PLAZA
ENTRADA
Paul G. Alexander
P. C. Pearson
Philip H. Faulkner
Mr.. A. Reybine
Mrs. G. C. Rockwood
Robert Henkel
TAR 1T1
bE ACtF
e2P
r
I y q3 -,5L6vit 1-04 fnuanvwwr-cry(-I- cteuAat1.t3-1
Miami Population Growth Areas 2010-
2020
Granada Golf
Course
Iapattah
-41
ry W
work -
Coral Gables
7.1
r
S rTvCitoa#1
•
1
Mal f
Ocean View
Hekghts
1
The Barn.itle
ti+S[Qrl€
Submitted into the pub'
record or ite (s)
on ity Oerk
Source: US Census 2020 ArcGl5
https://www.arcgis.corm/home/webrnapMewer.html?webmap-850e5e8a669a4470a6b9(2b48aecc074&extent 80.2552,25,7804,-80.089.13,25.8572
Concentration of Black families in
Miami
District 4
V 240 St
Coconut
Grove
hiafieah
Miami
international
ni rpD rt
Coral Gab
Submitted into the
recor4 for items)
on
District 5
District 2
City Clerk
Source: U5 Census 2020 ArcGIS
httPs://www.arcgis,cam/homefwe bma phfewer. html?webma p=850e5eSa£r69a4470a6b9f2b48aecc074&extent=-80.2582,25,7804.-80.4898,25.8572
Submitted into the public
reco d or it (0
on City Clerk
Concentration of Black families in Coconut Grove north of Bird
Ave.
Milam's
Supermarket
27th Ave
Flanigan's
Source: US Census 2020 ArcGI5
https:f/www.arcgos,camfhome/wrebmapfviewerttml?webmap=850e5e8a669a4470a669f2648aecca74&axtent=-130.2583 25.7804r80.Q898,25.8572
Divided Neighborhoods are not just a Grove issue
• They burden both Civic leaders and citizens
Example: Douglas Park, The Pines
• eve
to Awr
Ji
re
Silver Bluff
Estates
Ocean View
Heirits
Source:
https://www.arcgis.com/home/webrnap/viewer.html?webmap=85Oe5e8a6
69a447Da6 b9f2b48aecc074& extent=-80.2582,25.78D4,-8a.0898,25.8572
Submitted into the pub
record 'er item(s)
on
City Clerk
Divided Neighborhoods 2021
• Shenandoah North
• Shenandoah South
• The Pines/Douglas Park
• (Fiagarni North and South)
• Civic Center/Jackson
• Wynnwood
• Morningside
• Baypoint
• Magnolia Park
DeGrandy Redistricting Guidance Presentation
to City Commission: 11/15W21
'ti,tbmittcd into the p blic
record nr I fc}
tin "..[ . City C:'crk
TRADITIONAL REDISTRICTING CRITERIA
Compactness (a measure of a district's geometric shape)
Contiguity (all parts of the district must be connected)
Preserving communities of interest (single-family residential, high -density residential areas,
traditional neighborhoods, business districts, coastal or environmentally sensitive areas,
etc,
Preserving the cores of prior districts (to provide continuity of representation and avoid
voter confusion)
Use of man made or natural boundaries when feasible ja river, a major expressway, major
roads such as section lines, roads, or the boundaries of traditional neighborhoods)
Any other non racial or ethnic rational or important city interest,
Submitted into the public A
rec d for it (s) I�
an " City Clerk
Alternative District Boundaries are available.
Reunite neighborhoods previously divided
Preserve communities of interest
- Simplify leadership and civic burdens
- Anticipate growth
Submitted into the publ
record for ite (s) • �"
on `� l City Clerk
ternative Example - A
Analyst Rebecca Quinlan
Hi aril Spring.
Iln al a. sh
District 1
88108
Illustrative Example
Popuiation Deviation °lo
Ideal 88,448
D1 88,108 -340-0,4%
D2 89,623 1175 1.3%
D3 88,993 545 0.6%
D4 88,939 491 0.6%
D5 86,578 -1870 -2.2%
5.0%<
District 4
88939
District 5
86578
m
Distfic1 3
81993.
i
ILI.-,r..i R....IN
2020 DEC R als:r-cting Data tPL £4--17 T is L$ Census at https:'.'ca°.,_:-^.sus - c=__i'
2020 Census Blocks: US Census T1GERtire Shapefiles at
ht ps:Thwwav2_census.gov gea:tiger. rISER2023PLCSTATE 2_FLDR?DA 12
Ba semaa p: Ope n Sttee;Map
Many Alternative District Boundaries are Possible.
1 Compact
1 Contiguous and connected
1 Preserving and uniting communities of interest
1 Preserving cores to avoid voter confusion
1 Using natural and man-made boundaries
o Other important interest
Marini
Internationat
Airpo'`
9f69
District
Population
Deviation
Deviation%
1
88751
302.8
0.34%
2
88355
-93.2
0.11%
3
88201
-247.2
0.28%
4
88441
-7.2
0.01%
5
88493
44.8
0.05%
SUM
0.79%
Submitted into the public
record foritem(s)
on; f +City Clerk
A ternative Example - B
Analyst Abraham Parrish
Miami Redistricting Alternatives ArcGIS
Alternative Map https://arcg.is/1C1CD9
Comparing Alternatives
Submitted into the
record f r item(s)
on /r ),2,
ity Clerk
ae+Grandv 2/22 Alt -A► Alt-B
Compact 1 1 1
Contiguous and connected Ei Kennedy Park 1
Preserving and uniting communities El Grove, Others 1 1
Preserving cores: voters, services 0 Food, Voter access 1 1
Using natural and man-made boundaries 0 US-1, Wall, Metro 1 1
Other important interest 0 No explanation
Sum of deviations ✓ 5.2 est.
5.0% 0.8
Submitted into the pub ir
record Or itern( s)
on ity twler
Schedule, process and deadlines
Christina White
Miami -Dade County Supervisor of Elections
Friday 2/25/22 9:3OAM
March 11th redistricting is "Not a hard and fast deadline."
March 11th is "only a goal".
We could easily wait until next year and any penalty would be
well worth it.
Submitted into the pub
record ilor it6.;n0)
on
Public support and engagement
Petitions 1592 signatures as of 2/24/22
▪ Miarni 1312
• Other Florida 31
• Other US 248
Engagement
• Leadership group 96 members
• Website KeepCoconutGroveTogether
Change.org
• GoFundMe.com
• Blogs
• NextDoor.com
• Facebook groups
• Newsletters
Google Forms volunteer enrollment
ity Clerk
J �L
5 ;Ir._
•L•
rut ra
r'
Submitted into the public
record for items)
tin City Cter<
J