Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSubmittal-Public Comments Submitted Online for the February 7, 2022 Special City Commission MeetingSpecial Commission Report - Final Special Commission Meeting Public Comment - February 7, 2021 February 7th, 2022, 3:55 p.m. EST Public Comment motero@miamigov.com First Name Last Name William Munroe Nancy Ney Sven Stumbauer Susan Silver William Ross Street Address 3164 Mary Street Coconut Grove 4055 Bonita Avenue 1745 Tigertail Ave, Miami, FL 3400 Oak Ave 4140 Poinciana Ave Miami, FL. 33133 Agenda Item SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Public Comment Keep all of Coconut Grove in one district Remove the upper northeast end of district 7 if needed Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. Nancy Ney Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections. . Thank you for considering my position. Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami. DO NOT DIVIDE US....We are a cohesive community!! 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that 11467 Submittal -Public Comments Submitted Online for the February 7, 2022 Special City Commission Meeting james kishlar Sven Stumbauer DI.1 11436 Discussion - 3505 wildwood Redistricting of cr City Commission Districts 1745 Tigertail DI.1 11436 Ave, Miami, FL Discussion - Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. 2. Let's not dilute our community voice: Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. 3. Just say no to dividing a community into separate commission districts: I am strongly against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. James Kishlar 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that ilaria Pezzatini Katherina Komisarjevsky 33133 Redistricting of City Commission Districts 4064 LOQUAT AVE 4288 Lennox Drive DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center, and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. Against Redistricting Coconut Grove Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Against Redistricting Coconut Grove 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner. I vote and pay taxes. Katherina Komisarjevsky Anthony Shareef CORINNA ADRIANA Vinciguerra 4288 Lennox Drive 3325 Charles Avenue 3635 St Malnik Gaudens Rd, Miami, FI 33133 LEVINE VILLA South Le Jeune Road 3900 PARK AVE, Miami fl 33133 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Against Redistricting Coconut Grove 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner. I vote and pay taxes. As a long time Coconut Grove resident, I implore you, our City Officials, to not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami. There is a clear desire on behalf of Grove residents to remain a unified district - commissioners who support the division of the Grove will be acting against the voters will. Please listen to your current, and future, constituents. Anthony Vinciguerra As a resident of Coconut Grove, I wholeheartedly believe that the proposed City Redistricting will damage the cohesive and historical neighborhood we Grovites cherish. Please do not allow the dilution of the most historic neighborhood and village in South Florida. Sincerely, Shareef Malnik (Shareef@theforge.com) 2625 St Gaudens Rd Miami, FL 33133 Coconut Grove cannot be allowed to be spilt up between different Commissioners. The Grove community must be represented and under the accountability of a single City Commissioner. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Kurt Ian Wagner 4151 Park Ave Reiss 4100 El Prado Boulevard Cindy Snyder 3980 Hardie Ave DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Dl.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Dl.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: I am vehemently opposed to any plan that would SPLIT the existing Coconut Mary Munroe Marlene Charles 3564 St. Seabrook Gaudens Rd., Miami, 33133 E rve n Munroe 3066 Washington St 3530 Saint Gaudens Court Coconut Grove, FL 33133 City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Grove voting district into multiple, two or more City Commission Districts. (Amazingly despite the poor noticing of this matter this agenda item has come to my attention. i.e. It has come to my attention and that of other community members, that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by splitting the historic city of Coconut Grove into multiple different Commission Districts. The city of Coconut Grove dates back to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community; the West, Center, Business area, North and South Grove sections should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. The interest of the people of Coconut Grove must prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. This process must take place in a suitably noticed fashion. Initially a date in March was published for a decision to be made with discussions to begin and take place over a prior period of time. The time table to allow for sufficient noticing of the public. Calling for input over several meetings with a redistricting decision to be made at the conclusion of the process. Abruptly this process was abandoned, replaced by an inadequately noticed meeting to include voting on the important matter. To proceed with procedure in this fashion, is both INAPPROPIATE and UNETHICAL. Coconut Grove is a distinct and cohesive community and is older than the City of Miami. Redistricting it would harm our community's ability to promote for a better neighborhood. As a fourth generation resident of Coconut Grove and great granddaughter of Commodore Ralph Munroe, sometimes known as the "Founder of Coconut Grove" I oppose any effort to split up Coconut Grove. Thank you. Coconut Grove is the oldest community in South Florida. It is five years older than the City of Miami. I am opposed to redistricting and especially not having a voice in this effort. Shame on you commissioners. Coconut Grove is the oldest neighborhood in the City of Miami. It was an independent city before it was annexed by the City of Miami in 1925 against the wishes of most of the citizen of the Grove. Splitting the Grove into separate districts will further erode the unique character Walter John rita Walter Ringwald 3940 Utopia Ct Kominoski 2740 SW 28th Terrace, #708, Coconut Grove, FL 33133 kritcher 3866 main hwy 4145 El Prado Gibson Blvd Miami FL 33133 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts of our community, and make it more difficult to coordinate support for Grove issues via multiple commissioners. I strongly urge the commission to resist the power grab and to redistrict such that ALL of the Grove stays in District 2. Coconut Grove is unique, in Miami, in the US and in the World. Its unique features are admired and well-known all over. By definition and because of its specificity, and specific needs, Coconut Grove needs to keep its unity and be defended, preserved, saved - especially at a time when environment preservation is a first priority, when uniformity sadly becomes more and more the norm, and when so much needs to be done to preserve beauty, history, trees, ecosystems, cohesion. It is a duty. I am very concerned and opposed about the possibility that Coconut Grove will be divided into two or more city commission districts. Coconut Grove is a strong, cohesive community with a highly engaged and active population of voters, and it is one of only three neighborhoods in the City of Miami with the designation of Neighborhood Conservation District.. Coconut Grove should not be divided, nor the power of its voters diluted. Coconut Grove is where Miami was born. It is a diverse and progressive community that cares about all people, our environment, and our neighborhood community. If you live here, you understand what it means to be a Grovite. Redistricting is a major challenge in America today. It is not a fair way of retaining communities, and it has been shown to enhance political divisions and extremes. We don't want that to happen to our home. Coconut Grove is our home. Thank you for your time. Vote with your heart and your conscience. DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of Do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting City process. Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Don't divide the community of Coconut Grove. Redistricting of And give the voters an opportunity to study and City comment on the proposed changes to the Commission districts. Districts Miriam MIRIAM Augusta Amber Maria Cristina Wedderburn WEDDERBURN Neal Sreenan Abello 3060 ELIZABETH STREET 3060 ELIZABETH STREET 2431 Tigertail Ave Miami, FL 33133 2987 Bird Ave 2255 overbrooke DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Greetings Commissioners:!sb'jsb_j As you continue to make decisions as it relates to the redistricting of City Commission Districts, it is important to keep traditional communities such as Coconut Grove together, and that there is equity in the repopulation of the Districts. Further, it is imperative that the public have access to redistricting plans, and are afforded the opportunity to participate in the plan selection process at public hearings, meetings, etc. prior to approval of the final plan. [SE_p] Miriam Wedderburn Greetings Commissioners:!sb'jsb_j As you continue to make decisions as it relates to the redistricting of City Commission Districts, it is important to keep traditional communities such as Coconut Grove together, and that there is equity in the repopulation of the Districts. Further, it is imperative that the public have access to redistricting plans, and are afforded the opportunity to participate in the plan selection process at public hearings, meetings, etc. prior to approval of the final plan. [SE_p] Miriam Wedderburn Greetings! Our community is over 100 years old. We are a community. Our interests should be aligned. That will best be achieved by staying together in an electoral district. Thank you for your consideration. Augusta Neal Having lived in several different sectors of coconut grove, it is important to me that we do not redistrict and segregate different parts of the grove. It's an identity to all of us who live here and that it what makes living in the grove special. If it is a matter of resources then the better option is to make this an inclusive process where grovites come together and come up with a resolution to stop this. I volunteer. I Just say no to dividing a community into separate commission districts: WE ARE A HAPPY FAMILY. When ride our bikes throughout the neighborhood, people know you... people salute each other. We have neighborhood block parties. The original Bahamians from the West Grove built with their own hands our first homes, the Barnacle, the historic Coconut Grove Playhouse. Center Grove is the heart of the Community, North Grove and its charming low key, (even if being inundated by massive Carolyn Katrina Louis Susan Susan Donaldson MACEDONIA MISSIONARY BAPTIST CHURCH - 3515 DOUGLAS ROAD 4130 Lybyer Morris Ave, Coconut Grove, FL 33133 Dessaint James Cote 1 Grove Isle Drive #102 3848 Main Highway 33133. 2927 SW 30th Court DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting concrete houses that have nothing to do with its quaint atmosphere), its united. Neighbors know each other, help each other and this goes to the South Grove as well. I am strongly against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I STRONGLY OPPOSE THE DIVISION OF COCONUT GROVE AND SPECIFICALLY WEST GROVE AS PART OF ANY PROPOSED REDISTRICTING. I am a resident of District 2, which has recently been singled out for redistricting after the results of the census. While I agree that District 2 may need to be divided into additional districts, I believe that two additional Commissioners should be added, rather than splitting up District 2 and adding voters to the remaining four Commissioners, the district should be divided into three distinct and homogeneous districts to be divided by causeways as natural dividing lines, ultimately adding two additional Commissioners. District 2 A - Northernmost border of District 2 to the MacArthur Causeway (395) District 2 B - 395 to the Rickenbacker Causeway District 2 C - Richenbacker Causeway to the Southermost border These are three distinct cohesive neighborhood areas. Furthermore, I request that the Commission not take action on redistricting until the voting public has had the opportunity to review the proposed changes and provide inquiry and feedback on such plans. Thank you, Katrina Morris I am against changing any district. I am against redistricting in Coconut Grove. I am commenting on the proposal for the redistricting of District 2 and am against it. As 30 year Coconut Grove residents, both my husband and I do not believe District 2 should Roy Irene Marcia Jamila John Mathew 3837 loquat ave Munroe Proctor Stephens Stephens Dora Stephens 3164 Mary Street 3821 La Playa Blvd. 33133 3181 Hibiscus Street 3181 Hibiscus Street DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts 3181 Hibiscus DI.1 11436 Street Discussion - be split into muliple districts with different commissioners representing us. I believe Coconut Grove residents should have a vote in regards to any gerrymandering that may be put in place. So for the record, two 30 year Grove residents are against dividing up District 2. Thank you for reading. I am opposed to any redistricting of coconut grove I am opposed to the redistricting plan that would divide Coconut Grove. We are a community that should remain as one district only. We are proud citizens who remain loyal to our history and do not wish to be divided. I am vehemently opposed to the redistricting plans the Commissioners are talking about for the Grove! From what I can tell we are united in opposition to this, throughout the Grove. My spouse and I have lived here since 2001, and recent changes seem to imply that we no longer have a voice, in matters that affect us maximally! I am very concerned about the possibility that Coconut Grove will be divided into two or more city commission districts. Coconut Grove has a rich history as the place where Miami started. It is a strong, cohesive community with a highly engaged and active population of voters, and it is one of only three neighborhoods in the City of Miami with the designation of Neighborhood Conservation District.. Coconut Grove should not be divided, nor the power of its voters diluted. I am very concerned about the possibility that Coconut Grove will be divided into two or more city commission districts. Coconut Grove has a rich history as the place where Miami started. It is a strong, cohesive community with a highly engaged and active population of voters, and it is one of only three neighborhoods in the City of Miami with the designation of Neighborhood Conservation District.. Coconut Grove should not be divided, nor the power of its voters diluted. I am very concerned about the possibility that Coconut Grove will be divided into two or more Michael Sylvia David Lynn Jim 3986 Park Drive Miller Coconut Grove, FL 33133 2301 TEQUESTA Rossi-Montero LN , Miami, FL 33133 3 Grove Isle Schaecter Drive, apt. 310, Miami, FL 33133 2542 Swanson FECTEAU ave Coconut Grove FI 33133 Wall 2801 Florida Ave Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts city commission districts. Coconut Grove has a rich history as the place where Miami started. It is a strong, cohesive community with a highly engaged and active population of voters, and it is one of only three neighborhoods in the City of Miami with the designation of Neighborhood Conservation District.. Coconut Grove should not be divided, nor the power of its voters diluted. I am very strongly OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. This is a small area, all sections functionally overlap- ie in its everyday use by Grove homeowners I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. I completely disagree with distracting. It is not a time to divide but unite the district on pending development issues to our village and community. This is no need to add an extra seat at the table for another opinion to create more discord and conflict to the existing community unit. I have been a resident of Coconut Grove since 1982. I am concerned about the prospect that our historic district may be divided. I speak for many and am opposed to changing the character of Coconut Grove and this important and unique district. What do I need to do so that the elected officials consider my voice and those of others who strongly oppose redistricting? David Schaecter, 3 Grove Isle Drive, Apt. 310, Miami, FL 33133 I have lived in Coconut Grove most of my life. I am TOTALLY AGAINST splitting up Coconut Grove. Lynn fecteau I oppose the redistricting of Coconut Grove, especially as this decision has not allowed for sufficient participation of Grove residents. Christine Roger Joseph Gary Lata Monte Davies Wells Shea Person Thomas Lichtiger 4152 Battersea rd Coconut Grove, FI 33133 3638 St. Gaudens Rd, Miami, FL, 33166 4039 Crawford Ave 2740 SW 28th Terrace #708 Coconut Grove, FL 33133 3837 Loquat Ave 3475 South Moorings Way Coconut Grove, FL 33133 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts I strongly object to redistricting Coconut Grove. It needs to remain intact as a community. We don't want to be a community divided. No decisions should be made without the consensus of the community. I strongly object to splitting Coconut Grove. Coconut Grove has a long history and should not be split. I wish to express my opposition to the proposed redistricting of the Coconut Grove area. The Grove is a unique and very different section of the city of Miami and should be allowed to maintain their separate district. I think that those who wish to change this must have undisclosed motives, such as the desire to rezone for high rise buildings and break up the lucrative property tax base, for instance. I have been a resident and property owner in Coconut Grove since 1972. I moved here for precisely the character and ambiance that certain people are now trying to change. Those who are for redistricting will be suspected of ulterior motives and the voters will not react kindly. Thank you for your consideration of this matter. I would like for the Grove to remain intact as a community and without gerrymandering to effect a dilution of our community's impact on our governance. I would like to express my strong opposition against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thanks, Lata Thomas I'm opposed to the redistricting project that involves Coconut Grove. Scott Siegel 4288 lennox DI.1 11436 It has come to my attention that the Miami City Kelly John drive Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts 4181 Pamona Clark Ave, Miami 33133 Snyder 3980 Hardie Ave DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I Frances Harry Bentley Grant Jennifer Maclntyre Gottlieb 409 Viscaya Avenue 3629 Grand Ave. #410 Rubinstein 3865 Park Ave Sheehan 3741 De Garmo Lane 3507 Saint Beber Gaudens Road Miami, FL 33133 SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts vote and pay taxes. It is important that neighborhoods remain intact and are not divided according to a political agenda. Please keep Coconut Grove in one piece. It was an enormous travesty that the Village of Coconut Grove was illegally annexed out of existence and made a neighborhood of the City of Miami in 1925. Now there seems to be an effort by Commissioners outside of D-2 to once again decimate Coconut Grove by forgoing it's historical significance and slicing it up for their own benefit. This must not be allowed to take place. Shame on them for even considering this act of disrespect. Let's not dilute our community voice: I am strongly opposed to any plan that would split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. Let's not dilute our community voice: Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner, and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. Grant Sheehan My husband and I are strongly opposed to redistricting the Grove, which seems a blatant attempt to redistribute perceived power for political aims which do not meet the needs of the people you serve. The Grove does include many disparate groups, but we are united by our love of this community and have much more in common with each other than with neighboring areas, particularly across US1. The Grove is the oldest community in the county and should not be split up unless we, the Raymond 3895 Park Av Robinson Coconut Grove 33133 voters, request it. And we haven't!!!! My letter is AGAINST REDISTRICTING. i understand that Joe Carollo said: "The southern part is very different from the center, which is different from the north. I'm not even including the Bahamian Grove." Actually each street has its own character.... This thinking doesn't make sense because does ALL of the North Grove think alike, does ALL of the South Grove think alike, does ALL of the Center Grove and Bahamian Grove think alike? of course not.... .... That's what makes a community - all different thoughts, people, etc....if we all thought the same thing we would all marry the same person, eat the same food, have no personality at all. Again, if you did what Joe Carollo said them this thinking would be the premise of All districts throughout the City....why stop with Coconut Grove? you would end us with hundreds of "little districts" that we all alike....or so you think? DON'T TEAR OUR COMMUNITY APART we are over 100 years old and going strong... 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission SP - Special is contemplating redistricting City Commission Meeting Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. 2. Let's not dilute our community voice: Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South 3895 Park Ave Robinson Coconut Grove 33133 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. 3. Just say no to dividing a community into separate commission districts: I am strongly against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. -- Ray Robinson, Park Avenue, Coconut Grove South Grove Neighborhood Association My letter is AGAINST REDISTRICTING. i understand that Joe Carollo said: "The southern part is very different from the center, which is different from the north. I'm not even including the Bahamian Grove." Actually each street has its own character.... This thinking doesn't make sense because does ALL of the North Grove think alike, does ALL of the South Grove think alike, does ALL of the Center Grove and Bahamian Grove think alike? of course not.... .... That's what makes a community - all different thoughts, people, etc....if we all thought the same thing we would all marry the same person, eat the same food, have no personality at all. Again, if you did what Joe Carollo said them this thinking would be the premise of All districts throughout the City....why stop with Coconut Grove? you would end us with hundreds of "little districts" that we all alike....or so you think? DON'T TEAR OUR COMMUNITY APART we are over 100 years old and going strong... 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. 2. Let's 3895 Park Robinson Avenue Coconut Grove 33133 not dilute our community voice: Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. 3. Just say no to dividing a community into separate commission districts: I am strongly against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. -- Suzy Robinson, Park Avenue, Coconut Grove South Grove Neighborhood Association My letter is AGAINST REDISTRICTING. i understand that Joe Carollo said: "The southern part is very different from the center, which is different from the north. I'm not even including the Bahamian Grove." Actually each street has its own character.... This thinking doesn't make sense because does ALL of the North Grove think alike, does ALL of the South Grove think alike, does ALL of the Center Grove and Bahamian Grove think alike? of course not.... .... That's what makes a community - all different thoughts, people, etc....if we all thought the same thing we would all marry the same person, eat the same food, have no SP - Special personality at all. Again, if you did what Joe Meeting Carollo said them this thinking would be the premise of All districts throughout the City....why stop with Coconut Grove? you would end us with hundreds of "little districts" that we all alike....or so you think? DON'T TEAR OUR COMMUNITY APART we are over 100 years old and going strong... 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive Raymond 3895 Park Robinson Avenue Coconut Grove, 33133 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. 2. Let's not dilute our community voice: Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. 3. Just say no to dividing a community into separate commission districts: I am strongly against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. -- Suzy Robinson, Park Avenue, Coconut Grove South Grove Neighborhood Association My letter is AGAINST REDISTRICTING. i understand that Joe Carollo said: "The southern part is very different from the center, which is different from the north. I'm not even including the Bahamian Grove." Actually each street has its own character.... This thinking doesn't make sense because does ALL of the North Grove think alike, does ALL of the South Grove think alike, does ALL of the Center Grove and Bahamian Grove think alike? of course not.... .... That's what makes a community - all different thoughts, people, etc....if we all thought the same thing we would all marry the same person, eat the same food, have no personality at all. Again, if you did what Joe Carollo said them this thinking would be the premise of All districts throughout the City....why stop with Coconut Grove? you would end us with hundreds of "little districts" that we all alike....or so you think? DON'T TEAR OUR Debbie 4205 Lennox Dolson Drive, Coconut GRove, FL 33133 COMMUNITY APART we are over 100 years old and going strong... 1. Coconut Grove is a cohesive and vibrant community: It has come to my attention that the Miami City Commission is contemplating redistricting City Commission Districts by separating the historical city of Coconut Grove into different districts, The city of Coconut Grove dates to 1873 many years prior to the settlement of Miami. I strongly believe that Coconut Grove remains a cohesive and vibrant community and that the West, South, Center and North Grove should not be separated into different commission districts as this would not be beneficial for the population in any way. I trust that the interest of the people in Coconut Grove will prevail over any other considerations the politicians may have. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. 2. Let's not dilute our community voice: Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. 3. Just say no to dividing a community into separate commission districts: I am strongly against Coconut Grove being divided into two or more city commission districts. I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. -- Ray Robinson, Park Avenue, Coconut Grove South Grove Neighborhood Association PLEASE MAINTAIN COCONUT GROVE'S STATUS AS AN UNDIVIDED COMMMUNITY WITHIN A SINGLE DISTRICT. Coconut Grove, is the oldest continuously inhabited neighborhood of Miami SP - Special and was annexed by the city of Miami almost Meeting 100 years ago. The village of Coconut Grove must remain undivided within a single district. The Grove's integrity, rich history, population, and racial diversity MUST remain as an undivided section within ONE district. Joanne Scott Maria Joanne Butler Siegel Morales 3750 Park Avenue Miami, FI 33133 4288 lennox drive 3801 Battersea Road 3134 center Braga street, coconut grove, FI 33133 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts Redistricting MUST NOT be used as a tool to influence electoral outcomes, manipulate funds, or discriminate against any group. The goal of redistricting is to provide fair and effective representation for all. "Fair and effective" means keeping Coconut Grove as one cohesive unit within a single district. Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would Split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner of Joanne Leigh Barbara Richard Stephanie Donna Patrice Emily Butler 3865 Park Avenue 3475 S Lichtiger Moorings Way Coconut Grove Zelman Leigh 3536 St. Gaudens Rd.Miami 3350 SW 27 Avenue unit 1005 Coconut Grove Draper 3685 Justison Rd Guiol 3595 St Gaudens Rd, Coconut Grove, 33133 FL Boland 2645 S Bayshore Dr, #301 DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting several generations, I vote and pay taxes. Do not do this. It will not be good for our community in having a diverse and true voice of this historic community. Please be advised that I am VEHEMENTLY OPPOSED to any plan that would split the existing Coconut Grove voting district into multiple sections, thereby diluting our community voice in future elections. I would not support any elected official who votes for this action. Further, I would not support said officials in any future elections . I am a resident, homesteaded property owner and member of the South Grove Neighborhood Association: I vote and pay taxes. Thank you for considering my position. Joey Butler Please do NOT divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process! Coconut Grove needs to remain the cohesive community it has always been. Please do NOT divide Coconut Grove into multiple districts. The Grove is a very cohesive area, and should not have its representation on the City Commissiin diluted. If you vote to divide the Grove please be assured that we shall not forget at election time. Please do not change Coconut Grove's boundaries. We are a unified community that should remain as such. Thank you, Stephanie Leigh Native Miamian Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. As a native Miamian and 50-year resident of Coconut Grove, I cannot understand any valid reason for breaking up our cohesive community. Please. The entire Coconut Grove is that special and should remain intact. Thank you. Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami. Elizabeth Jamie Nicholas Rebecca Kathleen Tany Gibson Bunce Nathanson Badger Hamilton Reid Barbara Lange 4145 el Prado blvd 234 NE 3rd St. Apt 1602 Miami, FL 33132 3531 Crystal Ct 4091 Park Ave. Coconut Grove, FL 33133 3600 Saint Gaudens Road Coconut Grove, FL 33133 3180 Bird Ave, 33133 3901 Braganza Ave DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami. I have been a resident since I was a child in 1951. The redistricting would be unfair. We want to stay where we are Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami. Also, as the people living in the neighborhoods being considered for transfer out of district 2 are primarily people of color, the the current proposal will further silence already marginalized voices. We should be striving to increase diversity within each district. Segregation hurts us all. Please do not divide Coconut Grove in the redistricting process. Coconut Grove has been a cohesive community longer than any other part of Miami. You will weaken a core community - one that is not based solely on tourism. Keep the grove intact. Please do not divide and redistrict Coconut Grove, my personal home for 15 years. We love where we live —a community that is growing and improving. We have a variety of residents within our area, but that is not a reason to split us into tiny parts; it is a reason to celebrate and support our remaining together, as we have been since 1873. I do not support this proposal and am disappointed that this is the "solution" proposed to the "problem" of a thriving, diverse, and cohesive community. The rest of Miami should be so lucky! Please do not divide up Coconut Grove. I have been a Grove resident since 1977. It is historic community with a special charm not equaled in this state. Please do not destroy what makes it so special. Too many changes are already taking place which are eroding its beauty and individual character. This idea is terrible and must be stopped before this community is destroyed. Please do not split Coconut Grove into separate districts. We are the oldest and most cohesive neighborhood in Miami. Please leave us alone!!! Please don't divide Coconut Grove into 2 different commission districts. Mary Berta Robert Twyman Erik Vicki and Hardy gait Theodora & Howard Walsh Montalvo 4141 Lybyer Ave Miami, FL 33133 1740 South Bayshore Drive OLeary 2310 Tigertail Ct Bentley, Jr. Wagner 1400 NW 54 ST APT #609 Miami, FL 33142 1818 Espanola Drive 3774 el prado Katz blvd Coconut grove 33133 beckham Oberlander 3138 center street 3969 Hardie Avenue, Coconut Grove DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts SP - Special Meeting DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of Please keep Coconut Grove together in its entirety when splitting up District 2. (Borders: LeJeune Rd. - U.S. 1 - Rickenbacker Causeway - North Prospect Drive) We have a common culture here and our issues are unique to our geographic area. Thank you. Please maintain Coconut Grove's integrity and character. Do not divide this community . Thank you Stop dividing the Grove. We are one in thought & vision! I own property in ALL the Grove. Very happy with Ken Russell! Stop Carollo nonsense. To the Coconut Grove Village Council: I am very concerned about the possibility that Coconut Grove will be divided into two or more city commission districts. Coconut Grove has a rich history as the place where Miami started. It is a strong, cohesive community with a highly engaged and active population of voters, and it is one of only three neighborhoods in the City of Miami with the designation of Neighborhood Conservation District.. Coconut Grove should not be divided, nor the power of its voters diluted. I urge the Village Council to convey my concerns to the Miami City Commission. We do not need to split the Grove. Do not redistrict. The fact that this was not brought up by residents speaks to the fact that is being done to undermine the power of the community we've established. Stop trying to weakling our representation. We do not want Coconut Grove divided into two or more commission districts. i object strongly to the redistricting City Commission districts .... and I vote against any redistricting anything in Coconut Grove. I believe this may be call gerrymandering and I am against it. Theodora and Howard 3969 Hardie Oberlander Avenue Coconut Grove Carol Blades Gale 2 Grove Isle Drive Apt 210 Coconut Grove, FL 33133 3122 Aviation Napoliello Ave., Miami, FL 33133 City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts DI.1 11436 Discussion - Redistricting of City Commission Districts