HomeMy WebLinkAboutExhibit CExhibit "C"
Miami Historic and Environmental Preservation Board
File ID 14-00296
Resolution: HEPB-R-14-017
April 1, 2014 Item HEPB.2
Mr. Hugh Ryan offered the following resolution and moved its adoption:
A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI HISTORIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL PRESERVATION
BOARD, APPROVING AN AD VALOREM TAX EXEMPTION FOR HISTORIC PROPERTIES
(PART 1) APPLICATION AT 3518 SOUTH MOORINGS WAY, MIAMI, FLORIDA.
Upon being seconded by Mr. David Freedman, the motion passed and was adopted by a vote of
7-0:
Mr. Timothy Barber Absent
Mr. David Freedman Yes
Mr. Gary Hecht Yes
Mr. William E. Hopper, Jr, Yes
Mr. Jorge Kuperman Absent
Ms. Lynn B. Lewis Yes
Mr. Gerald C. Marston Yes
Mr. Hugh Ryan Yes
Mr. Todd Tragash Yes
Megan Schmitt Execution Date
Preservation Officer
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE )
Personally appeared before me, the undersigned authority, Megan Schmitt, Preservation Officer of the City of Miami, Florida, and
acknowledges that she executed the foregoing ResooI t�ion. /�
SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS DAY OF 119) I , 2014
4 L61-0
VCve.sc; Irq J1 IL)
Print Notary Name
Personally know or Produced I.D.
Type and number of I.D. produced
Did take an oath or Did not take an oath 0L.
Nota Public State of Florida
My Commission Expires:
'n':t.,. VANESSA TRUJILLO
MY COMMISSION # EE 105250
EXPIRES: July 11, 2015
0tI•'` Bonded Thru Notary Public Undersriters
• AD VALOREM TAX INCENTIVE FOR HISTORIC RESOURCES
PROCESS & INSTRUCTIONS
1
APPLICATION PART l: PRECONSTRUCTION APPLICATION
SECTION 1 Determination of Property Eligibility (determination of historic status)
O If requested, applicants must provide proof of historic status.
SECTION 2 Description of Improvements
O All applicants must provide a full description of current state and proposed improvements. These
improvements must comply with the Standards for Rehabilitation of Historic Properties set forth
by the Secretary of the Interior.
O All applicants must provide printed photographs (labeled and numbered) of existing features and
architectural plans or diagrams of proposed changes. ' 2(; 2 . O
O APPLICATION FEE: All applicants must present a 5 application fee (check made payable to
the "City of Miami") along with the Preconstruction Application (Part I).
PROCEDURE:
1. Review of Preconstruction Application by Historic Preservation Officer (15 workdays, following receipt of
completed application with all supporting materials).
2. Officer schedules a HEP Board meeting to approve Preconstruction Application. Preconstruction Applications
may be reviewed with a Special Certificate of Appropriateness before the HEP Board.
3. Officer notifies applicant of HEP Board meeting.
4. Historic Preservation Officer notifies applicant of decision in writing, either granting or denying the Special COA
and the preconstruction application.
2
CONSTRUCTION PHASE
Applicant has two years from the date of HEP Board Approval to complete the improvement project.
The Historic Preservation Officer may grant 1 extension for a period of one (1) year for extenuating
circumstances.
AMENDMENTS TO PROPOSED PROJECT (IF ANY)
PROCEDURE:
1. Historic Preservation Officer reviews Amendment Application. Officer may approve minor amendments or
presents before the HEP Board, if changes are significant.
2. Applicant receives notification of acceptance of changes in writing and resumes construction.
3
APPLICATION PART II: REQUEST FOR REVIEW OF COMPLETED WORK
O Applicants must complete a Request for Review of Completed work once the
project/improvements are substantially completed.
O All applicants must indlude printed photographs of completed work that correspond with
photographs submitted for the Preconstruction Application (all photographs must be labeled)
PROCEDURE:
1. Historic Preservation staff will contact the applicant to review the completed work and determine if the work is
consistent with the previous preconstruction application. Officer will present this review before the HEP Board.
2. Historic Preservation officer presents Review of Completed work to the HEP Board, along with Part l:
Preconstruction Application and all supporting materials and amendments to project. Officer makes a
recommendation before the HEP Board.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION TAX EXEMPTION COVENANT
1. if the NEP Board accepts the work completed as up to standards, the applicant and the City of Miami enter into
a Covenant to ensure proper maintenance of the property for the period of the exemption.
Applicant and Historic Preservation Officer sign a Covenant for Historic Preservation Property Tax Exemption.
REVIEW BY THE HEP BOARD AND FINAL DETERMINATION BY CITY COMMISSION
1. The HEP Board must recommend to the City Commission that it either grant or deny the exemption. Such
reviews must be conducted in accordance with the rules adopted by the Flonda Department of State. The HEP
Board recommendations and the reasons must be provided to the applicant and to the City Commission before
consideration of the application at an official Commission meeting. The Commission shall also be fumished with
a covenant executed between the property owner and the city, confirming their intent to maintain the qualifying
improvements for the duration of the tax exemption granted by the City Commission.
2. Public hearing scheduled. The applicant shall also be advised of the date of the hearing.
3. City of Miami Commission makes the final determination as to whether or not to grant the tax exception and
sets the duration of said exception.
4. The covenant is filed by the Historic Preservation Officer before the Clerk of County Courts and will forward a
copy of the complete application to the Miami -Dade County Property Appraiser's Office.
APPEALS OF HEP BOARD DECISIONS
The applicant shall have 30 days from the HEP Board decision to deny a preconstruction application, to appeal
said decision. A written notice of appeal shall be filed with the Hearing Boards Department, with a copy to the
Historic Preservation Officer. The appeal shall set forth precisely the reasons or grounds for the appeal, and
shall be accompanied by the applicable fee of $
•
CITY OF MIAMI
Ad Valorem Property Tax Exemption for Historic Resources
PART 1: PRECONSTRUCTION APPLICATION,
Section ` 1. Determination of Property Eligibility
READ ALL INSTRUCTIONS CAREFULLY BEFORE COMPLETING THIS APPLICATION
Your application cannot be evaluated unless it is complete and all required supporting
materials are provided. In the event of any discrepancy between the application form and
other supplementary material submitted with it (such as architectural plans, drawings,
photographs, and specifications), the application form shall take precedence. Type directly
on form, or print clearly in black ink. If additional space is needed, attach additional sheets.
GENERAL INFORMATION (To be completed by all applicants)
I. PROPERTY IDENTIFICATION AND LOCATION:
Histonc Name (if applicable): Fisher Residence
Property Address: 3518 South Moorings Way
City: Miami
State: FL
Legal Description: (attach additional sheets as necessary)
Zip: 33133
THE MOORINGS PB 31-52
LOT 7 & Et OFT LOT 6 BLK C &
PROP INT IN & TO STS-PARKS-YACHT
BASIN & CANAL
LOT SIZE 12000 SQUARE FEET
OR 18862-1638 1099 5
Folio No. (available at w' v miamidade 0cv'protax/) 01-4128-006-0110
Historic Status: (Check all that apply)
❑ Individually listed in the National Register of Historic Places
0 Individually listed in the Miami Register of Historic Places
Listed as a Contributing Resource within a Historic District in the National Register of Historic Places
❑ Listed as a Contributing Resource within a Historic District listed in the Miami Register of Historic Places
1 Plan ning. HP.AV. P 1 6/2008
II. OWNER INFORMATION
Name of Individual (s) [or organization] that owns the property:
If the property is in multiple ownership, attach a list of all owners with their mailing addresses.
Joel and Courtney Denaro
Complete the following if signing for an organization or multiple owners:
Title: Organization name:
Mailing Address: 2100 Tigertail Avenue
City:Miami
State: Florida Zip: 33133
Daytime Telephone Number(s): 786-357-6137
Contact Person:
E-Mail Address:cldenaro@hotmail.com
Fax Number:
4. Owner Attestation: I hereby attest that the information I have provided is, to the best of my
knowledge, correct, and that I own the property described above or that I am legally the authority in
charge of the property. Further, by submission of this Application, I agree to allow access to the
property by representatives from the Historic Preservation Division of the City of Miami's Planning
Department, from which the historic tax exemption is being requested, for the purpose of verification
of information provided in this Application. I also understand that, if the requested exemption is
granted, I will be required to enter into a Covenant with the City of Miami granting the exemption in
which I must agree to maintain the character of the property and the qualifying improvements for
the term of the exemption.
Courtney Denaro
Name
Joel Denaro
c6Wr EciALvvo
Sign
q Itf
)ate
Name (co-owner) 1) Signature
Date
2 Planning.HP.AV.P1 612008
Ad Valorem Property Tax Exemption for Historic Resources
PART I: PRECONSTRUCTION APPLICATION
Section.2:, Description of lmproveinents
PROPERTY INFORMATION (To be completed by all applicants)
Complete the blocks below. Include a description of proposed feature work, new
construction, proposed alterations, etc. Include photographs of existing resource and
architectural plans. All photographs and architectural plans MUST be numbered, dated, and
labeled with the property address. Please note: Improvements to historic resources must
meet the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and Guidelines for
Rehabilitating Historic Buildings.
For more information on Guidelines, click: http:t/www.npsgov/history/hps/rehabyes-no/index.htm
Property Address: 3518 South Moorings Way, Miami, FL 33133
Check one: ❑X Exterior ❑ Interior
Feature:Windows
Approx. date 1925 & more recent
Describe existing feature and its condition:
Mixture of original casement windows and various
types of newer windows ie. jalousie, plate glass,
awning, single -hung sash, and steel casement
windows. All the windows need to be replaced.
Most of them have broken mechanisms and glass.
Photo #'0"`( Architectural Plan Pg. # R d. I
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
Replace windows with ones consistent with
Mediterranean Revival style and in compliance with
Miami Dade County regulations.
Featuree2,
Check one:
❑X Exterior OX Interior
Feature:Electric
Approx. date 1925 & more recent
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The electrical system is old with numerous additions
and modifications over the years.
Photo #r Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The work will entail a complete replacement of the
electrical system.
3
Plan n ing. HP. AV. P 1 6/2008
Check one: XD Exterior ❑x Interior
Feature:Plumbing
Approx. date 1925 & more recent
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The plumbing system is old with numerous additions
and modifications over the years.
Photo # 10 4-1 I Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The work will entail a complete replacement of the
plumbing system.
Check one:
Exterior ❑X Interior
Featu re: HVAC
Approx. date unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The HVAC system is old with numerous additions and
modifications over the years.
Photo # ! CZ Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The work will entail a complete replacement of the
HVAC system.
Check one:
❑X Exterior ❑ Interior
Feature: Roof
Approx. date Unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The main roof is cross gable and the other portions of
the roof are flat. There are numerous leaks inside the
house due to the poor condition of the flat roof.
The roof originally had barrel mission tile which was
removed at some point.
Photo # fljav I rp Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The plan is to replace the roof - keeping the cross
gable roof and replacing the barrel mission tile and
replacing the flat portions with a hipped barrel tile
roof consistent with the Mediterranean Revival Style,
4
Planning .HP.AV.P 1 6/2008
Feature 6
Check one:
0%"I
M X
Q Exterior Ei Interior
Feature:Covered front entrance/carport
Approx. date 1940's or 50's
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The front porch and carport are covered by a wood
overhang held up by metal poles. The wood has
areas of rot, as well as exposed wires and rusty bolts.
Photo # J1--al Architectural Plan Pg. # 2.
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
This overhang was added by the Fisher's in the
40's/50's - according to April Fisher it was done by her
father himself as a temporary cheap fix. The plan is
to replace it with a beautiful alternative consistent
with the Mediterranean Revival Style of the house.
Check one:
Exterior 0 Interior
Feature: Interior
Approx. date unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The fireplace, staircase and balustrade - good
condition.
Photo 23Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The plan calls fora complete renovation of the
interior with the restoration of the original fireplace,
stairwell and balustrade.
Check one: x❑ Exterior ❑ Interior
Feature:driveway
Approx. date unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The driveway is cement with numerous cracks.
Needs to be replaced.
Photo #2g5Architectural Plan Pg. # A ` ,
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The plan is to replace the cement driveway with a
material consistent with the Mediterranean Revival
Style of the house.
5
Hann incl. HP .AV. P 1 6/2008
Check one: n Exterior Ei Interior
Feature:Pool
Approx. date unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The pool is rectangular shape and located very close
to the house.
Photo #2 —2 !/ Architectural Plan Pg. # A 1, I
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The plan is to keep the original rectangular shape but
to move the pool in order to meet the requirements
of zoning and building codes.
Feature 10
Check one: ' Exterior Interior
Feature:Landscape
Approx. date unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The landscape is overgrown and unmanageable in its
present state.
Photo #
Architectural Plan Pg. # A at
t
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The plan calls for a simple, elegant landscape
consistent with the Mediterranean Revival Style of
the house. A tree survey has been completed and we
will keep several of the existing trees.
Feature 11
Check one: 0 Exterior ❑X Interior
Feature:Guest cottage (garage)
Approx. date unknown
Describe existing feature and its condition:
The guest cottage/garage is in poor condition.
Photo #
Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
The plans call for a complete renovation of the guest
cottage with an addition above. The addition is set
back and will not significantly impact the view of the
house from the front.
6
Planning. HP.AV.P1 6/2008
reTrilITZPI Check one:
fg Exterior 0 Interior
Feature:
Approx. date
l9c 5
Describe existing feature and its condition:
�rCe—
-fed / ccp cv
eXiWmhe y cue ortyina_(
, e oure. . dr,cia /1 Y7
q—.,! x�
Photo # Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
h,IA-Lnit-efita-ilf pow n7Cit5-0-
bark% cillur 'Ali" an,c
cclarra stra-frit:
2 e pe.� l _. k -
v.in
l( verrcut-el 1)sk Scti
Feature 13
Check one:
0 Exterior 0 Interior
Feature:
Approx. date
Describe existing feature and its condition:
Photo # Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
rtnTr fl Check one:
❑ Exterior ❑ Interior
Feature:
Approx. date
Describe existing feature and its condition:
Photo # Architectural Plan Pg. #
Describe work and impact on existing feature:
7
Planning. HP.AV. P1 6/2008
APPLICATION FEE
A non-refundable application fee of $250.00 is due upon submission of the application.
Enclose with this application a check or money order payable to the "City of Miami."
RETURN COMPLETED APPLICATION TO:
PLANNING DEPARTMENT: HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION
444 SW 2 Avenue, 3 Floor / Miami, FL 33130
(305) 416-1400 phone / (305) 416-2156 fax
Mailing address: P.O. Box 330708 / Miami, FL 33233-0708
e-mail: preservation@ci.miami.fl.us www.historicpreservationmiami.com
Print Form
8 Planning.HPAV.P1 6/2008
Miami Historic and Environmental Preservation Board
File ID 13-00548
Resolution: HEPB-R-13-028
May 7, 2013 Item HEPB.12
Mr. Gary Hecht offered the following resolution and moved its adoption:
A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI HISTORIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL
PRESERVATION BOARD APPROVING WITH CONDITIONS AS SPECIFIED IN
EXHIBIT "A", AN APPLICATION FOR A SPECIAL CERTIFICATE OF
APPROPRIATENESS FOR RENOVATIONS TO A SINGLE-FAMILY HOME AT 3518 S
MOORINGS WAY.
Upon being seconded by Mr. Hugh Ryan, the motion PASSED by a vote of 9-0:
Mr. Timothy A. Barber
Mr. Nelson Diaz
Mr. David Freedman
Mr. Robert John Graboski
Mr. Gary Hecht
Dr. William E. Hopper
Mr, Jorge Kuperman
Ms. Lynn B. Lewis
Mr, Gerald C. Marston
Mr. Hugh Ryan
STATE OF FLORIDA
COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE
Yes
Absent
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
egan i ghlin
Prese ion Officer
Personally appeared before me, the undersigned authority, Megan McLaughlin, Preservation Officer of the Miami Historic and
Environmental Preservation Board of the City of Miami, Florida, and acknowledges that she executed the foregoing Resolution.
SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS33
✓Gvze-CS G Tr ; 1 m
Print Notary Name
Personally know OC or Produced ID.
Type and number of I.D. produced ^l
Did take an oath or Did not take an oath
AY OF rriati 2013.
Notary Public State of Florida
My Commission Expires:
u i VANESSA TRUJILLO
MY COMMISSION 0 EE 105250
n ,sonde EXPIREt4oply 11 2015
°tayL ticUnderwriters
EXHIBIT "A"
1. The large chimney on the rear addition shall be subordinated in size from the original chimney,
and shall be differentiated in design.
2. The addition shall be further differentiated from the original portions of the house, for instance
through a variation in the stucco finish or other means.
3. All proposed new windows shall match the original in color, style, and profile and may be in
compliance with Dade County regulations.
4. The proposed addition and driveway shall meet all current zoning and building codes. Any
potential alterations to the design to meet zoning and building regulations shall be subject to final
approval by the Preservation Office.
-1-
1w-
. .
not 2.L
A Proposed Restoration,
Courtney
Renovation,
& Joel
and Addition for
Denaro
F APROPOSEU RES]ORA770!w; REYO{A77DV ANDADD7770?,'POR - -
g COIRI NEY& JOEL DEA'.ARO 1, � w,x ti�A M u
354Somh Moorings Way
il
Miami, FL 33133 ,m.,,,,,.—,.Olaf.-..
l
3518
South
Coconut
Miami,
lU
Moorings
Grove
FL
a.
IIJ.
33133
1
41
Way
...
,�f, ,,,, iY ��)
ayer+�� TL -cam
` <
:. _
..„..„:
�';�
3:
-
__
r. _
;, _
4 �' . ..Ti�lP,,,
2`... a
t9
r
a
...
"Iar
f
�.
ill
`
r
1,
us 1
-
ARCIlITECCURALDRAWING INDEX
a x mPPP wu
SHEET IMF
SHEET
TITLE
PRAWN RV VP
n'sr.na or PP
AO 0
Cover sheet-
Al. I
Proposed First Floor
_EXI.I
F.xisti •Fint Floor
A1.2
Inclosed Second Floor
Iwnwwoamer.
A0.0
EXI.2
Donn/Second Floor
A2.1
Pro oP sed Pront Elevation
irX 1.3
Existin Front and Sack Flo/allowsA2.2
Proposed Re.Elevation
EXI.4
Existing Side Elevations
A2.3
Proposed Side Elevations
_
A2.4
Proposed Site Plan
T,
W•41411110, r
.1 r
1, I no ,e1
Hcra Azol...11C
irdpe.lcaLon
0000.
Mit 10 *rl 1P4.
OR/1.NY.
011,161111.
1.11ANG0/Y111,
1.1
611s T-w�4se
0
7
t
P�!
PkIkrA&knIgI IL
,r+R I! �rry� � •�
INIANDIONM
lis1-.T" 14-b.A .1..EVAtrlost
PEI
AtZt:717:
ra.
IDATL I, ,Iva, ,
1.1W/X101:
CILACKUBT:
ENUNNOS1110.
rr r rot.'
IL
/10-1,-o
Yak Itril AlraMill:
5weax
Itrpen1e0.15.21
Oho. IVIELIM
0141101:511.47.
0
,r4
L
'
1.1
t V, e• m
c L 4.1
T—
j-e..41.4 I
414
de')
Pek Ikedi Asoria.111!
Nolui..
111,115104
130.41MOIllit
.ALL.
P�!
Yd II ya & A»1at%1L'
Irydv 111.1.iw
Mw.. 1v 4r fly 1W
114.7411,
AIr2-
[11
Vat itp(a
103ftaktArow KY, la
PRISM
MtC le Arp.,
1114.11.1/11,1,
2.1
•
jJ
14aL1,1t
(
r -*a 414
• ..pe. 1.•01. gp;10A
A
• :
•
rrrvrrrIrrrI
0,1a
.,4
a...n.0 .1
PFI
RkHt&hsflUi
.111.15fOnt
011.grin
PRAWIMOSIIGCT:
A q 2
Axulaq Llf
uts...4=?.....
wolsvlie
0.12.4.1
:8 2
Ea
8 Z
OK1t10 N•1,1..
URAY11111,
OUG.11.1.:
111.11418M1110.
AZ,')
R 1/2'
PARKWAY
100. 00"(A4)(P)
u T
L
h., w . •
0.10 CL—
CL
1/2'
-9.90'
CONC.
/ 8
1.1
2800
PL
10.20'
800711
/ :, SLAB b
/
wk. • ,A.A0',4 07
\ 840'
1000
07
.00'
CONC.
WAIX-\
"17
TWO STO Y
RES1OEN E 1..W :11g
# 351
6.90' TAO%
41- -
.4g 22.00'
4'10' 713
FXL
20.60'
77340'
1.11-KA.P. 1/.
—15 .35"i
CONSC;11/S1S
SIZ
3 711-
PL
COS WALL--,
J' VAR, ;RAT
100 00YM)(P)
T • I T
60 'CL
Ob.
11\ -PO NAIL
L-1
wITt "'1-•
111
ile,.11 0.01873/83
rnk 1•11131:12
Lola ..44107.0
EMIL ID Arp,L /81
1,31331Y0
ataxmuut
111.014111114.
Al,