The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutEvaluation ReportProject Description: RFP Number(s): EVALLIATION FORM REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR NEW ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING The City is inviting PrepSera to bid on RectLiest for Proposals (REP") No. 15-16-009 ror the Rev bpment of a new administrative facility orthe City of Ilksrn RFP No. 1E-15-609 Name a. Signature, ilkirgal/74W 47/ni Date: EVALUATION CRITERIA Value 1 (Adler} COMMENTS Froodsents Financial Ca-acite and Dual -Poston 20 aka /d i) Iaifl-sile4g,a; _PfiatTiI liffii-4d t2C-7. 7i e?,-y f,e, / iiV- f f _ , / /1?-7 kftalL,Z. Financial Returns to the City 20 pis i' I ' : 5.5 i il &rti 1 " 5/ i - ry t1atAtis -.1,1-1-0,e a tAike, /.<-1-w, L Extent of Laical Participation 5 fits J I ill Eiti /77t' ll a a 1 . ':ITW- 'ikii EI / 94 Elexinitiv and Ability to Provide Seamless Occupancy 10 pti, r 11CI15tAi' AO r 104:i ZVI'5 r; 11V aL,), 11- ' I ?VW ; , n I I'f' La 1-2=i i (= 4 5) -tii IPAR k Transition Pala/eels OM and RFP nncmepentut awl oan. teAcrotnisoitmecictuludierantt OsiteacttePd iseenunsttianinniDabe 20 pts in .-i 5l- Aew,17 C 1./a,435ann- l4t.,,_,/„:,,•,,id/,/ efI /Lt 11 -1 I1/ - (ctf na5/_7f4i dreevienlc aCllaiPthrisliit dotherfnle Project Team and Development Team Experience 15 pis / ul 6.f,7,-- . ,cep,,,e-Y i7/1 1 ioi-,,,;_-;.47,4 6:-,,:s- 1,-/ ,,,,-45," . m ev -- ,,,- 6- / , „.5...-/.„!._ ,..„, Benefits of New Administrative Feat" Location 10 pts 1 , ifi, it,- k -,,,, ,, -is - , , (-!./iii-i Aie, . ''.,ai - nit v.-.:- t( is NI jf Pee yvIC r', i Ird-rt - i i r - ; - - -.1 57 1 ddi di&ydieiZ 7 aineal ItZlajyaal ta0,12efe iike, 7-&-43,u,„/-il,12:5- z;.,f.ei/z-p,(,>4-iz-h:w,- , „ -,,,, includino if on Ciao ned brood.fa roximity to major roadways & 01.1 bli a transportation etc,' TOTAL 100 pante Please indicate whether you regornmend to proceed with negoliations or rewct al proposals; (7 r P-J-1/4/ Instn.ictionsi 1) The Evaluation Criteria listed above is derived friarn itte information provided in the RFP for this project. 21 Each Reviewer must sign end date their Evaluation form(s) in ink_ 31 Each Reviewer roost base their evaluation on the same criteria so that value tantorrinty can be esbilishein. gNLY wl}ole nuintwirs should be used an scoring 4} Each Reviewer will evaluate and score elf Proposals and provide. tire original somelete-d score steets_ 5) Committee Chair 11 provide a Nwittan 'Ries-arm-nano:ate, tor Final Selectsat tooperrandteb .dressed ;a fhe City bteree-ger Proposer's Firms: 1 Lancelot Miami River. LLC ("Adler) 2 Project Description:: RFP Number(s1: EVALUATION FORM OFFERING MEMORANDUM FOR MIAMI RIVERSIDE CENTER DISPOSITION 1 4 City Is na nc Proposers to NC on Of:_. tog Mernetarcium. OM") NO. 15 i & CCE f r tso clsp0s? c.t of Gay -owned property located at 4,4 SW 2 the Mani Riverside Center. OM No. '...5-1E-ooa Name & Signatu EVALUATION CRITERIA -...- Value t (AdIaq 2lpanther) COMMENTS Prooneer's Financial Capacity end O,aelifieatians 40 is p'_ ,_ MA tt'5 }(� Ditty I { t t ;,fig j-1 p C - ' i V -' ldiJ a id t` ,I i )O[ •= P -- Financial Returns to the City 45 pts MA L+i } 0 Neil et ( Extent o€ LOCBI Far icipati0n 5 pts. J NSA # Fiealtaliy and Ability to Provide Seamless OccuaancY 1Q F NA 1 i n Ti�its` iI[d11/l SriI t t f � (wheeler i } t'` f ,l 'rlfy�1 TranSitiDe between OM and RFP TOTAL 7aoptslnts ' NIA Please indicate y-u racpmmerd to pr^.ceed with gat ap. s r r3je toll proposals, j� j 1 eti id ='ie a0dura 2C 2S5ev Proposer 5 Firms: 1 Lancelot Miami delver.. LLC f'°A: E 2) Each Rea ever mast sin sro date LIe0 Fir: s4 _s�ivat€ a scare al pro owls ar O mottle € to aona p 2 Panther Capital Management LLC (Panther) WITHDREW 1 NO LONGER APPLICABLE .,_= the Same cr1'.0'a_c that oak', err. tench ion for teEta. Select:Sri. Project Description: RFP Number(s): REQUEST FOR PR The Li =5 3r' li n2 PP ;pCs .y _`o bid on Requ-e: RFP No 15-164)09 e 8 Signature: ALUATION FORM OR NEW ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING RFP"). No. the Development .,f a new administrative faci Sty for me City of Miarnl- Date: EVALUATION CRfTERIA -.. Value t gAdler) i COMMENTS '... Prg¢$.sses Financial Capacity- arty QuafiFcatione 20 pis , Fine e'. Return§ to the Cif 20 pts '+ ---�,_?- s ',. Fx.nt of Lpcaf Particioatitn 5 pts EleRitail 'tv ana Ability to Provide S m0500 accedence t4 p _ ' i.. NJ Transition between OM and RFP onso trra1 F'cttooa PI ino.VosiontArOSlt tus= incit;dinn . rsr�ent w toted s:tstsfoaOltiiv. eco*s mi o : i reF. _ = ``-i - _ and other noels, Fe1atToarr5 ar.A. tveincrrsgnt Vans Exrs.?.rie?ncR 15pts 'q ". Bsn�;tits of Now fisi_eililiatrad e Facility's Location 10 pis _.. ] �' =, "•; `° "` 1 1`. f ffngiddinq II' on City: 7vme:J ProPerts, proximity to m®ior r. {aos ®ubhr transport tzmn. east TOTAL 1-4 paanis A The Evaluation Criteria listed abai^s is .:drrveri rytrts 1h into, provNed in the REP for:hi project. 2; Each Reviewer must sign and date the, r Evaluaton tc s established. 0N1 Y whsis numbers shou d be used in scoring. 4) Each Reviewer will evaluate and store all Proposals and provide the original completed stare addressesto the City Manager. Prodoser'S Firms: 1 La ami in ink.. 2) Each Reviewer must baso their evaluation on the same c.i,-.,.^,a so that vat s. 5= Cs mmlltee Chair wii provide a written 'Recommendation for Fin I Ns05 isn" ptlon: Number{ ;EVALUATION FORM OFFERING MEMORANDtlit FMIAMI RIVERSIDE CENTER DISPOSITION The City is inviting Proposers to bid on Merin the Mrmi Riverside Center, OM No,15-16-008 urn ("OM') No. 15-15-008 for the disposition of City -owned property, located at 444 SW 2 Ave, Miami Florida 3313 Dabs_ vn as EVALUATION CRITERIA Value 1 (AdterJ 2 (finer) iflMMEN'i=$ Prooese(4 Financial Capacity anrons 40 pts ,+ '= , r i- 4.-q Financialrns.to tho City 49 pts i sit -_ v 45 i'1- t t Extent of Local Participation 5pis s (_ fiexibilei and Abinny to Prgvine Sham esc Occuoancv 10 pits - TraP,5ition between OM anal RFP TOTAL 100 points tnr_rr41Qn. Thai Evaluation Cate, -xate ,..=&inlay cznu: bashed. ONLY h rr r.e.-�nora uro addroso€d to Ina Day Manage, Pr000seds Firms", 1 Lancelot Miami River, LLC ("Alter"} 2 Panther Capital Man C (Panthe ink 3. Each Re4ower aini use f=^.e=r e,iniuMkiln oo the same ite oo that ve e Cinnhanien Chair v11 provide a Mitten `Fecornman en.•or Firo1 Saleclion" Project Description: RFP Nurnber(s): EVALUATION FORM OFFERING MEMORANDUM FOR MIAMI RIVERSIDE CENTER DISPOSITION The City is triii0no Proposere tO bid On Offenng MMtioronditrr, COM') No, 1541 &OOP for the disposition of Citytovirried prope.rat located at 444 SW 2 Ave, Miami. Florida 33130 and known as the katerni Riverside Centeaa 15-16-1538 Name & Signature: n f_n< °ate: / ai-aa EVALUATION CRITERIA tialue 1 fAclior) 2 tParither) COMMENTS Proposer' s Financial Capacity and Qualifications 40 ets iitil I ..-iit 0 NiA = v F a . i / , t ul'I, it-- /47-: .-,--.I.. „nt ItTilkartillitt: Financial Returns to the City 45 pis --,, L-- nt- NIA Extent of Local Participation 5 pts y ---; NIA Lc2 p17,ii 73;_ii,l, fitt l---LY.0. tIsiTint 1-IC 1-72374,13,110:5 ;-11b-02 7,170.4y ,- c:-.., trag saa_aa: fat -VS. -MC a Peri a a4 Flexiblity and Ability to Provide Seamless Occupancy s U ,i, . Pi 5(7 NIA . , So7I-Fliiot7 itIII IF 417 5 1.1---f .,-'- it T ITO it -I i ri,c,"--745z- 6 ."-.) ci,r,_ .---' Transition between OM and RFP TOTAL 100 polo% '77---,:' '' NIA Pease indicate whether yob recoinntend to preceied AU: negotiations ct reject ail pricanuaie: instructions: 11 The Evaluation Criteria Ested eiticee is derived from the infouranion provided in Sae OM for this ontjaci. 21 Each Rai-a:ewer must alg:s sag date the Et's:Oita:Poo torrys) in tnat 31 Each Petiewer must Paso their evaluation ran Me sante cdtaina so Met value uniformity can be established. ONLY tynoie numbers should he used in scoring. 4) Each Reiviaim eirakisis and score ell Proposals and provide Ins -original completed snore sheets 51 Commit:se Chair will provide a istitten 'Recommendation for Final Selection" memorandum accassasat to the City Manager, Proposers Firms: 1 Lancelot: Alt lariat Riper. LLC ("Adler) 2 Panther Capital PA anagernent, LLC (Panther) WITHDREW 1 NG LONGER APPLICABLE Project Description: RFP Number(s): EVALUATION FORM REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR NEW ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING The City is k.vAtino Proposers L< bid on Recut for Proposals CRFP1 P- i No, 15-15-009 for the Deveicpment 0 a new administrative RFP No. 15-16-00a Name & Signature Cute: EVALUATION CRITERIA Value 1 (Adler) Clai . NTS Prd# ewes Fineeci.41 Capaclfy and Qealiticatione 20 pis , fd < E 's s 7^ °,f', emeretim , ., -. Est s : - 7;1 C1 _ , tr,-`_ < - i Financial Returns to the City 20 p PTP h 1 4-00f 0' - , ` �` - . "- , - -"! Ex ent of Local PartEcipalian 5 pi5 }-- _ Flexibilty and Ability to Provide 'Seamless. Occupancy 1U pis _. .i Transition betwee-07 n 091 and REF Con eptual Proleet PlapnineMesiontirchitedmre incIudind 2a pis. y _ ,�. -- .� : _ 7 - _ , - = 't -: F - .: i-:r . 01 . ..I`::, - olio :rr;arit with stated susta,nebility. economic development and other goal Proti°et Te,rr and Ee4 :oer-e.-:tTpatn Experaerce 15 Pis r Benefits of New Administrative Facility's Location 10 pis 1 -r t r c f 1: =tom li '`' } ; • , ' �,< 1,<- , .� _ ¢t ,- a y r 1-7motor :s..,'` . f e' d-.� .� (including if an City -awned property. proximity to roadways &.) public transportation.. etc TOTAL. 100 points. ,^=ro10 if f- ee =._% instructions: 1 i The F.a,aup. ,0neic<r r tV car be _a,e_, the NL _ `•>•:nol€ Memeraneme delefessed 10 Me City Mande Propooer's Firms: 1 Lancelot Miami River. LLC ("Adler") FP °or this ;.-elect 2) Each Re. _v,0r must sign and date the r E aleaLer Tarn� eiwpc__s a c __ €-_ seci me csaratelec scare s=wits Each o° sat base at aria sp Project Description: RFP Number(s)t EVALUATION FORM REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR NEW ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING The City is €nulling Proposers to bid on Request for Proposals (R°P') No, 15-16-00 for the Developm va adminslrative facility for the City of Miami, talc,, st. Name & Signature: 5 EVALUATION CRITERIA _ --- _..-... Volga 1(AdItr gF^.sr _erg €;rers f 20 Gts 20 I'ltu ftharcldl rsT�.envt: Ct!'c,r_uz;F -�_ iR tle�proposal liYFC �k'6,LL eCil C�ilYi"Flf %�pLL#abl6' India �'t¢Sl.klt.'f}[3�a6'd Ekit€2llCed.�da:F3 caaa snd th nddct. - .. - _ - _. -___. Financial RR5SErSSsQ h&Citx -...- 2a #ts 10 The �r 1l UC PrgUpos1d Cp. ,j0- 2) an.Cl the a€ bsequCnl ).iAP L➢dicate R ro pocC of achie do sans actnc peri l€'rnanC4; nn rho !4 +.4Fiiii7, wisa 34 €Ci U:at .1FE 41t} ad Cl err =€c.tr r €r ar; nun €3. rt t . l'1!R= CC..'I^C p€`� kCd C4�ct C5t tltC nC4:' 84f215 RFSt d1.' t45[lI�E1 �, }.CSC °.�. it h3 1�2 �1�_ B>d l�c.ii�e,2u't.3r in. tl3#r.,. t, steni.,of Local Particleatleo 5 pts p2 _ l t oftlie prtspasal details CISe iC 3l 118.'tirtpa<inn dior t•.ill ent;a 4, in. Tit et2]CCtat1C:.t* for (till± i.r.te.tu'.lro Lfearl_r 4T 1= Frcxila=l,�Abillty to P-- 16p#s - e. s tle-xible wish .Cs terms. however_ .ts tia':ate Frapo_al ism ri..? €et nt tt meat the ..dvriz:•i tca calve - TF n 8 ion a>s='xen Oi'�l and FtFP -•. - - _ C�r�Cet#t;t$�Er4i�&.S?!�'tiir�y fi3€o�At�hit�?'s&Inc 20 uts 20 "r , is,U._ iJ Lie L` t'sli .2-L<'II Peve .ili-•o st _-;�..2'e R"ii iI alined. Supporting tit v C . _.. �',t .. ..SC 'f .s or rd s Ae€b_ . P< 8 cafe ore are clean-; m..t Or csheeded, not ent vri n stated es in 5 fo eospp e)c devodzpinggt Pra3 -,fit `a8ra� a*�d C7evei� er=serg.'y, Exaerience 15 pts 15 Ahe project and develocenect team ises -n .= .xperse.:.e v es-.uc: caco i e _pas s .. e- 5_ tea<.=<u,_.. in l' e propasal, I led there .maid be a c of tie minfstr< < -,t' '�`'}� pts isvo e„ .he [tree, Lahr tc _s , r d r trc suecGY ? bt [he Cie;-- c=c .Fe :4r'e < .c«maser, p o f ::#-;e . /lit Iud'`tip <t drt C eusad Q. oo ' . 4F X55I10 water roed^i°ay=.$ggt�ll tP2!;Rng[tatitm TOTAL lruopotnts ,� e P 'as s Z t `u l I F� .ape c .per n e �r-= l he -ar• •oat. genera- e *t , n-r e efrr o i`hs. nos ata d 4�car_ ta,onabl, 1recn€om^ndp,-w-wsii, .tl vr...and lec,a= cal mez <.act.seer,Ialso ._®o ,ueorzthctw,.sci ist tnstruciion5.' 11 The vaM.aia =Crle;i unifermlty can be :stabs seed. 0NLv w memorandum 000resseo to the C:ly l a Pronosere Fioms: 1 Lancelot Miami River, LLtl ¢"Adler-) �d abcue `s give- n rhs ,nsarmari prided Is the Rr-o : Sh s pro --eel. z; Each Fevietver must sign and mete then Evaluation fbrmts in ink. 2) Each Rev'.,?r number should ha used In scodrg. 4) Each Reviewer will evaluate and score ail Proposals and prbv'cie the anginal completed score sheets. 5) Committee Cha prov zErrw , c ,err: a ua5.v-1 on the same criteria so that sob s z "Recommendation for Foal 5_I?.etan" Project Description; RFP Number(s): The city the Mienn OFFEI Pa en EVALUATION FORM NG MEMORANDUM FOR MIAMI RIVERSIDE CENTER DISPOSITION rs to bid on Offering Memorandum ("OM") N. 15-16-Q0 for th=. dleposItion of CI, props iy located at 444 SW 2 t1 re, ft9ianti, notice 33100, and Krovr O,1 No,15-10 4 Name & Stgnat EVALUATi€1N CRITE,tLA. Value 1 (Adler) 2 (Panther) COMMENTS Pto: Plnanca3 G4i€4't-n 40 pt=_ 40 The fnao inetadcd (u the prop): aj xt ere fro ro �a,d :�nc°.s-n, t puttable le..d' e-inot €a- re'v c `rrd tert . - - - Pinal Ratnrnn fo fha Otto 45 pts 22 lit Foa,-cid! retssn_ curt.c;. ar, <.�.defc. lfac City to a at a i`-.�a">+ .w_ is t . v..n„ _,n r..nt? fry. c:r. d: au.,'r-- rF c ?MRC to pov for a artir a inactimistratice buildin . t€nt of bonnl paot1ot„atlrn 5 pts 5 Page 48 of the proposal,ils tlae':ncal :Sic' filer. =r i ia„e in. 'Ph- e\pectations te-th s ell o.° nuA. :. Fles',bilta* and Ability to Pr¢vide_Sesr-ie5o O0 ubenct t[ pis — Adkr is tl, ttbic }jiff; its tcrlr.. hus� ` ._ i+ €��. .ts S`W..ta � Pr � c�c .,u �tciect .,a root tf?d Czh-> weds s c==..,az.: =`=irl ng. Transition 424=' ion betwe 1 and. RFP TOTAL. 1 0Fa'�EStt r -- e p - a ea_r ca -E a c sia..a rut h nar to t}e atr v ->drt _c' e. €s, aC �u u'v Y6^€oo,..L is Cc))), t<__ tiucrg.`e `e e-o .F3 t.,L UPocne.1 u`ir3 .�1. itf. t�Q.... i,e .i Jr 31 PF._FY�.i.s 4Gc.L: C.3i Instructional ,, The Evaivabon Ccleft rated above is derived t-o n the Inferm, tic a provided In the 014 for thin project 2) Each Revatter m .fin tcmrl'y .....an aa established. f6 J whale numbers should 0e used th scaring, aj Each F.ev ewer will evaluate god _core all Proposals and m= orn gum adaressed to the City Manager. ProzoseekFtre s: 1 Lancelot Warn! River, LLC I''Ad )n and date t'^-eir Evaluation form(s) in ink. 2) Each Revievler moot base their evaluation on the same cateria so that value s ihs utig{r i cewplet to scare sheets- 5) Committee Chair ,:tl provide a written °'Reonnuuuendeaon far Final Selection' 2 Panther capital Management, LLC (Farther) .shin Zn0_ non_. Prniect C1escripn: RFP Number(s): EVALUATION FORM REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR NEW ADMINISTRATIVE BUILDING The City is inviting Proposers to bid on Request for Piloposals (RFP") No 15=16,0C9 for the Development of a new administrative tociiit`y for the City of Miami. RFP N 1s-'6-G09 Name & $rgnature. �1 _ ©ate: C`- /., S .` EVALUATION CRITERIA Value 1 (Ad1er) COMMENTS . Praacs&r's Financial Capacity and Qualifications 20 .'t5 • �ti- •��`'� '4,,_'s`®. I gibe. 'S K Ste. e .� Financial Returns to the City pts (' rti, #a ' �:.,,,.. -say s ,_�.� - ,. ' Extent of Local Participation 5 pts T r` .-. � ' ems.-- , A.- tiq s � .. Flextbilty and Abitity to Provide Seamless Occupancy_ iit pfs Transition between OM and REP Cooceatuai Project Plan nintt!i siordArchitncture trictudine 20pts '"' 1#- . p' i; -- t cs .it1 -,_i;:5 y--.-'^- a. nehmen t with statedsustanabilirv, economic development and other pools Project 7eam;and Ltevelapment Team Experience 15 pts "..-- bs 5-�e""'. �' - »'.. - - 0azi t'r=-�S '-ems•-.. y. L.>.. t , 7� - Benefits of New Adrr=,1nis. a atsan 10 pts ' yg ` :`� � �` r' . +"i t"'# �- '4 t `r sa.�, �Sa `t �. ti y £-4 � '� � � lm z m. _. S ` i �t R. Cam-? 4 T-a- t i � 5 ,.c. � .¢ = 3a "'� '� •. - •- l-`�. L* { S' --�-i`. as- Linciudingi. on City -owned property proximity to major roadways $ public transportation. etc.i TOTAL 100 points Pease ihat na' a _3 : r+; =m a ::^.d ._„> tiote mil . _._;e ,s . �.j I Instructions_ 11 The Eva. man uniformity oar sab io .v= ONLY whole i<., me3^: rndxin. addresSeci to toe Citis Manage: ProPDoor'S Firms: 1 Lancelot. Miami River, LLC ("Adler"} toren en the in .t , z RFP `cr Mr; t Esc, R.e..-..ver edi1-'trrrtse in __WI some .,hams. a, nda on so char .o u _Ai.- -°�=. Project Description: RFP Number(s): EVALUATION FORM OFFERING MEMORANDUM FOR MIAII I RIVERSIDE CENTER DISPOSITION The City is inAting P -oi oo s to bid ch. 0 00no Memaancium )'M 1o, 1 -18 for the d5o s' c-n of Cit,pot n pr = : i a.44 : SW 2 Ave, Miami, Freda 3313 as the Miami Riverside Center. - OM No. 15-16-0CS Name & Signature: Date: EVALUATION CRITERIA Value 1 (Adler) --. 2 (Panther} COMMENTS PrOReser'S Financial Capacity and Qualrfiealions 40 pts 3 C NIA Via= , a g t �� . i t �. � t' <�§ - �c�. � ,,,.�8� — ;��,:. -,� ct.. E d ,>i '" a t e - tot 6ic®a •' .. vs,B ice:-�}+. ' =cis (,+n �, sit al-=—•-% '.�+.', �(. - - �.I:�� ' .-_.. t�T• -r -- Financial Returns to the CRY AS pis ` N/A �. i ism Extent of Local F ticipation 5 pts NM i FIs*aibIity and A5i ity tat Previdless Occuaancv tt} P NIA - - :t. i i & > „-L F• was ' Trail sitacr. tveaen uM and RFP TOTAL 100 points C NIA P L'a5£ Indicate .vnether yc, recommand 4G proceed wi'n regcfietionS •fir dejeci ail prop 4£als; - g- , al ?-4: C/ r .. i = d -- tea' ' .z.:,...L4 -,L, instruct nS i T o E.c uallan Critaria lived shams Jeri 3 'ti a^ 5 es 3: ,..eu. ,mot.€ Y, r, e !lumbers _ culd t-e us` in memorandum cadres €.. 1•e100City Manager Praposer's Firms: 1 Lancelot Miami river, LLC ("Adler") Each Reeewsr 2) Earn Reviewer m P0)poeEls an- 2 Panther Caoital Pa S. Edon Resierver must orma their eral a, Csrem:I;,e_ Cna.i will provide 0 0d 089 AELE 1dat1u^.