HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation ReportRFP NO. 763388
STORMWATER PUMP STATION MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR, M-0122
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
COMPOSITE
CONDO ELECTRIC MOTOR REPAIR, CORP.
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Per Member
Hector
Badia
Alex Barrios
Douglas
Yoder
Victor
Fernandez-
Cuervo
Lee Wilkins
Maximum
Total Paints
(5 members)
Total Points
(5 members)
Proposers relevant experience, qualifications, and past
performance
25
25
25
25
23
22.5
125
120.5
Relevant experience and qualifications of key personnel,
including key personnel of subcontractors, that will be
assigned to this Contract, and experience and
qualifications of subcontractors
25
12
19
20
20
21.25
125
92.25
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
25
20
22.5
22
23
17.5
125
105
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
12
15
15
12
15
125
69
TOTAL POINTS
100
69
81.5
82
78
76.25
500
386.75
CHAI SIGNif..
CHAIRPERSPiN PRINT NAME:
Z-Jr�iewy M . 1-ieviseAn
REVIEWS SIONRTIIR
REVIEWED BY PRINT NAME:
DATE:
/2//gb7
DATE:
12/21/2017
RFP NO. 763388
STORMWATER PUMP STATION MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR, M-0122
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Hector Badia, Assistant Director, City of Miami Office of Capital Improvements
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Condo Electric
Motor Repair,
Corp.
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
25
7_,5-
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of
subcontractors, that will be assigned to this Contract,
and experience and qualifications of subcontractors
25
j Zr
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
25
„� �0
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
I V
TOTAL POINTS
100
ci
SIGNAT1 RE:
PRINT NAME:
t
DATE:
2_71.6iil4-
12/21 /2017
RFP NO. 763388
STORMWATER PUMP STATION MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR, M-0122
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Alex Barrios, Manager, MDC Department of Transportation and Public Works
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Condo Electric
Motor Repair,
Corp.
Proposers relevant experience, qualifications, and.
past performance
25
L
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
25
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
25
K
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
/5'
TOTAL POINTS
100
7 /
SIGNATURE: DATE:
PRINT NAME:
/e/r-,-, j err rC
11 /28/2017
RFP NO. 763388
STORMWATER PUMP STATION MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR, M-0122
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Victor Fernandez-Cuervo, PE, ENV SP, Engineer 3, MDC Water and Sewer Department
EVALUATION \ PROPOSERS
CRITERIA \
Maxims
Points
Condo Electric
Motor Repair,
Corp.
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
25
z
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
25
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
25
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
1 2.
TOTAL POINTS
100
78
SIGNATU
PRINT NAME:
V I C-1-0 r-eg/VA-^15,76--Z -
DATE:
11 /28/2017
RFP NO. 763388
STORMWATER PUMP STATION MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR, M-0122
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Lee Wilkins, Superintendent, City of Miami Public Works
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Condo Electric
Motor Repair,
Corp.
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
25
as ,5-
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
25
i , a,j
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
25
( 7. 5
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
)5—
TOTAL POINTS
100
-16,5
SIGNATURE; DATE:
PRINT NAME:
Lee
i ligl//7
12/19/2017
RFP NO. 763388
STORMWATER PUMP STATION MAINTENANCE AND REPAIR, M-0122
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Douglas Yoder, Deputy Director, MDC Water and Sewer Department
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Condo Electric
Motor Repair,
Corp.
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
25
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
25
F
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
25
r} f
!""
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
! 5-
TOTAL POINTS
100
8 Z
SIGNAT RE: DATE:
PRINT NAME:
Dcu•Cat ci YDDGR.
L21Lct- i 7
1 u2S/2017