HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation Committee ReportEVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
REP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (I3-30632A)
POST ORAL
COMPOSITE SCORES
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's Qualification
and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology
in Designing and Master Planning in
South Florida
CBE Participation
Maximum
Points Per
Member
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
25
20
15
30
10
100
Maximum Total
P06rnS
(6,menibors)
150
120
90
180
60
A.D.A ENGINEERING, INC
132
106
79-05
152.8
54.7
CDM SMITH INC.
137.25
109.4
82.05
162.4
55.8
605
524,55
546.9
HAZEN AND SAWYER
134
112.2
79.05
146.8
54.7
5
531.75
SIGNATURE:
Chairperson:
RANKING
tel
Reviewed by: %'
• I
3
r
1
2
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (B-30632A)
POST ORAL
HECTOR 13ADIA ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, OCI
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
A.D.A ENGINEERING, INC
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and
Methodology in Designing and Master
Planning in South Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
CDM SMITH INC.
25
19
15
28
HAZEN AND SAWYER
24
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 16-17-0111
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (B-30632A)
POST ORALS
SAMANTHA DANCHUK, PHD., ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AND
GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT, FROWARD COUNTY
SELF_CTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and
Methodology in Designing and Master
Planning in South Florida
CBE Participation
Maximum
Points
25
20
15
30
10
A.D.A ENGINEERING, INC
21
17
12
24
9
CDM SMITH INC.
23
17
14
30
9
HAZEN AND SAWYER
21
18
12
21
9
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
100
83
93
81
Ito lu_•ul!
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (B-30632A)
POST ORAL
JOSE LAGO, SENIOR PROJECT MANAGER, OCI
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's Qualification
and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionatityllnnovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology in
Designing and Master Planning in South
Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
Maximum
Points
25
20
15
30
10
100
A.D.A ENGINEERING,
INC
22
17
13.05
CDM SMITH INC.
22.25
17.4
13.05
26.4
HAZEN AND SAWYER
22
17.2
13.05
25.8
8.7
86.75
lurlut:III
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 1 G-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (B-30632A)
POST -ORAL `CORES
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
KEITH NG, CFM, PROJECT MANAGER, OCI
Maximum
Points
25
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionalitytlnnovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology
in Designing and Master Planning in
South Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
20
15
30
10
100
A.D.A ENGINEERING,
INC
24
17
14
25
10
90
CDM SMITF4 INC.
25
20
14
299
HAZEN AND SAWYER
10
98
24
17
14
22
8
85
[lil ILWYll 1
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 1G-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF M1AMI (I3-30632A)
POST -ORALS
)BEYSEKERA, HYDROLOGIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL SYSTEMS DIRECTOR, SFL WATER MANAGEMEI
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/innovation
Maximum
Points
25
20
15
30
Technical Capabilities and
Methodology in Designing and Master 10
Planning in South Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 100
A.D.A ENGINEERING, INC
CDM SMITH INC.
10
HAZEN AND SAWYER
20
20
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (B-30632A)
POST -ORALS `.:CORES
VIRGINIA WALSH,P.G.,PHD., SENIOR PROFESSIONAL GEOLOGIST, WASD, MDC
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's Qualification
and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology in
Designing and Master Planning in South
Florida
CBE Participation
Maximum
Points
25
20
15
30
10
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
100
A.I1.A ENGINE[RING, INC
22
18
13
24
8
85
CDM SMITH INC. HAZEN AND SAWYER
23 23
20 21
14 13
26 25
10 10
93 92
ItIl lui:•011
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RIP NO.16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (E3-30632A)
�t 1. EC1IUN
PR()posr kt S { fit fF FZIA
' Proposer's Qualifications and Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's Qualification
and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/innovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology in
Designing and Master Planning in South
Florida
lCt3E Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
F6ANKING
SIGNATURE.
Chairperson:
Reviewed by.
MAXIMUM
['Writs
Per Member
Martin nnnn
Tidal 6uints
(I members)
25 150
20 120
15 90
30 180
10 60
5
100 605
COMPOSITE SCOPES
A8P CONSUI IING
1 RANSP(lht I A I It )N
F"NGINFF ItS. CORP.
111.25
89
70.65
130
45
445.9
5
PRINT NAME.:
•
A I).A E NGINFFRING,
INC
133.75
104
80.55
156.2
53.1
527.6
3
AFCOM 1FCIINICAL
SF RVICFS, INC.
134
104.6
785
144.8
52.7
5
4
COM SHIM{ INC.
134
105.4
80.55
158.9
52.3
2
h(AZE N ANI) SAWYF
135.5
109.8
80.55
153.3
52.7
5
536.85
1
SF LE {; I I(JN
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
Proposers Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and
Methodology in Designing and Master 10 9 10
Planning in South Florida
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
FIFP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE SIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAM! (11-30632A)
Maximum
Pulpits
HECTOR 11AF)lA AS;31STANT DIIZI[CTOR, OCI
A&P CONSULTING
TRANSPOR TAT ION
FNfINFFitS, CORP.
A.U.A FNCIIJI 1 RING, INC
25 13 23
20 1ti 1/1
15 15
21 27
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 100
93
AFCOM TECHNICAL
SERVICES, INC.
25
20
15
21
10
91
COM SMITH INC.
23
18
15
27
10
93
FIAZEN ANI) SAV, . —R
25
20
15
27
10
97
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
REP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE STORMWATER MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (13-30632A)
5AMAN I HA UANCI IUK, PIID., ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION AIID GROWTH MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT,
IIROWAI:I) COUNTY
St Lt CHIUN
PROPOSE RS CRtrFRIA
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
;Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
,Technical Capabilities and
Methodology in Designing and Master
Planning in South Florida
CE3E Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
Maxttntom
Points
25
A&P CONSk1L1INC
1 RANSPUR I A LION
FN(;INFTFRS, CORP.
21.25
16
12.75
25.5
8.5
84
A II.A FNGINI FfilNG, INC
AFCOM TFCIINICAL
SFI2VICk S, INC.
23.75 23.25
19 18.6
'13.5 12.75
29.4 27
9.5 9
95.15
CDM SMITH INC.
23.75
19
13.5
28.5
9.5
HAZFN AND SAWYL ,<
23.5
18.6
13.5
25.5
9
111•YI k: 111
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
REP NO. 1G-17-041
COMPE:E:IUF-NSIVE STOItMWATCR MASTER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (13-30632A)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's Qualification
and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionalityllnnovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology in
Designing and Master Planning in South
Florida
CFlE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
.JOSE LAGO, `:FNIOR PROJECT MANAGER, OCI
Maximum
Points
25
20
15
A&P CONSULTING
TRANSPORTATION
ENGINEERS, CORP.
22
17
12.0
25.5
8.5
85.9
A.C1.A ENGINFERING, INC
22
.17
13.05
25.8
8.6
86.45
AECOM
TECHNICAL
SERVICES, INC.
21.75
17
12.75
25.8
8.7
CDM SMITH INC.
22.25
17.4
13.05
26.4
8.8
HAZEN AND SAWYER
22
17.2
13,05
25.8
8.7
86.75
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
REP NO. 16-17-041
COMPREI IENSIV[ S FORMWAIER MINS I ER PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (B-30632A)
I't;L:-ORAL SCORES
SE I F 1:11()N
F'R()I'()SE RS CRITERIA
Proposer's Qualifications and
Experience
Proposer's Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology
in Designing and Master Planning in
South Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECIINICAL POINTS
M.i>ttr1111111
Penns
25
K CT} 1 NG, CI=M, PROJECT MANAGER, OCI
A&P CONSULTING
TRANSPok!A1ION
rwcrNrrRRs, CORP.
25
16
13
23
0
86
A.n.A rN(.INI- -RING,
1NL
24
15
14
23
10
AFCOM lF CIINICAI.
St RVICUS, INC.
24
16
14
25
10
COM SMI INC.
25
10
IIAZEN ANO SAWYER
24
17
14
25
10
90
IFu It . IT
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFf' NO. 16-17-041
COMPREHENSIVE- STORMWAT!"R MASTFT PLAN CITY Ol= MIAMC (B-30632A)
JAYANTFIA OI EYSFKERA, HYDROLOGIC AND ENVIRONMENTAL sr;TI_MS DIRECTOR, FL WATI:R MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
St t t C: i lUN
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposers Qualifications and
Experience
Proposers Team Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's
Qualification and Experience
Design Approach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and
Methodology in Designing ancl Master
Planning in South Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
Maximum
F'��iuls
25
20
15
30
10
100
A&P CONSULTING
TRANSI'ORTAi ION
ENGINEERS, CORP.
15
10
8
18
5
56
A I7.A ENGINE! RING. INC
20
18
12
27
AFCOM TECHNICAL
SERVICES, INC.
20
16
12
22
8
CPM Willi INC.
19
14
11
22
8
HA7EN AND SAWYER
19
19
12
25
9
84
Ettt'IION
I'ROPC)-E NS
CHITE NIA
EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS
RFP NO. 16-17-041
COMPRFHI=NSIVr S1 ORMWATFR MASTER (PLAN CITY OF MIAMI (13-30632A)
PRE -ORALS SCORES
VIRGINIA WALSI I,P.G.,PI11)., SENIOR PROFESSIONAL GEOLOGIST, WASD, MDC
Proposer's Qualifications and Experience
Proposer's Tearn Qualifications,
Experience and Availability
Proposer Project Manager's Qualification
and Experience
Design App►oach and Process to
Functionality/Innovation
Technical Capabilities and Methodology in
Designing and Master Planning in South
Florida
CBE Participation
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
Kixi1tttiiit
Nuiuls
25
20
15
30
10
/f N
100
A&P CONSULI ING
TRANSPORTA1JON
ENGINEERS, CORP.
15
12
9
17
5
A n_A FNGINF FRING, INC
21
17
13
24
6
AFCOM 7FCHNICAL
SF1 VICFS, INC.
20
17
12
24
7
CDM SMITII tNC.
21
18
14
26
6
I1AIE N ANL) SAWYER
22
18
13
25
6