Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation Committee Report5ELECTiON PROPOSERS CRITERIA Proposer's qualifications and Experience Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposer's Team Project Manager's Qualification and Experience Methodology and Approach to Functloatality acid Design Concept Innovation Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida Project ManagementJSchedule Adherence and Plan Delivery CBE Participation Its TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS maximum Pullets Per Member 25 20 15 TuteI Pumts 14 nrerebersy 15 15 10 100 80 60 60 60 40 EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS RFP NO. 16-17-049 WYNWOOD NW 3RD AVENUE WOONERE STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN AECOMTechnical Services, Inc. 72 59. 51 31 48 35 5 0 100 405 296 Arquitectanica GEO Corporallon 80 65 50 42 54 33 0 324 COMPO5ITE SCORES 8erruello Ajamil & Partners, inc. 68 54 45 31 42 35 0 275 Curtis + Rogers Design Studio 60 59 46 34 40 32 0 EDSA, Inc. hlmley•Norn and Associates, Enc. l utal Ottice l.andxaPe & Urban I Trachtviiberg Fllegenzi LLC Design t L C 60 64 82 64 64 51 48 54 32 0 271 47 67 58 44 i 55 35 48 32 0 329 270 52 54 35 0 46 52 45 26 345 293 RANKIN r SIGNATUREr / -' Chairperson. /• _L ��� ` 1 Reviewed by: 4 3 6 PRINT NAME: jif>,%7 / . /?f •%C4Y Jam''!' 7 7 2 SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA Proposer's Qualifications and Experience Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposers Team Project Manager's Qualification and Experience Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept Innovation Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida Project Management/Schedule Adherence and Plan Delivery CBE Participation TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFQ NO. 16-17-049 WYNWOOD NW 3RD AVENUE WOONERF STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES Max pnl Pna Forms 25 20 15 15 15 10 AECOMTechnical Services, Inc. 18 JOSEPH EISENBERG, PLANNER Il, P&Z Arquitectonica GEO Corporation 19 17 15 12 15 Berniallu Alarm' K Partners, Inc. 18. 15 15 Curtis + Rogers Design Studio 15 16 15 EDSA, Inc. 20 kiniley-Ham and Associates, Inc. 18 15 15 12 10 8 78 Local Office Landscape 8 Urban TrachtenbergFslr• Design L.LC i L LC 20 19 15 14 14 8 90 18 16 15 12 14 8 83 SEL ECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA Proposer's Qualifications and Experience Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposer's Team • Project Manager's Qualification and Experience 'Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept Innovation EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFQ NO. 16-17-049 WYNWOOD NW 3RD AVENUE WOONERF STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES DAVID POLINSKY, WYNWOOD BID MEMBER, FORTIS DESIGN + BUILD LLC Maa<itl S4111 AECOMTechnical f Arluitechmlca GEO Points Services, Inc. 25 20 Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida Project Management/Schedule Adherence and Plan Delivery CBE Participation 15 15 15 10 Corpuraliun 12 I 15 10 12 13 8 3 5 10 12 8 8 Berrneilo Ajamil & Partners, Inc. 13 12 9 5 6 8 Curtis • Ruyers Design Studio 10 10 7 6 5 5 ED5A, Inc. 18 13 10 10 12 5 khtlley-Horn and Associates, liic. 10 5 5 3 14 5 Local Office landscape & Trachtenberg Ldkyenzl Urban Design Ll C LLC 16 12 12 10 14 8 13 15 8 13 10 4 TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 100 55 61 53 43 68 42 72 63 SEL L C1ION ,PROPOSERS CRfTFRSA Proposer's Qualifications and Experience Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposer's Team Project Manager's Qualification and Experience Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept Innovation Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Honda Project Management/Schedule Adherence and Plan Delivery CBE Participation TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS Ma: Pornlsm 25 20 15 EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFQ NO. 16-17-049 VVYNWOOD NW 3RD AVENUE WOONERF STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES AECOMTechnical Services, Inc. 20 ROBERTO ROVIRO, FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY Arquitectonica GEO Corporation 23 17 13 13 13 8 75 87 Bernell() Ajantil 8 Partners, Inc. 15 10 8 8 61 Curtis + Rogers Design Studio 15 15 10 10 10 10 70 E ❑SA, Inc. 20 15 12 12 15 10 84 Minley.Horn and Associates, Inc. 13 10 10 10 10 10 63 Local Office Landscape & Urban Design LLC 23 18 14 14 12 10 Trachtenberg Fayenxi LLe 12 10 10 15 9 8 91 64 SEt EC1ION PROPOSERS CRITERIA Propttser's Qualifications and Experience Maximum Nunn% 25 EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFQ NO. 16-17-049 WYNWOOD NW 3RD AVENUE WOONERF STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES AECOMTechnical Services, Inc. Qualifications, Experience and Availability ot Proposers Team Project Manager's Qualification and Experience Methodology and Approach to Functlonality and Design Concept Innovation Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida Project Management/Schedule Adherence and Plan Delivery CBE Participation 20 15 15 15 10 22 18 14 10 14 9 VICTOR SANCHEZ, WDRC CHAIRMAN, GOLDMAN PROPERTIES Aryultectunica GEO Corporation 23 18 14 12 14 Berrnenu keine & Partners, Inc. TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 100 87 90 22 17 13 10 13 9 Curtis . Rogers Design Studio 20 18 14 10 13 9 84 84 EDSA, Inc. 22 18 14 12 14 9 89 kirmley-Horn and Associates, Inc. 23 17 14 10 14 acal Office Landscape Trachtenberg Filiyenti 4 Urban Design TLC LTC 23 18 14 14 21 i7 13 12 14 12 9 9 87 92 83