Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation Committee ReportsEl ECti(SN PROPOSERS CRITERIA Proposers Qualifications and Experience Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposer's Team ,Project Manager's Qualification and Experience Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept innovation Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning In South Florida Project Management(Schedule Adherence and Plan Delivery CBE Participation TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS RANKING SIGNATURE! Chairperson: Reviewed by Mar/morn Total Polnls µ a,slnaarsl AECOMTechnlcal Services, inc. 76 56 47 38 44 PRINT NAME: EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS REP NO. 16-17-044 WYNWOOD STREETSCAPE ANO STREET TREE MASTER PLAN Arqunectonica GED Comorallon 89 72 57 65 57 COMPOSITE SCORES Curtis . Rogers Design N.rAly 60 65 47 33 44 3 EGSA. Inc. I /f klmleyhotn and Associates, Inc. 75 71 63 64 48 43 46 2 49 37 44 Miller, Legg a Associates. Inc. 72 54 45 Saving ACID, Oaalgn Snoslis. The alrnel Plans Coliaboralwe 67 71 58 66 48 Trachlenbsr9 Fit gan.n LLC 65 50 48 40 39 40 44 39 45 49 27 29 45 41 27 27 290 289 262 7 4 5 9 EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFC! NO. 16-17-044 WYNWQQD STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES JOSEPH EISENBERG, PLANNER II, P&Z SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA 1 Maximum AECOM7echnlcal Services, Inc. Arquitectonica Corporation GEO Curtis t Rogers Design Studio EOSA, Inc.Kimtey-Horn and Associates, Inc. Miller, Legg Associates, 8 inc. Savino Miller Design Studio, P.A. —. -r The Street Plans Collaborative 18 Trachtenberg RigProms LLC Proposers Qualifications and Experience 25 21 20 15 20 20 18 17 18 Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposers Team 20 18 16 16 18 15 15 12 10 8 15 15 17 15 16 15 12 14 8 Project Managers Qualification and Experience 15 15 15 15 15 15 15 Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept Innovation 15 7 12 7 12 11 �~ 10 14 14 Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida i5 15 14 12 13 13 14 8 Project ManagementiSchedule Adherence and Plan Delivery 10 8 8 8 8 8 8 CBE Participation �100 4110 I�TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS r 82 85 a a 73 ,_ Tr��~ J868C 1�--.—�_ — �_- 80 79 �� _... 83. 86 -I EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFQ NO. 16-17-044 WYNWOOD STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES DAVID POLINSKY, WYNWOOD BID MEMBER, FORTIS DESIGN + BUILD LLC SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA . Maximum Points AECDMTechnieai Services. tnc. Arqultectonica GEO Corporation Gunis. Rogers Design Studio ED5A, Inc. Kimsey -Horn and Associates. Inc. Miller, Legg & Associates, Inc Saving Miller Design Studio. P.A- The Street Plans Collaborative — Trachtenberg gene Rh LLC 10 10 5 9 5 5 ' Proposers Qualifications and Experience 25 12 24 5 10 8 12 13 15 Qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposer's Team 20 6 20 8 10 6 6 10 12 Project Manager's Qualification and Experience 15 7 15 8 8 8 6 10 10 8 — 8 Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept Innovation- 15 8 15 7 $ 2 5 8 — — — Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida 15 3 15 7 7 10 8 10 ,Project ManagementiSchedule Adherence and Plan Delivery 10 8 9 5 5 8 5 5 5 CBE Participation I / TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 100 44 98 40 46 42 42 56 58 44 (SELECTION (PROPOSERS Proposer's 0 Qualification of Proposer` Project Mana Experience Methodology Functionality ,Innovation Technical Ca Master Plann Project Mana and Plan Del CBE Particip TO TA EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFC) NO. 15-17.044 WYNWOOD STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES VICTOR SANCHEZ, WDRC CHAIRMAN, GOLDMAN PROPERTIES : RITE RIA s maximum Points AECOMTechnical Services, Inc. Arquilectcnlca GEO Corporation Curti$ * Rogers Design Studio EDSA, Inc_ Kimsey -Horn and Associates, Inc. Miller, Legg & Associates, Inc. Savino Miller Design Studio, P.A. The Street Plans Collaborative Trachtenberg Filigen: LLC ualifications and Experience 25 23 22 20 22 23 22 19 20 19 s, Experience and Availability Team 20 18 18 15 18 18 18 15 15 14 ger's Qualification and 15 13 14 12 13 14 13 13 12 12 and Approach to and Design Concept 15 11 15 10 14 11 12 12 13 10 pabilities in Designing and ing in South Florida 15 14 15 12 14 14 13 12 12 12 8 gement/Schedule Adherence ivery 10 9 10 8 9 9 9 9 8 olion 100 # $$ L TECHNICAL POINTS .�_,_—___m_.__,._.._._._._�......_.....-......�.. 94 77 _ ..... 90 ._.__.__,�._._.__.—..---..__—.__.. $9 87 .. — 80 $0 75 EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS RFC) NO. 16-17-044 WYNWOOD STREETSCAPE AND STREET TREE MASTER PLAN SERVICES ROBERTO ROVIRA, ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR, FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA maximum Points AECOMTechnical Services, Inc. Arquiteclonica GEO Corporation Curtis + Rogers Design Studio EOSA, Inc. - Kimley-Horn and Associates, Inc. Miller, Legg 8 Associates, Inc. Savino Miller Design Studio, P.A, - I The Street Plans Collaborative - - - - Trachtenberg Filigenzi LLC Proposer's Qualifications and Experience 25 20 23 20 23 20 20 18 18 18 10 qualifications, Experience and Availability of Proposer's Team 20 16 18 16 17 15 15 18 12 Project Manager's Qualification and Experience 15 12 13 12 12 12 11 10 9 8 Methodology and Approach to Functionality and Design Concept Innovation__ _ 15 12 13 9 11 12 11 10 9 8 10 6 'a Technical Capabilities in Designing and Master Planning in South Florida 15 12 13 13 12 10 11 12 11 Project Management/Schedule Adherence and Plan Delivery 10 9 10 10 9 5 5 7 6 CBE Participation4141 TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS 100 �i 81 90 80 84 74 73 75 65 60