Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation Committee ReportRFP NO. 680381 EMPLOYEE DISABILITY INSURANCE PROGRAM EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS COMPOSITE SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA '� Maximum Points Per Member Maximum Total Points (5 members} METROPOLITIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STANDARD INSURANCE COMPANY Proposer's organization qualifications, capabilities, and financial stability 25 125 107 116 Proposers proposed plan designs and benefits 20 100 80 97 Proposer's customer services and claims administration 20 100 96 87 Proposer's financial reporting and records 20 100 91 97 Technical Points 85 425 374 397 Proposers proposed price and cost effectiveness 15 75 61 72.25 Local Office (as defined in Section 18-73 of the Code) TOTAL TECHNICAL AND PRICE POINTS 5 25 0 0 100 525 435 469.25 Ranking 2 1 Signature: Chairperson Reviewed 9 5)1,! D17 Print Name: Lydia Osborne, CPPO Print Name: r 5nfir2017 RFP NO. 680381 EMPLOYEE DISABILITY INSURANCE PROGRAM EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS JAIR ESPINOZA, GROUP BENEFITS MANAGER (City) SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA Maximum Points METROPOLITIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STANDARD INSURANCE COMPANY Proposer's organization qualifications, capabilities, and financial stability 25 22 23 Proposer's proposed plan designs and benefits 20 18 20 Proposer's customer services and claims administration 20 18 17 Proposer's financial reporting and records 20 20 20 Technical Points 85 78 80 Proposer's proposed price and cost effectiveness 15 13 15 Local Office (as defined in Section 18-73 of the Code) 5 0 0 TOTAL TECHNICAL AND PRICE POINTS 100 91 95 5n 6/2017 RFP NO. 680381 EMPLOYEE DISABILITY INSURANCE PROGRAM EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS FRANK GOMEZ, PROPERTY AND CASUALTY MANAGER (City) SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA Maximum Points METROPOLITIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STANDARD INSURANCE COMPANY Proposer's organization qualifications, capabilities, and financial stability 25 26 25 Proposers proposed plan designs and benefits 20 15 18 Proposers customer services and claims administration 20 18 18 Proposers financial reporting and records 20 18 18 Technical Points 85 76 79 Proposer's proposed price and cost effectiveness 15 12 14 Local Office (as defined in Section 18-73 of the Code) 5 0 0 TOTAL TECHNICAL AND PRICE POINTS 100 88 93 511612017 RFP NO. 680381 EMPLOYEE DISABILITY INSURANCE PROGRAM EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS AUDREA HINDS, DEPUTY DIRECTOR, HR AND RISK (North Miami Beach) SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA \N. Maximum Points METROPOLITIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STANDARD INSURANCE COMPANY Proposer's organization qualifications, capabilities, and financial stability 25 20 20 Proposer's proposed plan designs and benefits 20 15 20 Proposer's customer services and claims administration 20 20 15 Proposer's financial reporting and records 20 15 20 Technical Points 85 70 75 Proposer's proposed price and cost effectiveness 15 12 15 Local Office (as defined in Section 15-73 of the Code) 5 0 0 TOTAL TECHNICAL AND PRICE POINTS 100 82 90 5/16 2017 RFP NO. 680381 EMPLOYEE DISABILITY INSURANCE PROGRAM EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS CHRISTINA CRESPI, DEPUTY DIRECTOR (DDA) SELECTION \ROPOSERS CRITERIA N. Maximum Points METROPOLITIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STANDARD INSURANCE COMPANY Proposer's organization qualifications, capabilities, and financial stability 25 20 23 Proposer's proposed plan designs and benefits 20 16 19 Proposer's customer services and claims administration 20 20 19 Proposer's financial reporting and records 20 18 19 Technical Points 85 74 80 Proposer's proposed price and cost effectiveness 15 12 14 Local Office (as defined in Section 18-73 of the Code) 5 0 0 TOTAL TECHNICAL AND PRICE POINTS too 86 94 5117, 2017 RFP NO. 680381 EMPLOYEE DISABILITY INSURANCE PROGRAM EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS DAVID DALEY, ASSISTANT DIRECTOR, RISK MANAGEMENT (CITY) SELECTION PROPOSERS CRITERIA Maximum Points METROPOLITIAN LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY STANDARD INSURANCE COMPANY Proposer's organization qualifications, capabilities, and financial stability 25 20 25 Proposer's proposed plan designs and benefits 20 16 20 Proposer's customer services and claims administration 20 20 18 Proposer's financial reporting and records 20 20 20 Technical Points 85 76 83 Proposer's proposed price and cost effectiveness 15 12 14.25 Local Office (as defined in Section 18-73 of the Code) 5 0 0 TOTAL TECHNICAL AND PRICE POINTS 100 88 97.25 srl8I2 17