HomeMy WebLinkAboutReport of Evaluation CommitteeRFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
POST ORAL
COMPOSITE
Pre -Paid Legal Services, Inc. of Florida dba LegalShield
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Per Member
David Daley
Richara
Brown-
Clarke
Steven
Mayer
Janies
Soper
Aniska
Elliott
Maximum
Total Points
(5 members)
Total Points
(5 members)
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and past
performance
20
18
18
20
20
18
100
94
Relevant experience and qualifications of key personnel,
including key personnel of subcontractors, that will be
assigned to this Contract, and experience and
qualifications of subcontractors
10
8
7
10
7
10
50
42
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
18
15
20
13
18
100
84
Member Services
20
15
15
19
15
18
100
82
f ity AssurancelUtilization Management
10
8
6
9
8
8
50
39
Proposer's Proposed Price
20
15
15
20
20
20
100
90
TOTAL POINTS
100
82
76
98
83
92
500
431
SIGNATURE:
Chairperson
Revjfewed By
DATE:
6/.71h7
6121 /2017
RFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
PRE -ORAL
COMPOSITE
Pre -Paid Legal Serv'ces, Inc. of Florida dba LegalShield
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Per Member
David Daley
Richara
Brown-
Clarke
Steven
Mayer
James
Soper
Aniska
Elliott
Maximum
Total Points
(5 members)
Total Points
(5 members)
Proposers relevant experience, qualifications, and past
performance
20
18
16
20
20
18
100
92
Relevant experience and qualifications of key personnel,
including key personnel of subcontractors, that will be
assigned to this Contract, and experience and
qualifications of subcontractors
10
5
7
8
7
10
50
37
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
10
15
17
15
17
100
74
Member Services
20
15
15
17
15
18
100
80
( ity Assurance/Utilization Management
10
5
6
10
8
8
50
37
Proposer's Proposed Price
20
15
13
20
20
20
100
88
TOTAL POINTS
100
68
72
92
85
91
500
408
SIGNATURE:
,4414
Cha'rprson
Rviewed By
DATE:
4/2-1 /17
612112017
RFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
POST ORAL
James Soper, Law Offices of Timothy K. Barket, P.A.
EVALUATIONPROPOSERS
CRITERIA
\
Maximum
Points
Pre -Paid Legal
Services, Inc. of
Florida dba
LegalShield
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
!past performance
20
ACC
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of
subcontractors, that will be assigned to this
Contract, and experience and qualifications of
subcontractors
10
1-
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
-
Member Services
20
1 C
Quality/Assurancellitilization Management
10
Proposer's Proposed Price
20
a
TOTAL POINTS
100
W'
DATE:
615/2011
RFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
POST ORAL
Richara Brown -Clarke, Graduate Intern to the City Manager, City Manager's Office
EVALUATION \ PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Pre -Paid Legal
Services, Inc. of
Florida dba
LegalShield
Proposers relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
20
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
10
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
1
Member Services
20
t 5
Quality/Assurance/Utilization Management
10
t
g
Proposers Proposed Price
20
TOTAL POINTS
100
DATE:
Printed Name
fil5/2n 17
RFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
POST ORAL
Steven Mayer, Miami -Dade County
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA_
Maximum
Points
Pre -Paid Legal
Services, Inc. of
Florida dba
LegalShield
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
20
.7 t
(-7'
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
10
1 ( j
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
-
Member Services
20
Quality/Assurance/Utilization Management
10
!)
i
Proposers Proposed Price
20
i 0
TOTAL POINTS
100
DATE:
t vnC. 07 r d
Printed Name
I7
6/5J2O17
RFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
POST ORAL
David Daley, Assistant Director, Risk Management Department
EVALUATION \PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Pre -Paid Legal
Services, Inc. of
Florida dba
LegalShield
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
20
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
10
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
1
Member Services
20
I
Quality/Assurance/Utilization Management
10
Proposer's Proposed Price
20
TOTAL POINTS
100
DATE:
(E)-4-v 0,16,
Printed Name
6/5/2017
RFP NO. 616390
GROUP LEGAL SERVICES AND IDENTITY THEFT SERVICES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
POST ORAL
Aniska Elliott, City Manager Intern, Risk Management Department
EVALUATION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Paints
Pre -Paid Legal
Services, Inc. of
Florida dba
LegalShield
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
20
\ (1
Relevant experience and qualifications of key
personnel, including key personnel of subcontractors,
that will be assigned to this Contract, and experience
and qualifications of subcontractors
10
0
Proposer's approach to providing the Services
requested in this solicitation
20
Member Services
20
1
Quality/Assurance/Utilization Management
10
Proposer's Proposed Price
20
20
TOTAL POINTS
100
SIGNATURE:
Uztf
Printed Name
tJATE:
6 Lzl
20l1
6/512017