HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation ReportSELECTION
CRITERIA
PROPOSERS
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications, and
past performance
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel that will be
assigned to the project
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
COMPOSITE SCORES
RFP 678364
Employee Benefit Consulting Services
MaKimurn
Points Per
Member
35
10
30
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Maximum Total
Points
(5members)
175
SO
AON Consulting, Inc.
158.50
45.50
Bolton Partners, Inc
152.95
Trion Group, a Marsh
& McLennan Agency
USI Insurance
Services, LLC
111.90
160.50
48.70
150
375
138.60
124.70
41.40
117.30
47.70
142.80
342.60
326.35
270.60
351.00
Proposer's Proposed Price
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
rechnical Pf tGil ,ewe 7irove)
25
125
100
500
100.00
442.60
86.75
100.25
99.50
413.10
370.85
450.50
PRINT NAME: C. Aar le) j
L '171 cql\t( S/420/7
.1,7. O.,
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Aniska Elliott (City of Miami)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
and past performance
Maximum
Points
AON
Consulting,
Inc.
Bolton
Partners, Inc
Trion Group,
a Marsh &
McLennan
Agency
USI Insurance
Services, LLC
35
35.00
35.00
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
that will be assigned to the project
10
10.00
10.00
31.50
35.00
8.00
10.00
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
30
27.00
26.70
21.00
30.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75
72.00
71.70
60.50
75.00
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
20.00
15.00
25.00
15.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(Technical & Price rows above)
100
92.00
86.70
85.50
90.00
5/1712017
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Jair Espinoza (City of Miami)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
A®
Consulting,
Inc.
Bolton
Partners, Inc
Trion Group,
a Marsh &
McLennan
Agency
USI Insurance
Services, LLC
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
and past performance
35
33.25
30.45
30.80
33.95
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
that will be assigned to the project
10
9.50
9.70
9.40
9.70
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
30
27.90
28.50
28.80
29.40
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75
70.65
68.65
69
73.05
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
22.75
21.75
22.25
22.25
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(Technical & Price rows above)
100
93.4
90.4
91.25
95.3
5117120 17
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Ramona White (Miami -Dade County)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Maximum
AON
Consulting, onsulting,
Inc.
Bolton
Partners, Inc
Trion Group,
a Marsh &
McLennan
Agency
USI Insurance
Services, LLC
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
and past performance
35.00
35.00
30.00
20.00
35.00
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
that will be assigned to the project
10.00
8.00
10.00
9.00
10,00
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
30.00
30.00
20.00
25.00
30.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75.00
73.00
60.00
54.00
75.00
Proposer's Proposed Price
25,00
25.00
15.00
10.00
25.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(Technical & Price rows above)
100.00
98.00
75.00
64.00
100.00
5117,12017
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Daniel Gonzales (Miami -Dade County)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
ConsOulting,
Inc.
Bolton
Partners, Inc
Trion Group,
a Marsh &
McLennan
Agency
USI Insurance
Services, LLC
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
and past performance
35.00
22.00
33.00
17.00
24.00
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
that will be assigned to the project
10.00
9.00
9.00
8.00
9.00
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
30.00
27.00
27.00
26.00
24.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75.00
58.00
69.00
51.00
57.00
Proposer's Proposed Price
25.00
10.00
20.00
25.00
15.00
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(Technical & Price rows above)
100.00
68.00
89.00
76.00
72.00
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
RFP 678384
Employee Benefit Consulting Services (Risk Management)
Sandra Ruiz (City of Mianrii Gardens)
SELECTION
PROPOSERS CRITERIA
j
MaximumBolton
Points
AON
Consulfing'
Inc_
Partners, Inc
Trion Group,
a Marsh &
McLennan
Agency
USI insurance
Services, LLC
Proposer's relevant experience, qualifications,
and past performance
35
33.25
24.50
12.60
32.55
Relevant experience and qualifications of Lead
Management Consultant and key personnel
that will be assigned to the project
10
9.00
10.00
7.00
9.00
Proposer's approach to providing the services
requested in the solcitation and ability to meet
schedules
30
26.70
22.50
16.50
29.40
TOTAL TECHNICAL POINTS
75
63.95
57.00
36.10
70.95
Proposer's Proposed Price
25
22.25
15.00
18.00
22,25
TOTAL TECHNICAL and PRICE POINTS
(Technical & Price rows above)
100
91.2
72
54.1
93.2
5/1712917