HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation Committee ReportCITY OF NIIAMI, FLORIDA
INTER -OFFICE 1NIEMORANDUMI
TO: Daniel J. Alfonso
City Manager
FROM: Arnie Perez, CPPO, !'rector
VA
Department of Procurement
DATE: April 13, 2017
SUBJECT: Report of Evaluation Committee for
RFQ No. 15-16-032, Capital Program Support
Services for the Office of Capital Improvements
ENCLOSURES: Response Security List,
Evaluation Committee Score Sheets. and Evaluation
Committee Appointment Memo
Background
On January 3, 2017, the Department of Procurement ("Procurement") issued Request for Qualifications
("RFQ') No. 15-16-032 for the provision of Capital Program Support Services ("Services") for the Office of
Capital Improvements (FOCI"). On February 13, 2017 three (3) proposals were received in response to
this solicitation. Subsequently, the proposals were reviewed by Procurement staff. and deemed
responsive and responsible in accordance with the minimum requirements and submission requirements
of the RFQ.
Summary of Evaluation
On April 7, 2017, the Evaluation Committee ("Committee") met and completed the evaluation of the three
(3) responsive and responsible proposals, following the guidelines stipulated in the solicitation. The
proposals were evaluated pursuant to the five (5) evaluation criteria listed below:
Evaluation Criteria
1, Proposer's Experience and Qualifications
2. Proposer's Team Experience and Qualifications
3. Management Plan
4. Experience of Program Coordinator
5. Proposer's Approach and Methodology to Rending Services
Maximum Points
(Per Committee Member)
25
25
25
15
10
Proposers who met the Community Business Enterprise ("CBE") participation requirement by assigning
certified CBE Firms with a "Local Office", as defined in City Procurement Code, Section 18-73, were
granted five (5) Bonus Points. in accordance with the RFQ and City Procurement Code, Section 18-87,
as amended. Only one (1) Proposer, CH2M Hill Engineers, Inc., met the CBE participation requirement
and "Local Office" criteria, and was granted the five (5) Bonus Points.
The final scores are as follows:
Proposing Firms
1. Atkins North America, Inc.
2. CH2M Hill Engineers, Inc.
3. Parson Brinckerhoff, Inc.
Awarded Points
(Maximum 505 Points)
469.25
457,5
416.75
Page 2 - Capital Program Support Services
Daniel J. Alfonso, City Manager
The Committee decided not to hold oral presentations, as the proposals did not require further
clarification. The composite and individual Committee member score sheets are attached as supporting
documentation.
Consensus Statement
The highest ranked firm, Atkins North America, Inc. ("Atkins"), received a total of 469.25 points out of a
maximum total of 505 points. The Committee determined that Atkins has assembled a team of design
and engineering professionals distinctly qualified to provide comprehensive Capital Program Support
Services for OCI.
The Committee discussed the experience and structure of Atkins proposed multi -disciplined team. Atkins
proposed a substantial resume of in house design and engineering professionals, in addition to proposing
a team of subconsultants to support civil engineering and information technology needs. As the
incumbent and a highly regarded engineering firm within the South Florida community, Atkins has played
a critical role managing the City of Miami's ("City) extensive Capital Plan. After deliberation, the
Committee members unanimously agreed that Atkins presented a proposal comprehensively suited to
meet the critical needs of the City.
Recommendation
The Committee hereby requests authorization for Procurement, in collaboration with OCI, to commence
negotiations with the highest ranked firm, Atkins North America; Inc., for the provision of Capital Program
Support Services, based an the immediate and projected needs of the City. Should negotiations fail, the
Committee hereby requests that negotiations commence with the second and third ranked firms,
respectively, until a Professional Services Agreement is successfully negotiated and subsequently
awarded.
Approved.
Daniel J. Af oeis , Ci ;Manager
Date: ! //7/
c: Fernando Casamayor, Assistant City ManagerlChief Financial Officer, City Manager's Office
Alberto N. Parjus, Assistant City Manager, City Manager's Office
Rafael Suarez -Rivas, Senior Assistance City Attorney, City Attorney's Office
Jeovanny Rodriguez, P.E., Director, OCI
Hector Badia, Assistant Director, OCI
Lydia Osborne, Ph. D., CPPO, CPPB, Assistant Director, Procurement
Maria Carballeira, CPPB, Procurement Administrator, Procurement
Anthony Rolle, J.D., M.Acct, CPPB, Procurement Contracting Manager, Procurement
PR17170
BID 1 [FM:
CITY 01NMI OFFICE OF TIFF CI IN CLERK
WI) SECT "i LIST
Capital Program Support Sell ivy;
BID NUNII31.:U: RET) 15-16-032
DATE RID OPENED: Fehr 13, 2017 TI,NIE: 2:00 p.m.
1ar4ons BrinckerhotI,
;.:INS
CI 12
f:
BIDDER
',.-, .17. !
ticoL, - 2._4 , _.(- ,.,-
4, _ ..
I
0
!I : ,--74-- r 1/4-± ,----LCI i.
1-o1..iVo Date.
IND 10111.
A1101 ".s,T
\."
1111) 13()ND tFiR
CALMIEIZ'S
C I K
lieceivez.1 (3) bitlis) on b,.....))i rrr
: Proeutement
7" CP.). 044-litrtp;
7
PREPARED 13Y: <17,"
Deputy City e1r1,
.lulicitafirm'fillet raffia al Program Support Services
(omillinet. f(Icniber
I left,:Dirt'Clul
(Alice of ('ultil/d Lnl,Inlrnrrnl5
l'ity of hli,lrrli
Jose OIIY':lni, ('lnCf (`unstruelinn Manager
()I Il.:c at Gail lt:at Improvements
City o1 Miami
h4ari Slt:ruiaki, Pi., 1)irectur
Public Wart,, 1)cl,artnu•nt
VIllaucof I'inL rL (
I.duurda Sant:unuria• 1'. Li., C'GC', I.ITD AP, f)ilttulr
I)c•Iruiulcul of
CI } ul t'+iltiI (i.Illlri
r 1.Ie1a 1'incd.+, 1 I°lit] Gwen r\Wylie❑+Ie, .'�1]I,Lnll i]inrlut•
Puhli Work, and Iingincvring Department
('Itt of I Itioicsic.4l1
1)eparl null( of 1'rt. tt rrmcnl
Evaluation C'ulnluillce !tanking I'`orlu
ritlas, April 7, 21117
l 'ongionile
It ji itsl for Qualifications (ltl°(f) No.: I S.l (-I1i2_
Parsons liriuek,crlrul'I', Isle. ithllr, N iii i11 1uu•rir;i, Inc. l•11211 11111 Engineers, Inc.
92.75 98,25 96.5
(1') XI 79
77 05 8')
87 l; 96
YI
Prt•lindn;4rti 5r11rc: 4111.75
hi±y IS) 131iu 1'uirlla; 15'Ui (I11' 1'aari. yrniun whllia ('ily of Miami IStlllndllries II
1.>I:11 ticurr; a 16.75
ItIIlk iuti!:
('uuuuill er Chair- Shot ( lial)t`v, 5elllclr Provuronl911 emit rat.' nlr• (nicer
Signature
'i '1?
Jnu,+S .w a.5
3
Verifier: M1laria (:.Ii1II a•irly, khurura ulrnl :\Ilnriniclr;Itur
Sigrlalure:_. !
.157.E
2
i. 1iciraru,n 7 fitly: Capital fragrant Vnl,(K,rl Srr, ices
I(5niantlun L!rllrrlr
1-5110 :n5c and 1)uullli.'.tl1.vuti
f'1u4a,.sel'o ! cmu 1'tlmn vice anti t lualnldllti its
11.111aj.•nn111 Nan
1- apcnent r ur I'lupl aw t 1 v,r.lmalur
1'uqu,.e1', ;xpla lurch .n.I 11rlhix6,lu l Ia Hcatk[ru.
?1asl ntunl
Department of Procurement
I:(altuttiau ( unmiltce Ranking Farm
Friday, Arill 7, 24117
1`unllx 1`al.aux H, inc6ci halt, li+;. :1ll.lnx %. rlh Ault rlcu. Inr. t 11!f11 11111 I'IL'inr1.x, lur.
.. _ _'d.7s ' 1
15 114 141 i1
lu •l1,
1111,11 tirnre tl' 7.5
I{rgura[ B,r (ia afiRr:llivao lli 1:12, Ntt.: I35-11.1053
rti Mt
( mnn11111 r N1,11111v1: I IvtIvr 14adia.. Asxislun1 Ili1.0 a, Office ul Capital 111.1.1 t-11,a,. l_in . 1 111.�wk
I)elrartnu•ur ul E'rurtlrernens
Fv iluatioti lianking Furirt
I'rid.l e, April 7, 211 ! 7
1 s .sl ation ('rlrc,in Iilnxlrtlullt I'1111.01111 III I neL,rhuFI, Enc. ,Ir1 Les hrn9h 4nu•1ku. Inr.
I'uim�
,,p,3acr, J \IaneI ca• �wd i 4rlliliauusss _'
u,I1tlrali,u,., 132 Ffrl \n.; Imo. Ir,_u e.
112'SI 11111 I'uwinrct,, Itu. ('om1rtenb
I'i ,prt+c•o'a I c4111fsperi:r1,: 4.K1 i)u.afilic.iunns :'.S li 22 f?
i 13
, ,a
Aitlnd�emeiu I'Inu - _.
I xrycrntit.c t,f 1'ra��r:3ni 1 •artcdm;u.,r 13 t' 14 1 _'
3i�,11t.,;.•r'a.4Ppro;16:11 tic+hudulagu cu Itcudcring ifi
Soo- it,ea
1.1110 Seurc
l amt3eilIrc NFclniier: .brae U11A,rn,v, l rucft ndr,aructinsi 11uu:ts!v.•r, 1N'firr of apiful I11tp1'o44111.111c, l iI sd \li:uui
F-r nluudun I I llrrlu
I'n,I+.o:Ka', b.pel lcuar .nni I)udlf i,•;unrna
Ih u1k1M.fs Ic,.ul 1 >.pallvucc ;w,l t1uaII1,1,ntio :
\Luwerw.:m Plan
l iu,:ncnca nI I'a.eg[aul r".Ng1litoh.t
I'rvq.v.xt`� Appr.c.ah and )Ictllwln&Igy 10 ltendrring
'ticn
\IHR§llllluI,
15
111
Il.plrluu•nt lal I'rucureincus
N.\iiluuliun I Ipuuuillce I{•rnkillt; Gunn
ha'irl'r1,.\piit 7, 241117
I'urpuua 14rinslacrlulll, In . .\tjlua Mn Ilr \r.ar. i.rv_ lu.. t 11--\1 s§dl FgFinvew, lua,
!li
21.1
Iti 'J ryi
15
6 itral tirnre 77
liryoa•,I Im i�n..lil ..u.,[ R 1:tp. _IS- 464l12
i'nnmten!,
I'unrmluet• 1u 1uhcl \I 14 5211o§ II I hµs)l ieurr, Puhlic 51'ur6e R II n [En},In, 1 1kL[ue of Viuel•resl
1
S1,rl44aSE011 li k Cupitrd,Etwru !
141191111111.0111 rf lel'r4 nr l•11R'111
E+;11uaiion ('rnuuillcr I(ankin. 11,rn1
Frillac, April 7, '_II E7
lie�uo,1 t..r 1}u;,liliryri,,,,. lRI (1?5.l,; 15.k0-41!
I•.YMlurllun f•rIftrIN !41xid1onln rXr'1N1111 Itrhrckerhnrl, Ng. .41 khn \,.rih .1 nIerlca. Inc. 1 11211 Hill Buplinwt, 1oa f'nnulnmll
leulnln
Ih..11.Po '11',Ixy 1r114c.11u1 14y,dhli.;t111.,n5 24 eu 2-I •1
1'a.yr,laa-a l it1111 lsp ircli ;nil 1)1r.,1d1.1tlu,u. '_5 24
1IJI1.ILIIkY,F 11JI1 h5 22 �l
I•xp.• ,,ua.w.1 I'eu1;I.1n, t euudivale,e 15 15 15 15
Ei,4 wl>ce4. Appro:u h curl htclhn:k.lugy 111Overdo uIg
lu l 7 III
1•inal Score 14? ai rm.
! ouuuitecc 11en1ber: I du i.1 eh 51uu nunlie,•.1',I• (I. ( I J » 1 I11r(Cp,r. Ilcyrarlr11r11t of 11uhlic Nark,, CI11 nt' l neal Gables
IkparimenIu1.1'runii iii,u1
F'ealuutiux f'onuuiuec liuukiu, Ptlrut
Fl itIa}, .\prit 7, 21117
�ulirit+t6+.n "1'S11c: l.ulril..I 1'ragruut 5.r1>IMrei ScrNins _ _ _ _ - Itrj. --.1 iur ilu:dil5t•;itiuny tto..Ql
1 Alxxhluml
F, xluxllun I' 1 Iola f'uimn 1'atuaun Ili inc6rl Lce ull, I . AlAlus \ul lh tnno kill. Ill, t 111111 11111 ',ugh., P.i, Inr.
I'i,gn.v:r', 1..p.elenre anal JJuulill,;alom;; 2.1
I ....Alb P w l icn..r ,.ul,i I W.IIilidunuu.. ,:,
)auu�egrutcul plan - ... +
F ryirocn,c ul 14,1yr. l'txlydurn+rt IS I + 14 14
hop mcr, Aplmmid Moll, 001,/0 Ia I(e11nL011lg
Ill
Final Scum
4,1
ku
r7�
('II1iWllt'il1S
('nwaulacr U dnri. hi.ul Fiicr+.l a. t 11 11 / l rn h»nn iulv_�tn+inl I( Iflrn Cn I_Ih]ic R'urk an .1:211,opuci,mg 11cg111 null, tl Ilmlii.klr ll,