HomeMy WebLinkAboutBack-Up - AppraisalLAND APPRAISAL REPORT
Fain File No. 1851731 Page #1I
#A-07-15-012
File No. 185173
Borrower City Of Miami Census Tract 0064.02 Map Reference 54-41-10
Property Address 1197 SW 1918 Avenue
„
City Miami County Miarni-Dade State FL Zip Code 33135
i.e Legal Description Lot 12 BLK 2 SOUTH SHENANDOAH PB 11-64
Sale Pr ce $ N/A Date al Sale N/A Loan Ten N/A yrs. Property Rights Appraised Z Fee Li Leasehold L. 1 De Minimis PUD
Actual Real Estate Taxes $ 1,883.63 (yr) Loan charges to be paid by seller $ N/A Other saes concessions N/A
Lenden City Of Miami/ Jacqueline Lorenzo Address 444 SW 2nd Avenue, 3rd Floor Maxmr, Florida 33130
Occupant Vacant Land Appraiser E. Jorge Santin Instructions to Appraiser Determine market value.
Folio 01-4110-064-0172 *Owner of Record;Federal National Mortgage Association **On 05/29/2015, the property transfered
Location Z Urban Li Suburban El Rural
Built Up Z Over 75% El 25% to 75 El Under 25%
Growth Rate Z Fully Dev. LI Rapid 0 Steady f--4 Slow
Property Values Z Increasing Z Stable LI Declining
Demand/Supply El Shortage Z In Balance LI Oversupply
Marketing Time Li Under 3 Mos. .6. 4-6 Mos. 0 Over 6 Mos.
Present Land Use 45%1 Family 40% 2-4 Family 5% Apts. i% Condo 8% Commercial
% Industrial /Ms Vacant Ms
Good Avg. Fair Poor
Employment Stability Z Z hi El
Convenience to Employment Z LI1 Z EJ
Convenience to Shopping Z Z Ed Ell
Convenience to Schools Z Ei fil Li]
Adequacy of Public Transportation Z El Li II
Recreational Facilities El X El 0
Adequacy of Utilities Z El LI II
Change in Present Land Use Z Not Likely 14 Likely (*) EI Taking Place ()
(") From To
Property Compatibility 0 Z 0 El
Protection from Detrimental Conditions El Z E E]
Predominant Occupancy Z Owner Z Tenant 0 % Vacant
Police and Fire Protection LI Z E El
Single Family Price Range $ 150 000 to $ 750,000 Predominant Value $ 295,000
General Appearance of Properties ttl] sZ r] E
Single Family Age New yrs. to 91 yrs. Predominant Age 60 yrs.
Appeal to Market Z El Ed E
Comments including those factors, favorable or unfavorable, affecting marketability (e.g. public parks, schools, view,
nose): The property is located in the Shenandoah
neighborhood in an established area of the city of Miami just west of downtown. The neighborhood has good appeal because of its proxirnity
o Coral Gables amenities, Coral Way and 10 downtown Miami. I is composed of a mix of ostly single-family homes and 2-4 family uses.
Coral Way leads east and northeast to downtown Miami and the Brickell financial district and west onto Coral Gables.
Dimensions 57 x 118 - 6,726 Sq. Ft. or Acres Z Comer Lot
Zoning classification T3-R ,Sub Urban Transect Zone (Restricted) Present Improvements LI do Z do not conform to zoning regulations
Highest and best use LI Present use IX Other (specify) Construction of a two-family or single family residence -Zoning restricted to Residential
Public Other (Describe)
OFF SITE IMPROVEMENTS
Topo At Street Level
Elec. Z
Street Access Z Public LA Private
Size Average
Gas E
Surface Asphalt
Shape Rectangular
Water Z
Maintenance Z Public L..] Private
View Other Homes/Two-family Residences
San. Sewer
Z Storm Sewer Z Curb/Gutter
Drainage Adequate
Eli Underground Elect. & Tel
EI Sidewalk E Street Lights
Is the property located in a HUD Identified Special Flood Hazard Area? Z Na El Yes
Comments (favorable or unfavorable including any apparent adverse easements, encroachments, or other adverse conditions). No adverse easements of encroachments
observed. Typical corner lot for neighborhood. There are no known adverse environmental conditions or adverse easements. The Flood Zone
is X. 208 C-0 1 L. 09-11-2009 ** via a certificate of title as rocordod on plat book 29662 page 2591 on pubt,o records of Miami -Dade
County, Florida for $150,600.
The tinders g ned has recited three recent sales of propel es most similar and proximate to subject and has considered these in the market analysis, The description Includes a dollar
adjustment reflecting market reaction to those Items of significant variation between the subject and comparable properties, If a significant item in the comparable property is superior
o or mere favorable than the subject property, a minus (-) adjustment is made thus reducing the indicated value of subject; if a significant item in the comparable is Inferior to or less
favorable than the subject property, a plus (+) adjustment is made thus increasing the indicated value of the subject.
ITEM I SUBJECT PROPERTY
COMPARABLE NO. 1
COMPARABLE NO. 2
COMPARABLE NO.
Address 1197 SW 19th Avenue
Miami, FL 33135
1176 SW 22nd Terrace
Miami, FL 33135
1322 SW 11th Stree
Miami, FL 33135
1938 SW 22nd Ter
Miami, FL 33145
Proximity to Subject0.27
miles W
0.58 miles E
0.84 miles S
rice
ale Pre
N/A
30,000
5,000
315,000
Price SF
56.41
40.38
2 35.90
=
Data 500rce
Warranty Deed ,MDP
Warranty Deed / MLS, MDPA
Warren y Deed / MLS, MDPA
Warranty Deed / MLS, MDPA
k
Dale of Sale and
Time Adjustment
DESCRIPTION
DESCRIPTION
+ (- )S Adusi.
DESCRIPTION
(- )$ Adjust
DESCRIPTION
(- )$ Adjust.
N/A
04/16/2014-Clsd
04/16/2015-Clsd
03/03/2015-Clsd
Location
Urban
Urban
Urban
Urban
Site/View
6,726 SF
5.850 SF
7,800 SF
8,775 SF
Improvements
None
Vacant1,012
SF House
Vacant
Vacant
Bldg Townhouse
Zoning
T -R
T3-0
T3-0
T -R
LP 5379,999
P $358,000
Sales or Financing
Concessions
N/A
DOM 26 Cash
Cash
DOM 10 Cash
Net Adj. (Total)
I- F -
II Fl
PI -'$
Indicated Value
of Subject
330.000
'
315,000
315,000
Comments on Market Data: The four comparables used are the most recent and best available sales of buildable lots from the subject's general
market area with similar zoning. All sales are located in similar zoning as st bject. Consideration was given to all sales but most weight 10 sale
2 & 3 in subect's neighborhood. Sales 1 & 4 are located in tlre "Roads" neighborhood in the city of Miami which is considered superior.
Comments and Conditions of Appraisal: See attached addenda.
Final Reconciliation: The sales comparison approach has been give so e consideration toward the final estimate of value. The above sales
sw, gest a range of approximatelly $35.90-$56.41 per Srare fo)181he598'e00917Th10n001 value falling within the higher end of range.
Land value was concluded or subject property based op 04,Qjeyguare feet or $305,000.
ESTIMATE THE MARKET VALUE, BS OEFINED,OF SUBJECT PlOP OF 8/17 20 15 to be $ 305,000
i
1
E. Jorge Santin
i Chavoustie, MAI M Did E] Did Not Physically Inspect Properly
Appraiser(s) Review Apprauer (if applicable)
)Y2K]
Appraisal First (305) 470-2100
Form LND iNVinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
LAND APPRAISAL REPORT
MARKET DATA ANALYSIS
Main File No. 185173111-2
#A-07-15-012
File No. 185173
ITEM I SUBJECT PROPERTY
COMPARABLE NO. 4
CO PARABLE NO. 5
COMPARABLE NO. 6
Address 1197 SW 19th Avenue
Miami, FL 33135
1823 SW 2nd Ct
Miami, FL 33129
Proximity to SubjectSubect
1.62 miles E
Sales Price
N/A
60 000
Price
48.00
Data Source
Warranty Deed MDP
Warranty Deed / MLS MDPA
Dalo of sale and
DESCRIPTION
DESCRIPTION (-1$ Adjust.
DESCRIPTION
+(-)5 Adjust.
DESCRIPTION
+(-) Adjust.
Time Adjustment
N/A
/24/2014-Clsd
Location
Urban
Urban
Site/View
6 726 SF
7 500 SF
Rnpnoverrents
None
Vacant
Vacant
Zoning
T -R
T -R
LP $375,000
Sales or Financing
Concessions
N/A
DOM 12 Cash
Net Ad. (Total)
11 + 1-1 - ,
1-1 Fl
1 1 - ,$
Indicated Value
et Subjgct
60,000
$
Comments: Comparable sale 4 is a located in a neighborhood in higher demand,
Form LND.(AC) —11NinTOTAM appraisal software, by a la mode, inc. -800-ALAMODE
Main File No. 185173
File No. 185173
Supplemental Addendum
Borrower/Clienl
City Of Mlatni
Properly Address
1197 SW 19th Avenue
City
Miami
G000ly Miami -Dade
Slale FL
Zip Code
135
Lender
City Of Miami/ Jacqueline Lorenzo
• Land : Conditions of Appraisal
USE OF THE APPRAISAL
This appraisal report is to be used by the client for internal purposes as it relates to a buying decision. The
appraisal reports are for the sole use of the listed client, or its assigns. "Readdressing an appraisal report
to another party that was completed and delivered to a client is prohibited by USPAP. Once the
assignment is completed, it is misleading to try to add a new party as client or intended user who was not
the original client or identified intended user.- Any requests for updating or re -certification would
constitute a new assignment at an additional fee.
INTENDED USER OF THE APPRAISAL
The intended user of this report is The City of Miami.
PURPOSE OF THE APPRAISAL
The purpose of the report is to estimate the Market Value of the subject property.
DEFINITION OF MARKET VALUE
Market Value is the most probable selling price in terms of money which a property should bring in a
competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to be fair sale, the buyer and seller, each acting
prudently, knowledgeably, and assuming the price is not affected by undue stimulus. implicit in this
definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and the passing of title from seller to buyer
under conditions whereby:
1. Buyer and seller are typically motivated;
2. Both parties are well informed or well advised, and each acting in what they
consider their own best interests;
3. A reasonable time is allowed for exposure in the open market;
4. Payment is made in cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements
comparable thereto; and
5. The price represents a normal consideration for the property sold unaffected by
special financing or creative financing or sales concessions granted by anyone
associated with the sale.
Source: The Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines, Federal Register, Volume 75, No. 237,
December 10, 2010.
Marketing Titne: An opinion of the amount of time it might take to sell a real or personal property
interest at the concluded market value level during the period immediately after the effective date of an
appraisal. Marketing time differs from exposure time, which is always presumed to precede the effective
date of an appraisal.
Source: Appraisal Institute, The Dictionary of Real Estate Appraisal, 5th edition (Chicago: Appraisal
institute), 2010.
The marketing time for land for redevelopment in the city of Miami can be a short as 1 month and
typically less than four months. The local market is active with investors showing a willingness to
purchase. The supply of redevelopment sites for sale are limited. Most properties are sold word of mouth
and not actively listed. When properly marketed at an asking price no more than 10% over the estimated
market value, the marketing and exposure time of the subject should be less than three to four months.
Form TADD ---'WinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, Inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
gain File No. 1851731 jla_gli
Subject Photo Page
Borrower/Client
City Of Mlatni
Properly Address
1197 SW 19th Avenue
City
Miami
County Miami -Dade
Stale FL
Zip bode 33135
Lender
City Of Miami/ Jacqueline Lorenzo
,IIII111011111,11111111i1"11
gd„
liV4/070741040,iprz4441
Subject Front
1197 SW 19th Avenue
Sales Price N/A
G.L.A.
Tot. Rooms
Tot, Bedrms.
Tot. Bathrms.
Location Urban
View 6, 726 SF
Site
Duality
Age
Subject Street
Form SUBLG2 i'VVinTOTALli appraisal software by a la mode, Inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
Subject Land Photo Page
1Main File No. 1851731 Pane #51
Borro or/Client
City Of Miami
Proporty Address
1197 SW 19th Avenue
City
Miami
County Miami -Dade
Stale FL
Zip Code 3
135
Lender
City Of Miami/ Jacqueline Lorenzo
Subject Front
1197 SW 19th Avenue
Sales Price N/A
Date ol Sale N/A
Location Urban
Site/View 6,726 SF
Improvements None
Vacant
Zoning T3-R
111111110111101111hiovoriiiiii
111111111
12.1171,11,10001RIfr
Subject Rear
Subject Street
Form DMSLND — 'WinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
Main File No.
Comparable Land Photo Page
Borrower/Cli nt
City Of Mlami
Property Address
1197 SW l9th Avenue
Sty
Miami
Co in y Miami -Dade
State FL
Zip Code 33135
Lender
City Of Miami/ Jacqueline Lorenzo
!FOV A
f0oitt
?,1,h
montolottijr 11111111111111,tattft itta
„ vkiii/1 dy"A
,7feNt411WattfaVflif
,t 4,,,/,/21,4,1010:/1/ //q,Ae,//0",/e/ozopiti41,664t,
offtiket/
WOW geme; *Age,
WyrT4w
4,4KOKtViAtAMMAMV<;,,,/ kOlo*
Comparable 1
1176 SW 22nd Terrace
Prox. to Subj.
Sales Price
Date of Sale
Location
Site/View
Improvements
Zoning
Comparable 2
1322 SW 11 Street
Prox. to Subject
Sales Price
Date of Sale
Location
Site/Vew
Improvements
Zoning
Comparable 3
1938 SW 22nd Terrace
Prox. to Subject
Sales Price
Date of Sale
Location
Site/View
Improvements
Zoning
Form DM%LND —'WinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
NLIa.J, No. 1851731 Paue #71
Comparable Land Photo Page
Borrower/C lien 1
City Of Mlami
Property Address
1197 SW 19th Avenue
City
Miami
County Miami -Dade
Stale FL
Zip Code 33135
Lender
City Of Miami/Jacqueline Lorenzo
,
tA ?A it 14?
?ttAA ?A'AA14‘AkIpA `1 'P)1.611ktti %1'?; I IV?
uth '111141 140 ILvAdk,
Comparable 4
1823 SW 2nd Ct
Prox. lo Subj. 1.62 miles E
Sales Price 360,000
Date of Sale
Location
Sitc/Vicw
Improvements
Zoning
11/24/2014-Clad
Urban
7,500 SF
Vacant
T3-R
LP $375,000
Comparable 5
Prox. to Subject
Sales Price
Dale of Sale
Location
Site/View
Improvements
Zoning
Comparable 6
Prox. lo Subject
Sales Price
Date oiSale
Location
Site/View
Improvements
Zoning
Form DM%LND — VinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
[fin File No.1851731 Page #81
Comparable Properties Map
Borrower/Client
City Of Miami
PropelyAddress
1197 SW 9th Avenue
City
Miami
County Miami -Dade
State FL
Zip Code
3 /
5
Lender
City Of Miami/Jacqueline Lorenzo
a la rnode, in
see 55
PTH 2::Rd
11/11 11/1 N 2 0 / St
11:7/1
1,,wv //g5
4 5
NW 17th 14 I.,. >
'414
...., .
11/1
111003
NW 14th
Nerd
mamap "aa /5
• , r7„,
139
“.1 01
Hao
3433
St
Lu,s 'W.ay NW
NW 4231 Sk
33trrn,
;3 3th 5 3991,./15 ,
10*103
5-
t„.
452
5 Comi Way
132333
072
12
',/e,
5i2 e,d1', e' • '5
//56 Ay•ft ';',,,,?:;
tA:
...4.
n-
5,
2 Per,
SVV 1.si.
• 1'11,(,i'0011.1:111.'
•
SW 155 St.
,.,4444/4-,••••,
4
9399*990
1111111111
111,, ••••//ist15: 01/15e, •
v —
992 'Q.th
4:1
, 10.
95
NW 2544
141
;43
4)
43
514':i2rid
44.74a
02"...3601
10A, 64h M33
15
11111UlalllUkill11:111111111f i'11.1.1711i111l11"111111111114i
f Or
S,Aq
145/1/11lee 15'5555 tee:
5355e.5.75" 995//99
/ . ./ • 0..g Odes'
Form MAP.LOC 'WinTOTAL'' appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
Main Ho No 185173 Pa c
Flood Map
Borrower/Client
City Of Mlarni
Property Address
1197 SW 19th Avenue
City
Miami
County Miami -Dade
State FL
hip Code 33135
Lender
City Of Miami/Jacqueline Lorerrzo
Prepeaed Aprtrais21 First
1197 SW 19th Avenue
Fl. 33135
7.,LES,AZ
ote,i e CO ow, tr,
FEMA Special r 19 co Hazr:rci ArenNo
1`.1a p fflumbor, 12086C0313L
Zwe: X
Mop DrrP. September 11, 2009
F1P.5.- 12086
Arer3q, inundated by 5.90-yEzr floodely
0$ emulated by 100,ypr flooding
Velomly HOZUK{
Form MAP.FLOOD —ttAhriTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, Inc —1-800-ALAMODE
USPAP ADDENDUM
Plain File No. 1851731 Page #101
#A-07-15-012
File No. 165173
Borrower City Of Miami
Property Address 1197 SW 19th Avenue
City Miami
Lender
City Of Miami/ Jacqueline Lorenzo
iami-Dade
State FL Zip Code 33135
This report was prepared under the following USPAP reporting option:
Z Appraisal Report This report was prepared in accordance with USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(a).
E Restricted Appraisal Report This report was prepared in accordance with USPAP Standards Rule 2-2(b),
Reasonable Exposure Time
My opinion of a reasonable exposure time for the subject property at the market value slated in this report is: 6-12 months
Additional Certifications
I certify that, to the best of my knowledge and belief:
V] I have NOT performed services, as an appraiser or in any other capacity, regarding the property that is the subject of this report within the
three-year period immediately preceding acceptance of this assignment,
fl I HAVE performed services, as an appraiser or in another capacity, regarding the property that is the subject of this report within the three-year
period immediately preceding acceptance of this assignment. Those services are described in the comments below.
— The statements of fact contained in this report are true and correct.
— The reported analyses, opinions, and conclusions are limited only by the reported assumptions and limiting conditions and are my personal, impartial, and unbiased
professional analyses, opinions, and conclusions.
— Unless otherwise indicated, I have no present or prospective interest in the property that is the subject of this report and no personal interest with respect to the parties
involved.
— I have no bias with respect to the property that is the subject ot this report or the parties involved with this assignment.
— My engagement in this assignment was not contingent upon developing or reporting predetermined results.
— My compensation for completing this assignment is not contingent upon the development or reporting of a predetermined value or direction in value that favors the cause of
the client, the amount of the value opinion, the attainment of a stipulated result, or the occurrence of a subsequent event directly related to the intended use of this appraisal.
— My analyses, opinions, and conclusions were developed, and this report has been prepared, in conformity with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice that
were in effect al the time this report was prepared.
— Unless otherwise indicated, I have made a personal inspection of the property that is the subject of this report.
— Unless otherwise indicated, no one provided significant real property appraisal assistance to the person(s) signing this certification (if there are exceptions, the name of each
individual providing significant real property appraisal assistance is stated elsewhere in this report).
Additional Comments
The appraisal report intended for the exclusive use of the client towards determine market value for internal purposes, and not intended for
any other use.
AnnaMaria Chavoustie has completed the continuing education requirements of the Appraisal Institute. We currently hold the appropriate
state certification for the State of Florida..
APPRAISER:
e.x
Signatrire: C
Name: E. Jorge Santin
Date Signed: August 19, 2015
Slate Certilication #: Cert Gen RZ 3274
or Stale License #:
State: FL
Expiration Date of Cedification or License: 11/30/2016
Effective Date of Appraisal: 8/17
SUPERVISORY/AP
Signature:
ER: (only if required)
Name: AnnaM..rw uv ustie, MAI
Dale Signed: August 19, 2015
State Certification #: Cert Gen. RZ 323
or State License #:
State: FI
Expiration Dale of Certification or License: 11 /30/2016
Supervisory Appraiser Inspection of Subject Properly:
H Did Not [1] Exterior -only from Street Li Interior and Exterior
Form ID14AP — VinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
Nain File No.
ADDENDA - Page 1
851731 Paye 11
7/212015 City ofKinni
REVISE!) !KT:QUEST FOR APPRAISAL 0 LOTE
You are invited to submit a. quote to prepare', an appraisal report based on the Appraisal Assignment
attached herewith as Exhibit "A",
Please complete the informption requested at the bottom of this pae. The, quote and below
information must be received by the Department li4osl Estate and Asset Mamwement. ho 3:00o:m.,
Tuesday, July 7, 2015.
You may submit your proposal via email or by mail to;
Jacqueline 1:„,orcrizn
Project Manaaemerit Representative
Department of Real. Estate, and As;,,e1. Management
City of Ilytiami
444 SW 2 Avenues, 3'6 Floor
31 FL 33130
005) 416-1423
ihrgiVgiraiOnd
ADDRESS
1197 SW 19th AVCT11,10
FOLIO
01-4110-064-0172.
JOB No,
A-07-15-012
Fees:
Comprehensive total fee to per Corm appraisalLs:
Hourly fee in the event expert testimony is required',
Format to be used: (Select. one)
D Uniform Residential Appraisal Report FUTITS
D Narrativct Surrunary Appraisal Repoli
Appraisal Firs!.
Appraisal Compaily:
Teleplione/Fx tension;
Bv: Anna Chavoustie Da, 7-1-15
s 350.00
S
Delivery 7-16-15
NOTE: When sending a quote, your company must comply with the completion doe date, If
selected, your company must provide a Certificate of Insurance in the manner
prescribed in Exhibit "C" below.
Page 1 of 5
Form SCNLGL —'WinTOTAL'' appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
IMain File No. 1851731 Pape #12I
ADDENDA - Page 2
7/2/2015 City ofMiarni
EXHIBIT "A"
APPRAISAL ASSIGNMENT
Job Number: A-0.7-1.50Q12
Category of 'Work:.
Fiscal -Year: 2014-15
Location: 11.97 SW 1.9th..Avenue
Fotin No, 0) 411 0-064-0 172
Lot Size: Approximately 6,726 SF
Adjusted Area: 0 SF
Improverntats: None
Purpose. of Appraith lo determine fair Market Value at -Highest eidUt Use, in order
to negotiate purPhase priee For possible property acquisition,
Property R ig,hts Appraised: Fee Simple
(0urrem Zoning: 1-3-42 Sub -Urban Transect Zone (under Miami 2) Zoning Code).
Type of Appraisal-. Summary Appraisal R.cport. (Either Narrative Pr USPAP-compliant
Uniform Residential Appraisal Report are. acceptable)
Time to Cornple(e: The e ppraiStil reportnius be completed no later than fifteep (15)
days after authorization.
Number of boundpies: .Four„ (aigned and certified),
City Contact Persom
Jacqueline Lorenzo, Property Management Specialist
T: (305) 416-1.426
RcsclLion Reference: None.
Date of th(.:: Valuation; Date of the appraisal reTort.
Fee: Full payment upon completion of the assignment, subject to
revisions by the City of Miami and any other review appraiser
should there be any discrepancie,,,' in the appraisal. reports.
Page 2 of 5
Form SCOLGL — ''VVinTOTAL' appraisal software by a la mode inc. --1-800-ALAMODE
MDfri No. 1851731 Pa e #131
ADDENDA - Page 3
7/2/203 5 City of Miami
THE APPRAISAL REPORT ,LJOE THE FOLLOWNG:
1. The appraisal report shall be performed hi compliance with the professional serviees agreement
with the City for appraisal services as applicable.
The apnraiSal report must consider all three approaches to value and provide an explanation to
the weight given to each approach in arriving at the final reconciliation of value, in the event an.
approach is not used, please provide justification, Please provide evidence for not using the Cost
Approa ch.
caleulitting the Market Data, .the appraiser should analyze and provide current local market
dataand submit adjustment tables of comparables.
4, If utilixiirtg a Land Sales Gi.»nparable 'fable to calculate Sales Price per Square Foot, please
provide- line item adjust:merits in a matrix format for 1.1berier understanding of the SUrrirnary and
Land Value (ion -elution conclusion.
5, Provide source and proof of -capitalization rate tier the income approach to value in local market
versus other market when applicable,
6. Provide Market IJata as if taxable. property.
7. 'fbe apprail;a1 report should he :in compliance with the current Uniform Standard of Professional
Appraisal Practice (USPAP) according to Section 475, Part 11, of the Florida Statutes, The City
of 'Miami reserves the right to review the, appraisal report and submit its comments. The final
report will he dur five days oder the appraisal is reviewed by City's staff
Note: All calculations 111115t be explicit, Show all steps used to arrive at any conclusions provided.
All data in this sheet rni [sr be verified by the appraiser, if arty discrepancy, please call this office at
305-416-1426.
Page 3 of 5
Form SCNLGL—'WinTOTAL'' appraisal sotlware by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
Main File No.1851731 Foe #14I
ADDENDA - Page 4
7/2/2015 City iDi'Miarni
EMI] for "II"
INSURANCE RE()1.1112 EMENTS
(I) Commercial General Liability (Primary & Nou Contributory)
A. Limits of Liability
Bodily Injury and Property Damage Liability
Each Occurrence SI ,000,000
General Aggregate Limit S2,000,000
Products/Completed Operations S1,000,000
Personal and Advertising 'limy SI „000,000
3. Endorsolents14isipirpd.
City of Mlani] included as an additional insured
Contingent Liability (Independent (2ontcactors Coverage)
Contractual Liability
Premises 0 Operations Liability
Primary Insurance Clouse
(II) Business Automobile hirthility
A. Limits of
Tujitry and 'Properly Dinnage
Combined Single Limit
Any Auto/Domed Ai/Scheduled
Including I tired, Borrowed or Non -Owned Autos
Any One Accident $ 1,000,1)1)0
0. En.dorsements Rewired
City of .Miami included as an Additional Insured
(111) Worker's Compensation
A. 'Limits oft „labitli.
Statutory -Slate of Florida
Waiver or subrogation
(IV) Employer's Liability
A. Linitaofliabil.ity,
00,000 for bodily injury caused by an accident, each accident,
$100,000 for bodily injury caused by disease, each employee
$.5 00,000 for bodily injury caused by disease, policy limb
(V) :Professional Liability/Error's & Omissions
A. I.Imits of Liability
Combined Single Limit
Each Claim
General Aggregate Limit
Retro Date Included
SI ,000,000
51,000,000
Page 4 of 5
Form SCNLGL — MinTOTAL" spot sal software by a la mode, Inc 1-800-ALAMODE
ADDENDA - Page 5
'Main File No. 1651731 Pacie #15,1
7/2/2015 City of Miami
BINDERS ARE UNACCEPTA B LE.
The above policies shall provide the City of.Miarni with written notice of cancellation or material
change from the insurer in accordance to policy provisions. Companies authorized to do business
in the State of Florida, with the fol,lowing qualifications, shall issue rifi insurance policies
required above, and must meet the ibllowing, requirementS:
The crympany must berated no TOSS than "A-" as to management, and no less than "Class
V" aS to Firianeial Strength, by the, latest edition of Best's Insurance Guide, published
by A.M., Best Company, Oldwick, New Jersey, or its equivalent. All policies rind /or
certificates of insurance are subject 'to review and verification by INisk Management prior
to insurance approval.
Certificates will indicate no modi,rrea non or change in insurance shall he made without thirty (30)
days written advance notice to the cortificaie holder. The Bidder shall be responsiblefor assuring
that the insurance certificates required in conjunction with thi Section remain in force for the
durationofthe contractual period; includins. any and all option tortm that rnay he granted to the
Bidder.
In the event that expired certificates are not replaced witin new or renewed certificates which cover
the contractual period, the City shall have the option lo; (1) Suspend the contract until such time. as
the new or renewed certificates are received by Go City in the 1114171elf prescribed in the Request for
Appraisals Quote; or (2) Tile City may., at its sols discretion, terminate this contract for canoe and
seek 're -procurement damages from the Bidder in conjunction with the euen1 and Special Terms
arid ConditiOill; of the Bid.
The insurance coverage required shall 'includethose classifications, as listed in xtandard liability
insurance manuals, which most nearly reflect the operationS of the bidder, Compliance with the
foregoing requirements shall not relieve the bidder of his liability and obligation under this seetion
or under imy other section of this Agreement.
Page 5 of 5
Form SCNLGL —'VVinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
ADDENDA - Page 6
Vain File No, 1851731 Pace #151
y Search. Application - Miami -Dade County
Summary Report
Prope ty krtfor nation
I- !if
0 t-4110-M4-0172
Prcaper1y Address:
1197 S` 15 y'.VF_
FEDERAL NATIONAL 3UtORTl3AGE
Owoor
ASSN
C,fC E1NAtdClAt,
FP,F:GDOM
Nla;ling Address—....._....._.._..____...V....._
2900 E''SPEF/A/JZA
CROSSING
_m
AUSTIN , TX 75709
Primary Zone
01C10 StMOLE
FAMILY - GENERAL
0091 VACANT
RESIDENTIAL
F�rirnary Land Use
VACANT LAND
Oeds/Baths! Half
0/0/0
rleorx
0
.Living Units
0
A Area
0 Sy,F1
Living Area
0 Sq.Ft �..�.._._..._.
AdJustTt 1 Area
0 S9.F1
Lot Size
6,726 Sq.Ft
Yoar Built
0
Assessment Information
Year �.. 2015
2014
2L13
Land Valua $ 41,23r�
__._._.$05800
$56,365
Bulldiny Value 60
$0
$0
XF Value 50
rv0
$0
Market Value $141,23a
$4.'S,Bt)0
$55,585
Assessed Value 55:9,544
357.62E
$ri3,38S
!Won on
hlar
Cap
/401e: Not all it are applicable to all Taxle Values (i.e. County,
vahaalF3aar ,City, Reglanal).
art L.tlgal Et yscriptlon
G5441
SOUTH SFIENANDOAH P6 11-64
LO'r12.BLK2
LOT SIZE 57.000 X 118
Generated On 8/16121315
T5xab/e Value Information
20151 2014 2013
County
Exc, nptlon Value
50
$01 S0
Taxable Valua
$63,389
$57,6261 S52,3S8
tithooi B and
Exernp1Vn Value
$0
$Ti
60
Taxable Value
$i41,2$6
$95,000
City
Exemption 4`elue
Sfl
.50
00
2001,6de Vu/uo
Regional
5'uenlrrti=.,err Vahse
$63 38£
90
$57,826
652.;F68
50
00
i 7tatale Value 562,3f36
$57,6220
tes Information
OR Pdoo
Page
Oue.lff/calian L"+oocriptier
r,r.t ru cortf•E/r 1iv xell , 0 and updating tess lox [ua, 7hiweb., TSr, PropeC/ Appro/orr
and Ka. C•:rnty 000ur tc .uelrtksElity, <1t,P.rils4edmer and 1150E Ag1een(ant 0/ etteikeere.rnlairr1ttd)
Vorolun,
lutp:!/w' w.u'Iola.idade-eov°/propert<'search/
8/18/201
Farm SCNLGL--'WinTOTAL" appraisal soflware by a la mode, inc.—1-800-ALAMODE
Main File No.18517
ADDENDA - Page 7
Propetz Seal oh Application - Miami -Dade Coun1y
a 0
r
Property Information
Foil o: 01-4110-05.4.0172
Proporty Address: 1197 SlAt 19 AVE
Page 3 of 5
Generated On 8/1F/2015
Roll Year 2014 Land, Building and Extra -Feature Details
and Infarntion
Laud Use Mord Zone
GENERAL T3 R
Building Information
PA Zone Unit "Typo dolts
0107 Front Ft 57 00
Ca lc Value
51.11236
Building Number
Sub Aroo
Year Bielt
Actual So F1.1 Living 5q,Ft,
Adj Sq.Ft.
Cale Value
Extra Features
Description
Year DJ%
Units Caio Value
The Office of the Property Appraser is oartMuar, y edtrg and updailop the tax tois wobsito may roPect the most curreM inforrno5on rc,00rd. The Property Apordispr
0:11d MiarTii-Dade County aseMMIS no fiat:8,4, see fail disolairner and nn 0htivfiwArw.rniamidade..gov/hfaidiscl:aimer,esp
Version:
http://www.rnia midade .gov/propertysearc hi 8/1 f,V.-2 1. 5
Form SC,NLOL — lWinTOTAM appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
MijriF/eNc.185175LEje #1a1
ADDENDA - Page 8
Prope:rty Search Application - Miarni-Dade Couray
Property Information
FoJo 01-411D-C64-0172
Property Address: 1197 SW 15 AVE'
Full Legal Ooscrlptio0
Page 5 of 5
Generated Os B11E112015
10 54 41
SOUTH SHENANDOAH PEI 11-64
LOT 12 BLK 2
LOT SIZE 57,000 X 116
$a es Information
Previuus Sale
Price
taR tdchrthdrrathe
2g662-259
Qualification Dethrrriptiurt
Financrat inst or In Lieu ris Forclosure" staled
The Wks of the Propurty Apprdishar 81dartrinusily editing and updating the ti:.KK roll This websits run not rsitsct Set tuout cut itlformatee or, record Pnoporly Appraiser
Ind Miami -Dade County sssurees nu tiatihty, u=e fur disdaireter and Ow Agreement at Wig:Wm, mist-11080u ordirtiorSisd.talmer asp
VBrsium
hap:// \:‘,,,t,w:Iniamiciade.gov/prop rse
8/18/2015
Form SCNLGL — 'WinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. 1-800-ALAMODE
[Main File No, 1851731 Paw t/-191
ADDENDA - Page 9
2014 roll details - Real Estate AcQount al 1197 SW 19 AVE, Miami, FL 33 I25-51.49 -Ta.. Pagel of 2
mia
Tax Collector Home Search
Reports Shopping Cart
Please do not include any 4440044cheraolers in the name, address, and e4r1aH field such as #, hyphens, comma,
clashes
'We have moved, Our new address is,
289 NW Znd Ave, Miami, FL 33128
The information contained herein does not consMute a title aaareh or property ownership,
201.5 2nd Ouartor Tar, Ms arePnrynble nn September 1, 2015.
RALSCAPOMOBrift. 1,4141tP.AAMPISSZOA„
Real Estate Account #01-4110-064-0172
F
Parcel details Latost, bill tt L'All
2014 2013 2012 2011
PAID PAM PAID PAID•
Owner, FEDERAL NATIONAL
MORTGAGE ASSN
2900 ESPERANZA, CROSSING
AUSTiN, TX 78708
and 1 other
&Ws, 1197 SW i 9 AVE
Miami, EL 331005140
Account number:
Millage code,
Pillage rata,,
Assessed value:
School lassethseci
2014 annual 611
Ad valorem:
Non -ad v6icreri:
Total Discountable:
No Discount NAVA,
Total tax:
01-4110-064-0172
0100- MIAMI
22 67E60
57426
95,800
-7 corrected
r view Losa] destriplion
$l 611 28
$0 00
161128
0,00
AktkItoslAn
Other owners, C/0 Fl
10 54
0M,
7.
y'r ,
IAL FREEDOM
Location
1
2003
PAM
hitp.s....//www.miaraidade,eautity-ttlxes,ccurl/publiciroal cs0a1e/pa0ecls.4141.1006401/72
Property Appraiser
Range' 41 C,
Township: 545
Section: 10
Block: 72
Use code: 0081
Total acres: 0,000
8/18/2015
Form SCNLGL — tWinTOTAL1 appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
ADDENDA - Page 10
IMain File No.1851731 Page #201
Corrected
Paid By Fl ii.IANCIAL FREEDOM,
County, Floridii
Notice of Ad Valore
EVERSE
paid 06/1E/2015
ago
XitAhate publuser CB/18/2015
iTAXE4t.E-15-000900 $1,803,63
Tax and Non -Ad Valorem Assessments
DE FOR MPORTANT INFORMATION
F0t, 0 00M8E0 5 I 1540N1t1P4t,ity tot)t
as
-4110-OG4-0172
0100
FEDERAL. NATIONAIx MORTGAGE ASSN
2/07 ESPEW,NIZA CROSSING
AUSTIN, TX 78708
5r44.-444410a,,, [X4r7114410P4:
1197 SW 1.9 AVE
gragesouggigospoP"":05#
Oar Dadh 55047o1 Board
Schoul Board Operating
Sohoul Board Debt Service
Und °into
Florida Inland Navigation Dial
South Florida Water Mgmt Dist
Cikeechobee Basin
Everglades Construchon Proi
Childrens iiruxi. Authority
Miami -Dade Countyi,
County Aide Opeiating,
County Wido Debt Seiviiiik,
Library Diatrint
74,1,85
19.06
9.09
9.8,3
3.1C
28 81
298.93
2E93
17,37
'ILPREIO:TAXEs,',5'5'!,,hIlIN
Combined Taxosi and Assasstriont$
S.t,611,28
111110.01"01MlfiPtliOlt)1111111!
•
Tax Due 1911.28
Auution Fee. 15.00
Advar.itisumerit Fee 5.00
Tax Cali., Comm, 84,19
LAill.nquenny tratanat, 72,51
Cert. REaemplioil Fun 925
Curt. Interest 8940
cemiiihata hunted; 'Jane 1,
2015
Face 1.787.98 Curt 44495 if Roceived By
Rate, 0.25% Bidder #27 Please Pay
.3ave Time, Pay Oniine. www.rniamith. de,gmi 4 RETAIN FOR YOUR RECO 1D S t
2014 Delinquent Tax
Certificate Redemption
01-4110-064-0172
FON() 99MBlifi
1197 SW 1.9 AVE
PROPERTY ADD FeES5
1,:q;441
00in9 S NAHLYJAH PLI, .515
LO7 512( 2
LC Sir 57 WA)
Jun an, 2715
$1,F99:163
is. DETACH HERE AND RETVRN THIS PORTION ViEtTii YOUR PAYMENT 4 Duplicate public tisei 08/18.'2015
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSN
2900 ESPERANZA CROSSING
AUSTIN, TX '93708
1 q 1 4
' T
. i ', , 1
'.,
khdise checks p- yahle Lau MiamF,Ditio Tax Collector
U,C,FondS dos n on 115, hank0
Deknouera Tatea mat oe paLl by Candies's Eheok, Money
C rdor or Cerkked Funds,
Arnaud duo May ha Subject to Chan9n Wthodt Notes,
Mak poymesdo los
250 N,V) End AV611114, Wand, 51 33128
Ed/4/ate issued... June 8, 2010
Face: 1,707,98 Rate: 0,254/
Cert #4495 Bidder #27
111i.:appivea:ByRieaaatay
.§11:4.g,:i:§, 3
19000 00 00[3000 0000 3014 11,0064017220 14 0 000GO 000 OD000 000 000005
Form SCNLGL— VinTOTALi appraisal software by a la mode, inc,. —1-800-ALAMODE
IMain File No. 1851731 Paoe #2I1
ADDENDA - Page 11
I 1c7 Redeemed certificate #4455 Face 91,707 98
Rate 0 25%
Bill Li story - Real Estate Account at 1197 SW 19 AVE, Miami, FL 33135-5149 TooSys Page 1 42
Tax Collector Home Search Reports Shopping Cart
Please do not Preclude any speci5lcharacters in the name, address, and e-mall field such as #, 5, hyphens, cambia,
dashes..
We have moved. Our new addrsss Is;
290 NW 2nd Ave, Miami, FL 33128
The information contained herein does not constitute a title search or property ownefship.
•2015 2nd Quarter Tax Bilis are Payable on Septembe71, 2015.
Eil Hist Ps Estate Act okett At 1191 SW1 AVE, 14OTI FL 3:035-5149
Real Estate (Account #01-4110-064-0172 IV!' Parcel deta.(1.5 Latest bill Full bit history
Amsbints as c// o4'/4/20/5
Bill BAltance
2514 Annual Bill $0.00 06/15/2015 Paid $1,883.63 Receipt PTAXSALE-15-000900
D6115/2015 Cerfificats redeemed
D6/0112015 Certikate issued
0510712015 Advertisement file crested
LI 2013 Annual 13111 $0 00 05/10)2014 Paid $1,27,5,12 R,asaipt #FPPU05-14-011,017
2012 Annual Bill S0,00 D5/29/2013 Paid $3,897.22 Receipt N20130529-5002-0000247
2011 Annual Bilt 50,00 05/25120'12 Paid 174,141,40 Receipt 420120525-6016-0090001
17, 2016 Annual 50,00 07,10613011 Paid $2,915,30 Receipt 420110705,6002-0000104
Eff6utiv0 G6/3012011
Redeemed certificate #8614 Face 52,770,55 07/00/2011 Certticato redeemed
Rate 0,29% 06/01/2011 Certificate, issued
04101/2011 Advertisement file created
2009 Anneal Bill 50,00 06121/2010 Pahl S2,589,36 Receipt 420100021-5002-0000257
Redeemed certificate #0408 Face $2,555724 06/21/2010 Cer0fiCate redeemed
Rate 0,2515 06/01/2010 Certificate issued
04,61/2010 AdverbSemeot.file crested
2009 Annual BIll 00,00 05/31/2009 Paid 92,644.01 Receipt 420090031-6011,41000104
Redeemed certificate 49591 Face 52,512%4 08/3112009 Certificala nadeemed
Rato 0,25%
96/01/2009 Cetfioete1050ed
04/01/2009 Advertisement file created
2007 Annual Bill 00,00 0.513012000 Paid 52,056.29 Receipt 420080530-0606-0000075
2006 Annual Hill 50,00 09/3 ":/2007 Paid $2,761,21 Recelpt #20970531-0225-0090095
2005 Annual Bill $0Oa 05119/2006 Paid 0.111,05 Receipt #200606•19-60000000185
Redeemed certificate *6050 Face 52,956,95 06119/2006 Certificate redeemed
Rate 0.2515 06M1/2006 Ce,fificate issued
04/01/2006 Advertisement !de created
Total Dalai ICE,
https://www.iniarnidadc ,coan (y-ta xes.comipubli 0/real eslatelparcels/01 -41 10-064-0172/bills 8/18/201.5
Form SCNLGL — VinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
rMain File No, 1851731 Page #221
ADDENDA - Page 12
Real ties t eon] - Report Page 1 of 1
Property Detail Report
For Property Located At
1197 SW 19TH AVE, MIAMI, FL 33135-5149
Owner Information
1 OW,C, No FEDERAL NAIL YTS' ASSN
Mtitis Address: 1197 SM; 12TH AVE, MIAMI FL 33135-8149 0002
Veoeila Codes, IIAS
Location Infonnetion
1 Lrga urerrior,,, 10 54 41 SOUTH SHENANDOAH PR 11-.64 LOT 12 ELK 2 LOT SIZE 57.000 X 115
, Gerbily: DACIE, FL APRs 01-4110-084-0172
, (loos Traor I Block, 54 0214 Adui Rote AIRS, 01-41-10-064-0172
Town bhp -Range -Seat, 54-41-10 Subeiviand: SOUTH SHENANDOAH
1 ',opal /Ptl..ge.:. 11-04 Map Feriae:ern, 245 ; 34A
, Legal Lot, 12 limn ta:
Leal Stook, 2 Sobroit Diatribt,
I Mardiet Area: 41 Iterhool Distripl Name,
Nelgiilsor Cede, 1,triter/ owrietilF: MIAMI
1 Owner Transfer IfformetIon
Recerain0/S0lie Da/ere 06113;2015 i 05/22;2015 Deed Type,
''.,..110. Noe, 6150,600 101 Alta Despenent ft,
Duriddrient rt, 1191a52-859 I
Last Market Sale information
RocontlidgSalp Daro, 1 lst Miro saniouiteTyPe:
Sete Rine, 1st Nap Int Rata/Type,
, &Nu latter !tor Mfg Dainebent 4,
i Document ;I: 1/Id Mto Amount/lobo,
! Deed Rion 2r12 Mfg int. Rare/Types
Tboardier Docionint fr, Pape Per :KIEL
New Fairstruotien: Multi/Split Sole,
, Title Company,
, Lapeer,
Seiler Nome
Prior Sale Information
Prior ReulSriie Date: Fri -or Lander:
Prier Son ['dos: Prior 10t Mto Anul Pow i
Prier Doe Nomber Pilo, 1st tate Rote/Type, 1
Prier Deed Type:
Property Characteristics
• Soar Built I FR ; 8114/ Rooms/Offices Garage Area,
, Gress, Arne, imp] liestropritei Ramp Capacity,
Budding Area, Roof Type, Perking tippose:
Tot. Aej Ai UM. Raat Matador: Heat Type,
Above Grade, Cionotteclion: Air Curet,
ta or Stories, Fredric atior, Pool,
• Other tropinveitterew Ea1111a01 wall: Quatitto
Hesiereent Arad: Condition,
trt
,yo CoreLrag
1 I Q. e st Prole ssional
1t9 6i1F For Sole
Site Information
Fortinft, R-1 Acres: 0,15 County Ilea,
Lot Area' 6,726 Lot ;Abed ;Depth, $7 a 118 Stole Use,
Lona Urn' VACALLF LAND (NEC) CiDr071,,,,id Uerto, dedler Ttipe,
Site influence! Sewer 'eyrie: Bestir p C"aaa:
Tax information
10131 Vatuit, $99,600 A depound Year 2014 Pf opcoty !Tsai
Lane Vetoer, $113,800 Improved Ws., Fos:Arabi
11111aMene1111\10111e: Tax Year. 2014 Tax Experrati DIY
r111a1 I axablu Va up: 695,300
CERTI ri CATE OF TITLE (FL)
VACANT UNDEV (51)
REFERENCE ONLY (MK
$1,611,28
0100
http ://proelassief ea 1 quest coln/jsp/report jsp'?&client—&aotion=eonfinn&ty,., 8/1 8/2015
Form SCNLGL — "WinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE
ADDENDA - Page 13
Hain File No, 1851731 Paue #231
QUALIFICATIONS OF EFRAIN JORGE SA.NTIN
State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser
No. 0003274
EDUCATION
Florida International University, Miami, Florida
B,A. Degree-Finance-1997
PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION
Florida International University
Course: FIN 4343-Real Estate Analysis-1996
Gold Coast -Florida
Real Esoie Appraiser-2002
AMU Mastering Real Estate Appraisal-2007
Appraisal Institute
API 310-Basic income Approach-2003
API 510-Advanec income Approach-2003
API 520-1-ighest & Best Use Market Analysis-2003
USPAP LIpdated-2008
Supervisor Trainee Roles and Rules-2008
LICENSES
State Certified General Real Estate Appraiser-RZ #0003274
Licensed Real Estate Sales Person SL #703744
EXPERIENCE
Assistant Residential/Commercial Fee Appraiser-2002
TYPES OF PROPERTIES APPRAISED
Single Family Residential 2-4 Family Dwellings
Vacant Land Individual Condominiums
Office Building
GEOGRAPHICAL AREAS .SERVED
Miami -Dade Broward - St. Lucie
Form SCNLGL — MinTOTAL" appraisal software by a la mode, inc. —1-800-ALAMODE
'Main File IVo. 8517 Pa c 24
ADDENDA - Page 14
Form SCNLGL 'YtfinTOTAL appraisal software by a la mode, inc, — 1-800-ALAMODE
IMain File No, 18517311aue #251
ADDENDA - Page 15
ANN AM ARIA C,HAVOUSTIE MAI
State -Certified General Real Estute Appraiser
CA:NMI-M(41n NI).323
annailthappylsisalfiraLnet
E:HOC/ATM N
B.S,, Florida International University - 1980
Society or Real Estate Appraisers;
Course 10 ntroduetion to Appraising
Course 102 - Appraisal Case Study
Course 2(11 - income Properly Valuation
American Institute uf Raul Estate. Appraisers:
1987 Cuomo 2-3 - Standardof. Professional Practice
1988 Course 1B-A • Capitalization Theory ifir. Techniques - A
1988 Course IBLI • Capitalization Theory & Techniques -11
1989 Course 2-1 - Case Studies
1989 Course 2-2 - Report Writing
Appraisal Institute;
1993 Litigation Valuation
1994 Limited Appraisal
1995 Florida currimrrcial Conutrucition Seminar] 996 Luxury Waterliran 74 ttkct
99S NOTI Conforming Meet
1999 Appraising Apartments
2001 Cass Stadics Iliiihost and Best liS6
2002 Analyzing Lease Clauses
2007 Commercial Construction
201/9 Appraising Narsing Homes
2010 Hotel Appraising-
2011 Business Practices and Fthica
2011 Appraisal Curricidum
2012 USPAP
21113 Marketability Studies
20 [3 Residential Sales Comparison and Income Approach
7013 Appraising Cell "lowers
EXPERIENCE
1977-1980 Learning Disability Teacher -Center for Learning
1980-1982 .Arrner 13. White, Inc., - Commercial RNA 111ato Sales
1982-I996 Florida East Coast Realty - Vice Fresident,Commercial Real Estate Broker
1996 AmeriFirst Appraisal Company Commercial Appraiser
1987-I9S9 AppraisalEirst, Inc., (formerly AmeriFirst Appraisal Company) - Commercial Appraiser
1909- 20I() A pprakialFirst, Luc, , South Florida Regional Commercial Appraisal Manager
201 I Appraisalliirst Real Estate Appraisers LI C, President
GEOGRAPHICAL AREAS SERVED
Dade, Brossard, Brevard, Mouroe, Indian River, Si Lucie, Osceola, Orange, Okeechobee, and Palm Beach
Counties, Florida,
CLIENT'S SERVED
Various employer clients including; banks; savings mid loans; thc Archdiocese of Miami; FDIC; RTC; Lennur
Commercial Properties; Brigham Moore Gaylord, et al; foreign investment E.roups and individua le. Bankruptcy and cavil
courts,
TYPES OF PROPERTIES APPRAISED
Commercial, malti-farnily, industrial facilities, office, buildings, botelS, A CIE's., vacant land, acreage, day-tiure
centers, proposed subdivisions, condominiums, service stations, fast food franeldses and development projecis,
AFFILIATIONS
Member of the Appraisal Institute, MAI
Licensed Real Estate Broker State of Florida
Member Miami Board of Realtors; Indian River 9) oord of Realtors; Melbourne Rea liters Associal ion
39
Form SCNLGL — VinTOTAr appraisal software by a la mode, Inc, -800-ALAMODE
IF.grFHe
No. 185 7 Pa( e #26
ADDENDA - Page 16
R[ek< CO i .30VERNOR
Oattg00.4444404
KEN LAWSON, SFOREPaY
STATE OF FLORIDA
DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION
FLORIDA REAL ESTATE APPRAISAL ED
The CERTIFIED GENERAL APPRAISER
Named below IS CERTIFIED
Under the provisions of Chapter 476 FS.
Expiration date: NOV 30, 2016
CI lAVOUSTIE, ANNA MARIA
144,1 BISCAYNE BLVD SUITE 211
MIAMI EL 33132
ISSUED'. 09/16/2014
DISPLAY AS REQ
EB EIY LAW
sEralr 4O5lOO551557
Form SONLGL — 'WinTOTAL appraisal software by a la mode, inc. — 1-800-ALAMODE