The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutCertified Resolution R-13-0471City of Miami Certified Copy City Hall 3500 Pan American Drive Miami, FL 33133 www.miamigov.com File Number: 13-01030ii Enactment Number: R-13-0471 A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI CITY COMMISSION, WITH ATTACHMENT(S), DENYING THE APPEAL BY GRANT STERN, PETER EHRLICH, ROSI BARRIOS, SANDI MADGER, DAVID LE BATARD, YASMINE GARATE, AND ANTHONY DAVIDE, AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD, THEREBY APPROVING THE CLASS II SPECIAL PERMIT APPLICATION NO. 12-0054, ISSUED BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT ON AUGUST 12, 2013, TO ALLOW NEW CONSTRUCTION ON THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT APPROXIMATELY 3055 NORTH MIAMI AVENUE, MIAMI, FLORIDA. WHEREAS, the Miami Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board, at its meeting on October 2, 2013, following an advertised public hearing, adopted Resolution No. PZAB-R-13-049 by a vote of six to four (6-4), item no. 1, to DENY the Class II Special Permit Appeal; and WHEREAS, an appeal of the Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board decision was filed by Paul C. Savage, Esquire, on behalf of Grant Stern, Peter Ehrlich, Rosi Barrios, Sandi Madger, David Le Batard, Yasmine Garate, and Anthony Davide; and WHEREAS, the City Commission after careful consideration of this matter, finds the application for Class II Special Permit does meet the applicable requirements of Zoning Ordinance No. 11000 and deems it advisable and in the best interest of the general welfare of the City of Miami and its inhabitants to affirm the decision of the Zoning Board and the Planning and Zoning Director and deny the appeal of Class II Special Permit as hereinafter set forth; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA: Section 1. The recitals and findings contained in the Preamble to this Resolution are adopted by reference and incorporated as if fully set forth in this Section. Section 2. The decision of the Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board to deny the appeal of Class II Special Permit Application No. 12-0054, issued by the Planning and Zoning Director on August 12, 2013, to allow new construction on the property located at approximately 3055 North Miami Avenue, Miami, Florida, as legally described in attached "Exhibit A," is affirmed, and the Class II Special Permit is approved. Section 3. The findings of fact set forth below are made with respect to the subject property: a. The proposed project will be beneficial to the surrounding area by providing new retail and service facilities while creating jobs for the area b. The proposed project, as presented reflects revisions and refinements made based on comments from reviewing Departments and the Urban Development Review Board, and is appropriate in scale and size pursuant to Section 1305 and the Midtown Overlay District 6.27.2 City of Miami Page 1 of 2 R-13-0471 File Number: 13-01030ii Enactment Number: R-13-0471 Midtown Miami West. c. The proposed project is in compliance with the Miami Comprehensive Neighborhood Plan in that it promotes good urban infill and is consistent with the Buena Vista East Regional Activity Center (RAC), designation as applied to this property. d. This application has been reviewed pursuant to Section 1305 of Zoning Ordinance No. 11000 and the Miami 21 Code, Appendix C: Midtown Overlay District 6.27.2 Midtown Miami West and found to be sufficient. Section 4. This Resolution shall become effective immediately upon its adoption and signature of the Mayor. {1} Date: NOVEMBER 21, 2013 Mover: CHAIR SARNOFF Seconder: COMMISSIONER CAROLLO Vote: AYES: 3 - COMMISSIONER(S) GORT, SARNOFF AND CAROLLO ABSENT: 2 - COMMISSIONER(S) SUAREZ AND SPENCE-JONES Action: ADOPTED Date: Action: NOVEMBER 29, 2013 SIGNED BY THE MAYOR I, Todd B. Hannon, City Clerk of the City of Miami, Florida, and keeper of the records thereof, do hereby certify that this constitutes a true and correct copy of Resolution No. R-13-0471, with attachment, passed by the City Commission on 11/21/2013. y Clerk (for Todd 8. Hannon, City November 05, 2014 Date Certified {1} If the Mayor does not sign this Resolution, it shall become effective at the end of ten calendar days from the date it was passed and adopted. If the Mayor vetoes this Resolution, it shall become effective immediately upon override of the veto by the City Commission. City of Miami Page 2 of 2 R-13-0471 AuwA .ni.,+e.a.*i .w+wiAWW2%w$O4W e. .A.s OEM vhrtt R9P Air.irF��A. SN.UM1+wW9pRua.M.0 "pl SNJ'I.#i d h:?i Miat:3'fiix Sif:±,Po«b!£'•+w. rsM .npp nDOt..h+S �,.Ar.q 4:A.MOms.Cr Y.,in-t-X Nex. •1 RwAW R. m.e-e..eJRn.bctA Ad{.. ti. '{4.a"etu,..+.mrt6?..= AM.K.05 q+!s NTLa�Hf v m,&ty+siF citu,s eL+.»K.'uyAiYa4nRyayn32. MO*. WRAM. UM, reMIAMMRwa.f•. M.9w.944.W.MAMA+..M ai+.RNR4001I{Nl R.6.110 MIMMI SIIgIMAMI.M RRr ffR1Wf11....1 ./.M. Awn nw.. W{ aa.e.wrI,tM.awta�.nwY. .a..R t.Y OV NSINOWNAMnM CPO. 201011.40,* am.wAA.MMOw1HRR! MBA W.V. nlnbnA. »Ft°bt"uA'MA YMRaffammtS OMMIR,OM YSn tlae+..ASA Wet tl@P .,,.G- lm moto4c*n+. nfl+loiftM.MFw Mt.} 1.14451O1.9.010201...4 A.A <SVR,.+n,CSOIL wm.wmc ..aeA.c, rusl m.w.er'Ynscis1.eV R•. MOO KO. a RIALOOirC.fA ell I..MC,. rw.A . 1s w.w.mow. MNM.0144... flea~. Y. R.nf44.Pa.... AIHS Mli�fRAf maw. Off ew.a. .«,cn.. w»10,11. ,aff .aa apmnm. Y�rnms`�ta RGe4paRw wm,Aa Aca.*vas wAa. w9 s.,.t ep,,.sx....oTv..T;M s Ontffi °vmw '<'"$wc., Oa., uea.04 LOO,u..>awlcmw.r%OW 1+w Trx,. na w:Ae n aA =at, .. ...m>w.e,..,i.ffi,+rn x,. a an a7 v sw+ r.•. 6ANI,b..a.rA AU AMIu W.01, OM.. ~MINIM W. 0111.1.4"..l MOO ova' rea/ o:MOOn.•nceep., OSSOO.an,;u+ssroa.x...s:w.e: m 8%2+AM % t K rox wn..,.,..l N...;..T MAYA RMTIM.M.M.M8 rtoriOTS O Oct VO:w»r scnwiA, Maw..;rr+ep..ax.n.r.Al•.Rww1v.N Mel. W V eW nog fratawstom Afw. Tot T AMTANA RWASoraRwf R LAI,INiNM IR.'.ARC MOWN TmlearTerg RAT WW2.EAan..waMAatl CS•seiw WA RA. tAMAPTIATAVIRAntAIT MM1a HMHRmom. ha, llA 4.1t MA9lae.A.x Y+AY Hv A'A.:MA.w RRwfM BM • P.+MAremaa WSm6[aaA(AAiAtatAf.. A.S1Aixt..A .i. .CLM B/,+?a Mzpl. Fain.iaKA MIK1. arri.... R&Atn a.+mvee.»v A.yeu.g.'.w.t 3&wwaA*in aA..i..aRa.a.0 M.FYLARH.w. Y.aA 4%.”Satl'••fi #,T�[. Mf6YYtS .. w;.n L.fl.�ArN'. YFEpY@t aba.A 9RM.p N...II1..! • ,.kr.,w,.A<.,a-a.,. ASV allitsier6a it�.s xrOOO « ...1%.%.1 wt.A...raHiLln' e.' ^. a...,:aR.»,AM.p. _,,.n,nArs1:H...e1 a.0, a rw arar.R.. w.rc %% nccoamkepAAT .aart faliMt.IsTnWi..a... wAro*waMA.Mma...wwMA:rw,..........wAs al...IMM AT... � °a'• rim. �AA/ tAllo . Aes,AAL.,a+,tens min tnaec+.aarR.ew. » 19 MeMMIMMIng. ...:wW.a�x.,M«.RTM.w.A,;,a.p.:.w•� o-v+w-u.:axa,e. .wR.e..A».eM.cn WWIwn pomae uaeR.wwae.r0 wea+e18 w: *VOLO. ,raw:f a.rR..OMO %.11 ar .tum-:»w ar r.: ,eatYtW[A.R. <aM..'tRs79itSPN'='1t A.V.1.15.0.FAIML MahG�t. MffaMIes.- R1K•M'.,...* 040,Ayww. AANI n WO.41 .s. 1% f t N. ga..[wA MILT Ye OMICARMOMP WIibC ?l: .EMtiSYds+-1.0.1 AM.% MtnefefrL +'rtFi's��'-M u/'ARil3.uY+M Vsl6 V74,19fLexe56i1ffi mom • MiwR�ArIRyt nM". 110. 1M6.1 en1PR W.®KlY,xi.MfS mow. M1MW 9MORMiRIR! Imre te9.11110.wq{01113.1W elkOerO.p. :6A.MAs . w6ISA+'{m11.e111ttr NArne/AAoN s4FTmVnb AAAss0rOlY. 3. LWOW NOWWWW. .. Yfl6M�slMpd.OM !F+RRroffbMMIYeNORf. • Mt.., enr.Mdii al4 fJ Mfa.m.. mom, to WAmnM1MMp vAii. NFW.TA.AVR ssFs9f6 V sMM1arcw6V WSCY ..CA.VMTs.m..(pw.t iaRR.lxncaN,SR11•exatYO AmsrM "'ew..M w fATM*f. nrtota n 0f4mifi A.nA9A�SMa0M 9R23' r# tiv5.`t MIMM fl aMMII wW.M.r ....1.MMCMIMO MIA.:1 oaA.w spw.. p:,mnnnxw..errwn.....mle..n ZWW SURVEYOR'S NOTES •. >rv,o.x.n.. • STA., SIAVA..ACt..M Ree sc-Homo,. Alma Ail IAR.RTNM ANOT ITIMINA CwR1WApI.Y11ALm1Q�� • leA merNPtY.2t.IM Am WAL.wlMM.I NYAaw.07.: AWww .MWM,x..weMMON SADMAwaswRaJ ��I A�AO W, E 4AVAIS A.pTRRYA�lR.t 2*$e1r.WM,ewSE$a1RR4.!ASJTS ,aDATUM i1➢ECANRtlNFB11.4C.0. T8lMMJ 2i i eYpY, A0.R4A`wlYa..k.@A l aRs. 7R 1111.1 OfeNR 0.111MR6M4 i0@MwBNf N'S N. TTAN i+. RSA MseA,S iwl.... AsTS . ,VMM.M.IreLM M.fl wA; �liMA1R1Y PMIMN rtsrAMJM. ale wa.w«a WXm MewP9pMRMi .11.001611.061.0 MOM Axtraakot, MCC MIMMIMbogmmmImMINIAMIM ofsaVesefoTATATALMARATal 'Yam Toms. moo. re pole +A +w4. uTANIe AA Al.anue *..wa+at+x5ay. s+.v+c�r.+a- OM RwaaR, MON .AR....,.<,altoo ewa. tA,IM IAMRMAiAw.MRMMMaffiAgi Aroay.flWM tlnwr*, uregiViielw121004motam ma* re mem .IYkiGA• ono* 011•01CON 'q.NIaYA moo, 4'IR.a.Ae . 9.sGA 45,41 LEGEND OF S Y VIROLS 1904. AE9RF V I ATIONS SHEE INDER SAJACAS OAS SIATTATTOR'S TAMES TANS l l 04EAFY SURVEY Aies1 i CACKSIAPHIC WAVES. MX TAU SIARVEY LSAT ,TTILITY LOCATIONS "Exhibit A" ..e, Rad'Y 6000 City of Miami Master Report Enactment Number: R-13-0471 City Hall 3500 Pan American Drive Miami, FL 33133 www.miamigov.com File Number: 13-01030ii Version: 3 File Type: Resolution Status: Passed Reference: Controlling Body: Office of the City Clerk File Name: Class II Appeal - 3055 N MiaAv Introduced: 8/27/2013 Requester: Cost: Final Action: 11/21/2013 Title: A RESOLUTION OF THE MIAMI CITY COMMISSION, WITH ATTACHMENT(S), DENYING THE APPEAL BY GRANT STERN, PETER EHRLICH, ROSI BARRIOS, SANDI MADGER, DAVID LE BATARD, YASMINE GARATE, AND ANTHONY DAVIDE, AFFIRMING THE DECISION OF THE PLANNING, ZONING AND APPEALS BOARD, THEREBY APPROVING THE CLASS II SPECIAL PERMIT APPLICATION NO. 12-0054, ISSUED BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT ON AUGUST 12, 2013, TO ALLOW NEW CONSTRUCTION ON THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT APPROXIMATELY 3055 NORTH MIAMI AVENUE, MIAMI, FLORIDA. Sponsors: Notes: Indexes: Attachments: 13-01030ii PZAB 10-02-13 Supporting Docs.pdf,13-01030ii CC 11-21-13 Fact Sheet.pdf,13-01030ii Maps & PZAB Reso.pdf,13-01030ii Appeal by Appellant for Commission.pdf,13-01030ii Appeal by Appellant for PZAB.pdf,13-01030ii Class II Approved by the P&Z Dept.pdf,13-01030ii CC Legislation (Version 3).pdf,13-01030ii CC Legislation (Version 4).pdf,13-01030ii Exhibit A.pdf,13-01030ii-Submittal-Presentation-Background and Introduction.pdf,13-01030ii-Submittal-Presentation-Wal-Mart Projection in Midtown.pdf,13 -01030 ii-Submittal-North Miami Elevation.pdf,13-01030ii-Submittal-Paul C. Savage-PowerPoint Presentation -Appeal of Class II Special Permit.pdf,13-01030ii-Submittal-Mark Alvarez Presentation -Midtown Walmart Class II Special Permit.pdf,13-01030ii-Submittal-Peter Ehrlich.pdf,13-01030ii-Submittal-Emails-Midtown Wahnart.pdf, History of Legislative File Version: Acting Body: Date: Action: Sent To: Due Date: Return Date: Result: 3 3 Planning, Zoning and Appeals Board City Commission Office of the Mayor 10/2/2013 DENIED BY PZAB, 11/21/2013 ADOPTED 11/29/2013 Signed by the Mayor Office of the City Clerk 3 Office of the City 12/2/2013 Attorney 3 Office of the City Clerk 12/2/2013 Reviewed and Approved Signed and Attested by City Clerk Pass Pass City of Miami Page 1 Printed on 11/5/2014