HomeMy WebLinkAboutSummary Evaluation FormRFP No. 391314
SUMMARY EVALUATION FORM FOR PROPOSAL
EMPLOYEE VOLUNTARY LOAN PROGRAM
PROPOSERS
BMG Money, Inc.
EVALUATORS
Jose Fernandez
Vladimir Murad
Andrew Warburton
Overall
Qualifications
and
Experience
25
30
28
Approach and
Methodology
25
25
25
Financial
Proposal
20
22
28
Local
Preference,
if applicable
5
5
5
COMPOSITE SCORE FOR PROPOSAL:
TOTAL
SCORE
81
Evaluator:
Signature:
RFP No. 391314
EMPLOYEE VOLUNTARY LOAN PROGRAM
Evaluation C_ ommittee Meeting
Technical Pr osal Evaluation Form
1�/ctali�rr' ✓er.,4-
PROPOSERS
BMG Money
tt�t
Overall
Qualifications
and
Experience
Approach and
Methodology
Financial
Proposal
Local
Preference, if
applicable
TOTAL SCORE
FOR
TECHNICAL
RANK
RFP Evaluation Criteria Scoring Matrix: Scoring of evaluation criteria to be completed in accordance with the rating scale
immediately below:
15 Points Max
Scoring Criteria
20 Points Max
Scoring Criteria
g
Adjective
Description
Score
Score
Outstanding
Proposal meets requirements and indicates an outstanding approach and understanding of
the requirements.
13.5-15
18-20
Good
Proposal meets requirements and indicates a good approach and understanding of the
requirements.
12-13
16-17.5
Adequate
Proposal meets requirements and indicates an adequate approach and understanding of the
requirements.
10.5-11.5
14-15.5
Unacceptable
Proposal does not meet requirements and is unacceptable.
0-10
0-13.5
PROPOSERS
BMG Money
RFP No. 391314
EMPLOYEE VOLUNTARY LOAN PROGRAM
valuation Committee Meeting
T: hnical Proposal Evaluation Form
Evaluator: Date:
Signature:
Overall
Qualifications
and
Experience
Approach and
Methodology
Financial
Proposal
Local TOTAL SCORE
Preference, if FOR
applicable TECHNICAL
RFP Evaluation Criteria Scoring Matrix: Scoring of evaluation criteria to be completed in accordance with the rating scale
immediately below.
• rA ' '`o 1
r* ,rw k n4
,,,
,gag
, . a
15 Points Max
Scoring Criteria
20 Points Max
Scoring Criteria
Adjective
Description
Score
Score
Outstanding
Proposal meets requirements and indicates an outstanding approach and understanding of
the requirements.
13.5-15
18-20
Good
Proposal meets requirements and indicates a good approach and understanding of the
requirements.
12-13
16-17.5
Adequate
Proposal meets requirements and indicates an adequate approach and understanding of the
requirements.
10.5-11.5
14-15.5
Unacceptable
Proposal does not meet requirements and is unacceptable.
0-10
0-13.5
RFP No. 391314
EMPLOYEE VOLUNTARY LOAN PROGRAM
0
Evaluation Committee Meeting
, Technical Proposal EvaluationForm
Evaluator: ✓dv.��'�,L tJR b Llktai✓ Date:
Signature:
PROPOSERS
Overall
Qualifications
and
Experience
Approach and
Methodology
Financial
Proposal
Local
Preference, if
applicable
TOTAL SCORE
FOR
TECHNICAL
RANK
BMG Money
24
0
115,
RFP Evaluation Criteria Scoring Matrix: Scoring of evaluation criteria to be completed in accordance with the rating scale
immediately below.
dUa
15 Points Max
Scoring Criteria
Score
20 Points Max
Scoring Criteria
Score
Adjective
Description
Outstanding
Proposal meets requirements and indicates an outstanding approach and understanding of
the requirements.
13.5-15
18-20
Good
Proposal meets requirements and indicates a good approach and understanding of the
requirements.
12-13
16-17.5
Adequate
Proposal meets requirements and indicates an adequate approachand understanding of the
requirements.
10.5-11.5
14-15.5
Unacceptable
Proposal does not meet requirements and is unacceptable.
0-10
0-13.5