The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutRFP #295579 - Security Guard Srvcs. CitywideRFP No. 295279 SECURITY GUARD SERVICES CITYWIDE SUMMARY EVALUATION SHEET ,:r Evaluators: Numerical Ordinal PROPOSERS. Jose Gell: Numerical Jose Gell: Ordinal Karen Cartwright: Numerical Karen Cartwright: Ordinal Marcos Osorio: Numerical Marcos Osorio: Ordinal Jennifer Ramirez: Numerical Jennifer Ramirez: Ordinal Jose Rodriguez: Numerical Jose Rodriguez: Ordinal Total Numerical Points Numerical Rank Total Ordinal Points Ordinal Rank 4=��.ffy� �� p syCv��.�°."°a+n� .,. ,.,. _, .F r� d..;^ jl ¢ !�L ...d...9F t .4"�;�t:5�.. .:.,�s�...��f` ,, .h'+e.�$ L ,+ d�,."�,:a., M , it,`� s�. :4<,.. k�i1 ,. .�.,, .r`.W.t� k- . bf.�n :Y, Ry. . t �.. AS"„ .,x.+ti.�1s_lH ih.,a,.. w... w" }M �?"1.i'�.....i..._��,';a'4;-':C�V S": 4' N Yf��. F..k yN .6' l$�c41.% y,, 17,i�E'%.�Si <..,fz3....,, . � - -, v 7ik .+' , . fin°%.. a .._ ,y 4 �F�i�.+f +$. F.. r 1 w +-__r...._.... .. s. . 1�� M`}. "R ��% ..... ..,. �. .:�.. ATE � f " :+41`�� , �'1�. .,.�. .-.a... t T..,.. -.o .. m. :� 4\ H• ",... "' ..T ..�. ....: � G.�L Sf S.� � ,.... .. o... ... -... .,_ . _,.. _. __. _.... __ _ 50 State Security Service, Inc. ,...... .._....._ 71.16 .. _ .. _. .... 8 _„ �.,..� ..ra.imnx... 69.16 ..... 8 ...... � ,.,.." ...� 76.16 . ,- 8 ...___:_-" 73.16 8 ...c., 70.16 8 i LL ... 359.8 8 40 8 ABM Security Services, Inc. 77.16 6 78.16 5 78.16 6 78.16 3 79.16 4 I 390.8 5 24 5 Feick Security Corporation 75.83 7 75.83 6 82.83 2 74.83 6 76.83 5 386.15 6 p 26 6 Florida Patrol Investigators, Inc. 80.69 4 81.69 2 82.69 3 76.69 4 76.69 6 398.45 4 19 4 Kent Security Services, Inc 89.57 1 93.57 1 92.57 1 89.57 1 88.57 . 1 453.85 1 5 1 P.G. Security, Inc. 81.33 3 81.33 3 81.33 5 76.33 5 82.33 2 402.65 3 18 3 PM Security Service, Inc. 78.69 5 74.69 7 77.69 7 74.69 7 76.69 6 382.45 7 - 32 7 Security Alliance, LLC 81.42 2 79.42 4 81.42 4 81.42 2 80.42 3 404.1 2 15 2 RFP No. 295279 SUMMARY EVALUATION FORM FOR TECHNICAL AND PRICE PROPOSALS SECURITY GUARD SERVICES CITYWIDE PROPOSER PRICE PROPOSAL PRICE PROPOSAL POINTS TOTAL TECHNICAL PROPOSAL POINTS TOTAL ADJUSTED SCORE (TECHNICAL + PRICE PROPOSAL): RANKING: $x°`,.....u..�.. a.. ,..,. t.. r t `hY v..<.a,=a.''he.:»5'P` ii :t i f ..-..dY.^rK w5 .i 'Y.:.'` °.d vL�i`s' '.Y v-',`P., ;, `� ` :a�sal •i a .a.SA'T 54 ,.,.. ` ,''3c`^ia 'w.''.•„ . ct- agp::,?a'"„'.5R3,'S, Yl^W.d. a....sk:.;A ,.,'f ,. .....,.. K; ... e =>m ss.<:G;,,..,. . , as ,;:; , z.. ,,. au z»::.4, :.F.,1:3.:°an 44....-;:-. '2,,,_....fl.. : s vr.,.. :;, ...., _ 50 State Security Service, Inc. , ,,rc4,14^:, s . A. $785,459.00 e . x . , , ti , 24.33 47.63 71.96 8 23.24 4 54.92 78.16 5 ABM Security Services, Inc. $822,130.00 $801,975.00 23.83 53.40 77.23 6 Feick Security Corporation 19.02 60.67 79.69 4 Florida Patrol Investigators, Inc. (FPI Security Services) $1,004,527.50 ., � _, ,_ .,.w_., .. x <„,..„, k4„ a 4„, ,;,,_,,.a ,b _ s- „..n_—®...,,,,.,su _ ,., ,,, .,,,,,,, . ,>;.a.# _, -,,a, .,_ ,,,9... w-4>n;>=_., .., : X 4o:,_,.. ..,,, .,4 4W ..,_. A,,,, ,, ,,. Kent Security Services, Inc. $775,135.00 24.65 66.12 90.77 ..,x .1 n ..r w,.,x,_ S, _ ,.P ..3.lz :x. , ,.3.>.SF M.,.1, w.A`z,v.£. ..'.. . ..a .PA a..? .., >, ,,,,.vt : ..l-S`. .,.,, x _:, -»... . , ,.,,.. ..,.. c ,,..,.. .., e...+. . .. ._. .. . �..., f n.,?, a,."ewMf. -_ L.. d.e :.. P.G. Security, Inc. (Platinum Group Security) ,, ,,,:.n .. v ',N, . .:..,: .,, t.._,, _... a,_. , ,tip . ,_. $764,400.00 ,M._.,,, urn,,, �� ... ,,_F,s .__- 25.00 55.53 ..,,. .. 80.53 ... . .... .:......, s. 3 ,-, ,_.. ,,. .3W .._, ..,.4....,. 21.02 .. � ....._ . .�... � 55.47 _,. ,, .. __s, M... _, .. ,,...... 76.49 ,_.. _,�p. ..,y...,,ro 7 PM Security Service, Inc. $909,349.00 . .,, ;� ;; .. 23.25 ... ....:: .., ::: n> 57.57 .,. : n ...,,.;; ,,n .,.art..5 ,- J.,,,,,,,,,, ,..x.,. 80.82 4,4.M.k-<.. �, 2 u..v. 2 Security Alliance, LLC $821,980.00 RFP No. 295279 PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE SUMMARY SECURITY GUARD SERVICES CITYWIDE ...,,,,,..,--44., :.,-. : .. , -.t,„ ,-.- , , ,-,,,-,--e z, .... „-4.,... '. ,:','..,A,,,-',:...•:,:k:•,,,Jzl ,..:,,sv!,,m:;:,>zp.v.<t:,-ago,r:,fdow:qrmmrmr:t,A,...,s.:,.itt,..t,„...,-,,,,,,..:L—Ar,„, Amtg.n,..:,,,mtmmitl;.,,, ds-..,Azum-...-.: 7,..Zu .„AISSMIT:1072R,,,,$i-,==-..,4 PROPOSER PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE TOTAL POINTS TECHNICAL PROPOSAL PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE CRITERIA POINTS 'Iff,R.:in*F:':UV.Titafgtzliel'",:,,k*Adigg4WligMTri5ZVIO4,-5,.'5::17:,,,:AZ,2,.*.?;.I.a.Pk,;?Z .:=,.0"gAii4k,i0..ig,itlig,"$ Wa.gagt1,46.gili::*.iViC6V:i.Wri40.WifiWk.tkckatV4,4':,i445141kbaliliKaWEWAV,.W.g.VW.3:0AVOWW-4,74M410.01,WWW•WW,M,,i0., ,..4,,,,,,•,,,..,,..:,,,,Is.,w,,,,,,N,,,,;.:0i,,,;,....4,,,,,,,,,,,--r,...,,,-....;44‘,,,,,,,4„.7., :.:!-,a,,,-:,,R,i,n,p,::,,i,-.,:.:;,,,,,..,,,,,,,,,,:.,,,,,,,-.3.::,,,,,4;,,,,,,,:p.v.,,,w..t.,,,,,,,,,,:.,,,,,,‘,,,,,,,,,,,:p..y, Y,,,:.," L',,,.,,,,.: ',-V-4ci',;p;:i,MA.;i.,,IU:A,I,s:,sYiel',,,,,,xe.c,,,,t,..:,;v%:A.M,i,,,,i.:;qa.:,I,5.1s,,,,,,,,. -,,,,,,,,,,,,.:r., z....,-,,,,,,ro,,,,--,,r,m..f.,;,,.4.,::.,,,;.',.,-.=:,L-a....;,:......:,.,.,,,v.x,..,,,,,,t,,,,:--,4-,w;k.2„.:,,,,:r,,,,,,i,,:.-,oN,w..,:; 50 State Security Service, Inc. 118 9.83 ABM State Security Service, Inc. 155 12.92 ,,,,,,,,,, ,....,C," .,:a2., :,:,..,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,..i.,,,,,,,,,,,:,,,,,,,4.-i,::4,-,,,,,:lf,,,,,,; Feick Security Corporation 180 15.00 -.,z,,.,,-,.,..,,,,,,:v.,.,,,,,,,,,,„,-.„,..,,,,,-,-;:,,,,,,,,,,-,,,,,,.„,:-.,,,.--,:-.0„;.,,,,,,•:.,,,•,,,,,,,,,,,,,,:k,.,,,,,,,,,,,,„,.,:,,,,,,.,,•,:,„,,,,..-,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,:':,:,7,,,,St.tK:V,N,W,,t,,,,,A.T:'f,,r,V'.,,,,,;',,,A, ..,.-4,,,,i,,,,,c,,,....,,,,,ZOS:3,1,-,0.--,,,,PM.i,i-Ma..,,,,,,,,,,,,,I.,,,,,k.ti'ill.i.,,,,lk.,11!-,,,,,,,,I.T.,,, Florida Patrol Investigators, Inc. 176 14.67 C."5,9,,,,,, ' , ,,,,W'V',,,,,,,M. 7 ,,,,, • it,.4",.. ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,i -,,,, '''' ,?..i',..M1,,,,,,,,,, i,,,,','-', ,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,n,,,, '',,, ,'," ,,,,,,,, 1 a..t. .., ',',,,,,,,,,,,,,, ..". ., 0,,,,,,,;1.1,,,,.41,,,,,,,,,,,, ',41,,,,''''M4M,,,,,,',,,' : ,,,,,,,,,I.,.. ,...,,K.,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, ',..,..t,,,T,M,K77,,,,,,,,,,,T,,,,,, F,,,,',5',',,,'3',1'1',IbMZ.'g,'r,f,',,,,,,,,,V1,,r,,Z,,,,,,.:'Z-,,,I,:*',5:,,,,P,. Kent Security Services, Inc. 179 14.92 t•VRII,",,,F,-.:,7V,:knt.l:,,ir,,F,,rael.r.:YZ18,rEE,:nii..,ZgnK,..,,,nk.TM,,,,F.,,,r,"'F,,n.,IS.at.:...rdf..i.I.E...nTr.,9S..,',T,',,,t,,,s7r,., P7nk,,,,,,I,FE.VT,S.*R.R,Sr<5,V,,Fr,..ai,A.IS..,,,,,,,,r-......V.g,,,,,,,,a2TZ,'N., .,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,MW,,,,M.,,,,,nn,,i,,,T.t.M.,,,,,,,,,,V-M,,i.,,,,,,,,7,,,,,,,,,,,,,VMME., P.G. Security, Inc. d.b.a. Platinum Group Security 172 14.33 ,,,,,,,WW,,,,,,,,,,,,NI,,,,,,,,M,,,,:4,:,,, ,,,,,,,3,...,,,,,,,,,P;11,,,,,,,,,,,,f , , ,,,,.'.,....,Ka'P.V.,fi,..,,,,,,,,,,,,F ,..,t,r4r•-1,:..,,,,,,,,T.., ,,,,,,,,,V.,,,..n••ST,;,.,,,,,:,v,,M,4,,,.•,..a.,:Vi'.....V:P',•..,,,,at,.SFV.-a.S,iA..:d,,,,,,,...,,g., .Z:..,.'K,,,,,,,,,gc,.',,ai.,,; ........i.113,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,..C-',.....,,,,,,,,,,,411 PM Security Service, Inc. 176 14.67 .,,„,,,,,,,,,„_,-,-;,..-,..,.,,,,,...:,--,....,,,,„...,,,,..„,,„:„_,,,,,. ,,,.. w ,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,V ,.• ',,,t,i.,;•:.4.,,,,k3,.."4-,,,,, ',:,,,,,,A,,, , ,:.. .,,,,,,,,,,,,, ei,,, '-:,,,,,,,' ',,,,,,,,. :,,, ,`:,', ..,,, .',A,,,,,,,,,..",,?,a-A.R.,,,,,A.V.,,,,,,,, `V. •,,,,- ',,,ei. a',,,,,l,•-,, • ,n,,.•,.., ,..",'',,,W ,,'N''''A'',,,,,,'...,',.T,,,,,,',A Security Alliance, LLC 170 14.17 PER THE EVALUATION COMMITTEE MEETING AND AS REFLECTED ON ITS RECORD, IN AN EFFORT TO FURTHER ASSURE THE OBJECTIVITY OF THIS PROCESS, THE MAXIMUM FIFTEEN (15) POINTS AVAILABLE FOR THE TECHNICAL PROPOSAL'S PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE CRITERIA WAS AWARDED TO EACH PROPOSER IN PROPORTION WITH THE TOTAL PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE POINTS THE PROPOSER RECEIVED FOR THE THREE (3) PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRES THAT WERE REQUIRED PER PROPOSER AT A MAXIMUM NUMBER OF POINTS OF SIXTY (60) PER PAST PERFORMANCE EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE.