Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutMaster Evaluation FormsAUCTION SERVICES RFP 270254 Master Evaluation Form - Summary GROUP 1 - On -Site Auction Services Total Rank PROPOSERYa us Fisher Auction Co., Inc. 496 1 GROUP 2 - Internet Auction Services Total Rank a PROPOSER ... x ..,... � ,. S .ev Wan Rene' Bates Auctioneers, Inc. 460 1 Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc. 442 2 GovDeals, Inc. 430 3 The Public Group, LLC 397 4 Fisher Auction Co., Inc. 372 5 InterScholastic Trading Company 282 6 Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB December 9, 2011 1 of 1 AUCTION SERVICES .<,,..e e ... .._.. - RFP 270254 Master Evaluation Form - Detailed e GROUP 1 - On -Site Auction Services Evidence of ability,understandingCapabilities of required services, capacity & skill of firm to perform, including timeliness, stability, availability, marketing efforts and location Quality, depth, and scope of response to proposal Successfule governmental experience & background In similar services Background, qualifications & experience of personnel assigned to the project of proposer's software to process transactions expediently for P y resporting and checkout Price/Compensation TOTAL , -.. r .: . ,.... , .. f.: ",EVALUATOR >. ........., ma _.h...: «.v � ,? - .. s......: .... , ?. 3 �: , ss.. , r. ... ,.: . k.„ � x��. � a tip'so ,, ,� FROP,OSER�. ..>.... . _,:. _, >... x ..._. � i- ,. ::a-. "g''.:. ,.-r .....,......,�_ ._.;.,„+�'"'...3z:�-.:,.�e....�ti... .�„ 'Th�`re . �,y�: �.. .. ,.. ,.ss.. -y "p.. t- e4y. � � � '�. � : ,�, � . � .....k > ..M ,�c � . _ x... .. ... � ,.:.. r _ ,. .., w S- '5.,.:. ......i ...-c... �-,.Y `i iv......x"�2:: -"�i�r y� `�r..'ie.::,.,.. - ar �: ,. . l i: ?..,"' A L _ ?�t � ,. ��•� _�.k� ., � �,�. i U _ rKK �,... I' ;v. s: h-.. ,.?'. '' +. .- , ,... °kxa ...:.. 1.. £ a s c .� X %.-. '�:� � , - . � -:.2r. �,'..:. .. _ ,15 .....':.mac ..,.. .. ..» �: % "'�.:..-,s ��... ; - '�� _ :'. : : h;'& "1 ::� � � , rrra A S wY > e .., � ... .,' '':.�-,a 'S`7� t:.. �-, r ,. Fy ..i�.rr � � �-, � �, �Sr. "�.� 1 w . ..�. ^{ - .3raL C i'�:: r b.�. 's8 i `T � ,-� �� ,� -: r ;' 25..i. .�, ::r'S'. q-.>il.: { '_ j• David Santucci Fisher Auction Co., Inc. 20 10 15 15 15 25 100 Herb Hyman 20 10 .15 15 14 25 99 William Garviso 20 10 j15 15 15 25 100 John Babos, Jr. 20 9 .15 15 15 25 99 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 20 10 j15 15 15 • 23 98 12/9/2011 1 of 2 Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB AUCTION SERVICES RFP 270254 -_._... R— .• �_ 'I ,,W n,�; ..t . ;..: , ..: S = Detailed . .. Master Evaluation Form GROUP 2 - Internet Auction Services Evidence of ability, understanding of required services, capacity & skill of firm to perform, including 9 timeliness, stability, availabilit Y: marketing efforts and location Quality, depth, and scope y' p p of response to proposal Successful governmental g experience & background in similar services Background, qualifications & experience of personnel assigned to the project Capabilities of proposer's software to process transactions expediently for res ortin and p g checkout price/Compensation TOTAL EVALUATOR s P.,ROPOSER .. �n ,� .. , 20 � �...�., �, ,� : a� . x6 �5 <:�. � ,, .:b.�. �,15 �';i_ ' �,�.1; .�..,.._ ': 15 �g _:� ��? •>w�.. a,_ � -•� 100Y �y,� David Santucci15 Fisher Auction Co., Inc. 14 13 , 10 �,� 20.7 . 77 Herb Hyman 20 9 .14 14 14 .. 25:.. 96 . William Garviso 10 5 5 10 1 20'> 51 John Babos, Jr 10 5 10 10 10 . 20= 65 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 15 10 .10 15 15 ' 181.,; 83 David Santucci Rene' Bates Auctioneers, Inc. 19 10 :14 15 12 23: 93 Herb Hyman 20 10 14 14 12 10=` 80 William Garviso 20 10 15 15 15 25 ' 100 John Babos, Jr 19 8 14 13 13 23 90 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 20 10 15 15 15 22 97 David Santucci GovDeals, Inc. 16 8 .15 15 15 17 86 Herb Hyman 20 9 13 13 14 15 84 William Garviso 20 10 15 15 15 10 85 John Babos, Jr 20 . 8 :14 14 ' 10 ' 20 86 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 20 9 113 14 15 18 89 David Santucci The Public Group, LLC. _ 19 10 '15 14 15 • 19 92 Herb Hyman 10 8 12 . 12 14 20 76 . William Garviso 10 2 10 10 12 : 20 64 John Babos, Jr 18 7 13 13 10 20 81 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 18 9 10 14 15 18 • 84 David Santucci Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc. 16 10 :14 12 12 20 84 Herb Hyman 20 9 7 14 14 • 25 89 William Garviso . 20 10 14 12 15 20 91 John Babos, Jr 20 9 :14 14 11 25' I 93 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 15 9 14 14 15 18 i 85 David Santucci InterScholastic Trading Company 10 6 10 8 2 10 46 Herb Hyman 10 5 5 10 . 10 5 : 45 William Garviso 15 5 10 10 1 5 46 John Babos, Jr 17 7 .13 13 12 . 15 77 Gamaliel N. Souffrant 10 9 .10 14 15 10 68 12/9/2011 2 of 2 Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB