HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation FormsAUCTION SERVICES
RFP 270254
-1,,Y.y;":,:,r-r,�,si:,.nq'ytss--.y'—SLa:;w. 'i5.as:=r- ':^.i'mi(C,[43:tr.Tw.-a,:(¢TSiudSdd:LntGYSsiST.SiumV,li&:vnTLJiw:ilC.Tnv19.>r�.z4i1:;LiN+.uwS, vRSwL:Ii RK.kudi.164iiNaraalaaail,11,r 11;1Z4Ila lii'vi4L" U,
Evaluation Form
Evaluator: GJ,r.Q ,:J`1--,..//�-c__:-, Date : _I cA I
Signature : ✓L1ad/d( L=� ---''---
PROPOSER
Evidence of ability,Capabilities
understanding of
required services, capacity &skill of
firm to perform, including timeliness,
stability, availability, marketing
efforts and location
Quality, depth, and scope
of response to proposal
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in similar
services
Background,
qualifications &
experience of personnel
assigned to the project
P of
proposer's software to
Process transactions
expediently for
resporting and checkout
, .
l,
PricelCompensat1on
TOTAL
:, x.. -.,.u, :.a .-
,. i ::
a. ,T :a: in. ., ._.., _. i,.
?E '4 , v. ... p+ J3...
K.. 4 r _ n
.,.,t �., , ,: t...fa,
..,E.M �v .. ,7, 7.
e: r :... eu.. -. ..
.,: If_ f tip v. S::
.:..:, ... .,.
:.
...,,,.� ..
,.,. t��, Aa,. a_
:e. ... � _. .,.. .. ,..:a.
ti
., u :..
>,�, _G . U ..
,.,,. RO P . uryg�. ,,,
� �w f
[ -. _� ...... Lw. ., ,. .: YC ''c..
u _ ..: e. ... r -
h
�..w .L .R 1, a .w.,.
,. .+, ,... v:x k .....a. :t ,,,...n'.iS -x9 Y,u
,w. ._. t , ,..... I P
. _ �... :..
.:- .'.
r.On-SIte.Aactton Sera ces,
z ,.Ir. , ., ,,aa
.... . , , ... .«
fl-.. .nY.:..... .t. ._Si+ .1,1.... ,m.:
,., �. . k,e. .:� W..,c-�. �
..,.,.utvm:,�r,:.r;n.,�re,,.,..x:,��t�d,awx,m,a'vs-7-ems"
_,:,.. , ,:., ..,..: .., .,, ... -., .' „'
.. .F , rvm N
M, :Oa.Y.. o ila ! 9. I
„fi ". °a y. .,:� r. ?2< , r . 9 Y
rr .. , ^, , ,
"d�_c ,, _. r ..., ..,.4...t.
yy S
., ..., i. .... ..,� L'. n. .:'^ 6.A ,.d �.
7 y u.
".rw _., � M h .,. ( ,.rdh
i� .r �.. ... ,.... 3
, .� n e, ,.. � . ..,,.
, . , . f � II :
n.�.e . „ .,,.: ,eq r<, ,:S ,
.,. .,: F ... ,... I: p C.,, , . _:.1
j 3
„� a7 «... ., t!'J„ �,..., ....
4h.. .. , o ii n
..... .�t�., `� y_,.t ...
r .n. >at� � ,J ..� �?
i
. . ., 1. f.a.. ,.. .. 4 .,.Y ,,..:. atl , ,...1
i : n � � ..
a �, � ,..,. .,. Md 3
Y" 7... ... ... ..
r�h1 , j rt'•IH . �
.. , v:... [t . w ,_ .20 ,, .. .>$ , k .,�"
:. .., vas +i.,. f,.: i. ,....N'S.. `i ..
, T w tu.-G ,. i .:: .e.
.: , , n.,. .kr, L -.. fi Sx� .,... 5, d i
,N:t.�,, . � � Y_ .... r< ...ra,. �
:... ,. ,. . ,u r 4
�.. , . �,. :. . P , �
,+d. .y,, .I:It e,.,,
. ,::. I,CS CV RY q.. �a.. ', I.ri, ,
;::&�y3���ta� �i`✓.ach4i�:l:��� ��6nIF,�<7"
.. r -.,. .'.,,.
. , T".t
.tl�, wa ....
,.... n..• ,:
. r,< }f". 1
,. � �
J h_v. �C .::'.,,1.,,,
,M1 1. ..t ,oll,
_� h, . �
9.�
LJ to �YJ
�r.
t �`., .
M1 ,.. ,.
.. rc» r
.,r{
- _[
1 � ,A
Y , ,� . ,. ,:,
ar..
,l a �
v Y IA,. E..,
.. �.Y. iN,..
�o[,m,1Nit�6.xrsetl.L�e
n,
I hl7
a Y a r
i i ,:
1'r,l
.. : E
.�.
r f� I 7 o.
: 5;
1 t, 10 n:4.-,
„,
.' .1 .,,
, :�
I . Aid.
.l ..1.
W...u,::ln.1
�� �.,,r. Ell
, r,r:,
wx A ...
,. .„ .. 'X
Lk: 77
nd r,
..14 J,r ..�
.. .,..
i 4 , f
� ,, [
! C1 .'D.C.
..
l.0 1,1
.. s
�i
� ..7,
tl �.
ow° �h.>`�.F��d:r.Ps
x,,.
.l g.
„b „ a ,
.,6,�1 I.:
e 1 I
M 44x- r „
1 1� , �
,
:[. ,.
:'P11
�
t,,,.�p:
L :I 4..41
.,,,1 .,.
�I, a .., . -
a,
l.. �,C -
S,
k .. ,
1 .: .:
.F.�u
vr,r, ,, =sr
.f J ai., m.,`MGu
..... F; d 1rR .9" r
r .I �" . I
_.. .. S.
,5. �.. ,
� , i I,.. V I. � :
j:,
v.. .: 11 k
�Pr I �.
t, l t.. . :
f i .. :,.
,, �., tlt.la: t . . a.l . `�F
t � I
.4 :: � Id
>.N .� : 1
jn
�,, 7N
^...: I :a,.4. �1.
+f: ..
„l,v ,: ,.
4 , , � . . ,r}
d 11: C, a .. 99 t
4 { .. 7 ..
fi ,
�� ..}.,,, E
I,.i I,' .:1, .lF r�l
,L I., a. 15a . N, a,�
~a I . E, ,
, e.r.•. a , LI , NY
.M1: 1, . .m.:I�`6, ,.
i � i � .�. �4 £
, _ �� r , . ,� .
d„rl , ,,,
'A` , a f�,
,s J�@r:1Y E, ..,�y4�r
fsn t. ,P 1140kr1 rC.
?!. Ia,.aoa.:nrHES4r.,x.:7nhk�n.x'�rtl:6titV,,.riYr>Kkli,a
. r I .M . Y...
�G. .:: :t:u
R4
r :. .� i5 J,
...: j nl .'(J, �..,. ...
JI .:. . .. ,
c„ � r
., : ,
n .
.I.fi 1.., .,(,,q ,.,
4 dn V^ <k. l
N. Y rIC .i, ,. IC
,:. �,: �n .... p , .. I ,h. �
I 1.,. t o , �
:�ytf .9
,,,� ., . � i t � .
,.,w ..„ Iwr �,;
,:Y , ::p"F,
,. a. i l!L �,.
I 1 1
r: [[``^^ r•:. Irl, �kM1 .i.
:...: Stt r r I
,. .. ,: f,
I,. e.r 5.n e. ..I .....
:( � l ,J �-
�, � ,, r: l„
5 h .,t' r u a, .,,E . �..r
.,. � � _f
J C.n.. ,_ ., � � :.
" F -�, . _
� .,.
i u r'k ,... ,l a l " ,»,d
n,. fTJJ. e. , ..� �,I YS. 1J ..
.. ,Ldy x Pr'1,I. v4
ici,rr.,..a9 .It ..,,e�,:nr
L .... �..�'.. .. Y. 0 1 d..:.
W :M1. li.v
�"._.ti�... .. Y .., : YF,
:V•. .A � a. n
.:
1 ,�.
, 4Y,. Y,
:F .. o E •
,..s:i:�,.,,,., ti
kEIY . „. .(.a , r
_ i. .... x.
. a_ , . �I tl ,I k y ..
4 s r
IPlrr rfl [. "R �E
3, 1 .: .: VV
, .n�,. ,�
,a ,� ._I.: �t:�Y .tip,
, � ., , , }"i:':'
1 h ,�. F.
f L a . , � . :.2 a ,
t. 15
,.� .
5. e Tt'
C r, .r.a
ii � ,. ..,tt .. :. ..
.,: .,
t 4
� , Eat:. .. E.
ar C" .. ,� •l 1 E
�7! " ,5C4 x:mr:x�,afV, ..f
S_x".„9h r, � , uV
Y 4t. , r. �..I�N:,
1. .a..`t. r. A ., ., }
.� ,.. ,..,,2 <. -L
rr } :I ,I.
..a
1' E
4r! '
,':-,: .1. .. �F
� _ . . ��
�. .k:
P.ta :r tn._
:n.
.. _,., , �
t, L.
... ... � 1 .:�
f „� ',. l.k k
25r.
t 7 ,.4 '�_JF.
.:�
.
_bf. W, .r .
her'ufiAo.. s.�F..r,n..uti'IG.rzi'>.
„: E..
�,ht.. - .,, 1... +
In a ..- t .,, •
Fi' .[�i -:.
]. ,:.,, .f. '.
.y5 .` ...c.,.
.�Y
";.. a c, U
:,..
.r,., .L. ,
,. .�i:�vi l`i :,u...
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
.a..,
.t ..
'twO..: e
!.E.•,d a.:rB.e..!f ,J..r.., .,< ..GY._. u.r.0. ,.P.rM :w�w .,_G,...x>,.... ,x e...W;:,g., ,n�1x..,._.._..:,...,.,t..c......,.:....>k.,.<.a.,
.Int. er.neAwet_anSery ces4
._v?xi..._r..sS�MrXet7
7 T
LJ -.
.yw�....r,4 ..-.,,..,_,W
....,1 .. .
:� a
..;
I.�.
,
4.„
Qx
/�
l l at . Nr..lei;
1I 97
lt
S
tpy'9. .!:n.C6+
„,
[.E.
,, d
I
,1,
,
'"
ifE 4 .eY..>..r. ...:..,.!...',!'...
' �,.
P.ir
i Fr
./ 5
.
,4N., i
s
3,.
..3 ,.�F. ,.L_E`,A.+r,. Y,^'•::
2
..- 2,C
,_
/a
� HJ. •
._�
.:.'.:
..v
.
..s
! . �.
Fisher Auction Co. Inc.
V
[.-
/
/ 3
1
2�
�7
Rene' Bates Auctioneers, Inc.
/7
%c)
j'
% .:�
j Z
2?--33
!
GovDeals, Inc.
>/
/ 5/
/ S
/ 7
7C
The Public Group, LLC.
/7-
/6
/)
/ G/
/ 3
/ci
77
Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
/ (
/
/ c!
/ Z
/ Z
- 2 a
�1/
InterScholastic Trading
Company
//
(n
/ 0
/
/ e
L t
/E fi '
AUCTION SERVICES ='
RFP 270254
Evaluator:
14G45`1P1l`!)
Evaluation Form
Date . ! �f
/ r
Signature
: 'r,ti k ,,,,,_..z —
PROPOSER
Evidence of ability, understanding
of required services, capacity &
skill of firm to perform, including
timeliness, stability, availability,
marketing efforts and location
Quality, depth, and scope
of response to proposal
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services
Background,
qualifications &
experience of
personnel assigned to
the project
Capabilities of
proposer's software to
process transactions
expediently for
resporting and
checkout
#!
x zsl:
i
PricelCompensat� in
TOTAL
,GROUP:
i.
Auction etvlces
.:, �....r:+
10
t t t
15
15
15
25
100
Fisher Auction Co.,Inc
rr
GROUP:2
<Intecnet Auction $ ervtes
0
/ I
/ , -
J
L
.,
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
9
1 ,% /
%
V
j "> j�
.„ r - -
`n
Rene' Bates Auctioneers, Inc.
a 0
/
i y
19
r.-0,
yo'
05
GovDeals, Inc.
%1 0
'
1 3
3
/, J
1 ,
P
The Public Group, LLC.
tjo � i PP f % , ;v o P,: td ckroad
Ir_; ,/r Aa mot.
E
/ tom.<
/ cgt-ij
/hr
I
'[ �v '
Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
� 0
II
/ Y
! �
/ G%
+�'i! 3
c! _l
;(�
InterScholastic Trading
Company
/)
J
�_CQ
l a
Evaluator:
AUCTION SERVICES
RFP 270254
Evaluation Form
Signature
D e : //� / /.0/74
PROPOSER
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
Rene' Bates Auctioneers, Inc.
GovDeals, Inc.
The Public Group, LLC.
Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
InterScholastic Trading
Company
Evidence of ability, understanding
of required services, capacity &
skill of firm to perform, including
timeliness, stability, availability,
marketing efforts and location
70
go
Quality, depth, and scope
of response to proposal
/6,
70
2-
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services
1`0
Background,
qualifications &
experience of
personnel assigned to
the project
to
Capabilities of
proposer's software to
process transactions
expediently for
resporting and
checkout
15
Price/Compensation
TOTAL
AUCTION
RFP
SERVICES
270254
'.:.+e.:.:a.a.a.az,......hiu.,.x, :.u.:::':i+l::«.r.:..Crviw' s.u'.,.:..:.F ai1x:..S.:v.:n..,`.._ .2:.vw" x,..:,;,,...:tt:::«...:.mew
Form
\— CA i Date : /Z.-Tly.fi"Zsajt
.r,„ -- `a
•':fit`"z
�
�s.t:::ri`II5,'^:' T: �..'�,...,.
Evaluator:
.=.9... e:. .'.S::R..arm.td'....Ufw
Evaluation
1 kIr
/y
Signature : . —�!!�: ./
PROPOSER
Evidence of ability,understandingCapabilities
of required services, capacity &
skill of firm toperform, including
9
timeliness, stability,expediently
availability,
marketing efforts and location
Quality, depth, and scope
of response to proposal
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services
Background,
qualifications &
experience of
personnel assigned to
the project
of
proposer's software to
process transactions
for
resporting and
checkout
�r
Price/Compensation
TOTAL
GROUP:
O i te.,Aucttort
.. .,. ', . i4
.... .. ., .: .s.'..�� .. .:'.. .:,
Z.,:.
nr
x.. ... _
r «
r
.... 4.. Y
'....�:`^.5 ::., '
.
,.... :, . ,..: �. .:v.
x : �... �x. :, �. ,.,
..;. k^.
i". "r...>v'1 dS
... ^.e.._.............s ...:.:, .. <..wL.r:
l <
a _.:'
t z : F .e
x x..h
f a i 2 .P
% . L"t i ¢�A. t
.<,..e+.:..::k .m
7 :.tLL
.: t
.t � _ r..,.
z
l...
L y .y J"-�>
«.....1.:,%� a..,,....:::.:i
s
:.,„p. .-s: .-:. _,
.Y,�
i ' ax
e +e .2
. wxcs [
1..
........
..
1` .,....
1
...........
a�Jr.
Fisher Auction Co. Inc.
ZO
CV x,--Y
'..
..
s �
k
Y ...a. �,_ .�. ..._..
`/i"
4.
15 ,� r
v,
•"d S...,Si�r ,..?v,... �.-
/
y,. r...:.K^":.
15,
i-.,%A*.. .i,T,n,
/
9y
15'
.,-_ .5..-.,..:3. a. ..o
Z
25
��•,� :M..✓.:.:5
� ..:.¢
::,I
it ..1
GROU
Internet Auction:
Servl es x
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
...,
...
... ...,�
-Rene'Bates Auctioneers, Inc.
i1
`�'
��
y
f
�F �G
C
,�
y�
�F
:��111 GovDeals, Inc.
ZP
j�
/
>
IZ�
LD `The Public Group, LLC.
`Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
�%
f
/ /
g- InterScholastic Trading
`.- Company
�,
/ /,'`
^'�
��
,!` / S
//
r
f
77
,.'"",,.'' .,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,Z,W.,,,,,...4d..,2a4.....Z1,,,V.,,,.31,4...,1.411....,,,,,,,,...4X4.4,4.:,,44,.,',4,
Eva I u ator:
AUCTION SERVICES
.
RFP 270254
Ak.g.W.,......,,,,,t.,i,==1, t,.=,a.,L,.,,,,tiii:,f.R.,.'..t.'...t,..'&:.,:...i......%.P.W.Z:.::..:.,:y4,..a.4..-a,....ia,.,.,..µ.,.....}j.U..,,,,•...n.Z
Evaluation Form
'."-p v-cli 4-n \ :. Date ; 4
• r , F.' _
.-,. ),,.,.,
::
,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
re. %, it......14.4...4.4...i.=int.:•....f.f...i.
. ..
a,
Signature
: _----"r------e--'"
. .
. . ..
PROPOSER
yr,11..,,,,,,,,J.,..5a;:f.r.tM,17,;=5.ie ',-
ROD- -..
ii.-Site.:, Auction. ervices,
Evidence of ability, understanding
of required services, capacity &
skill of firm to perform, including
timeliness, stability, availability,
marketing efforts and location
Quality, pdethto, and scope
of response proposal
/
Successful
governmental
experience &
backgrotind in
similar services
•
Background,
qualifications &
experience of
personnel assigned to
the project
Capabilities
proposers software to
process transactions
expediently for
resporting and
checkout
,',i •.2 ! - , `,- Ei
Price/Cornpensation
TOTAL
, , -.? ,!.: , i,,, •,--,.-
,. .. ,
-- .
_ _ „. ,
,. , ; -,.,
- _
' A
.,..4 , - _ .„, ,...
... ,,,, :-„, ....,-.;•:, , ;-....!.
„ . ,.
„_. _ _
,,-,. , 4=:,
.t•41
- .
,
.. --
,,„, ._,„
,
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
'' — - , r '" ' ''''
00
liltOrpo ucti`eiti ei;vices.-
.'..,:i;:';.'0.-s7.-,-.,"-,,A,'-,...,:•,-I-.:,,v,.?;:zKi,,..1:;,„-,...p:',.:
t• 0
\
''.'.'•.,,,h•:•'1' ' ,,,,
_
'" '1' z = -,,,,, *,',,,,
, .,,,,
, ,„
,,,„15,::-,:o
,.,.. -
—
":
'1'
t -c---
-i„,, ,-,-,,
,„, .,... ,
'7'
•
1 3----
. . ', ''
,-.
„ -,
, '',„',,,-1,'7,7i,'•-:: r:', ' '
' :* .
,
4P.P -11
, -
-
,,, 1;):
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
2 '
‘' ..-'' . .
1,5-- .
t i
, ,• -1
i Rene' Bates Auctioneers, Inc.
—
2 0 \
i, - , ,P
- • ,,,,
...-
— . The Public Group, LLC.
1 fr' -
Mk
••-,
t
/4;3' ."-
.. .
. .
''." Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
.--".
I ,
.
interScholastic Trading
, Company
Ic-b).01'
.
' r?
CA
ial
..-.2'