HomeMy WebLinkAboutTabulation BidBID TABULATION - SUMMARY
THREE LOWEST RESPONSIVE, RESPONSIBLE BIDDERS
IFB 263247 -TEMPORARY PERSONNEL SERVICES
Item #
Description
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
TERTIARY
# 1
Clerk I
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
. $12.15
$12.15
$12.15
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1702
1.1774
1.1801
Unit Price per Hour
$14.22
$14.31
$14.34
# 2
Clerk II
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$13.43
$13.43
$13.43
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1702
1.1774
1.1801
Unit Price per Hour
$15.72
$15.81
$15.85
# 3
Custodian
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$13.43
$13.43
$13.43
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1702
1.1774
1.195
Unit Price per Hour
$15.72
$15.81
$16.05
# 4
Clerk Typist
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$14.10
$14.10
$14.10
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1701
1.1774
1.1800
Unit Price per Hour
$16.50
$16.60
$16.64
# 5
Laborer•
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$14.10
$14.10
$14.10
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1701
1.1774
1.1950
Unit Price per Hour
$16.50
$16.60
$16.85
# 6
Account Clerk
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$15.53
$15.53
$15.53
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1701
1.1774
1.1800
Unit Price per Hour
$18.17
$18.29
$18.33
# 7
Heavy Equipment Mechanic Helper
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$16.39
$16.39
$16.39
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
1.1774
1.2050
Unit Price per Hour
$19.18
$19.30
$19.75
# 8
Painter
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate: _
$18.10
$18.10
$18.10
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1701
1.1714
. 1.2200
Unit Price per Hour
$21.18
-$21.20
$22.08
Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB 11/9/2011
Approved by:4LY'f(//41/)f
1 OF 3 De�t Director Designee
p /
BID TABULATION - SUMMARY
THREE LOWEST RESPONSIVE, RESPONSIBLE BIDDERS
IFB 263247 - TEMPORARY PERSONNEL SERVICES
Item #
Description
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
TERTIARY
.# 9
Senior Heavy Equipment Operator
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$19.00
$19.00
-$19.00
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
-1.1774
1.2200
Unit Price per Hour
$22.23
$22.37
$23.18
# 10
Accountant
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc.
d/b/a A1A Employment
of Miami
Adelante Staffing Services, Inc.
Employee Pay Rate:
$19.23
$19.23
$19.23
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.0619
1.1799
1.1799
Unit Price per Hour
$20.42
$22.69
$22.69
# 11
Transcriber
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$21.00
$21.00
$21.00
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
1.1774
1.1800
Unit Price per Hour -
$24.57
$24.73
$24.78
# 12
Heavy Equipment Mechanic
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$21.00
$21.00
$21.00
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
1.1774
1.2100
Unit Price per Hour
$24.57
$24.73
$25.41
# 13
Special Projects Assistant
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$22.00
$22.00
$22.00
M
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
1.1774
1.1800
Unit Price per Hour
$25.74
$25.90
- $25.96
# 14
Administrative Assistant
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$22.00
$22.00
$22.00
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
1.1774
1.1800
Unit Price per Hour
$25.74
$25.90
$25.96
# 15
Accountant Senior
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$22.00
$22.00
$22.00
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1700
1.1774
1.1800
Unit Price per Hour
$25.74
$25.90
$25.96
# 16
Surveyor
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$27.41
_;$27.41
$277.41
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1699
"1.1774
'1:1799 " "r
Unit Price per Hour
$32.07
- ---$32.27 ""°
$32.34
Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB 11/9/2011
20F3
Approved by:
tx 4.t�+�l e // 7//
DepartmereDirector / Designee/
BID TABULATION - SUMMARY
THREE LOWEST RESPONSIVE, RESPONSIBLE BIDDERS
IFB 263247 - TEMPORARY PERSONNEL SERVICES
Item #
Description
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
TERTIARY
# 17
Project Manager
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$33.30
$33.30
$33.30
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1699
1.1774
1.1799
Unit Price per Hour
$38.96
$39.21
$39.29
# 18
Special Projects Administrator
Deanna Enterprises, Inc.
d/b/a A1A Employment of
Miami
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
Atrium Personnel, Inc.
d/b/a TransHire
Employee Pay Rate:
$48.78
$48.78
$48.78
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1788
1.1800
1.2280
Unit Price per Hour
$57.50
$57.56
$59.90
# 19
Grant Writer
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$24.64
$24.64
$24.64
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1702
1.1774
1.1801
Unit Price per Hour
$28.83
$29.01
$29.08
# 20
Administrative Aide
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc.
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
Deanna Enterprises, Inc. d/b/a
A1A Employment of Miami
Employee Pay Rate:
$18.09
$18.09
$18.09
Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier
1.1702
1.1774
1.1801
Unit Price per Hour
$21.17
$21.30
$21.35
NOTE: Unit Price per Hour is obtained by multiplying the "Employee Pay Rate" times the "Marginal Mark -Up Multiplier"
Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB 11/9/2011
3 OF 3
Approved by:
Act
Departmen Director / Designee
BID TABULATION - DETAILED
INVITATION FOR BID (IFB) 263247
TEMPORARY PERSONNEL SERVICES
Deanna Enterprises, Inc.
d/b/a AlA Employment
of Miami
(Local Vendor)
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc,
(Non -Local Vendor)
Manpower
International, Inc.
(Non -Local Vendor)
Malan Tate,
Incorporated
(Non -Local Vendor)
P2P Staffing
Corporation
db/a TekPartners
(NomLocal Vendor)
Premier Staffing Source,
Inc,
(Non Local Vendor)
Atrium Personnel, Inc.
d/b/a TransHire
(Non -Local Vendor)
Hirequest, LLC.
d/b/a Trojan Labor
(Non -Local Vendor)
W estaff (USA), Inc.
(Non -Local Vendor)
Royal Regions
Incorporation
(Non -Local Vendor)(Non-Local
COCHHBHA Enterprises,
Inc.
Vendor)
Kelly Services, Inc.
(Non -Local Vendor)
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
(Local Vendor)
Item
a
Description
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Markup
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier) •
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
- Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Markup
Multiplier)
1•
Clerk)
Original Bid: 1.1901
Best and Flnal:1.1801
Original Bid: 1.1802
Best and Flnak1.1702
1.3550
1.2403
1.3893
1.2379
1.2280
1.2500
1.2500
1.2472
1.2305
1.4016
Original Bld: 1.1984
Best and Final: 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
2•
Clerk II
Original Bid: 1.1899
Best and Final: 4.1801
Original Bid: 1.1802
Best andflnol: I.1702
1.3550
1.2398
1.3902 -
1.2375
1.2278
1.2500
1.2490
N
1_472
0
1.2308
1.3984
Original 81d: 1.1981
Best and 7Ina8, 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
3•
Custodian
Original Bid: 1.2301
Best and Final: 1.1950
Original Bid: 1.1802
Best ono Final:1,270;
PRIMARY
1.3900
NO BID
NO BID
1.2375
1.2278
1.2500
NO BID
N
1.2472
1.2345
1.4244
Original Bid: 1.2278
Bestand Final: 1.1774
TERTIARY
SECONDARY
4•
Clerk Typist
Original Bid: 1.2442
Best and Final: 1.1800
Original 01d: 1.1801
Best and Final: 1.1701
1.3350
1.2397
1.3894 •
1.2376
1.2277
NO BID
1.2450
R
1.2472
1.2305
1.2674
O,Iginal Bid: 1.1986
Best and floor: 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
5•
Laborer
Original Bid: 1.2298
Best and final: 1.1950
Original Bid:1.1801
pest and Final:1.1701
1.3900
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
1.2277
1.2500
NO BID
5
1..2472
1.2695
1.3567
Original Bld: 1,2191
Baltand Final: 1.1774
ER
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
6•
Account Clerk
Original Bid: 1.1848
Best and Malt 1180Q
Original Bid: 1.1801
Best and Flna1:1.1701
PRIMARY
1.3350
1.2402
.
1.3902
1.2376
1.2279
NO BID
1.2430
0
1.j472
/V
1.2305
1.3947
Original Bld: 1.1983
Best and Final: 1.1774
TERTIARY
SECONDARY
7•
Heavy Equipment Mechanic
Helper
Original Bid: 1.2398
Best and F/na812050
Original Bid: 1.1800
@.Stand F1n01: 1.1700
1.3900
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO RID
5
1. -72
1.3106
NO BID
Original Bid: 1.2535
8 na
Pelt and
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
44008.1774
SECONDARY
V
Painter 8
' -•
Original Bid: 1.2481
Best and Mel: 1.2200
Original Bid; 1.1801
Best and Flnal:1.1701
1.3900
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
1.228E
1.2500
NO BID
V
1. !2
1.2696
NO BID
Original Bid:1.2287
Best and Final: 1.1714
• TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
9•
Senior Heavy Egaipment.`i
Operator:; n.
.: y
'original Bid: 1.2479
Best and Final 1.2200
Original 131d: 1. 1B00
Best and Flna1;1.1700
PRIMARY
1.3900
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
12472
1.3105
NO BID
-
Original Old: 1.3000
Pest and Final: 1.1774
TERTIARY
SECONDARY
10a
Accountant ^
1.1799
• SECONDARY
1.1799
T R� l lY
1.3350
1.4186
1.3900 -
_
1.2376
1.2278
NO BID
1.2400
1.2472
1.2309
1.4441
1.0619
PRIMARY
Created by: YusbeIYOantalex, CPPB 11/.9/2011
1 of
Approved by:
/P VA I
Department Director / Desig
BID TABULATION - DETAILED
INVITATION FOR BID (IFB) 263247
• TEMPORARY PERSONNEL SERVICES
Deanna Enterprises, Inc.
d/b/a A1A Employment
of Miami
(Local Vendor)(Non-Local
Adelante Staffing
Services, Inc,
(Nan -Local Vendor)
Manpower
International, Inc.
(Non -Local Vendor)
Moten Tate,
Incorporated
(Non -Local Vendor)
P2P Staffing
Corporation
d/b/a TekPartners'
Vendors
Premier Stalling Source,
Inc.
Nan -Local Vendor
( )
Atrium Personnel, Inc.
d/b/a Transpire
(Non -Local Vendor)
Dlrequest, LLC.
d/b/a Trojan Labor
(Nan -Local Vendor)
Wester( (USA). Inc,
INon-Local Vendor)
(loyalRegions
Incorporation
(Non -Local Vendor)
nd
C081111BNA Enterprises
Inc
(Nan -Local Vendor)
Kelly Services, Inc.
(Non -Local Vendor)
TriState Employment
Service, Inc.
.
(Local Vendor)
Item
Description
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
MultIpller)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier) •
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Markup
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier) •
• Unit Price
(Marginal Mark-up
Multiplier)
11'
Transcriber
ONglnal Bid: 1.1824
Best and Final: 1.1800
Original Bid: 1.1 fl00
Best and Final: 1.1700
1.3350
1.2400
NO BID
1.2376
1.2281
NO BID
1.2400
1.2472
1.2310
14624
Original Bid: 1.1986
Best and Final: I.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
12•
Hoary Equipment Mechanic
Original Bid: 1.2448
Bess and Flnpl:1.;300
Original Bid: 1.1800
Best pod Flnpl: 3.1 700
1.3900
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
NO BID
- 1.2712
1.3110
NO BID
000
Original Final1:
Best pod Final: 1.]]Jq
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
,277
SECONDARY
13'
Special Projects Assistant
Original Bid: 1.1800
Best end Final- 1.2600
Original Bid: 1.1600
Best and FM I. I1700
1.3350
2.7495
-
1.1364' .
-
1.2376
1.2282
NO BID
1.2360
//''11
1.' /2
1.2309
3.1041
Original Bid: 1.1986
pest and Final: 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
14
' -
Administrative Assistant
Original Bid: 1.1800
Best and FingI' 11800
TERTIARY
Original Bid: 1.1800
Best and Final: 1.1700
PRIMARY
1.3350
1.2400
1.3900
1.2377
1.2282
1.2000
1.2360
i. ;72
R
1.2309
1.3364
Original Bid: 1.1986
Best and Final' 11774
SECONDARY
15'
'
Accountant Senior
Original Bid: 1.1800
Best end Final: 1.11300
Original 81d: 1.1800
Bestand Flnol: 1.1700
1.3350
1.2400
1.3900
1.2377
1.2282
NO BID
1.2360
1 2
1.2309
14623
Original Bid: 1.1986
Best and Find: 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
16'
Surveyor
Original Bid: 1.1799
Best and Mon 11799
Original Bid: 1.1799
Best and Final: 1.1699
1.3350
NO BID
NO BID
1.2375
1.2273
NO BID
1.2350
Jpp
1. 71
1.2309
NO BIO
Original Bid: 1,1985
Best and Final: 1.1774
T R� TIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
17'
- _
Project Manager
Original Bid: 1.1799
Destand Molt 1.1799
Original Bld: 1.1799
Bestand Final: 1.1699
1.3350
1.2399
-
1.3901 •
-
1.2375
1.2279
NO BID
1.2300
1A8jj
1.1i72
1.2309
NO BID
Original Bid: 1.2198
t and Final: 1.1774
ERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
18
Special Projects Administrator
1.1788'
PRIMARY
1.1800
SECONDARY
1.3350
1.2901
1.3899
1.2376
1.2280
TERTIARY
NO BID
1.2300
1.12
V
1.2308
1.4000
1.2798
19'
Grant Writer
- Original Bid: 1.1802
Best eqd Fln01:1.1800
Original Bid: 1.1802
Bestand Fin I. 1.1702
1.3350
1.2399
-
NO BID
1.2374
1.2281
-
NO BID
1.2350
C
1,472
1.2309
3,0609
Original Bid, 1.2200
Best and Final: 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
20'
Administrative Aide
Original Bid: 1.1802
�8est and Flna : 1.1807
Original Bid: 1.1802
Best and Fln41: 1.1702
1.3350
1.2399
1.3903
1.2377
1.2289
NO BID
1.2430
12472
1.2305
1.6252
Original Bid: 1.1973
Best and Flno1: 1.1774
TERTIARY
PRIMARY
SECONDARY
'BIM. has wIthdrahnt Its. bid
der
submled Incorrect lung p[de.
llon-liesponsIve for lallute to
. • nor o
cllent it
"Otthtrnm rm , as
tired under secelrnc2.9 (2)of
the lia
Note/II- LOCAL 736968ENCE ORDINANCE 13275 APPLIED. Bur uant to 66ctIon
10.RS of the Code nl the City of Miami non -local and local bidders were
provided with the opportunity to submit a best and final bid equal to or lower
than the amount of thelow bid submitted by the non -local bidder.
1 Note a2-DE BIDS: Awaid decided pursuant to
section 1.10(6) and 2.16 of IFB 26 247, consistent
with Local Preference Ordinance 13275.
Created by: Yusbel Gonzalez, CPPB 11/R/20
2 of
Approved by:
Ni
ar ant Director/Designee/
IFB 263247 •
ATTACHMENT A - JOB CLASSIFICATION PAY RATE
IFB 263247
Classification
Hourly Pay Rate to Employee
Clerk I
$12.15
Clerk II
$13.43
Custodian
' •
$13.43
Clerk Typist
$14.10
Laborer
$14.10
Account Clerk
$15.53
Heavy Equipment Mechanic Helper
$16.39
Painter
$18.10
Sr. Heavy Equipment Operator
$19.00
Accountant
$19.23
Transcriber
$21.00
Heavy Equipment Mechanic
$21.00
Special Projects Assistant
$22.00
Administrative Assistant
$22.00
Accountant, Senior
$22.00
Surveyor
$27.41
Project Manager
$33.30
Special Projects Administrator
$48.78
Grant Writer
$24.64
Administrative Aide
$18.09
Created 6/14/2011 1 of 1
City of Miami, Florida