HomeMy WebLinkAboutRanking FormCity of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Final Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
Committee Member
BEA International
E Verner Johnson
Freelon/Judson
Olson Sundberg
Alex Peraza
1
3
1
4
Basil Binns
1
4
2
3
Carolyn Mitchell
1
4
3
2
David Shorter
1
3
2
4
Marcel Douge
Steve Stuempfle, Ph.D
2
1
3
4
1
2
4
3
Average Score
1
4
2
3
CIPCAT Chair: Meredith J. Nation Signature' ' \
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 114
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Final Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Proiect B-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
Committee Member
BEA international
E. Verner Johnson
Freelon/Judson
Olson Sundberg
Alex Peraza
95
78.5
95
75.5
Basil Binns
97
56
95
64
Carolyn Mitchell
93
50
89
90
David Shorter
94
81
88
65
Marcel Douge
Steve Stuemptle, Ph.D
91
97
76
79
93
93
72
82
Total Scoring Points
567
420.5
553
448.5
CIPCAT Chair: Meredith J. Nation Signature 'v) Q tax ;'V\ 5
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 114
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Protect B-30508 RFP/RFO No. 05-06-081
...
.i. K'
' am;
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEA Ind
E. Verner Johnson
Freston/Judson
Olson Sundbsrg
•Proposers Experience & Qualifications
30
2.136
Z4
?S tb
27_15
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
' t i 5
7.2 ito
w13' c
Z j
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
174
3B.
";z
Total Score
100
et
75.E
5tFi
5-, t)
Ranking
E
3
1
4
Explanation of Ranking
r!
is ,a'v ' ‘ \ .ut•.,� th.0.t -> �
i-. •q1.vrf GP1,1•tiV;w
N p[to-(.'
4
t
,t r l• rS
j
t
Name of Committee Member
62`L ``) ?'6` "'6""' Signature:
Jr
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Prolect B-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEA Intl
E. Verner Johnson
Proposer's Experience & Qualifications
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
30
30
40
o
R4-
FreelonlJudson
Olson Sandberg
2 `t
Total Score
100
7L
�f
el
2.
Ranking
Explanation of Ranking j`µ! 4: x� ti`��"Ctr'lit-A�� .
?� A 1n�R--vJ S•�4-CD+J �o— V�-� s tS nI �`�}--{l1irC �'lt � A-t cv � � \ t 1 fn.s` i � ► a.� ��t c a c fAv 4C�,•�-•� �yti•�; < <`t1
` ���u S�CI t��� �`� 11u�rtyv-ac#urd S L
:7- e. �i V JJ
la � --dam ,�: a., �� � � � � �
3 e vu�d [ILA) �� iYJS`l' ViS /G V r j::74 vl 1.1 Div! (1•'�,i-',,,,,
fn [Lt +t L� (G �% f n u L h) I 1 � f`b (-A' VJ� ' 7
q' . D LSo�I Sur 3 -kb `. -- - i 16 � 's,S
`..t; f Yr► Co IV Aare ! i o 1✓ -- - Tv ct`r , Ct �/C'''�
Signatur . ,
Name of Committee Member:
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital improvements
Evaluation Committee RankingForm
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
"�='°
�, . ,
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
. Points
BEA Ind
E. Verner Johnson
Freston/Judson
Olson Sundb.rg
Proposer's Experience & Qualifications
30
23
2. 63
2 c))
? 7
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
/2 ' /
2 2
' $3,
1 g
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
A 6
P}
73 &'
'a 0
Total Score
100
95 (
1 6
e
17 i'
Ranking
/�..
3
i
A.,
Explanation of Ranking
0,- -oszE.- *CA- tsktt
tp c c c_t
N � Q:�,
irk 4-0T- ik 1 uses
s� .
I.-i C .AM ,...,.., ,L '
w.............
-
t% , v,
t,\V- d,1
jv..e. ,
, U 2
, La�R,
a.O A O `tom-
-1-42
da- ,.
OW.
iouel
a.Aay.im_t t
41,.,4 . i, ic.)
`-to '`-`1
�p 4-
. N-Qf :v,�
* I 4' 2 'rc4
�}-b. .. kt, iovokiii,
42 ,,ibis- .,t-tAx,..)3-4,1;�x4.0
1- card
al
i,.3 lvev,VL
ika- twiDe a-
0 v'r
teuime,
c _o
b -
\,,,,,,,...
Name of Committee Member: m ,4,., m.e,...L.... /;:to ciet � Signature:
e-iii,u,
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services fora Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
cw
;,, r"�"-1,
;� '
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEA Intl
E. Varner Johnson
FreelonlJudaan
Olson sundberg
Proposer's Experience & Qualifications
30
,q°I
a to
Q
a(D
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
3o
,(1
3
r .Z
'.
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
3
3 c'
39
' `1`
Total Score
100
Cn
II
r -3
S' .
Ranking
.
,. 1
Li
-
- 3
Explanation of Ranking
{
•
ti
Name of Committee Member Sy ` hem tm k &
Signature: �i-��f j�l V�! �
ViQ„�
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
-
,:.,.
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEA Intl
E. Venter Johnson
FreeIon/Judson
Olson Sundberg
Experience & Qualifications
30
- ,
Proposers
ing personnel
30
! ; ,
7 f
• c
,• ,
• -
Expeream,
P-rojecetofManPr°jagerectaTnd sub-cconlixis-ultantkeys
Project Project Approach
40
,._.; ....-)
if.
i ..'
., •
H C-•
Knowledge of and
100
Total Score
I
9
•'7
-7
,----
Ranking
Explanation of Ranking
! / • ,---,_-- r--..'•,' ,•-•... ,, ).•• ,
• •
( , :- - • . -lc .,--,„ . ,
7,
fr)n '71 —4 .., ;::(
• r r ••• t ,..- „ •---': 1.1
• r • c- -4 .r/' ',' .; e: -/_ ,
r -."- -... , n— . -
., - : • ,, • :,•-• / j .. :::: t2 ,. ;_, ,,. , ' ,... . , ,,
s
(, '- .-- -: ‘'....-r• -::-, ,':-._ .... , , .; . "
' ..: ' ' ' t• r -; .: ...", I o , r- 1 .., •
. 1, - . - -' _, :. ; -. r - , _
' -•, _, .
,
, -- .. ... . ,-, .
/
( ‘,. , : (E-...: .? .. / : c•-!
i " ', 4": (.../ *,,-':. 1„. ;,,--'.•• r : • ,•:"' , .., "*/ i t F 1 15 •"' I :
Ile ; ' " ‘ e - • • r - --..(Ce7 i -, • ---, -.! .- / e., -. 6-,,_-.-- jr .. 6: r'
,?/•• ' -
,,
i )•,•''...z 6, •y,.. .,,-( v4tik. ....,,, .r...,,,-, ... • ..,- :t ,,r - 'e- i =-:. 4- i.
C t -, : . ''' 7. r ' I -- =,4 - ; ( eil.
' " .1... i , ..' r - / 41( ,.-7. ,,._ .; t i r ...--; • ' . ",.. ';,•-' A',
r•_ r
.- - . e :. -I itr-7; ' ' (.',_ •.:C. ' ' , '''''. -'(-( ) Ler'' 4 :- -‘-'1. i •r-, ":-
Name Committee Member: Cafry 6-1(1( ro, ufz. 14-el 1
Signature: ,11",
c7 / i
of
rImr., sentember 13. 2006
'Form 113
Gary 07 imam
Department of Capital improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
%
`•.`'
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
. . BEA anti
E. Verner Johnson
Freeior✓Judson
Olson Sundberg
Pr er's Experience & Qualifications
30
'
�';
, 66
,.,
`�?
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
- ,
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
`,
,
Total Score
100
9
,
,-'
Ranking
Explanation
dCCLLIM,,li. 44
wvr+rkmv itetHisi,f
(Ike kh trogok 4
g4"
it Soc[tr.,3 �0f„i6, t,
,.,#i. 0441 o'Nlet -itbw, 40
refre Ilk ev rx y -4oie taw rye wy4
?askng
*9SgS! e/p'�ti � i�r={�,'�F'oAS
Rd nfpo
Et--4 / u' r to,06" '' "'` lisu 4 beffel-
-lit G.J(L iE a "''ft
st suSsati a4f 1'fr Not, 0t i' 41' it 49 l415k
Name of Committee Member: 3Qt 7
* p»s,
Signature:
Date: September 13, 2006
,,ctt
Form 113