HomeMy WebLinkAboutArticle-1Julia
Tuttle
imore than
acauseway
r he•first article I ever wrote
for The Herald — almost
I 10 years ago — was an
• appeal to recognize Julia Tuttle's
contribution to Miami's birth
with something more than a
causeway named in her honor.
Unfortunately, nothing has
happened. Julia Tuttle remains a
parenthetical notation on road
' maps. In practice, this pioneering
woman, the true Mother of
' Miami, is mostly known as 1-195.
In the past few years, Mary
Brickell, the woman who now is
referred to as "the other Mother
of Miami," has been honored
with a statue on Brickell Avenue.
This was a labor of love and
effort by Roads district activist
Carmen Petsoules, who battled
the odds and almost single-
: handedly raised the money.
While Mary Brickell's contri-
bution to the early days of Miami
enormous, that she now has
:been elevated to "the other
:!:•Mother of Miami" means that
Tuttle has lost ground; she
now shares her title with another,
: I 1 can present arguments as to
! why Tuttle belongs alone at the
;
top, based on her documented
and persistent entreaties to Henry
Flagler to extend his railroad
south to this area and her land
offers to him. All of that preceded
Mary Brickell's emergence. 1 am
not looking to downgrade Brick-
coI1tributions 1 am trying to
get Julia up to Mary's more -tan -
tier of local recognition.
It bothers me that there is not a
proper remembrance for
Tuttle among the bun-
--!iireds of public schools
• ,.;,in Miami -Dade County,
• ••, 'not one is named for her
(but two are named for
,,s(tting members of the
',School Board). That
!Biscayne Boulevard is
dotted with statues and
-b.usts of people — must
not from Miami — and
there is not one of Julia
Tuttle, rankles me. That
' • the only likeness of her
' 'appears on the bottom
level of the/ Brickell
HOWARD
KLEINBERG
SPECIAL
CONTRIBUTOR
While Mary Brickell's
contribution to the early
days of Miami was
enormous, that she now
has been elevated to "the
other Mother of Miami"
means that Julia Tuttle
has lost ground; she now
shares her title.
participated, but to a lesser
degree.
The initial issue of the first
newspaper ever published in
Miami — The Miami Metropolis
— on May 15, 1896, paid [his
tribute to Julia Tuttle: —A few
years hence it will be realized
that she builded [sicl better than
the critics knew, and the future
residents of Miami will accord
her full credit for her plans of
today, and bless the good fate that
put the founding of Miami in
such competent hands."
Full credit never has
come. It is long over-
due.
Tuttle died suddenly
on Sept. 14, 1898, at the
young age of 48. She
never lived to see
:Miami grow from a
small enclave alongside
the Miami River. But
she knew !that it I would,
and she gave half her
property to 'Flagler to
ensure that Miami did
have.a'future.
Over the years,
places that were named
' Bridge., whereshe shares for her disappeared to
her place in history with several progress. Even the historic
'others, is upsatisfactury. 'marker that was placed on her old
Hundreds Of streets in Miami- homesite just east of South
Dade County ihave been named Miami Avenue is gone. Julia
for poets, politicians, business Tuttle, except for that causeway
• : people, generals, law breakers, designation, has disappeared.
pioneers and strangers. None is Call this an appeal. It is the
named for Julia Tuttle. resurrection of an appeal that 1
— - She was a visionary. She saw made in 1990: That one resulted
Miami becoming a great seaport in my receiving a $5 check from
one day, and she was right. Her someone who agreed with me and
longtime relationship with Flag- wanted to start a fund.
ler, dating back to when they both Is there an organization out
jived in CleVeland, often was there that is willing to take the
,embattled, but she persisted in lead in establishing a proper
getting him to extend his railroad memorial for this woman? Like
• here. the statue of Mary Brickell in the
There are considerable files median south of the Brickell Ave-
': containing her pleading letters to nue Bridge, can't there be one as
Flagler and his responses -- well of Julia Tuttle? On a street
-enough to document that it was named Julia Tuttle Boulevard?
' ' the widow Julia Tuttle who insti- Don't we owe this woman
:• gated this town. The Brickells something?
SUBMITTED INTO THE
PUBLIC RECORD FOR
ITEM Do.' ON 2-RL/-05.
VVWW.1-IHRALU COM
LITTLE HAITI
Way clear for
gg A bronze statue of a
Haitian founding father
inched closer to reality
with a groundbreaking
ceremony in Little Haiti — a
bright spot during
troubling times for Haiti.
BY TRENTON DANIEL
tdarel@herald.com
The year of Haiti's bicen-
tennial was supposed to com-
memorate an epic revolt, but it
was marred instead by the reb-
el -fueled ouster of President
Jean -Bertrand Aristide, two
devastating floods that killed
at least 5,000, and steady vio-
lence and lawlessness that
undermines the nation's stabil-
ity.
But for at least an hour on
Saturday, the 201st anniver-
sary of Haiti's independence,
South Florida's Haitian com-
munity got the opportunity to
celebrate a modest yet sym-
bolic feat on a bright, breezy
New Year's Day: a ground-
breaking to kick off the cre-
ation of a statue honoring one
of Haiti's founding fathers,
Toussaint Louverture, who
launched a 13-year rebellion
that freed Haiti in 1804 from
its colonial ruler, France.
"We need a bright tomor-
row, because today, if you
nook] around the world, it's
very sad what we have to see.
But we have to go forward,"
Jean Olbin, onc of the project's
organizers, told his audience,
which included Miami Mayor
Manny Diaz and activists Mar-
lcine Bastien and Jean -Robert
Lafortune.
•
at
SUNDAY, JANUARY 2, 2005 I 3/3
ian founder statue
MARIANNE ARMSKAW/FOR THE HERALD
STATUE SITE: Activist Jean -Robert Lafortune talks about renovating Little Haiti's Freedom Garden on Saturday.
UPON COMPLETION
The bronze statue, sched-
uled to be unveiled on Haiti's
Flag Day, May 18, will stand
13 feet tall, and the indepen-
dence hero will hold the
nation's 1801 constitution in
his hand.
Local sculptor James Mas-
tin won a bid to design the
statue for $35,000. The money
was part of a $250,000 budget
that the city of Miami ear-
marked for the year -long fes-
tivities.
Organizers expected the
statue to be built last year, but
a lack of funds and snags in
planning put the project on
hold.
And so, a few dozen Haitian
leaders gathered on Indepen-
dence Day in the Freedom
Garden, a wedge of brownish
grass also known as Place
Kamokin, in the heart ofLittle
Haiti.
White hard hats were
donned, gold -tipped shovels
got gripped and soil was
tossed.
ATTENDING THE EVENT
"Happiness for Haiti," said
bystander Gino Holybrice, 33,
with his 2V2-year-old daughter
Nina in his arms.
Holybrice, a professional
trainer from Brooklyn in town
visiting family, was walking
home from a friend's home
when he stumbled upon the
groundbreaking.
"Something told me to stop,
and I needed her to know who
Toussaint is," Holybrice said
about his daughter. "This is
the movernent for all people,
for Miami period. We are
starting to recognize the work
'T/iis is the movement
Jor all people, fin'
land period. We
are starting to
recognize the work of
Haitian people.'
— GINO HOLYBRICE,
bystander al statue's groundbreaking
of Haitian people."
Lending gravitas to the
event was a celebrity — at
least one known among Hai-
tian moviegoers. Rudolph
"Rudy" Moise is an osteo-
pathic doctor who practices
family medicine in North
But he is also known as
"Richard Lazard" from "Wind
of Desire," a low -budget soap
opera -like movie set in Miami
mansions and on Haiti
beaches that is about an adul-
terous attorney who falls for a
troubled New York physician.
The wide-eyed fans moved
"Hi, Richard, I've seen your
movie," cooed Regina Dolcine,
13, timidly trying to hide
behind a slim tree.
Moise, who was part of the
bicentennial coordinating
committee, said Saturday's
affair was an opportunity to
mark a fresh beginning for his
turbulent country.
"We can only hope that
2005 will be a much better
year," he said.
in.
L;i1)1
,k
Ct. C
a) .52 rt
a) c
o c o •
<
— o
T3 0— —
a) c
• .u)
-`1
.0 0
0) a) a)
Respect for our histo
Submitted Into the public
record in connection with
item 5-3. i on - OS
Priscilla A. Thompson
City Clerk
The way Dr. Paul George describes what then was a circular park at
it, the defining term is indignation. He Southeast First Avenue and ThIrd
recently took his local history class to Street.
the site on today's South Miami Ave- That area was considerably reat-
nue where Miami was incorporated
on July 28, 1896,
and where Julia
Tuttle, the
"mother of
Miami," lived
beginning in 1891.
The Miami -
Dade Community
College class (16
students, mostly
adults) asked why
there are no his-
torical markers at
those sites.
His answer was
one of frustration, Their response was
one of indignation — not at George
but at the lack of private, city, county
or state commitment to Miami's his-
tory.
Out of that defining moment sev-
eral weeks ago has come "The Orange
Blossom Initiative," a group deter-
mined to reinstate historical Miami
markers — genre as yet undefined —
that have vanished and to get new
ones erected at sites where history has
been ignored. The group is also rais-
ing money for a statue of Tuttle.
This is an issue close to rne71n the
first column I wrote for this newspa-
per, on Dec. 31, 1989, I called for a
statue of Tuttle. Not just some
abstract mass of metal but a likeness
of the lady. It was she who induced
HOWARD
KLEINBERG
SPECIAL
CONTRIBUTOR
Henry Flagler — through, as the stoT--y
goes, a gift of local orange bloSS-Offis
when the rest of the state was wither-
ing in a freeze — to bring his railroad
here and, thereby, establish Mianii.
(Hence, "Orange Blossom InitiafiVe"
for this new group.)
At the forefront of this movement
is Linda Collins Hertz, a partner at the
law firm of Holland & Knight, a mem-
ber of George's class.
She is so indignant that she has
begun tracking lost markers. Among
them is a traditional stand-up marker
that was placed near Tuttle's homesite
by the Historical Association of
Southern Florida on July 25, 1952.
Surviving newspaper clippings tell
us the marker included this: "She
resided in the remodelled officer's
quarters of Old Fort Dallas 100 yards
S.E. of this spot until her death Sept.
14, 1898." The marker was placed in
ranged in 1966 when an 1-95 express-
way ramp and overpass were bat.
The Tuttle marker disappeared.
When I caught up with it in Jartna'ry
1992, it wasn't "100 yards S.E. of`this
spot" any longer. It was 500
miles away, warehoused in the Ste
archives in Tallahassee. When Lirida
Hertz caught up with it last molith,
she was told that it
had been melted
down.
Many historical
points here are
unmarked or so
remote as to be tan-
tamount to being
unmarked. That
includes markers
signifying the
indigenous civilization of the
Tequesta and of the arrival of Spanish
conquistador Pedro Menenderle
Aviles in 1567. They once were-4n
Miami's downtown Bayfront Parkbut
removed a decade or so ago. Present
reference to those historical sitesis
now along a riverwalk under, the
Brickell Avenue bridge to which
access is challenging.
Hertz assembled her ad hoc group
June 22, and out of that initial Meeting
came battle plans for leaping thratigh
the necessary bureaucratic hoops:and
soliciting funds for the Tuttle stgm.m.
To kick off general participatipAi,
Dr. George will lead a free histclical
walking tour that will coverlie
Miami -incorporation and Tuttle ings
on July 28, Miami's 104th birthday.
(For more information, call Na,dine
McConney in Hertz's office at
305-789-7459.)
Much of pioneer Miami has been
razed, the Tuttle house, which dated
back to the 1840s, William and Macy
Brickell's trading post of the 18709:and
house on the south bank of the riqei.
Should they also be forgotten?
Miami has a rich history, pie -
Columbian, Spanish colonial andlpio-
neering days of the last half of the Wth
Century. Through public energy, $uch
as that of the Orange Blossom Initia-
tive, it can be hoped that all of us:will
become more conscious and respect
ful of our historical buildings 'atid
sites.
hkmiami@aol.com
........