HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRA-R-15-0010 Submittal-Todd Jonas-Poinciana TJJAPoinciana TJJA
Monday, March 30, 2015
697 North Miami Avenue, Loft # 3-H Miami, Florida 33136-0000
Re: Design/Build firm for Town Park South RFQ No. 14-06
Submitted into the public
record in connection with
Item Z. on 3- 50-15
Todd B. Hannon
Clerk of the Board
We do not believe a fair and impartial ranking took place in evaluating our proposal
Poinciana/TJJA 350 points
HA Contracting 352 points
The rankings were not done
By secret ballot in a open form.
NO preference was given to our
minority woman owned firm as
required by the state statute.
The contrast between this and
the rest of the committee
just too great
All other members of the
committee rated us between
65% - 87% in these categories.
Selecticm Co.mminee Scaelp Shot
e.e M.m.4er
t sr, ea.*
e.>,,11
A .0.1 e11a&1i .,03,
RFC Is 06
We dispute the validity of this ranking sheet
Score C.rtaa
Caro CCoq:,
Cap
Emerald
lN1e.c11 Budd..s-Can
Po'newnei,
Prop0Ws e,oaence
And pec..a.lme
20 0,...,
P0006l1, Teem
Peesaeeee=men.
Imo. 15D. )
Z0
aG
..0
U
D
16
---
to
o---
it.)
/'J
l �7
Expem. oPmgea
Mm.en lm.r e 10 pobt
T
1 0
l v )/)
D
P1ru.eoe
De, M ml
Pmte s (ems. ,0 ppm.
S
S
5
Occaparn Romano.
APP... aro E
aneae mu. e5
0
.S.
/�
max n pomtst
o
I°
l0
0
/0
Lowe. .61 15 pomeN
10
G
3
IS
S
Oons, 5 es,me.
5
5
S
�edScan O.,eo)
44
G94
73
.35
46
We received an average of 13 points from all other members(Max 20 points)
All other submittals rated at the highest possible points-
- Working Bro Bono with TPS for over 10 years. PDG/TJJA
- Prepared the original estimates for all the Town Park projects TJJA
- Top 100 Architects in Florida. TJJA
- TJJA was awarded 2015 City National Bank Better Miami Beach Awards
- PDG built Sugar Hill (132 unit) Apts for the Urban League of Miami
- PDG built Opa Locka City hall for Miami Dade county
-PDG completed work Town Park Village, Edison Tower Apartments
Technical Capabilities: We received an average of 8.75 points from all other members (max 10 points)
Estimating: TJJA Prepared All the estimates that this project is based upon
Sustainability: TJJA prepared the original sustainability criteria for this project
Value Engineer: TJJA Is Technically certified in by Miami -Dade county
Quality Control:TJJA/PDG submitted a quality control plan in the submission
We have been in this business for over 30 years
We received an average of 8.5 points from all other members
(Max 10 points)
Ms Forest is a minority General Contractor since 1993
Mr Jonas is a licensed architect 1978, a licensed General
contractor for 15 yrs.
TJJA is technically certified by Miami -Dade county
Construction Management
We do not claim to be perfect in everything, but on the other hand, we are not unqualified or incapable either.
15-0O335- Subrni f ta I - I O d d Jo n oc s - lhi n dana TJJA - g F- . 14 - Ur