HomeMy WebLinkAboutCRA-R-05-0015 Submittalov
One Voice, LLG 1730 Biscayne Boulevard, Suite 201-P, Miami, FL 33132 (305)577-3525
Community& Faith -Based
Partnerships
Sheldon Oak Central, Inc.
Non -Profit
New Washington Heights
CDC
Mt. Zion
CDC
St. John
CDC
Contractors Resource
Center, Inc.
Non -Profit
OV Members
Ted Lyons
Elsie K. Hailer
Marvin Seidman
James Burke
Irby McKnight
Daniel Merida
Jose Perez de Corcho
February 25, 2005
Ms. Priscilla A. Thompson
City Clerk
City of Miami
Miami, Florida
Dear Ms. Thompson:
We are asking for your support of our proposal (CEUONE VOICE) on Block 36.
Your decision will not only affect the Overtown community for decades to
come, but will also uphold a reputation that can withstand public scrutiny.
Please be responsible in your selection by choosing the proposer who has the
financial capability, the experience, unprecedented community inclusion, the
ability to preserve the historic "colored town', and the where -with -all to begin
immediately.
We can work together for the City and Overtown.
Sincerely,
Elsie K. Hamler
Member - Manager
Enclosure: News Articles
Mayor Manny Diaz, City of Miami
cc: City Manager Joe Arriola
Mr. Fank Rollason, CRA Director
(70
A _°act
Yahoo! Mail - gradymuhamma-" ahoo.com
Page 1 of 2
oOY. MAIL
Date: Fri, 25 Feb 2005 13:38:28 -0800 (PST)
From: "grady muhammad" <gradymuhammad@yahoo.com>
Subject: Qustions regarding Block 36 recommendations
To: frollason@ci.miami.fl.us
Print - Close Window
CC jwinton@ci.miami.fl.us, law@ci.miami.fl.us, mannydiaz@ci.miami.fl.us, jarriola@ci.miami.fl.us,
jlallen@ci.miami.fl.us, jsanchez@ci.miami.fl.us, tr@ci.miami.fl.us
February 24, 2005
Mr. Frank Rollason
Executive Director
City of Miami's CRA
49 NW 5th Street
Miami, FL 33128
RE: Recommendation on Block 36.
Dear Mr. Frank:
As the Chairman of the Comittee to Stop the Abolishment of Historic Overtown. The Committee does
not support any speific proposals for Block 36.
The Committee will support "ANY" proposal that hs met the established critireia of the CRA"s RFP for
Block 36.
• assiting the Historical Residents of Overtown with affordable housing.
• help the Longshoremen and the Lyric Theater with their parking requirements.
• has the financail committment to fund and complete this project.
• has a track record of successfully doing projects similar to this elsewhere.
• who development team has clearly defined ownership, princiapls or partners.
As Chairman of the Committee, Last Wednesday, I met with Mr. John Hall and Dr. Dorothy Fields of the
"Lyric Promenade" a mixed -use project proposed for Block 36.
I have also spoken with other proposers about their project as well.
I still have questions concerning the Lyric Promenade.
1. Where are the financials and acommittment letter of particpation form the Carlise Group?
2. Who are the real owners of the Overtown ForkLife Village Developmnet Corp., because as of the
writing of this email that company lists only a Lynn C. Washington as the Registered Agent and it
was only Incorpaorated on August 12, 2004.
3. Thier propoasl was submitted by the Overtown ForkLife Village Development Corp. which is a
SHELL, Corp. with no Directors, Presidents or Officiers and not the Black Archives.
Frank if you have any questions please feel free to contact me at 786-285-1133 or via email.
http://us.f501.mail.yahoo.com/ym/ShowLetter?box=Sent&MsgId=7508_10216547 41274... 2/28/2005
Yahoo! Mail - gradymuhammad@yahoo.com Page 2 of 2
Sincerely,
Grady Muhammad,Chairman
Committee to Stop the Abolishment of Historic Overtown.
Do you Yahoo!?
Take Yahoo! Mail with you! Get it on your mobile phone.
Will City "Do The Right Thing?'7,
CRA to decide on Overtown
proposals next week.
The clock has ticked down to the deadline for CRA Executive Director Frank Rollason to make his rec-
ommendation on redeveloping Block 36 in the heart of Overtown. Community residents and organizations are
waiting to act on the direction city officials will take to develop Overtown. Whether community people who
live and work in Overtown will be left out again on Overtown development has been a constant concern at com-
munity meetings -Although City Corrimissioners have spoken against "poverty pimps" and stated their desire
to do the right thing at recent CEA and Commission meetings, Black experiences in beingleft out of
opment decisions have them closely watching the City's action's..
. Although "affordability" of housing for residents and a transparent process have been the central com-
plaints voiced at community meetings, the six proposals submitted to the CRA on Block 36 are not encour-
aging, although one stands out.
One proposal presented by a coalition of Overtown community organizations, called "ONE VOICE,
L.Ilirt," has presented a financially sound and community involved redevelopment plan. A study of all the pro-
posals resulted in a matrix diagram that showed that the ONE VOICE plan focused on housing that is afford-
able at much below the $150,000-$350,000 costs of the other proposals. By a written agreement with the devel-
oper, ONE VOICE, has secured a continuous return of income to the Overtown community from the devel-
opments and a partnership in the major decisions made during the development years.
Jackie Bell, New Washington Heights CDC president, recalled past promises. Bell remembered,
"Promises have been made to the Black Community from as far back as when 1-95 was being built.
Government used eminent domain to take the' land to develop for doymtownis needs and then built 1-95
through the heart of Overtown."
Elsie Hamler, CEO of the Contractors Resource Center, Inc.,
assured that "We [ONE VOICE], are anxious for this decision, but we are
ready and able to begin the development activities within 180 days after
receiving the cityfs approval Our anxiety is based upon past decisions
where government made political deals that gave such developments to a
group that could not deliver, then recaptured the project and gave it to a
nos zornmunity developer."
Hamler also stated that the ONE VOICE proposal not only builds
affordable housing, but also provides for the historical and cultural devel-
opments envisioned by the Lyric Theater and Folk Life Village con-
cepts. "We will not have to endanger our communityis history, culture
or present needs because we have the financial ability to start now,"
Hamler declared.
118 MIAMI N EWTI M ES FEBRUARY 24 - MARCH 2, 2 005 mlamlnewtImes.com
A 110
• H .,!!)
0 SUOZ
_ °
-11
0"' o
n
5 -1 O
co a
.- 0
O
CD
m CD
b
oa
4n
iv
0.
2 0 rA a c° s' WhliIII
A'
O - 7C< o cn n � O P w 000
°cp4�5<o: "W,-i-0"g0 a'o
O y °,°a `�� n 0 n n o
crw r cmyO WN a,tium ..-
co
coo o .b 5 M = y�y 0.0 c0i F fop O
R a' N lA .'... W E f.``_]pi O C Qa
ag
3 b n ,A-) - iol R.5 Q' f, n 47 ° 0
O
1
0c/D.
v
E-"D
CD
F—�
O
O
Overtown coalition secures
local group to save them
By Gigi Tinsley
g tinsiey@mtamitimesonlne.com
A group of Overtown commu-
nity -based organizations and
businesses met, recently. to
respond to the City of
Miami's bid to redevel-
op the core of the
Overtown area. The
project. known as Block
36, is located across
the N.W. 8 Street area,
north of the
Crosswinds develop-
ment protect.
The coalition named
themselves, "ONE
VOICE" and include the
St. John, Mt. Zion. and
New Washington
Heights Community
Development
Corporations (CDCs), and the
Contractor's Resource Center
(CRC). as well as, co -venturer
CEI, a Connecticut based devel-
opment giant that specializes in
developing affordable housing
and economic services for sever-
al years.
"The CRC, by our written co-
HAMLER
venture agreement, will ensure
that the level of small and Black
contractors participation in the
project is maadmizek" said Elsie
Hamler, president of the
Contractors Resource Center.
"This proposal is not only the
most financially
sound but it is the
best for the present
residents' employ-
ment and housing."
CEI and its non-
profit affiliate.
Sheldon Oaks. are
nationally recognized
for their successful
track record in
affordable housing
projects. danny
Merida, Sheldon
Oaks executive, stat-
ed "The CEI team
presents an impres-
sive portfolio and has already
obtained a 6187 mlllion dollar
commitment letter from its
financial lenders which proves a
strong commitment tot he
Overtown community."
Mt. Zion CDC released a study
of the proposals which show
Please turn to OVERTOWN 8B
IA I MONDAY FEBRUARY 28, 2005
IN S Kl 6Hi ,1394 _^.,i}
OPINI
NjFp281-'11 ` : 04
THE HERALD
- - ALBERTO IBARGI;EN, PUBLISHER i TOM FIEDLER, EXECUTIVE EDITOR ! JOE OGLESBY, EDITOR!¢F.P GEEDITOR MES L KNIGHT 19f.9 's79it
I
CTY...
THE READERS' FORUM I www.herald.com (dick on Opinion)
Poor in boondocks?
Re the Urban Development
Boundary debate: Although I
live about as far from the area
in question but still in Miami -
Dade County, I am as inter-
ested in the solution to this
problem — not only because
of the impact on the Ever-
glades, which is undeniably
important, but because
"affordable housing" in this
area is impractical
Most of the employment
opportunities for people who
need affordable housing are
not in the boondocks but in or
near the center of the city.
Since public transportation
will be the last thing to arrive
in that area, affordable hous-
ing near the Everglades will
serve no purpose.
With traffic the way it is,
middle- and low-income fami-
lies need decent housing in
areas where public transit is
available. There must be a
solution that will allow low-in-
come residents to lead_ pro-
ductive lives in an area where
the jobs are and at the same
time save that portion of the
Everglades, which the builders
now seek to invade.
- ELAINE KAPLAN, Miami Gardens
Romance not for TV
Re Leonard Pitts Jr.'s Feb.
21 column, Twisted tale is any-
thing but a love story: The so-
called "romance" between
Mary Kay Letourneau and her
former student should make
any sane person shudder. Add-
ing insult to injury, book pub-
lishers and TV producers are
hot on their trail and consider-
ing televising the big event, a
wedding that neither the bride
nor the groom, both unem-
ployed, can afford.
To what depths have the
media sunk? Do we now
appeal to the lowest and most
prurient level to entertain the
American public?
- PHYLLIS LENSKY, Aventura
file, 06M
A crucial Overtown decision
Whether Miami will have a transparent process to rede=
velop the Overtown community or revert to discredited
"secret dealing" will be determined at today's Community
Re_ development Agency meeting..
The deadline for proposals ended last summer, at which
time they were to have been evaluated. However, evidence
is mounting:that.-the city is being asked to -allow illegal
financial addition's:for favored proposers.
• . The request.
for proposals, andthe city-fmanced1982.
and 2004 South East Overtown park West Redevelopment
Plans clearly outline -the processes and principles that
must guide Overtown development: The major consider-
ations are affordability of housing and improvement of the
quality of life for current residents. All responders were
asked to state their ability to finance their proposals.
The Contractors Resource Center and its partners —
ONE VOICE/CEI — presented one of two proposals that
met all of the criteria. The other is the Crosswinds pro-
posaL However,'only the ONE VOICE/CEI proposal has
community -based organizations with written agreements
to make decisions.and assures that community stakehold-
ers will share in the proceeds of successful redevelopment
for years to come... -
•
As recent events have shown, just because a project has
a black face does not assure that the black community will
share in the financial benefits of development. The City
Commission/CRA decision today will determine whether
Overtown's future will be a successful community devel-
opment or end with signs that remind people, of what
Overtown was in its heyday.
If the .process.is transparent and fair, the city
Overtown communi
ty will both win.
-ELSIE K. MANUA dtrecta,tRCjONE VOICE
•Editor's note:-The.CRApublic meeting takes place at 5
p.m. today in the Conference Center at the Technology
Center of the Americas, 40 NE Ninth St.
Police lauded
On Feb. 1, we were affected
by a main gas -line rupture in
front of our hotel The rupture
sounded like a jet engine. The
immediate response by the
Miami -Dade Police Depart-
ment's airport station was
unbelievable.
We called 911 and barely
had hung up the phone when
the first units arrived to secure
the area. The response of the
Miami -Dade Fire Department
was exceptional. It truly
shows what bravery these men
and women have when they
strap on their gear and
approach a gas -line rupture of
this magnitude.
Everyone takes these pro-
fessionals for granted until
there's a situation like this, and
then you truly see the dedica-
tion these people have for the
safety of their community.
Miami is fortunate to have
such a great group of people
protecting us.
- SELIM SOLIMAN, general manager,
Wyndham Miami Airport Hotel, Miami
Sick kids can't learn
Re the Feb. 23 article Pull-
ing the plug on school clinics:
As a registered nurse and the
PTSA president of Nautilus
Middle School, I know the
value of our school clinics.
One only has to visit our clinic
to see how many students
receive primary care, immuni-
zations and first aid.
The public should send a
strong message to the Florida
Legislature, county govern-
ment and our school system
that healthcare in our schools
should be a priority. Indeed,
how can sick children learn?
- KAREN RIVO, Miami Beach
Investing at birth
Re the Feb. 23 article Retire-
ment plan sees million -dollar
babies: Former Treasury Sec-
retary Paul O'Neill's retire-
ment plan is something to be
considered as an addition to
the current system. It would
ensure that we would con-
tinue to have a safety net and
that all Americans retiring 65
years from now would have
that extra million to buy
another SUV.
- ANTONIO CAVACO, Coral Gables
No fences mended
The Feb. 24 article Bush
mends fences, tests allies was
quick to proclaim the presi-
dent's visit to Europe a suc-
cess. His actions tell a differ-
ent story. Instead of visiting
Jacques Chirac in Paris and
Gerhard Schroeder in Berlin,
Bush asks them to come to see
him in cities like Mainz, which
are conveniently located near
American air bases.
The message of these
actions is crystal clear: Bush
doesn't care to mend fences.
Rather: he puts some of the
most important European
leaders in their place — subor-
dinate to him.
-tllDICTnc roc ucn