HomeMy WebLinkAboutSubmittal-District 5 OfficeAlexander, Koteles
From: Ed Griffith [EdGriffith@MiamiSAO.com]
Sent: Thursday, January 13, 2011 12:03 PM
To: Alexander, Koteles
Subject: RE: Public Information Request
Attachments: Police Department Police Shooting Investigations 2010 City of Miami.doc
As you have requested, attached is the latest report we have compiled regarding the status of 2010's City of Miami
police department's shooting investigations. This report, which gives an example of the numerous possible items
needed to complete an investigation, also specifies exactly what case(s) may be complete and what case(s) lack
important necessary items. Other "preliminary" reports which may predate this document may lack some specific detail
which this document was intended to remedy.
From: Alexander, Koteles [mailto:KAlexander@miamigov.com]
Sent: Thursday, January 13, 2011 10:50 AM
To: Ed Griffith
Subject: Public Information Request
The Commissioner Richard P. Dunn, III would like to make a public information request of any documents indicating the
status, as of today, of the city of Miami police department's shooting investigations for 2010. We would appreciate
your assistance as soon as possible. Thanks you in advance.
} ^� ED INTO
,��,IC RECORD
_ 7- . ns. i ON7)"
1
to- 0000t - Subl r fa,l-1;sfr► ct 5 Office
2010 - City of Miami Police Department Police Shooting
Investigations
Compiled as of 1/11/2011
1. Victim: Emmanuel Fluker
Date of Incident: 4/15/10
Officer: Refuse Luddwidge (01-28575)
ASAs: Susan Dannelly & Isis Perez
We presently lack:
• the police investigative file from the Homicide Bureau
2. Victim: Ulysses Hathway Bodie
Date of Incident: 4/18/10
Officer: Erica Carter (01-28564)
ASAs: John Perikles & Phil Maniatty
We presently lack:
• Police reports
• 911 tapes
• Crime scene photos
• Fingerprint comparisons
• Medical Examiner Reports
3. Victim: DeCarlos Moore
Date of Incident: 7/5/
Officer: Joseph Marin (01-40039)
ASAs: Frank Ledee & Charlie Johnson
We presently lack:
• the original OIR's
• any additional police reports / 301 reports or supplemental
police reports generated by the other homicide detectives on scene,
• 911 communications
• crime scene or arial photographs
• vehicle storage reports
• crime scene reports generated by the other on -scene CSI's
• property receipts
• finger print reports
• laboratory analysis requests
• laboratory analysis reports
• firearm NIBIN reports (a Federal Alcohol Tobacco &
Firearms report)
• medical examiners reports and photographs
1
Submitted into the public
record in connection with
items D5.1 on 01-13-11
Priscilla A. Thompson
City Clerk
4. Victim: Joel Johnson — COMPLETE FILE
Date of Incident: 8/ 11 /
Officer: Ricardo Martinez (01-4441)
ASAs: Abbe Rifkin & Colleen Kay
We presently lack: Nothing
• our file was received in late November. Our 90 day goal to
complete review is in late Feb. 2011
5. Victim: Gibson Belizaire
Date of Incident: 8/14/10
Officers: Andre Mathis (01-4451) & co-defendant is &
Jason Clifford (01-1103)
ASAs: Abbe Rifkin & Colleen Kay
• our file was received in mid December 2010 & our 90 day goal
to close is in March 2011
We presently lack:
• lab blood results
6. Victim: Tarnorris Gaye
Date of Incident: 8/20/10
Officer: Ricardo Martinez (01-4441) & US Customs Agent
Maikel Guinard
ASAs: Dawn Denaro & William Altfield
We presently lack:
• the police investigative file from the Homicide Bureau
7. Victim: Lynn Weatherspoon
Date of Incident: 1/1/11
Officer Soldre
ASAs: Michael Von Zamft & Gary Winston
We presently lack:
• we have not have a complete investigative file
2
Submitted into the public
record in connection with
items D5.1 on 01-13-11
Priscilla A. Thompson
City Clerk
Example List Of Potentially Necessary Investigative Materials Relating To
Police Department Shooting Investigation
While every police shooting investigation undertaken by the Miami -Dade State Attorney's
Office has its own list of specific investigative items that may pertain only to that incident, this
list may give a "generalized picture" of the informational needs necessary to make a proper legal
determination.
1. Daily police shooting report.
2. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
3. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
4. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
5. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
6. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
7. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
8. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
9. The transcribed sworn statement of Witness
#1 & accompanying CD.
#2 & accompanying CD.
#3 & accompanying CD.
#4 & accompanying CD.
#5 & accompanying CD.
#6 & accompanying CD.
#7.
#8.
10. The transcribed sworn statement of Officer #1.
11. The transcribed sworn statement of Officer #2.
12. Daily police staffing "P-sheet"
13. Copy of a photograph of the shooting officer.
14. 3 photocopies of single photographs of victim's wound.
15. Copy of victim's driver's license summary.
16. Copy of victim's booking mugshot profile.
17. Victim's criminal history.
18. Shift log for Officer #1.
19. Transcript of radio transmission.
20. Crime scene report from CSI Technician #1.
21. Crime scene sketch.
22. Power point summary of the case.
23. the original OIRs (Officer Incident Reports), which are reports generated by line
officers or detectives who have had a lesser role in the actual
24. any additional police reports 1301 reports or supplemental police reports generated by
the other homicide detectives on scene,
25. 911 communications
26. crime scene or arial photographs
27. vehicle storage reports
28. crime scene reports generated by the other on -scene CSI's
29. property receipts
30. finger print reports
31. laboratory analysis requests
32. laboratory analysis reports
3
Submitted into the public
record in connection with
items D5.1 on 01-13-11
Priscilla A. Thompson
City Clerk