HomeMy WebLinkAboutCompositeRFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Pre -Qualification Testing
COMPOSITE
SELECTIONN PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
\\\
Maximum
Points
Per
Member
Maximum -
Total Points
0-members)
•inc.
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
LLC
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
The Bode
TechnologyInc.
Human
Identification
Technologies,
Orchid Cellmark
Inc.
Florida
Forensics
DNA Security,
Inc.
DNA Labs
International
Commonwealth
Biotechnoligies,
dim Fairfax
Identity
Laboratories
Proposer's experience, qualifications, and
past performance related to providing the
type of services requested in this
Solicitation, including project managers
experience.
40
200
132
156
173
72
144
74
101
119
106
Proposer's approach to providing the
services requested in this Solicitation
(including the results of the qualification
testing if applicable, refer to Section 4.3.b).
40
200
148
172
165
66
157
72
103
94
98
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
400 '
- . 280.00
.328.00 ;
338.00 '
138.00
301.00
146.00
204.00
213.00
204.00
Total Price Points
20
100
59.00
73.00.
81.00
35.00
31.00
80.00
90.00
69.00
73.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
500
339
401
419
173
332
!
226
294
282
277,
Signature:��
Cna+
C
r
Reviewed By /
DATE
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Pre -Qualification Testing
STEPHANIE STOILOFF (MDPD)
SELECTION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
LL.C.
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
Human
Identification
Technologies,
Inc
Orchid Gel'mark
Inc.
Florida
Forensics
DNA Security,
Inc.
DNA Labs
International
Commonwealth
Biotechnoligies,
Inc. dba Fairfax
Identity
Laboratories
Proposer's experience, qualifications,
and past performance related to
providing the type of services
requested in this Solicitation, including
project manager's experience.
40 .
35
33
38
16
25
16
16
24
16
Proposer's approach to providing the
services requested in this Solicitation
(including the results of the
qualification testing if applicable, refer
to Section 4.3.b).
40
38
40
40
9
40
9
25
10
20
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
73
73 "
. .
78
25
65
25
' 41
34
36
Total Price Points
20
15.00
'
15.00
20.00
`
5.00
5.00
10.00
15.00
10.00
5.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100 :
. "
' 88.00
88.00
98.00
:
30.00
70.00
35.00
56.00
44.00
41.00
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Pre -Qualification Testing
MICHAEL A. HASS (MDPD)
SELECTION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum:
Points -•
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
Human
Identification
Technologies,
Inc.Identity
Orchid Cellmark
Inc.
Florida
Forensics
DNA Security,
Inc.
DNA Labs
International
commonwealth
Biotechnoligies,
Inc. dba Fairfax
Laboratories
15
Proposer's experience, qualifications,
and past performance related to
providing the type of services
requested in this Solicitation, including
project manager's experience.
40 -
30
36
40
10
49
10
15
25
Proposer's approach to providing the
services requested in this Solicitation
(including the results of the
qualification testing if applicable, refer
to Section 4.3.b).
40
36
40
36
10
36
20
20
26
15
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
66
76
76
20 ~
76 "
30
35
51.
30
Total Price Points
20"
1bA0
15.00
17.00'
1.00
1.00
19.00
20.00
17.00
18.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
76.00
91.00
93.00 `
21.00
77.00
49.00
' 55.00
68.00
48.00
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Pre -Qualification Testing
WILMO ANDOLLO (ME)
SELECTION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum'Sorenson
Points .'
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Genomics, LLC
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
Human
Identification
Technologies,
Inc
Orchid Cellmark
Inc.
Florida
Forensics
DNA Security,
Inc.
DNA Labs
International
Commonwealth
Biotechnolig tes,
Inc. dba Fairfax
Identity
I abnrunries
25
Proposer's experience, qualifications,
and past performance related to
providing the type of services
requested in this Solicitation, including
project manager's experience.
40
24
28
28
12
28
12
25
25
Proposers approach to providing the
services requested in this Solicitation
(including the results of the
qualification testing if applicable, refer
to Section 4.3.b).
•40 :` ,'
20
30
28
15
28
15
20
20
20
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
44
58
56
27
56.
27 -
45
45
45
Total Price Points
20
13.00
15.00
15.00
12.00
10.00
15.00
17.00
15.00
15.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
57.00
73.00
71.00.
39.00
66.00
42.00
62.00
60.00
60.00
2/6r2003
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Pre -Qualification Testing
MICHAEL EDWARDS (HRD)
SELECTION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
'''
Maximum
Points -
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Sorenson
Genomirs,
LLC
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
Human
Identification
Technologies,
Inc
Orchid Ceilmark
Inc.
Florida
Forensics
DNA Security,
Inc.
DNA Labs
International
Commonwealth
Biotechnoligies,
Inc. dba Fairfax
Identity
L ahoratories
26
Proposers experience, qualifications,
and past performance related to
providing the type of services
requested in this Solicitation, including
project manager's experience.
40
23
24
30
16
23
16
23
24
Proposer's approach to providing the
services requested in this Solicitation
(including the results of the
qualification testing if applicable, refer
to Section 4.3.b).
40
30
30
26
16
20
16
20
24
23
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
53
54 =
56
32
43
32
43
48
49
Total Price Points
20
10.00
15.00
15.00
10.00
10.00
20.00
20.00
15.00
20.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
63.00
69.00
71.00.
42.00
53.00
52.00
63.00
63.00
69.00
?l82008
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Pre -Qualification Testing
JAMES VOSE (DBD)
SELECTION PROPOSERS
CRITERIA
Maximum
Points
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Sorenson
Genomics, LLG
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
Human
identification
Technologies,
Inc.
Orchid Ceilmark
Inc.
Florida
Forensics
DNA Security,
Inc.
DNA tabs
International
Commonwealth
B1Otechnoligies,
Inc. dba Fairfax
Identity
Laboratories
24
Proposers experience, qualifications,
and past performance related to
providing the type of services
requested in this Solicitation, including
project manager's experience.
40
20
35
37
18
28
20
22
21
Proposer's approach to providing the
services requested in this Solicitation
(including the results of the
qualification testing if applicable, refer
to Section 4.3.b).
40
24
32
35
16
33
12
18
14
20
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
44
67
72
34
61
32
40
35
44
Total Price Points
20
11.00
13.00
14.00
7.00
5.00
16.00
18.00
12.00
15.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
55.00
80.00 `
86.00
41.00
66.00
48.00
58.00
47.00
59.00
L&ZCO8
.ECTION
TER)A
PROPOSERS
poser's experience, qualifications, and
t performance related to providing the
e of services requested in this
'citation, including project manager's
erience.
poser's approach to providing the
vices requested in this Solicitation
:luding the results of the qualification
ting if applicable, refer to Section 4.3.b).
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
Total Price Points
nature:
31
✓iewed By
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Post Qualification Testing
COMPOSITE
Maximum Ma
PotntS xitnmii Strand Analytical Per. -Total Points Laboratories, Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
Lmembers) L.L.C.
Member .
0 400 179.00 248.00
0 100 59.00 73.00
100
Orchid
Cellmark Inc.
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Post Qualification Testing
STEPHANIE STOILOFF (MDPD)
ECTION PROPOSERS
FERIA
Maximum
Points?
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
Orchid
Celimaric Inc.
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
loser's experience, qualifications,
past performance related to
iding the type of services
ested in this Solicitation, including
?ct manager's experience.
loser's approach to providing the
ices requested in this Solicitation
uding the results of the
ification testing if applicable, refer
action 4.3.b).
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
Total Price Points
35
9
44
33
17
50
25
32
57
38
35
73
20
15.00
15.00
5.00
20.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
59.00
65.00
62.00
93.00
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Post Qualification Testing
MICHAEL A. HASS (MDPD)
:CTION \PROPOSERS
ERIA Maximum
Points'
user's experience, qualifications,
past performance related to
ding the type of services
sted in this Solicitation, including
ct manager's experience.
oser's approach to providing the
ces requested in this Solicitation
iding the results of the
fication testing if applicable, refer
action 4.3.b).
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
40
80`;.
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Total Price Points 20 " 10.
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
5.
Orchid
Cellmark Inc.
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
100 49.00 67.00 75.00 93.00
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Post Qualification Testing
WILMO ANDOLLO (ME)
:CTION PROPOSERS
ERIA
Maximum
Points ``
Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
Orchid
eelImark Inc.
The Bode
Technology
Group, Inc.
aser's experience, qualifications,
last performance related to
ding the type of services
>sted in this Solicitation, including
ct manager's experience.
40
24
28
28
28
user's approach to providing the
ces requested in this Solicitation
(ding the results of the
Fcation testing if applicable, refer
ction 4.3.b).
40.
5
15
24
24
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
29 `.
43
52
52
Total Price Points
20
13.00
15.00
10.00
15.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
42.00
58.00
62.00
67.00
28r2008
RFP NO.8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Post Qualification Testing
MICHAEL EDWARDS (HRD)
ECTION PROPOSERS
FERIA
Maximum
Points `
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.G.
Sorenson
Genomics,
LLC
Orchid
Gettmark Inc.
The Bade
Technology
Group, Inc.
loser's experience, qualifications,
past performance related to
iding the type of services
ested in this Solicitation, including
act manager's experience.
40
23
24
23
30
wser's approach to providing the
ices requested in this Solicitation
uding the results of the
ification testing if applicable, refer
ection 4.3.b}..01•11011.1111111111111
40
8
20
32
38
Total Technical Paints
(Total of Technical rows above)
11!
80.
31'
44
55
68
Total Price Points
20
10.00
15.00 <
10.00
15.00
TOTAL POINTS
(Technical + Price)
100
41.00
59.00.
65.00
83.00
RFP NO. 8514
FORENSIC CASEWORK FOR DNA ANALYSES
EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
Post Qualification Testing
JAMES VOSE (DBD)
CTION PROPOSERS
_RIA
Maximum
Points
Strand Analytical
Laboratories,
L.L.C.
Sorenson
Genomics, LLC
Orchid
Celimark inc.
The Bode
Technology
Group, inc.
sees experience, qualifications,
ast performance related to
ling the type of services
sted in this Solicitation, including
;t manager's experience.
40
20
35
28
37
sers approach to providing the
,es requested in this Solicitation
ding the results of the
ication testing if applicable, refer
lion 4.3.b).
40
16
24
33
35
Total Technical Points
(Total of technical rows above)
80
36
59
61
72
Total Price Points
20
11.00
13.00
5.00
14.00
TOTAL POINTS
(echnical + Price)
100
47.00
72.00 -
66.00
86.00
vsrzws