HomeMy WebLinkAboutSummary SheetRFP # 50031
Group Health Benefits for Part-time and Temporary Personnel
Summary Sheet
Evaluation Committee Meeting
Day / Date
FINAL TABULATION RESULTS BY CONSENSUS
FIRM PROPOSED
Bettie H. Scott Santiago G.
Thompson Simpson Ly,on:J.D.
w IN -AN
.... (.!N.......,
INA t(4.641'
Sum Total
Ranking
. Ilf.Z.
4,
Il' 't!roa!-1:41A,,,,t.
.,,
CIGNA
1 ,
CI r ct
t i)
0 \
cle) k,4
)
LgPill)
Brown & Brown
95 C31
(.1.)
.....S COz-
OptiMed Heallh Plans
, ./
S40
1 ricc)
44
CZ.Q,),.,
,f.— .ii- 1 .-)
),, l., v.
r) c-70)
f,-, -
F)141.1 4.".7
?--)
TOTAL
Approved Committee Members:
Bettie H. Thompson, Assoc. Vice Provost, M-0
College
Scott Simpson, Chief Financial Officer, Miami
Parking Authority
Santiago G. Leon, J.D., ACC Hall International, Inc.
LeeAnn Brehm, Director, Risk Mgmt
Magaly Gonzalez, Assistant Director, Risk Mgmt
Alternate: Denise Morales, Benefits Coord., Risk
Mgmt
Approved By:
Request For Letters of Interest for Group Health Benefits for
Part•time and Temporary Personnel
Evaluation Date: Thursday, Ma 1, 2008 at 10:00AM
Evaluated by (Print Name): 991
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Overall Qualifications and Experience
Proposed Plan(s), Network and EMptoyeeCost(s)';
Proposer's Ability & Capability to Perform Required Services
— Local Preference, if applicable
Live Presentation, if applic;abfe
Evaluator's Signature:
REP NO. 50031
Date:
MAX
ASSIGN,
POINTS
Brown & Brown OComments
Request For Letters of interest for Group Health Benefits for
Part-time and Temporary Personnel
Evaluation Date: Thursday, May 1, 2008 at 10:OOAM
Evacuated by (Print Name):
EVALUATION CRITERIA
RFP NO. 50031
Date: 'S.- 'Ic•oti
MAX
I ASSIGN,
POINTS CIGNA Brown & Brown OptiMed Health Plans
.arur e...s,s,.
Overall Qualifications and Experience 25
Proposed Plan(s), Network and Employee Cost(s) 50
Proposer's Ability & Capability to Perform Required Services 20
Local Preference., if applicable 5
Live Presentation, if applicable 10
TOTAL POINTS
Evaluator's Signature:
110
4+
Comments
Request For Letters of Interest for Group Health Benefits for
Part time and Temporary Personnel
Evaluation Date: Thursday, Mayy�/9't/ / 1, 2�0088�at 10:OOOAM
./ Evaluated by (Print Name): 74-4t�
EVALUATION CRITERIA
RFP NO. 50031J,
Date: 5/ ' 7ZT/(/�
__..._�.._ MAX
ASSIGN.
POINTS CIGNA Brown & Brown
Overall Qualifications and Experience
Proposed Plan(s), Network and Employee Cost(s)
Proposer's Ability & Capability to Perform Required Services
Local Preference, if applicable
Live Presentation, if applicable
TOTAL POINT
Evaluator's Signature:
25
50
20
5
10
O.tiMed Health Plans
Comments
Request For Letters of interest for Group Health Benefits for
Part-time and Temporary Personnel
Evaluation Date: Thursday, May 1, 2008 alt 10:OOAM
Evaluated by (Print Name): [e/?'i' 7AeS(,,�l ite:
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Overall Qualifications and Experience
Proposed Plan(s), Network and Employee Cost(s)
Proposer's Ability & Capability to Perform Required Services
Local Preference, if applicable
Live Presentation, if applicable
Evaluator's Sig
ASSIGN.
POINTS
L POINTS j 110
RFP NO. 50031
di id te
CIGNA
Brown & Brown
O.tiMed Health Plans
Comments
Request For Letters of Interest for Group Health Benefits for
Part-time and Temporary Personnel
Evaluation Date: Thursday, May 1, 2008 at 0:00A(���..,,, t� ']
Evaluated by (Print Name): I { I nfl �1�rlv�:r 7 )'-`bate:
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Overall Qualifications and Experience
Proposed Plan(s), Network and Employee Cosl(s)
Proposer's Ability & Capability to Perform Required Services
Local Preference, if applicable
Live Presentation, if applicable
TOTAL POINTS
Evaluator's Signature
MAX
ASSIGN.
POINTS
25
50
20
5
10
110
RFP NO. 50031
30' 0 8
CIGNA
Brown 8 Brown
O . tiMed Health Plans
Comments