The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutSubmittal-Application for Special Exceptionpow CLUB INVESTMENT INC. d/b/a VISIONS/ APPLE MARTINIS 3015 GRAND AVENUE #320 AND #410 MIAMI, FL 33133 CITY OF MIAMI HEARING BOARDS FILE NO.: 07-00796x APPLICATION FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION NOL I'jjjj _ 210j ael0Oal onend Hi OINI OJ1iIVflS 07- 0o7aev- submittal_ eppRcatan for SFrcb.i Excepton TABLE OF CONTENTS EXHIBIT A REST ME OF PRINCIPAL OWNER EXHIBIT B PICTURES OF THE OUTSIDE EXHIBIT C NOISE STUDY EXHIBIT D RESOLUTION FOR PREDECESSOR IN SAME SPACE (BANANA JOE'S/ MARGARITA MOMMAS ) EXHIBIT E RESOLUTION FOR COYOTE UGLY (IN COCOWALK) SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEMPz u,ON oi-zy-os. EXHIBIT A SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEM Z( ONo2q. 41 Shore Drive North Coconut Grove, FI 33133 (305) 461-1118 (305) 972-8842 (305) 858-8552 sshahnazi@comcast.net Shawn Shahnazi Shawn Shahnazi has over 22 years of experience in the Restaurant and Hospitality Industry. Having started from ground zero as a busboy in Monty's Raw Bar, when he arrived in Miami, he worked himself up through various promotions to becoming Food & Beverage Manager of Hyatt Hotel in Coral Gables. His desire of becoming a business owner combined with his years of experience in the industry, led him to open his first restaurant in March of 2001 in Coral Gables. Since then, he has bought three more establishments which employ over 100 people and generated sales over $5M in 2006 and plans on continuing to E. sand. Professional Experience: July 2003 — Present Exile, Inc., Downtown Miami, Flo: *:ia President • Owns and operates Club ENVY located in the 24 hr. entertainment district. o 14,000 sq. ft. high energy nightclub. Jan 2003 — Present Club Management Investment Grog.,r) LLC, Miamip Florida "i.1"anager/Operator • Owns and operates Vision Nightclub located in Cocowalk. o 12,000 sq. ft. nightclub and high energy sports bar. • Owns and operates Apple Martini Bar and Lounge located in Cocowalk. o 7,000 sq. ft. nightclub and supper club rapt. 2001 — Present Jan 1997- Pre_ ZBA, LLC, dba Karma Restaurant, Coral Gables, Florida Manager/Operator • Upscale Asian restaurant which seats over 200 people. • Opening Vancouver, B.C., summer 2008 Atlas Marketing & Prom ?ti ons Ent., Inc., Miami, Florida President • Marketing and Management Consulting Firm • Subleased and operated Alcazaba Lounge at Hyatt Regency Coral Gables • Provided management and marketing to Monty's Miami Beach. • Provided management and marketing to Bijan's Catering Aug 1996 — April 2001 Hyatt Regency Coral Gables Food and Beverage Manager • Managed staff of 80 employees. • Generated sales over $5M in total food and beverage sales. • Maximized 80% growth in food and beverage department from 1996 to 2000. • Developed and implemented all promotion and marketing for the food and beverage department. • Forecasting for budget income and expenses. • Trained all management and staff as Responsible Vendor Submitted Into the pub recortin connection with item 11Z1 , on+Of-2L-0g Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk Resume of Shawn Shahnazi Page 2 Feb 1993 —July 1996 • Alcohol awareness meetings • Manager certification for public service employee training. Cafe Casablanca Restaurant & Lounge, Miami Lakes, Florida General Manager • Designed and developed Cafe Casablanca's concept. • Hired and supervised staff of 50 employees. • Generated gross sales of $3.5M annually. • Developed marketing strategies. • Controlled food and liquor cost. • Analyzed cash flow level. July 1991 — Feb 1993 Charcoals Restaurant & Bar, Miami, Florida Beverage Manager • Supervised a staff of 40-50 employees • Prepared staff training manuals. • Reduced costs by 15% and increased sales by 20% • Sales audit and analysis. • Conducted and analyzed liquor and food inventories. Feb 1990—Jan 1991 Suzanne's in :' Grove, Coconut Grove, Florida Bar Manager May 1985 — P_ 1989 Montt/ Trainer Raw Bar, Coconut Grove, Florida Busboy/Valet/Bartender Education. 1996-1998 1987-1989 University of the Atlantic — Correspondence School • BA -Business Administration Miami Dade Community College N:\Data_R-Z\VISIONS vs. CITY OF MIAMI\Shawn's Resume.7.5.07.docx SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEM pz io ON or zv as. EXHIBIT B SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEMF2 ONoi-2-o.s Submitted into the public record,in owned:Io item VZ 1 to on 01 4 Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk Submitted Into the public itemrecos ifection n01 � �L Priscilla A. Thompson Clerk Submitted into the public connection with item in c2 on 0 I - IL( - record Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk the public with ItemZ ft on D1 -2 Ptirit A. Thompson EXHIBIT C SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEMVz ON O-z-os THE AUDIO BUG, INC. 3800 HILLCREST DRIVE, # 102 • HOLLYWOOD, FL 33021 • PHONE: 954-983-2788 • FAX: 954-983-2789 • audiobug1('ci aol.com July 6, 2007 Mr. Shawn Shahnazi Visions Night Club 3015 Grand Avenue Coconut Grove, FL 33133 Dear I'm pleased 'o present findings of the Noise Survey conducted to assess sound propagation from Visions Night Club/Apples Martini Bar in Coconut Grove and its potential impact on the surrounding residential area. Sonesta Hotel and Suites is located at 2889 McFarlane Road, approximately 700 feet from the center of the Cocowalk complex. It appears to be the main source of noise complaints. Indeed, there are numerous references to noise in reviews posted on Google by people who have stayed at this facility. This report will address and attempt to specifically identify sources that have an impact on the hotel. Our survey was performed between the hours of 10:30 P.M., June 15 and 12:45 A.M., June 16, 2007. Friday evenings are representative of the highest level of activity common to this area of Coconut Grove on a busy - weekend. Indeed, all of the establishments in and around the Coc-owalk district were very busy this evening. The primary sources of music contributing to the overall sound level observed included Fat Tuesday, Hooters, Cafe Tu Tu Tango, Visions Night Club, Apples Martini Bar and Johnny Rockets. In addition, intermittent sound sources were noted; car alarms, motorcycles and car sound systems. At times, their contribution to overall sound levels was considerable. Determining the individual contribution of sound levels from each of the establishments active at the time presents considerable difficulty. From the street level, music from Fat Tuesday, Hooters, Cafe Tu Tu Tango and Johnny Rockets blended into a cacophonous mass of sound. Music from Visions and Apples could be heard only intermittently, as it was somewhat lower in level and only audible when doors to these clubs were opened to allow entrance and egress. The open-air nature of the other clubs ensured that they were audible at all times at fairly consistent sound levels. Figure 1 below provides an aerial overview of this section of Coconut Grove. The various clubs are identified with text. Sound level measurements were documented at the following locations: TABLE 1 - Sound Level Measurements Recorded during Survey - (in dBA) LOCATION L10 L5o L90 Lmean Lmin Lmax Leg Outside Patio Bar at South end of Visions Night Club 83.7 80.1 77.1 80.3 73.8 87.9 81.1 Inside Visions Night Club (for reference) 90.9 85.3 79.6 85.2 74.1 99.0 88.0 East side of Fat Tuesday on the 2"d floor deck 86.0 83.3 81.0 83.4 77.8 89.9 83.9 Grove View Terrace at the Sonesta Hotel 65.9 62.1 60.9 62.9 52.7 85.5 65.3 Street level along Grand Avenue and McFarlane Road 80.5 75.2 62.8 73.1 48.2 97,8 78.8 Submitted Into thel SuptJD+c redorci in connection with item KZ Ito on OI-2LLQ Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk THE AUDIO BUG, INC. 3800 HILLCREST DRIVE, # 102 • HOLLYWOOD, FL 33021 • PHONE: 954-983-2788 • FAX: 954-983-2789 • audiohug `a,aol.com This information is displayed in the chart format below, Figures 2 through 6. The charts show changes in level and trends not readily apparent in the figures above. The difference between L50 measured inside Visions and outside next to Fat Tuesday differed by only two decibels. Energy generated outside will certainly travel a greater distance than that contained inside a building. Sounds observed along the street level measured about eight decibels below those measured by Fat Tuesday. The lowest sound levels recorded were observed along McFarlane Road just outside the entrance to the Sonesta Hotel and Suites; 48.2 dBA. Long-term sound levels (two) taken on the 8th floor Grove View Terrace were about 20 dBA below those measured within and around the Cocowalk complex. The minimum sound level here was dominated by air conditioning equipment located on the rooftop of the building adjacent to the Sonesta. While music could be heard over this mechanical noise, it was impossible to conclusively identify its source other than that it emanated from Cocowalk. Its nature was similar to the discordant sounds noted earlier at street level along Grand Avenue, only at far lower levels. It is safe to say that all of the open-air venues contributed to the overall sound heard on the 8th floor terrace. One would expect that sound levels inside rooms and suites at the Sonesta Hotel would be considerably attenuated by the windows and doors. I would expect that only if these were opened would the music be audible. However, the influence of atmospheric conditions and variabilities in sound levels generated on a nightly basis by the clubs, especially the open-air venues, would inevitably have an impact on these conditions. When considering the contribution of the various venues generating music audible around the area, the evidence weighs heavily against the open-air establishments. Those whose music systems are located inside, such as Visions Night Club and Apples Martini Bar, clearly exhibit far less potential to influence overall outside sound levels when compared with the other venues mentioned above. On a cautionary note, I would recommend that doors to both Visions Night Club and Apples Martini Bar be kept closed as much as possible simply to minimize leakage of sound to the outside. I hope the information presented herein will be helpful to your company. Please feel free to contact me with any questions concerns. I will be more than happy to assist. Sincerely, Ad(ly Donald J. Washburn President SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEMZ_,ON orzv-ae . THE AUDIO BUG, INC. 3800 HILLCREST DRIVE, # 102 • HOLLYWOOD, FL 33021 • PHONE: 954-983-2788 • FAX 954-983-2789 • audiobug 122r;aol.com SUBMTTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEM f'z ON o-zq o. THE AUDIO BUG, INC. 3800 HILLCREST DRIVE, # 102 • HOLLYWOOD, FL 33021 • PHONE: 954-983-2788 • FAX: 954-983-2789 • audiobug 47)aol.com Leq 0.1 seconds 100 88 76 64 52 40 Uisions Outside Patio 09:05 716./ 7 Channel A Line Weight: A Output: Off Lrs in L1O = 83.7 dB L50 TIME(HH:MM) 15sidiv Duration - 00:01 09:06 File TRACK-01 = 73.8 dB Liaa = 87.9 dB Leg = 81.1 dB 80.1 dB L90 = 77.1 dB Lmean. 80.3 dB Figure 2 Lea 0.1 seconds 100 88 76 64 52 40 Inside Visions Night Club 09:09 7/61 7 TIME(HHJIM) 15s/div Duration - 00:01 Channel A Line Weight: A Output: Off 09:10 File TRACK-05 Lnin . 74.1 dB Lmax = 99.0 dB Leq = 88.0 de L10 = 90.9 dB L50 = 85.3 dB L90 = 79.6 dB Lnean. Figure 3 85. eibmitt recor Into the public in «nnectlon with on Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk THE AUDIO BUG, INC. 3800 HILLCREST DRIVE, # 102 • HOLLYWOOD, FL 33021 • PHONE: 954-983-2788 - FAX: 954-983-2789 • aud.iobuQ 1'reaol.conm Leg 0.1 seconds 7/6/ 7 100 88 76 64 52 40 Fat Tuesday 2nd Level, East Side Channel Line Weight: A Output: Off 09:07 TIME<HH:MM) 15s/div 09:08 Duration - 00:01 File TRACK-02 Lorin = 77.8 dB Lmax = 89.9 d8 Leg = 83.9 d8 L1O = 86.0 dB L50 = 83.3 dB L90 = 81.0 dB Lmean= 83.4 d8 Figure 4 Led 1.0 seconds 7/6/ 7 100 88 76 64 52 40 Twelve minute sample measured from the 8th floor Grove Uiew Terrace at the Sonesta Beach Hotel. Channel Line Weight: A Output: Off File TRACK-03 09:48 TIME(HH:MM) 3m/div 10:00 Duration - 00:12 Lorin = 52.7 d8 Lmax = 85.5 dB Leq = 65.3 dB L10 = 65.9 dB L50 = 62.1 dB L90 = 60.9 dB Lmean= 62.9 dB Submfttesi Into the public . _ 'connection with item 110 on 01.2L1_p Pt�whT - Figure 5 THE AUDIO BUG, INC. 3800 HILLCREST DRIvE, # 102 • HOLLYWOOD, FL 33021 • PHONE: 954-983-2788 - FAX: 954-983-2789 • audiohug 1::aol.conm Leq 0.5 seconds 7/6/ 7 Six minute sample starting outside American Apparel, ending at Sonesta Beach Hotel entrance Channel Weight: Output: Off File TRACK-04 09:12 TIMECHH:MM) 1m/dio _ 09:18 Duration - 00:06 Lorin = 48.2 dB Lmax = 97.8 dB Lan = 78.8 dB L1O = 80.5 dB LSO = 75.2 dB L9O = 62.8 dB Lmean= 73.1 dB Figure 6 SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR lTEMz ru, ONc'ics The Audio Bug, Inc. 3800 Hillcrest Drive, # 102 • Hollywood, FL 33021-7937 Phone: 954-983-2788 • Fax: 954-983-2789 E-mail: audiobug1(c�aol.com NOISE LEVEL ANALYSIS TERMS Sound Pressure Level (SPL) = The RMS sound pressure expressed in dB re 20 microPa, the lowest threshold of hearing for 1 kHz for a healthy auditory system. [As points of reference, 0 dB-SPL equals the threshold of hearing, while 140 dB-SPL equals irreparable hearing damage.] See: inverse square law below. 1 Pascal = 94 dB SPL. Average face-to-face conversation equals approximately 65 dB SPL. Decibel (dB) = means of expressing power ratios, i.e. the difference between two sound levels, or an absolute sound level expressed in Sound Pressure Level (SPL) referenced to a standard pressure, i.e. 94 dB SPL = 1 Pascal. dBA = "A" weighted sound pressure level. Please refer to the attached discussion of weighting filters and their applications. -?LM = Sound Level Meter. Device used to measure sound pressure levels. ,in = Lowest, or softest, Sound Pressure Level measured during the test period. max = Highest, or loudest, Sound Pressure Level measured during the test period. Leq = Equivalent continuous sound level. The steady level which would produce the same sound energy over the test period as the specified time -varying sound. This figure is useful for studying long-term trends in environmental noise. A single Leq number is often used to define an entire measurement period. = Sound level exceeded 10% of the measurement period. Highest of the Ln figures. L50 = Sound level exceeded 50% of the measurement period. Median of the Ln figures. L90 = Sound IevE exceeded 90% of the measurement period. Lowest of the Ln figures. This figure is most commonly used in estimating true ambient noise level. Lmean = Mathematically averaged Sound Pressure Level. NC = Noise Criter. a standardized method of characterizing noise loudness. Extensively used in the analysis of noise and vibration. Sone = a subjective unit of loudness for an average listener equal to the loudness of a 1 kHz. sound that has an intensity 40 decibels above the listener's own threshold of hearing. Phon = the unit of loudness on a scale beginning at zero for the faintest audible sound (0.00002 Pascals) and corresponding to the decibel scale of sound intensity with the number of phons of a given sound being equal to the decibels of a pure 1 kHz tone judged by the average listener to be equal in loudness to the given sound. Submitted Into the pub repo 1n wtt� Vkern con Zt 2'1-O Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk The Audio Bug, Inc. 3800 Hil!crest Drive, # 102 • Hollywood, FL 33021-7937 Phone: 954-983-2788 • Fax: 954-983-2789 E-mail: audiobug1(a?aol.com iverse Square Law = inverse square law Sound Pressure Level. Sound propagates in all directions to form a spherical field, thus sound energy is inversely proportional to the square of the distance, i.e., doubling the distance quarters the sound energy (the inverse square law), so SPL is attenuated 6 dB for each doubling of distance from the source. N Dise Reduction Coefficient (NRC) = The average of the individual sound absorption coefficients at 250, 500, 1000 and 2000 Hz, to the nearest .05. Impact Insulation Class (ICC) = Single -number rating that indicates the amount of impact noise isolation provided by a floor/ceiling assembly. The higher the number, the better the floor/ceiling assembly. :`ound Transmiss.:i Class (STC) = A single -number rating that indicates the sound transmission Toss of a partition or ceiling system between adjacent closed rooms. STC Ratings are: 25 Normal speech can be understood quite clearly 30 Loud speech can be understood fairly well 35 Loud speech is audible but not intelligible 42 Loud speech is audible as a murmur 45 Must strain to hear loud speech 48 Some loud speech is barely audible 50 Loud speech is not audible efiniti 1) sor:,a: utilizing, produced by, or relating to sound waves; broadly: of or involving sound: having a frequency within the audibility range of the human ear: of, relating to, or being the speed of sound in air or about 761 miles per hour (1224 kilometers per hour) at sea level at 59°F (15°C) subsonicof, relating to, or being a speed less than that of sound in air 3) supersonic: of, being, or relating to speeds from one to five times the speed of sound in air 4) hypersonic: of or relating to speed five or more times that of sound in air 5) audio: of or relating to acoustic, mechanical, or electrical frequencies corresponding to normally audible sound waves which are of frequencies approximately from 2I3 to 20,000 hertz 6) infrason L. having or relating to a frequency below the audibility range of the human ear (< 20 Hz) 7) ultrasonic: having a frequency above the human ear's audibility limit of about 20,000 hertz 8) audible: heard or capable of being heard 9) intelligible: capable of being understood or comprehended 10) aural: heard or perceived with the ear SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEM Pzi, ONoi-z'/ O?. The Audio Bug, Inc. 3800 Hillcrest Drive, # 102 • Hollywood, FL 33021-7937 Phone: 954-983-2788 • Fax 954-983-2789 E-mail: audiobugl�a,aol.com auditory: of, relating to, or experienced through the sense of hearing acoustic: of or relating to the sense or organs of hearing, to sound, or to the science of sounds vibration: a periodic motion of the particles of an elastic body or medium in alternately opposite directions from the position of equilibrium when that equilibrium has been disturbed (as when a stretched cord produces musical tones or particles of air transmit sounds to the ear) 14) noise: 1 loud, confused, or senseless shouting or outcry 2 a: SOUND; esp. : one that lacks agreeable musical quality or is noticeably unpleasant b: any sound that is undesired or interferes with one's hearing of something c: an unwanted signal or a disturbance (as static or a variation of voltage) in an electronic device or instrument (as radio or television); broadly : a disturbance interfering with the operation of a usu. mechanical device or system d: electromagnetic radiation (as light or radio waves) that is composed of several frequencies and that involves random changes in frequency or amplitude e: irrelevant or meaningless data or output occurring along with desired information SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBUC RECORD FOR lTEMVz ,b ONoi-z4o�. The Audio Bug, inc. 3800 Hillcrest Drive, # 102 • Hollywood, FL 33021-7937 Phone: 954-983-2788 • Fax: 954-983-2789 E-mail: audiobuglPaol.com Sound Level Meter Weighting Networks The following brief description of how the various weighting networks are used is intended to provide the reader an understanding of the purposes for and applications of standard weighting networks found in professional sound level meters. The information is an extract from "The New Audio Cyclopedia, Handbook for Sound Engineers", edited by Glen Ballou. It can be found on page 21 of that reference publication. 1.16 Weighting ",etworks Sound level meters come with one or more weighting networks built in. The question confronting the user is, `Which one should I use?" The frequency responses of the three standard networks (A, B and C) are shown in figure 1-16. In the simplest terms, these different curves are designed to give readings of sound pressure level that will correspond, at least roughly, with human response to the sound. As we shall see in Chapter 2 "Psycho Acoustics," the Fletcher -Munson curves show that the human ear is less sensitive at lower frequencies than at a frequency of 1 kHz. This effect is greater for lower -level sounds than for louder sounds. Therefore, it makes sense to reduce the sensitivity of the sound level meter (chiefly in the lower frequencies) so that its readings follow the characteristics of the ear more closely. The A -weighted curve of Fig. 1-16 is based on the 40 phon Fletcher -Munson equal -loudness contour and is to be preferred for measuring lower -level sounds such as background noise. The B-weighted curve is based on the 70-phon equal -loudness contour and is suitable for measuring sounds of intermediate level. Measurements taken with the A and B weighting are called weighted sound levels. The C weighting is essentially flat and is used for very loud sounds. It is also used when sound pressure levels are to be measured and generally when th`e sound level meter feeds a signal to other instruments for analysis. Table 1-4. Use of Weighting Networks Sound Level Range, in dB 20-55 55-85 85 - 140 Recommended Weighting Network A B Table 1-4 gives generalsuggestions as to which weighting to use for different sound level ranges. When comparing different sound levels, such as in Table 1-5, it may be expedient to use the A -weighting for the entire range rather than to shift weighting in the midst of a series of measurements to be directly compared. Table 1-5. Typical A -Weighted Sound Levels Sound Source Jet airplane taking off (200 ft.) Subway train (20 ft.) Freight Train (100 ft.) Speech (1 ft.) Shopping Mall Average residence with TV Quiet residential area at night Soft whisper Sound Pressure Level, Decibels, (A -Weighted) 120 90 70 70 60 50 40 30 Recording studio background noise rhreshold of hearing 30 20 Figure 1.16 - We'fht!ng Networks RELATIVE RESPONSE-OECISELS 0 10 20 _ 30 B AN Tf c s A _50 20 50 100 200 500 1K 2K 5K 10K 20K FREOUEWCY—HERTZ Frequency Response Characteristics in the American National Standard Specification for Sound Level Meters, ANSI-31.4-1971. Submitted Into the public cord in ,connection with Item i'Z '6 onQ1-ZI-! Pnec#la A. Thompson Gty Clerk EXHIBIT D SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEM z ONot-z- os ANALYSIS FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION 3015 Grand Avenue CASE NO. 2003-0648 Pursuant to Article 6, Section 602 of Ordinance 11000, as amended, The Zoning Ordinance of the City of Miami, Florida, the subject proposal has been reviewed to allow a supper club use at 3015 Grand Avenue. NOTE: The subject proposal shall also require the following special permit: Class I1 Special Permit as per article 6, Section 602.3.1, for development of new construct ion within the SD-2 "Coconut Grove Central Commercial District". The following findings have been made: • It is found that the proposed supper club use is located within an existing Retail Specialty Center known as Cocowalk (within the SD-2 District in Coconut Grove) and is therefore compatible with the area. • It is fc.:nd that the proposed use is appropriate for the existing space within the Cocowalk structure. • It is found that the required parking has been provided as part of the Cocowalk comple _ • It is found that the subject proposal, being that it is a component of an already approved retail specialty center, has been reviewed and found in compliance with the following factors: ingress and egress, offstreet parking and loading, refuse and service areas, signs and lighting, utilities and drainage. • It is found that regarding control of potentially adverse effects generally, the proposed supper club use, due to the late hours of operation permitted in conjunction with lieuor sales, may have an adverse effect on nearby residential areas for the latter part of its nightly operations (more specifically, for any operational time after 2 A.M.). Specific concerns are related to security and offsite parking within the adjacent neighbc ' ;-ood at such a late hour. • It is found that this analysis is based on the proposal presented for "Margarita Mama's' only and should not apply to any future supper club proposals for the same location. • It is found that upon compliance with conditions set forth below, this project will not have any adverse impacts on the surrounding area. Submitted Into the public in con on with ( ont L' Pri>dlla A. Thompeon City Clerk Based on these findings, the Planning and Zoning is recommending approval of the application with the following conditions: 1. Approval of this special exception shall run with this operator only; any changes to a different operator shall require a separate Special Exception. 2. The proposed facility shall provide security during the operating hours between 2 A.M. and 5 A.M.; the applicant shall submit a security plan, which specifies the number of security personnel and locations for said personnel to be posted, for review and approval by the Planning and Police Departments, prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Use as a supper club. 3. The applicant shall promote onsite parking for the hours of 2 A.M. through 5 A.M. by providing some kind of parking voucher system with reduced onsite prking rates for those hours. 4. In order to discourage enforcement problems with underage patrons during "nightclub" hours, no one under the age of 21 shall be permitted into the club between the hours of 2 A.M. and 5 A.M. SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR lTEMr2u0_ON oi-zwos. Miami Zoning Bo; rd A F esc ution No.: 2003-0709 Monday, April 21, 2003 Mr. Joseph H. Ganguzza offered the following resolution and moved its adoption Resolution: AFTER CONSIDERING THE FACTORS SET FORTH IN SECTION 1305 OF ORDINANCE NO. 11000, THE ZONING BOARD GRANTED THE SPECIAL EXCEPTION AS LISTED IN ORDINANCE NO. 11000, AS AMENDED, THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, ARTICLE 6, SECTION 602.4.1.1(5), REQUEST FOR SUPPER CLUB AS DEFINED IN THE CITY CODE, CHAPTER FOUR, OF THE CITY OF MIAMI FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT APPRO IMATELY 3015 GRAND AVENUE, LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS TRACT A TOGETHER WITH TRACT B, LESS THE SOUTH 10 FEET OF SAID TRACT B, COCONUT GROVE ARCADE (126-93), PUBLIC RECORDS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA; ZONED SD-2 COCONUT GROVE CENTRAL -COMMERCIAL DISTRICT. THIS SPECIAL EXCEPTION WAS GRANTED v ;ITH A TIME LIMITATION OF TWELVE MONTHS IN WHICH A BUILDING PERMIT MUST BE OBTAINED, SUBJECT TO THE FOLLOWING CONDITIONS BY THE PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT; 1) APPROVAL OF THIS SPECIAL EXCEPTION SHALL RUN WITH THIS OPERATOR ONLY; ANY CHANGES TO A DIFFERENT OPERATOR SHALL REQUIRE A SEPARATE SPECIAL EXCEPTION, 2) THE PROPOSED FACILITY SHALL PROVIDE SECURITY DURING THE OPERATING HOURS BETWEEN 2 A.M. AND 5 A.M.; THE APPLICANT SHALL SUBMIT A SECURITY .PLAN, WHICH SPECIFIES THE NUMBER OF SECURITY PERSONNEL AND LOCATIONS FOR SAID PERSONNEL TO BE. POSTED, FOR REVIEW AND APPROVAL BY THE PLANNING AND POLICE DEPARTMENTS PRIOR TO THE ISSUANCE OF A CERTIFICATE OF USE AS A SUPPER CLUB, 3) THE APPLICANT SHALL PROMOTE ONSITE PARKING FOR THE HOURS OF 2 A.M. THROUGH 5 A.M. BY PROVIDING SOME KIND OF PARKING VOUCHER SYSTEM WITH REDUCED ONSITE PARKING RATES FOR THOSE HOURS AND 4) IN ORDER TO DISCOURAGE ENFORCEMENT PROBLEMS WITH UNDERAGE PATRONS DURING "NIGHTCLUB" HOURS, NO ONE UNDER THE AGE OF 21 SHALL BE PERMITTED INTO THE CLUB BETWEEN THE HOURS )F 2 A.M. AND 5 A.M. Upon being seconded by Mr. Charles J. Flowers, the motion was passed and adopted by the following vote: { AINft00 Mr. Charles J. Flowers Yes Mr. Miguel Gabela Null Mr. Joseph H. Ganguzza Yes Mr. Charles A. Garavaglia Yes Ms. Ileana Hemandez-Acosta Yes Mr. Carlos Martell Yes Mr. Juvenal A. Pina Yes Mr. Allan Shulman Yes SUBMITTED THE Mr. Angel UruINTOuiola Yes Mr. Georges William Yes PUBLIC RECORD FOR AYE: NAY: ABSTENTIONS: NO VOTES: ABSENT: Ms. Fernandez: Motion carries 9-0 .g 0 0 0 ITEM_iON oi-z11-os. i Teresita L. Fernandez, Executive Secre Hearing Boards ry Case No. 2003-0648 Item Nbr: ltisa: rni Zoning Board Resolution No.: 2003-0709 Monday, April 21, 2003 STATE OF FLORIDA ) SS: COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE ) Personly appeared before me, the undersigned authority, Teresita L. Fernandez, Clerk of the ;.zoning Board of the City of Miami, Florida, and acknowledges that she executed the foregoing Resolution for a Special Exception request. SWORN AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS . -'DAY OF t-tU11(.� �� , 2003. oziuivxi 0/JI-166 Print Notary Name Notary Public State of Florida Personally know \. or Produced I.D. My Commission Expires: Type and number of I.D. produced Did take an oath or Did not take an oath 4 .�� r VANESSA CASTI LO MY COMMISSION d DD 199627 o EXPIRES: July 11, 2007 to , " Boated Thru Nalay Public UMia hers SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEM ON Case :'o. 2003-0648 Item Nbr: 8 EX IBIT SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECORD FOR TEMz i ONorzti-oS. ANALYSIS FOR SPECIAL EXCEPTION 3015 Grand Avenue CASE NO. 2005-1019 Pursuant to Article 6, Section 602 of Ordinance 11000, as amended, The Zoning Ordinance of the City of Miami, Florida, the subject proposal has been reviewed to allow a supper club use at 3015 Grand Avenue. The following findings have been made: • It is found that the proposed supper club use is located within an existing Retail Specialty Center known as Cocowalk (within the SD-2 District in Coconut Grove) and is therefore compatible with the area. • It is found that the proposed use is appropriate for the existing space within the Cocowalk structure. • It is found that the required parking has been provided as part of the Cocowalk complex. • It is found that the subject proposal, being that it is a component of an already approved retail specialty center, has been reviewed and found in compliance with the following factors: ingress and egress, offstreet parking and loading, refuse and service areas, signs and lighting, utilities and drainage. • It is found that regarding control of potentially adverse effects generally, the proposed supper club use, due to the late hours of operation permitted in conjunction with liquor sales, may have an adverse effect on nearby residential areas for the latter part of its nightly operations (more specifically, for any operational time after 2 A.M.). 'Specific concerns are related to security and offsite parking within the adjacent neighborhood at such a late hour. • It is found that this analysis is based on the proposal presented for "Coyote Ugly" only and should not apply to any future supper dub proposals for the same location. • It is found that upon compliance with conditions set forth below, this project will not have any adverse impacts on the surrounding area. Submitted into the publd recor in connection with ilea] �Z 1 o on 01- - OS Priscilla A. Thompson City Clerk Based i,p7 these findings, the Planning is recommending approval of the application with the foilowing conditions: 1. APproN al of this special exception shall run with this operator only; any changes to a different operator shall require a separate Special Exception. 2. The proposed facility shall provide security during the operating hours between 2 A.M. and 5 A.M.; the applicant shall submit a seci:, ay plan, which specifies the number of security personnel and locations for said personnel to be posted, for review and approval by the Planning and Police Departments, prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Use as a supper club. 3. The applicant shall promote onsite parking for the hours of 2 A.M. through 5 A.M. by providing some kind of parking voucher system with reduced onsite parking rates for those hours. 4. In order to discourage enforcement problems with underage patrons during "nightclub" hours, no one un,=°r the age of 21 shall be permitted into the club between . 3.,. ;lours of 2 A.M. and 5 A.M. SUBMITTED INTO THE PUBLIC REC')RD FOR ITEM z iv ONoi- oa: Miami Zoning Board 111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111 • ? ii eA 20 i. R5:3, 35 c�t�:r2 Resolution No.: 2005-1079 ' F. "j` �" ' `} 4267 -:55: ;nos 17 HARVE't RUVIN CLERK O y C0..IF�T Monday, October 17, 2005 ;"SWAMI-C.��;DE +_OUP T•r r 'FLORIDA Ms. Cti iioe Keidaish offered the following resolution and moved its adoption Resolution: AFTER CONSIDERING THE FACTORS SET FORTH IN SECTION 1305 OF ORDINANCE NO. 11000, THE ZONING BOARD GRANTED THE SPECIAL EXCEPTION AS LISTED IN ORDINANCE NO. 11000, AS AMENDED, THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, ARTICLE 6, SECTION 602, TO ALLOW A SUPPER CLUB IN THE SD-2 DISTRICT FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT APPROXIMATELY 3015 GRAND AVENUE, LEGALLY DESCRIBED AS EXHIBIT "A" (HEREBY ATTACHED), PUBLIC RECORDS OF MIAMI-DADE COUNTY, FLORIDA; ZONED SD-2 COCONUT GROVE CENTRAL COMMERCIAL DISTRICT, THIS SPECIAL EXCEPTION WAS GRANTED PER PLANS ON FILE WITH A TIME LIMITATION OF TWELVE MONTHS IN WHICH A BUILDING PERMIT MUST BE OBTAINED, SUBJECT TO SECURITY BEING APPROVED BY THE NET DEPARTMENT AND SUBJECT TO THE PLANNING DEPARTMENT'S CONDITIONS AS ATTACHED HERETO AS EXHIBIT "B". Upon being seconded by Mr. Charles J. Flowers, the motion was passed and adopted by the following vote: Mr. Charles J. Flowers Yes Mr. Miguel Gabela No Mr. Joseph H. Ganguzza Away Mr. Charles A. Garavaglia Yes Ms. Ileana Hernandez -Acosta Away Ms. Chloe Keidaish Yes Mr. Carlos Martell Yes Mr. Juvenal A. Pina Yes Mr. Angel Urquiola Yes AYE: 6 NAY: 1 ABSTENTIONS: 0 NO VOTES: 0 ABSENT: 2 Ms. Ft Tnandez: Motion carries 6-1 SU8MTTED INTO THE PUBLIC RECOR FOR 1TEM z i ONi.-i-o g. Teresita L. Fernandez, Executive Secr Hearing Boards Case 'o. 2005-1019 Item Nbr: 10 EDCETIBIT "A" I.-:0•k1cp1ICB111J4t1 CCJCS?M'Ai,.h 1.111JLU1NC;,`�1TF,- Tract 11 together with TrAveA E. ices tltc South 10.00 feet of said Tract 11, 'COCONUT GROVE ARChDE', according to th< Plat thereof tccordtxl l Pint Book 176, tt Page 41, of the Public Records of %tiami•13adt: Couriiy, Florida &VIATIQN i31JtLDING S]Tt: Emi. I. Commencing at a point Sixteen Hundred Forty-Th ec and Thret-Tenths (1,643 3) feet West of t>4 Southeast corner of the Se tf4 of +. , Na114 -_ vn 21. Tow,::i:.:. 54 South, ;tinge 41 thence run Nonb Three Hundred Minty -Sic (396' ,. `t, thence run West Fifty -Five (55) feet, C.- . -,: run South Three Hundred Ninety -Sit - )6) thence run Eau : ifly-Five (55) feet to ibe Point ; rsuuung. less' the South ortyThree (43) feet thereof lying utd being in hMiamt-Dade County, Florida Commencing at a point Sitieen Hundred Ninety -Eight and Titter-Tenths(1,59S_1) feu West of the Sautltcui corner of the SE 114 of the NE 114 of Section 21, Township 5-4 South, Range 41 gag. thence run North Three Hundred Ninety -Six (396) feet, thence run West Puny (40) feel. thence run South Three Hundred Ninety -Six (396) feet, thence run F.xu Forty (40) feet to the Pmint oft3egumin , iv>t'the South Foray- ihrce (43) feet t1 lying and being in Miami -Dade County. Florida £AECEE.111. Commencing at a point Seventeen Hundred Thirty-Ei$M and Three Tenths (1,738.3) feet West of the Southeast cpmec of the SE 114 of the NE 1i4 of Secllo 121, Towtiif4p 54 Sotm, T ngc 41 East.ihence tun Nor `: Three Hundred Nincty-f. ix (396) feet, thence run West Twiny -Five (25) Cc, ,, `:tenet run South Th►ee'.'ntlred Ninety -Six. (396) feet, thence tun East Twenty -Five (25) ten to the Faint of Beginning. lest the South Fony-Three (43) act th41Cof, lying and being in Mimi -Dade County, Florida, ABMITTEDINTO THE PUBLIC RECCRD FOR ITEMVz i ONoi-zij-o. • a E�IBIT "B" Based on these findings, the Planning is recommending approval of the application with the following co.:sitions: 1. Approval of this special exception shall run with this operator only; any changes to a different operator shall require a separate Special Exception. 2. 'r _ proposed facility shall provide security during the operating hours between 2 A_r id 5 A.M.; the applicant shall submit a security plan, which specifies the number of security personnel and locations for said personnel to be posted, for review and approval by the Planning and Police Departments, prior to the 4uance of a Certificate of Use as a supper club. 3. The applicant shall promote onsite parking for the hours of 2 A.M. through 5 A.M. by providing some kind of parking voucher system with reduced onsite parking rates for those hours. 4. In order to discourage enforcement problems with underage patrons during "nightclub" hours, no one under the age of 21 shall be permitted into the club between the hours of 2 A.M. an0 5 A.M. SUBMITT2INTOTHE PUBLIC RECORD FOR ITEMpz Miami Zoning Board Resolution No.: 2005-1079 Monday, October 17, 2005 STATE OF FLORIDA ) SS: COUNTY OF MIAMI-DADE ) Personally appeared before me, the undersigned authority, Teresita L. Fernandez, Clerk of the Zoning Board of the City of Miami, Florida, and acknowledges that she executed the fort going Resolution for a Special Exception request. SWOP!': AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS '2 —DAY OF }'`}0''--60 t , 2005. Print Notary Name Notary Public State of Florida Personally know T or Produced I.D. Type and number of 1.D. produced Did take an oath or Did not take an oath 1 My Commission Expires: VANESSA CASTILLO MY COMMISSION x OD 199627 EXPIRES:July 11, 2007 Thin hb'�ry Pcb ...: Un.;envn!ors S!JrMITTE? INTO THE PU,_ ,_IC R. I\L FOR ITEMz CN ol- z.'- o , Case No. 2005-1019 Item Nbr: 10