HomeMy WebLinkAboutFinal Tabulation ResultsFIRM PROPOSED
Arthur J Gallagher Risk Management Services
The Mack Group, Inc.
Brown & Brown
USI Southeast
TOTAL
Evaluation Committee Members:
Leo Ann Brehm, Director. Risk Management, Cily al Miami
Elliot Eisler, Director. Risk Management, City of Miami
Stuart Myers, Consultant
Ed Beecher, Risk Manager, City of Pompano Beach
Eddie Demicco,Risk Manager, City of Hialeah
John Petitto, GIC, CPA, ICA Risk Management Consultants
Approved By:
Glean Marcos, Dir
Purchasing De
Approved By
Department Director/ Designee
RFP # 06-07.001
INSURANCE BROKERS SERVICES
Summary Sheet
Evaluation Committee Meeting
Friday, July 13, 2007, 10:00AM
FINAL TABULATION RESULTS BY CONSENSUS
LceAnn Brehm
9-6.'J..
Stuart Myers Ed Beer.her
3 2)
9 %I)
?BO'
F/3) L
73 0}
`f(y
7163)
Ed Demicco
( s1
73 0-1
8 (.3J
Pe Petillo
2J
7S0 )
EIIiol Eixler
57 IVY
9//a�
k LJ
a
/7
Sum Total
c
Rankin
3
4/
3
INSURANCE BROKERAGE SERVICES
RFLI NO. 06-07-001
Evaluation Date: Friday, Juty 13, 200T
Evaluated by (Print Nam}:
EVALUATION CRITERIA
- '314Z5
repors.ers,Ov eralEhofts lonaliDualirLcalions and_ „.
ieilierkence, including liey sled Account Representative
0.1i=-1MAia,sPAPA
!Overall strategy 10 represent IteCty: sk identification:
l& use of computerized syslem(s) Proposers Ability and Capability to
iPerkurn Required Services
r*A4r,taf tr.A.P;eA,"4:
1stl,e1 Strategy or Plan which Best Represents the Cit of Miami
L)
DMA:
MAX
ASSIGN.
POINTS
14,41?:14 '414.
-
for Ser,-es
11:
TOTA
Evaluator's Signature
Firrn * 1: Brown and Brown
Finn A 2: US1Southeast
Firm 4 3: Arthur J. Gallagher & Co - Miami
Firm 4: The Mack Group, Inc.
• • ',NW%
4, 0,
7
CONVIENTS,
INSURANCE BROKERAGE SERVICES
RFLI NO. 06-07-001
Evaluation Date: Friday, July 13, 2007 !
Evaluated by (Print Name): £c/cJ i a . �,�:(� e:- h.a+.,rDate: il, 'd •7
MAX
ASSIGN
EVALUATION CRITERIA POINTS Fern Finn Firm#3
PmposersOverallProfessionaIOuali&alionsand �^
experie rice, includkrg key staff & Account Representative
'�c .�A!."�f>k'S�".*�:r.4^,:wRc....�°.arrrrrrrn
Overall strategy la represent the Cit ; risk identification;
i& use o1 computerized system(s). Proposers Ability and Capahety to
,Perform Required Services
--,sAwircremTfeyz-
r.fa
k,etS Irategy or Plan which Best Represents the Ci of Miami
TOTAL POINTS
d ,
Evaluator's StonalurarrT%yt
Firm # $: Blown and Brown
Firm # 2: USI Southeast
Firm It 3: Arthur J. Gallagher& Co -Miami
Firm.# 4: The Mack Group, Inc.
eep
COMME
TS
INSURANCE BROKERAGE SERVICES
RFLI NO. 06-07-001
Evaluation Date: Friday, July 13. 2007
Evaluated by {Print Name): Z.L f
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Proposers Overall Professional qualifications and
e_ xperience, including 1m/ staff & Account Representative
Overall strategy In represent the City. tisk identification
& use of computerized systems). Propa s era Ability and Capability to
Perform Required Services
Markel Strategy or Plan which Best Represents the C.
Date:
MAST —
ASSIGN. 5a
POINTS
Fees for Services 20
TOTAL POINTS
Evaluator's Signature
Firm R 1: Brown a rown
Firm 0 2: USI Southeast
Firm ft 3: Arthur J. Gallagher & Co » Miami
Firm 11 .1' The Mack Gxnup, lnc.
100
Firm42 1 Eirmk3
.17
.._ �.. a
(
Lt )
1
i
x
COMMENTS
INSURANCE BROKERAGE
RFLI NO. 06-07.001
SERVICES
s,— 1` , e?r
j I �1.r k
CO acte.
Evaluation Date. Friday, Jana 12, 2007 n
ryi �L/ yam( 1 7 !/
Evaluated by (Print Name): to n � c.�l"a r It, te; !1� j2,9.0 7
,
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Proposals Overall Professional Qualification and
eerience, includingkey stall & Account Representative
Overall strategy to represent the Cite; risk idenldiealioni
& use of computerized system(s). Proposers Ability end Capability to
Perform Requred Services
i
Markel Strategy or Plan which 0est Represents th
Fees for Services
TOTAL POINTS
Evalua..761----
tor's Signature ..--"
ity of Miami
f r..
Firm # 1: Brown and grown ' .
Firm #2: UsI southeast -- /T' P :'�J 5°3•'�:'lof.l.; 1- <<fl r;•- -�*_ .r ;;?'
Firm#S: Arthur J.Gallagher &Ca--Miamimi`/. Syr
Firm#4. The Mach Group, Inc.
MAX
ASSIGN.
POINTS
100
EGm#1 Firm#2 Fi
1r) f.:r
rt,ILCj)r��
° Jr -I
COMMENT
INSURANCE BROKERAGE SERVICES
RFLI NO. 06-07-001
Evaluation Date: Friday, July 13, 2 7
Evaluated by (Prin( Name):���
EVALUATION CRITERIA
P r4po5er5 OveraA Proressional Onali1lcaliens antl __
experience, includnq key slat!& Account Representative
':4rx.�ri`.a
!Overall 9Y prese _...y'. risk identification:
stra4ep Ip represent P,-,-,_„__._......:,__..._..-_
!8 use eI eom ulerized s stem s Pro oSers Ability and Capability 1d
,Perlorm Required Services
.- `� •, R v'-.^Fi ; Fes' aiy•.: rig
Marke
t Slraleyy qr Plan which Besl Represents the
Fees for Services
TOTAL POINTS
Evaluator's Signature
Firm A 1: Brown and Brown
Firm A 2: USI Soulheasl
Firrn A 3: Arthur J. Gallagher & Go - Miami
Firm A 4: The Mack Group, Inc,
!)ate:
MAX
ASSIGN.
POINTS
MG'
30
INSURANCE BROKERAGE SERVICES
RFLI NO. 06-07-001
EvaWalton Dale: Friday, July 11, 2001
Evaluated by (Print Name): .7 .%r/% j/'7W
EVALUATION CRITERIA
Propn5er3 overall Pmfes zonal Ruakfecations and
ie penence including key staff & Account Represeeldtnre
.�'�v�.�i:';:R�a�'
�Overatl strategy to sepreent theCif risk Aentifa:ation:
6 use of computerized syslem(s)_ Proposers Ability and Capability to
I Perform Required 5enices
Markel Skate y or Plan which Deal Represents the City of Miami
Fees for Services
TOTAL POINTS
Eva#uator's Signature
firm # 1: Brown and Brown
Firm # 2: USI Southeast
Firm # 3: Arthur J. Gallagher & Co - Miami
Firm # 4, The Mack Group, Inc.
Date: / / r 3/ 07
ASSIGN.
POINTS
Firm tlt 1 Firm p 2 Firm rt 3 Firm p 4
.43
COMMENTS