HomeMy WebLinkAboutCommittee Ranking FormCity of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Architectural/Engineering Services for the Waterfront District Projects
RFQ No. 05-06-119
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
Cooper'
Robertson &
Partners
Kimley-Horn &
Associates
Associates
Arquitectonica
GEO
Respondents Experience & Qualifications
30
Experience with Similar Projects
10
/0
.5
,,
South Florida Experience
10
/ a
A
Financial Strength and Proof of Insurance
10
tr)
/
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
35
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Experience of Team Members
20
0-15
/ ()
/ Q
Experience of Consultants
10
f D
(gr
/ t
Team Organization
5
Cr-s.
3
p
Project Approach
35
Knowledge of Project Issues
15
r
1 0
3
Management Plan and Approach
10
! 0
3
Key Staff interaction and Experience
10
/ D
7
Total Score
100
/0 b
4 S
5 0
W
Ranking
r
_ � _
a.,
Explanation of Ranking
Name of Committee Member.
featAtot af7AtA,4 e;6_04eltte.sk.s6A-a-
IZj,;411- AJAiro (,e
tl. ' ./Allot Qh
-d- 1 i,
`LAY otA) Idt_cevQ WkAAAAAti)(
•i
P4e-R-
CtimmJ
Sign
7o-tiv-71Q
Date: April 10, 2007
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: ArchitecturallEn9ineering Services for the Waterfront District Projects
RFQ No. 05-06-119
Evaluation Criteria
Respondents Experience & Qualifications
Maximum
Points
30
Cooper,
Robertson &
Partr�er_s
2
Kimsey -Flom &
Associates
Zo
Arquitectonica
GEO
Experience with Similar Projects
10
0
South Florida Experience
10
/D
Financial Strength and Proof of Insurance
10
/0
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
Project Manager and sub-consuttants
35
3.f
Experience of Team Members
Experience of Consultants
Team Organization
20
10
5
O
1
Project Approach
35
3a
66
/O
LJ
3d
Knowledge of Project issues
Management Plan and Approach
Key Staff Interaction and Experience
15
10
10
TO
i0
Total Score
100
90
la
/0
/Q
sjg
Ranking
Explanation of Ranking
dJ-7Va-ee(4tice
-1C1/717 -4eAkadiA44-,
eivde_oLrcv-e-
Nim
Name of Committee Member.
Date: April 10, 2007
Form 113
W d •e,a aire
Signa
City of Miami
Department of Capital improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Architectural/Engineering Services for the Waterfront District Projects
RFQ No. 05-06-119
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
Cooper'
Robertson &
Partners
Kimley-Horn &
Associates
Arquitectonica
GEO
Respondents Experience & Qualifications
30
Experience with Similar Projects
10
I
CietI
_
W South Florida Experience
10
3
IF
` 7
Financial Strength and Proof of Insurance
10
i
8
5"
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
35
_
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Experience of Team Members
20
Zi6
/ 7 _
7,77
Experience of Consultants
10
' /6
it'
Team Organization
5
5"
Project Approach
35
Knowledge of Project Issues
15
/'
/ 3
/[)
Management Plan and Approach
10
/
/S.
Key Staff Interaction and Experience
10
' -9
%
c
Total Score
100
T 2
J
Ranking
7
2-
3
Explanation of Ranking
TA.e, frfryp) eokispx _.)ece 7Xe. MPS74 4frAi "40i/Ec24
opf _ dater .J/7c.41-e4c .A., ,i c,L 721..,e, 8- 21e-k . �
Alec73-F7A-, iitexA hi -weal -AA" sr
Name of Committee Member:
Date: April 10, 2007
-Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Architectural/Engineering Services for the Waterfront District Projects
RFQ No. 05-06-119
y
_
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
Cooper,
Robertson &
Partners
Kimley-Horn &
Associates
Arquitectonica
GEO
Respondent's Experience & Qualifications
3014:
Ili
Ili
Experience with Similar Projects
10
South Florida Experience
10
Financial Strength and Proof of Insurance
10E°
Experience of Project Team, induding key personnel
35
c
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Experience of Team Members
20
Experience of Consultants
10
40
VI,
Team Organization
5
t
Project Approach
35
1 g:
4
Knowledge of Project Issues
15e
Management Plan and Approach
10
elKey
Staff Interaction and Experience
10
1
p
Total Score
100
1 CI
9 4
e l
Ranking]
W
4
Explanation of Ranking
sr
. 7
i r _
Name of Committee Member: VeAmoue6 UA Ct/ Signature'
Date: April 10, 2007
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements r_ s•'
`
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form • •
Project Title: Architectural/Engineering Services for the Waterfront District Projects RFQ No. 05-06-119
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
Cooper,
Robertson &
Partners
Kimley-Horn &
Associates
Arquitectonica
GEO
Respondent's Experience & Qualifications
30
`�
...
e
,
Experience with Similar Projects
10
1n
South Florida Experience
10
10
le)
R
Financial Strength and Proof of Insurance
10
I0
1 Q
I 0
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
35
5
55
5
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Experience of Team Members
200
'' 7
Experience of Consultants
r 10
lc'
I e
f
Team Organization
5
5
J
Project Approach
35
13c,
S c
i
-
Knowledge of Project Issues
15
15
y• 5
j 5
Management Plan and Approach
10
jQ
I
A
Key Staff Interaction and Experience
10
y0
la
9,
Total Score
100
`
9
88
Ranking .
Explanation of Ranking
L.!
ILA,-
i
Name of Committee Member.( 112 L1 17- > () kJ Z- Signature/�
Date: April 10, 2007
Form 113