HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation Ranking FormCity of Miami
Department of Capital improvements
Evaluation Committee Final Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB. Project B-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
Committee Member
BEA International
E. Verner Johnson
Freelon/Judson
Olson Sundberg
Alex Peraza
1
3
1
4
Basil Binns
1
4
2
3
Carolyn Mitchell
1
4
3
2
David Shorter
1
3
2
4
Marcel Douge
2
3
1
4
Steve Stuempfle, Phi/
1
4
2
3
Average Score
1
4
2
3
CIPCAT Chair: Meredith J. Nation
Date: September 13, 2006
ECM114
Signature'`
I
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Final Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
Committee Member
BEA International
E. Verner Johnson
FreelonlJudson
Olson Sundberg
Alex Peraza
95
78.5
95
75.5
Basil Binns
97
56
95
64
Carolyn Mitchell
David Shorter
93
50
89
90
94
81
88
65
Marcel Douge
91
76
93
72
Steve Stuempfle, Ph.D
97
79
93
82
Total Scoring Points
567
420.5
553
448.5
CIPCAT Chair: Meredith J. Nation _ Signature
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 114
tak
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form,.
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
ems;
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEA Intl
E. Verner Johnson
Freelon/Judson
Olson Sundberg
Proposers Experience & Qualifications
30
2466
I4-
°1..Str.
27, 5
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
"1.?,, =
7.2.
1- ,r;
. 1
Project Manager and sub -consultants
`
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
'c
35
72
Total Score
100
c
7.b.*5
r
t r ,
Ranking
1
3
1
4
Explanation of Ranking
e;
-. . i _, r Y- y 1 - s. - r jI
., 1 R '_'�,,t —.�. k.E ,F �iA!.["
s`
G*+lM`vr't • ,,, KG';
fi.
; 14 ,wC:.:-f_P k v , i' . - t—
` 1ig4j4,-0 .....iNO.i ,... O.,. —
`, ti`i--•lbWf: t, F-
i
,',
7 1 .;d r-A-1 . \‘\ ` ' Y� '} i {
'ILA
1' .4 'tia,"," 1; VI 1 } �_ 0 }
� ., .C.-'..C..
;',,S;: .) —T.1,� ,/}f \.)!,,"'^ .:� '"'`"-
.l�L'.t ,. _
; J` mot- Az
Name of Committee Member: ��
A`1"`
-
Signature:
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFD No. 05-06-081
--
ems'/ Y-
=..
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEA Intl
E. Verner Johnson
FreelonlJudson
Olson Sundberg
Proposers Experience & Qualifications
30
rri
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
�2 i
Z �a
Z ` _i
2- C)
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
--'
,�
='
; =:
Total Score
100
7 1
(
z `3
Ranking
/
...3
2
-7
Explanation of Ranking
t
-t ' -f 5 U 1'•v f C-- X (i, r--e 1,--c-c, 4--ki 1
to L0 TC`4 G7,, 0,, Ai vJ -' : LjVi +VL C.i .;:ti4''.{2 JV% c-
72 zv
�`1`,�:- �i i L, 1 �3 „ 1 "S-
7
i}1 ^i \ �. 1 f�ifiCv t'�,- aj �Y?i,.3i) f'f !� i,'-,/,:
y -1
i_ jAkA-v i- 01, 6- i1) -P . t s f�
ff_ q ,4 GGLi
-LV
3 . ` v.r-e L. 0 `.. � ;,c5-oi� - Cc : C. 10
ji? VC'
Cc)•N_A if)
��CJ
�.
r V` S r c 1/
.�5.�+ �iU�t
,Aviel
"+ L..r c iiJ I �i. J
[' lr.ut<fi' �" L ['. 1 �
4 . 0(So/tii svrL0k ._.. wC.•
Li.' i 'r,'T rot, %3A.47E-.7.io'✓— re PT-
Name of Committee Member:ietwt,Sigrtatur
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project 8-30508
RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
Evaluation Criteria
Proposers Experience & Qualifications
Maximum
Points
BEA Ind
E. Verner Johnson
FreelonJJudson
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
30
30
40
22
2
Olson Sundberg
f7
15
Total Score
Ranking
Explanation of Ranking
100
93I
6
3
r
` r -z 'icer-eci c.3't GLvj -est. e-- it,' "
tp cene-e—t 'H&c_ A-1-0 v\%---eArr. a,
ter, :t om .vn€.Q
ceartywo.Arcb.k4 ct-kkAL. _
k�.
1
Name of Committee Member: C>
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
Signature:
7 2
,00.h.ydbe
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
_1 �•.
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
r
BEA Intl
E. Verner Johnson
Freelon/Judson
Olson Sundberg
Proposer's Experience & Qualifications
30
,acrl
a IF
,
air ,
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
A9
a3
- ,'z
•,-,
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
3CI
` r1
3 `f
Total Score
100
Cri
' l I.
9 -3
S ?.
Ranking
I
Li
3
Explanation of Rankings
Name of Committee Member: e )vEtiPr�- �� Signature: j},'ttn
t
Date: September 13, 2006
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFQ No. 05-06-081
�;; _are
�'
�_:� -_
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
BEAD
-
E. Verner Johnson
FreelonlJudson
Olson Sundberg
Proposer's Experience & Qualifications
30
�_L ;,
y..-
F
s a
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
.' 7.
"
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
c-
?':
--`
Total Score
100
-
Ranking
(
9
7
Explanation of Ranking
may,•
< . en.- r , _
. -{ r.
Gr.., r ? is ' `(
1
e
1 I .. f
! f
Name of Committee Member: Carat? Lty„ fri. ,I/1-e i 1 Signature: ( c t 5/e 4-
Date: September 13, 2006
/
Form 113
City of Miami
Department of Capital Improvements
Evaluation Committee Ranking Form
Project Title: Professional Design Services for a Museum at VKB, Project B-30508 RFP/RFCI No. 05-06-081
Evaluation Criteria
Maximum
Points
-
BEA Intl
E. Verner Johnson
Freelonkludson
-
Olson Sundberg
Proposer's Experience & Qualifications
30
Experience of Project Team, including key personnel
30
:.? ::
. ,-)
Project Manager and sub -consultants
Knowledge of Project and Project Approach
40
,
-, .
7
Total Score
100.,—
,
/ f ,
,-,
Ranking
/
--,
2
Explanation of Ranking
A dus so...i -6. 9-44litis it 'ea
ffee- ..."!-- kPlti Ref t (-cos il ., AIL
4 ii`ii k frit a to ;road, -Iv 14, rieur
L49.4--
Cr'* t‘t 4%4W-1. had evat,
061i '144 Ai- 4ilan 4(
(.4 c,(Ii.e.x., -idie few 95 eigio14
Rif g12161 t7.7*',Seil eipeduthd 4- i . za-,441-17045
5 fit / tof , Elcoail ' 3 leagn 41.4) A4P4 4
stp- iuviev gie. L ce a.... -Trit c...uctiLde.
4 wertiku si 4 044, 0 EA h it' 4ii
Name of Committee Member: 8t AA 4- brag
Signature:
Date: September September 13, 2006
_____________________
-
Form 113
Form