The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutSubmittal-Amanda Hand-PowerPoint PresentationSubmitted into the publicIFF record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk r' `' -POIr S*� INCO RP 'a 19 /oe PRESENTATION Appeal of PZAB Resolution R-23-108 to Uphold WarrantPZ- 23-16544 to allow for new Recreational Facility Use for the installation of new outdoor fitness equipment. 15113-Submittal-Amanda Hand- PowerPoint Presentation INTRODUCTION Staff Analysis Report No.: PZ-23-16544 Location: 1095 Biscayne Blvd (the "Property") Folio Numbers 0141370730010 Miami 21 Code Transect "CS" Civic Space Zone MCNP Designation Public Parks and Recreation Commission District 2 (City Commissioner: Sabina Covo) Department of Human Service Neighborhood Service Center Downtown-Brickell Planner Sevanne Steiner, CNU-A Assistant Director Property Owner City of Miami Project Representative Nelson Fonseca, Leadex Corporation Current Use Maurice Ferre Park Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Request: I REQUEST, ZONING & AERIAL OVERVIEW OF THE SITE Pursuant to Article 4, Table 12 and Article 7, Section 7.1.1.2 and 7.1.2.4 of the Ordinance 13114 ("Miami 21 Code"), as amended, to allow for new Recreational Facility Use in a "CS" Civic Space Zone for the installation of new outdoor fitness equipment (the "Project") at Maurice Ferre Park. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk ISASE OF TREE APPROKIMETELY 2FT BELOW FINISH GRN]E OF SLAB H NEW 8' CONCRETE StAE SITE PHOTOS OF PROPOSED LOCATION SCALE: • a 1'-0" Proposed Exercise Equipment I CONCRETE EDGE 7FT FROM BASE OF TRLPa< EDGE OF 6' CONCRETE SLAB Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk SKEET NC. A-8 J EXISTING CONCRETE WALKWAY EXISTING SOLAR LIGk!TPOST IZF MDWASQ SROWARG GRCLE PI1p1}9 LEASEMENT 10.50 ISTI NG CONCRETE WALKWAY !z 9.A DRAWING: PROPOSED SITE PLAN Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Greenflelds Outdoor Fitness. 8B8-315.9039 6 www.greenfleldsfltnessxarn Proposed Exercise Equipment Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City CIe k Florida - Miami - Maurice A. Ferre Park VERSION4 REV1 - 2023-01-13 GREENFIELDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZC:, _i... ;rod ND aecpmmediea;la rr co.,• .ro pto AG Dna: 111194toorA ti 1pr iVaDONAUDA mu" WY. rt.: 3akro lglh de9m imoUrlfor,:bean exrnci N•oHd di in StiC,7'SR93i el cscCV'awrAbM;rvaludm a1G 1e dewwalgindon lieuz.uu "Alf tKr. ennaer hal boon daa rod M.PIitllead pain 5 Warrant Review Criteria 7.1.2.4(d) • Compliance with Miami 21 • The intent of the Transect • The guiding principles of the Miami 21 Code ANALYSIS CRITERIA FOR APPROVAL Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk • The manner in which the proposed Use will operate given its specific location and proximity to less intense Uses Article 4, Table 12, Design Review Criteria, as applicable Miami 21 Code MIAMI 21 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk • Pursuant to Article 7, Sections 7.1.2.4.d, it is found that the Applicant has submitted the necessary information to the Planning Department and Office of Zoning which demonstrates compliance with the guidelines and criteria required for this type of permit, as specified in the Miami 21 Code, including Article 4, Table 12. • Planning comments were provided in ePlan pursuant to a comprehensive review of the application materials. All comments have been addressed through the ePlan review process. • Pursuant to Article 7, Section 7.1.2.4.c of the Miami 21 Code, it is found that notices were sent to all Abutting property owners and registered associations in the Commission District 2 area by certified mail on or about June 1, 2023; the Planning Department received no objections for the request. • Pursuant to Article 7, Section 7.1.2.4.d of the Miami 21 Code, the City of Miami Zoning Ordinance, the application has been reviewed and found sufficient. 2.2.1 The Intent of the Transect: MIAMI 21 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk • Increasing access to the natural environment through the Baywalk, the Riverwalk, the north -south Greenway, and new Parks The Guiding Principles of the Miami 21 Code: • 2.1.3.1 The City - Guiding Principles • g. A diversity of land use should be distributed throughout the City to enable a variety of economic activity, workplace, residence, recreation and civic activity. • 2.1.3.2 The Community - Guiding Principles • d. The ordinary activities of daily living should occur within walking distance of most dwellings, allowing independence to those who do not drive. • e. A range of Open Space, including Parks, Squares and Playgrounds, should be distributed within Neighborhoods and urban centers. • g. Civic, Institutional and Commercial activity should be embedded in Mixed -Use urban centers, not isolated in remote single -use complexes. • 2.1.3.3 The Block and the Building - Guiding Principles • f. Civic Buildings and public gathering places should be located to reinforce community identity and support self-government. The manner in which the proposed Use will operate given its specific location and proximity to less intense Uses MIAMI 21 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Submitted into the publicMIAMI 21 record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Article 4, Table 12, Design Review Criteria, as applicable Building Function & Density • Ensure transitions of Density, Intensity, and Height that complement the Neighborhood context. • Calibrate Density, Intensity, and Uses to facilitate walkability and promote transit use. Submitted into the public MCNP record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Miami Comprehensive Neighborhood Plan (MCNP) • Pursuant to Goal PR-1 of the MCNP, the project advances the goal of providing sufficient opportunities for active and passive recreation to all City residents based on access to parks, recreation and open space, per capita park funding, and regular surveys of residents on park and recreation needs. • Pursuant to Objective PR-3.3 of the MCNP, Park and recreational facilities will be accessible to handicapped persons and provide opportunities for special needs groups. • The project advances Goal PR-7 of the MCNP, develop public parks and open spaces that are aesthetically appealing and enhance the character and image of the City. Conditions: or CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk 1. As per Environmental Resources Review Group condition, the applicant will need to adhere to the guidance provided within the latest certified arborist report, dated 8/30/23. Namely, that no ground disturbing activity is to be done within 20 feet of tree #1 nor is to be done within 16 feet of tree #2. The applicant must also utilize structural soil and permeable materials. 2. Pursuant to Miami 21 Code, Section 7.1.2.4(c) 4 "A Warrant shall be valid for a period of two (2) years during which a building permit or Certificate of Use must be obtained. This excludes a demolition or landscape permit. A one-time extension, for a period not to exceed an additional year, may be obtained if approved by the Planning Director. 3. The City reserves the right to inspect the site to ensure compliance with the conditions as listed. 4. Review and approval by Environmental Resources is required prior to issuance of a building permit. 5. Failure to comply with the conditions herein may result in the immediate revocation of this Warrant and shall be subject to any fines and penalties pursuant to City Code. Appeal Basis 1: APPEAL BASIS 1 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk "We dispute that the proposed development will increase the appeal or enhance Ferre Park, although admittedly this is a subjective standard." -Appellant Appeal Basis 2: More particularly, the proposed development violates key elements of the 2007 Parks Master Plan, the 2023 Parks Master Plan and the CNMP, which the planning staff did not consider. These include: • multiple provisions in the 2007 Parks Master Plan as to the role of "destination parks" and amenities that should be contained therein; 2007 ParKs iviaster r°ian proposes to provide active recreation in the downtown area (pg 105) APPEAL BASIS 2 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 , on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk • multiple provisions in the 2023 Parks Master Plan about the distribution of selected recreational amenities throughout the City; 2023 Parks Mastei Plan suggests eAercise equipment as an amenity )v community parks (parks over 4 acres, pg 176). • multiple provisions of the 2023 Parks Master Plan as it relates to the process of community input and engagement when planning for park amenities. Pursuant to Article 7, Section 7.1.2.4.c of the Miami 21 Code, it was found that notices were sent to all Abutting property owners and registered associations in the Commission District 2 area by certified mail on or about June 1, 2023; the Planning Department received no objections for the request within 30 days. proposed exercise equipment ler COMPARISON Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk AFA Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 , APPEAL BASIS 3 Appeal Basis 3: on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Within the CNMP, we argue the proposed development conflicts with the following priorities, which were absent from the analysis by the planning staff: • Policy PR-2.1.1, which requires that when recreational facilities are built in park land, development "limit building footprint on any such land, [and] will require that conversion of park land for any other purposes be subject to public procedures, and replace the converted park land with land similar in park, recreation or conservation value in terms of usefulness and location." We argue the proposed development violates this policy. • i ne proposed exercise equipment limits footprint to the necessary amount to fulfil its purpose. • Goal PR-3, which requires park development to "increase public access to all parks, recreation, facilities and open spaces". We argue that due to nature of the proposed amenities in the development, public access will be decreased. r he proposed exercise equipment adds a recreational use that is accessible to the public. Appeal Basis 3: Within the CLAMP, we argue the proposed development conflicts with the following priorities, which were absent from the analysis by the planning staff.- AFAAPPEAL BASIS 3 (continued) Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk • Objective PR-3.2.8, which requires that development "enhance the public's visual and physical access to waterfront areas" and Policy PR-3.2.8 which says "all renovations and improvements to City parks and recreational facilities will be designed to enhance rather than obstruct waterfront views." We argue that the proposed amenities clearly violate these objectives and policies The proposed exercise equipment does not obstruct waterfront views or access. • Objective PR-4.1, which asks that park development "continue to improve the quality and diversity of recreational programs offered at destination and community parks, and neighborhood parks where such programs may be offered." We argue the proposed development violates this objective. The pi upused exercise equipment adds a recreational use that is accessible to the public. Appeal Basis 3: APPEAL BASIS 3 (continued) Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Within the CNMP, we argue the proposed development conflicts with the following priorities, which were absent from the analysis by the planning staff: • Policy PR-5.1.2, which states priority in park development must be given to "the quality of programs in, and the physical condition of, existing park facilities and to meeting existing deficiencies, before constructing new facilities for parks and recreation" We argue the proposed development violates this policy. Policy PR-5.1.2 states that "The City's operating budget and the Capital Improvements Element (CIE) will give priority to the quality..." the project is managed by the Bayfront Management Trust. -double check • Policy PR-5.2.3, which asks that new development plans "provide opportunities for park user and neighborhood consultation in the planning and design of park and recreation facilities improvements and new parks and programs." We argue the proposed development violates this policy. Pursuant to Article 7, Section 7.1.2.4.c of the Miami 21 Code, it was found that notices were sent to all Abutting property owners and registered associations in the Commission District 2 area by certified mail on or about June 1, 2023; the Planning Department received no objections for the request within 30 days. AFA Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 APPEAL BASIS 3 (continued) Appeal Basis 3: on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Within the CNMP, we argue the proposed development conflicts with the following priorities, which were absent from the analysis by the planning staff: • Policy PR-6.1.2, which plainly states the City should work to implement the Museum Park Master Plan, and not move away from it. We argue the proposed development violates this policy. The pi °posed exercise equipment adds a new recreational use with a minor footprint in the open space that was proposed in the Museum Park Master Plan. The master plan serves a as a guiding document that can be modified. • Goal PR-8, which asks that park development "encourage the development of high quality cultural arts facilities and programs within the City. " We argue the proposed development violates this goal. The proposed exercise equipment does not impede this goal, they are not mutually exclusive. Staff Recommendation: e CONCLUSION Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Motion to APPROVE the appeal and uphold Warrant PZ-23-16544 Greenf►elIds Oufdeor Flrnass. Florida - Miami - Meurk a A. Ferri Park VERSION4 REV1-2023.01.13 GREENFIELD5 PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE PRO/aflba]MYM1NI LION. aMee Le.. daft Ctlm• e8.16 ae....• r.,•e•w.-an.aetrllw,- 681Pm 14nnCwr:en17., e: ea 2.w.-144,1,em cone. :.c.axen Iw.w,.nww.c-...40 6GRFtiw ac,ne, .Lau.•••1.•, ,, 661091 4,04,01Mna . e6.'Y + ..vr ew kon [ ?..6.0 Oa. MM.', CR+LInW A, anw.q ▪ SARA %WANE SWe19w kA ▪ LAY.R1 wL..na.•a64ma reoaaeq n UMW MI Un II.!&.Wnr.as.,a i ✓ UMW •wem x1iairwaru,wl k V.+1 Y1awLsx iurr.+al IW1•01.PaW t 1GIIt. M [5'a QlY. Mwiow( nswI Ipn 14wsL+4..+1'w... rwwrneY..air. 11l1'8 iC1' Al Ra:m CPI Greenfelds Outdoor f-1 t n ass Florida-Mieml- Maurka A. FamF Park VERSlCN4 R£V1. 2023-31.13 3REENFFIELDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR RTNESS ZONE IA; 116 107 v �a�e...rnrm..F=. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Proposed Exercise Equipment ta Green/kids Outdoor FifneBa. Florida - hoard - Maurits A. Fared Rork IIERSIDN4 REV1- 2023-01-13 GREENFFELDS PROPOSEOOJ DOOR FITNESS ZONE Wen Y611;e1Tf wareY..nF... +.a• m ugreanfieids rtroar Fitness. Florida -Mad - Pdaurka A. Ferri Park 4E17S¢N4 1-2023-¢".-13 GREENFI€LDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE • 1 !rail I141i-OM 0I.x4.1tlf00ir.•ala400. :.........i.......... a.. �.._n..ius. .v..•. Greenfields Outdoor Fitness. FParida - Miami - Maurice A. Ferr6 Park VERSION4 REV1 - 2023-01-13 GREENFIELDS PROPOSkO OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE es8418411.1s I 141,40111•MI.m11,1emae.n • Greenfields Outdoor Fitness. Florida • Miami • Maurice A Ferrel Park VERSION4 REV% - 2023-01-13 GREENFIELDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE ...sx µyYn.el...ivnc� lubmitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Proposed Exercise Equipment Greenfields Outdoor Fitness. Florida - Miami - Maurice A. Ferrk Park VERSION4 REV1 - 2023-01-13 GREENFIELDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE snail Ann. u Greenfields urdnnr Fitneae. Florida - Miami - Maurice A. Perrr Park VERSION4 REV1- 2023-01-13 GREENFIELDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE s..w.mmomm..,.pomp Submitted into the public record for item(s) PZ.3 on 01/11/2024 . City Clerk Proposed Exercise Equipment Greenfields Outdoor Fitness, Florida - Miami - Maurice A. Ferre Park VERSION4 REV1- 2023-01-13 GREENFIELDS PROPOSED OUTDOOR FITNESS ZONE Hexagon Extreme Functional Fitness Rig Thts unit offers th• fol Iowin9c Connection point for optional bane ropes This Functional Fitness Rig requires a fill attenuating surface. 1. Split Squats 2. Incline Ladder 3. Sit -Ups 4. Lat Pull -Ups 5. Sall Target 6. S-Shaped Pull -Ups 7. Leg Raises 8. Dips 9. Swedish Ladder 10. Cannonball Pull -Ups 11. Ring Rows 12. Battle Rope Attachment 13. Flag Pole 14. Captain's Chair 15. Rotating Pull -Ups e28-'216-9037 I ldeiftn a'54. CAFlI an ea,_rot..en vra�. pnuaz er.r�r.w �s�.r bi. nuc ,. ._ r. a 4a,V netts V.tclaf knee. ,rn.rx aim an •tM.. ill Ave: .Na tlao.nonl' m pwanetl:n nrscanenl,t rGtr er.flt r, lei _p W EMI Prrelm.an l•s9.aYen., Map nerralen n.f Elsn EaY;:W 1M peM a an awwla'I'.>^ tl.edpesx, 12