Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation FormProject Title: Qepartment of Capital tmprovemen EYalUatiOlitommattee Vina RankOng Form Architectural/Engineering Services for the -Orange °BowiStadiurriRedevetooment Ellerne Becket: Spillis Candela DMJM Committee Member Arquitectonica: GaryFabrikant:: John Paccione: Laura;:Biliber y Stetson:: Clines Total Ranking Points E�nal Ranking CI�CATCha�'. Date: AugUSt 16;::20.06 Form 1 i1 3 4 i i 3� 5 24- f i i 4 4- Rodriguez & Quiroga RTKL 3 3 as! S#gnature f . . Department of CalSaYMProvern q; Evaluation Conirnst:. ee an....:ng:Form ProjecTitle;: ArchitecturallEngineering:Services for`the'Orange-Bowl Stadium_Redevefopment Evaluation Criteria P.rappsers (:zperience:_8:4uaiifiraGons: . Ezperi . ante with. Similar.:Prbject§::._ . _..... • :fir:47 da..Expei»nce:; :" Max hiunl Points l=ller4+: Becket_; Spillis Candela; Ewing :Cole= Aarquetectoncca Sermeilo�;jamil -:::F1aK5 ort :::Leo: A :Daly • - HEERY Rocirignez:..::: - RTKL y 7 ti Financial.:Strerig..'an.;Proof :o , nuranee.] is is Experience: of ProjectTearn including key personnel �_ Project. Manage:rand. su_ ... su n...:::.:::. .Ext erien0ce-pfTearriAteretiets: -:; Team::Org anization_ ::-:::_:::.. i1 f `l 4-1 ! LI 5 3 3 Knowledge pf: Project:andProject-Approact: : Knowiedge=of Pioje t Issues Management:Plan::and `Approa: it 7 1`i tj 7 j� 7 is Key Staff-lnteractiorn: and Eig erience- .7 lJ iE Total: Sdote -- .....::......:..: .......:.::..:.:.:...:..:......:... Ranking: _ :.: Exptanation.:of Ranking :` Name of Committee Member Date: :August..16 200fi. 5 :Department iof Capital -Improvements' Evaluation;Com ittee Ranking.;For Project: Title: ArchitecturalIEngineering $ervices for the Orange Bowl Stadium -Redevelopment :: E.v..aluation Criter..ia:::; Propose>'s::Experience. &. flualificat icperience:with:Sin- ilar::Projects::: South FJixida:Expenenoe. :Financial Strength :and Proof of Insurance, Maximum:.; .:Points- .......ket; Spillis: • andela = 5 Ewing Cole Arquitectariicai 0 Bermello A3amit Leo:A :.Da1. Y_ 2 I:::HEERY. 9 4 Rodriguez & _ Q.u..irog..a::::: . RTKL Experience of Project:Tearn including: key personnel:_'.::_ Project. Maria:get` and.subceon5uitantS- Experience:.of Team fulemhers._:_-_: • Experience: of.Consuitants_ beam: Organization l�• 407 4- 1 fcv i; Knowledge:of.:Project:and-:Pxoje:ctApproach :: Knowledge: of: Project Jssues.:;: =: Management Plan Approach:'_::: Key:Staff:Interaetion and:Experience. 13 1 Cr? ev f4 9 13 J1 Total: score Ranking Explanation of Ranking ..:: • Name of Committee Memfer'.' Date: August :16-2006 :':: ::Cityx�f::Mtami:: Department: of Capital Improvements - .: Evaluation:'Committee'Ran .fng.;;Form • ProjectTitle: ArchitecturallEngineerinri::Services for:=the Qrange Bowl:StadiumRedevelopmer<t Proposers Experience & _Qualifications: ExpeHe..:.n:c... with: imi ar.::.. jects,::'.:::::._ e SoppyFlorida Experience::: Financial. Strength and Proof o : Insurance::::_.:::-.' Experience .of Project Team.. including key: peirOnnel Preject:Nlanager.and:sutrconsultapt . :: Experience of:Team: Members.:; Experience: of. Consultants Team Organization Knowledge:of::Projebt end:Project;Approach:•. LL; Krioivledge :af..Projectjssues Management.Plan:`aritl.Apprceit r Key: Staff lnteraction:ari:..... hence i7;. Tofat::Score Ranking Explanation of Ranking ter::::.✓mot ...:....... .:.:......... .... Name of Committee Member Date:-.Augusf.:16 Maximurri. Points :. 4d 100 Elleibe Becket Spilhs:.Candela 1 1 :ic 7 Jr 7 Ewing oe::::::. Arquitectonica air fit /3 }INT6 Bermell0`Ajamil 16 IG aft cec lfQ.KS . art.: 10 4 /0 /t? /C! Leo A.: R:al Y 7 f> 7 7 1-6 Rodriguez=8, Quiroga RTKL.:.. tz. 7 3 9 5 t? LI •epartment Capital llnp 'ovement_s` _ :: Evaluatiorn Cat imitteeRank ng Form _: Project Title Archttec#oral]Engineering`Services: or the:Orange: o* 1:_.Staditstit Redevelopment: EvaluationCriteria . • Maximum.; Elled e:.8ecket::: Spillis: Candela .::Ewing Cole Arquitectonica.: Berr ello;Alamil. :i-iDK.:Sporf, ea. Daly. Rodriguez Queroga ..... RTKL Proposers Experience: &..Qualifications Experiencewith Similar Projects ..:: :South' Florida Experience:::. :::Financial.Strengthand Proof of fa t0 /d /0 10 /0 -7 !a !ft Frperience.of.Projec{ Tears :including'l ey:personnel::: ProjeCF:Manager and sub cons tan nenre;:af Team,: Members Fes:... . Expeitence'o#;Consultants::_ Team:Organizatior Know Iedge-of:ProjectaritiPriije'et:Approa =:: Knowledge:u#.:Proiect'issues -:i Management-Planand::Appfoaeh Key:Staff interaction::ariTE eHenCe Total Score`: Ranking Explanation of Ranking Name of :Committee Member, Date August;16 2006.,. /2 ZQ 3 !G 4 rr 7 Cr fig :9Si natur:e :. oir Cityof Miami ................ . -]epartmet'.of Capital Improvements : - Evaluation:commeftee:Ranking Form ........:.:....... Project:Title:: ArchitecturallEngineering Services°:for_the.;Orange; Bow( Stadium Redevelopment::=.::: ........................:: Maximum _Points:.:: Spjllis':Cande...la DMJM: Arguitectonica Bermello Alarm!: :HOK:Sport::: • L,eo A.; Daly:. • R riguez•& 9. . -.. RTKL.... Proposers Experience.:& :Qualifications.. Experience;with::Simiiar,Projects south Finn laEzperienoe: .. inancta.-.Strength . aril - r of:0 nsurance 7 7 7 T 4 [o 1- 10 7 7 G EkOenence PrOlOct Tabin jriciudirig*ei-Perionnet Project Marraget.and._sub_conultants nence.:of:Tearn Memlaers:: E*Oerien66 61E-consutian Team.Ocganization: Knowledge of.:Ptojeef ani3 projeetNiproactr _ : kriowledge.O#P ojecttssites •. Maiiagernent Plan;and Approas . XV- 1� 5 15 IS 4 S 14 I7- 10 14 ts 14 6 �5 14 Key: Staff •Interaction: and.Eitperieoc;e:- Total.. Score: too eke i 5- 7.1. Ranking Explanation of Ranking