HomeMy WebLinkAboutEvaluation SheetRFP No. 04-05-137
AUCTION SERVICES (COOPERATIVE)
Evaluation Sheet
Evaluator. Neil Appel Date : 12/16/2005
Proposer
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
Liquidity Services, Inc.
Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
Property Bureau.Com, Inc.
101Z11-4:111771MIIIIMIIIIMIE
Evidence of
the ability,
understanding
of required
services,
capacity & skill
of firm to
perform,
including
timeliness,
stability,
availability,
marketing
efforts and
location
19
15
14
0
10
Quality, depth
& scope of
response to
proposal.
10
9
8
10
9
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services.
12
14
13
Background,
qualifications
& experience
of personnel
assigned to
the project.
13
15
13
0
Capabilities
of software
to process
transaction
expediently
for reporting
and
checkout.
and
15
15
10
Cost
20
18
15
20
10
TOTAL
92
MEM
90
MEIN
RANK ORDER
1
2
3
1
4
RFP No. 04-05-137
AUCTION SERVICES (COOPERATIVE)
Evaluation Sheet
Evaluator. Pam Thompson Date : 12/16/2005
Proposer
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
Liquidity Services, Inc.
Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
Property Bureau.Com, Inc.
I,1171r4;i i
Evidence of
the ability,
understanding
of required
services,
capacity & skill
of firm to
perform,
including
timeliness,
stability,
availability,
marketing
efforts and
location
20
18
18
0
10
Quality, depth
& scope of
response to
proposal.
10
8
7
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services_
15
0
0
10
Background,
qualifications
& experience
of personnel
assigned to
the project.
15
15
15
Capabilities
of software
to process
transaction
expediently
for reporting
and
checkout.
and
10
15
0
0�
10
10
Cost
25
25
0
18
TOTAL
70
82
66
60
RANK ORDER
1
1
3
4
RFP No. 04-05-137
AUCTION SERVICES (COOPERATIVE)
Evaluation Sheet
Evaluator. Maritza Suarez Date : 12/1612005
Proposer
aid T kx4F i $ ¢sE�e4 i
Fisher Auction Co., Inc.
Liquidity Services, Inc.
Lone Star Auctioneers, Inc.
Property Bureau.Carn, Inc.
Evidence of
the ability,
understanding
of required
services,
capacity & skill
of firm to
perform,
including
timeliness,
stability,
availability,
marketing
efforts and
location
20
20
20
20
Quality, depth
& scope of
response to
proposal.
10
10
10
10
8
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services.
10
10
10
10
Background,
qualifications
& experience
of personnel
assigned to
the project.
15
15
15
10
Capabilities
of software
to process
transaction
expediently
for reporting
and
checkout.
and
10
15
Cost
25
20
25
10
22
TOTAL
95
90
RANK ORDER
IMEEMI
80
80
1
3
0
Evidence of
the ability,
understanding
of required
services,
capacity & skill
of firm to
perform,
including
timeliness,
stability,
availability,
marketing
efforts and
location
RFP No. 04-05-137
AUCTION SERVICES (COOPERATIVE)
Evaluator: Shannon Graham Date : 12/1612005
Quality, depth
& scope of
response to
proposal.
Successful
governmental
experience &
background in
similar services.
Background,
qualifications
& experience
of personnel
assigned to
the project.
Capabilities
of software
to process
transaction
expediently
for reporting
and
checkout.
and