HomeMy WebLinkAboutSubmittal-2Miami Neighborhoods United
December 12, 2005
Mr. Otto Boudet-Murias, Chief of Planning & Economic Development
Mrs. Alicia Cuervo Schreiber, Chief of Operations
City of Miami
Miami, FL
RE: Ordinance File Number 05-01042
Development of Impact Fee and Other Related Fees
Dear Mr. Boudet-Murias and Mrs. Cuervo Schreiber:
Regarding the referenced ordinance and the accompanying study "Growth -Related Capital
Improvements & Impact Fees" prepared by TischlerBise dated September 16, 2005:
MNU proposes that in addition to citywide parks included in the proposed Parks and
Recreation Impact Fee Schedule there should be a separate Impact Fee Schedule for Local
Parks. Since separate controls will have to be established for controlling the expenditures of
this Impact Fee, it will require a separate financial account. MNU proposes that Sec. 13-12 be
subdivided. The current recommended "Parks and Recreation Impact Fee Schedule" would be
revised to "Citywide Parks and Recreation Impact Fee Schedule". A separate sub -section
would be added to cover the "Local Parks Impact Fee Schedule".
A Local Park is defined as a park less than 3 acres and within .625 miles of a development.
This Impact Fee would be collected for purchase of land and/or improvements of parks within
0.625 miles of a development and would have to be used within 6 years as per Sec. 13-16(d)(1)
or would be considered for a refund request from a current owner.
Based on data supplied by the city, MNU has identified the parks of less than 3 acres which are
within 0.625 miles of a transit corridor. Please see the map attached as Exhibit A "Local Parks
and Proximity to Transit Corridors" and Exhibit B "Miami Park Acreage and Local Park
Acreage". We have used the transit corridors as a proxy for high density areas in the current
Land Use Map.
We have prepared the following tables consistent with the TischlerBise Report:
Park Type
Acreage
Local Parks
46.3
Year Round Population
386,127 People
Proportion of Year Round
Population within .625 miles
(12.5 minute walk) of a local
park (conservative estimate)
40%
Population accessing local
parks (conservative estimate)
154,451
Local Park Level of Service
0.3 Acres per 1,000 People
Page 1
Following the MNU approach to present the Local Parks Impact Fee as a separate fee, the
following table would be appropriate.
Persons Per Housing Unit
210 Single family Detached
2.91
230 Low Rise
2.56
220 High Rise
1.69
Level of Service
Local Park Acreage per 1,000 People
0.3
Park Land Cost per Acre
$2,178,000
Land Cost per Person for Local Parks
$653
Improvements Cost per Person for Local Parks (est)
$50
Net Capital Cost Per Person
$703
Maximum Supportable Impact Fee per Housing Unit
Current
Fee
Increase
(Decrease)
$2,045
210 Single Family Detached
$2,045
$0
230 Low Rise
$1,800
0
$1,800
220 High Rise
$1,188
0
$1,188
If you determine that it would be more appropriate to present the Local Parks as part of the
overall Parks and Recreation Impact Fee, then the following table (modified TischlerBise)
could be used.
Replacement of TischlerBise Study Figure 16 — Park Impact Fee Schedule
Persons Per Housing Unit
210 Single family Detached
2.91
230 Low Rise
2.56
220 High Rise
1.69
Level of Service
Citywide Park Acreage per 1,000 People
0.9
Local Park Acreage per 1,000 People
0.3
Park Land Cost per Acre
$2,178,000
Land Cost per Person for Citywide Parks
$1,960
Land Cost per Person for Local Parks
$653
Improvements Cost per Person for Citywide Parks
$170
Improvements Cost per Person for Local Parks (est)
$50
Waterfront Park Improvements Cost per Person
$147
Pools Cost Per Person
$46
Gymnasiums Cost per Person
$33
Revenue Credit per Person
($13)
Net Capital Cost Per Person
$3,046
Page 2
Maximum Supportable Impact Fee per Housing Unit
Current
Fee
Increase
(Decrease)
210 Single Family Detached
$8,864
$0
$8,718
230 Low Rise
$7,798
$261
$7,537
220 High Rise
$5,148
$221
$4,927
MNU has also drafted appropriate changes to the proposed Ordinance.
During the Commissioner's meeting on November 17, 2005, the Commissioners were positive
about developing a separate Impact Fee for Local Parks. We trust that you will discuss this
recommendation with us and include it as an amendment to the original Ordinance Amendment
proposal for presentation to the Commissioners at the next Commission Meeting.
Sincerely,
Hadley C. Williams
Chair MCNP / Miami 21 Committee
Page 3
Submitted Into the public -
record in connection with
item Si./ on p. as
Priscilla A. Thomason
City Clerk
Miami Neighborhoods United
Local Parks and Proximity to Transit Corridors
minute walk radius
mimic,
CORRIDORS
Name of Park
Exhibit B
Miami Park Acreage and Local Park Acreage
Source: City of Miami
Analysis: Miami Neighborhoods United
Dis Address
Park Acreage Local Parks
African Square Park
Albert Pallot Park
(Magnolia Park)
Allapattah Mini Residential
Allapattah Mini Park Site
Allen Morris ( AMCO)
Antonio Maceo Park
Armbrister Park
Athalie Range Park
Bay of Pigs (Flagler
Terrace Mini Park)
Bayfront Park
Baywood Park
Belafonte -Talcocy
Belle Meade Mini Park
Bicentennial Park
Biliy Rolle Mini Park
(Coconut Grove Mini Park)
Biscayne Heights Mini Park
Biscayne Park
Blanche park
Brickell Park
Broward Circle Mini Park
Bryan Park
Buena Vista Park
City Cemetery
Coconut Grove Tennis
Courts
Coral Gate Park
Coral Nook Park
Crestwood
Cuban Memorial Plaza
Culmer Mini Park
Curtis Park
David T. Kennedy Park
Dawkins, Miller
Dinner Key Picnic Islands #4,
#5, #6
Dorsey Park
Douglas Park
Eaton Park
E. G.Sewell Park
Elizabeth Steele Mini Park
5 1400 NW 62nd Street
2 North of 36 St. on Biscayne Bay.
1 1500 NW 16th Ave
1 1935 NW 21 Ave.
2 SE 1 Ave & lost
1 5115 NW 7th St
2 236 Grand Ave
5 525 NW 62nd Street
4 SW 3rd St. & 55 Ave
2 100 Biscayne Blvd.
2 890 NE 69 St.
6161 NW 7th Ave (305) 751-
5 1295
2 768 NE 77 St
2 1075 Biscayne Blvd.
2 3410/ 3412 grand ave
2 E. Dixie Highway at NE 84 St.
2 NE 19th Street & 1st Ave
2 3045 shipping ave
2 501 Brickell Ave
1 NW 8th Ave & 15th Street
4 2301 SW 13th Street
5 200 NW 53 St.
2 1800 NE 2 Ave
2 Approx. 2975 Oak Ave
4 1415 SW 32nd Ave
4 SW 31 st Ave & 5th Street
5 NW 11th Ave & 48th Street
3 999 SW 13th Ave
NW 2nd Ave between 10th & 11th
5 Street
1 1901 NW 24 Ave
2 2400 S. Bayshore Dr.
5 NW 8th Ave & 47th Terr.
2 Biscayne Bay
21701 NW 1st Ave
2 2795 SW 37th Ave
2 6015 NE 4th Court
1 1815/1825 NW South River Drive
2 South Bayshore Drive & Hiawatha
Page 1 of 3
1.17 1.17
3.00 3
0.33
0.40
0.10
3.65
5.13
11.85
1.00
61.30
1.87
3.09
0.40
30.30
0.33
0.4
0.1
1
1.87
0.4
0.17 0.17
0.04 0.04
7.32
1.50 1.5
2.20 2.2
0.25 0.25
2.07 2.07
1.20 1.2
10.00
0.30
3.62
0.25
1.00
0.20
0.60
27.70
20.89
1.00
56.70
2.52
10.00
6.21
10.33
0.3
0.25
1
0.2
0.6
1
2.52
0.50 0.5
Submitted Into the public
record in connection with
item S-__k.j on / ,s *-
Priscilla A. Thomp on
City Clerk
Name of Park
Exhibit B
Miami Park Acreage and Local Park Acreage
Source: City of Miami
Analysis: Miami Neighborhoods United
Dis Address
Park Acreage Local Parks
Elizabeth Virrick Park
Ernesto Lecuona Park
Fern Isle Park
Flagami Mini Park
Fort Dallas
Gibson Park
Glen Royal Mini Park
Grapeland Park
Grove Mini Park
Hadley Park
Henderson Park
Highland Circle Mini Park
Japanese Garden & Boat
Launch
Jose Marti Park
Juan Pablo Duarte (Allapatah
Comstock) Park
Kenneth Myers Park
Kinloch Park
Kirk Monroe
Legion Park
Legion Picnic Island #2
Lemon City Park
Lincoln Park
Little River Commerce
Lummus Park
Margaret Pace Park
Marjorie Stoneman Douglas
(Silver Bluff Mini Park)
Martell Park
Maximo Gomez Park(Domino
Park)
Melrose Park
Merrie Christmas Park
Meyers
Miami River Rapids
Miami River Walk
Moore Park
Morningside Park
Morningside Picnic Island #3
North Bay Vista
Oakland Grove
Pace Park picnic Islands #1
Paul Walker Mini Park
2 3255 Plaza St.
3 900 SW 1st Street
1 2201 NW 11 St.
4 7121 SW 3rd Street
2 60 SE 4th Street- (Butler Buildg).
5 401 NW 12th Street
3 NW 22nd Ave & Glen Road
1 1550 NW 37th Ave
3 NW 8th Street from 15th to 17th Ave
5 1300 NW 50th Street
3 971 NW 2nd Street
5 NW 8th Ave. & 13 St.
3 351 SW 4th Street
1 2800 NW 17th Street
2 27th Ave & S. bayshore Dr.
1 455 NW 47th Ave
2 3101 Oak Avenue
2 6447 NE 7th Ave
2 N/A
5 27 NE 58 St.
2 2950 Jackson Ave
5 8024 NE 2 Ave
2 404 NW 3rd Street
N. Bayshore Drive btn. 17th Terrace
2 & 20th St.
2 2901 SW 22nd Ave
2 NE 36th Street & 7th Ave
3 1444 SW 8th St.
1 NW 30th Street & 25th Ave
2 Le June Rd& Barbarosa St.
1 2900 S. River Drive
2 SE 2 Ave to Brickell Bridge
5 765 NW 36th Street
2 750 NE 55th Terrance
2 Biscayne Bay
5 4850 NW 6th Ave
5 NE 3rd Ave & 84th Street
2 S. of Julia Tuttle Cswy.
2 46 West Flagler St.
Page 2 of 3
4.65
0.25
8.41
1.02
0.65
8.04
0.20
20.00
0.50
29.70
3.50
0.25
3.50
5.60
9.16
10.00
3.49
1.44
13.70
11.48
2.30
0.22
0.50
5.90
12.00
0.25
1.02
0.65
0.2
0.5
0.25
1.44
2.3
0.22
0.5
0.50 0.5
0.60 0.6
0.11
2.60
5.39
10.00
0.85
0.70
19.60
42.38
19.28
0.50
0.20
11.02
0.11
2.6
0.85
0.7
0.5
0.2
0.12 0.12
Submitted Into the public
record in connectio with
item See • / on /fit is oS
Priscilla A. Th son
City Clerk
Name of Park
Exhibit B
Miami Park Acreage and Local Park Acreage
Source: City of Miami
Analysis: Miami Neighborhoods United
Dis Address
Park Acreage Local Parks
Peacock Park
Pine Heights Mini Park
Plaza De Cubanidad
Pullman Park
Rainbow Village
Range Park #1
Reeves Park
Riverside Park
Roberto Clemente Park
Robert King High Park/Carlos
Arboleya Campground
Shenandoah Park/Pool
Simonhoff
Simpson Park
South Bay Vista
Southside Park
Spring Garden Point
Stearns Park
Torch of Friendship
Town Park
Triangle Park
Twelve Ave Mini
Unity Hall Park
Virginia Key other acreage
VK Beach Beach Park
VK Beach & Hammock
VK Nature Walk in
association with county
Virrick Gym
Wainwright Park
Watson Island
West Buena Vista
West End Park
Willams Park
Woodson Park
Total
2 2820 Mcfarlane Road
NW 16th Street btn. 8th Ave & 8th
1 Court
3 Flagler Street & 17th Ave
5 N. Miami Ave & NW 49st.
5 2001 NW 4 Ct.
5 Under 1-95 btn.10 & 11 St.
5 600 NW 8th Street
3 SW 8th Ave & 3rd St.
2 101 NW 34th Street
4 7025 W. Flagler Street
4 2111 SW 19 St Ave
5 NW 54th Street & 18th Ave
3 85 SW 17th Road
5 NW 6th Ave btn. 46th & 47th Streets
3 140 SW 11th Street
5 601 NW 7 Street
2 South of NE 38th Street & 6th Ave
2 100 Biscayne Blvd.
5 1686 NW 4th Ave
3 SW 15th Road & 11th St.
5 NW 12 Ave & 62st
5 NW 16th Terr. & NW N. River Drive
East of Biscayne Bay & North of
2 Rickenbacker Cswy.
2 2600 S. Bayshore Drive
2 2845 Bricked Ave
2 McArthur Cswy.
5 NW 45 St & 11 Ct.
4 250 SW 60 Ave
5 1717 NW 5th Ave
2 NE 36th St. NE 2nd Ave
Page 3 of 3
9.40
0.25
0.25
0.40
1.52
0.11
3.44
3.50
4.89
17.00
10.00
1.50
8.21
0.20
2.23
1.14
5.40
N/A
0.86
0.50
NIA
0.26
317.00
77.00
72.00
20.00
4.46
21.44
51.96
1.10
6.94
5.03
0.40
1208.86
0.25
0.25
0.4
1.52
0.11
1.5
0.2
2.23
1.136
0.86
0.5
0.26
1.1
0.4
46.29
Submitted Into the public'
record in connection with
item Sf• I on 1> s os
Priscilla A. Tho p on
City Clerk