HomeMy WebLinkAboutattachmentBATTACHMENT B - EVALUATION SUMMARY
Construction Engineering & Observation Services - HORIZONTAL
Consultant
Marlin Engineering, Inc
Keith and Sdrners. PA
The Cafridino Group. Inc.
Consul -Tech Construction Management,
Inc.
Nova Coneulinn* Inc.
Trumbull Corporation
Barmello% Ajama.& Partners
Metric Engineering. Inc.
0BF Enginerrin0. Inc.
A2 Group, Inc.
Parsons Brkldketilo1V Construction Services,
Inc.
ICoaa, Castilla Cabana Thompson Selman,
PA.(C3T8)
Semite Reboil San➢, Inc.
0▪ irnamio Corporate Consultants, Inc.
P148 Engineering Corporation
A&P Consulting Transportation Eng_irn•rs
7Lin M Associates, Inc.
A.D.A. Engineering, Ina
Vlllanueve Aseodates, Inc.
belts Consulting Engineers Design Grp.
Inc.
EBS Engineering, Inc.
GES Consultants, Inc.
RPO No. 03.04-131
Evaluation Summary • Rank Oder
Jorge
Cano
1
4.
8
2
12
15'
6
9
10'
3
7
6
11
18
13
18
14
,,.17,. •
15
20
11
19
' Stephanie Scott
Grindall Pritchard
2 10
g 3
3 4
10 1
2 2
7 5
8 6
4 8
12 18
5 9
8 18
d 17
13 11
3 2a
11 15
10.0.061. 24«ryA•
17 14
9 19
16 23
18 22
Fernando
Paiva
1
4
4
15
8
10
12
11
13
6
15
9
8
10
11
2
9
12
12
16
8
7
TOTAL
14
20
20
24
29
29
30
32
35
38
37
40
45
48
48
49
49
54
69
50
84
85
87
RANK ORDER
1
2
2
3
4
4
6
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
12
13
13
14
16
15
17
18
19
Pistarhw & Nam Consulting Engineers. Inc. 17 21
R. J. Behar 8 Comps . Ina 21 11 20 16 87 19
Rodriguez Peterson & Prams Architects,
inc. r 24 , _ 18 13 14 ' 87 19
meting Engineering a Sdenos. Inc. 23 18 26 17 53 20
PPuriusnl to 6adba 11-74 or the City of Mimi 0relwks No,12241, •'Cone *1 = is Ynpc.sd upon mob RUT, R 0. RPLI, or WO altar ads
and 1Mednets at me erns the City Meager Issues a Olen rscanomendrtbn w the MIYnI Cb CcmmNNon. The Cone of Slims sew be applicable only b
Coloreds for te provision of goods end merlon and ingagaggigggit rw�rw Roes. RPQ RFU. a Ins public arks or «gam�onsa far amount greater awn 2200,000. Tna Cone or Bwnos grains
• patmael vendors, eevka providers. bidden, bbbyisb or oxidant send the CPO protessicost stair including, bur snot Inked*. the CPI Menegsr and me
Coy managers etfrvoodoo,
. isMayor, 0 * C bidders,
s, nsni,lobbyist
aorr oonsuwds, any member d arse CIO peal �• �' oepeebnent Modem cr our
gist respecavo stairs:
, moms vsrdces. swiss previdara, btddua, Isbbyiq
respedhre stags esd any member of 1M respect" steclionieveluollon commilaa.
22
On October 18, . the Evaluation Committee reconvened and agreed to recommend en award 01' contract to_ 1- (quantity) fine
ranked through (rank number).
i Jorge Cano
e Grinds!!
Scott Pritchard
Fernando Palva
2
3
4
6
8
7
a
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
18
17
15
19
20
21
22
28
28
DOC (4).max
ATTACHMENT B
Construction Engineering & Observation Service - Vertical
RFC/ No. 03-04-131
Evaluation Summary - Rank Order
Consultant ,
Grou • Inc. .
' Jorge Csno
Stephanie
Grindell
Scan Pritchard
Fernando
Pahre
TOTAL,
RANK
ORDER
lid ummitzere—inom®umailmU,
, Castello Carballo ' :
• pson•S.Iman, P.A. (CM)
.
2
1
15
3
•
21
r
1
nddgo Service Corporation .
, . 5
8
4
5 .
22 .
2 .
Russel Partnership, InC
7
1
13
1
_
22'
_2 '
Nov. Gowning, Inc.
15
7
1
1
24
3
idlest; Construction .:
anapement, Inc.
6
2
7
11
26
4
Benno*, Afamtl a Partner
' 1
13
3
• id
27
" 5
dangle Associates, Inc.
12
v 5
— 10
2
_ 29
6 -
nrmbuN Corporaion
18
3
2
6
29
B '..
stria Engineering, Inc.
18
4
5
6 _
30
7
e BF Engineering. Inc.
_
15
4
. 5
5
33
a
-:• • riguez Peterson 8 Parrs
fleas, Inc. •9
7
_
14 •
3
33
8'
,-arsons 8dnclerhaff '
BeMas, Ina
8
8
8
4
14
34
,
a
- istorton S Adam Consulting
• , Inc. '
4
'
12
17
4
• 37
10
p,*ct Management,
19
9
9
7
_
44
11 •
118 Engineering Corporation
11
14
8
12
45
18 1
tdo Architect, Ina
" 10
_
10
le
9
_
45
.12
Red Design Group, L• LC
14
14
12
12 •
52
13
ES Consultants, Inc.
13
11
19
11 .
• 114
. 1.4
- J. Behar d Company, Ind
17
'
18
18 .
1
13
63 L
18
nds Gevsloprrtant
nagement LLC
20
18
'
20
r
6 —
70 _
16
uant to = - 18-74 • tha'CNy of Mlanli • • Inane No. 1 r 1, a 'Cone "" fs imposed upon tech RFP, �
, or IFB after advertisement and terminates at the time the City Manager issues a written raaoinmsndetlon to the Miami Cly
The Cons •o} Silence shah be applicable only to Contracts for the tin of goods and services and for public
or city improvements for amounts granter than 8200,000. The Cone of Sisnos problbita •env communicating rsgaldhrg '
> RFOs, Raiser IFBs (bids) between, among others:
Potential vendors, ssrvlca provider, bidders, lobbyists or annuitants and the Clty'a profsislon.l staff including, but not limited
o, the City Manager end the City Manages staff, the Mayor, City Commissioners, or their respective staffs;
• potenitrd vendors, service pnovld.m, bidders, lobbyist or consultants, any member of the CNy's professional staff, City
par went Directors or their respective staffs end any member oldie respective eelectIonlsvakistlon commits.. .
On October 18, 2004, the BvaIyCommittes re-comened'end agreed to rornmweird en rd of contract to 10
(quantity) firms ranted through' • (rank number).1 r .....
Jorge Cano
tephanie Grindefl
Scott Pritchard
Fernando Paiva
3
4
. 5
6
7
a
9
t0
11
12
13
14
15
18
17
18
19
20
21
DOC (4),max