HomeMy WebLinkAboutbenefit plan 1MRFP # 03-04-066 - EMPLOYEE BENEFIT HEALTH PLAN Final Tabulation Results
Proposers
Consensus
Scorin
AvMed
BlueCross BlueShield of Florida
CIGNA
253
254
270
Rankin •.
3
2
1
Recommended in rank
order
*
United Healthcare
CBCA (not short-listed)
United Benefits (not short-listed)
Vista (not short-listed)
240
American Stop Loss
out of 300 points
59
3
*
AvMed
BlueCross BlueShield of Florida
CBCA
48
61
50
2
*
CIGNA
United Benefits
United Healthcare
BlueCrose BlueShield of Florida
54
68
53
90
4
1
ants
2
t
*
CBCA
80
Caremark
CIGNA
81
94
1
Express Scripts
SystemedlMedco
United Benefits
88
83
82
3
*
United Healthcare
84
Vista (N / A as fully insured)
Walgreens
0
85
* out of 100
oints
f
AvMed
82
BlueCross BlueShield of Florida
85
3
*
CBCA
87
2
*
CIGNA
95
1
United Healthcare
52
* out of 100 points
Evaluation Committee Members:
Mr. Charlie Cox, President of AFSCME Local 1907
Mr. Edward Pidermann, Presidneet of IAFF Local 587
Mr, Joseph Simmons, President of AFSCME Local 871
Ms. Ramona Fiumara, Assistant Dir. of Risk Management
Mr. Stuart Myers, Advisor to the City Manager
Ms. Ana Gonzalez -Fajardo, Deputy Director Labor Relations
Ms. Denise Morales, Group insurance Supervisor