The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutExhibit 4City of Miami Department of Capital improvements Program Evaluation Committee Final Ranking Form Project Title., Design Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, B-303058 RFP 08.09-064 Committee Member MBR Construction Recreational Design and Construction, Inc. Marcel Douge, Senior Project Manager, CIP 91.1 106.9 Gregory Gay, Planner 11, Community j Planning 90.1 104.9 Bobby Starkes, Executive Assistant to the I Director. Partes and Recreation 116.1 129.9 Jessica Pacheco, Sr. Staff Counsel, CRA 106.1 115.9 Emanuel Washington, Construction I Mana er, Miami-Dade County 112.1 109.9 Bonus Points X5 30 30 Total Score 545.5 597.5 I i j Final Ranking 2 1 i �```"'� ✓�.e 1 Name of Committee Chairperson; —_ Date: October 14. 2009 City of Miami _- Capital Improvements Program Project Title: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, B -30305B RFP 08-0"84 Recreational Design and Evaluation Criteria Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Construction, Inc. Qualifications & Experience of the •�' J Pro oser yF^ v%t , Qualification & Experience of the J t fs " Team„. �1a - :u r t,.,%.• a. .., ,.” . ,, . .... .,.: k�X,t��3. ��5�'i�..�ai, "}�-'3��i1��%ithi � i.��'a�3�a7i. _ 87E . -1,100 ��MRc�Fi MUM Qualifications of Project & w >�E}� aT %4 Construction Managers y Design & Construction Approach and Process c•. nils_. ,. iR`P t -j5> MNl`i•�.:gYi�'�l.'��tiLY'�.t �.l,da� r�6.l+i��421".'�+: �N1�d�v4 Technical Capabilities s 10 i a Local Workforce Participation 13:. c s;5Ilm Price Proposal -Phase 1 Price Proposal -Phase 2 ` Total Score i( Ranking Exolanation of Ranking (Optional) Committee Member: Date: October 7, 2009 Total Score "" t XI l Ranking (Committee Member:x— Date: October 7. 2009 City of Miami Capital Improvements Program Project Title: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, B -30306B RFP 08 -Dg -064 Recreational Design and Evaluation Criteria Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Construction, Inc. Qualifications & Experience of the f Proposer d «od.. st'� 4�'S� r,- t 'i...t.,�� y,yyttyy' r,,�s ti>n"s. LEiiu5+ii�•t£p '3�i�f,�F..xTi�-':�:5 i Qualification & Experience of the t ° : " Wx Team s �Y.i: . t vi r .."it •`;i! .cM Si'�.1 r�''"'n�. '„��'��,'.- k�.v��'�'t"iix�:a'k�.. � 'w.'�°., .� . Qualifications of Project & Construction Managers Design & Construction Approach and Process ... 1, .5 air 10± hi?L• f,x.. �. ..l.:.v ��-`.�..'v� 1, -:;;i� y 47-: �2 T!T°.^��Sr�x}'��:� �ye�eA �l.•,'-i �G:1T�t��v'�3i;f?�rt. .-��` $� �y An dr'+f iii 'Yik �A� Technical Capabilitiesu.�0..:tA`.K Ilx•t��A �C(J Local Workforce Participation ` .<- Price Proposal -Phase i 15. < (Price Proposal -Phase 2 10 .. l ITotal Score Ranking Explanation of Rankina (Optional) Committee Member. Date: October? 2009 City of Miami "f Capital Improvements Program Project Title: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, B30305B RFP 0"9-064 Recreational Design and Evaluation Criteria Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Construction, Inc. Qualifications & Experience of the f Proposer =.r: 'r 26>i �:.,.?i - Qualification & Experience of the st Team 36'b'r Ni A I j i Qualifications of Project & k Construction Managers �; 10 s Design &Construction Approach and ,. Process .. Y,7}i sae•• ,'i. �, ':Va i:?'�A'i 1"fte` h�?�lN7A8_�{tlielic." .i'�.^a i �}'��"xe,SY�:Yr`�J Technical Ca abilities Local Workforce ParticipationNOWNINUffidum Price Proposal-Phase I r *, iPrice Proposal-Phase 2 yy yeQ Ranking Explanation of Ranking IOptionall Committee Member. c Date: October 7 2009 City of Miami Capital improvements Program Evaluation Committee Ranking Form Project Title: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, B-303056 RFP 08-09-064 Bonus Points Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Recreational Design and Construction, Inc. Utilization of Certified Subcontractors less than 5% of the construction value 0 0 0 A Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 6% & 10% of the construction value 1 ^ ` 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 10°k & 75°h of the construction value 2 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 16%&20% of the construction value 3 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors in excess of <3 20% of the construction value ". 4' _ , 4 4 Sim Proposer has sucessfuily completed a LEER Silver or greater project 1' 0 0 Proposer and Prime Design Firm have together successfully completed LEED Silver or greater r . `.U. projects f- 2 91 0 0 Design Build Firm and Primary Consultant have worked together to successfully complete more - q„ than t ark project as defined b the RFP 2: Vii, 0 0 i Proposer has sucessfully completed more than i three 3 Design Build Projects One or more Park Project as defined by the RFP yui} that Includes a pool 1 f 1 1 Total Scare -Bonus Points 6 6 Committee Member: 6 Meeting Data: October? 2009 I Clty of Miaml Capital Improvements Program �rvr Evaluation Committee Ranking Form Project Tdie: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of.Gibson Park, B -30305B RFP 08.09-064 Bonus Points Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Recreational Design and Construction, Inc. Utilization of Certified Subcontractors less than 6% ' of the construction value i`0 ,' ;" 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 6% & 10% of the construction value 1 .rn 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 1001.&16% of the construction value 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > } 16%&20% of the construction value J3 0 0 l `I Utilization of Certified Subcontractors in excess of 20% of the construction value p . A.,.:. 4 4 Proposer has sucessfully completed a LEED Sliver or greater project 0 0 Proposer and Prime Design Firm have together successfully completed LEED Sliver or greater projects „ ?; 2 3'. t rh 0 0 Design Build Firm and Primary Consultant have worked together to successfully complete more�� than 1 park prolect as defined by the RFP ;z2 ;'c irk 0 0 Proposer has sucessfully completed more than three 3 Design Build Projects 1 1 1 'One or more Park Project as defined by the RFP that includes a pool 1 1 1 Total Score -Bonus Points 6 6 Committee Member. /i r -- Meeting Date: October 7, 2009 I City of Miami t Capital improvements Program Evaluation Committee Ranking Form Project Tide: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, B-305058 RFP 08.09-084 Bonus Points Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Recreational Design and Construction, Inc. Utilization of Certified Subcontractors less than 5% or the construction value Or 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > { 5%& 10% of the construction value ;1 f..,>, ... 0 6 "A Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 10%&IS%of the construction value 02 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > , 16%&20% of the construction value 3 D D Utilization of Certified Subcontractors in excess of i 20% of the construction value : `: A s 4 4 Proposer has sucessfully completed a LEED Silver or rester nrolect 1; 'u 0 0 roposer and Prime Design Firm have together successfully completed LEED Silver or greater ro"ects `�' 0 0 Design Build Firm and Primary Consultant have w worked together to successfully complete more than 1 park projeet as defined b the RFP 2. ! 0 0 WONNOW Proposer has sucessfully completed more than three 3 Design Build Pro eoft j 1 t One or more Park Project as defined by the RFP v that Includes a pool Total Score -Bonus Points 6 6 Committee Member. Meeting Date: October7,2009 City or Miami Capital Improvements Program Evaluation Committee Ranking Form Project'ntle: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, 0.30305B RFP 0&0&064 Bonus Points Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Recreational Design and Construction, Inc. Utilization of Certified Subcontractors less than 6% 5 of the construction value 0 t 0 0 Ewa Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > 5%. &10% of the construction value 1' ..... , z . .. ? 0 0 s7 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between> 10°k & 15°Je of the construction valuer+2 0 0 NUNN Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > U, `x 15% & 20% of the Construction value 3 �; 0 0 -10 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors in excess of 20% of the construction value d . _.... 4 4 Proposer has sucessfully completed a LEED Silver 0 successfully completed LEED Silver or greater Design Build Firm and Primary Consultant have worked together to successfully complete mare than 1 nark nrolaat (as defined by the RFPs 2, 4 __ —0 Proposer has sucessfully completed more than three 3 Design Build Projects i j One or more Park Project as defined by the RFP that includes a pool 1 Committee Member. Date�irnad: City of Miami Capital improvements Program Evaluation Committee Ranking Fonn Project Title: Design Build Services for the Design and Construction of Gibson Park, &303056 RFP 08.09-084 bonus Points Maximum Points MBR Construction, Inc. Recreational Design and Construction, Inc. Utilization of Certified Subcontractors less than M, of the construction value s0 ;, : ":+ra 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between >i 5% &10% of the construction value 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > w' 10%M15% of the construction value _... .,2 ... _. _.: , , 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors between > s , >a, tr 15%& 20% of the construction value 0 0 Utilization of Certified Subcontractors in excess of 20% of the constructlon value 4 4 Proposer has sucessfully completed a LEED Silver .f Tttt or greater project -,._., 1 ......,... _..,,'x 0 0 a ui Proposer and Prime Design Firm have together successfully completed LEED Silver or greater projects a` 2 �h 0 0 Design Build Firm and Primary Consultant have worked together to successfully complete more than 1 park project as defined by the RFP Y 0 0 Proposer has sucessfully completed more than three 3 Design Build Projects 1' 1 1 One or more Park Project as defined by the RFP that Includes a pool Total Scare -Bonus Points B 8 Z Committee Member: D� meeting Date: October 7. 2009