HomeMy WebLinkAboutVol. I. Sec. C.1. Economic Impact Studywe I Tho Wnshington
Fcnnomitics Group, Inc. -
THE ECONOMIC IMPACTS
OF THE FLORIDA MARLINS ON THE CITY OF MIAMI.
DEVELQPMENTAND RECURRING PHASES
Prepared by:
The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
October 3, 2008
(Revised on January 28, 2009)
2655 Lejeune Road, Suite 608
Carat Galles, Florida 33134
Tck 305.461.3811 — Fax: 345.461.3822
info@weg.com
www- veg.com
U au
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. BACKGROUND....................................................................................................................1
II. THE ECONOMIC IMPACTS DURING THE DEVELOPMENT PHASE OF THE
FLORIDA MARLINS BALLPARK ON THE CITY OF MIAMI................................................3
III. THE RECURRING ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF THE FLORIDA MARLINS TEAM
OPERATIONS ON THE CITY OF MIAMI..............................................................................9
IV. POTENTIAL ECONOMIC IMPACTS ASSOCIATED WITH BASEBALL'S ",JEWEL"
EVENTS...... ................................................................................................................. ...... 15
V. CONCLUSION....................................................................................................................17
APPENDIX I: METHODOLOGY..................................................................................................18
APPENDIX II: DETAILED IMPACT TABLES................................................................................21
APPENDIX.III: THE WASHINGTON ECONOMICS GROUP, INC. PROJECT TEAM AND
QUALIFICATIONS................................................................................................33
0
List of Tables
Table 1. Summary of the Economic Impacts Arising from Development of the
Florida Marlins Ballpark...............................................................................................4
Table 2.
Person Years of Employment Arising from Development of the Florida
MarlinsBallpark...........................................................................................................5
Table 3.
Labor Income Impacts Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins
Ballpark.........................................................................................................................
F
Table 4.
Miami GDP Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark....................6
Table 5,
Economic Output Impacts Arising from Development of the Florida
MarlinsBallpark...........................................................................................................7
Table d.
Fiscal Contributions Attributable to Development of the Florida Marlins
Ballpark.........................................................................................................................
Table 7.
Summary of Annual (Recurring) Economic Impacts Arising from Florida
Marlins Team Operations in the New Ballpark..........................................................1D
Table S.
Recurring Employment Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins Team
Operations...................................................................................................................
11
Table 9.
Recurring Labor Income Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins Team
Operations...................................................................................................................
I I
Table 10.
Recurring Miami GDP Arising from Florida Marlins Team Operations....................12
Table 11.
Recurring Economic Output Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins Team
Operations...................................................................................................................13
Tabie 12.
Recurring Fiscal Contributions of Florida Marlins Team Operations ........................13
Table 13.
Sales Tax Generated at the Completed Florida Marlins Ballpark ...............................
I4
1. BACKGROUND
The Washington Economics Group, Inc, (WEG) has been retained to prepare an economic
impact analysis of the development of the proposed Florida Marlins Ballpark and ongoing
operations of the Florida Marlins Baseball Team in the City of Miami.
As currently proposed, the Florida Marlins Ballpark will be located at the site of the former
Grange Bowl adjacent to the central business district of downtown Miarni. The proposed
state-of-the-art ballpark will consist of 927,000 square feet of constructed area for 37,000
spectators, enclosed with a three -panel operable roof system. This roof system will be able to
cover the playing field and seating terraces if conditions require. In the open ballpark
configuration, the operable roof panels will park over a grand plaza, creating an
entertainment entry district. When the roof and outfield wall are retracted, the ballpark's
interior space transforms, and the seating terraces become open to the sky.
Spectator seating areas are supported by three distinct levels, the main concourse level, the
club/suite level and the upper concourse level. All seating levels are oriented for prime
views of the playing field, as well as offering views of the Miami skyline beyond the outfield
wall.
The architecture of the ballpark has been described as a kinetic sculptural expression with its
large curvilinear movable roof panels and exterior form. The retracting roof will be fully
operable, offering flexibility to protect the spectators and the field from sun and rain if
needed. When the ballpark is fully enclosed, it will be air conditioned to provide a
comfortable environment for spectators and players. The curving faceted forms enclosing the
spectator seating area and concourses will terrace down from the roof and will be layered to
create balconies with views out to the surrounding skyline, while appearing to reduce the
scale of the building gracefully. The exterior skin of the ballpark will consist of a faceted
metal panel system, glass curtain wall and pre -cast concrete panels. These elements will be
organized in a manner to create a powerful symbol within the Miami skyline.
Plans for the ballpark also call for the construction of up to 96 residential units, up to 61,678
square feet of ancillary and accessory retail space, four parking structures and six surface
parking lots with approximately 6,000 spaces on the site as well as improvements to public
infrastructure on and adjacent to the site.
For this analysis, WEG utilized the Minnesota IMPLAN Group, Inc.'s (MIG) software and
basic data needed to formulate the economic multiplier model developed for quantifying the
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page I
proposed ballpark development and ongoing activities of the Florida Marlins on the City of
Miami. MIG has been providing economic multiplier models for regional economic impact
analysis since 19851. Models developed using IMPLAN software have been widely used by
the private sector, academic economists and by federal, state and local government agencies
to measure the economic impacts of various policy alternatives.
The development of the proposed ballpark in the City of Miami will generate significant
quantifiable economic impacts. These impacts, estimated by utilizing a professionally
accepted and widely used methodology, will support employment, the generation of labor
income, economic output and public revenues in the City of Miami. Estimates calculated on
page 14 will result in close to $1 million ($780,000) a year in sales taxes alone that are paid
to the City from operations inside the ballpark. Therefore, the economic outcomes expected
from development of the proposed ballpark will provide significant economic benefits to the
City of Miami and its residents.
It should be noted that the model utilized in this study measures only economic impacts
generated within the boundaries of the City of Miami. Additional benefits are generated
within other cities in Miami -Dade County and other parts of South Florida that are not
included in this analysis, but which are indeed substantial.
Methodology Used in this Analv,sis
Economic models that explicitly account for inter -industry lirilcages (supply relationships),
the generation of labor and capital income and the spending of household income have been
used since the 1960's to estimate the contribution that a particular business or industry snakes
to the general economy. These "input-output" models recognize that, as an industry
experiences an increase in the demand for its products or services, it in turn needs more goods
and services from its suppliers and must increase its purchases from other industries in the
economy. The effect on regional production resulting from successive rounds of inter-
industry linkages is referred to as the indirect effect. The resulting increases in regional
production also lead to expansions in ctnployment and labor income, and the increases in
labor income lead to more consu;ner spending, further expanding sales and production
throughout the regional economy. The latter economic impacts are referred to as the induced
effects. The successive waves of production, spending and more production result in
economic intiltiplier effects, where the final or total increase in regional production, income
and employment, respectively, is larger than the initial (or "direct") increase in production,
income and employment. The total quantitative economic contribution of these activities,
therefore, is comprised of a direct effect, an indirect effect and an induced effect.
'Information on the IMPLAN Group models and the company history can be found at www.implan.com,
The Washington Economics Group, hoc. Page 2
II. THE ECONOMIC IMPACTS DURING THE DEVELOPMENT PHASE OF THE FLORIDA
MARLINS BALLPARK ON THE CITY OF MIAMI
The expenditures associated with the development of the proposed Florida Marlins Ballpark
will generate economic impacts that extend beyond those directly related to the development
process. These "spillover" or multiplier impacts are the result of each business activity's
supply relationships with other firms operating within the region, the proportion of Gross
Domestic Product (GDP)2 that accrues to households in the form of labor and capital income,
and the propensity of households to spend income on goads produced within the local area.
The direct impact of the development of the proposed Florida Marlins Ballpark is comprised
of all of the local expenditures for labor and materials that will be used in the construction of
the ballpark, parking garage and associated public infrastructure. A portion of the total costs
of construction is likely to be paid to business establishments and workers located outside of
the City of Miami. These "imports" of goods and services do not add to the level of
economic activity in the City, though they benefit the South Florida region and other
communities where these expenditures take place. This is likely to be the case for a
significant portion of the cost for architectural and engineering services for the ballpark.
The estimated construction costs of the ballpark, parking garage and associated
improvements to public infrastructure in the vicinity of the ballpark are $634 million
(ballpark $515 million, parking garage $94 million and public infrastructure $25 million).
While a detailed breakdown of construction costs is not available, the impact estimates are
based on the total "hard costs" of construction of $559.9 million and $64.1 million of "soft
costs" (design, engineering, etc.). Further adjustments to these estimated expenditures were
made to exclude payments to businesses located outside the City. It is projected that
approximately 22 percent of the hard cost expenditures will go to businesses located outside
the City, and 50 percent of the soft cost expenditures will go to suppliers located outside the
City. With these adjustments, total project expenditures within the City of Miami are
expected to be $470.1 millions.
"The GDP of an area represents the net economic value created through the local production of goods and
services. This economic value is used to compensate workers, pay taxes, and provide a return to investors in
these business activities.,
3Cruz, Dr. Robert D. "Economic Impact of Construction Spending on Three Special Redevelopment Projects:
The Marlins Ballpark, Museum Park, and the Port Access Tunnel," May 23, 2008. Dr. Cruz's estimates focused
on Miami -Dade County. These estimates were utilized in this analysis, as almost all of the local expenditures
will occur in the City of Miami.
The Washington Economics Group, fnc. page 3
The construction spending estimates discussed above constitute direct economic impacts
entered into the IMPLAN Model for the City of Miami, Based in the direct impacts the
IMPLAN model estimates the direct impacts for employment, labor income, public -sector
fiscal revenues, and City of Miami Gross Domestic Product. The IMPLAN model also
estimates indirect and induced economic impacts of the proposed Florida Marlins Ballpark
development for all variables. These comprehensive direct, indirect and induced, economic
impacts are summarized in Table 1 below.
Table 1. Summary of the Economic Impacts Arising from Developmennt of the Florida
Marlins Ballpark
Fliptoyment (Person Years) — — -
I 4,774 '1
3,007
7,781
Labor Income ($ Mill.) F 216
F 125
F 341
City of Miami Gross Domestic Product (GDP $ Mill.)
F 242
F 203
445
Federal, State & Local Tax Revenues ($ Mill.)
103
Total Economic Impact ($ Mill.)
470 F 345 F $15
Source: The Washington Econonucs Group, Inc.
An estimated 7,781 person years of employment (one person employed for one year) for
local residents will result from the development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark, The
development phase of the ballpark is directly responsible for 4,774 person years of
employment in the Construction and related support sectors. CuiTent estimates call for the
development phase to be completed within three years of commencement. Based on this
schedule, the estimates of person years of employment can be divided by three to obtain an
approximation of the number of people working on the job at any one point in time. These
calculations suggest that approximately 1,600 people will be directly employed on the
project, and that another 1,000 jobs throughout the City of Miami will be supported by the
ballpark's development. These estimates for direct employment on the ballpark are consistent
with estimates prepared by the projects managers.
The ballpark's indirect and induced job creation process reaches deeply into all sectors of the
local economy. This dramatically demonstrates the close supply inter -relationships that the
Construction sector has with all of the other sectors of the local economy. Specifically, 1,334
person years of employment are supported via these indirect economic effects (mostly
suppliers). Lastly, 1,673 person years of employment in all sectors of the local economy are
The WashinVOT Economics Group, Inc. Page 4
generated by induced spending effects. Therefore, the total number of person years of
employment, directly, indirectly and induced, supported by the development of the
Florida Marlins Ballpark is estimated at 7,781 — making a significant contribution to
local employment opportunities in Miami.
The number of person years of employment estimated by the IMPLAN model to be created
in each economic sector by the development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark is summarized
in Table 2. Of the 7,781 person years of employment supported by the Development phase,
59 percent are in the Construction sector, 27 percent are in the Knowledge -Based Services
sectors, and the remaining 14 percent are distributed among other economic sectors.
Table 2. Person Years of Employment Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins
Ballpark
1Constructitan F_4,55$
nowledge-Based Services
2,075
etail Trade
560
holesale Trade & Transportation Services
23$
isitor Industry
217
Manufacturing
$4
Government & Other
49
Total All Industries
7,781
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
*Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on
See detail in Appendix Il, Table A -I.
,page 22.
The development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark will also be an important generator of
Labor Income for the City's workers. (Labor Income is the total value of compensation to all
workers.) In addition to the $216 million of Labor Income directly generated by construction
of the ballpark and associated infrastructure, $59 million of Labor Income is created by
indirect economic activities, and $66 million of Labor Income is created by induced
economic activities.
In summary, development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark is estimated to generate
almost $341 million in Labor Income, with the largest proportion of income generated
from. the Construction and Knowledge -Based Services economic sectors as shown in
Table 3 next page.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 5
Table 3. Labor Income Impacts Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark
($ in thousands)
&R70 Pact
mlma�11111 119=1
'Construction
203,990
Knowledge -Based Services*
94,202
etail Trade
F_ 17,385
holesale Trade. & Transportation Services
11,732
[Visitor Industry
5,425
anufacturing
4,119
Government & Other
3,920
Tufal All Industries
$340,772
rSource: The Washington Economics Group, Inc. See detail in Appendix 11, Table A-2.
'kFind Knowledge -Based Services definition on page 22.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) arising from the project is another measure of
economic development benefits from the development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark.
The GDP of an area represents the net economic value created through the local production
of goods and services. This net economic value is used to compensate workers, pay taxes,
and provide a return to investors in the business activities. GDP is also the principal source of
household income and a key measure of the contributions that the development of the
ballpark and associated infrastructure will make to the City of Miami economy. The
development of this project will create over $212 million of local GDP directly, while $83
million of local GDP will be the result of indirect activities, and $120 million of local GDP
will be the result of induced economic activities. In total, the development of the Florida
Marlins Ballpark will generate almost $445 million in GDP for the City.
Table 4. Miami GDP Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark
($ in thousands)
L""J
anstniction
1 229,922
Knowledge -Based Services*
122,998
Government & Other
29,332
etail Trade
27,963
[Wholesale Trade &'Transportation
20,142
[Visitor Industry
8,155
anufacturing
6,434
Totrtt All Industries
1 $444,946
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc. See detail in Appendix 11, Table A-3.
*Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on page 22.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 6
Table 4 summarizes the local GDP estimated to be created by the development of the
ballpark in each economic sector. The greatest increases in Miami GDP are estimated to
occur in the Construction and Knowledge -Based Services sectors where it is projected
that 80 percent of the Miami GDP is to be created.
A final and comprehensive measure of the total economic impact of the development of the
Florida Marlins Ballpark on Miami is Grass Economic Output, representing the surra of gross
revenues (receipts) of private firms plus the value of government services (valued at cost).
The total economic impact of the development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark on the
City is estimated at almost $815 million — generating a significant economic impact. Of
this total, an estimated $470 million is generated by direct activities, while an additional
$345 million is generated by indirect and induced activities. Table 5 shows the industry
distribution of the total economic impact.
Table 5. Economic Output Impacts Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark
($ in thousands)
RT-1t,l Impact 91
Construction
446,077
Knowledge -Based Services*
219,924
etail Trade
42,245
Government & Other
36,707
holesale Trade & Transportation Services
32,273
Manufacturing
23,243
isitor Industry
14,496
Total All Industries
.$814,965
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
*Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on
See detail in Appendix H, Table A-4.
page 22.
In addition to the various economic impacts presented, the development of the Florida
Marlins Ballpark will result in significant fiscal revenues for federal, state, and local
governments as shown in Table 6 next page. Over the course of development, almost $103
million of fiscal revenues are generated. Of this total, $78.5 million, or 76 percent, flow to
the federal government, and the remaining $24.4 million, or 24 percent, of tax revenues are
allocated to state and local governments.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 7
Table 6. Fiscal Contributions Attributable to Development of the Florida Marlins
Ballpark ($ in thousands)
Fe
i xes PaidI3,y L QUI
Labor
$ 30,299 $ 595 $ 30,894
Capital
3,891 3;$91
Households
33,649 2,076 F 35,725
Corporations
7,950 2,908 10,858
Indirect Business Taxes
2,71$ 18,795
1,511
Total:
$78,505 $24,374 $102,879
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
See detail in Appendix II, Table A-5.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 8
III. THE RECURRING ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF Tim +i ORIDA MARL1Ns TEAM
OPERATIONS ON THE CITY OF MIAMI
In this section, the annual economic impacts of the ongoing operations of the Florida Marlins
Baseball Team on the City of Miami are analyzed. These activities include:
* Local expenditures made by the Florida Marlins in order to operate the stadium and
the baseball team. Included are all expenditures that the Marlins project will incur to
undertake operations in the new ballpark, administrative expenses, and player salaries
prorated for the portion of the year that these individuals can be expected to reside in
Miami. The Florida Marlins estimate that these expenditures will average $130.1
million per annum.
• Lodging, dining and local transportation expenditures made by visiting teams,
baseball umpires and non -local members of the press. The Florida Marlins estimate
that these expenditures will average $2.3 million per annum.
• Expenditures made by out-of-town 'baseball fans as they attend Marlins home games
in the proposed ballpark (excluding the purchase of tickets to the games). These
expenditures include purchases of food and drink, parking and purchases of novelties
.and. souvenirs. In instances where out-of-town fans remain in Miami overnight, these
expenditures include lodging expenditures. The Florida Marlins provided estimates of
nut -of -town fan attendance at their home games. Estimated fan expenditures are
based on experience at Nationals Park in Washington, D.C. The projected fan
expenditures are consistent with other local surveys of out-of-town visitor
expenditures, including those produced by the Greater Miami Convention and
Visitors Bureau. In total, these expenditures are projected to average $45.2 million
per annum once the new ballpark is fully operational.
Therefore, the ongoing activities in the completed ballpark will generate significant
quantifiable and recurring economic impacts each year. These impacts, estimated by
utilizing professionally accepted and widely used methodology, will support other
employment and the generation of labor income, economic output and public revenues in the
City of Miami on an ongoing basis.
The expenditures associated with activities in the completed ballpark generate economic
impacts that extend beyond those directly related to its operations. These "spillover" or
multiplier impacts are the result of each business activity's supply relationships with other
The Washington Economics Group, frac. Page 9
firms operating within the community, the proportion of local GDp4 that accrues to
households in the form of labor and capital income and the propensity of households to spend
income on goods produced within the local area.
The direct impact of the activities that will occur in the completed ballpark is comprised of
all expenditures made by the team, visiting teams, and expenditures made by out of town
fans attending Marlins home games. Utilizing the direct economic impacts discussed above,
indirect and induced economic impacts of the activities occurring in the completed ballpark
were calculated using an extended input-output model of the City of Miami economy. These
comprehensive direct, indirect and induced economic impacts are summarized in Table 7.
Table 7. Summary of Annual (Recurring) Economic Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins
Team Operations in the New Ballpark
IF-mployment (Jabs)
I 1,667 1,041 2,708
Labor Income ($ Mill.)
96
44 140
Miami Gross Domestic Product (GDP — $ Mill.)
F 127
F 76
F 2f13
Federal, State & Local Tax Revenues ($ Mill.)
F—� 57
I
F-
F-
Total Economic Impact ($ Mill.)
178 121 I 299
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
An estimated 2,708 permanent jobs for local residents result directly or indirectly from the
baseball and related activities occurring at the completed ballpark. Expenditures related to
baseball operations and out-of-town fan expenditures are directly responsible for 1,667 jobs
in the Knowledge -Based Services, Government & Other and related support sectors.
However, the indirect and induced job creation process reaches deeply into all sectors of the
local economy. This dramatically demonstrates the close supply inter -relationships that these
sectors have with all of the other sectors of the local economy. An additional 377 jobs are
supported via indirect economic effects (mostly suppliers). Lastly, 664 jobs are generated by
induced spending effects. Therefore, the total number of jobs, directly, indirectly and
induced, supported by activities in the completed ballpark are estimated at 2,708 –
making a significant contribution to local employment opportunities.
4 The GDP of an area represents the net economic value created through the local production of goods and
services. This economic value is used to compensate workers, pay taxes, and provide a return to investors in
these business activities.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. page 10
The jobs created in each economic sector by baseball and outer activities that are projected to
occur in the completed ballpark are summarized in Table 8. Of the 2,708 jobs supported by
these activities, 67 percent are in the Knowledge -Based Services sector, An additional 23
percent of the jobs created are in the Visitor Industry, with the remaining 10 percent of jobs
distributed among other economic sectors.
Table 8. Recurring Employment Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins Team Operations
Knowledge -Based Services* 1,815
[Visitor Industry 629
[lZetail Trade 145
holesale Trade & Transportation Services 71
iGovernment & Other 1 22
Manufacturing 18
Construction 8
Total All Industries 2,708
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc. See detail in Appendix II, Table B-1,
*Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on page 22.
The ongoing activities that will occur in the completed ballpark will be an important
generator of Labor Income for workers in the City of Miami. In addition to the $96 trillion
annually of recurring Labor income directly generated by activities that will occur in the
ballpark, more than $18 million of Labor Income will be created by indirect economic
activities each year and $26 million of Labor Income will be created by induced economic
activities each year, In summary, activities in the completed Florida Marlins Ballpark
will generate over $140 million in Labor Income each year, with the largest proportion
of income generated from the Knowledge -Based Services economic sector as shown in
Table 9.
Table 9. Recurring Labor Income Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins Team Operations
{$ in thousands)
otal ImP act
Knowledge -Based Services* l 1p,432
isitor Industry 18,933
etail Trade 4,415
holesale Tracie &Transportation Services 3,602
Government & Other 1,733
Manufacturing 889
Construction 375
Total All Industries $140,380
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc. See detail in Appendix Il, Table B-2.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 11
*Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on page 22.
Gross Domestic Product (GDP) 5arising from recurring activities (ongoing) in the
completed ballpark is another measure of the economic benefits of this development,
The GDP of an area represents the net economic value created through the local production
of goods and services. This net economic value is used to compensate workers, pay taxes,
and provide a return to investors in the business activities. GDP is also the principal source of
household income and a key measure of the contributions that the Marlins ongoing
operations in the completed ballpark will make to the City of Miami economy. Each year
activities at the completed ballpark will create over $127 million of local GDP directly, while
close to $28 million of local GDP will be created by indirect activities, and more than $47
million of local GDP will be created by induced economic activities, In total, baseball and
other activities at the completed ballpark will generate just under $203 million in local GDP
each year. Table 10 summarizes the recurring local GDP impacts of baseball and other
activities associated with the completed ballpark on each economic sector. The greatest
increases in local GDP will arise in the Knowledge -Based Services and the Visitor
Industry where 87 percent of the local GDP will be created.
Tattle 10. Recurring Miami GDP Arising from Florida Marlins Team Operations
($ in thousands)
T"tctf Irirp
Knowledge --Based Services*
F 145,542
isitor Industry
30,805
avernment & Other
12,014
etail Trade
7,025
holesale Trade & Transportation Services
5,626
anufacturing
1,419
I onstruction
395
Total Aft Industries
$202,825
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc. See detail in Appendix I1, Table B-3.
Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on page 22.
A final and comprehensive treasure of the total recurring economic impact of the ongoing
operations at the Florida Marlins Ballpark is Gross Economic Output, representing the sum
of total gross revenues (receipts) of private firms plus the total value of government services
(valued at cost). The total recurring economic impact of the activities at the completed
$The GDP of an area represents the net economic value created through the local production of goods and
services. This economic value is used to compensate workers, pay taxes, and provide a return to investors in
these business activities.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. .Page 12
ballpark is estimated at just over $299 million annually. Of this total, $178 million will be
generated by direct activities related to activities at the ballpark, while an additional $121
million will be generated by indirect and induced activities. As presented in the previous
analysis of these economic impacts, the greatest increases in total economic impact (Gross
Economic Output) will arise in the Knowledge -Based Services, Visitor Industry and
Government & Other sectors, where 91 percent of the recurring economic output will be
created as shown in Table I I below.
Table It. Recurring Economic Output Impacts Arising from Florida Marlins Team
Operations ($ in thousands)
EPIWcal 7orrr!
Labor
Knowledge -Based Services*
206,983
isitor Industry
50,758
ovemment & Other
15,124
etail Trade
10,547
holesale Trade & Transportation Services
8,923
anufacturing
5,764
Construction
941
Total All Industries
,$299,039
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc. See detail iat Appendix II, Table B-4
*Find Knowledge -Based Services definition on page 22.
In addition to the various economic impacts presented, baseball and other activities at the
completed ballpark will result in significant fiscal revenues each year for federal, state, and
local governments as shown in Table 12. Each year almost $57 million of fiscal revenues will
be generated by ongoing activities. Of this total, $35.3 million, or 62 percent, will flow to the
federal government, with the remaining $21.7 million, or 38 percent, of tax revenues being
allocated to state and local governments.
Table 12. Recurring Fiscal Contributions of Florida Marlins Team Operations
($ in thousands)
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. page 13
EPIWcal 7orrr!
Labor
$ 14,360 $ 282-1 $ 14,642
Capital
814 ----- 814
Households
13,379 825 1 14,204
Corporations
3,943 1,442-1 5,385
Indirect Business Taxes
2,771
19,175
21,946
Total:
$35,267 $21,724 .$56,991
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. page 13
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc, See detail in Appendix Il, 'Table B-5, I
Baseball and other activities at the completed ballpark will be important generators of Sales
Tax Revenues for the City of Miami and for the State of Florida. The Florida Marlins have
prepared estimates of fan attendance and taxable revenues that will occur at the completed
ballpark. On average, during the first five years of operations, the Florida Marlins forecast
that ticket sales, concession revenues and other activities occurring at the ballpark will
generate $10.9 million dollars of sales tax revenues each year, as shown in Table 13 below. It
should be noted that these estimates do not include fiscal revenues associated with other
taxes and fees, nor do they include taxes or fees collected on activities occurring outside of
the completed ballpark.
aT ble 13. Sales Tax Generated at the Completed Florida Marlins Ballpark
Yr. 5 55 Y
Attendance (Tickets Sold) 2,835,000 2,700,000600,000 2,400,000 2,300,400 2,567,000 1
Total Sales Tax Ballpark Events $11,344,872 $11,150,232 1$10,901,900 $10,474,521 11$10,696,884 $10,913,682'
(Source: The Florida Marlins.
[.ander Florida law, one half of erre. percent (4.50) of all local taxable
expenditures, air one twelfth (1112) of the State's gales tax collections are
transferred to local governments. Consultant estimates that recurring
expenditures attributable to activities at the completed ballpark will average
$156 million each year, and that the City's portion of the associated sales taxes
will be $780,000 each year.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 14
Ill. POTENTIAL ECONOMIC IMPACTS AssoCIATED WITH BASEBALL'S "JEWEL" EVENTS
Major League Baseball has three high profile also known as "Jewel" events that have the
potential to take place in the completed ballpark. These events are the Major League All-Star
Game, the World Series (and the remaining portions of the Major League Baseball post -
season) and the World. Baseball Classic. All of these events draw large numbers of visitors to
the host conununities, as well as extensive media coverage of the host community in both the
sports and mainstream media. Involvement in these events by either Miami as a host City,
and/or the Florida Marlins as participants will generate significant economic impacts in
addition to those already discussed.
The Major League All-Star Game highlights a multi -day series of baseball -related events
occurring in the host City. The All-Star Game pits the top players of the American and
National Leagues against each other, and determines which league will have the home field
advantage in that year's World Series. Major League Baseball has an established pattern of
awarding the All-Star Game to newly established teams and teams with new ballparks a few
years after- the teams are established or after the new ballpark is opened. While it cannot be
guaranteed that the Florida Marlins will have the opportunity to host an All-Star Game in the
future, past patterns and other indications from Major- League Baseball strongly suggest that
it is likely to happen at some point during the first five years of the ballpark's existence.
Economic impact analyses of prior years All-Star Games played at locations throughout the
nation suggest that a wide range of potential economic impacts can occur if this event were
held in Miami. The smallest economic impact was $37.6 million for the 1997 All-Star Game
played in Cleveland, while the largest impact was $148.4 million for the 2008 All-Star Game
played in. New York 6. The impacts of recent All-Star games held in markets similar to Miami
include Houston, which hosted the 2004 All-Star game with an economic impact of $65
million, and Pittsburgh which hosted the 2006 fall -Star Game with an economic impact of
$52.3 million.
The World Series takes place each October in the cities of the champions of the American
and National Leagues. Each team has the potential to host between two and four games of
this series, following the successful completion of their division and Ieague play-offs. Like
the World Series, the league play-offs are a "best of seven" series, guaranteeing each team a
minimum of two home games, and a potential for four games during each of these series
(The division play-offs are a best of five series). The World Series is followed throughout
6 Major League Baseball data.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 15
the world, with extensive press coverage for the duration of the series. Additionally, it draws
large numbers of visitors to the host cities each year. Since the establishment of the Florida
Marlins baseball team, the team has played in two World Series championships. Potential
economic impacts for the City of Miami from the Marlins participation in a World Series are
likely to be similar to the range of economic impacts associated with hosting the All -,Star
Game.
The World Baseball Classic (WBC) takes place once every four years with the next Classic
scheduled to be played in 2009. Given the Marlins proximity to over half of Major League
Baseball's spring training facilities and Miami's proximity to many of the Caribbean nation
teams (Dominican Republic, Venezuela, Puerto Rico) participating in the Classic, Miami will
likely be a regular candidate to host the finals or one of the major rounds of the WBC every
four years. Major League Baseball has indicated to the Marlins that the team is a strong
candidate to host the 2013 World Baseball Classic if the new stadium is operational. The
Marlins will also have the opportunity to host practice and training sessions for one or more
teams during each Classic, and the Marlins will also he a candidate to host one of the
Classic's first round brackets in any year that they are not selected to host the finals or semi-
finals of the Classic. Hosting activities associated with the World Baseball Classic will bring
significant numbers of out-of-town visitors to Miami to attend these events, as well as
creating significant national and international media coverage of the Classic and Miami as
the host City for the event.
Each of these events has the potential to significantly increase the economic impact of the
Florida Marlins by drawing large numbers of visitors to Miami and thus generating favorable
media coverage of the community. Further, the baseball "Jewel" events occur outside of
South Florida's winter tourism season helping to increase patronage of South Florida's
entertainment and visitor industries during periods of reduced activity. The impacts
associated with these "Jewel" events are not included in this analysis and are additional to the
recurring impacts associated with the Florida Marlins ongoing activities during the regular
baseball season.
Information from the Florida Marlins.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 16
V. CONCLUSION
The development phase and recurring operations of the proposed Florida Marlins Ballpark
will be a significant generator of jobs in the building trades and the construction industries of
Miami -Dade and the City of Miami. The ballpark will require large amounts of goods and
materials, becoming an important customer for local companies that supply these products to
the building industry. When completed, the ballpark will be home to the Florida Marlins
Baseball Team and host over 80 baseball games each year, generating important economic
impacts on jobs supported, labor income, economic output and fiscal revenues. Due to
Miami's location and reputation as a premier vacation and recreation destination, the ballpark
has the potential to host high profile baseball events as well as many other activities that can
take advantage of the ballpark's capabilities and Miami's varied and multiple amenities.
The Washingron Economics Group, Inc. Page 17
APPENDIX I:
ME, THODOLOG
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 18
IMPLAN MODEL
The multiplier impacts calculated by the 1MPLAN model are based on input-output
methodology, which explicitly considers the inter -industry linkages that exist within an
economy. Each industry needs labor and inputs from other industries in order to produce
economic output. Whenever an industry experiences an increase in the demand for its
output, many other industries within that economy indirectly experience an increase in
demand as well because of these inter -industry linkages. This increase in demand that results
from the need for material inputs is called the indirect effects. In addition, an increase in
production within a region also leads to an increase in household income through the hiring
of workers, which in turn generates further demands for goods and services within the region.
Firms also need to expand their base of physical capital to meet higher levels of demand, and
this too stimulates regional economic growth. The latter effects are referred to as induced
effects. The interindustry linkages and the induced effects on consumer and capital spending
lead to successive rounds of production, and this process results in an increase in output that
exceeds the initial change in demand, or a multiplier effect. Similarly, the increase in
household income will exceed the initial payroll increase encountered in the industry that
experienced the original increase in demand. The total change in employment in the regional
economy is a multiple of the direct change in employment.
The following represents the system of equations that comprise the regional economy in
an extended input-output model like IMPLANT
x1 ! aI IXl + a12X2 + al3X3 + , , , + alkXk + alhxh + aliXi + fl
x2 = a2lX1 + a22X2 + a23X3 + ... + a2kXk + a2hxh + a2I XI + f2
X3 = a3lXl + a32X2 + a33X3 + ... + a3kXk + a3hxh + a3ixi + f3
Xk = akI X1 + ak2X2 + ak3X3 + ... + akkXk + akhXh + akiXi + fk
Xh — ah1Xl + ah2X2 + ah3Xh +. - - + ahkxk + ahhxh + ahiXi + fh
Xi = ailXl + ai2X2 + ai3Xh + ... + aikxk + aihXh + aiiXi + fi
The variables x, to xk represent total production of output in each industry. The coefficients
The Washington Economics Group, Inc, Page 19
ai, represent the purchases from industry "i" that are needed to produce a dollar of output in
industry "j". These are known as the direct requirement coefficients. The variable xh refers
to household income and the coefficients aih refer to the average amount of household
income spent on purchases from industry "i", or the average propensities to consume. The
coefficients ahi are similar to the inter -industry purchases (a,a's), but they represent the
household income that is generated from each dollar of output produced in industry "i".
Similarly the variable xrrepresents regional spending on capital goods, and the coefficients a[1
represents the spending on capital goods for each dollar- of output produced in industry "j".
The coefficients alp represent the amount purchased from industry "j" for each dollar spent on
capital goods within the region. The variables f, represent the exogenous final demand faced
by each industry, respectively.
This system of equation reduces, using matrix notation, to the following solution for
industry output and household income:
X is the vector of industry outputs plus household income and F is a vector of exogenous
final demands. The "output multipliers" (i.e., the change in industry output and household
income that results from a change in final demand for the output of a particular industry) are
given in the columns of the (I -A)"' matrix. The IMPLAN software calculates these
multipliers for counties, states and other sub -state regions. These multipliers can be used to
provide a sense of file economic importance of an industry or an economic activity in a given
region. The multipliers impacts for gross state product, labor and capital income and the
government revenue impacts are derived from the basic output multipliers given by (I -A.)-1.
The IMPLAN model uses historical relationships between public -sector revenues and
regional economic output in order to estimate the public -sector revenue impact resulting from
the establishment of a new, or expansion of an existing economic activity.
The Washington Econoinics Group, Iris. Page 20
APPENDIX II:
DETAILED IMPACT TABLES
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. page 21
DETAILED IMPACT TABLES
Within the main portion of this analysis, the economic impacts are presented at a summary
level. Direct, indirect, and induced impacts are aggregated into the Total Impact, and
Industries are summarized by function. The following tables present detailed impacts at the
two -digit NAICS industry classification level.
The following industry sector summarizations are used in this analysis.
1. Government and Other is the sum of: Agriculture & Forestry, Mining,
Utilities, Company Management, and Government & Other
2, Knowledge -used Services is the sum of: Information, Finance & Insurance,
Real Estate, Professional Services, Administrative, Educational Services,
Health & Social Services, Arts, Entertainment & Recreation, and Cather
Services
3. Wholesale Trade & Transportation Services is the sutra of: Wholesale
Trade, and Transportation & Warehousing
4. The Accommodation and Food Services sector was renamed to the Visitor
Industry
List of 'fables:
Table A-1. Person Years of Employment Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins
Ballpark.......................................... ................................................................................... 23
Table A-2. Labor Income Impacts Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark ....... 24
Table A-3. Miami GDP Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark... ..................... 25
Table A-4. Economic Output Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark ............... 26
Table A-5. Detailed Fiscal Contributions Attributable to Development of the Florida Marlins
Ballpark............................................................................................................................. 27
Table B-1. Recurring Employment Impacts Arising from the Florida Marlins Team Operations ,..., 28
Table B-2. Recurring Labor Income Impacts Arising from the Florida Marlins Team
Operations................................................................... . ......... ........................................... 29
Table B-3. Recurring Miami GDP Arising from the Florida Marlins Team Operations .................... 30
Table B-4. Recurring Economic Output Impacts Arising from the Florida Marlins Team
Operations__ ....................................................................... ............................................. 31
Table B-5. Detailed Recurring Fiscal Contributions of the Florida Marlins Team Operations.......... 32
The Washington Economics Groaip, Inc. Page 22
BALLPARK DEVELOPMENT
able A-1. Person Years of Employment Arising
from Development
of the Florida
..arlins Ball ark
lm,pacts
Agriculture & Forestry
0.0
0.2
1.1
1.3
Mining
0.0
0.1
0.0
0.1
Utilities
0.0
2.4
5,9
8.3
Construction
4,544.4
6.8
7.2
4,558.4
Manufacturing
0.0
53.9
29.8
83.7
Wholesale Trade
0.0
56.5
62.7
119.2
Transportation & Warehousing
0.0
66.9
51.4
118.3
Retail Trade
0.0
244.5
315.4
559.9
Information
0.0
16.5
20.1
36.6
Finance & Insurance
0.0
54.1
92.7
146.8
Real Estate
0.0
64.4
83.4
147.8
Professional Services
229.6
456.1
68.6
754.3
Company Management
0.0
12.6
11.8
24.4
Administrative
0.0
219.3
85.5
304.8
Educational Services
0.0
2.6
62.8
65.4
Health & Social Services
0.0
0.0
378.1
378.1
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
OA
7.2
38.4
45.6
Accommodation & Food Services
0.0
35.5
181.6
217.1
Other Services
0.0
30.9
165.1
196.0
Government & Other
0.0
4.0
11.0
15.0
otal:
4,774.0
1,334.5
1,672.6
7,78i.i
Source: The Washln tion Economics Group, Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 23
able A-2. Labor lncome Impacts Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins
;allpark ($ in Thousands)
agriculture & Forestry
0.0 7.4
33.9
41.3
Mining
0.0 7.9
4.2
12.1
Jtillties
0.0 248.3
601.9
850.2
Donstruction
203,353.6 308.6
328.1
203,990.3
Manufacturing
0.0 2,611.4
1,547.7
4,119.1
Nholesale Trade
0.0 2,692.1
4,092.4
6,784.5
Transportation & Warehousing
0.0 2,805.9
2,141.2
4,947.1
Retail Trade
0.0 7,608.1
9,777.0
17,385.1
Information
0.0 1,429.2
1,700.1
3,129.3
Finance & Insurance
0.0 3,709.8
6,219.9
9,929.7
Real Estate
0.0 1,781.9
2,079.7
3,861.6
Professional Services
12,815.3 26,275.6
4,333.2
43,424.1
Company Management
0.0 1,100.1
1,033.6
2,133.7
Administrative
0.0 5,815.5
2,258.9
8,074.4
Educational Services
O.0 107.7
2,352.0
2,459.7
Health & Social Services
O.0 1.5
17,316.8
17,318.3
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
O.0 234.5
1,135.9
1,370.4
Accommodation & Food Services
0.0 1,054.9
4,369.9
5,424.8
Other Services
OX 954.1
3,680.1
4,634.2
Government & Other
0.0 225.91
656.3
882.2
Total:
216,168.9
58 980.4
65,622.8
340,772.1
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Wage 24
able A-3. Miami GDP Arising from Development
of
tate Florida
Marlins Ballpark
$ in Thousands
Agriculture & Forestry
0.0
17.0
86.0
103.0
Mining
0.0
18.6
10.2
28.8
Utilities
0.0
901.6
2,178.4
3,080.0
Construction
229,255.3
327.5
339.3
229,922.1
Manufacturing
0.0
3,975.3
2,458.2
6,433.5
Wholesale Trade
0.0
6,573,7
7,286.4
13,860.1
Transportation & Warehousing
0.0
3,566.9
2,715.4
6,282.3
Retail Trade
0.0
12,264.2
15,698.9
27,963.1
Information
0.0
2,831.7
3,638.3
6,470.0
Finance & Insurance
0.0
6,156.9
10,343.1
16,500.0
Real Estate
0.0
6,431.8
8,021.2
14,453.0
Professional Services
12,880.4
27,727.1
5,027.9
45,635.4
Company Management
0.0
1,415.4
1,329.8
2,745.2
Administrative
0.0
7,008.0
2,821.0
9,829.0
Educational Services
0.0
115.1
2,543.0
2,658.1
Health & Social Services
0.0
2.1
19,956.8
19,958.9
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
0.0
303.4
1,571,0
1,874.4
Accommodation & Food Services
0.0
1,709.1
6,446.2
8,155.3
Other Services
0.0
1,155.2
4,464.0
5,619.2
Government & Other
0.0
383.9
22,990.6
23,374.5
Total:
242135.7
82,884.5
119,925.7
444,945.9
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 25
able A-4. Economic Output Arising from Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark
� in Thousands
-= direct Indirect Induced Tot
Agriculture & Forestry
0.0
21.5
119.9
141.4
Mining
0.0
42.1
23.4
65.5
Utilities
0.0
1,136.1
2,765.0
3,901.1
Construction
444,504.0
781.5
791.4
446,076.9
Manufacturing
0.0
12,921.0
10,322.0
23,243.0
Wholesale Trade
0.0
9,747,3
10,804.1
20,551.4
Transportation & Warehousing
0.0
6,596.3
5,125.0
11,721.3
Retail Trade
0.0
18,501.6
23,743.2
42,244.8
Information
0.0
5,732.4
7,513.8
13,246.2
Finance & Insurance
0.0
10,643.8
19,090.2
29,734.0
Real Estate
0.0
10,442.8
12,109.0
22,551.8
Professional Services
25,548.1
54,048.2
8,950.7
88,547.0
Company Management
0.0
2,420.1
2,273.7
4,693.8
Administrative
0.0
10,722.3
4,654.5
15,376.8
E=ducational Services
0.0
184.5
3,967.6
4,152.1
Health & Social Services
0.0
4.3
32,536.3
32,540,6
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
0.0
464,0
2,501.4
2,965.4
Accommodation & Food Services
0.0
2,827.4
11,668.5
14,495.9
Other Services
0.0
2,350.9
8,459.6
10,810.5
Government & Other
101.1
838.4
26,965.6
27,905.1
otal: 470,153.2 1 150,426-51 194,384.9 1814,964.6
ource. The Washinaton Economics Group. Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Wage 26
e A-5. Detailed Fiscal Contributions Attributable to Development of the Florida Marlins Ballpark ($ in Thousands_
—Taxes Paid By
Ca ital,Households Corporations Indirect Business, Tat
Taxes
Federal Taxes
Transfer Payments
$261.4
$261.
Corporate Profits Taxes
$7,949.7
$7,949.
Customs Duties
$552.4
$552.4
Excise Taxes
Non -Tax Payments
Income Taxes
$33,648.8
$1,489.1
$675.1
$1,489.1
$675.1
$33,648.8
Social Ins. Taxes - Employees
$14,908.3
$3,891.0
$18,799.3
Social Ins. Taxes - Employers
$15,129.1
$15,129.1
Total !Federal Taxes T _ — _$30,298.$
$3,891-01 $_33,648.
$7,949.
$2,716.6
$78,5.04.9
-
—
State & Local Taxes
Corporate Profits Tax
-
$1,052.
$1,052.
Dividends
$1,855.0
$1,855.0
Business Motor Vehicle Licenses
$150.0
$150.0
Other Business Taxes
$2,083.2
$2,083.2
Business Property Taxes
$6,565.1
$6,555.1
Business Non Tax Payments
$835.7
$835.7
Business Sales Taxes
$9,139.4
$9,139.4
Severance Taxes
$21.6
$21.6
Personal Motor Vehicle Licenses
$432.0
$432.0
Personal Fines & Fees
$1,434.3
$1,434.3
Personal Use Taxes & Fees
$26.5
$26.5
Personal Property Taxes
$183
$183.2
Social Ins. Taxes - Employees
$119.0
$119.0
Social Ins. Taxes - Employers
$476.4
$476•
Total State & Local Taxes
$595.4
$2,076.
$2,907.
$18,795.0
$24,374.
Total Taxes
$30,894.2
$3,891.01 $35,724.8
$10 857.51
$21,511.61
$102,879.1
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 2T
ONGOING TEAM OPERATIONS
ataie B-1. Recurring Employment Impacts Arising
from
the Florida
Marlins Team
erations
-
impacts
n ustry
Total
Agriculture & Forestry
0.0
0,1
0.5
0.6
Mining
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Utilities
0.0
1.5
2.3
3.8
Construction
0.0
5.4
2.9
8.3
Manufacturing
0.0
6.5
11.
18.3
Wholesale Trade
0.0
6.9
24.9
31.8
Transportation & Warehousing
2.4
16.4
20.4
39.2
Retail Trade
11.9
7.4
125.3
144.6
Information
0.0
8.1
8.0
16.1
Finance & Insurance
0.0
13.9
36.8
50.7
Real Estate
0.0
24.2
33.1
57.3
Professional Services
0.0
35.0
27.2
62.2
Company Management
0.0
5.6
4.7
10.3
Administrative
0.0
50.3
33.9
84.2
Educational Services
0.0
0.5
25.0
25.5
Health & Social Services
0.0
1.3
150.2
151.5
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
1,077.5
168.6
15.2
1,261.3
Accommodation & Food Services
546.1
10.9
72.1
629.1
Other Services
29.0
11.7
65.6
106.3
Government & Other
0.0
2.5
4.6
7.1
otal:
1,666.9 376.8
664.5
2,708.2
Source: The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 28
able B-2. Recurring Labor Income Impacts
Arising from
the Florida Marlins
Team
aperatians {$ in Thousands}
industry
'�:���•^direct
Impacts
IndTotal
- -
Agriculture & Forestry
0,0
22 13.5
15.7
Mining
0.0
0.61.7
2.3
Utilities
0.0
152.0 239.0
391.0
Construction
0.0
244.3 130.3
374.6
Manufacturing
0.0
290. 598.9
889.4
Wholesale Trade
0.0
452 1,625.5
2,078.1
Transportation & Warehousing
53.5
620.1 850.7
1,524.3
Retail Trade
301.6
229-E 3,883.7
4,414.8
Information
0.0
691.8 675.4
1,367.2
Finance & Insurance
0.0
979.4 2,470.9
3,450.3
Real Estate
0.0
656.3 825.9
1,482.
Professional Services
0.0
2,029.8 1,721.3
3,751.1
Company Management
0.0
489,0 410.6
899.
Administrative
0.0
1,456.2 897.4
2,353.£
Educational Services
0.0
18.3 935.1
953.4
Health & Social Services
0.0
60.2 6,880.0
6,940.2
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
77,867.0
9,478.4 451.4
87,796.8
Accommodation & Food Services
16,892.0
305.3 1,736.1
18,933.4
Other Services
579.0
296.1 1,462.5
2,337.
Government & Other
0.0
163--9 260.7
424.
vtal:
95,6911
18,616.5
26,070.6
140,380.
aurce: The Washington Economics Group. Inc.
The Washington Economics Group, [tic.
Page 29
able B-3, Recurring Miami GDP Arising from the Florida Marlins Team Operations
r in Thousands]
\griculture & Forestry
0.0
4.8
34.2
39.0
Jtining
0.4
1.4
4,0
5.4
Aiiities
0.4
552.0
865.1
1,417.1
.onstruction
O.0
260.5
134.8
395.3
Jlanufacturing
0.0
442.8
976.4
1,419.2
Nholesale Trade
0.0
805.8
2,894.1
3,699.9
Transportation & Warehousing
73.7
773.0
1,078.9
1,925.0
3etail Trade
418.5
370.0
6,236.4
7,024.
ntormation
0.0
1,298.9
1,445.4
2,744.2
=inance & Insurance
0.0
1,667.6
4,108.7
5,776.2
Seal Estate
0.0
2,958.9
3,185.2
6,144.1
'rofessional Services
0.0
2,339.9
1,997.3
4,337.2
;ompany Management
0.0
629.1
528.2
1,157.2
kdministrative
0.0
1,905.1
1,120.7
3,425.9
ducational Services
0.0
20.4
1,011.0
1,031.4
Aealth & Social Services
0.0
83.2
7,928.8
8,012.0
arts, Entertainment & Recreation
98,331.8
12,559.4
624.3
111,515.€
kccommodation & Food Services
27,760.7
483.3
2,561.0
30,805.0
)ther Services
834.8
346.5
1,774.0
2,955.2
.Aovernment & Other
0.01
258.01
9,137.01
9,395.0
otal: 1 127.419.51 27,760.61 47,645.1
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 30
able 6-4. Recurring Economic Output Impacts
Arising
from the
Florida Marlins
Team
perations ($ in Thousands)
11-
Total
Agriculture & Forestry
0.0
7.1
47.6
54.7
Mining
0.0
3.2
9.3
12.5.
Utilities
0.0
692.7
1,098.0
1,790.7
Construction
0.0
626.3
314.4
940.7
Manufacturing
0.0
1,664.2
4,099.7
5,763.9
Wholesale Trade
0.0
1,194.9
4,291.3
5,486.2
Transportation & Warehousing
125.0
1,275,5
2,036.2
3,436.7
Retail Trade
557.5
558.1
9,431.4
10,547.0
Information
0.0
2,704.2
2,985.0
5,689.2
Finance & Insurance
0.0
2,684.0
7,584.0
10,268.0
Real Estate
0.0
4,741.2
4,808.7
9,549.9
Professional Services
0.0
4,466.5
3,555.7
8,022.2
Company Management
0.0
1,075.8
903.2
1,979.0
Administrative
0.0
3,301.9
1,849.2
5,151.1
Educational Services
0.0
32.6
1,577.4
1,610.0
Health & Social Services
0.0
173.2
12,926.8
13,100.0
Arts, Entertainment & Recreation
130,133.0
16,903.8
994.0
148,030.8
Accommodation & Food Services
45,305.1
817.1
4,635.8
50,758.0
Cher Services
1,548.9
651.0
3,361.9
5,561.8
Government & Other
0.0
570.4
10,716.4
11,286.8
Low:
177,6619.q
44,143.71
77,226.0
299,039.
ource: The Washington Economics Group, inc.
The Washiiagton Economics Group, Inc. Page 31
o r 0m(9 R- raC)coIgIp QcoC?I-q
cq
CO N co m co 00 a) O w N Ca c7 LO N N 0 N r C] C] N
N co Iw 1- R I� CD N N �t) N CY) to N N C• � Y T�
r (3 Lo LS7 LO CYJ CO r Cl Ll7 M — .-- tp 00 co GO ,-- L[7 64 6A
CF} co (A or, C7 r- � L47 61), U�, 69 C6 &3} ER 63
(�y EFi 6Pl b3 M EFJ ff3 ECJ
I Ea3 fA
it
Na) co CY> c c� N ') Cn iC6
LD N m LO N N
r CQ co C'7 b3
y N ` CV (0 69 67
6g 5f1. ` 69 U) EO
07
C9
(3?
L
r Q
cli N C)
CA LA N N
`f CO C6 � 691
�v L
v. O
0 Q.
�s
� Lrs
cn Q- cq cq CO 03 Ln o0
y co as o ca CNI
C K M C7 ,� LO yg �
O C*j cl EA C!3
1P r
M f!3 Vi
s,
E F,
w x
CD m
C it 00 CO
69 Gn�
tai. LL.
c
Cl) LO o
N cD f -
C7 r
69
I
i
LO v
N CJ
N P'+
C3i r
cr;
Ef3
r
s
o
'i)
o
j,
Lll
O O
J
0)
a) �
J 0)
LL
❑ ❑ a,0
Q�
N
❑
O CL CZ X
O
ees
W tU
W
r_
IL IL
X
0 0�
W W�
�
aX)
CCS
a) .'��' to
d N
Ql
N
Cl) CE)
i'""
1 •t-
D
�. f,/}
D N
ID H
C]
0
N
�. }--
4
(D a) as O
ez Jx
. CL n
N
C) w
X
S— H
L
CL
❑
D O
ECS
t�3 ❑
O C N
CXG (X8
D F i'- ®V
O
N
� f
x CL
co
'a
0)
.N
fL
N
[U LL
d u;
X
LU [Il
to VJ
C
Cy
w
"i3
to D
to aa')
N
U _ _ _
C SlS w CM1i
_ [F} N
cu = ++
iC
F-
E
O7
0?
LL
s_ O
Cll [Y]
N 41
tU
id C £~ C
C _ _ c)
12
Cll
C Q O
E
m CSf
Rf
Q.
C
C
C
Q1 N N N
V7 . a
U
❑ l
X❑
U❑
O
Q
00
!- 0 C)
LII Z
C
CI7 cn
H
0 C_l
cn 0
CO rn
in
CJ] d 0_ d.
a. m to
cn
s
'I'IIIi WASHINGTON ECONOMICS GROUP, INC.
P'ROJEC'T' TEAM AND QUALIFICATIONS
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. Page 33
� �i e g I FICO orniCS titan
'�I �I Fcancrmic� C=roup, ixIc.
J. ANTONIO "TONY" VILLAMIL
Dean, School of Business of St. Thomas University of Florida
and Principal Advisor of
The Washington Economics Group, Inc.
Tony Villamil has over thirty years of successful experience as a business economist,
University educator and high-level policymaker at both federal and state governments.
He has served as a Presidential appointee U.S. Undersecretary of Commerce for
Economic Affairs, and is the founder of a successful economic consulting practice, The
Washington. Economics Group, Inc. (WEG). Since August 2008, Tony is the Dean of the
School of Business of St. Thomas University of Miami, while continuing to serve as
Principal Advisor to the clients of WEG.
Tony is a member of the President's Advisory Committee on Trade Policy and
Negotiations in Washington, D.C. He is the immediate past Chairman of the Governor's
Council of Economic Advisors of Florida, and during 1999-2000, he directed the
Tourism, Trade and Economic Development activities of the State in the Office of
Governor Jeb Bush. Presently, he is on the Board of Directors of the Spanish
Broadcasting System (NASDAQ), Mercantil Commercebank, N.A. and Enterprise
Florida — the State's principal economic development organization.
Among other leadership positions, he served in 2008 as the economist of the
Constitutionally mandated Tax and Budget Reform Commission of Florida (TBRC), and
is currently Chairman of the Economic Roundtable of the Beacon Council -- Miami -Dade
County's official economic development organization. He is also a Senior Research
Fellow of Florida TaxWatch, an established fiscal and policy research organization of the
State. After winning the gubernatorial election in November 2006, then Governor -elect
Charlie Crist appointed him as his Economic Advisor during the transition period.
Tony earned bachelor and advanced degrees in Economics from Louisiana State
University (LSU), where he also completed coursework for the Ph.D. degree. In 1991,
Florida International University (FTU) awarded him a doctoral degree in Economics (hc),
for "distinguished contributions to the Nation in the field of economics." He speaks
frequently to business, government and university audiences on economic topics, and was
until the summer of 2008 a member of the Graduate Business Faculty of Florida
International University (FIU).
The
1wegi Rconornicq Grou
Group. Inc. A
CHARLES K. YARDS
Associate Consultant for Economics
Chuck Yaros is an Associate Consultant for Economics at The Washington Economics
Group, Inc. (WEG). He serves as economic consultant in the areas of financial economics
and economic impact studies. Prior to joining WEG he was a Vice President and
Portfolio Strategist at Shay Financial Services in Miami where he specialized in
developing, implementing and managing interest rate risk and capital optimization
strategies for financial institutions.
Mr. Yaros has over 20 years of experience as a business and financial economist, having
worked in a number of positions of progressive responsibility in the South. Florida
business community. Additionally, he has spoken and taught courses on financial risk
management.
Chuck received his undergraduate degree in Economics with Honors from Trinity
College and his Master's degree in Economics from Duke University, where he also
completed course work for the Ph.D. degree.
Chuck and his family are residents of Coral Gables, Florida.
The Washington Economics Group, headquartered in Coral Gables, Florida, has been
successfully meeting client objectives since 1993 through strategic consulting services for
corporations and institutions based in the Americas. The Group has the expertise, high-
level contacts, and business alliances to strengthen a firm's competitive positron in the
rapidly expanding market places of Florida, and Latin America.
j� e [ `fiic Washington
V ii.�� Fconomics Group, Inc -
The Washington Economics Group, Inc. (WEG) has been successfully meeting client
objectives since 1993 through economic consulting services for corporations, institutions and
governments of the Americas. We have the expertise, high-level contacts, and business alliances
to strengthen your competitive positioning in the growing marketplaces of Florida and Latin
America.
Our roster of satisfied clients, over the past fourteen years, includes multinational
corporations, financial institutions, public entities, and non-profit associations expanding
thein operations in the Americas.
EXCLUSIVE CONSULTING APPROACH:
Each client is unique to us. We spend considerable time and effort ill understanding the
operations, goals, and objectives of clients as they seek our consulting and strategic advice. We
are not a mass -production consulting entity nor do we accept every project that comes to us. We
engage a limited number of clients each year that require customized consulting services in our
premier areas of specialization. These premier and exclusive services are headed by former U.S.
Under Secretary of Commerce, Dr. J. Antonio Villarrnl, with over twenty --five years of experience
as a business executive and as a senior public official of the U.S. and most recently of Florida.
PREMIER CONSULTING SERVICES:
Comprehensive Cotporate Ftipansion_5eryices. Our seamless and customized service includes
site selection analysis, development of incentive strategies and community and governmental
relations.
Economic Impact Studies highlight the importance of a client's activities in the generation of
income, output and employment in the market area serviced by the entity. These studies are also
utilized to analyze the impact of public policies on key factors that may affect a client's activities
such as tax changes, zoning, environmental permits and others.
Strategic Business Develoi2tnent Services. These services are customized to meet client
objectives, with particular emphasis in the growing marketplaces of Florida, Mexico, Central and
South America. Recent consulting assignments include custorxtized marketing strategies, country
risk assessments for investment decisions and corporate spokesperson activities and speeches on
behalf of the client at public or private meetings.
--- "----- -...------------.---`-------------------------------i
For a full description of WEG capabilities and
x ,
� .services, please visit our website at:
I
www.weg.com
'--------
-*Are � Ttac W.stn.'Stnu
13conomio% Group, Inc. -
Representative Client List
1993-2008
Multinational Corporations Financial Institutions
- Lockheed Martin
- FedEx Latin America
- IBM
- Motorola
- SBC Communications
- Ameritech International
- Lucent Technologies
-
MediaOne/AT&T
- Joseph E. Seagram & Sons, Inc. (Vivendi)
- Microsoft Latin America
- Carrier
- Medtronic
- Phelps Dodge
- Esso Inter -America
- Visa International
- MasterCard International
- Telefonica Data Systems
- Bureau Veritas (BIVAQ
- Merck Latin America
- DMJM & Harris
- DLA Piper
- Wilbur Smith Associates
- PBSJ
Florida -Based Corporations
- Sprint of Florida
- Florida Marlins
- Flo -Sun Sugar Corp.
- Farm Stores
- The BMI Companies
- Spillis Candela & Partners
- The Biltmore Hotel/Seaway
- Trammel Crow Company
- Advantage Capital
- WCI Development Companies
- Iberia Tiles
- Florida Hospital
- Mercy Hospital
- The St. Joe Companies
- Florida Power & Light (FPL)
- International Speedway Corporation
Latin America -Based Institutions
- Federation of Inter -American Financial Institutions
(FIBAFIN)
- The Brunetta Group of Argentina
- Association of Peruvian Banks
- Peruvian Management Institute (IPAE)
- Mercantil Servicios Financieros, Venezuela
- Allied-Domecq, Mexico
- Fonalledas Enterprises
- International Bank of Miami
- Pan American Life
- ABN-AMRCI Bank
- Barclays Bank
- Lazard Freres & Co.
- Banque Nationale de Paris
- HSBCIMarine Midland
- Fiduciary Trust International
- Sun Trust Corporation
- First Union National Bank (Wachovia)
- Union Planters Bank of Florida (Regions)
- Bank Atlantic Corp.
- Hemisphere National Bank
- BankUnited, FSB
- Mercantil Commercebank N.A.
- PointeBank, N.A.
- The Equitable/AXA Advisors
Public Institutions, Non -Profit Organizations &
Universities
- Baptist Health Systems
- Jackson Health Systems
- Miami -Dade Expressway Authority
- Miami -Dade College
- Miami Museum of Science
- Zoological Society of Florida
- Florida International University
- University of Miami
- Universidad Poiitecnica de Puerto Rico
- Sistama Universitario Arra G. Mdndez (SUAGM)
- Keiser University
- Full Sail Real World Education
- Florida Agricultural & Mechanical University (FAMU)
- Inter -American Development Batik (IDB)
- United Nations Economic Development Program (UNDP)
- Florida Ports Council
- Florida Sports Foundation
- Florida Citrus Mutual
- Florida Nursing Homes Alliance
- Florida Bankers Association
- Florida Outdoor Advertising Association
- City of Plantation
- City of West Palm Beach
- Economic Development Commission of Lee County
- Economic Development Commission of Miami -Dade
(Beacon Council)
- Economic Development Commission of Mid -Florida
- Jacksonville Chamber of Commerce
- SW Florida Regional Chamber of Commerce
- Enterprise Florida, Inc.
- The Beacon Council
- Visit Florida
- Louisiana Committee for Economic Development
- University of South Florida/ENLACE
- Space Florida
State of Florida