Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-79-064971 ties, without to the residents RESOLUTION NO. 79-649 A RESOLUTION REQUESTING THE DADE COUNTY COMMISSION TO IMMEDIATELY DEVELOP THE APPROPRIATE MECHANISM TO FINANCE THE METRO & FIRE RESCUE SERVICE IN FISCAL YEAR 1979-1980 WITHOUT COST TO MIAMI TAXPAYERS, OR REMIT $1,196,740 TO THE CITY OF MIAMI REPRESENTING THE AMOUNT OF DOUBLE TAX COLLECTED WITHIN MIAMI; AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER TO MEET WITH PROPER DADE COUNTY OFFICIALS TO EXPEDITE THE RESOLUTION OF THE DOUBLE TAXATION ISSUE; FURTHER AUTHORIZING THE CITY MANAGER, TO RECOMMEND A DOUBLE TAXATION CONSULTANT TO THE COMMISSION AT ITS NEXT MEETING. WHEREAS, Metropolitan Dade County Miami Taxpayers for Metro Fire do not receive; and (Metro) is.charging City & Rescue Services that the city ,:;WHEREAS, the cost'for those services amounted $800,00.0 for :,Fiscal Year 19 78-79; and W:HiEREAS, the 1979.-80 Dade? a cost of 'app�proximately r-4 taxpayers, ariid taxpayers solely Rescue County taxpayers to approximately Budget presently anticipates .2 million;' to;be taxed against City of Miam WHEREAS, such a tax represents double taxation `of Miami for Metro Fire & Rescue Services, inter:alia; and WHEREAS, these Metro .Fire & Rescue for the benefit of 22 cities that D epia'r tm e n t s.over WHEREAS, the. to. Metro; inclusion Dade County's General' Operations in direct and Services are provided turne "DOCUMLN j l�t e ITEM NO. rr of Metro Fire & Rescue Services i Budget is in fatal conflict with and violation of Section 125.01 (6)( prohibits the use of countywide by the County where no real and within a municipality; and ), Florida Statutes, which revenues to fund any service provided substantial benefit accrues to the property WHEREAS, Metro Fire & Rescue Services charge, does not provide any real or substantial benefit of the City of'Miami; and, WHERE'AS,Section 125.01 (6)(a) further provides governing body rendered municipality by "resolution' specially_ for the benefit of the given to 22 municipali- for the o identify a service property or residents of LY COMMISSION i MEETING OF SE P 2 7 iS79 la.79-64 municipalitq $1,196,740; Board of the unincorporated to petition mechanism.to area and financed from countywide revenues:.and the Board of County Commissioners to develop an appropriate finance the activity or remit the identified cost to the within 6 months of the adoption of the County Budget; and WHEREAS, the City of Miami has".identified that 'cost to be and: WHEREAS, the City of Miami requests that the Dade County: CountyCommissioners remit said amount to the City of Miami as provided by law; and WHEREAS', :refusal to remit said funds to the City of_.Miami or to develope an appropriate mechanism to finance such activity shall be an admission by Dade County::that it willfully continues,t impose double taxation upon the citizens of Miami"and is engage pattern and,pr.actice of tax discrimination taxpayers against the . citizens .any of the City of Miami, Florida;" NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA:. Section 1. The Metropolitan Dade County Board of Count Commissionersis hereby mechanism 22 cities requested :o.' immediately develop .an appropriate to finance the cost of providing Fire & Rescue Services to for Fiscal Year 1979-1980 in order'to provide the taxpayers of Miami, Florida, with relief from being required to:pay`` & Rescue Services that they do not "receive. City of the for Fire Section 2. In the eventthe appropriate mechanism cannot; be implemented, the Dade County Board of County Commissioners :'shall remit to the City of Miami'a payment in the amount of six (6) months; of:the adoption of the .1979-1980 Budge $1,196 740 within said amount being the amount of Dade County taxes imposed upon property owners P the corporate limitsof the City of ,Miami, .Florida, and representing a.double tax on said property owners in providing,;' Rescue Services which they do`not.receive. , situated within Fire & Section hereby requested The Metropolitan to make Dade County Commission is its intentions known to the Miami City "SUPPORTIVE - DOCUMENTS T` FOLLOW" 79-64' Mi f COMMiSlii°1114; 6 Resnuet::::71-tilliculoeills1;:;14:::;:i:::;;;;:;::1141;:till.ed to resolve and eliminate. double in the cost of providing Fire distribut cost to City taxes. Section 4. Ther,is hereby authorized City Manager :he . to meet with the appropriate county officials to expedite resolution and elimination of double resulting from the collection, and expenditure of ,Bade-:C()nat..7e7e11777,:, - Section The City manager is hereby authorized n to investigate the qualifications of and re7mileo:dto ila:-'%Cif-i517:fi:;:::ii::i''° a reputable consultingfrmto as7istthe.Ciy ,.,i 74 llu7 resolving, and elimiaati7g, all forms 0f double taxation that affect oroet owners and. taxpayers, and the cit714anIIgarshall-.71il:li::n. Miami Pr at ' e such recomMendatiOn the neXt regular gulaweetiUBof t!1a-:1-:7,:olia19:::s PASSED AND ADOPTED tha,;?.2iL1 day.of'sar-Nm17r, .,.. . . /S- -MAURICE- A. FERRE , . MAYOR,, , .. . . ATTEST: RAFH G. ONGIE, CITY eLERK PREPARED AND APPROVED BY: RCBERT . CLARK, ASSISTANT CITY ATTORNEY APPROVED AS GEORGE F. ORM AND CORR SS: "SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS FOLLOW" 79-649 TO: CITY OF MIAMI, FLOf2IOA IMT R-OFFlCC McMc7RANDU;,1 Joseph R. Grassie City Manager Clark Merrill Assistant to the City Manager DATE. $Ut3JECT: ,September 20, 1979 me, PEF'EHENCEB: Double Taxation resulting from Metro Fire & Rescue Services. I recommend that the attached Resolution requesting the Board of County Commissioners to pay the City of Miami $1,196,740 unlaw- fully taxed against the property owners of the City of Miami or to immediately develop the appropriate mechanisms as required by law to end the Double Taxation of City of Miami taxpayers be adopted and delivered to the proper County officials prior to October 1, 1979. This issue rises as a result of Dade County contracts to take over the Fire and Rescue Services for 16 Cities (and 6 cities without contract) and unlawfully apportion the cost to all county taxpayers rather than to the benefited Cities directly. This causes taxpayers in they unserved cities and the unincorporated area tobe double taxed for Fire & Rescue Services not received. Although some County officials readily admit to the lack ofequity in this arrangement, they are bound by contract not to directly tax the benefited Cities for these servi- ces unless it is as a result of an election held for that purpose or by Court order. In 1979-80 the taxpayers of Miami, Hialeah, Miami Beach,'Coral Gables, West Miami and the Unincorporated Area will be paying over $5.6 million in Dade County taxes for Metro Fire & Rescue Services that;are provided in the 22 benefited cities. ilia-` mi taxpayers will be paying $1,196,740 of that amount. Thisrepresents over $35 out of every $1000 in Dade County taxes that are collected in Miami to pay for Metro Services that are not received in this City. The countywide millage rate could be reduced by .302 mills if Metro would directly charge the 22 cities for the County Fire and Rescue Services that they are receiving. The removal of this Double Taxation would provide a $5,684,200 tax relief to approximately 82% of the population of this County. The City of Miami property owners are pay ni g approx. $22 million for one of the best Fire Departments in the County and it is simply not equitable for them to have to pay another 5% on top of that for Metro Fire & Rescue Services they do not receive. tt SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS FOLLOW" 79-649 Joseph R. Grassie September 20, 1979 Page 2. A new State Law went into effect on July 1, 1979 that prohibits the use of County revenues to fund any Service provided by the County where no real • and substantial benefit accrues to thejroperty or residents within a munici- pality or municipalities. The Law also provides for -the governing body of a municipality by resolution to identify a service rendered specifically for the benefit of the residents in the unincorporated areas and financed from Countywide revenues and petition the Board of County Commissioners to develop an appropriate mechanism to finance such activity through service charges, special assessments or a municipal service taxing unit or to remit the identi- fied cost (double tax) to the municipality or municipalities within 6 months of the adoption of the County Budget. While the Law refers to services provided to the unincorporated areas, whose property owners coincidentally are also double taxed, it is apparent that passage of the attached resolution represents the best method of identifying the double taxation problem and urging an immediate solution by the County. It is imperative, however, that this notice to the County be presented to the proper County officials prior to October 1, 1979. The obvious solution to this double taxation problem, is to create a special taxing district and charge the people who are benefited by the services received. Another method would be through the Courts. To this extent Coral Gables has voted to take this issue to court and would like the City to intervene. Double Taxation has existed for many years and the County has' not taken the necessary steps to eliminate?the problem. The CiAttorney will` have to advise the Commission on the Citysprospect of winningty in Court. It.would appear, however, that due to the large amount of double tax being paid to the County by Miami Taxpayers, that persuasive action is needed soon. In order to provide additional explanation of this Issue, the following material is attached: 1. Outstanding Issue with Metro (County Cost. Apportionment Formula) 2. Metro Fire & Rescue Services Cost Distribution Analysis 3. County Fire & Rescue Service Charges distributed to Dade County Cities ▪ Dade County Ad Valorem Taxes collected from City Taxpayers . Chapter 79-87 (Laws of Florida) regarding Double Taxation 6. Dade County Comparative Tax Roll and Property Tax Millage Rates Tofurther demonstrate the gross inequity of the present County arrangement for distributing the Costs of Metro Fire & Rescue Services I call your attention to the fact. that the 1979-80 Metro Budget provides for an additional $925,000 to pay for the Miami Springs Fire & Rescue. The cost that will be distributed to the Miami Springs taxpayers through the Countywide Ad Valorem Tax will be only $54,575 or a net savings of $870,425. Miami taxpayers will pay at least $170,385 to provide Miami Springs with Fire & Rescue Services this coming year. .,Revised 8/15/79 Outstanding Issue'With M DOUBLE (DUAL) TAXATION.- Metro Fire & Rescue Countywide Cost Distribution_Formula DOUBLE TAXATION is the result of Dade County chargingall County tax TIax payexiers for services that benefit only a portion of the County. Miami due to Metro Fire and Rescue Services being provided to 22 Dade County Cities and charged to all Dade County taxpayers including 5 of the largest cities that pay for their own Fire and Rescue Services. These unserved Cities are res- ponsible for approximately 37.5% of the County Taxes. Miami has itseownaFireaand Rescue Service at a cost of about $22 Million per year. However, payers must also pay approximately $1,197,000 more in their County taxes for their rovides to hre of the costthof eservedFire b and Metrosore$397,000Services morethat thanDade theyninvoluntarily the 22 Cities that areY contributed in County taxes last year. Since the City of Miami, in 1979, had 18.42% of all taxable property in Dade County, Miami taxpayers pay 18.42% of cost of Fire and Rescue Services for the 22 Cities served by Metro. The formula for Municipal Fire -Rescue Service cost, Allocation is as follows: (figures are based on estimates in the Metro ,1979-80._Proposed'Budget and from the Metro Office of Management and Budget). Unincorporated Area Population Total Served by Metro Fire and Rescue Services i.e. 731,530 918,260 79.66 USE 80 % Population of 22 Cities Served Total Served by Metro Fire and Rescue Services 20.34 % USE 20 i.e. 186,730 B18,260. Unincorporated MunicipalService Area Less special benefit to 22 Cities Unincorporated Area Share County Wide Cost Allocation 20% X 25,477,000 Add as a result of the special benefit to 22 Cities (Based on Dade County Budget Formula) Total to be distributed through County Wide Ad Valorem Taxes (Including 5 unserved Cities and additional tax on Unincorporated nincorporated Cost Allocation = County Wide Cost Allocation Dade County 1979-80.Budget for Metro Fire and Rescue Service = $ 25,477,000 (does not includelRandall Eastern'Ambulance Contract or Capital Improvements, etc.) 0,381,600 USE $ 20,382,000 - 1,402,000 $ 18,980,000 80% X 25,477,000 Miami's DOUBLE TAX for Metro Fire & Rescue 18.42% X $6,497,000 = Population Served Cities Not Served 22 Cities Served = Unincorporated Area = Total vs Unserved. 609,500 (40.0%) 186,730. (12.2%) 731,530 (47.8%) Population 1,527,760 (100h = $ 5,095,400, Area', 1,196,747 918,260 (60.0%) USE $ 5,095,000 + 1,402,000 $ 6,497,000 USE $ 1,197,000 'SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS FOLLOW" . Page Two The DOUBLE TAXATION for the 5 Cities that are not served is Estimated Per Centof County. Amount of City Tax; Roll * . DOUBLE TAX Miami Hialeah Miami Beach Coral Gables West Miami Total of Unserved Cities 1842 % 6.62 7.39 % 4.75 % .27 % 37.45 % Population * $ 1,196,740 344,000 430,100 128,800 480,120 89,000 308,600 42,200 17,540 5,500 $ 2,433,100 609,500 Population Not served = 609,500 = 40.0 % of County Population. Additional cost allocated to County Tax Payers due to Metro Fire & in 22 Cities is as follows: Unincorporated 22 Cities Served 5 Cities NotServed. Area - County Wide Allocation Allocation Allocation (DOUBLE TAX Total Metro Fire & Rescue Costs to be Allocated County Wide DOUBLE TAX) $ 3,251 Unincorporated Municipal Service Area Budget Allocation Total Cost All * As shown i Metro Fire & Rescue 1979-80 Metro Budget Per Capita Cost DOUBLE TAX $ 3.48 3.34 5.39 7.34 3.19 3.99 A • Rescue Service Percent Per of Capita Tax Roll Cost 100 50.04 % 12 800 433,100 12.51 % 37.45 % 497,000 100. % 189B0,000 * 25,477,000 Ir • .UPPORTIVE OCUMENTS FOLLOW" $ 4.44 4.35 3.99 ($ 4.25 Av.) Prepared by: Clark Merrill City of Miami Intergovernmental Affairs August 15, 1979 79-649 ea Q) CITY:'/UNINC. POPULATION METROPOLITAN DADE COUNTY FIRE AND RESCUE SERVICES COST DISTRIBUTION ANALYSIS FIRE & RESCUE NITRO PER CAPITA COST CITY UNINC. PER PER; CAPITA'. DOUBLE' TAX METRO TOTAL.:COST COST. TOTAL COST DOUBLE TAXATION PERCENT INCREASE DUE TO DOUBLE TAX TOTAL COST FIRE & RESCUE SERV. PPER RECAPITA TACUE SERY. TOTAL COST METRO + MUNICIPAL METRO + MUNICIPAL / M1AMI 344.000;.. #_HIALEAH "- 128,800 / MIAMI BEACH 89,000. $ 22.045,388 $ 64.09 3,559,497* $•27 64' $ ::3,674,486* $ 41.29*:_: 1,196,740 430,100 $ 3.34 480,120 $,5.40 5.4 % $ 23,242,135 12.8 % $ 3.989,598 13.1 % $ 4.154,614: $ 67.57 $ 30.98 / CORAL GABLES 42.200_ 2,885.977* f'68.38* 308,600,', 7.31 .10_7 %; WEST-;MIAMI 5,500 157.627` ' $`,28.66*;' 17,540 3.19 $ 3,194 585:' 11.1 %: $ 175, 170 46.69 $ 75.69' $ 31:85 (CITY SUB TOTALS) (609,500) ($ 32,322,975)* ($ 53.03 Av.)*($ 2,433,100), UNINC. AREA 731.530 18;980.000** $ 25.95** $ 3,251,100 f 4 44 ,- METRO DOUBLE TAX DISTRIBUTION TO 5 CITIES 1 UNINC. AREA (1,341030) 22 CITIES 186.730 5.684,200**, XXX ($ 5,684,200) " S 4.24- 812,700**, $ 4.35*** 0 TOTAL COUNTY 1,527,760 * CITY TAX ** METRO TAX *** PER CAPITA COST IF DOUBLE TAXATION ELIMINATED $ 34.79 / CITIES NOT SERVED BY METRO FIRE & RESCUE SERVICES W (Metro) $ 57,799,875 USE $ 57,800,000* (Average) $ 37.19 $ 5,684,200 XXX Notes: - Totale & Rescue perDadeCounty Budgett of Metro rOffice: $ 25.477,000 - Cost to be distributed to County -Wide tax payers = $ 6.497.000 per Dade County Allocation Formula - Metro Double Tax is based on Cities share of the Dade County Tax Roll - Metro Double Tax - = $ 2,433,100 - Metro Double Tax = $ 3,251,100 Total for 5 unserved Cities - Unincorporated Areas 7.53% Av:)($ 34,756,102) 17.1 $ 22.231,099 XXX XXX 0 % $ 812,700 XXX $ 57,800.000 `'PT1VE F ... ;.a' ($ 57.02 Av). 30.39 XXx $ 4.35*** (Average) $ 41.08 (Average Excluding 22 Cities) $ 47.20 Prepared by: Clark Merrill City of Miami Intergovernmental Affairs August 15, 1979 COUNTY FIRE & RESCUE SERVICE CHARGES DISTRIBUTED TO OADE COUNTY CITIES *. Not Served by Metro Fire & Rescue (DOUBLE TAX) 1979 Distributed Costs Cities Population % of Tax Roll for Metro Fire & Rescue * Miami 344,000* 18.42 % $ 1,196,747* Hialeah 128,800* 662 % 430,100*, * Miami; Beach 89,000* 7.39 % 480,128* North ,Miami 42,200 2.54 % 165,024 * Coral Gables 42,200* 4.75 % 308,608* North Miami Beach 34,000 2.05 % 133,188 Homestead 25,300 .80 % 51,976' OpaLocka 13,400 .78 % 50,677 Miami Springs 12,600 ,84 % 54,575 South Miami 11,100 .71 % 46,129 Miami Shores 9,000 .71 % 46,129 Sweet Water 8,000 .24 % 15,593 * West Miami '" 5,500* 27 % 17,542* Florida City 5,000 .16.'% 10,395 Bay Harbor Island 4,800 .49 % 31,835 North Bay Village`; 4,800 .39 % 25,338 Surfside 3,900 52 % 33,784 Biscayne Park 2,500 .14 % 9,096 Virginia Gardens 2,500 .15 %'. Bal Harbour 2,500 .88 % El Portal 2,400 .10 % Hialeah Gardens 1,100 .32 % Golden Beach 840 .15 % Medley 600 .49 % 31,835 Indian Creek 80. .05 % 3,248 Islandia 10 00 % 0 9,745 57,174 6,498 20,790 9,746 ` Pensucco. �. r, Not listed in Dade County Budget) All Cities 796,230 49 96_% $ 3,245,900 Unincorporated Area 731,530 50.04 % 3,251,100 Total Population 1,527,760 Amount to be distributed - .S 6,497,000(52.6% Increase, County wide : over last year, O c rn 79-649 DADE` VALOREM TAXES_; cOL,LE.CLEDiiOM CITY TAXPAYERS CITIES. Miami Hialeah Miami Beach North Miami Coral Gables North Miami Beach Homestead OpaLocka Miami Springs South Miami Miami Shores Sweet Water West Miami. Florida City Bay Harbor. Isand North Bay Village Surfside Biscayne Park Virginia Gardens Bal Harbour El Portal Hialeah Gardens Golden Beach Medley Indian Creek Islandia Pensucco All Cities Unincorporated Area Total, Population PERCENT OF POPULATION TAX ROLL 344,000 128,800 89,000 42,200 42,200 34,000 25,300 13,400 12,600 11,100 .;. 9,000 8,000 5,500 18.42 6,62 % 7.39 ,, 2.54 4,75% -; 2.05 % .80 %' .78'%, .84 % .71,% .71 S .24 % .27 % 5,000 .16 % 4,800 49 % 4,800: .39'% 3,900 .52 % 2,500 .14 % 2,500 . .15.% 2,500 .88 %' 2,400 .10 % 1,100„ .32.7 840` .15 % , 600 " .49 % 80 .05'% COLLECTION OF 1979-80 COUNTY TAXES PER CAPITA ($182,355,732) $ 33,589,926 $ 97.65 12,071,949, 93.73 13,476,089 151.42 4,631,836 8,661,897 3,738,292 1,458,846 1,422,374 1,531,788 :. 1,294,726 1,294,726 437,654 492,360 291,769 893,543 711,187.. 948,250-. 255,298' 273,534 1,787,086 182,356 583,538 273,534 893,543 91,178 10 .00' a 0 , ( Not Listed in Dade County Budget 796,230 731,530 1,527,760 49.96 5' $.' 91,104,924 50.04 S $ 91,250,808 Amount' County Wide $ 182,355,732.. UPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS 10976, 205.26 109.95 57.66 106,15 121.57 116.64 143.86 5471 89.52 .` 58.35. 18615 '. 148.16 243.14 102.12 109.41 714.83 75.98 530.49 325.64 1,489.24 1,139.73 Av.)$114.42 Av.) $ :124.74 County Average $ 119.36. 9-649 •1AOE: Y�Ap VALOREM _TAXES ,C_OLLECIED ROM CITY TAXPAYERS CITIES POPULATION Miami 344,000 Hialeah 128,800 Miami Beach 89,000. North Miami 42,200 Coral Gables 42,200 North 'Miami 'Beach 34,000 Homestead 25,300 OpaLocka Miami Springs South Miami Miami Shores Sweet Water: West Miami Florida City Bay Harbor Island 13,400 12,600 11,100. 9,000 8,000. 5,500 5,000 4,800-= North Bay Village 4,800 Surfside 3,900 Biscayne Park 2,500 Virginia`Gardens 2,500 Bal Harbour 2,500 .88 % El Portal 2,400 .10 % Hialeah Gardens 1,100;, Golden Beach 840 .15 % Medley 600 .49 % Indian Creek 80 .05 % Islandia 10 .00 % Pensucco - ( Not Listed in Dade County -Budget. PERCENT OF TAX ROLL 18.42 % 6.62 % 7.39 % 2,54:% 4.75 % 2.05 % .80 % .78 % 64.% .71 % .71% .24 % .27.% .16 % 49 % .39-% .52.% .14"% .15 % COLLECTION OF 1979-80 COUNTY TAXES ($182,355,732) $ 33,589,926 12,071,949 13,476,089 4,631,836 8,661,897 3,738,292 1,458,846 1,422,374 1,531,788 1,294,726 1,294,726 437,654 492,360 291,769 893543 711,187 '948,250 255,298 273,534 1,787,086. 182,356. 583,538 273,534 893,543 91,178 PER CAPITA $ 97.65 93.73 151,42: 109,76 205.26 109.95 5766 106.15. 121.57 116.64 14386 5471 89.52 58.35 186.15 148.16 243.14 102.12 109.41 714.83 75.98 , 530.49 325.64' ,489.24 1,139.73 All Cities 796,230 49.96 % $' 91,104,924 (Av) $ 114.42 Unincorporated Area 731,530 50.04 % $: 91,250,808 (Av) $ 124.74 County Total Population 1,527,760 Amount County Wide ' $ 182,355,732 Average $..119.36 'SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS 79-649 CHAPTER 79-87 House Bill No. 1568 An, act relating to county government: amending paragraph (a) of S. 125.01(6), Florida Statutes, and adding a subsection thereto; providing a method of remitting the identified cost of a service to a municipality or municipalities; providing for the use of any other method prescribed by state law; providing a restriction on the expenditure of county revenues; providing for a study by the Advisory Council on Intergovernmental Relations; providing an effective date. Be It Enacted by the Legislature of the State of Florida: Section 1. Paragraph (a) of subsection (6) of section 125.01, Florida Statutes, is amended, and subsection (7) is added to said section to '' read: 125.01 Powers and duties.- (6)(a) The governing body _ of a municipality or municipalities by resolution, or the citizens:of a municipality or county by petition of 10 percent of the qualified electors of such unit, may identify a service or program rendered specially for the benefit of the property or residents in unincorporated areas and financed from countywide revenues and .petition the board of county commissioners to develop an appropriate mechanism to finance such activity for the ensuing fiscal year, which may e-ither be by taxes, special assessments, or service charges levied or ,imposed solely upon residents or property in the unincorporated area, by the establishment of a municipal service taxing or benefit unit pursuant to paragraph (q) of subsection (1), or by remitting the identified cost of service paid from revenues required to be expended on a countywide basis by--Eke-lakes-iev3ed-open-peepetty-s3tnaee-w#eh3n-the-mam4edeeiity et-mon4e4pai4t4es to the municipality or municipalities, within 6 months of the adoption of the county budget, in the proEortion that county ad vanotem taxes collected within such municipality or municipalities bears to the total amount of countywide ad valorem taxes collected by the county, or by any other method prescribed by state law. (7) No county revenues, except those derived specifically from or on behalf of a municipal service taxing unit, special district, unincorporated area, service area, or program area, shall be used to fund any service or project provided by the county where no real and substantial benefit accrues to the property or residents wilt inn a municipality or municipalities. Section 2. The Advisory Council on Intergovernmental Relations is hereby directed to study the relationship of federal and state shared revenue programs, municipal utility charges, and other fiscal aspects to`' the double taxation issue. The council shall file a report of its findings and recommendations with the Governor and Legislature by March 1, 1980. Section 3. This; act shall take effect July 1, 197.9. Approved by the Governor May 28, 1979. Filed in office Secretary of State May 31, 1979. This public document was promulgated at a base cost of $13.50 per page for 1,500 copies or $.0090 per single page for the purpose of informing the public of Acts passed by the Legislature. CODING: Words in.seenek-theengk typeare deletions from existing law; words _in underscored type are additions. 'SUPPORTIVE IVE DOCUMENTS FOLLOW" 79.649 FROM 1979-80 PROPOSED DADE COUNTY BUDGET COMPARATIVE TAX ROLL 1979 Value Per Mill of Taxable Property (Preliminary Assessment Roll) 1978 Value Per Mill of Taxable Property Increased Value PROPERTY TAX MILLAGE RATES General Operating Debt Service Total Countywide Millage Unincorporated Municipal Service Area Library System , Miami Lakes Parks Distrlct= - . . . 524,102,000 21,595,000 2,507,000 1978-79 1979-80 8.096 7.566 1.160 1.360 9.256 8.926 1.092 1.0216 .446 • "SUPPORTIVE DOCUMENTS FOLLOW" 1.375 9-649