HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-80-0905P
RESOLUTION No. . J
A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE MOST QUALIFIED
CONSULTING FIRMS TO PROVIDE PROFESSIONAL
ARCHITECTURAL/E:NGINEERING SERVTCES FOR
THE DESIGN AND CONSTRUCTION OF COMMUNITY
BUILDINGS AT CURTIS AND WEST END PARKS
AND SWIMMING POOL ACCESS RENOVATTONS AT
WEST END AND SHENANDOAH PARES; AUTHORIZING
THE CITY MANAGER TO UNDERTAKE NEGOTIATIONS
WITH THE NOST QUALTF:rED FTR!-IS TO ARRIVE AT
A CONTRACT WETCH IS FAIR, COMPETITIVE: AND
REASONABLE, AND AL,LOCATTNc; 51C,5, 5G .00
_
FROM THE CAPITAL TMPROVEIMEN`I' FUND AND FROM FOURTH, FIFTH AND
SIXTH YEAR COMMUNITY DI VFLOPMENT GIANT
• y`f17
FUNDS TO COVER COST OF SATD CONTRACT, AND
Y
DIRECTING THE CITY t-IANAGEP TO PRESENT
EXECUTED CONTIACT TO THE CO1'-U-1ISSION AFTER
THE EXECUTION 01' CONTRACT, FOR RATIFICATION
AND APPROVAL OF THE COMMISSION.
WHEREAS, the City of Miami intends to acquire professional services
for the design and construction of Community Buildings at Curtis and
West End Parks and Swimminq Pool Access Renovations at West End and
Shenandoah Parks in t.lre near future; and
WHEREAS, the C i t v Commission adopted the Capital
Improvement Program Budget, including, among other items, allocations
from the U. S. Department of the Interior Urban Park and Recreation
Recovery Fund for the aforementioned construction and renovation pro3ects;
and
WHEREAS, the City of Miami has also programmed future year Community
Development Block Grant Funds for the aforementioned construction and
renovation projects; and
WHEREAS, in the implementation of the said construction program, the
City Manager solicited expressions of interest from qualified consultants
and evaluated tho qualifications of those firms which responded to his
inquiry, then selected the most qualified firms for providinq professional
architectural/enq.ineerinq services for the design and construction of the
Community Buildings and Pools, all in accordance with the State of Florida
Consultants' Competitive Negotiation Act, enacted by the legislature of
Florida, July 1, 1973 and by City of Miami Ordinance No. 8965, July 23,
1979; and
WHEREAS, it is in the best interests of the City of Miami to begin
the design of the Community Buildings and Pools as soon asl
MICROFI! 1,IINC COMPLETED
�� r, C. I L l; I Z N
lI p, .:Ii1L !1,
cin COWAISSI N
KI E ING OF
�� ��_L' _ 'I1�
F.�11
Or
in order to reduce costs;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI,
FLORIDA:
Section 1. The City Commission hereby approves the selection
of the City Manager of the following firms as the most qualified to provide
professional architectural services for the design and construction of
Community Buildings at Curtis and West End Par}:s and Swimming Pool Access
Renovations at West End and Shenandoah Parks, in the rank order listed:
(a) Firm No. 1: Carr Smith and Associates, Inc., 123 Almeria Avenue,
Coral Gables, Florida 33134, telephone 442-0035.
(b) Firm No. 2: Stottler Stagq and Associates, 3501 S.W. 8th Street,
Suite #204, Miami, Florida 33156, telephone 444-5890.
(c) Firm No. 3: Wallace, Roberts and Todd, 150 S.E. 2nd Avenue,
Suite 41111, Miami, Florida 33131, telephone 371-3822.
Section 2. The C i L v Comm i s s i can he reh \• authorizes the City
Manager to negotiate and enter into professional services agreement on
behalf of the City of Miami with the first rank ordered firm listed in
Section 1, hereinabove. In the event that the City :.anager cannot
negotiate an agreement which, in his opinion, is fair, competitive and
reasonable, with the first rank ordered firm, then lie is hereby authorized
to terminate such negotiations and to proceed to negotiate with the second
most qualified firm. In the event that he fails to negotiate a satisfactory
contract with the second firm, then he is authorized to undertake negotiations
with the third most qualified firm.
Section 3. The amount of $165,569.00 is hereby allocated from the
account entitled "Capital Improvement Fund" and from Fourth, Fifth and Sixth
Year Communit%, Development Cr,uIL Funds to cover the cost of the professional
service agrremWnt :Intl 011 relrlLeLl cletii};n sL!1-v1re5 expenses.
Section 4. The
City
Manager is directed
to present to
the
City Comm i s s i on
the
executed contract
at the earliest
scheduled
meeting of the
City
Commission
immediately
following the
execution of the said contract, for ratification and approval of the
Commission,
11SUPr -%r�—ri Fr
0�'�05
-W.,- ' ' ",-
OV
r-"
PASSED AND ADOPTED THIS 17 day of DECEMBER
198
r
MAURICE A. FERRE
M A Y 0 R
ATTEST:
�LPH u. ONGIE, CITY CLERK
PREPARED AND APPPO%T-,D BY:
- z C—O4-44-c— -;-.
ASSISTANT CITY A'Vr0f,'j,,'FY
APPRQ E3. AS TO FOP.!,, MM CORRECTNESS:
GEORGE KNOX, JR., CITY XTTORNEY
TIS I 10 F--, n
j
1
13
C1tY c.r MIA1,11. 1 ��i�ID•1
.NTER•0E-*7!C,'-: NiEt+i(.-- ?ANDUM
Richard L. Fosmoen °.
City Manager
Carl Kerp, Rector "F
Depa. ent-of ParksYO
L./
December 8, 1980
Approval of Architectural firms
and Authorization to Negotiate
Contractual Agreement.
For City Commission Meeting of
December 17, 1980.
c%J "It is recommended that the architectural firms
_ found most qualified for provision of services
in planning and design of two park community
t, buildings and two swimming pool access renova-
CID
tions be approved in ranked order, and the City
_ Manager and/or his representative be authorized
Lu to enter into negotiations with said firms in
o their respective ranked order."
E3 c
03
On Monday, December 8, 1980, an approved Architectural Selection Committee
met to select a design firm to work on projects financed through the Urban
Park and Recreation Recovery Program grant (UPARR.)
The work is to consist of design and construction of park community buildings
at Curtis and West End Parks and swimming pool access renovations at Nest
End Park and Shenandoah Park. Primary design objectives for the buildings
are that they be aesthetically pleasing in harmony with their surrounding
communities, functionally suited to requirements of City operation, flexible
for change or expansion later on, contain energy efficient mechanical and
electrical systems, he inexpensive and easy to maintain, and be constructed
within approved budget and time constraints. Swimming pool renovations
include modification of existing restrooins to provide handicapped accommo-
dations, installation of handicapped ramps in the pools and more energy
efficient equipment to improve water duality.
The architectural firms found most qualified (see attached) to provide
professional service:; in the above regard are, in ranked order: (1.)
Carr Smith and hs:ociate: (2) Stuttler Stagg and Associates; (?) I-allace,
Roberts and Todd. tIith the City Conunission's approval of these names and
authorization, the City Manager and/or his representative will. enter into
negotiation with said firms in order of their rank.
CK/TL.M/cg
DO(
FOLLOW)y
05
i
upon i.nteT-view and TOTALS SHEET;
consul'Lant presentations
to Selection '�RCI]ITECTURAL/ENGIIIEI:P•,Ti,G F'IR"1 - FINAL SEL•FCTION
Committee
• APPLICANT'S i.'Ui•IP,ER
I'11:;1
CRITERIA
RATING
1
2
3
%,
5
6
1
l:L!Lhod of approach:
60(240)'211)
(214)
(218)
(196)
(191)
(201)
a: Orr�nization
15
staff
10
C. C,i or t, capabilities
10
C3. ;:ctivi scheliules
10
e. I rocr(,s and >T,ctIIods
15
2
I'1-(2Vi0l1S e::rience
20 (80)
!
1 (69
(F8)
(6 7 )�
I
(0R)
(62)
(62)
3
Cai,a'..i11ty to eet City's requirements
10 (40)
(37)
(33}
(35)
(31)
(32)
(34)
Y
1..;L'tive action plan Yes/too
yes)
(yes)
(yes)
(yes)
(yes)
(yes)
t,, _........,ion of fees
j
h
Ir;esti0
10 (40)
(40)
(40)
(2R)
(36)
(3?1)
(29)
(3l�)
(36)
(333)
TOT;�L
100(400)
356)!(355),(3,I8)
'•iol ri s Kaufmann
?gin ire rCrouch
CoruTittec 1;c;,bers (4) rerarc?o Salman Date 12/8/80 Sheet 1 of 1
* Applicant's 'Number:
I-ORM D I Farr ! ;ni th and ;jssoci ates, Inc.
St-otler Staml f Associato's
3 h;a l l ac e, Roberts anal Food
4 Otero -'"a teu . s Lef `. an,1 Alexander
an(! :1�,c;nClateJ, P.A.
"� �:I ea9,°,np71r,�7s.n I?�Q?a:v�lmr fang"!aPR �I'P�''"��U}Ur�AR�p!ill ,!'I'RJ4ulug111"Ilu Im!P'I�'i°'�u4 'PINI'IE19 P ° !E WIWH4 RI4 �I !Hk' I R '! I
k
I
Richard L. rosmoen
City Manauer
Carl Kern, Director
Dep.Xrtment of Parks o,
- - r--------- -y-=—
-'ITY
v
�• December 8, 1980
Tabulations and Findings of
Architectural Selection
Committee; i'PARR Grants Project
Resolution approving most qualified
firms for City Commission Meeting
of December 1.7, 1950
In accordance with Sub -section (5) (g) of Section 16-17 of the
City Code, I am trans:rittinq tabulations and findings of the
Architectural Selection Committee in evaluation of firms
interested in providi.na professional services for design and
construction of two 1-ark romr".unity buildings and two swlmminq
pool access renovations.
The Architectural Selection Committee met on December 8, 1960,
to make final selection of firms found to be most qualified.
They are (in ranked order) :
(1) Carr Smith and Associates, Inc.
(2) Stottler Sta��q and Associates
(3) Wallace, F.ol.i-•rts and Todd
A resolution seeking City Cormis:;i.on approval for these three
names and authori:,atinn for the. city :tanager and/or his
representative to nr<;r;tiate an ar,rremrnt with them in order
of rank, has Loo-n :-tll.rdtteci un(lor cover for the
Commission �;eetinq of Urcernher 17, l9r?0.
This project is bein(; funded under all i'rt,.11i Park ;and P.ecreation
Recover; Prorarram C rrjnt invnlvin, c•�::,muni ty huilrlin,i:, at Curtis
and West F_nd Park_, and swimminri pools at ,pest End and Shenandoah
Parks.
CK/TLi•1/vb
Enclosure
it UDP
VGCL.'t.IL ..
FU'-"vL'0uv1,
R. G. Ongie
City Clerk
IL iit.il-�
Carl Kern, Director
Department of Parks
CITY OF MIAMI. FLORIDA
INTER-CFFICE MEMORANDUM
A r F December 2, 1980 "`.E
Tabulations and Findings of
Architectural Selection
Committee; UPAPR Grants Project.
REFERENCES Resolution approving most qualified
firms for City Commission Meeting
ENCLo9URVS of December 17, 1980.
In accordance with Sub -section (5) (g) of Section 16-17 of the
City Code, I am transmitting tabulations and findings of the
Architectural Selection Committee in evaluation of firms
interested in providing professional services for design and
construction of two park community buildings and two swimming
pool access renovations.
This project is being funded under an Urban Park and Recreation
Recovery Program Grant involving community buildings at Curtis
and West End Parks and swimming pools at West End and Shenandoah
Parks.
Cis/TLM/cg
Enclosure
cc; Mr. R. Fosmoen -'*-W'_:+_. ;.o.�r�
City Manager __._
CIVE
FOLLOW
MAU911
CI
r ,, I ev., a n
consultant presentations TOTALS SHEET
to Selection ARCHITECTURAL/ENGINEERING FIRM -_FI.N_A1_, SELECTIC,-I.-
Committee
CRITERIA .1 2 3
1-:L!thuJ of approach: 60(240) (211) (2141Y (218) 1-, C,, (191) (201 1
Orranization 15
L. 1'10?essional staff 10
C. S""i i or-t capabilities 10
d. 7.ctivitiOs and schojules 10
C, Procedures and iiiet1jods 15
2 1,_-uv_ious experience 20 (SO)-, (68) (6P) (67)1 ('R) (62 (r• 2)
3 C31'aLilitY to meet City's requirements 10 (40)1(37) (35) (32)
action plan- Yes/No
f7
5 1,iiscuSslon of fees
CL
6 Ins 0 S tigation 1.0 (4 0) 0)
TOTAL 100(400) 356),(35 5) -1
1-lorl is Kaufmann
Ia For Qn
n(" r ev: Nolicil
Committee flembers (4) Gerardo Salman Date 12/8/80 Sheet 1 of I
Applicant's, r:
F OW-1 D 1 Carr STlitll any, As.,oc-iates, Inc.
2 Stotlu Sticic, & I
3 Ila It 1 all , Poher i- �; Z-A n(, TOO(I
4 Otorr)-,atc,u, T,(,ff-
5
IMP
I
Based upon interview and
consultant presentations
to Selection Committee
FEnSTBTETiDESIGN - FINAL SELECTION
U
APPLICANT'S t:UMBER
ITEM CRITERIA
RATING
,1
2
3
4
5
6
1 Method of approach:
60
15
SS
a* Organization
S
UC
Tj
b. Professional staff
10
S n
j c. Support capabilities
10
d. Activities and schedules
10
e. Procedures and methods
15
2 Previous experience
20
to
3 Capability to meet City's requirements
10
4 Affirmative action plan Yes/No
\
5 Discussion of fees
10
63nvestigation
10
�,�
TOTAL
)' " IO
(i
Committee Member ff) X r. C./Vi Any Date lv a 0 Sheet_ Of
(December 8, 1980)
FORM D
�M
A,^
III 'o T i ntc 1 is and
consultant T-r(,scntat ions e I-T-Ti.97IBT=i-Y--iriiEr-DESIGII FIUAL SELECTION
to Selection (-=,.mittee
D T T
I21�':'Ii:C
60
{ i
-
�-:Uthc)Li Of approach:
anizatior.
15
Professional staff
10
C. capalAlities
10
d. ;l%.ctiviti,,2-j and schedules
10
C. Proce-,-'ures and iaethods
15
2
11rc,jious exj)orience
20
3
Carahilily to CJ ty's requirements
10
4
Af- 1- 1 t i v e action plan Yes/Nlo
5
6
Discussion of fees
Investigation
TOTAL
C!
CL
CL
0
LL.
Committee Member Date Sheet of
F 0 RM D (December 8, 1980)
Based upon interview and
consultant presentations FERS1ST1'rTDESIGN - FINAL SELECTION
to Selection Committee
APPLICANT'S V14klBER
ITEM'
CRITL•RIA
RATING
1
2
3
4
5
6
1
method of approach:.
a. Organization
b. Professional staff
C. Support capabilities
d. Activities and schedules
e. Procedures and methods
60
15
10
10
10
15
/3
i2
9
�
¢Q
9
•
tZ
1r
2
f
Previous experience
20
114
3
Capability to meet City's requirements
10
9
9
A
9
Affirmative action plan Yes/No
1
j
f
5
Discussion of fees
6
Investigation
lb
l?fl
8
tQ
S
to
TOTAL
Y $' its, TO i 7 'IF
Committee Member�,�J/J,PE� ��nIZZ4l Date lop 27,z 8D Sheet of
(December 8, 1980)
FOR"1 D
L
k
—� LL-
1 f�
Based upon interview and
consultant presentations
to Selection Committee
FEASIBTL'T3z ti+n DESIGN - FINAL SELECTION
0
APPLICANT'S NUMBER
ITE'11
CRITERIA
RATING
.1
2
3
4
5
6
1
Method of approach:.
60
ep
e(S
so
is
50
s
a: Organization
15
b. Professional staff
10
C. Support capabilities
10
d. Activities and schedules
10
e. Procedures and methods
15
2
r
Previous experience
20
i
3
Capability to meet City's requirements
10
to
4
Affirmative action plan Yes/No
y
v
5
Discussion of fees
I
6
Investigation
err
r o
to
!a
g
tQi
g�
10
TOTAL
��
0 c 0
0-5 d
O LL-
Q
Committee Member9mg/s L L% l�it%ra/ Date OCI'a eW 27, /�% Sheet_ of
(December 8, 1980)
FOR!"1 D
c
COMMITTEE
1
2
3 4
5
6
Total
1
90
58
61 63
58
90
425
2
68
49
64 79
66
78
404
— 3
55
53
58 40
57
60
323
4
82
50
74 65
60
80
411
5
98
68
79 76
77
98
496
6
66
36
51 61
58
78
350
7
86
42
62 62
71
93
416
8
58
34
53 35
62
80
322
9
83
65
70 57
83
90
448
10
73
35
61 53
49
63
334
11
100
45
65 73
5S
90
431
12
98
50
78 44
79
78
427
13
84
63
71 62
63
78
421
14
68
73
66 48
76
83
414
15
95
55
81 54
58
75
418
16
70
44
65 37
53
66
335
17
81
51
77 50
77
83
419
— 18
68
45
73 56
59
78
379
19
75
74
75 53
63
63
403
20
77
77
72 61
70
70
427
21
58
23
48 32
59
58
278
— 22
65
70
68 41
68
65
377
23
58
42
63 46
66
70
345
24
70
46
62 48
61
80
367
25
61
57
61 48
53
73
358
26
75
53
69 36
63
85
381
27
65
61
63 65
61
73
393
28
40
43
64 52
82
80
361
29
85
63
70 49
60
85
412
30
63
73
62 69
52
93
412
31
68
37
59 42
67
80
353
— 32
51
28
52 39
47
56
273
S
1
FVLLV'VVIf
LLJ
L" I
=__w
0
CL
�C�
v a
�II �I� iI �dl��lI YILL,I��OIVI�I��V�GIef�= ��-��`�� - '='.— ;>� r."'��'�^�� ���� fTii'EY�i9'ef3l��ra�d�il�k��IS16141tli11'iIIIS%i6i'�m IiIB�L'�idii�Iliilil9illli �lLlVfiilSii7i11dIVYii86iid1�4N�Yi�I&4tl5eiiriWt6isIiYW�t7ulmn Wi�na�.�m i �����
rlasc," upon rc: icy: of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
hl<<'il I'1'1�;(:`I'tlr'.T�L/I•:fJ�;LI:I;I:}t1 �:C; 1'II�' - 1 �.'. ' '..., .... ., - --
? I'L:•�
1
CRITLRIA
Previous professional experience
�a. years i.n field
h. !�t.,-,," tiara `c:c,i litics
c. !iandicapped code experience
2 Orcanization and staff
a. Or<;:ni.:ational Structure
b. Frofe��ict:al �;�p�rience*
3 hi fi r:;:. tip✓e action p1 ,_in and
2 �:l' L:O Meet C:itl,'s
:�c•,ui�c:.;�nt�
y Location: (Rate once only).
a. City of :;iami: JO
t�. liaue County: 8
C. Florida: 3
UV
RATE; ; v
i— -� ---,
to
�i
I
d
15
'
to 10 10 ro
10
i ► �--I 1
11I9 1/01 / 015 1 �ItoIg
I-73
Committee Member M • Date Sheet p
1%v
L
jw
J1
R'.1 S e, (I upon Of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
CRITEMA I", T I
3
7
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
t i can f I i t i (IS
10
to
-2"o le>
C. ii'-IndicLipped cocle experience
2
C),Y:,ajjlzatlon and staff
11. Ur(,'Llnizat-jonal structure
1). Frofessional e:-:j-,c:rience*
20
19
vo
3
F,f f I t j,je action plan and
'Ice city S
10
10
4
Location: (Rate once only),
a. cit"r Of "'liami:
D'-1(](? County:
C. Florida: 3,
Committee Member A) 1 J!�2 O-F/17Date sheet f
2 a 1 psx i � .. ... ��� I V�� ��lilili�l�ll�l� �I��i Vi�iIW�1�3E��''.r aa�•...: t"'„'F sY���.�4! i iJ��j�t`���Im�UC"'1iclYC".�:�a'x'"ik'd3�uY�'�o��QiW7l�IJi9 ooiWa�iiW:��.�6i�1lulltii��i ah�i�shiiftli, l6 i.' ;tnre., um u�nlri i„.�u�
Paso(i upon reviov: of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
11EII::I;I:ItI IIG I'I P''
1TL;•I
C12I`I'EItIA
j
1
Previous professional experience
a. "'cars ill field '
c. c0cie c':;perience
1
'
?
Orcani::ation and staff
structure
b. I'roiessioi:al e:;pericnce*
3
T,i : i rt:..�tive action pl ari and
CL
t0 I:lCet ltl' S
-�.�: �, i r c•::,_i� is
y
Location: (Rate once only),
Ij
ft•
y
a. Cit1' of :•;ialid: 10
h. I:acie County: a
C. Florida: 3
'I'OThL
GO
10 10 v
✓ �-
�S f� �►� JS '� � '> >S t�' p S ��
Ip �� � � O20
i0
�0
J i ,
100 b f o 1 q 5
Nl • <AV omm ztee Member /IN� Date d S� g'6 Sheet
.r
II I I I I
40
qai 9 ni l,. 1. V R. Y v^y4 F � rs:^ : "' } d k fii"h* t c ygl:✓ml.,tR' < 4.:.. e i
... _ __.
R�ii'sm��h�l�:u'i V 11411411{ �e � Ili I I Rn MEMO"kIYYyy''yyji``J+iilIii� 6, lu,�,�'�ab {j� fsk� u�.�c5'�s ,� t{ li _, �5cv�xr'ukg �:�ritlyr3t�' �
�Iliillitl9� 4
realer'. u; on re. ie:: of Consultants'
Letters of Interest .
I'II'.'1 - I::i"."I�.I. Si:i I'�"ii� •: .. .
L CIS
..ems
p
U.
I'I'Ll"
C1.I i ERIh
Z
i
FL
1
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
10
i o
I D
� �
� �
J
# (fl
1 0
�
(�
t f ��-
J. Z''t'2 -'.: l oll It(-- t1 Co
2(1
�
c. :ianclicapped cc)Oe experience
15
1
2
Orc;anization and staff
`
a. cr:;ai:izational structure
b. 1'rof.essional experience*
15
20
I*J
� D
O
)
, Q
!0
�
%
`�
to
Z
� to
5
) p
1
) O
f
1
action plan and
to meet City's
10
_
j
y
Location: (Rate once only).
a. City of miami: 10
b. County:
C�
f
Dade
C. Florida:
TG'iI:L
100
Committee Member ,V( Ff � � �ly Date �i� ��� ZS� Sheet 3 ri£
t4l
St$�'-�!t �_ � .'t.•r •. � .�,y�..�����iSf{Il�iiYiIiIII IIuI YY is rll ideull ��li� di' IJIiJ4 M11 4���
Base(' upon review. of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
• 11F�i1J'I'!:r"1'URI�L/I:t](;Ii:I'.I'.R1 I]G F'i I?I1 - I'lI'�`L'+: SI:I,I'�"; I'.'. �''� I .... .. � i
L,I, i t .,
?1'LII
ClUTEPIA
IUATII'G
-;I V
32
1
Previous professional experience
a. Fears in field
10
10
So
h. "t,crel-Ition fzlcilities
20
10
S
C. 'Iaiic3icapped code experience
.15
2
Organization and staff
a. Organizational structure
15
5,
1) FrofeJJional experience*
20
I 0
/0
actici1 plan and
to meet City's
zC.iiU1ZC'I:;ents
10
y
Location: (Rate once only),
a. City of 1•Iial7y
1: 1 o
/D
h. Dade County: fl
C. Florida: 3
TOTAL,
100
or Committee ,Member � f�V ��� ,/i1/V Date � `��' � Sheet
UJ
AA , J � �"j i .9. N 16� 'I L"ilWaw 4�61 ICU. V, i, "M d., U I i I I I
Based upon reviev., of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
A I CC i f I 'IN -j CTI I 1� A L E r I I I I 1? I t 1 1, T I"
AA , J � �"j i .9. N 16� 'I L"ilWaw 4�61 ICU. V, i, "M d., U I i I I I
Based upon reviev., of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
A I CC i f I 'IN -j CTI I 1� A L E r I I I I 1? I t 1 1, T I"
CR ITL 1 Z I A
V-1
71
Previous P-Ofcssional experience
a Years in field 41
ill
c. -lial-iclicapped code experience
20
15
.7)
2
Orcjanization and staff
a. Crc-an; za-4 onal structure
b. !-rofeSsic:al e.---.,�erience*
is
20
3
e a c t- o -1 1 1 all and
1: o meet C i t Y ' s
r C., 4 L., z em C 11 t s
10
Location: (Rate once only),
a. Ci-L'Y of 1-liami:
b. County:
C
C. !;'lori6a:
T G "'I L
100
f
Comittee Member Date J r f
Sheet
Rased upon review of consultants'
Letters of Interest
E h1'CI17 I'I;C'I'UR:1L/I:I'GIIII ER7I.G I'll'." - T':ITT�:I, ` I r ^I'
7 7
LU Cn
APO
'I, T
TIUM
CRITERIA
RATI .G
3
4
1
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
10
--- 1 ,It i0ll f,11-- j.1 i ti
20
-2
C. iianclicapped code experience
2
Organization and staff
a. rc�,--Inizational structure
15
1). Professional experience*
20
3
act:ion plan and
to meet City's
10
4
Location: (Rate once only),
City of Miami:
b. D3,32 County:
C. Florida:
J
CT A 11
100
Committee Member Date 6 0 Sheet of
Of coil.sultants,
Letters of Interest
C R ITER 1 A
Previous Profes--ional experience
a. Years in field 01
10
/C
�7
cilities
20
C. !iall(.1-icappec" code Uvperience
is
j
2
Organization and staff
Ci. Or--ilizaticnal structure
b. i-'rofess-40""al
20
3
action J)Ian and
to mcet city is
S
10
4
Location: (Rate once only)
of 1-liami:
r.-1u0 County:
c Florida:
l';% L TO"
100
75
Committee Mcrriber e
Date Shet
j
Rased upon review of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
A PIC I I I TEC"I'lu 111,1�11/ib*r IG IN FE]z 1 r.'(;
CRITEPIA
11 TIN
2-1
2;,
1,3
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
10
L
1). 'ze(-i-eati-on facilities
20
�2
c. liandicapped code experience
15
2
Organization and staff
a. 0 r cj,- anizational structure
b Frofessional experience*
20
3
action plan and
C to meet City's
remuircmejits
10
A
Location: (Rate once only),
City a. Cil, of Miami:
1). made County:
c Florida:
TGTA L
10 0
5
Committee Member Date Sheet f Cl
,�; ,. - g,� ;. i.. ..., I�! i ! PI 4� ;'tl � ey,;.€ ,.', � e; a a»�wy"f'Zr.;� �.'�$r.. � I • a ,,,�
s `II
I?ase(i upon nevi ev. of Consult,nts'
Letters of Interest _
, �'�I'.CIiI'I'IBC'T'•l�i?��L/E[]r,It)I:ERCII(; FTI?'1 - II:I`I'T�.I, `":I,'•r'":?''; .'r".. fir;
CRI`1ERI11
7.. 0
1 Previous professional experience 4
a. years in field f 37
�_-
1-C
1) < ,If i'n f.:(-ilitie, 2 n i
C. ?ialidicapj)ed code cy::perience 1,
r �
W f
2 Orc;anization and staff
r . �
Or"janizational structure
I'rafessioi:al 20 ,-
3 :..`ir::�t.ive act 4Oil plan and
c�:I���i�� 1 I ty to meet City's
11.. r��iuire:;:ent:� 10 _
0
4 Location: (Rate once only),
a. Cit of :-liarii:
County: is ,
C. Florida:
TGTAL I0C
1
/ v 1 i
l `
Committee t•Iember Date Sheet cif
... ., - 91idl11i�7tlitn4lSfl�+�
.. 1 t a n t s'
consu
upof Interest 1'l,�`i't}I?i�L/�;tf�It;ELl?It:e; 1'IIt
Let10
ters �Ii?�J ? _
TZT;1 professional experience
l Previous- 1.0
ficicl 20 f>• �l �_
r
a• years in ICIlitais 15
IJ• q,2c I—e,, on tcoc-e experience
—
i exp e
c • tian�icappeci
z
and staff 1�
Organization 1.5 _
2 structure
20 '
Q Il " t
and
V•I Cf3 ti e action 1>1`� s 1G _
to T11Cet L1
s
rc Iuixc''c
°nce only
Location: (Rate
f city of ;Miami:
a . County
Li- c • Florida • - r �-,► i
100 t ;
� J
- Sheet..----�'"
Date
committee ticrobex
I
1 40
i
{
I+ �U 1 '. 1 �,,. }�4 , ; 'ter •, o t�!"v ,+
" Nam' �����4�'IEi�C�191oi�16�I���i�ilY111�41�IIf��lili�iidi�4ilVn�Yi911�1i9iYIWE�Li�$L'61dV6i3i:4�iV1�uiYYGtliiheYiiiYi611�Viiisiii�6iiril�Yrihiu�idumeu� �owim�
1 8�
� III
P,aseci upon revie: of Consultants' h•
Letters of Interest
AI?CIII'1'1'rptiR11L/L•'I:( IrIEE tit?(, F'.II"' - ;' . : i .:, .`'I ' ; : .. ✓
t
CItITE'RI11
� 1
Previous professional experience
a. Y c�.rJ in field
c
F,. ;� •�,�'cation f�lciIities
c. tlandicapped code experience
15
r
•
�
�
��
4
2
Orc;anization and staff
rr, c�rc;.rniZ ationai structure
b. I'rOLC2SSiOl"Ll e::hcricnce*
?0
,
3
f i lVe action jA'1;: and
c: , ,.._ � 1 . • to meet City - J
4
Location: (Rate once only).
a. Cit of 1.]iam, i;
b. Fig Ce CUL'I1ty:
I1
=
100
Committee Ilember Date Sheet r,£
`
L.LiCO
.ti
I
Based upon of Consultants' �
Letters of Interest •
r
APCII
i
CRITERIA
l�1f1G
3
.
i 0
+ 1
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field '
10
•
1). (-"ition ftlC.ilities,
�O
c..;anclicapped code experience
15
2
Orc;anization and staff
�. Cyr .ini ational structure
15
b. Frofessional experience*
20
�.
3 A fi r:;,ati Ve <lctic;n pl )n and
cai"-I1-41 i ty to inset City's
r� c111i rc. ;en is
10
4 Location: (Rate once only).
a. City of j'lianli:
ID. Davie County:
C. Florida:
2'C'TI•L
100
'Committee Member Date Sheet cif
U
O
::D
VJ
v
„....k .::. ,7 ,,.`:r.:A L,k+d abai.�i” d:.o-. y;,' I I 'i II Cori! ii: ed.wY Yq ,,� a fi 4 ! La.,...�Il4•.�3iu$seYS�uJ4ii�5slioaiol a ,.. .. �..._.__ _
�""�'�'��d�����I�i�I��iYVII�I�iIV�lml!�u61hViWIVh�IIV�iY�ill�il!kI:I�I�iVIVVI� "' ti r
P,asc.? upon •-evie•v. of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
CRI'I'I.'RI11
j
?
�
i
0
1
Previous professional experience
i
a. Yc,, rs in field
10
?r�`�
�,�
�,
-
C. E,ar:,.3ica?sped code experience
15
=
�
�
.
.�
�p
2
crcganization and staff
a. Or_;,Inizational structure
15
rul:essional e:-perience*
20
3
... 1 .'h aCt�Uil (71aI1 and
1 i.t• to meet City's
r-
-
r r (,:nen ts
10
r
y
Locution: (Pate once only),
a. City of
b. Eats County:
C. Florica:
a
41
x
V" I II'
Q i
Committee Member ��`�� �'� Date �'��.�: SO Sheet of `'/
LL-1
14,11IIIIIIIII'I Iqla; Ilia
upon re%7i(-%--, of consultants'
Letters of Interest IJ(-, 171 pill
•
A T
CRITERIA
I I'A III I I., G
1
t 2
13
Previous professional experience
a Years in field
1
-0
0
/
1). %-cy"'ation flcilities
20
C. !iandicapped code experience
15
Orcaiiization and staff
/0
3- c),.-canizational structure
1). ial e.,--perience*
15
20
3
r:: IL 0 action plan and
C:,-!*,�11�i1i'Lv to nicet City
7 /
r (2 e I I ts
10
4
Location: (Rate once only).
a. City of miami:
h. e County:
L12
C. I., loricia:
T CT III,
10 0
4
Sheet Cormnittee Member Date
11 1 1 1 im I
i�i'6��g+ �ts�.. ,x � ���'�� � ��i��i"I VI �i�i�9d��i���lil:ic�lii�l�IY IIIL�iV�{�Iii IYII��il�llk i��illVil'I�'ill aunl�Ildmmolinllt9lBYVuOi�Wru �J:�NW1
-a Se" VT`On :"C`; 1 C':: of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
:1:C11I'I'I:C'I UIPIA T,/1:N(-,I I.I:I:'t? f i:(-, FT 1'," - I ... . . 7, . .....
?TL;I
C!'I` E'RI11
1
Previous professional experience
—
CI . Years in field
10
atio:: L.iciliti _
?',
coy?e e-perience
1
2
Cr ani:.ation and staff
structure
15
..DI e:,o::al 2::1),:Zie11ce*
20
j
✓
_
;J
-
3
:.f�....,:;:i.c action I1::r. and
y
Lccatlon: (Rate once only),
a. City of
b. I;auc County:
�C)
C. Florida:
Committee Member �O /� Fl L fj �%'� f� Date `."/? � L3L) Sheet 7 c : ci
AO
r
W
(J)
III
�-
'��E��WIdIV'tliSl�iillllli.�lIliil'i�l�l'�IlllilfiIN6dilllYllFllidiw
I':ase(: upon re,, iev. of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
4
?'I'LtI
CRITi:RI11
0
1
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
10
1). (:. c : - ;311ion flici I ties
20
C. band-icappeJ co0e ex.perienee
15
2
Crc;anization and staff
:.,. Or.;:inizati.onal structure
15
b. Frofessional experience*
J
.. acticn Elan and
,Iv to meet city' s
10
4
Location: (Rate once only).
a. City of 1•:iami:
b. D,-i,]e County:
C. Florida:
'' OT I: I.
100
Committee Member �='otJ/ r9 LAmq- Date � �
mac? ! �; Sheet c - of `�
40
killill 1I111hI III I rIIIIIIII1III NE
reviev, of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
iwij j ri uru iz Aw ier.,c. I P T F T I r- T
w
1 IU-1
CRITERIA
16, P I
:
1
Previous professional experience
La Years in fielcl
10
j
b. j 0"" f �Jc7j 1i t- i 0C.
C. 11,-11 )ped code experience
2
Orcjanization and staff
-7
structure
b. Pro<�ssiorlal experience*
?0
i,f f I r::.:I tive -,ct ion 1;1 zin and
-V City'
C 1) i 1 -4 t ILO I'I'lUC't Cit S
10
Location: (Rate once only),
-I Ci of 1."i'mili:
1- (] c-, County:
100
c,
Date Street t o
Committee Member
'1011" , - Y,�l - -
lifl111I1lI �Miili I I Jii�lilliiiI1114
Based upon re%licV.' Of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
A P C I I I TEICTU P AL/ EN(',[ 1.11' - I P I I-' I I,,"it
CRITERIA
-
1
12
/3
Previous professional experience
in
Years
field a.
1). 1?-(-roat-ion fc.1cilities
10
C. !iandicapped cote experience
2
cruanization and staff
f
'7
I
U
a. cr,,:inizational structure
is
1). Professional experience*
20
3
-it--ive zic,Uion plan and
to ilicet City's
t S
10
4
Location: (Rate once orily)
a. city of :Aiami:
`6
1). Daue County:
C. Florida:
T GTA 11
i0o
s
T
j
,Committee Member
Date Sheet of
4P
>
CL
0 LL.
U)
Pase,- upon review'
- of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
11C1 I ITECTU RA L/Et 1C, I ER IN'(;
9 ( )
C I Z ITEI Z I A
RATI
—iTLA
Previous professional experience
a. Years in
10
f aci 1i t i C's
C. 11"111".111capped
C-
code experience
Orcianization and staff
3. Of 3,!IliZQticnal structure
15
Z
-7
C.-:perience*
L
f f i 1 action Ilan and
to C_ t C i S
11 t s
10
Location: (Rate once only),
a. City of Miami: JeLl
County:
C.
L
100
j
committee Date Sheet of
P
q pp99pp yyII yp IIy y�II jiII III `I J I` �II .:., ,:;,
"aof Consultants'r�
Letters of Interest
'l1IITERTNG,
c�� 1
ITE:-]
C1'%I'I'..i:IA
FATI
1
Previous pzofossional experience
'
J
r1
a. Years in field
10
v
?0
C. .landicapped co Oe c::perience
15
2
Organization and staff
.ni..ational structure
15
I'.o.'essional exi)crience*
3
action I;la:i and
i
10-
4
Location: (Rate once only),
3. CitV of :•Iiarli• IV
Ci"
County: 1�
C. Fioric:a:
iJ
�J
r
L
�
00
Committee Member Date Sheet•_ of
w ,
40
�09
LL-
m
I '• a -- c, d u )o n r e v -1 c, of C o r i u It i i t s
Letters of Interest
I j I r
7
C I' 1TE'R I A
Previous professional experience]
a. Ye,:Irs ill field
10
o
C . r.(I i C�] C?d code experience
15
2
UrL-.31lization and staff
structure
15
-C) -sion �al e.-:i erience*
3
zlcticn and
to F".Cet City' s
10
4
Lccation: (Rate once only),
C i ty of i am i cj
4
I"O(de County:
c. FloriCa:
TCT;, L
100
f
Committee Member Date Sheet , of
MAN
11. 1 1 1 11 . I
40
vp-4
........ ...... ..
Fasc,(? upon i-uview of Con.sultL�nts,
Letters of Interest
11111.: CT
Y., T
TOTAL 100
Committee Plember
Date
Sheet of
x1�NIN�AININI ININNI I��N�NiNNNN��N'®li'I+�IiNI�VIi }NNNiNiHYf�iNCn7 `fir �' -u. "r I �.� t_.1 "i. m H.+- T.�'�' c`,' i � x i° - }i4$} idlNiiikii6'iirdiHiu .uiii:u7AIWrIu;ItiN,.Jdi9 Nri Yw.rxxi pan µn a ,.......
Based upon review of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
I'I'I;C'I'UI? !'iL/EIIC;II:I:I:RII]GCP)
1'EI'1 CRI`1'ERIA IZATII:ci " 1 ! 2 3 O
F
1 Previous professional experience '
a, fears in field ' 10
b. �z c.r� rtt.ion fac,ilitics 20 _� �� l ,• �,,
2.�
C. 'iandicapped code experience 15
2 Organization and staff
L1J a. Organizational structure 15
Professional er.I.erience* 20
+; 3 I,f f i r.:,;at_ive action plan and
,Ibility to meet City's
require,. cants 10 - --- -
( 4 Location: (Rate once only),
i -
, a. City of Micud:
h. Due County: { �.
C. Florida:
7
i" Committee Member `r� �- �•I"'"' Date
Sheet of
a .
4M
G `
i��l�dl�IlA lil IIII 11III Ilo1IIII911015iiiluladi aiil ui niln �n Iiii
1
I',asec3 upon review of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
T�F2CIfI'1'I:C'F'f_)F?"�L/I P]G I'II?;? - I:'U'I'I'.L r":I,;'("II(;"
TT N
CRITERIA
RATI':G
13
1
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
10
h. Iz''c-r� ration £ac,ilitic�s
20
c. !iandicapped code experience
15
r
2
OrQanization and staff
L1. OrcTanizatl.onal structure
]-�
_
! -
h. I rofCJ51Ona1 C::perience*
20
7-
,
3
action and
cc::.al ility to meet City's
rcyuire:,,-_Iits
10
4
Location: (Rate once only),
a. City of Miani;
b. D. (3e County:
c . Florida:
Committee Member C:-'�'��IA.0 Date Sheet nE
BasC`;? upon review of ConsultLints'
-
Letters of Interest
I 'liI 'I'UI?1L/EI]�;II:I:F:It1.i(;
(•'Ti?' - T.';;
.
TTLAM CRITERIA
r
1 Previous professional experience
a, fears in field
10
c. T;ari 3icUpl�«�d cede c>::perience
15
t
Orc;anization and staff
��. (= •
�. of ;._r:i.._ tt .oral f'tructllre
c__jCD
b. i �o�essyo_:al e::h, rience*
?p
�— D ..�
3 �'.f:ir;,,ti .e acc,.�n plan MCI
�-- U
cI :,L!;,i l J t:% to meet Ci`4y 's
UL1,,.
r cl ;: i t c,: c n t s
10
---
- --
y Location: (Irate once only) •
a. Cit•;? of I:iai is t-�
1
h . I acre County:
c. Florida:
TUTAI,
Committee Mclriber-:r-_r.s".c -� . ,�..; -,.,
Date
Sheet of
a
Y
�II'Ii�IIIIIIHII(�flllillllli g�p7� i I ii '�'yigillppy� ��.. sR .;�. E., :y "fla�'. ,
iiil�llll IIII IEillfilli11�116fiGifil 9l��iE'�i�i�ia$:��191�1Ed�lglEifhlil��l''�YitlV�imdtld'lliliiitllli�'�Io9h�,.L6uiuiii9liiYal���°I�ii�eytlnHu�iu�Yirr"niamw�i�� m,������ i
i rase(? upon reviev: of Consultants'
Letters of Interest
hI?CllITEC'I UIPT�L,/EI:(;ItJI'.I,""T„C I.,T
Iwo
w
(,f
r
�0U.
r
0
r
"
f 1
Provious professional c.perience
t
J
a. Years in field 11
10
1•�
ion f cil
C. 'ia"dicapped code axperience
15
i♦� i,_, _
2
Or(-,anization and staff
I
Orr,�ni:ational structure�i-
h. I'roictisional e::h rience*
20
3
�,i i i r r,�t:i .'e action pla:l and
to Illeet LItV' S
4
Lo,:aticn: (Rate once only),
-1. City of N'i.ami:
County:
TCT tL 100
Committee Member I
Date -rrT- .. Sheet _ of
3�tlgi�.liiidlgIYlliw��l�,���� 6'i� tl��s��� I{�i�lLrilr+IIIII1I1lIiiIIIIIIVIIi VBYII II cYl idllliVIY�Iliiid.liV IlVisc IH1 s if 1 IIAIIIII 11,1111; I'll III I I A11111!
wi
I .
Lased upon review of Consultants' �
I..etters of Interest 1
1' J
1IU-1
C11I` 11-1'PI11
I ATII!(I
1
2
0
1
Previous professional experience
a. Years in field
10
2 (1
—
l0
C. !iandicapped co_le experience
15
2
organization and staff
a. Or- ,ani. atioinal structure
1"5
),+'
I'D
b. 1'rofel-sional experience*
20
l.',=
3
:,,f fir.,:_;ti re action L)laci and
c1-.;,1_11,i1it, to meet City's
rc �uirc:lcnts
10
4
Location: (hate once only),
a. City of Ni.ami:
b. D) I(le County:
C. Florida:
C)
D
TOTi,L
100
I
Committee Member Date � Sheet � �f
— r
Y.
G '
Own�
_ I 1 I I L'