HomeMy WebLinkAboutM-82-0287OF MIAMI. i=LORIOA
:NTER•OFFICE 'AE;MO�RANOU`.t ��� �•;� 1
J
Howard V. Gary -°tF March 31, 1982 V!UE
City Manager
Convention Center Bonds
Carlos Garcia I r
Finance Director
The City's financial advisor, James J. Lowrey, has teleponed the following
information regarding the value of the $60,000,000 Convention Center and
Parking Garage Revenue Bonds sold by the City of Miami in 1980:
The market value of these bonds is currently estimated
to be $43,200,000, due to the increase in interest rates
since the time when the bonds were sold.
If the bonds were to be sold under the present market
conditions, the interest cost would be approximately
$222,000,000. Actual interest cost to the City on the
1980 bonds is approximately $136,000,000, or $86,000,000
less than current market.
A letter containing this information is being express mailed from New York.
CG/avp
ww 8 2 - 2 8 7
A
r)
i'
F.
aMArtii all 1992
Mr. Carlos Frei*
Director of zinancg'
The City of Miami, Florida
350o P4D American DT ive
Miami, Florida 331
Dear Carlos:
wL- tave reviewed, as p4r your Tequest, the current markct value
of any outslandlntt L•3YV of Mimi, Florida C•on cntion C-EnItr and
park ine i.orAgr- These bonds w:rz i�sared bs !MIA
land thus tarry a AAA rating from. Standard &. poar's. The term
bonds of Soli (740,% O tt;c loia.i issue) which carry S.Z� ccu-ons
arc cartentiy v4ilued a: apprr i tel;c $72.00 pet Sla'3.%U
principal-amouai:--Tbis eyuAxes to s yield to matutity 4f
approximately 12.25%.
IA th*uid be un4erstoad that these rates are sabicet Lo
sipifieant fluctuation and that iley ire based on limited
secondary market dc;ivtty Sn these securities. This is t;te pT:ee
yaq might pal+ for x $2,000,000 black o• bonds. The pri" xoald
Change tar a substantially larger block of bonds, assOming thty
were available.
if the City •nre to issue $6t ,W,014 at bonds today to timance a
similar prajeri in tooay'la m&iket with similar credit ptovislorts
including MBU 1094r*r1ce, we would ;stimate the COOV*11tt
interest Bost at approximtely 13.05%. At thest tstes. total
Interest palible over the lite of the bonds would be
ippsasl tt:y based or. a te7aymcut se,%t4ult sLmilar
to tine etis4 g one, This to�ares to egprozi�ZCi' ;
in inters payable Over the life of the outstanding bonds.
E�02-27
The 13.0t-% rate for new bonds is hiethtt than the eurrttt yield 4n
the ostst&-nding bonds due to the d4i %tonal yield required to
issue $69,000,000 35 year bonds in today's ft srket envit�e tct,
sphere croapared with a pwrchs,�c of a much Mallet block of
autst�ncltng diseountcct sveurities.
t
It the City w re to eon-: ides ref inaneing tho esis i«� �rtklVCt i
s+E;vrral paints should bie noted:
It would not be neoesasry to issue $Sb million bonds. A
signi i i cacttly lower pr ineiphl _ ► —ant of bonds w*uZd be
sufficient to refinance t:;e outstfindirg bonds.
jb) A lower principal ttnw-jurit of bards would Te4uLC aggreg*te
interest payable over the titc at the P-ew bands. (rt:t
ir: interest mentioned &boor would be
rcdaecd ).
Any acceleration in the rtttr-.g:rA schedule would also
significantly red«�!e aggrtgake interest paynal=:.
if we spat, tie furtivet >,Esistanee in this matter, please 60 not
hes i ta; s to Call.
3 t�F;�ly yours,
M. Traudt
Exeeutsy ViCe PreoicScIIt
82-IV
''87
41
CITY OF MIAMI. FLORIDA
INTEROFFICE MEMORANDUM
TO Mr. Howard Gary GATE - March 23, 1982 FILE
City manager
James L. Knight International Center
April 1, 1982 agenda
�F.,•: Maurice A. Ferre
Mayor
J
Please bring up for discussion on April 1 the matter of the James L. Knight
International Center.
I would like to have an appraisal made of the value of the property in 1982
upon completion.
I would also like a letter from our financial advisors, James J. Lowrey, as
to their estimation of the value of our bond issue in today's market.
The purpose of these two requests is so that as we enter negotiations, the
Commission and the community are aware of the present value of the property
and of the bond issue.
MAF . anus
c;
rV ...
C�
82-ti87
7
1-allxxrwa
March 18, 1982
Mr. Daniel P. S.
Paul & Thomson
Suite 1300, 100
Miami, Florida
Dear Dan:
Paul
S. Biscayne Boulevard
33131
I appreciate very much the time that you spent with me
yesterday to further discuss our Lease with the City and
the relationship between the parties. I highly applaud
and commend you for the most generous amount of time that
you spend with "our fair City". You provide a genuine
service to its citizens. -
Attached is a table that lists the contractual payments of
the Lease Agreement with the City which recites that upon
opening we will have paid or be obligated to pay to the
City the sum of $4,100,000.00, and pursuant to our
projections of income, the total payments during the
intitial term of the Lease aggregate $167,872,000.00. Of
course, the ultimate payments under the Lease will be many
times the above number based upon renewal if executed. If
you take the above income stream and discount it at a 9%
internal rate return (present value), the value of these
payments in today's dollars is $25,353,000. As we discussed,
I could purchase a site for a hotel considerably cheaper
than the above, and as you appropriately pointed out, that
site would not have a convention center attached with it.
However, the fact that we were willing to risk dollars at
an uncertain time to build the hotel made the convention
center possible, because without the hotel revenue stream,
the City could nc; have issued bonds with which to build
the facility.
As a result of the above payments and the income stream
that flows to the City, the City will not only recoup
their actual investment, but the Convention Center will be
totally paid for by the revenues derived from the Center
and the Hotel.
Additionally, we are paying full real estate taxes which,
if escalated at 8% per annum for inflation, will average
approximately $700,000.00 per year over the next ten years,
and over the initial lease term will total approximately
$178,566,000.00 (the City thanks you for this!).
14of yY.,� 9.. �.' ✓f!�1!5°...� d°- P . ,t~1�.�. ��"�`� 7 . 140.0 PSP•PBs�
82-2'87
i]
Dan, if you have any questions, or would like to discuss
any matters concerning our relationship with the City,
please do not hesitate to call me at any time either in
Atlanta or Miami or at home. This project is important
for me, for you, and for the entire community.
Thanks for your very sincere interest and concern.
Sincerely,
EW
Earl S. Worsham
Chairman
ESW/cfw
cc: Mayor Ferre
Martin Fine, Esq.
82-287
LEwsE PA't
S
HYATT
REGE40
44Mt
RASE
RENT
YEAR
------
RENT
------
FACTOR
------
AMOUNT
------
4200
1982
218
1593
923
M4
1163
1985
1468
1936
1500
1.00
1500
1987
1500
1.09
1620
ties
1500
1.16
1740
1989
1500
1.24
1860
1990
1500
1.32
19EO
1991
1500
1.40
2100
1992
15,10
1.48
2220
1993
150
1.56
2340
1994
1500
1.64
2460
1995
1500
1.72
2580,
1196
1500
I.SO
2700
1497
1500
1.98
2820
li98
1500
1.96
2940
1999
1500
2.(14
3060
2000
1500
2.12
3180
2001
1500
2.20
3300
2002
1500
2.28
3420
2003
1500
2.36
3540
2004
1500
2.44
3660
2005
1500
2.52
3780
20_)6
1500
2.60
POO
2001,
1500
2.08
40:;
1008
I5U0
2.76
4146
2i,09
1500
2.54
4 2 E 0
IL
lE!U
2,92
4'80
2011
15C..0
3.00
44
20
1504
3.(6
4626
2013
ISO6
3.16
4740
2014
150U
3.,4
486v
205
150
3,32
4980
1016
1500
3.40
5100
2017
1500
3.48
5220
20:8
1�00
3.56
2019
1550
3.64
5460
2020
150
3.72
5580
2021
1500
3.30
5700
A.A.
1500
3.88
5820
2023
1500
3.96
5944
2024
1500
4.04
6060
2025
1500
4.12
6I80
2026
I.S
4.20
6300
TOTAL 167872
DISCOUNT RATF .09
NET FRESENT VALUE 25353
It
N-287
TAX PAYMENTS
HYATT REnENCY MIAMI
YEAR
------ __
TAXES
1982
462
1983
499
1984
539
1985
582
1986
629
1987
679
1988
733
1999
792
1990
8C05
1991
924
1492
997
1993
1.77
1994
116>
1995
1256
19%
1357
1997
1466
" 1998
1583
1999
1709
2000
1846
2001
1994
2002
2153
2003
2326
2004
2512
2005
2713
2006
2;30
2007
3164
i0(18
3;17
2009
3690
2010
3966
2011
4 305
2012
4649
241:
SJ2i
�J15
.s56
2016
6325
2017
E33:
2019
7377
2019
7467
6. &
86(t5
2021
9243
2022
10037
2023
10640
2024
11707
2025
12643
2026
13655
TOTAL 178566
v 82 - 2 8'7