HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem #02 - Discussion ItemHonorable Mayor and Members
of the City Commission
r'
Howard V. Gary
City Manager
March 26, 1982 1,LE
Annual Evaluation -
City Manager
City Commission Agenda -
April 1, 1982
On April 1, 1982 the City Commission will undertake an evalua-
tion of the City Manager for the year ending April, 1982.
This memorandum was prepared for the purpose of providing the
members of the City Commission with a highlighted synopsis of
the City's accomplishments. Candidly, I must stress City ac-
complishments rather than the achievements of an individual
member of the City.
Certainly, the items that appear in this memorandum are the re-
sult of many hours of hard work and difficult deliberations by
all those involved including the City Commission, City Attorney,
and the City Administration.
As the appointed Chief Administrative Officer of the City of
Iliami my role in the growth and development of the City of Miami
is to execute policies established by the City Commission in its
articulations of the will of the City's residents. However, were
it not for the cooperation from all those involved, the following
could not have been accomplished.
CABLE TELEVISION LICENSE
During the first six months of my serving as City Manager, the
City Commission selected two potential licensees to provide
cable television service to the residents of the City of Miami.
I was then charged with the responsibility of negotiating the
best possible agreement for the provision of such services and
given a 45-day time frame for accomplishing such. That mission
was achieved and the highlights of our license requirements are
outlined below.
Sstem Characteristics
The City of Miami is assured of having a state of the art cable
television system which will cost at a minimum $45 million dol-
lars. We will have a capacity of 104 channels plus a dedicated
two-way institutional network. Universal service affording all
City residents basic cable services is required.
r -2-
Public Access
In the City Commission's opinion public access (the public's
accessibility to provide localized broadcasting of a community
nature) was very important and, since this administration con-
curred wholeheartedly with that policy, the City's cable system
will provide a minimum of 20 channels for public broadcast par-
ticipation with a requirement that the licenseesspend an initial
amount of $2 million dollars for equipment and facilities includ-
ing:
1. Establishing, equipping, and maintaining three
access studios and one field production unit;
2. The hiring of competent and adequate staff; and
3. The development and implementation of viable and
effective training programs.
Revenue
The license is expected to generate revenue of some $25.5 million
during its term. Additionally, the Miami Community Access
Corporation (MCAC) will be receiving a $200,000 cash contribu-
tion within thirty days of its formation to serve as working capi-
tal and will also, beginning in the third year of the license,
receive for its annual operating budget $1 million dollars from
the licensees.
Overall, the City's license is regarded nationally as the most
stringent ever awarded in the history of cable television. The
license ordinance contains certain mechanisms to assure timely
completion of the system and to assure smooth operation and the
continuous provision of service to our residents. These assurance
provisions include a $3 million dollar construction performance
and payment bond in addition to an established procedure for revo-
cation of the license in the event the licensees do not fulfill
their requirements. Upon completion of construction a $2 million
security fund (already held by the City) will be used to insure
the faithful performance by the licensees of all provisions of
the license.
POLICE RECRUITMENT AND TESTING
During the past year, the City has had an extraordinary achieve-
ment in recruitment and employment of new Police Officers.
For the year ending September 30, 1981, 330 new Police Officers
were hired. This was more than double the hiring in any prior
year. 82.4% of all recruits were minorities and women. These
included 27% Black men and women and 52.4% Latin men and women.
,82-285.1
r -3- ON
During the fiscal year beginning October 1, 1981, the City has
already hired 232 new Police Officers. These figures include
21 recruits scheduled for April 12. In addition, the Police
Department is anticipating hiring 21 more recruits in June and
42 in September. This will make an estimated total of 295
Police Officers in the current fiscal year. Employment totals
thus far include 28.5% Black men and women and 43.9% Latin men
and women.
The budget for the current fiscal year includes an increase in
sworn personnel from 814 positions to 1,000. This is a total
increase of 186 positions. Projections indicate that the
September recruit class will result in a total of 1,038 uni-
formed personnel. This will temporarily produce 38 positions
over budget, in order to provide for attrition in the early
part of the next fiscal year. It is anticipated that all hir-
ing and affirmative action objectives will be met.
For the first time since the Cohen Consent Decree was signed in
1973, the City of Miami has begun to do its own testing for
police recruits and police promotions. This testing was pre-
viously done by the University of Chicago under contract. The
City has been doing recruit testing for the past year. The
promotional exam for Police Sergeant was prepared and adminis-
tered by the City in February 1982. Promotional exams for Police
Lieutenant and Police Captain are currently in process. The
exams will be prepared and administered in August, 1982.
The promotional goal for minorities and women in the Police
Department is 53% for this year. It is anticipated that the
goal will be achieved as a result of promotions from the new
Civil Service register for Police Sergeant.
FUND BALANCE
A critical and challenging issue facing municipalities across the
nation during this period of economic constraint and diminishing
federal support is the maintenance of adequate cash surplus funds -
referred to as fund balance. Fund balance is a critical ingredient
in the assessment of the City's financial health by the New York
Bond Rating Agencies. They consider it significant because it re-
presents a guarantee in that there will be dollars available to
operate the government. The rating agencies evaluating the credit
worthiness of the jurisdiction and maintaining an adequate fund
balance gives them assurance that the government who will be re-
sponsible to pay debt service will continue to operate.
The fund balance for Fiscal Year 1981 is an estimated $6.5 million.
This fund balance was developed as a result of very definite actions
and reflects in a positive way on the City of Miami. Specifically,
a portion was generated because expenditures were controlled and
,-82-285.1
r
O
-a-
savings were realized. If we are able to continue to maintain
in future years a fund balance of this same proportion, it will
continue to reflect well on the City CcmnLssion and the adminis-
tration of City affairs.
MINORITY VENDOR PROCUREMENT PROGRAM
The City Commission adopted the Minority Vendor Procurement Pro-
gram. The program's goal is to have minority vendors partici-
pate in the City's procurement at a 20% rate, 10% for Hispanics
and 10% for Blacks.
Businesses controlled and owned by minority vendors which have
annual sales of $1,000,000 or less is the definition used for a
minority vendor.
A special task force composed of personnel from the City Manager's
Office, Finance and Computers & Communications Departments have
been formed to implement this ordinance.
Qualified Hispanic and Black vendors will be offered a preferred
opportunity to fulfill up to one -fifth of the City's purchasing
requirements, based on vendor qualifications. The City will also
size purchase orders and bid calls, when appropriate, to the capa-
cities of qualified Hispanic and Black vendors.
Currently, the task force is designing an outreach program to com-
pile an inventory of minority businesses. These businesses will
be advised on how to do business with the City and how to partici-
pate in this program. The program is geared to using businesses
located within the city limits.
BUILDING AND ZONING MANAGEMENT IA'1PROVEMENT
In an effort to reduce duplication, improve the services provided
City residents, and reduce costs, a Department of Management and
Budget Resource Allocation and Budgeting Study was executed by
the Operations Analysis Division. The extensive evaluation deter-
mined potential results from transferring the Certificate of Use
Program from the Building and Zoning Department to the Fire Depart-
ment.
The program concentrated on safety to life consideration and eva-
luated personnel currently in the Building and Zoning Department
necessary to reestablish the office in the Fire Prevention Bureau
That transfer was accomplished with three Code Compliance Inspector
I's and one Typist Clerk I.
082-285.1
Li
-5-
P
Resources of the Fire Department, primarily personnel and the exist-
ing Fire Inspection Program, were used to supplement previously
budgeted positions. A total of five budgeted positions were elimi-
nated and the net result was a savings of $136,000.
By applying -the additional inspection personnel to this revenue pro-
ducing program, the City will ultimately receive increased revenue
from inspection fees. Of significance is that businesses without
Certificate of Use permits are being located and placed into the
system.
Additionally, a number of Neighborhood Improvement Programs have
been identified including emphasis on zoning inspection and en-
forcement by increasing Zoning Inspector positions, establishing
the Neighborhood Volunteer Inspector Program and conducting code
violation blitz to systematically identify on a geographic basis
those violations requiring action by the City of Miami.
IMPROVEMENTS IN THE FINANCE DEPARTMENT
Within the last five years, the City's operating budget has in-
creased from $116.6 million to $161.6 million. The Capital budget
for FY-82 amounts to $161.4 million. The number of Federal and
State grants has reached an all time high.
Maintaining good, acceptable fiscal records in accordance with
national standards requires skilled professional personnel.
The Booz, Allen & Hamilton firm recommended a major reorganiza-
tion of the Department of Finance. A part of that recommenda-
tion stresses the need to continue to upgrade the professional
staff. This is being accomplished.
The last five accountants
C.P.A. certification; two
all have experience which
very encouraging that we
this caliber and be able
and ability.
hired had college degrees; two have
have worked on a Masters level, and
will serve the City well. It is
were able to attract candidates of
to utilize their skills, experience
Quality personnel in this very critical area will help us to
keep the City Commission and Manager informed as to the City's
financial condition.
Some of the Finance Department operations had been for years
affected by the bad condition of its physical location. In
particular, the Accounting Division has been located in the
area where lighting and air conditioning, as well as noise
control, have been grossly inadequate to the extent that em-
ployees have occasionally requested transfers to other City
Operations due to the uncomfortable conditions.
W82-285.1
P
ors
me
During the current fiscal year the City Comm--nission has approved
remodeling of the Accounting area. The much needed improvements
in the working environment for the fifty persons stationed in these
offices will result in additional productivity and higher morale.
Work is currently underway.
In addition, the Purchasing Division is being transferred to the
south end of the Municipal Justice Building. This move will con-
solidate the Division operations, including Central Stores. It
will also provide additional space for records and materials
storage.
Future operations of the Finance Department will benefit by these
two major changes.
The City Commission created the Audit Advisory Committee a five
member committee including representatives from the public, City
Commission and City Administration.
That committee initially undertook the development of criteria
to be used in recommending an external auditor for the City Com-
mission. As a result of those efforts, the City Commission awar-
ded the auditing contract to Coopers & Lybrand.
That contract was negotiated by the administration and represents
the first time the City of Miami has had a performance based
contract for auditing services.
The City will be receiving quarterly as well as annual reports
as to the financial condition of the City. The increased fre-
quency of reports will provide an essential tool of the admini-
stration for adequately monitoring financial management effort.
AFFORDABLE RENTAL HOUSING DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM
To increase the supply of privately owned rental housing within
the economic means of low and moderate income families, the
Administration is implementing the Affordable Rental Housing
Development Program approved by the City Commission in November
of 1981. The Program's production goal is 1,000 dwelling units.
Developer selection is now underway as are the various legal ac-
tions required to secure project financing.
Housing production is expected to commence in the late summer of
1983.
Multi -family
elements in
tegy.
MULTI -FAMILY REHABILITATION
Housing Rehabilitation is becoming one of the key
the City's Community wide housing improvement stra-
82-285.1
0
ON
-7-
Last year, the City provided some $605,000 in low interest
loans to owners of substandard apartment buildings in the
Overtown Neighborhood resulting in the rehabilitation of
six (6) structures and an increase of 91 rental dwelling
units in Overtown's Housing inventory.
$1,993.656 of Community Development Block Grants funds are being
recommended to continue the program in Overtown in 1982 and to
expand the program into the other C.D. Target Areas.
SINGLE FPi%IILY HOUSING REHABILITATION
Miami's Great Neighborhood Single Family Home Improvement
Assistance Loan Program continues to be a prime tool in the
City's Community Wide Housing Improvement Strategy for up-
grading the housing in single family neighborhoods. The
program is operating in the Buena Vista, Allapattah, Wynwood,
Coconut Grove, Manor Park and King Heights neighborhoods.
In an effort to maximize CD funding earmarked for the -pro-
gram while at the same time securing the financial participa-
tion of private lending institutions in the program, the
Administration, in October of 1981, recommended conversion of
the program from a direct City funded loan program to one which
is funded jointly by the City and Dade Savings and Loan Associa-
tion.
The new "Leveraged" loan program has been operational since
October of 1981 and the Southeast Regional Office of the
Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation has indicated its in-
terest in using Miami's Program as a model for similar pro-
grams in the Southeast.
At present, the Program is leveraging one private dollar for every
public dollar invested.
POLICE DEPARTMENT
The Police Department has made considerable progress in creating
a safe environment for our citizens, tourists and businesses.
Some of the significant accomplishments are as follows:
1. Fulfilled the expectations of the City Commission
that we employ an additional 186 Police Officers
bringing the total number of officers to 1,000.
2. Fulfilled the expectations of the Commission and
community that the Police Department hire Police
Officers that reflect the ethnic characteristic
of the community. 82.4% of all recruits were
minorities and women.
_ 3. Assisted in reducing the City's crime rate by
approximately 15%.
4. Increased our responsiveness to the community
by reduc ng thy-: rec:r,-)nse time of Po' ice off i -ers
82-285.I
a
ME
5. Increased citizen participation in law enforce-
ment by increasing the number of Crime Watch
areas and by instituting the Reserve Officer
Program and Office of Professional Compliance.
6. Identified areas of responsibility that can be
performed by civilians thereby releasing addi-
tional Police Officers for patrol functions.
7. Continually provided input to the Vice President
and Governor Bob Graham about the need to obtain
additional Federal and State resources to fight
crime.
8. In an effort to create better harmony between the
Police Department and the community, a Cultural
Awareness Program was implemented. This program
sensitizes Police Officers to the various cultures
of our community.
9. Progress has been made to implement a Marine Patrol.
10. In an effort to provide safety to the recreating pub-
lic a Beach Patrol has been instituted at Virginia
Key Beach.
BOND ISSUES
Fire Fighting Bond Issue
On July 23, 1981, the City Commission authorized placement of a
$21 million Fire and Rescue Bond issue on the November 3, 1981
Special Election ballot. Based upon the Fire Department's esti-
mate of capital needs for the next 20 years and review and modi-
fication by the City Manager, the $21 million proposal was tai-
lored to provide major expenditures for buildings, apparatus and
equipment for the next 10 years. On November 3, 1981, every pre-
cinct in the City of Miami voted in favor of this Fire and Rescue
Bond Proposal. The overall percentage of those in favor of the
Bond Proposal was 65.3% with a voter turnout of 32.8% of the re-
gistered voters.
At its completion, the 1981 Fire -Rescue Bond Program will have
provided for an expanded fire apparatus maintenance garage,
two new fire stations, a complete refurbishing of four exis-
ing fire stations, a complete new radio communications system
(800 MHZ), purchase of a graphics display printer, the replace-
ment of 11 Pumpers (7 priority), 6 Aerials (3 priority), 1 Air
Truck, 15 Advanced Life Support Rescue Units (3 priority), a
closed circuit TV system, upgrading of computer equipment, ex-
pansion of the Fire Prevention Bureau and Administrative offices,
installation of an emergency traffic light control system through-
--- -- out the City, purchase of additional Basic Life Support equipment
for selected fire apparatus, purchase of
�- $2-285.1
4
OP
M:
fitness equipment for all stations, improvement of the pump
testing facility, installation of a flammable gas training
facility, a fire tactics similator, a pump simulator, a
high pressure air -cascade system and a heavy duty ground
ladder for drilling. (Priority expenditures in the first
and second years of the 1981 Fire -Rescue Bond Program have
been designated by underlining). -
Advancements in firefighting, fire prevention and rescue
services and equipment over the past year period have in-
cluded: purchase of Life Paks & ABCOR's for the Rescue
Division, placement of four new Rescue Vehicles into opera-
tion, development of the LARC amphibious vehicle, installa-
tion of oxygen cascade systems in several fire stations,
installation of an underground fuel storage facility, in-
stallation of mobile status and printer terminals in all
fire apparatus vehicles, initiation of the Incident Report-
ing System, development of the Manning System, and the initia-
tion of construction for the new Fire -Rescue Training Center
in Coconut.
On November 6, 1981, the City's seventh fully equipped and
manned Rescue unit was placed in service at Fire Station #6,
3600 N.W. 7 Ave. Rescue #6 has already responded to 1281
emergencies since beginning operations in November.
Sale of Parking Garage Revenue Bonds
The sale of $10.4 million Revenue Bonds at a favorable interest
rate in a difficult market is very significant. It is a strong
indication that those outside the City of Miami view Miami as
being a strong City financially. Investors are willing to pro-
vide money to the City because they have confident in the city's
financial strength. The desirability of the City's credit worthi-
ness is emphasized by the fact that we sold bonds 73 points be-
low the interest rate charged for other Triple A revenue Bonds.
The City paid an interest rate which is two-thirds of one percent
lower than that paid by other revenue bonds. In terms of dollars
on the $10.4 million issue, it saved the City more than $1 million
interest expense. We should all feel encouraged by the fact that
there were six bidders and that the spread between the bidders
was very close.
The process involved in preparing a bond issue for market is com-
plex. The effort that is necessary is often underestimated. The
successful sale of a revenue bond in today's market is a major
achievement for the City and in my view reflects very positive
upon the management of the City.
0'82 .`�Q.)
CODE ENFORCEMENT BOARD
The City of Miami has created a Code Enforcement Board in ac-
cord with the provisions of recent state legislation which
allows municipalities more effective means of enforcing their
code restrictions.
With its new members appointed last month, this board is now
ready to hear violation cases presented by the Departments
of Building and Zoning, Public Works, Solid Waste, Finance
(on license citations) and Police.. This will serve as an al-
ternative to the cumbersome and time-consuming process of pro-
secution through the State Attorney's Office in the court sys-
tem for obtaining compliance on violations of which the owner
and/or tenant have been advised. It further provides that if
compliance is not obtained, a fine may be levied and a lien
placed against the property.
As a means of ensuring speedy and effective response, this Board
will give enforcement personnel of the City the incentive needed
to cause chronic violations to be brought into compliance.
AFFIRMATIVE ACTION PROGRAM
The City's Affirmative Action Program has accelerated during the
past year. The City's affirmative action efforts were initiated
as a result of law suits settled by Consent Decrees in 1973 and
1977. Effective results were not achieved until the City amended
its Civil Service Rules in 1979. Progress has been significant
since that date. The program continues to grow at an increas-
ing rate.
There has been an immense change in the composition of the City's
work force. Minorities and women, who comprise approximately
84% of the City's labor market have been seriously underrepre-
sented in the City's work force. As recently as 1973, minori-
ties and women represented only 39% of the City work force and
i
30% of the uniformed police force.
These figures have been changing rapidly. Minorities and women
now represent 61% of the total City work force and 540 of the
uniformed police force.
In the last fiscal year, 330 new Police Officers were hired.
These include more than 80% minorities and women. An antici-
pated total of 295 officers will be hired in the current fiscal
year. By September 30, 1982, minorities and women should re-
present close to 60% of the uniformed police force.
82-!?R 1-,. 1
-11-
Citywide, Blacks now comprise 293 of the work force, compared
to 19% in the labor market. Hispanic employees have increased
to 250, which is more than double their previous representation
in `_he work force. In the last two fiscal years, the hiring
rates for minorities and women in the Police and Fire Depart-
ments have exceeded 80%.
These results are achieved through continuing training pro-
grams and establishment of appropriate Administrative Policies.
The success of the Affirmative Action Program may be measured
in part by the results of the discrimination complaints. Dur-
ing the calendar year ending December 31, 1981, the City had
10 discrimination complaints filed with Equal Employment Op-
portunity Commission (EEOC) and 30 complaints filed with the
Affirmative Action staff. EEOC found no probable cause for dis-
crimination in its investigations. The 30 complaints that were
handled internally were resolved satisfactorily through formal
investigations, negotiated settlements or employee counselling.
Perhaps the most striking data on affirmative action involve
hiring and promotions under the new Civil Service Rules. Mino-
rities -and women have represented 830 of all new hires and 79%
of all promotions. These same achievements are continuing in
the current fiscal year.
In addition to new
Blacks, Latins and
in non-traditional
sional jobs.
hires, affirmative action data show that
women have begun to achieve representation
occupations, including managerial and profes-
SETTLEMENT OF PENSION
The City has reached a tentative agreement with union represen-
tatives to resolve the Gates vs. City of Miami lawsuit.
In summary, this agreement will permit the City of Miami to re-
solve a $20 million plus lawsuit the union has filed against the
City alleging improper use of ad valorem taxes that were dedi-
cated for pension purposes. The City has been in litigation in
this matter for approximately three years. The settlement is
fair and reasonable and requires concessions on both sides.
r 82-285.1
C
-12-
The above summary was developed to identify outstanding ele-
ments of City activity during the year it has been my privi-
lege to serve as City Manager. It is my feeling that the City
can be justly proud of its accomplishments and I look forward
to participating in its future growth. It is my desire to serve
all the residents of the City of Miami and the City Commission in
furthering already established policies such as:
1. Further improvements in the Commission/Admini-
stration communications process.
2. Assist in the development of Downtown, the Omni
area, Brickell Avenue and implement the Park West/
Overtown plans.
3. Promotion of Miami as a center for international
trade.
4. Timely completion of the City of Miami/University
of Miami James L. Knight Convention Center and its
becoming operational to insure the City fulfills
its contractural obligations with certain conven-
tions.
5. Enhancement of the City's financial standing to
maintain the ability to accomplish major projects
essential to the local economy.
6. Maintenance and improvements in the quality and
level of police and fire services.
7. Continued achievement of Affirmative Action goals
and objectives.
8. Continued improvements in neighborhood Codes com-
pliance.
' 82-285.1