Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutO-09791w f.. °shy x a a 42-1 00INANCE N0. ... ' -AN ORDINANCE AMENDING THE ZVNING ORDINANCE NCO, 9500, THE ZONING ORDINANCE OF w'.:"R T11E CITY OF MIAMI r FLORIDA, BY CHANGING THE 20NING CLASSIFICATION OF LOTS 6 , 7 , 8 AN.0 30 IEES THE EAST 5' bF LOT lot BLOCK 2 , POINT, .W ( -93) OF THE PUBLIC RECORDS OF DADE_ 66UNTY; FLORIDA FROM RG-3/' GENERAL ; -e RESIDENTIAL TO RO-3/6 RESIDENTIAL OFFICE; BY MAKING ALL THE NECESSARY CHANGES ON PAGE NO. >1 37 - OF SAID ZONING ATLAS MADE A PART OF NO. 9�r00 BY REFERENCE AND ORDINANCE DESCRIPTION IN ARTICLE 3, SECTION 300, T'HERtbP; CONTAINING A REPEALER PROVISION AND A SEVERABILITY CLAUSE. 3 WHEREAS., the Motion of the Miami Zoning Board, at meeting of July 11, 1983, Item No. 5, following an advertised hearing, to RECOMMEND DENIAL of a change of .zoning classification, from RG-3/7 GENERAL RESIDENTIAL to SPI-5 BRICKELL - MIAMI RIVER Z. RESIDENTIAL OFFICE DISTRICT failed by a 3 to 2 vote, thereby constituting a RECOMMENDATION OF DENIAL; and WHEREAS, the City Commission, at its meeting of November 18, 1983, referred the consideration of the change of zoning classi-, fication as set forth above to the Planning Advisory Board; -and WHEREAS, the Planning Advisory Board, at its meeting of December 7, 1983, considered the change of zoning classification. set forth above and RECOMMENDED by a 4 to 0 vote approval of a change of the zoning classification of Lots 6, 7, 8 and 30.rlej�s the E 5' of Lot 301 Block 2, POINT VIEW (2-93) of the Public j? Records of Dade County, Florida, from RG-3/7 GENERAL RESIDENTIAL n to RO-3/6 RESIDENTIAL OFFICE, and RECOMMENDEDYi DENIAL of a c a 3 0 classification of Lot 4, Bloch 2, PO -IN, VIEW (27? ) .. Y of zoning the Public'Record of Dade County, Florida from RG-3/7 GENERAL to SP i 5 BRICKLLL - MIAMI RIVER, RESTDEI�TIA14_ Q�`oic �- - - and } t t �r f — �_L"�•4,�,.�:..taYJ.'1,.�i v+.: s., -. .- .. . ... .... _' _ _ ... ' . �. ---.: -_, .' ,". _ . - : . - x .. ..•k `S.sv.$� rv�-,$if ����� - _ — - - i., y Y...u.. i..., ....:. F'r VIM b4 ..,: .. - .. - `t:. r ;1 4 t A.-..�'���su +' a.M 14,k♦ Y ta ....b'':.5'<:.` �'F -u' ,•i',,-art -�1,ic c ' . . icy` 4di';? ,, .i•.` _ r lq - l 5.iaa 'as ?w Yl A� t # t �+�mtni its + at its meeting of bec��c��� ► e = f yx °off the Change of Zonfe6d the doll'sidlatatid , t , cat3 sib as set forth above to the Miami Zoning Board for another -� ry public heari.ngi -jk As the Miar�i honing hoard, at its t►eeting of �anuarh 1g 4� h &kA�` Aditional testimony but took no formal actiO 4 k t 1 and .'*4 IHIA; tha' pity commission after careful consideration of this�itter `deems it advisable and in the best interest of the � +nsirlteiare of 'the City of Miami and its inhabitants to grant this change of z ni'n§ classification as hereinafter set forth: 0 TE E�tFFOitE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF- MIAmI , FtORIDA : s: ~ -Sect ion 1 The Zoning Atlas of Ordinance No. 95001, the _ ... • r - onino ordinance of the City of Miami, Florida, is hereby amended ;.:. Rw= y the zoning classification of approximately 185 5: b ct Ang'i rig .; Southeast ` 1'�lth Terrace and approximately 200 Southeast ` 14th 5 Strut Miami, Florida, mote p described as Lots articularly 6'` p 8R`aof n 30 less the E 5' of Lot 30, Block 2, POINT VIEW ( ) ,< You w ;.., - the Public Records of- Dade County, Florida, from RG-3%7-GENSRAL =rty :._ RESIDENT.IAL..to_RO-3/6'RESIDENTIAL OFFICE. .." . It is hereby found that 'this zoning ` ciassi- Section' 2. � 6 ficatIon iai Is in conformity with the adopted Miami Comprehensive ' r= ` hborhood Plan; h µ, Ne ig - , ,_ {b) Is not contrary to the established land use pattern=. 1 not create an isolated district unrelated, to �c) Will ' adjacent and nearby districts; out of scale with the needs of the ne ighbdrhood "t i6 , not -=K;k I r : , or the Cityt xti u w� l not, materially alter the po.Vul,4.ti`9nj{i patt. ern or increase or v tax `» ; £ach es ouch as schools, utili,t # stre + +T•+,i`:.i'�tv'^t"d.3"ii_�n`I- s , ,•(. n.rsr.'_°'H •`r+[36fi.s 'a - - .}r 'fi = �{ 'a ease ar dins to changed or : bhe�g�n �iPtsi044►� nf�n+�e, i.i.vin+ Fcohd.oabn t# t rk k t Wi i t 'nit' adversely Y X neighborhood; not create off' excsssivci�► - xr - oog+�ton +�r otherwise affect public saii► . _ - s CF 4i _ yyyy1� l zt• ,::5:�;.€sr}r.'''> - - '� , M"!'2-'r y� i£ ,`e`e+ro:'�?'"r4.. '.:`� c R� t- ..,� _ _._ S tf dC 'i:_;r.-.er } .: lk.J-fieia'• - - r rn. p r s ij will no create a drainage problems .° FC_i f R Will not seriously reduce light and air to ad�aae�t t areal the (k) Will not adversely affect property values in adjacent area; _ YliY (l) Will not be a deterrent to the improvement or develop- ment of adjacent property in accord with eiting tegulationa e`i`7 y (m) Wi11 not constitute a grant of special privilege t the individual owner as contrasted with protection of public welfare; -; a part N 37 of the Zoning Atlas made p : Section 3• page o• ' tip "1dinance No.9500 by reference and description in Article 3 ,. r Section 300 of said Ordinance, is hereby amended to reflect the charges made necessary by these amendments. Section 4. All ordinances, code sections, all parts thereof in conflict. herewith are hereby repealed insofar as they , .f are in conflict. Section 5. Should any part or provision of this Ordi- Hance be declared by a court of competent jurisdiction to be °,: invalid, ' the same.-, shall not affect the validity of , the'.ordinance Y, as --a ,whole : ,= PASSED ON FIRST READING BY TITLE ONLY this 2 day of, October. , 19813. , f PASSED ON SECOND 'AND FINAL: READING BY TITLE ONLY; thin 26.__th t t - days,.. of -,ran aiy Y %3 MAURICE A. FERRE, Mayorr = ATTEST v.. s NG I E #Li RALF .;, a,_ Y Cle k ty _ :....:.-. - PREPARED AND APPROVEDaY t APPRoV�O �� • cl N R ER Ae�3stant City Attorney ty Attorneys_;GWWP, i }rr/ 199 ,t :p. :, a s} t y'''. r, v _ ^ •; �- 1 . 4�i 4Y�y3 hti;}r`r.hY-it yyS r, 2 q t AWE t' Y „��, � s y'i. ONAM Li z CITY OF MIAMI. FLORIDA x.;a. INTEA4� IFFIC9 MEMORANDUM r..,.. December 8, 1983 : y: d8ry DATE. �ILBa Howard : x 'CiX Y+' Manager r�w►t ommy Commission Agenda SUBJECT: \i • December 15+-1983: REFERENCE$: LOt.�i ': ji 6 +: ,_$ ° Bt t 3P ergio: Rodriguez . ' Rxeoutive Secretary Block 2," PdINTV .EW' Fi2�93) ENCLOSURE$: " Planning ,AdvisorY`�• Board, j. 3 members The Planning Advisory Board on a motion of 4-0, Fy-}ember' 7.;; 1983°, r�ommenzie`d =approval-' o#'' rezo�►iri'g=-`from `31`n a a`ss R the .r;E 5 + -°� f:rtl:ot`•;0n d_o►+:r f Rd'=316:'for. ;lots fi, 7 8 `'eind' °30 i = �t for lot t}: °Bloc k" 2; PO°INTVIEW 3 (2-.93) of rezoning r" F Co>mission +per. ` City . .: _..., 1 $3.,:'eonsid'eration of''rezon'ing tfiesubjeet property 'located' at roximately 2d0 ..S SE . 14 Terrace and app''_„ �f .$pproxiaately: 185 M m. General_ Residential to' SPIN 5 Briekell }, �� ;Street from RG=3/7' r;:'aie�i$nan�`` r #fiver': Residential offzi' "-Distr ct' 3 or «a ;. 7 esse + n' referred- to the Planning. Advisory Board.' Planning Advisor r..r Board', pAl er`'; ,;u<thert= r:eferra3' f m b ,tw C'6mcaission, considered this item in public meeting. +:''�; _ 3', -.3^� x c3j,,. ^� S3� 'R*-`. .;j," ,'.. .e`�,`''.'`6 { { t$•i+r2 w•. sf F i4# ase� fir' t4 - - v - - . ::e'^ ,' },�', ..4 o-� Sr. .Ap°prppriate matey%al`�satt`at�laed • ,� r'. i s,•.r t +te Yl>.-`.a. -S, k-s.,'".;-5>��. .i :°y �.� t . • p_"`•�at� � �. - : "y , -' :} ° _ a_ {. �„t� trwc ;4.r tr {' �.t ~:+i"�.a i��: 40 _ x�'W,ii�, +.5,4 � E,+ .'v .+.. < �. a ' ' '- 3 :, • .S.x'M, (' yy - +l f. �„� ,�,4"�?, a�� Z t qw� /♦ �y�M 1 MR./ �11!l/Y.}� sY; d. AA {ti. AyA� �M�!•t' ..> - ] t k.• � } '<. �e=`cam. :�:; :§•4#s -<gY"- &i•k a`.°Y _ x ,y "'`�� h � E ^ y ,� . .n.y.. _ ' � d;�y . � aass 1�+�'#" N-d �r,I' �r yY'�'�. t',•. A �.� ! '3 e �.t ',.- Y�yltF'fv.•,"x 6.'`+ _�#,,55 �j _ gv j+. •, tr, ���� i -�. .` a{, fix. � k '.i,r kt"k, ;•t /t� -' lr.,. �� '49,.#v-� i''*i,.'^t, Y�_$ $: �9�n's`'.. �.:.: ^A ' ;4-YY' �,.ri.�e 9, y,.t •2�;;�i'e 7r :'t :t:T'f< ';'r '< x _ Xk".x t'� tr z� 7•'i+x 7Y} `, a ';�5,t{R.. t�,< .•�, t�i,. �' r "e',�t rK; .����tz y.#id�r sr � � �.r, y�m"S. k-r _ s,.iw��. .. � �: F:i;'�•Ltn`s�-3�o "4o t; .4,''�?at,�'";�.Y s {:-- a."s�•° : ,..i .«;, -y..t�1'yR'y"t wy t,lk's'a�'yi�q h kr •r #*rb rtSFiV '.�`'a-"^•�!&-'�" �,=`+"�ix :;�'i• ''�s . ,nt r ;Y - y '� �' �1y,+. `•3�vilr.,,,p7�.,� ia�-+ `t > - 1(" d ; � _ »�`�,.. ,x�� - +°:-, xd,t1i� ���� ,.,fin � e e i , „' � � a 9i.`'�e-��'+y' ',3� 5 x����.d €�.'�i ��'. �• '� u'w t'� +fib }�' t Z r* �3 ���. agr.i�., vr+ � •.rk".' ,..,r,,, r�4;•r�a,,. t, - i� '4=o'�6ss ti �S- `ir .S 3'.'C:,c-y_ _ ,•yr��:•::''<.;'s+k,: .#;._� �iti _. .. . � .,. v':r,.. .. .,..-- a .. ... .... ....„ „r:;la,esTi ';t>;•-xri - _ _ ^�v= 'S' -u iil •' .:•_ ,.. •...-�'45!.. _ ��.'.,�...._r.�_... .. - 'r' __ .n.}",.E`e1L:u,�j A , - " •Y.:7'hr;.7:', • • _ y, T/.r17•s•• j. st`F �,��'�� - �+• -r _ -'1' + .. ,t; . ti .f..f. •a �•!" �s>a_ T, ��t tl �i'G11`i:+'t4`.eiiccir✓i �i�' a•r7.;-%'�?' � •. v ..' - .... '�. ... t.•a,S-.!;`'�... ;Si'"''Ti-'gC'YY�.�•l 4r_,..�e — nr:y:- r '• .i:_'". a"'� '''::.sr• � �#P`••'„}'" vi.,}}„s.. `s, 7•sl3 ' .. .,. .. .: ., f,' •` }•,.. , .s . 1 N':tliCt' .:b.�� �„' x r� 7� + v PUMP tiCh:>1►6�.;";:: y.•�;.a;_ n`•• i, - . ..:-. .. - .`••' ';x.a.�o.« •� '1k�r.G'vl:�ix'tij':.•r! P 'ram$' ' 'z ,�Y,-'f7..tij�� Y'(IY N..i'�: i•.'b.. •°•i,a:+; •. .. .n.. . • . .:.•' •P• :.Y." .isryliy:'' K •+4- .l+h'"jf '.f ii ''� :•4�t°' _'a. •♦t• ,.5}:. .y, :."• .�.i.e '.mN'>..:+ns�-•c;.p.,y*, - ,a�,L. k w''y.• al i'wy.•. - ., r - 'rk. i . Y.?a Yi/R+�' ..,.0 fi{{ gi Py yr, ;il..y,•i':-.•�1�.,,:::J �a^'��j/..�.y�At7]�llti�::'.�sFi`..i - .t:Y:�`.-•X,•a ti,••. 1•My t .. :.yi: ..yf.. ..'. :., :r .. ..,...••-t;�::tt;.ttt4.i`.,•�'143;4•!'tt'r111: �.iCf�•1kiSl.��•R .. - _ �".'"�:i ai -,� i"i�"u,1�fi'�ici,p::+�'.y iT'SaYs�'�".t'it�.rsdi:.. <:•1 ., :'a;: �:... �•lrlC �3..•..':' '- 7 r.NI PLANNING PACT SHEET City of Miami Planning Department: November 22, 1983. _ PETITIONS per' City.Commission Motions $ -1091, and.83-1092; Novembcr.l$i ..;' 1'g83..consideration of .rezoning lots 4,fi,7-,8,30.1ess tf►e<: ' � of,1oE'30, Block 2, PdINT iEw (2-93)..located.at e�proximately 185 SE'14 Terrace and approximately 200'SW 14 Street from RG--3/7 General Residential to SPI-5 Brickell Miami Rivei r Ree dential Office District or a lesser designation. from RG-31 7io. 1tEWST; To make recommendations regarding -rezoning SpI-5 or a'lesser zoning designation. r ing applicatio- n from RG-3/ 7 to SPI-5 was filed BACKGROUND: A rezon by three adjacent property owners in the point View 8ubdinision.:''` At:r-a —.h. x:;.fia ,ry e , three tracts are ,as _'follows.: "ttaa.ei?t-f.-1: - S• ,r _ .. - -'`; ` - r- • 'F` ';t -:,4ii3 r 0 less the E 5 of Lot 30 >; A�►.. :`Lots 6, 7, 8, and 3 >a, z� existing use: vacant `b. Lot 5 existing use: "The Babylon" condominium: (unoccupied) ?3`, f c. Lot 4 Y existing use: The.Coimnodore Club (unoccupied) g During the most recent application process :the' Planning, Depi=- h F menu recommended approval of SPI-S for I.ot.S and _foa� Lola b� and 30.and denial of rezoning for Lot 4. (See attached Zo S The 2onin .Board recatmneaded denial ��- t ,} Fact Sheets). v. e, k application, The Ciev, Gowmiasioa $pDroved a+ss$�r..:t�z:in, Fr RQ-3/6, for Lot 5nd' referred the remain%Ag tW,,Par+�e a k N, „ PAB for further study, to be returned to the::, . Sir - +mar •xM}, �"' "k�ra i i 4.A reZlonitn Lot' t,.ri:,.'�t,4-t_r .. ':;'::.,= �►I�TALXSISs - The action of fide City- Coms an s Qn.... sit aat ton ro8aroingta.►$c�iut.:: ttBS ;ay;��;�,"..,.•_:�-:...: _. changes the (Lots and 30) . Tot 5, iUdiiWU#UT does, h ,b,7,8, square footage or lofrontage t intended s ' ►:: sepaarete teeing district. Lots f►, 7,8`.' d':�0 , 7 be given .016 8=0 �,llA�tiR, ,�1�.Si tor IR:. }�1� p Q� 1� pjr �r /��j�r 1� /� /�/1Q �7s pj�J }�� . R�fi�/ .1[Rr •1147R 7► t�lU'. YMCA.IAM}7!�!pM,1�IS.Q:.r .. 5 !!fF9Rd fir, for a soning 41str�ut. 'his' ,00nststt e.:: u 1. �.'.•'•'yt, `. .. ]gyp �p}��r 1�1 /��/�pn�]� q)/'�p -sue` n g 'K71 partllT Pt- �ro�•M3�!!!!oodatiol ?: R Lots 5 94 R 7 # 8 a and 30 _ from �c�atdcDtfs�. :.. due-tQ�tcf_ Plysf ghsrst3t►a.g�+.�" - as ltu4 �}r io too . ' . PrcPorWafts ' 3 b 7aa-8, a qto �� a ^ 01 '.,vk"+.;•.,.�Fixyvr.�::;..,��...,...., . ,._.a��jt;;;;'s:�--..;��;y;a+C�ts�t�t;:% `''�+r,` a+ ._:ya r. ilMr. a: •yZ.'. �"�$z F���� �,s:T=P+ j�f i�- .{:•XZI .rJp1p�'-a �!«w:t l: �•. ,��S1t7. •.li 3n. 4 X.:�•�.•:� it _ i u 4 1 _ (- - i i i'gliiiii+•�te�,w�,,tf`.;. ,'ti:,.;,. a .. .;V•';o-• •;►: aG.t Ye�•.tllt'.IP.�f.}�Yi•3Yii,�:iu -.;�'r�`7,���:'�i7?R4!!"y'i•�l.��r� `�Q'aj•Ywv.:.-.. ."', ..- -... .r u- "..�.. .•• •... _ _... -.... _. _ - _ _..'4"'fi�i. *Y':1 �-4� 1 � ���� .. � ...i .. sat• ... �i': t"- s''�L%'. -{,. ..i: r"� ••i., as a.. i t a �t f, J l IYr•-.f'•��+ .ice.• .t S'a. »t _ •i4. '] s' Ih : • :Tt "tr_'i,tgq `d1rF>r- --.:fir _ _ �i"+• t4. •:L' ••'M„ �•4t''�. • i 'T'. - 4�_ 'i♦ '�:j4 ."1. :(. •lip.. - ��': • '+i!t . •r vw .ta .t z� NL t' u•.1 'f•+ M`.b,%r;:t•r,;.''Yly/�.i",...ry;�'.�{'.t,y F� .,,!J"•«:..�`.'! .� 1�,'1, - - �-NV ••avNNt .. .f,. AI' 13:)1r rfi�.. t,lr � i�'`t-Si. 3�= �- '- .. 1 +. t•: �j..+}.ir a"?:•t ••R•�{�, - : - e�Y.a+ _X _ - .. - ' •.'••/Yip., .. - - .j/;;i a 't'i t�ltYJ r�'t't�: :T13''�lria �!••..4�1-"tb,s•� E\t�i' �'J.,'„r'.$k'Y.i�i.�...-\}.:•'•a!•i�•,'tyt✓.'..+'>a4''Iy:G'''�"ii.'� ,?'ia..�.�, � ��'i'iJ'�' •i� �.. r'}} .Yitr'•ri r,(,i:'F,, igjn ti`i:�¢'�',t:' n• w, •......a'j:.''.''•,:tt.s•H,ullr4�tir't:►..u!NMY`X+"iyrii'�. r�:'S'�t,^;•{1.-"i"' - •y; �.y-,�`qc�t '� Sr: Y` •a [ifiM ri •"ry ix fit t•�!•, MRif i'ifiF,[`•i�•}ip:iJ (jifw..hrYr. ViY'i^+Y41. t�t( d`±�ts`,?�L�}:Y• . •��:.;i,c��ylr..=a}ipy{yc. «�+rH:s •!�! f rs� `__r,F The newzoning and restrictive coveilants on the adjacent Lot 5 Y will'o-nsure that -the Babylon provides a permanett buffer ' ` betudin the_-bayfront residential and the SE 14 Street office -;' district. Lot 4 should be developed with residential uses sim3 r to those existing in the Point View area; the SP175 district is too high in land use and intensitq. RBCOMINDATION : r Y, PLANNING DEPT.: a. "Approval -of rezoning from RG-3/7 tot.RO-3/4 fort,lo.ts 697,80 and 30 less the E 5• of Lot 30: t b. Denial of`rezoning for lot 4. r~ Y PLAW114G ' - APPROVAL.of rezoning from RG-3/7 to RO-3/6 for lots 6,7, h„:a =a ;; ' ADVISORY , BOARD: .. 8, and 30� lees the E. 5' of Lot 30 and DENIAL of rezoning for `:Lot t g. a '''',?�+;..'+� �Ar'-sr'I-� r';'q�Z .t , _ . ,s • 5 - - ,� k'" a" �� ; a.47�3Y•1-; � °Y� #���`€��-�' qua. �t • rid ; .. - . :1 � ,, � .. { tt. ' S .� n;'• �''v ` - a � � �'it* +X"f5�+�' .��'r� '`Y� � ;��.sep pp,i [F TM �Z k- - -•aaa .., rl"',..- m::„; ..'i{:_ , .» - .ar n ✓• ;At. �. �t'smr.:A•=.,rk.��.J^frt.�F•, t � si�},at„ , s. .,.. ..- :. a ...,, i'4':a-, »i` �4"'.� �:x''f 'f,.:�-:�-,. '.t„"' -L-; r.,;+�:'a•.,.r `r'xv, . ,.- _ !s, .,. � fin•' fir,. �,'k�:.,<•:Y}ya yi::�+fiL. — e r � to � k . _ „ , .s' ; a�C-=k - a •� ��.�,`'•'x�'�.'�',:<?•�.. :�- $� ,�a� 7' � _ 1Y,<$'• ,-. t F" i�;! �i, ..e.•'1' P t 4 _ "i a •.u. 4. _ c* X ,rR'^'3' YMM rf,E - 1• se. 3 , Y - A k. 2r' � � �- R - � tt R• ,�y ,2€ - �—VOi .y,,(4 - - - ) t i y h �' 3 t -y •t .,* 4 1 r+ } } s yy�.,'� -2 $ *w F F .tf' : hT�: }�, �y �••.t':a�'4 �'��;%t,'-� .q'c�- Y�.l�}+kK �R°{°Y k� ;s � it '� ��•�`� �$i•ir +�{., sJr'i "€ �`,yx .�! :4 .'�}���`' � - t�. ,, ;� 2 R., N .tGq�xfA - r+ Lrs "v.] .s.4Q ri-3' Aa L nu L 4-1 A 0. _4 w, wma REVISED ZONING FACT SHEET LOCATION/LEGAL roximatei z App Y, -186 SE 14th Terrace and 'A Approximately imitely 200 SE 14th Street 0_49596o7jS and 30 less -thik-E. 51 of,lot :36 'Block 9' ,POINT VIEW (2-93) OWNER/APPLICANTeaplace 'Realty Investments,-;N.V. 06 A.A. Scott 100,North Biscayne -Blvd., .1 or da Mon -3502' ................. `Allen- Eliss 1402 S. Bayshore* Drive ii0i*9'1 F1 13 31 Phone'#358-25*8*9 Cucusa, Inc. r Pi eside'rit' 4�/o'-Ray C�droai. 6240;,Suhs�6t'Dri ve _0 1 M1 aini 'Florida, 3143Phone-,6 -.# Pointview Towers ,of Curacao. Inci;-, "'Scott c o A.14 0rt tayrie" Blvd* 171,7102 Florida' '1 4 mo a si I-Attorhey for 'Applicants) 1401 Brickell Avenue 77 rt _k ZONINGR4­(Hih DensitYMuT eildeftlll'7_1 REQUEST, Change L of Zoning ClassifiCtion to a R-C8 (Residential-Offiee)./ SPI-5 Mr Residentia-l-Office District),. RECOIA44ENDATIONS 211.14 1611111 Intl MIR&M IN L PLMNING, DEPT,, 19PROVAL --0F LOTS 5, 6, ?,AND DENIAL - OF "lot, , "Face-4777 V, MWU40ad M and propert w, n 4 first lot facing'the water. ►od.- M$identi 41 with *1 the. 'rest " of Ah water Alon soutblaysh0eoriv. that th 'buf f4r. ,-bqtw0aW,, tht, erne` is . •ate. .•a•.. 'gib :,�M .;tw+.•.+.«J:'�•t.,Fw42tyit,{aA�•!s '.`;Y: r.�.: S�. w;� ai}ie*a+"yz?': ��{'�S e Y•,;a - �+ a.t,. •,t• �;t15ti 1. .:. .. ..,'• >�Nl..v .Ity.ii •��,t{'""Y�,.:.-•• �y�y• •.r..ir.�.�.i `j'wia-4 �•s �.l-. 'i, .... • '..•{�3'..M...e >,L • •�•.an�:w'^!.7'w ..1•,'••�••.'''la.I •I Y,; •: 'Y,��.'.�y •! '�}���'i' _ ldlf_ :iib"tiFJy.�".:•r;•.�•'�pild'y!,W-: 1. � .!Td. 'tom 1 •1 2 I•' si. •1-':T";�i�.. - p:�+ti�e+ti = � .t cs x.tt:k'YI"N'a:i ;5;••»: `.i'r.4+'!i`. • •,�.'.. ..ir SSG. This will clintribute to a portion of our sewer PUBLIC WORKS system already. designated "overloaded" by (PI-5). It will further overload this system. It may •;''' have: a detrimental- ;_effect on downstream trunk mains which :survived the initial SPI District. if this. is cbnsidered as ,a trend 'spreading south along Bayshore it -will have''an,bverloading effect <r : _ on W, tntercept in Bayshore: ZONING BOARD 1983 made a motion to At its meeting of July �I, , recommend cenial which failed -by a 3 to Z vote, there - fort constituting- a recommehdatioft, of denial. (Ord 5871) At its, meeting- of, July l l' ' 1983, made a motion- to recommend denial which failed by 3 tb .Z'vote, there fore„ consti tuti ng a recommendati on of denial.. (Ord .95b0) .<<_'`:'°•r Granted•' Change. of . Zoning on '11 /18/83 on Lot 5, Block 2 - • " '<y CITY.COMMISSION 5t only. by `Ordinancea`9758. PLANNING ADVISORY T ,r At 'a pub! c `meeting on December 7 =�l 983, the Planning... = ry s BOARD P Advi sor` - `Board`; recommended approval of a change of Zoning;.= y Lots 6 7 8 and . 30 l ens z requs: from. RG`3t7'to° Rn=316 on ,.. . M: the ' E 5' of Lot 30 and denial of Lot 4Y bya} 4 to 0 _ ��ote...° - _ _ .1. <•G :. -' Board for further: Thi s ,,i teni wat , refe`rred to the Zoning Boa ` CITY, COMMISSION _ x study-'and".report by," on a83-1173, adopted by, the City Commi ssi on:Tbn December 15, 19,�3. Thi s..case Mill he :, ; considered' at'the` City. Commi ssion. meetin ; �ofi�= — 9k Janpav% t:2 1984 after, 6, 00 .pm. (Ordinance _9501 Section 3213) >, ''ZONING BOARD At>;ts, meetit� ' of'4anuar ra 15, 1984, .the Zoning Board 3 - `'- heard` additional testimony but took -no action ort Y a� ' s available which �tatas. the item. A transcript i P *�. each members thoughts and feelings, y: :.t e:.>- :'.f!`. - .* a.' ay.•�;+ax';p• w. - is f'ti;,�„�'=�'b`' r ... n a _ "s•• i v .. _ tN `.G`. Y''x, SY' .f fi,yy {{YY - >j* a !'s-+}'P!� Z � r'�x.-N �- fir:• N>.�{�,�x•:• . s .€ `n�.:�r, aa' y�ty' • { , t '.: a 9' 3;n � •' ' ': * ' s AA, 4sC t i is . -tST {, - _ _ Leg d•j {�', .. s,}p:,. �- .F ja s ,?V -a n - r. �.,�s�` is. :• 'tr,i�4k;.., any _— v a �a'�t?'z � � ' ° �• r. . .. . ...... : . _.... , -.. , f zr.,. � {fir ���'�'•'• _ -- z.-_-..,._ • d Y'Ta ��rr,,� - r . iit . =~ F91: !(:,•4.i: rryi �•.. y; tr a/=•-ry;3r s"ai't.�,. ' - L. � 1i� ifs.. . - ,yyit)',. +• i''. - „ , r. :Y Sv:Y: O:Z: t:i; .:.. <: • ` . '.f`.p:"MeF i iY•dJr!irfLfi(i:O ,iO tI :� •y yA,.yv :c'f ` 4 �ZN ` ZONING FACT SHEET _ _ ►' LOCATIONtt.EGAL Approximately 185 SE 14th Terrace and App - roximately 200 SE I4th ..Street - fM lot-41-6;7,8•and 30 1ess the E 5': _ of I bt 30 —'•- POINT VIEW (2-93) * ;OWNER/APPLIOANT beaplice Realty investments, N.Y. a c/a A. R. Scott .100 North Biscayne Blvd. Miami, Florida Phone # 3., ." � • i ,,. t t'r •=a 'i• it . „ , =7 1 i •k.• i .�., - r. t An X,' c/o Ribero t . � :.�-_ :• 51 S th Street t lorida Phone f Miami , F -r Pointview Towers of Curacao, `Inc. '�'' t:4 rj c/o A.R. Scott , rk k ;L _� 100 North Biscayne Blvd. $� q _. 3 _ Miami, Florida Phone # - f �?m�y `Florence Robbins (Attorney for Applicants) F+ �a ` i • L. , 1401 Sri ckel I Avenue ` _ _ • ►_ Piio»e4579 0609 Miami, Florida a' ZONING . '; 'L' R-5 (high, Density. Multiple) REQUEST Change of Zoning,Cl�ssificatson to s . ra xw R-CB (Residential -Office),:; 'irj�..�s. ;� s RCttQATIONS p r -DENIAL.+ Us cd on the fol]o�+ing r�o4�dns� t Yi�:�#� ��g'�# !) the change would car�si tuts :�e ee4nt� . into the stW0 hig�.';�ona��► 1 �� O:` residential ma, creStiftg ,4. �r f r theQih . � aYt � Q� `4►1r+. na, ^'3 : t- ;:x`.z.v_ti_.k._ I The #gong w 1d be,:.e p ` 4 fity Caarehenve p1on MY s' { • � Tie 0000 WiI1 40er-eel :inf1 � i #� �.•'� *L. �Of dt" ie� i Ya�.�i}�� � � !d '#e.1�.�.t�{��f�ig 'i��:`j{��.`J��is #i►� ^y•:*E t 41. t * • .. ra.,<. , ...�. 3 �'�..,.. ir.. r �l�C��S*,1 '"' }� __ . _r x. ' _-I.. ._. -: j'�a.J'�`�'vh j ��' u� ! r I 77 ":;r', •1• t giy � { jj of i:i •'t • . • I - . '•ii:•MY`i t •. N i.a�p�A=R!Rii,�.; ` �'R W.a'.-:— • .•+I,R T.1•.:, •- .. . . .. .. - - .. . n-. . - ... ta4 .. - - :9i'ii.i.wY.".y�.��«�.;.tLyt�:as ..•e.. ' ` � .t Y.'.C:-S .•a'.:•`.7� <Y3a {.. _ .-+.•i� ` � • cast; rr 1 .+: et• `` . � 1 :.•:: -. - "� .�D:-t -.. i.,.'i - �: - •'ara •A�� ;. :i .Sr.x?a• e� .R.. tilt: - _ - ;��::i.••"4,.: •t�ix�:,..;- - . ;y.,r,r>..: ,: :"'»;1p , ixi'^ i.x:.:'�i.` •.'•1 i^-^ 7�-�Y`^a�.v.diin'J�hY•'IaJO�t• 's1q ,.::.0 %.�•• - - _ .-_ •. ._a+-..t•.z_ �.nc�:_Y�...�..y.�.....L.'.J_L.w1...w LrYil.ilISIJ_ "a � _ —��� . .. _. aw-.. j_ � _ is 'ta. .1.•Y L,, y.r,x :m.y. t� .4i.. i y� . i'iSih'.l:a t.�.%"�-�Y,' I�'��,.' xn:•- t .,!W.r •:r,«x,•n:, ..�•. .•`!' w:i.:'.`t!�,!i„ t�`.: ,c;i• � :li :>• +•+: �;f �i�:%�r•Yior�.� Ww4.i 6:, st�+G. 7Ji.Cn"sr.ti' F r.hs, • (`,:S �•K1/il,Y...[S'.k S�' • .Y.. `3 l.' . - •1 , . .... ... ., :-i»: T. • Wr.•S.' ..f ".- - .i'. . an i.�s.�!Y�.� r,1iF•r �--i.,,•,� . N�fw+bi;._ `-.:':+-�.. -, ... »�:f��: wt�t»f,�i'�'vi}��7'::-t..t�7=1946�'..`s•i;rx ;.:.:•: zw.-. `x - - 'µ:i�b ----------------- Ait 1 The - change .i s out of _scale with the"needs ; of: the neighborhood and the, city; iince -' ;there` Ai sufficient'' 1 and all a1 oh —k. 7— r g - Br-i ckel l''Avenue zoned R-CR. PUBLIC WORKS .Flo •dedication: i s reques a ted ° r SEE R 11ISE03.FACT' SHEET �'FP-1 NG REVISED LIST ;OF OWNER/A� LICANTS vy ; ,. p • :• EE. REVISEO,.`FACT SHEET w' SHbWING TREVY ED RECOh1MENDATI01S A 1Q ZONING 80ARD = y ACTION...� x..i• - a>N a 4`'.rnvt.;. I t t '' . I ' - a MS 7 _ c�'� �� '•� � }:f- ?�dti`"=. �.rT}-.. - _ ��y' 4' � _ - •� - - � - � _ l• r i.��.;',"mot'=��`,' ��� sa#+ yyrcn - '7„F St'"t � 2 L r r' � ` > `• . - ( �T`�"` 4A y o ;.: :, ' � R'-"'aak £ �i -� s t, - '_ v 'F - � � k�v1�3e• n- Jr N : ` w '¢f♦ >s"?:e,;. i;,tt'.. .•'1`•il x :tii;? ,s'a., x fi`, - 4 s-,,ry{ 3'q °-^ _ gj;h;-;a y4 'rt'. ayn,. m•. 4f ".••r „ ,rh 7, . F .C,�1 rf 3 ¢Y • ,iSs; 'iY �� '. - 9.•r s rL -'i ri `'r-t r U ���f ` �� %w� t �'rx • � fin.:' ! 1- L,�: j � +=yd • t'.L"��� . r'' �':��� aj,a,°' y�:� '�`':I. ,,,F �-t-"'�n 'a4t� '_ a -� s?�,::a�Y"• Ps Tin ' i ; E �. y'ir - d- • » - V �qy„lax,:' - . ? aim'p'{:=.::yr`=A x - :.i,Ra�''''�-de'�� x "s- ;1 4� p".�.ni;_'�`y':_ <•r»3.r,,r v;t a -d •lt,'� i� s -- `"2.;9nax'ii'x`*-`'T"a'•r <:•'e"'�'` '� - - - - - t ` 2 - a': s`=:a ` t � r1+."o-F .:...,, ..ts r.»?j•„ si.:.;sxn �ii�,+F�7�Tl i Rea gx ,. •'" ,i ,r•tr•• t;;?.��•»I•.Srr..•;+w��.;::, ` ,::fir =-t�-`., i• '.?ir•r✓:K.'Wt..j ;t. .t «:ra �;' �IGI� + t, ., ': .,��-'' - _f ... •� f7 �F. .a+. t�.iY.•✓�'it �"•a r.�:t,.k�,Y ids•_- �'",_y:-� -. .. •t :.;�s.i:•'.••'•T`;:°:'' 7 h;..z�i„��. flt� i +t+r,C,r. - - Ae tjl�lwoloft Now r � i.. `{rIF•ft •'Yid y}"- . rpa :�.?` .J :•�r:�J. .�j•�j ::.4r.�:C,, :L'.iiv}. }��•Y�. �fy :::G�.t'f s •a _ ,•ii .Y Y:.Y:a. .��`: •1.: •f�.t• • i. . .. . • • .. .;{.i�'••'I �.•i _..7fi{,a:�1:•I1�•:.•R:4��+ • _ .- ., _ •{�. er6*40/JF` jj • !t r !{ - SOC ,. rRaCT q10 so 8 r7` f 14 ° i o l,° " !gip ip Ili 1e 2 wl. _. a° 100 vo .% ��s° yes . t2 sa f - tt toLAZ So l r:. /IA 33:� Leo �' •,. - — �' `'. _� 3,�� LA h :j,Ji ETA"' AC iP e t +r si ti u a�i�=.ph'"'1�W..,'' Y - 1 Y- w .. a—: -t .1At,L"k•,i«+i '`A= Y a yy 'E�py, {�*• ,+-�, k fi•�if•'\Y� �'•l•.i 1.1 n ..•. r a ..A M " Pu`f' D' ..i. - - E� S{ oft q�����+�(�r ;1 .l- •. :�!:iii .;•••�✓,•f:'S �i:r'�;{+°«.i".'�;C,',:.i,.i`,.'!:��''�t'�•�t �:.'tL'}�i iiit'�,r,_ " APPROX. 185, ,tiwt'�3N; ?�+'��}roy'�:"`a y y�^y'r '#' a i �,y,. M;i4x,-,,,� i r .:�M'�7':' ..•' .>.' £ ...,. ii•: ��• � x.. .�•2 .... � '. ` s -*. a,x,� �'} '� s t• #i i ) ��•�� s� i I�>:ict..-"` ,. �,f E.�;`�;� � �; .�.�j � � � ` .�••� •♦ ....•,. �...:� :• :�:s..s•L'aHr , ifr:..�,� ,�y}t�,�a�i j:tc'y' #��� � �r ^e. �•''�` i 4;' •-�.Z � t� �Yii•,. .:i'i. +�-:'S! .5.� i• ,Ki �1 • 11' .'i.•.i ♦• li aii •♦�•�fi,.i�• Y r' •ti•�i M Ki'/lb��i )II:tY�,IY ��L��'c,Yi�rH�.^ _ a i t �.F ',q�'1.'�"s .. YFs'•.''pYC4{L�a...! . t�Y`��t Csw�a ♦ ..a ..S♦:.fdq). ♦ M►:i l: ..i.Jj'i.fV:t Y•X �Y•t.�j 1,•ai .F{ t xa•r. •p ni- �i cr..�ii!. i ,+�'?!�..`�... �i. �� _ ,� .p�'•µi..,�Y� �fi,'f.r '•fy r .t=[r 1:. :� . _ . s . .. - _ - :it'��1�. .,'.�� a-i�'�ft '`�' -- I Y _ t " 'S • <_z"h : Y t r , l.- t Y� 14 a.= +:i ` £ rt ,1 (��1y�����(,',Y��/ �vAj • �/yy'�1� � y SF;� i}�• 1�k� � • Y's ..,• 1b i -yh s `.1 r 'Y't SAP -• • ST 51 WE IGA io yT;.tk'xif -t -S _ 'R i i •. _ j ��A�F'4 ,t' o i�`g nt:ri�•�'h'. `{'`1.�; it YY�, :t.� •_r�. .�.�n•�o-u•b.«„y�.�'p�= 7 � >�.,t "'.`s��`,.->�,,>r t tt ,�• s _. :'s<;�_•.," ♦ .T�! ,.5� Y"�>zx�Y : yt '. 4'i'► "Yr y'`.`i.ip.: `1 ?;r�,k•_i,EY i,: 5'•;'.-:.H•�.1.9i �,�y:."�,t a,.t�. '#iFse- �, ✓��-„_�. �''�.T�' ..a ■y y�_� £ 5 ` y,.a- tiY. ,-<t?'•, xn ;iF ''a5�q�r',�^. 34 -'�r'� M1�}'�.4 �� _ Ev$xs `� �>. �� a.4• '��' •�,�'�. j "i �;- �i;'�. � R i+. �Y % r' Y. � iY�F ye: �re :=. t,:a• y- •P 4.. 5"F �• ���¢ �' • arr mw�• «rya' .. , da -.t VX �'r � • 4 n � S.,.uSr 4 ' - 5< t - .i.�^ Wl- - 'tyre fi .j Sky ' r A• L>y ,. .,e� f.�£rsg ks U _:Y �: •n t /�/�� �». �� ''k �Y..'+. `} .k .hL?^'. LP 41 1p v r•n, tp : t r .} e%,"' z .•''w � 6k ,- • .`r -- .c - - s%g•s.- �p ♦vif '<"°#k Yr•_. `,,�+t'u^;. f •, �. ' Y ;j.',.?yA .,."':xi .ri;n '`i . Vj- • .�"' ,�.�,- ':�'fi�¢ ,{�N '� a>F. `` d�r�1r >i,�,, ,�-a'�'7+ �- ' F� " �yt' KS�r � q c�$ >, .. f� ti Y i �� S4 ;,-'y'S-rr'yt} 5. ��+•�� -� 'sL '".4fs. Y' ii'yy'fl J `C, .'"s'f,__- r-��'" '^ �` � � •.:aft t, �y.;`' ;i Y�" �^ _^'�" ;'va,-Y'}.� - .. - � ,r.$�� 4 +�t4 �� r s �:4 _ `:`�N.��,'i+•t7. _ _ ,$ �,�y�,- K _ � s �',-�'s.�;y•'�3r�� 3 4 `^.ty�d 'em tvt Ji X a " r _. _--_ _ _. r.���`£i'�- �'�.M1. .tom :s 3.,''�""�1^��5�'�'`�fp'�-'>�'��'•,��� F*�'�w-°� -'�._ r'� ___._. - _.-- ' wk u - • r., �e _ C �• - w� f 77 ow 1 •f ���� .'�•� .. as s'• + {`; r• �',` '� t� m ` ;. - �4�•Ek1 Y �y +�_ V:....•�}:�. t •19. j S tt NPI ,.Vn I x"r' ' '�:lr• t • �A 4. •�'1�*� y- f �(ai �` •�•. "�'M _ �,r:. 1 \ �' rM1 J o^ 41 Ilk At 71 1p jjj l ?i's'. .� ?,1+1y, of •:•1�r,.,rrn r � ,.l•+�.«r n l„ `� 2• -'�, . •.. > 1 • : y x_: 1 -;, .. s�,�J � ,'+.�I,�G,i lr •..-y,��•J "-'�l� ,�, r jyJr Y i }\ e,r �. �'. ' +.. " ?.wh� YY - •'�. } l�N ^' j �.:`• � t�.•.4' �. � 'ri �;1'+' �-:J�� �'$� s� 2� tl 6'. s�+- �• r �'r �•7! ~¢: 1 .•. ��• ,�y ' �t�'tv'af.. « r ,:••�K l,� �^�•tp�,. ter ,e W . g > lit �.. im ��• t. • `�_ _ �•,�' � • �-�„► � �/," � /'�' ! � t «ice 1 • t tr r L— - ri:;` - - e" '�:7:'v-r•:~'.',.�r� ��;�<a �'•FJ'.nei °,%-'8�'"���-i=,zl.`u2��e9. ''t3'•` ;•;i,, ":`.tYt,<'':i:-ia `f ?'. :"C..�'>_ - �5�a.. . v'.; - s�f.. - c%ri4s.% f-Rk .. . ` ' ,y+a i i t tW�� nary •i.F-+Pt :i •'�+try"S, '�0 51, .. f - - - f • • ��T,,i-ZtisiiYTsS�Ila.ari: ..� - ." F,„&i'f+ NOR WO , , ,,`,°° a1 ., .:i: i;._.�;•,,F - ''so-, HOWARD City' ivlanar..: ;ice; .. January 18,' 1984 - . Certi fi ed Mai I ic}ard" Friend,: Esq:.. . Manges t 800 Be kell Avenue a - Miami F:1=.33131.t >, f Deari Sir:; z a stated that you i ssi on . meeti n it .was At` a riacent` "City Co►mn 9 f he of F., r less th sr y; 7 .8 rand 30. -., of Lots)G ; ` . ,.. ent tttie oi�tner's`',�.`, .: :,.N:, 1:(•R _ - - f�:� 'Y- A r. .. _._.. .i;�' a c>. ?1L '1,'>• _f-`2i DIN�1l�EW ak 2 P w j' 0 3 1�0 - _ =f, -R� e t t b.. re resen a,� �..:. x a1 as le oil P .�.. �:.• Tra - `ertt H:° 9 - �1�ur���records sh /� °Rob 9 1 on ee the'' ; rauri is no ever, if Mr. T g 9 rt ..How - - • ;. for above -props _ 9 p . ),. x re�entative°,yoi,must cane to this office and to 4 so that our record i 11,- show the ,rope, _forms: r ords w �...F:zy:, the:-p_r,�per ,;;• x.; ate'. rpre;;er t�►�i} e. • c �:t- , �•it , :',£ r.,�u; >, ""4'S�'E"•"�"{ - �,� cam~ ' Tn�ii Code q 'i. �,} 1 TheCity ''Zo 9' re u res-.that..only..•an- owner ©r his 41egi3'�, representative,, w aP�14,ad} 4, CA" .1, P,jT0gt•,�of Boards cr f Ordi Hance ij 9 ��on>mission:� See-enclosed--copy°iaf::45ection`•3502.3 0 �j t _ .TYV .•Ir:}..r•1 _ `�fi., s': i.:p`-.'.f'' - '��"iE- � t�:' p r d is�i ,.3' q. _ :� �, ";c" a $ f; �'i-�S.ti �t .i' +' •• `y°r:;i.'a #r� �`a ��:.�� _i:C�•�Y. ^p.�l�nt- `;',x !• � / t Ey ' .s a ' a<a S -t t . j :.t.t• .`: f : ° i:�t..� .:'S,. im .s`J'! i-i„'�. , n . E } ..S•�,• „y�ya. a (a9 9t�. #: t."'. -? ,4�r' lb` qt •s y la`s -`+ :Aar _�,"�,gk ;r..� ��:�°'� ti a� ,`ts'� >�i:- , ,: f :"gn `n-.S';. s$ ,�-a ��',"°+a�`+�' � ��. `.� r�Y�'`7.'„-ir,:yw''A'.�`.��-�'�`�`k• '4' � ;`a ,. r ° .. ,", _t _t. ,v+aK '"° t'^�^�' `3 n#4' k .k ��.;a. "., �i••iro,e td":=�',P•,i lvUkt _ . . '� •++. .,.r t : Y.. -,°3.: ;' j'; :_,t �z t' »' v4 `" "cr" °'�c 'm �'t 4� �>�,'�' m- �p {i �.' ak, , `; e . '� Ci' t s < A ! ; • ,R �;.#�! 7: 4 # i. ,.a `:?�±� �St'"�` r j,� d'�''�'f'.. _�P� y , �'t �� '" taa,F.`' %« �t•.1i4. cit {.,;' • F.: - 2.. 'i 4�✓'��=§' It J11.'x I`-.+kr.•'`k .�. ..rr: ;, -- - '-,fi;�. _ ;• i,. ? 2 $ ' x ,;.c' ,',. ;. Drectoriix _ •{):x ,••t_,' S�Y� •`��q'��i°.. .}'$', a{ �" .,i, - � 'M lIT r').' l' _ 't.c':,.,..n+..h.,,r ,..t,a•'s r'srt •r1>.`?�'ry�+'" 1+C x':','�- `b ' cn 4n ..�b: �a'.ry:.,� =y, x a -a•� -+,'•J - rt:r.r r �{`�► :` f1 t t' �;-,r. n�-.-."._,w ..:.i,e ,<c•,+..,, b..>n,va,...!•.=:w.,..s .em_-ea- h1an�+'#R:tg�zR"1+4,'r}`�a.iy �.,P - akY ! TT-•W..r.-.45:r•Mti Y kM I• an"•' .. t'. c+�'M. -'�''r '<�3h >i ,''s< #.i,„, .:n y "?',` x a ,'•5:, 3.'?,� �f 'z..4i•`la.'�`'t ^' "` adhs�, VsL "�.d'�`'�`, ak;',' -eV"I a''`i''Sr0 >i., .`{. s•5 l>(_, $g•.;„'4 t'j• ' l *l. �St F`i'fi#:.. _st�",a.,a, �r't rr �.:�v -+;,; a'�" v.:3 ik': n'i,� _ .+ � § `6}., C•5F`7"i�'w� » ,_. zt '� a?f`+,x �,'f x".��^'" �' 'F .,, �q; t t = r %i 3;' a�r-�• ' 1 ��. a3' `.. , ti.., 'S . ,:-Y� �.:�3 � � a'r �• r h _�; i . �';$r';f3.�t' '�' '�' : Y .'++r' � 4 a - s.� -t. 4r ,- 7� iz w " f � ��sk;,3{,.�•i� -F ), R, iOU "•�' .e.' t� =` ` ,t , rl. ';�; #;=..# `.'¢,}..i ';1�.t xz s,{ .;" K - - i p ' PL,# J .. ��� i'.4Y�A�yer�pq»i�;••f'r�s`'-+,..;�r•uF ..a?nifio�' Oyu. .y uai„�n '.:.ru..i.�se5.e tq. ,+:o{,N<.a,i.: n�,.;:,r�'�r,-�la�i�';rs-+F'�,' `oT�. ti v� � , t '• T �:*'';`.,;, t�•.: ` _ .pp �{'�}-�gSp•:; a}�; 'o�tx,�e' p�,�r4`,';s;.y;::'��,µ,' _$"y!"•9,tttP& {;-'sih { 1540 i "i'T'W'� :'�'^}eA. ! •k ±sib' - •=f,, +.try - � - "_'.t, •c�.-:.j`�c,r;v'- ,:l1`7wti.� p� �.l;f... >1r.u: ih^u-.kl:;;..:'G,:.S ,lr�: c. ,'. "K"J.,•r :..•;� - — rY,. - a.. .•iv+7*'Ii'.. rl0.0 ,1..'.; ... •'!'•fti,.. , �'.i2'3„y ' - - ;C *,-,,' ARTICLE 35. AMENDMENTS SECTION 3511_i. IN, TENT. t. { This Zoning Ordinance, and the Official Zoning Atlas and Official Schedule of': District Regulations which are a part thereof, may from time to time be amended, Ysupplementedo changed; or repealed. It is the intent of this Article that the Planning `Advisory Board and the Zoning Board will each serve as advisory and recommendatory. Instruments to the City Commission for the specific categories of amendments for which each is responsible and in the manner herein set out. —: `'LL'�5ECTIC7fil:3502, IN OF APPLICATIONS FOR AMENDMENT. _ .::Who:M, 6gply. Except* as otherwise limited„by,this zoning ordinance, applications for zoning '. t r = . cirriendrriei�ts ray be made by: Ci c", mission "'Pld`h ng'Aavi ory Board i; (1) ,Zoning ,Beard depar ment� or age��cy of'ahe City- 4 u T(ei.Any Persri "other �than,tlose, liseii• in.(a-d)'obovej provided, no person in r this;aate t%).hd�lapplyar'ari arYiendment for fihe':cezoning of property e�ccept owner or agent or attorney for an owner.. $ •tea ., : a�s�- `':s .: _ ;;,:r ,,.t r�'�'„we:. ` 'c�; '�.=..—tk°E, Consideration by Boards. _ + '.: r.. f ,. t. - t.w it• ak iors;fvr -tonin omeildmens iappl icnt_ 9 :- ins ?.mayctn� i�a re *rod dtd; .as `' Pantng:Advipry :ard.`or the 'Z�ining 80 , liereIn"set. { l 6 f 350Z.3� "Submission of Applic attons for Aireii iiient. x'`j> t W. x "AIlry+oPpliaations for zoning arnendmentsc$p t whet) r rec uire be"haQcd fire by ,', ,�h 4 . in ad, o , # F�innnl tAlvisory3oard or fiat liy==thu Zion ga brnit#zsi tin #�i f�+fficr arc agent design4ted►j+a: Ciyf+an!q'�'1i1+5 f 4 JaE SeatiotiQi`e`siia�!`contoln o notaril'1+a'nt byte' #mot POW §.. hid %�y tfia't the facts as r resar. ri r 'a s�rrt - th� st 04�1a`awnor's IcnowWgQ or that stlfihis ott r �•� „ „ ..»R{� � ,. i broil pertinent 100MM iOR10-M��' sated°erhii p . l+jrggvi{rad for. rc►per- i t to" ana ►'i t § "§,t i. L•'»! :i ' .. . �, .. � k+77V�`'"yr,'�l1�1�MC1'-M 1STO BE � •z. ' _ y. 11 k,.ri,-7,�:.:r•..�*,..'".�'+.'e l.9 ry,�.'rH: `�RY'•i: iti _ - -��f� aWriq Advisory Board 141011 hq ►g:4Qomdcil thsarDon #.3 ' At by W in Sct, •i' q -M, : Ah+1F AAENT ID BE SyII�iC - » - �� } 7-77.m7, _a , .. - _ ... - ,1 t, ,iq,�•' ��.m., r, „ F:.,:. ; s fa 'v3' i{ V W,�T' x' 7 f3s j�• lS4^w'4 •i 4 y. Arr• rx�; d`t�"lSN�,y'v5k yi.Z. r •.' .4 ....,'.. %k"t?. A t>9 • •FI,S,.: •.•. yti•t. .. .:ra'1. ...q`%•• . .- .t +r ,-Z,- ; cam.. 4•.YYi.'i tf)t: .ti: -. - ,. :t,1: - - - = s: i`r.:.,�� I i w. ,: _ •. k LAW OFPICES bUPONTBUILMNG IW l' J t• 's' 169 EAST FI AGLER STREET E k MIAMI. fLORIDA 33131. 204 1ELf�HiMl �t Vlr ;•lt�,,`,:, �'_t,. (305)3i9.11 August.2, 1983ee r Mr. Ralph tOt►gle. •'. ; ark City of . Miami b1 - �American'D Pan r 93 - - - .r; , .. • ... r Meeting, Comm 2uly 28, _ 'First Reading fission Cie Item N mber ' 11 s Ordinance Real Investments, N. V • lacetY ' _£+8. do 'by Cucusa, Inc , Seapo o Chang the Zoning of £, n Inc.c•'t e k owers ?af-;Curses fid`Peint'Yievi► T S. E• 14 a roximately R T rrace and apF4„ a roximately, SPI-S In the Zoning _ pp 5tr�e :zfxort�.; G.3/7 to mi 3 ; 1 ZO- S. E• 1!r _ 95b0 of the Cl of Mia of 7. in ordinance; Y ar'Mr Bits ` list the n�►mes and h p' I started to lI u k the above referenced item, or Ferre asked �r►e.t° the public hearing on I Baking, Y ? 6 ,]3urin8: p� hose beha as sp d the :f addresses of those persons on whose the time of the Commission to read Y submit -the tii�it;rsther than = the xecord. .z., addresses into below the names and addresses yor's request, I am submitting xY:Ma 11i accordance withthe w �s rsons I represented at that hearing• i �! -: of those pe . shore Drive 1450 T v iemord Kopec 140 South Y re privy f y 1#SQ youthyre Orly* 3ullet anan DciWa M b Muth seer .:, 1 0 uth past° yshh9ra 1 8 UP.- 1 stiare::'�+a s ellen Corwin 1a3t1, Seuth Eat y. �lte NnIan 1#auth p•a►st M Macstial it�0 gputh iayher+st iv+ # , r� — t ` •• gcskn►rlella # Q 'ccve r :D��►c : , t ��t�. z E rr 'Z U.,10 Dollard 100l1fy "WI.'��►� � }�,:� fir`' t i r ,� r ,ti• "t: akra iil$ J -- (j if S `-7• XZ d.-.,+}c:E';f4''.°e`- ,qt.y{:'�.' nt' �` �'-„�`s�, �';;, ''., A-,.... �.,.,. ... :.�.:..�r _._ - -a=- i 3 �,� 't ..•.-'t,r:::...' ,.,t., :.., _ ,.-.,¢£,..}w:9t�'�:�i 4�.,�'r"-r,.` II �e`tta• •_7 .0 4 gyF`t2f•/'4't�i"iS�ii•����1�-,�:,{:I y�t�M >, , LC1M.�'�.Y� .._a .s I. .. , ♦ o _ ;�1f'�,.k - ��t -_ _ _ .. ,. . •.. `i. - -+ ... � - .. •rL': - .•ii.Kt Fi 7.• 'i'-.:fir;:;'=�^"i� , u tit .,iF. - i.Mfyyyi dIM+it •YLt P'l�,w..4!X})'xt�•'�•. «. � 01 .. i } Y k. is ri 7? tNlr. palph Ongle - August 2, '1983 t Drive 1430 South Bayshore ;.:.,. „ L�Iyn Turetta ' 1430 South Bayshore Drive Howard Bush 1430 South Bayshore Drive r. ar�d Mrs: PhI11i Gaiitz :. ; ': : -- ' : • . a. D . item. I will art of the -official record of this re that it is includad witti tom" other paperssubmitte� :. It is imp6'tant that" this ilst become a p- -' our being sure -£. uch a reciate y se call me very, tn, PP. lea estions, p htel i ,alf_Y u°have any:9uF at tha � - 51nc iy"yoursf ET '.COOPER:...: pF 11�1N iA•t i3FMCES ' l"' 1 —} E LAW 1gNFIT L Coo'ER r„ 3LCi•crt►m n� • ;'st ti �, k ` i •F! .y yea>d. % Erb tccs ' Bernard Kopel.,! 7ZZEa-,"` •{¢i ftil +'¢i Y a�w,•%. �. IC `'tx°�0.iAd! 5 5'•c" �. 'Qr .•e- ,3'#-` Es'xi! -u t r- s' d i,ei �t 1 {�i� of - � Y r -a ,p`r.�«;vy•'`aF� � tra s•:i.`-, ..'.,. - . _ f #�., .,., . ! E.. , _ ,., < .r _ - F % -; {}+ y'`=�,{�,�ts..:'h 41 �qP, («> .•r \ -i4 ' - F � , ! 1Y`�;�: c:w¢�•Y �z,t' St � t .. }. 'i9 ."a`.t $:t ;-€ fx°�'i � y 'a{;, a5 `fi '.}•�„',ii:..si + E e `�€ 1' '� _ � * � .r � � _ y ,.� i ,�• .t �, 't` 5, dry. �4�^! h z, S-�": ",i'.: a yd �, �j 'ai',� f- s ! it tt�p y,'` _L S#. a e- _ -r r,tVF�g�k�wa �U, ,,,y,yN+S'jVA �y�j�x py�, p it iiFY i++r LT^i�Nt V' ii•�,. ►1� Ind uwd W'C to p r. autho� �.Hy� {r ai 4t1y - ..: a $dPbWt who being by me firm du17 metoM. r upon oath, deposes and mays: ,+ That he is the o7�n�r, or the legal representative of the - l „a ri 'Wndrmibmitt,14 the actc... application for a public hear'ir4 as ai ed. hY Ordir=ce No.. S$71. of the Code of the City of Miarl�i, Florida _A e..a e'ect:rtg the real property located in the City of Miami as desc:ia.e3 and <, {. : ; listed on the pages attached to this affidavit and rude a part thereof. :' k ` 2. That all a:.•ners which he represents,. if any, have given the{ _ s full' and ccxrplete er:.= sion for him to act in their behalf 'for the e!�.a a and or. MA -di ication of a c7 a`si f ication or regulation of zoning as set out.in i i .. .. the acc0..•ra iyi.".a oeatition. 3. Tlt the ass attached hereto and made a par;`_ of this f _ aff idavi t cor m the • cu.- I names, r`ailirg add_r-es4es, phone =..be:-s a.,3 legal descriptions for the real property utdch he is the owner or legal. repr esentitive: y. 'The .facts as icepresented in the application and do �: vents 3 su...tte3 3n. con 'L�ction ch this affidavit -are: true � and .cor : rot. t } _ J _ . _ Fun- Cher AS fiant sayeth , not. 4 5P • 4 t w _ .,..... (Sr— L) {�� Svrom to and Subscribed before me of 1953.." ,�i• e*''j1?► Mf�r+/tr �W1/�! irb IF ion sMSAfr+ PY il'R X rSR T {RJC $ I A • P OFNNW ROM aMilRll I.`IM6tl ON W10 AU I by .. • - } _ " yp. _ y - 4Y1ik°ti ,`yam`'..". _ - ... _ < . .. - r:i"�Q•�-,rt —_ affidavit dated�903 NQvb�r � - _ - - 1! �'h '•::'S.�fA��,� yes - cr styli• t" �•,:':+' �sr i'' _ 4- `^. .Y" �`'� .�'3" '.dry+ ON ;A �yy� p flameCL1�iisa t Inc. c/o Ray` carona t President then`' G 4o Sunset Dri'�t� t Miami t Florida 33143 - ` 'It1phoneMu ber 56�&574 ''';' '` legal�sCription: l k 2 Point tiew Slat Bonk 2, Sots 4 and 5 t . B oc , ► , public Records of Dade County. r `.. Seaplace Realty investments, N.V. c/O Mr. A,, R. Scott - Own er t than 160'No. Biscayne Boulevard, 13th Floor# Miam i, .'rlorida ' 144ilin'g Ad TO tp' hOrte Number 371�-3593 Legal :,Descri,ptios:, ' Lots St 7, and 8t Block 2t Point View Plat Book, Page 93, public Records of Dade County , Owner Namot point View Towers of Curacao, Inc. c/o Mr. A. R. Slott % lob No.' Biscayne Boulevard, 13th Floor., Miami, Flox ida tiai 1 ins Address F •. =` Telephone Nunber 371-3592 • Legal Description: Lot 30 t less the East 5 feet thereof, .Block 2,. Point Viet,,, Plat Book i, Page 93, Public Records of Dade -County , `. Any other real estate propart• •rimed individually,-, jointly or severally (by corporation, partnership privately}' within.375' of" .the` subject } site is listed 'as follows: " ry >'<ia : Street Address _ Legal "Description _ `a _fw it�;'13 Ss'�et..ldress Legal Descr.iation .. }=E If -.�.e5CrA0�lf�.'< -4trnt Address " ' t: Via•^,+. 4 Ian _IL,_ �i� • • _ }{ a ' _ } ¢ • � 4+�4Y` � '♦sue ,f� - I �,s _ _ t '�;` fksu i-•! .'F --s .k �' s'�t -a r;d a.+,4e �%>R'A: °-�� ', i ' Fk, 'i�'�s"•',`* — UK t Legal description and street address of subject real property: ` tots 4t 5t 61 7t 8 and 30, Less the East 5 feet of ` public {30yr ,E:�1q.oL+k It point Vyie'wt Plat Book 2, Page 93, - rYtNl i�v Records of Dade County ^. i•r .sr Approximately 185 5. E. 14th Terrace and 200 S. 9. 14th St et. 2. ,er(s) of su;lt real proms...: and' percentage of ownership. `'"•"' Note: City of Miami Ordinance No. 9419 requires disclosure of all parties avinc� a financiaS- interest+ either direct or indirect+ in the suhjett 4 hatter of a presentation, request or petition to the City Commission. Aceordingl}•, question #2 requires disclosure of all shareholders of _ _ corporations, beneficiaries of trusts, and/or any other interested parties, together with their addresses and proportionate interest. As toLots6t�7 and 8: Seaplace Realty•Tnvesiments, N.V. 7 Mr. A. R. Scott and Mr. Richard West, Attorneys in Fact Agents As to Lnt 30: Point View Towers of Curacao+ Inc. Mr. A. R. Scott and Mr. Richard Westt Attorneys in Fact and Agents { • 3. Legal description and street address of any real property .(a) - =F owned by any party listed in answer to question2, and (b)`located within ;•.j A75,,: feet of -the subject real property. �• '' ' SEAPLACE _INVESTMENTS N.V. A YIN FACT �POINTVZES*T TOWE O CAO• C. ATTORNEY IN FACT _• - ` STATE OF MRIDA ) SS: =iCY OF DADE ) ' v. bea. a 1 ��ss• e�t�,, d orney in ac o eaplace #s f `e� p opeety ` { rpays at ne is a ,. , . described wwwei answer to 9uesticu1 R �, , •�bme; that he, has read the" foxegoa.�q t the :same nre txue and vc:rplete; and (if acts g as ,nxand thtorn��► for owner) that he has authority to execute this Disclosure of Owi_ner t p form on bal: Qf ; owner. ix eh g 10 p+NO�ry'wt• x before W4 this of p r _ r e R � s 3: _ MR. I �;» 1• i�;t i��$„l�f'F'�y 4gyi4� +4,#``: a'�ld'i�r'Wy,E�T a� vj, R, gi2e ? vp, 74* c�c 45Jrr U. Mj V :7- WE. 777777"'i Mum MMOR6 1_7 77 -7777 CITY OF MhAMI PLANNING MiNG LAW ^w OFFICES AUMIM UPOFF 'HOFFAAH, G AS+Kr.Wi GREENSiR6JRAURI OV • SRICKCLL. CONMURS •-9 A4:.;*lf' AVENUE A4Cjj,mVt1CKKLL ocA6 33131 Mj^Mj, rLOR ki (305) 579-0500 uOWAR6130b) 523-8111 Pt TcLitx ao-31P.4 v� + 78 TCLAccry (305) 579 JoVeMber: 1983 DF �T,tv!, . . . . . . . . .... 14s Betty- Malver A Perez-L'U90nes do f -;mikelib f City of miami.planning Zoning Boards Floor -2ipTt So_ jorida p U; 8 And dintView i As Lota B­2/93 Dear 'Betty o. on Of A Lng per OUt Of this Morn.' ID fo%Wr, re MU co al and Olile Py, 14, 1 1 this of icO d Of --uted by G t ioned 44 tt q 3: Vory truly YQU3;11� f 7 01 !Mj W Akk r STATE Or ± mDa w twiny OF efbY'e tom, the u°�.irz- t ' authority, this day pbrso y GARY M. #E D ,who being by rr first duly 9010 "•fl, u ` upon oath deposes and nays: �.' •` _.r ., t he 3s the o:met', or the legal representative the Of a. ligation for a public hem as 2 { pp O1dnaY`� sub.•,tti,.. she ar:clr...y a • ` ire a3.rer� by Ordinance No. js00 of the Code of the Gity of Miami, the Cit o£ thia i as desc: ibed ,d F' +�ffectiae5g the. Beal pro y Ideated an y :=,ri_ .. pea 1► r. ` made a part thereof iittted bh�the pages attached to this affidavit and — 2. That all moners which he represents,. if any, have given heir full and co.Tplete pe �sicn for rim to act in their behalf for the cha+^.ge f+` or modification of a classification or regulation of zenisg as set out In y -the acca., hying petition. - 3: That the pages attac. ed hereto and made a part of this 4 affidavit coldain the. cur e+�t nazis, rrai -Lng adda�-esses, phone a��ters &A Which he is the owner or legal legal descriptions for the real p.oYerty ;;•. representative. 4 4: ' The facts 'ss represented in the .application and doc=-er is , correct -1 suix�itted in con juric tion ;:zth this aff idcvit are true and,;. Pm Cher A.ffiant sFyeth not. _. Y GARY• M. HELD __gin Ded mom to tO and Sub�..ri: before me _w F thi. 8 day oP 19 ' �y* ' Q,' Stets of F20rida at iar$t� to n Ex X ccam 2l Q►dQ€it.Th1 ! ik4 JN$. 1�4+iK WRITM ;? s Y i o =-a. 113yrK -xi+ e.-: !m. -...ter.. ._ r--_l. ...:: - -_.-. -:;. - -'w• _t -___._ n..t._-u- E. ._ - _ _ 'W"O7 , ANIL r{dam x p��y���,yy��} y ppr� qqyy�� t}P�'lray ,; .7L,Lic41A�Egi nAL+i,-.1 o Roar B era � Addw��� 1401 Brickell Ave Numbs Fr Log Destri`ptibh. 6, 8; > o 2, POINT v >;w �� � y—t - POINT; V% TOWER Off' CU _ C NC �rnr` Ndfit4 , o e�. ' raurig R- Brickell Ave- 1401 Add s 579-D500- telephone `tJutni et�` -73 Block 2, tion: e al, Descrip_ Lot0, less the east 5 feet thereof, �' 9 POINT 'VIEW 12- 9 3 ) CUCUSA, INC. t Owner's Name c o o ert H. Traurig 1401 Brickell Ave. - . hailing Address tf 579-0500 , 'Telephone ijurober -r POINT VIEW i 2 - 9 3) k;,g De CH Pti or" Lbt .5 Block 2 r � fi ALLEN BLISS C/o Robert H . Traurig 1401 Brickell Ave. Lot 4 , Block 2, POINT VIEW (2-9 3) ,ilr y Qe jointly, or severall ''- .,tip owned individually, j ,;,;� Any other real esta*i property rivately) within 375' of the subject ,:.' partnership or p (by corroration, p - ' } site i s list ed as follows: Legal Description Street Address r 4.2 r . 1 Description on .. a -. Leoa s � Street Address } ` {i i.egaly Description 3. ty1 Address et t - - ?t'4 `_f•.-ari xi 'lei - t`•t4r.�yy1_',�y...?''_F: �_i'a''i�rv.J FL p y _ �{rt*f� - ` �#e+��' 3` a � ask' t # Y• 1 , � - �i} "4ia .yyT" �V w- __ S-�•i�Fa,id;s ..v£..-,•.. .,, .,. ,.s9 w -, ,:.. ,.. :. -,• ,- .,.1t k� .xr ,i' w e';s � _ � _. ____ ___-.- _ _- • yi. ii,r►r�iWi� � i Legal description and street address of subject real pr+opertyt Lots 40 So r 7 r 9 and 30 , less theEast 5' feet of Lot 30 _. block 2 r Point 'Wier PlatHooi� 2 r Page 93r public itet�ords • of bade County.' Approximately US 5. N. 14th l'`erraoee and 200 S. 2. 14th dtre+et. ! 2. Ownsr(s) of s lalatt real ,-16vy-`md- percentage of ownersthip. Motet City of Miami Ordinance No. 9419 requires disclosure of all parties suing a financial interest, either direct of indirect, in the subject matter of a p9resentation# request or petition to the City Commission. Accordirngly, question 42 requires disclosure of all shareholdbrs of corporations, betneficiaries of trustsr and/or any other interested parties, together with their addresses and proportionate interest. As to lots 4 WV L Ltr A) 3. Legal description and street address of any real property (a) owned by any party listed in answer to question #2, and (b}-located within 375 feet of the subject real property. :tom,==as`• t"r�'`'�', . `his - Of , ;•t,',. ..,ac� _ '.��� .* •S•"".,�u�'4tq+1+Si$lti�/�iY�:,`�%`f.�N'.�4!'tl��"�•'i�t'r•+�:iiM''�`.r..t�G�.� - .. • �,.. •. �'.'`� �: Via' �: ! t •a •r t•: ' �3�f�'.�Aa + •J -4 'Say it, _ ... •y ':.{,ara.x'��•• •�JM•. lid - �;. •�,°,,.,� �xi-_"-i'ki�ii •: t . •. �• r'^-:+;1 t. i>.i� �v F�{l�f;' ` `r �,. it '�' ?..'' ., ..:M• • +' .' - ;$;'r* 'iU7.i'.t. - _ �,�, L�»,1+:' .:.u'`,S' s '?,, +,}Y:•�.'i%t,•C»; - 7,,- y r _ ' .r...� + " 1� a:.rc.i'r:-'S�i.Sii•,nfEJa* -d ''. .f ,' .y,S.'i• a`XLf""�� 'i,�:i ..tyra q_. �-!.?s.te z - - -. .. .. 1��; ;.: .Y.••�+nri:'y i.. fF".Hi•'YyIA✓•sY'n ..5� CITY OF M! MI kk LAW OFf ICES /� �Ct( G,,,N�CftG,TMuRja, ASKrw,1- OFFMAN,.UP b F �i �iWENTEL, P. A. `83 DOT 13 P 1 �7 _ ANTHONY J. O'DONNELL, JR. LINdA KObbOteK AOLCR BRIAN K. COODKINO ROGER D. OSSURN LINDAEI O. ALBtRTINt MA*THtW S. bbpSON OYRON.0. PETERSEN AMb4tti M- MOSB, JR. CESAR L ALVARtt #ACLYIN N. GREENBERC VICTOR H. POLK. JR. ZACHARY H. WOLFF RUObLPH R. ARACON MApILYN' D. CRttNSLATT ALBERT D. OUENTEL plr COUNSEL RtUBIN O'b. ASKEW ROBERT L CROSSMAN RONALO b. RAVIKOFF JAMEB L. BACCMUS GARY,M. HELD �LOktNCE t' ROBBINS WiLAR1E BABE LAk144 �J. ""MAN NICHOLAS ROCKWELL bRICKELL CONCOURB NOAMAN J. BtNFORO ApMOLO M. JAVIPtt bAVtD L. ROBS MARK d. BLOOM ROBERT M. RUBENSTEIN 1401 bRICKELL AVENUt BURT BRUTON titTH P. J05EPH C01rFORD A. BCHULMAN MIAM1, FLORIbA 43131 +IOBERT N. BURLINGfiON MARTIN MO HY G K15H MARK SCHWIMMCR AIBEht a. CARUANA SttVEN J. KRAVITZ MARTIN B. SHAPIRO TELtPNONES ALAN R. CHASE STEVEN A. LANOY tUCENt SHY, JR. lsUE M. COBB MARLENE K. SILVERMAN MIAMI (Soo) a'r$"0500 KENDALL B• COFFEY STEVEN B. LAPIDUS TIMOTHY A. SMITH BROVVARo (305) 592,6111 _ MARK B. DAVIS ALAN S. LEDERMAN OARLENE STOSIK TELtX ,$O'+.ItilsS ALAN T, OIMOND WALLACE L. LEWIS, JR. HERBEtiT M. SUSKIN _ CHARLES -W. COOAR.7tY NORMAN O .LIP FF LILLIANA TORREH•BAYOUTH ttLCCOPV 13051(Sy$'0i19 pARV M. EPSTEtN ROBERT ti. TRAURtO MIIIITt11's blttltCT NO:. THOMAS K. EQUELS. CARL P. LOLOU141ET 'VOLANOA I, VILLAMIL AG RICHARD'C. CARRCTTUMirT • - + LAMIRENCt'TSOOO BKY OptOORYUA. MARTIN 8KY JONATHAN M. WARNER ALAN S. 660 . PEDRO A. MARTIN DAYID M. WELLS HARVEY A. GOLOMAN ALAN M. MITCHEL JULIE A. 5. WILLIAMSON STEVEN C. GOLDMAN LOUIS NOSTRO JERROLO A WISH $TEVEN M. GOLDSMITH October 13, 1983 lio E. Perez-Dugones =` Mr. Aure of Miami x Y Director, City - V l ' Planning & Zoning Boardszx Administrative Department 275 N. Second Street Florida 33133* Betty Atttion. - -� Lots 4 j, 5 F 6# 7, g and 30, Block 2, -, y Re point View Plat Book 2 at Rage 93 �r �) Bar bony, i V SSv Y. .j• yj�1�.Ci$.d,.. p�,ea - nd.. /a'� +�{e�YTd ^I/A� �QllM.kVS-q►,i�a�e �rMS�,1�'.a• rL Md to wIv '`' ,,$, !y ti4 Yx.w� t+' .der..• cl_ u'".,d M T M questions c®ncerninq 4ny, '®f'1�►6� �i�� � ou' h �. ; iiieas n t hesitate to, call. Ask- 16 tAqcwjj description We atteet address of subject real PtOP6-ttYl #,as the Bast S, feet of Lot 30# 4 7 p 8 and 30 # lie, R66 ' cords t Views plat Nook 2, Page V3# Pub- .1911ack 2t point D e and of Dade.CoUnt'Y', Approximately 185 9 14th '"""a 200:S,,2, 14th,Street. r(s) of suwjgtt real ptop.;.ari -percentage of ovonerahip.' Owne es disclosure of all Parties ce No. 9419 requires City of Miami Ordinan ct in the subject either direct Or indirect, Wtvn 0 the City commistion. g a financial interest matter of a presentation, request or petition to Accordingly, question #2 requires disclosure of all shareholders Of cotporationst beneficiaries of t=Stsr and/or any other interested partieat together with their addresses and proportionate interest. As to . lots 4 & 5: (sole shareholder, Ray Corona, President). Cuousir Inc.1 (see disclosure of ownership showing Allen Bliss as owner of Lot 4) ipt real property (a) and street address of an, 3. Legal descr ion to question #2f and (b): located within owned by any party listed in answer 37-5 feet of the subject real property. None STATE OF, FL MA SS: 0: -AMA Ray Ccfronr- , President WO-IZI-Ii I%4A# 6 Xt" rig ft 'Raw 01 Cog Y, 4 U I U, -:STAU,-W fit i4i W, U 4*4 VA 1 r , r Sal STM Or PWAM -:f M. or ) nr }V a�. Coronai being duly rn, deposes t — �u ua Inc .� ri a +esorf Si n answer t13 mast d ► emotes the comer of the, >i t�Y that he etas he foregoing answersread t; thAt the same are tree and ��tn� :. p1et� >n1 thath+e h�ls auth+ity t® eeta� this tiisi+�suref bilft ' ►3 'f� a halfOf tM Ow* Naft before this JO.: +�a of.. 983 . NO - IA, ; �� ' • • No tart' Publ c�0�_t ate of Florida at Large • _ '+r a �vass MIRES � NOTAkV PUBLIC STATE OF hORIDA MY COMMISSION EXPIRES MC 23 1986 ' &ON= THW GENERAL INSURANCE UND Y : iy�p,.r,� . w. • " "! ,+ 7c -ter., a �-t s �, egir�"ie'^F• •. ° ', . •. .� ....�. ,:,yv y '� .;a _� 'x# �i.a�`i++8,.tg - ' �) t "gA- _ r : •.a , . ,+. -w.s _^.yr 'i' rr�."'3 �{yam; _ t "�• .r ,,,, ..a ,rep, atr°, �. 4 +' �i.��C���� 5:�• tS {� a 5 _ �.,3,i x�.i i"'S A'-', � `E .i H IH 3 -, � k At _ � •�y"' _ i P� 1 ��I' r ' I � I A. '�+£aV" _ k Y �,.t&g&ldescription Wd street addtess of subject real pro tty3 Lots 4► 5r r 7# (A and 300 less the East 5 feet of trot0# dock, paint View, plat gook 3+ page 93► +iltslic i eoordn of 13ado County reiti�natiy ;155 S. g. 14th Irerrace and 300 S. E. 14th Street Dears o€ all parties - r ,� No. 5419 requires disclosure p ._ rnetts) of Ordinance real 'pros d` ercen�a a of ownermhip. 2bt ity of M �t►i a� rg a f financial interest, either " direct or indirect, in the subject matter of a presentation, 'request or petition to the City Commission. Acco'rdingll�, gbestion 12 requires disclosure of all shatsholders of corporations, beneficiaries of trusts and/or any other interested pa>�ties, Nether with their addresses and proportionate interest. As to Lots 6, 7 hnd 8: Seaplace Realty Investments, N.V. .able oWnership - Manuel Etter R. Grafenmatt 3706 f Aeschi► Switzerland As to Lot 30: Poinnu ie Towerter of Curacao, Inc.* Sole Ownership Grafenmatt 3706 Aeschi, Switzerland 3. Legal description and street address of any real property (a)- owned by any party listed in answer to question 42►'arxi (b)located within 375-feet,of the subject real property. _ - SEAPLACE REALTY INVESTMENTS N.V. oe A RNEY IN FACT s POINTVIEW TOWERS OF CURACAO•� INC. s A Y IN FACT ss• STATE OF l'LpRIDA ) COtTiv'1'X OF DARE ) k in fact, a. C. west , being duly sworn, demises and sa at n+ ss _ e (Grewwr) (Attorney or Ov►•ner) of the zeal pzogerty, �1 •that he has read the vreg n �. described in answer to gjes ion � .above, ,r#aMrexs and that the same are true and =Plete; and (if acting. is = z ex N for owner) that he has authority to execate this Disclosure of. p� • fo on behalf of the owner. r , {mat POW 70 f octoimr s 3 E [> C a _ z .i iF3epM _ �� JJ 3 FS•',, '"�, .h.._- �3 _-$ Y � �},-. •� : �a i -- 'fir,"' �;, M,s•- .s.3 at .i,. :i,,.aa`s;.e:+,�5,«a•e �,.lsto-'; '. -........... t- ■ -- KWI V sat • am 0 being duly SA#b 1 da 3sss a } b' �, $+5 " , 5 tt1 F btu y appointed ttn� c�3 ntv��t .' �s ' a to i�: y '�`t_ desc the t�1)�'Iit 6 the" r6a 1rroing bea n answer to quaitron � _ that be has rem the 6r�angwets; that the sauna arp true and ���h� : 74 has the auth�rit Plata, And that he y to execute this Disclosure of at ahi► on behalf of the owner. 'w +� (SEW bafc�"."tom this - as o i t�b�r , . �, ,, , ..1 e I Notary PUb11C, St- a a of •,,, ., _ " Florida at Large . '►►�1 , .,, , -_ r�C CO�"�SISSIOt� MIRES tw�AI, PUSUC STME OFF AEC 198 ,. MY C011•N►1SSION E1�'1 t RONDw. "U GENERAL INS. UNDERWRITERS : " • - . i' ,.- k '%# t - Y at. .fib iq.T }r'•x C. -�w - _ -' " .1 ���" - --- ::.p ��a. ��-yr.�e j•`��r "-rq ;`cam-,'•s 5' FAf't'."3•.yn.�1� - sg ` �.k, '- .., .. . _ ,. , .. .. .. '-,1. g�:' :.i`9 .. ' ,'i9;. �.�.•}:7�''^�a-„' :.':;'a'<.Y.�:.:.4 "�4a;.-, z tee w -! 4 ;{-� ;f t' ?'`.;:=^;k •'�+n�„ tl'�''sR-,+�vi� .ras 4� t �t1 - ., r t . - �.•,•w •wsw�•••'•s y, i - •` '$ ''.t .mi l.,§_. > -- - .. r Wg #ice-iC• : F' -+.>M/>+, z , _. i I•. ,..-. ,._. �1-SMxj-'i ,`TgS'R"M" ._j{,� ..6 Ff l,%w. ,� 4• - - � } J ..- ,J. � } v 5 _ .+. .,.. '•{ � { } f . 4,X- +Yw4O°Y 3°'. `vM�, r '",fit' _ - .. ' .. �- J 4 1 . - �• ' - , x�," `a[,:rk 9n'�k 1 1 C,�f iur`a• TNf a _. � � ..- .Y r : . - � , - �, y�ly.y-57yr� P F,t I{" - f 4 - - _ _ _ • - - - r'P S � x - 7 - ,) 'G� 1. 'a� i� � �' �^� J - k 1 'i }"'Z�Zx,' jldfi,•' '��q•€,',`� �' , r. ,� n .,�,y. - - - , , �' � X f btu+�i{''�.,j .�. _ •z3� - �`- t i Y r.. i- ,ate, �t _-- ,�+4.d,.a "A Aovroximately,185 SE,14 Terrace and Ap SE 14 rett Lots 4, Sj 6, 7, 8'atid 30 legs the E 51 of -Lot 10 ko6k 2 POINTNtEW (243): -Change otIoning Classification from R-5 (high Density Multiple) to R-CB (Residential -Office) -and- Annrokimately 185 SE 14 Terrace And Ap proxim te,ly 00 SE 14,gEfget Lott,4, 5,*6, 7, 8 and 30 less the D 51 of Lot 30. Block 2' POINT VIEW (2-93) th 1983,,a new Zoning Ordinance (Ordinance No. .9500) will take this -application for a change of zoning district ''classification under the new Ordinance shall be as follows: :."Change of Zoning Classification from RG-3/7 (Residential General) to SPIN-5 (3rickell-Miami River Residential -Office District).' ..'Secretaryfiled proof of publication of Legal Notice of Hearing and administered oath to all persons testifying at this meeting. PROPONENTS: 2 OPPONENTS:, 20 Ms. 'Baro:' Okay. Mr. Whipple, we're ready or you--. Mr. Whipple: Thank- YOUL Madam Chairman.- -The s. Planning-Departmentrecommends approvalof the majority.--._,pf the 1,,request.'befbre you this evening and- I note-- in; our: written_'_ recommendation that we did-leaveoneof the :lots out Al so:j .the main'. objective, perhaps wecould-.have the map, just _for: a,,, moment: iv.�.v_ t :it es tdy.the� is that we. concur.'-wi--th the' change, of zoning a L- relat that does not f ront on the -water,, 'that� -is., priindrily-!. property�t 1ot-4.,,­, We suggest:to-you:that lot 4 -not- be:,included� in the ch --,- 6,.. 7 and 8 and out request t f or a., ange of zoning but lots. 5 of our written recommendation we forgot lot 30 should be...we., , recommend"chatiging that to Residential -Office: The,basic', or is; �as I started to elude ta, is that'the.4,, �5 '6 n reaso in& f or 5, 6, 7 and 8 face directly onto R-CB zoning lying in,propert which is on, the. other side oUl4th:�Street and ,,to he", south -on 14th Terrace, there,:Aot, tho,piiki structure for the_ residential development that occurs -on 0= tn the f of the lots 30,, 3l.;--31' 32`. and 33,�.�, , is a reasonable request based upon certain suggestions that the;,,A_1' a �plicant'�` has;'ma to the­dtsqu ions,� p de,,,*in relation S�s th&V1,thi(- -',-jig` thittvb Department has had on numerous acc'a�ipns-,. with` themi r. th4,t th0tm'aintaini of, the structure on, lot 'aS-_wtijipfi, J` " ref e erred 'to as the 'A tiered . apart ent-,--stracture. that" KaoneV-er_-"beeni,­oc U an buf ferA) itV?eL retaited''as, sort of,'' additional a en,.,th6� -4ovol-,opmon wh ich we ext ect", �to occur to :,tho,, n6t--thwost,�. at, othe: �southea lthit�� 6 at uto:-Vnly :three -or, -four-estoft hi 4hd, iwith votwt -to t provt4ing residenti;U1,; dove lbpmefit, -At� X i. 4;6'aad bo dairy type, buf for_ Ao.f -the-two 'Us,# h4t;,�*4xii V e �'A _Pr Oommended, _P Q x4opt" Lot _Y .......... a Ms. baro Mr. Campbell, t believe you have Y. ibmething here Campbell. Oh, yes. At the risk of sounding Mr. CamWhipple and t do, Mr. dike we don't talk to each other, which we opinions on this and I would like to put fort have differing those o ini.ons, not just opinions but based on a technical basis p )tight now, we have an 1g"-�-where am 1-�-intercepter, Bayshore Drive which heavily flows main sanitary main in South northward and on up around the curve and then on up to the north. change in At the present time, with the, particularly with the been wrought under the R-CB and under the $PI�5, that has - we're concerned about the loading on that sewer. It's pretty redevelop- close to ,its upper ,limits now. Concerted development or detrimental effect on it and it • ment of'the area could have a n the - gays here.it might have a detrimental effect particularly on which survived i' } downstream trunk mains which are to the north there, the SPI district. If this is considered i the initial impact of a trend spreading south along Bayshore, now that's along the in as - curve, it will have an overloading effect on the interceptor from the stand- - Bayshore, definitely. We are looking at that the traffic. When you have the R-5 district, you Y point also of have a given amount of traffic, residents, service vehicles, etc. ..I-5 'you the for intensive office_ When with the SP y have potential which increases the traffic load significantly in development there or it can increase it significantly. Now, we're concerned erworked that this then becomes a domino effect to use a muche = southward along Bayshore Drive. recently - cliche proceeding rebuilt that street but we rebuilt it to allow for the present development along .day.and projected traffic for the residential know, we put in landscaping, there's, sidewall�s there. As you are in, drainage curb and gutters, the whole thing but mainly, of the we tried to keep the quality of that street reflective the west. We feel that if this trend con - - residential area to residential then we're gonna end up with a traffic situation in and it might be necessary , there which will be totally untenable and not only try to redo those sewers which area to go -back real pain in that area because of the proximity to the bay, -.but then to go back 'in and make some' we ma have (word unintelligible) adjustments to that street which we don't want to do. We don tr", and have want'to have to go back in on a fairly new street possibly it, adjust the grade or whatever to accommodate the addi- to widen tional traffic that would be generated by a continued office this development,in the area. So our opinion is negative on parts in zoning in there. t "cular 'request for, -the change x; Ms. Baro: Thank you,,George. Okay, we're read y for you Mr. Traurig. G Thank you. is it possible to put Mr. Traurig:z projector). the ,light back on the exhibit•(overhead Ms. Fox: Briefly, it' s starting to overheat ,a Mr. Traurig: Well if it' $ going to overk�e,at'. theh V i dog' t .inked it . That's okay. just,cal Your, anent . the alumination but ytau��.1" , ,rk to `u.a.y : o Gloria can turn off the lots that we're talking about, the ones t�tat �Va�� npz °that ye1.,�w, arethe only undeveloped lots in the;; area beoa_109 you along Bayshore: Pic. va w s e ou $win to the south w as y� 11 notice etc., that demonstrates that the weae yQu.s,e,the.51215 a ail s� a Qra w� thih that building and all those ark bui�dipig Bella Rella� sQ�hi�, and tea � � � r �� the y axaund ai d then you see andthe East Drickvil owes and so fo► th, 49 that $ Campbell talcs about the prol_tferatio.n, for men tip t ilC ai eut beeam r B the Catalyst• 4 ,r . _ men( hleh would have an adverse atf get 41014 v .. h lnQres the fact., t yshpre ;�cl , hat.Q ay. nth E fy July go } 0 �-i` n'i�`"�X� 11 fully developed and so this can't have that kind of effects , t Now, let one show you the neighborhood that, in which we OPerate. Vir6t of all, tod like to introduce myself, my name is 1"elit H. 'Traurig. t1to an attorney with offices at 1401 Brickell Mr. Gort:toy, you didn't want to let that..6ne Mr. Traurig: And the property which we're talking about is this property on SE 14 Street. Everything you're looking at here is in the,,old R-CB district and it's now the SPI-5 dis- trict._ ' Unfortunately$ since this is July and we'll be talking about,'& new, notoenclator because we won't be talking about R-CB anymore.. and we won't be talking about this being R-5 since -.4 those designations have changed and that's now RG-1/7 but for the purpose.of easy identification, I may sometimes refer to, R-5,and sometimes to R-CB because you've heard those designations so, -often but at any'rate, this area from 14th Street northward;to the river, from the bay all the way to the centerline of Miami Avenue is a district which is called SPI-5 and it was formerly. R�CB and everything to the south of here on a line that extends from where my arm is here, is also in the R-CB district, goes from Brickell all the way to the Point View curve. As a matter of fact, ct, only' that small area on the curve at Bayshore Drive is in the-,-R-5, district, the old R-5 district, the new RG-3/7. What we are.asking you to consider, and we did ask you to consider.the same thing several months ago and you asked us to go back and to work with.,staff).to talk to neighbors and we've done both, although L.see a lot;of neighbors who are here and obviously we couldn!t sPAAk,'_to,'alLof_the.m but we thought we were getting,the word -out. What weh.ave..tried to do is to demonstrate.how reasonable ,'this tequest:,is in relationship to the -total district.- I:think,,it..ts i.mportant. though$,fiot only to recognize that ,this 'property orj;,,,, 14th Street -.is the only property on that street that isn'-t zoned . -5 up.to'the.curve but..also to recognize that most of the prpperties,.tha.t,, are involved here are ,not -only :along.a-,street which. has. as, its basic, characteristic ; .this . SPI-5.,,Iright across.,_-. t -he:street from ,SPI-5,,backs.up to SPI-5 and;is.totally 'Within the­.,inf.1ueAqe,,of the SPI-5 district - When we,went-to_-the-,.Planning Pppartment:to discuss this, several things emerged. The issue was not just what is the zoning but how do we maintain the basic character of the neighborhood. : There. was .,,a very_ quick recognftiqp, that,.the properties that are the furthest west are in fact,' totally surrounded by the R-CB, the SPI-5 district but the two buildings that are to the exi'sting_condpminiumsare ,the, buildings - critical. . because these wh �dings that,,are the most live here are concerned,,about retaining the basic character- istics of the neighborhood. The distinction between what we're n aski & and what they have is that we can have residential Just the way they have residential but in addition, our districtperm' its offices. Sp.- these three lots that .were on the western end.,, ,,are s t 46ii 19gic,ally-the SPI-5-lots. Then 'this builai' V buildIri poses a, unique problem* because it's a: r :iuctli4z 'fi'' p.t already., there and then Mr. Bliss's OropeTty.aid,Aq,.7,BXJs ie which., s ore is.a parcel that es,be t ilie 'CoMod ,between .the y bu _ ixig, and, the existing condominiums, and,. who o, ,;Ne, 6those hann-ing-DOPAr4ment 4a f,:, iitld in �s went -to - the .01 it, i _has, rejected test e, market wtth-thi t, qq4,40t_i 'g -`� We h the s condo tii 'r do�mipium,. and.thoomarket' g.��"Oht�s '40d ve,.w6uld,like',to. pke the bui,14in X on qh.,14.th�, �tr at ana.:' 4 not tbe�Poipt View- curve, A Savejou,gn,qgreement not,;o the-0.1- artmce-in order to build, 4, 019,b4t,14 r*i4 q . ,,- t , J ci�olhati6;4ider"ti#1 that9p, wiff41044IAX "Z ems, wee o d d..to Mit tt rt 1Wt -,otwtura 41 we `WL opfloor and the 'the three rel*idtntial wits` on the 4 _0 JA ;,wt 'A' ­ o� § building will be, could be used for offices if we desire," In } the recommendation that you have received, makes reference to that. I think that because the recommendation is so clear, I ought not be addressing it, I ought to be addressing only the things that Mr. Campbell talked about but i think Mr. Campbell's arguments, they come from the Public Works Department not the Planting Department, are so easily refuted. He's talking about ouryir imposing sing a very great burden upon the infrastructure of the our ip area. When you look at this Helmsley project and a you look at all these new projects within this SPI-5 district � P J And you compare these very small lots and this building won't be any different whether it's residential or a combination of residential and office, not any different whatsoever; as a matter of fact, the office use, insofar as water and sewer consumption: -Sc is concerned, creates less of a demand on the City and we will f' create very, very little demand with regard to the traffic flows within this area. So for the Public Works Department to suggest, number one that we will create a very substantial demand And two that it will result in a proliferation of uses, I think is wrong. We urge you to consider favorably the recommendations 4 of staff with regard to all of the lots to the west of the Commodore. Mr. Bliss is here to -speak, himself, on the Commodore. I specifically represent the Babylon. We think that the action that we requests is consistent with action which you took immediately to the south of the units that we're asking you'to rezone because'on the curve immediately to the south you rezoned that property, recently, to the R-CB district and we are in direct line with that. We don't think that the living environ- a menu on South Bayshore-Drive will be disturbed at all. We think R that=South Bayshore Drive has a basic character that has to be protected,•but that it will be protected by this very ggradual transitional zoning where you go from their residential gradually by :.having our building, meaning the Babylon building, in a joint use,° a mixed -use and then.to the office use immediately to the west of -that. You will be keeping faith wi.th the people who live within this basically residential district., I'd like'the oppor- tunity to speak to you again after others have had the opportunity to discuss the application but basically we concur with the recommendations of your staff and urge your approval of this-. application. • Ms. Baro':, Thank you, Mr. Traurig. Anyone else to speak in favor? 4 Mr. Bliss: My name is Alan Bliss. `I'm repro- A senting the Commodore's property that I own. I reside'at that'' address, 1402 SE Bayshore Drive. Ms. Baro: All right. Mr. Bliss; I have tried.to-preserve"a• beautiful old building, the Commodore's rowing and sailing club that lass .original7.ytig a one -family home. It's again being used as a one, -family home. I'm staying there myself, more or less to protect the'propert . 1-'don't have a lot of --these little photographs show the ciub,y � the area around it. I feel, like on the Commodore's and perhaps-, the Babylon, is being given to get the other area and I think the Commodore's privately owned piece of land has got a right: to et- its hi hest and best use as well as an other ' rp ert " within $ ' p' reason: I have been Crying• to- sell the property And=have= ��uhd� -t3, the same as the Baby l on found, Chat Nobody is buying lxaiintil. there's foreclosure but there's no bu inQ l h111�� 'to>�e �` u ` with, an idea that I'm trying to promote to keep the Commol+ V, a `a: restaurant. I have several. restauranteurs :intorested properrty qnd no one has been willing to iaci,I d esi.dential b+eh .n } its l was �oi.ng to build reeidential small residantt* �-,A Uh nd it, They .are saying though that if we ee ld,het ,duly 11, 1483, ItOs14 *:1 i4. .777 behind there because of the difference in the value of office pace, right now, in the next two or three years evidently, it's t`ogg ttto be that way, they can see a way where a small office Ilding d6uld be built behind the club that way it would ptd- :' 96rve the club. The club is set well back. You've got green 'in.-frbnt of it, You've got A good view. If it is knocked ,down because we can't do anything else.and a developer comes In':, f they will'obvi6ugly move*as far forward as they can move to put the residential building up. For one thing, the place to the south of us, Brickell Towers, what used to be Point View North, is.13 stories high, covers most of the 300' depth and really to consider us a buffer with a half an acre for a huge property like that is just, is just not proper. We certainly aren't going to affect their rights to air and sunlight and V wind and everything else and they have been close to us with 6 `big parking lot at the back and all. Another thing that was brought up was the fact that ,we're on the water. If you can gee the property, we face the, corner of Mr. Helmsley's property. We've got a little bit of water in there and that wouldn't be there if myself and some of the people from Point View North hadn't fought the City when they tried to fill this whole area in and take part of the bay out. So from the time I had the property in 1971, 1 have shownj not as a developer but as to try to preserve and keep that area as nice. a's*� it cojild be -arid a half an acre of land is not going ta build -an office building or residential either that is going to affect the property but residential would be so small it wouldn't be room for the amenities of the swimming pool's and things that are needed in a.nice property and in the winter time with the sun moving further -south, the Commodores is shaded by'the building .to thesouthso we have that if we think of residential,: -With - office it wouldn't make any difference. Further to the West, where they1w6re-speaking, is over an acre in -the next arcel "beyond the'BAbylon. The back of the Babylon is only 351-from my--boundairy'line, and the Babylon through the variances they 'gotThe buildings -is Ab6tit-12 to 151feet away from my building. .are that close together. To make us, keep us residential with th6.officd 12'or 15 feet on one side, when you got on the south :fside'--a buffer of 100"parking lot from Point View North or `Brickell Bay which well separates the two properties'but ,if -you d6'building to the'west and you combine some of those pibceg-df property, you're not going to have us as a buffer but you're -really'gonna end up is, we'll be in a vice, we've got Point,,' View 'to the south of us and'we'll have a huge high-rise to the north, I ­ 'mean 'to' 'the west.'and across -the street,, we 11 have the, 500'. 00 square an "feet or let me see, 500,000 sqare feet -of apartmentv:i_ d 100,000 square feet of offices that's going to be built-6h-,'thi-s `areaa-across-from us diagonally. -if there" s I'd like to speak. later,`` zx - *iythin& 'too Mso Baro: Thank you, Mr. Bliss. Anyone ei'Ue?, Anyonee-else in,�favor? All right, *we'll now go to the bpObsition Right:,- come right up, sir. Mr. Korach: May I use the other one because 06uld like to referlto... (inaudible) ;Ms* Baros. Surely, Mr'.*at y Korach: My name is, Irvin; Korachi­ '1430'South Bayshore in the apartment Unown As r0iint"' View l-'iohih-�. c,"-*-.'-,'�i.1 '�-�,'�.-'Vit',I .you're probably all familiar with. I would liye'tq :take 4i" 'Ciou to-'' . .. .... .. -of "minutes to go back-guite-some number of yea�*- end %,#h,*tV' 0 1960 the f f ovo toped theres', Our building was built in, We've seen 'v o6r,up4n6y'in:1961. We' it brow and'we're', ery,- prou tha t, whole Some years ago, this name 4 ores ton, today', to 'Pder��­`dis�.,uss -ay was requested -or.4xx off a arid: at thattime4 the people from our area inct dtps4 July, It,, 191131 Tzemw"W of the later apartments came downy we opposed it and we showed fi';traffic study that had been made showing what would 'happen to that little area if offices were there. We realize there were already offices on South 13ayshore to the north but the traffic Was being divertedgenerallytoBiscayne, I mean to Brickell,oift'. 14th,Street. At that-times,the Zoning Board refused to grant the J requests, Now,.shovtly thereafter, I believe Mr. Whipple presented - to you-or-theiboard that was then in session a plan for this - whole Brickell-area going from the river actually to the 15th.P.Oad, Am I dorreetj Mr. Whipple? Mr. Whipple: Yes) SiT6 -Mr.,Xorach. This was carefully studied by I think everybody in the area and it was a very complete study and if .I could have this on for a: moment. Ms. 'Baro: Okay, Gloria. George, okay, You'll., have to speak into the mike, sir. 51 Mr. Korach: Oh, okay. Mr. Campbell: I'll point out*the property -for you.. Mr. Korach: All right. If I'm not mistaken,*. the Brickell properties were then zoned for business,or offices and a certain amount of space, I think it was approximately 200 feet to the east behind.,ifor instance the alley which is between 14th Terrace and15th°Road. (George Campbell pointed out the property on : the,overhead transparency) No the one further'to-the west and then threel,or four -.lots to the east of that and those were specifically designated to allow any large office buildings to build parking, multi -story -parking which was done. Forte Plaza did that,-- And ' everything then to -the east was to be residential.' J believe we,all..,concurred, it 'Made senise to us All. Also, atthesame time, we-were:presented,-you see the dotted line 'that, starts in -the,' corner.of,14th-Street and comes down and the*n is,.intersectedby another-line-m-that's it, no, no; out in -the water,, 'out fn-the`water.,� yes=-that.we:,werb-given to understand, the City of Miami-vequested that this would all be bulkheaded. It comes approximately three feet beyond' -the eastern point. We have to give up- riparian -:rights to",the -City vhich-we- all agreed to. We all thought at time and - _I have no objection to what Mr. Bliss, 'said, but it; thattime.,. it those e S' corners there was-a-tremendous,lot of-id-bri ' coming I from the bay which'would-just gather:there; the odors were terrible Thq#11they. went, ahead and: made Bayshore:as you see=. it: today-, :'and,�- -was thav not, done Now, we're not complainin& what -was '=dond-.T think: in'- Miami today, it's probably the, :longest : stretch' ',where�,_ anybody .can drive, directly on the bays: see :the water, �'see ;thd.,., islands_ .behind. I. haven't seen :any other thdt,_is, "that - ',-i.There" "'AA i$$Ome,in the. Shores and maybe down in -South, But W-re very. -proud of it; it 1s turned- -out very,, ;.very ;goo&t ­Ijow,, we -.feel that the property in,question,,, 4 -14ti,111"letid, itself,-,to;!residential ',,property- *Directly behind or. whdre, is....t W�`Cf! EAST "BRICKELL"TOWER SOB; Tract A- that is, show, no -dovin, hire, o 15th, Road es - ndw there is -a very' beautiful 27 4tbry,'b4iT14f, that,-,.,,- is:.;being, built.- I think it was originally--. 26,;­, tboy-"14OU 4 f floor. That i on the 'water, and one_ more' s not �X, xpensive rtments'. So I.* think,the 'argument,­ofi-,the fa! V the ��Trvpdrty is 'on, 14th Street,1 that', othei a sort v'f nois' V 10 � I Ulot that', somebody, would spend this- kind :' f m oney�- ; for4i 1- XbiOU a nk 1. more less gave th. n, brought before me or p I haveythoush Just --­0*0e"­1n- town but I've a s: 1-; 84 id IV Tivodry thoio Y a very: much interested in all that.' ''I AV 0 oacu -brought up Wo re, is good in many,Many, tareloii `Fwt POPOV'# "as `'� -0 JU 4 � ?t have it in ours now and to suddenly ;h 5:� Opp, it`' V WO bi 4 4etriaiint ,Thank you. Jul,o 1943,1: ulI y i a C rf Ms. taro! Thank you, sir. Anyone else? ,Ms. Ryder: Thank you. My name is Jean Ryder and I live at 1408.South Bayshore Drive and I'd like to appeal to you f to not change this neighborhood to a partial office space area. It is not geared for that this little half --moon section of Brickell, of. Bayshore, pardon me, is a beautiful residential area and itr doesn't lend itself ,to offices. It has no services for offices - and'I would submit that there's plenty of office space downtown. rY I!d like you to.keep it the way it is. t-have.,to believe ghat Mr. Campbell's protecting about y;t' sewerage -.and traffic problems aszopposed to what Mr. Traurig is:suggesting as an interested -party. l:urthermore, I really don't, again quote Mrs Traurig, I really don't think that you can..test the market_., the realty market, with a building like the Babylon. I think you're testing what people consider a livable building. It { is unfortunate end.I'm sure they, both the builders and the lenders, are suffering financially from what they put up "there. : One more.comment. I don't think that a buffer residential office.and.building in the area is going to protect us at all. I think it's going to be more of a matter of infiltrating the area and I. hope it :won't happeli.. Ms. Baro: Thank you, Ms. Ryder. Anyone else? Yes, -sir. Mr.. Galitz: Hello, my name is'Earl Galitz.- I live'.at 1430-South Bayshore Drive. I'm very much opposed to the opposed rezonings.a'nd I'd like to point out to the Board that $ay.shore Drive between,14th Street and 15th Terrace is now completely;residential. The area is"a relatively isolated, { quiet.neig'hborhood,...pleasant to live in, people now come to . fish and to,shrimp-in the_City's.new esplanade,. The -area is:,accessed - only by.15th Road and 14th Street,'both two-lane. The Bayshore DAVe : in that area is two -Zane. It's not going to go a"� "-here, except into the bay. I doubt it could handle any more traffic; than -it :;has now. I doubt that the people who now live.in.'that small area;woud appreciate seeing more traffic than'Bayshore`now carries. Mr. Traurig,has brought his:Iovely picture which is._.. taken .,from 'the' south and faces north; however, the affected"people," - who . I , see ',in about three or four rows here, all seem to , live 'in Te tt e, area that. is .shown south: of the, most southerly ; effected 1qt that r,i i ,.the; ' Commodore : Clufb and I'm sure that if we ::were to ::have :w :.photo'; of the area, view 'from the north, , we would get a'. different . intpressl.on . of the nature: of, the neighborhood, granted' e'veryth*ng,. nQrth::of ,14th, Street is 'now . primarily commercial ."or of f Lcd but HI'that;' i.s.;the area.that-=here comes another picture perhaps =but:that is,' thank you, but' that is, an. area that, .from .which the' traffic . row' dr"sins ..out onto' Biscayne from' I4th Street and not .down .:aToing k ��4 B�iyehoxe"to 15th .Road. _. i think that .people came . here- 4nd ,�te7,T us ; they yappreciate the , benef its w.of ,residential.. zdning, = we k cad . "p .res env- a zoning. I m sorry.: that_ 1f Mr, 131 ss .h utzeuble , } �.�,rthe�e ,difficult times_ getting what he Cotisidors veryz Best, ,use of his property, that : he' remember , tfiat' t erq ` art , hy-, tither pe©ple that do not eti"thL1t1'1.'W r hest u0pry;" ►adol .artens o.f their property and I eat ie _needsllust ih this- neighborhood. i.$ .a restaux'ai�t on. that .F'QFex'ty* Th►e s }.: 49es__n9t have the parking and a estaii*t w4641+ on 'r^i, r#40e, the txaf f io Qn..Sputh Bayshore , aad it wou14 es' ' i 111► `in Y,. the .late ;_Might. traffic -and. 1 would fOrthox' not c+ 'that all " 6���;,�rt 3 W&hbors or l: l.�agl.ne, 99%' of -them than 'hsve Cod ,Cede ` 's thel.t h$pcs ip ©pposition to the motion ..tq:.I,ter oing -in'this urea .'sl. i1e Co thank ou vex me = for oM roil$ eiatiQ}l, y y ,• .... , .. {, '.& 1 z • „ ., t j .Ma*QCpppQ :M ! hi �Nf/�ny.Q - lE..e��/;Q p Y.. It hand" R .. %��u� �M+1k r,i �ly'��q Rf $! 11l�J' f It r. #, Miti U r �t l j► U, l983 Its �� holi #. Doi id �•.`�` �i4T�'rtf snnr 9. - .. . R `•� t:: � - _'�b4. Y `t•}y0 ..'.yam_-',",,`�, ..Sr:1;„v:t:,n;vi},r. - ' Mr. Traurig: Thank you, Mt. Galitz asked that you -have the opportunity to see the neighborhood frost a different vantage point. z Mr. Dort- There you go. ' Mr. Traurig: Here's an aerial photograph looking east and you can very easily distinguish the entire Point 'View "area which is this area westward on South Bayshote Drive and 'you can see that there are two different areas here. This is an aid photograph. I'm sure that those of you who are -very familiar 'with the church will recognize that there hasn't been any devel :. opment that surrounds the church so you can date this photograph frotrn the day that the Palace began. r; Prior to the change in designations; this Rr-5 neigh- borhood was•.l'imited just to this what I think someone'called a crescent.' It -was a neighborhood dominated exclusively used for high=rise residential buildings and it swings around south- ward to 15th Road and the property which was recently mentioned. by Mr. Korach as East Brickell 'lower and the property that others` have talked'about which are on 15th and therefore utilized to . demonstrate that residential ought to be built on 14th are really within a neighborhood which is totally residential and the difference between what we are asking you to consider and what , exists on the south side, that is 15th.Road, is 15th Road is a a residential street exclusively, whereas 14th Street,' if you *will recall from looking at this photograph, is a totally office building street. Now the objective when the City zoned the R-5 which is now the RG-3/7 is that properties facing the bay which have an easterly bayward orientation should be residential to take advantage of that•bay view and I think that that was sound 'and Ithink that it ought to remain and I don't think that any one ought to disturb it,but we face north on 14th Street and we face the existing SPI-5 and there is a planning axiom" and, that is like should face like. We are not only facing SPI-5 but we're backing up `to SPI•-5 and•we're asking you to recognize that that's 1 a realistic zoning for our property because of the proximity of similarly zoned properties to ours. Now, is SPh-5 going-to=have a •great '"adverse effect upon this neighborhood. These ar4"small. hots'. They can't build very, much on ' these individual lots' hilt ''the' issue "is wihat 'should. they be permitted to build. Should the 'properties that are totally surrounded by�properti'es zoned''for • offides* have residential on them or should they, have the sai'67 r} kind'of„zoning which'exist around them: The Planning,. Department suggests- you that it should b`e similar to the; zoning twat presently exists and if SPI-5 exists-, I want you= to -'know •tha't'� "it IS, . :,. , got to go"through the Urban Development Review Board -'and `itn tlatti3 '' G . ,. ordinance° there is a mandatory amenity tequirement • and: "the bpi^ld ngs 'have 'to ° 'be `oriented in order to ' avoi'd` shadows' -and" i,t`` woulii:'' be,; :. Nery interestin Ito see- what do we' back'u to.` 'The`se­ are -big ` P. garages,^not big parking garages, but they'"re multideck'' `aces '' parking 's p ,` p o' theif­ =.b ion so that we're not backing u t th ir` res we're'bac%ing up to their parking gaxages. Now what''h y hav ,. b� '°asked that' `we 'do, that is the Planning Depar men` li sa'>s `property not be; changed' but that the other. pxoprt,iA ' =-4s g e i. brig buildingV and`,somet,.,k changed but" in de re s that this ex s ... :...-' ._ t e people think it's terrife: anc # people loin, t' likeit! and 'some t 3et1i Dungy opp wrote an article for the Herald- 'aay, rig=F we, � i "htb ' ► ' 9tetaih it because its got special. charaete istics ; and° it I ue,= `�ie're wi l 1. i.ng to, keep it , At f irs t ' we= came' to yc�u h ' Now' everybody want ui CQ° keel. {` Th'�� IIII U i fix sAre .11. tear' it` -down, , <�x „ Depertment- JTn part'icul.ar.: Ile said 1,Okay,� wee li' Q`apt �.�� '=fi.�7��� . z� {y1 _f gip, TAT • •, iI1 lam`,- "`...t. `.: �',t`,: • - h, `not :gfling.,'to' enlarge the property; we're not going to uee -the.. property for uses that are detrimental to the nei. hborho6d just put offices can the ground floor And the real ent.ia i.t the uFPerlddr Ia thi s a precedent for further rQni r�'.. P d 3 .. Obviously not because on that c ascent on thatSoh =SK£ : q.. =: Drive � t 6jre is, no . room for ex0ana�o�t e'er got gyring t hsv upon "the fttu deveiopmeat of that area; it is already.full,y 4 1 df ZoningSpar3 s kl t do think that Ms. Ryder, and Maybe t misunderstood, t think she was talking about the reason that these units didn't sell is that they're unliveable. tf t heard her right, if she means that, then obviously she would concur that pethsps if we retained the building, we ought to change the use of the building so that the building would be used for offices that we h6ve 'rem ` queated. Basically then, Vm saying to you that this is an office-_ neighborhood. You have the opportunityy to transition. You hav'o th-e opportunity to regone properties.that back up to R=CB`in the ' sane, or back --up to SPI-5, with the same classification and not only back up to it but they face it. Then you have the oppor- tunity to transition with the Babylon. by having the existing building retained with a slight change in use and an increase in landscaping and;so forth and then you have to deal with the problem that Mr. Bliss described. We urge you to at least support the Planning D6parttent's recommendations which are reasonable recom- mendations and give protection to this neighborhood. Thank you. Ms. Baro: Thank you, Mr. Traurig. Okay, we're now ready for questions... Mr. Bliss: May I have a few more minutes? May I return also? Ms. Baro: Yeah, just a second. What do you mean? What do you mean; Willie? Did you ask a question? Mr. Gort: No. Ms. Baro:: Would someone ask Mr. Bliss a question? Mr. Moran--Ribeaux: Yes,I will. Go right ahead, sir. Ms. Baro: All right, Mr. Bliss. Mr-. Bliss: One thing t would want to say, when Mr. Traurig was"representing my property, he'thought'it should go` - y the`'ame as the others. He's changed now. I have to, represent my own property but it is a 1916 mansion: It's the=last tine that's left there. My idea is to try to preserve that mansion: °= It"Ican go residential and it can go just as high and cause` us as; much sewer problems as , residential as it could if it was offices behind it.Br 'The,intent of the City, according'to'the"liokell Bay -,,the Brickell-book that was -put out and all I heard was they :k are trying:to'make the City not all residential in one area and a4ll Are- 9- offices in another but a mix and match and use the whole area on< a 24 hour period. Certainly a restaurant in the area is going'to kelp make it a more useful and a safer place at night, I should think, s being used than it would be the 'way -it is now. On that half acre,, you could have the same amount of residential as you could office.����� Brickel�l Bay to the south right _now has no guest ",park -4g - If i.t K was ;an,'offi.ce building there, it"could be very easilyahe~xe the t r.' guest parking might be allowed on the weekends for the people or , maybe in the evenings because theestauxant is tpt a big"aui.di�ng� it can't take care of that many people . 'At 'the lunctiti me 'when it , was `running, most of the people walked down from the office Wil.di�� and that's really all l got. That expl.anade that,$ out there; p p Miami. y The''restaurant for g... {r chance the.people that use it, toalsosit, l.00kdat�tl�et�8m eat the same as the people on the residential. high rise$ ire =dolor to�the south. Thank you. Ms. Baro, 'Thank you, si.r. Qkay, °aro h`re : t now' to ecloso the public hearing � Morn- RibP,4UX . Id Ukv ''to 4W you A M , F a 1 I as l.itti bit eonfused:. You need '4' oee 'he `viieaq �` = h ► ' � µ , s , ,a k.. not? ..> taurant or p+�rato the res 4. . pee=buotes: No, he has a restaurant already. i ', Mr hnon-•bonf ortnit1g use at the as nt a reaeit time whichs the �estaura ,<r ; Do you have I have a cuestibn. Mr. Cort:_ :specific clad of"�►y`ot� say you wero going to add some office in back of it, do you have any specific plans? t have had two or three 'Peo At. U119`9: one of them have talked they hgVen+t Made 'plans up Yet: Each o _._ about 50,000 square feet or even less of office space and 1 had considered" �knbbk�-ng the last 20' off the back the club that _ cons .. was 'put btt lifter the club was originally .bu Mr. $liss,•would you get neater'tb Ms. faro: sometimes. the milker l thi%tk that we have a little difffculty Mr,Bliss,.I'm sorry, yes. Excuse me. Is it _ on now? ,Ms. Baro. Yes. I have talked to, untold number of Mr. .Bliss: the poperty Baas in developers, because for one thing becauseI+ve agreed to ears. It is going to be, - iitigatio► fo"r so many Y So now I can still.deal and try a foreclesure''as of January. and put an office building up., k to keep the Club, the building, - otherwise,. I have , to sell to whoever will buy and wha�eVso'=fern, re ,r. gonna db and anybody residential, everyotb moveaalother``50' ,the buiidin has got to go, we're going oYa"ser to' the st reet or whatever they're allowed to go. because it .yfi Poi .gives them. a little bit more of a view where the ked ttheepeoplehin. =r1 on the south blocks quite -a bit of it and I ve to .: s -say it's possible that they could putts sThelrestaurteurs, of f ice y if someone would be willing to run a restauran `T find' more of 'them. The are definitely interested in a reS- 'rgnt.bud:they want to lease and.there'isnThe taxes were$29 000 .tau s their ",Lease .tb--take- care`of. that pr.operty:. 50. we can't hurt any.. Malone ` last year and it' s a half an° acre`.ut er it's residential, -or office but we can aPnthebthanthe „t body wheth so`We're`net really doing r - same number •of ,either upwill n= , i" + tr' 'in to" save :` the building, if -: ,I can, le'.I An thingtelse? vJbe,.. T m y g the City Commission• and you -.peop y _, : � . 4= decided by- LR. Thank you : Mr. Gort d: An other question? ?y ` Ms."Baro Y One` thin I'd like to show. you► {1'hot _tr .'Bliss: f them si wn there • :f £°. ari o were e'„ � a it was before y- rr . That's the w Thatxety, Those rlp;nie, arc. s�This���.�_ let's have some discus.o the same , 'There, 'Mr, Dort. ; There the satneNA'`+n ti Ms . Baro°} 3 h` why they: e}F to F iw4 #pi G iMt j J One is under the old c��ciinene t� f , Dort n+�, is in the new o�o� paneei. the other. a.� { '., �; � pia �,�'f#e'!'1g''! YOU; -'�?,� y N KOM# T . ' Why 4on' t w� 0��as :�, j ���� it' 4k F t Mr. Gott: I don't have any problem with this. The biggest problem that the neighbors have and I don't blame them, would'be the traffic going.into'a residential area, into the circle. t've been there myself many times and I love that area ..and I.have friends of mine that live in one of the buildipgs right :here.which I visit quite often but I will have to agree with Mr. Traurig.• You'.ve got the 14th Street, you also have Bayshgre. tf I ,,was to cone in the building, right on 14th Street, t' ll 96, bgt:k the same'way or take tayshore Drive, t would not go'all the way around the, circle so the traffic doesn't bother me. I don't think the,traffic will be problem in that area and like I said before, the mixed use of the residential and the office building, t find that to be a very reasonable use. Ms. �asila: Well I disagree with Mr. Traurig, myself. tt's my opinion that property shouldn't be touched at all. I think it should remain residential. I think there is sufficient.office space in the surrounding areas to accommodate the mixed use that we're talking about. I am in favor of mixed use but I really think that that should remain just as it is. That's my opinion. Ms. Baro: • All right. Anyone else? Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: Don't look at me now! Ms. Baro: Anyone else have an opinion? Mr. Romero?' Why do we have any doubts or we want to go ahead with. the motion?. Mr. Moran-•Ribeaux: I have some mixed feelings in.,this case.,'Originally, I was totally opposed to this project. Yester- day, I.see staff recommendation that it should be changed -and', this is what,really through me off. Ms. Baro: Except for,lot 4. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: Which is the one that if everyone .,wants,.:changed, I would actually request that to be changed because to preserve that I think it's worth it`:but I am totally, ,. ;.confused -with the staff recommendation because this was changed .` from'ihe original recommendation. Mr. Whipple? Ms. Baro: Because of'the fact that lot is still on the water and the others face 14th Street. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: No, no,. On• the original recommendati"ot1 when this came'up when we had a full Board, I remember this particuhar: case, I remember ail of the neighbors coming in and the recommendatoor;; at that, point was... Ms. Baxo; The whole` tract. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux; . O . that to retrain it resi+dentiat,. -' Ms;. Baro;- DO you w#pt to anything?: Mr.. Whipple, where are you? Cah yQu 'exlxe}'..`` t - - .- • , 4. - R , Mr.., Moran-Ribeaux: The change., Ms, 88rQ, ,,.reaso.ngQr tiz.s. oho+. (J- k lJR Mr. Moran_Ribe,aux; g+icause now you pt" gas 411'�p� Mere. i Mr, ri:H Whipple: Well, nitttber one.'' yea, r=en,w_t a ws Chang d._ It was Changed p0r�s0a13t' t9 ..fl .study,: f 'the . r e ty a ie e1 r .:_ f MOPS 49k k, V 4 is R _ there's a democratic process. 'There ere three people involved i`1d the directoY has three votes so planning Department... of diseussion-e-the reeommendationi Now there was quite abit recogniing:the principles of axioms, as Mr. Traurig referred - to them tonight, and some basic principles of toning we recon- was a interest in sidered on that baais and there particular ` hat might encourage the -preservation of trying to do something tharsh encroach the club building and yet still not have an undo or the office development toward the point View j merit for theme -from area and we felt with the special relationship with maintenance of this would _ # - the club and the physical being of the Babylon that the residential and then from that point it _ -_ lessen the impact upon a matter of'deciding that the office development to that point the was - would be all rights I was not directly involved in many of on this but several other staff conversations that did take place was a conclusion. members were and this Mr. Traurig: May I supplement Mr., Whipple's remarks? Mr. Gort: Yes, sir. Mr. Traurig: The declaration or restrictions that "unless approval of other action have been offered to the City say, is granted by the City of Miami Commission as a result of public is the Babylon, f J- hearing, the building presently existing," this be preserved and shall not "on the above described property, shall be modified except that is necessary structurally buildingnwithaaly and externally to convert said structure 11 and residential use. It was never a question, - combination -of office anning Director, to really, a strong *question on the part of the PI about the the use. He was concerned about scale; he was concerned of -the building -that could be built under the new SPI-5 F magnitude ordinance but when we offered to keep the building in its present meanly to upgrade the building`° - form and.to create the -mixed use and more compatible with the basic neighborhood, then _ so that it would the Planning 'Director felt that since it was on loth Street and not the street' water oriented and since it was contiguous and across that are presentin oatibleuwithse rthenneigh- from other properties lecom developed into offices, that it would p "restrictive covenants boyhood. So we `presented the declaration of that we would -keep the building in its current in' --order to confirm i condition, upgraded but current physical status. Ms. Baro: Okay, does that help you, Mr. Moran? . 5i Mr: Moran-Ribeaux: Yes. Ms. Baro :• Mr. Whipple, 'did you have..'. °` ; _ May I just add another comment, Mr. Whipple: suggest to be made here. As I indicated, 'we were interestedin preserving the older building and to encourage its preservation. As fir. Trauri& indicated, we have. a commercial use that ortunities � non -conforming status at this point. There's also opp w. � �{�a should they `be• sloughed out and agreed` with and I`' m not:'' sere the q they've agreeable or that the owners agreeable with how, with respect.to historical conservation, there are -some benefitst*:bdh character=, so :r - achieved and `some alternative usage of the property if V sA ma.n r , ta3:ined ar�de restored tl. . all. ` ism lost.,with re' pect to excluding this property.- 'There are at:hex' perhaps not the greatest alternatives that ota alternatives, p" might visuaiize if were to storm in there"with an SPI-S but there are ample opportunities that we thiare ffliobldl: � v property owner for the historical conservation,tFz, Don4 t sit: down# tone' asisx`' yQ_ v i r. Cort e, uaati+�n- whi.i.a you're there - and correct me if I'm wrong and this change that much but my understanding is that pertaf p��� fas ion , rl t now ax'e'.. ustai.ned ;Is"Yo h�vetm+� ►^ ledia�ta:'4 of the total space you ran you r�} { ul f° ;'i '. 1 Ai get at oecupational license within an apartment, am l eorrect? Mr. Whipple: That's referred to as home occupa-,::,. -- Yes, sir. Mr. Oort: night. Okay, thank you, air.- -= Ms. Baro: What does that --yes? Mr. Moran, will you ask her : a - question please? Mr.. Moran-Ribeaux: Yes, ma'am, - tp :Mai Ryder: Thank you very much., t was worideritig, ,if ' it, was out of order for me to speak again, Please,.-" you:-cats.argue'just .as well to the point that the Babylon is, off. ° .Y'ou, can gust as easily say 'it's. on the water. It is on the curve,. Yes,.you.are going to.have,to make modi- fications in that building to use it as an office, as a resi- dentialbuilding to use it. For heaven sakes, please make the "* modifications and use it as a residential. building. Thank you. Okay, Oka any other comment Ms . Baro : Y Okay, Y before we --we're ready? ' Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: Yes, sir?_ € Mr. Bliss: I'd like to bring just,. -one. question up and that . is the ,SPC--S or whatever ,it is •called, ' is` cet.tainly = not going to go tearing through and damage, we're gonna use a half an acre .of :-land. If it does damage, it'_s gonna ,be, when .,yq4, _- get down .where:, you got an acre or two acres or three acres combined. Then the SPC is going where you can go 10 times as much when ; you got an acre., as you can with,.a half ' an ,acre. that'-s ,,,where y g Y. , . ,. . you!re.going;to have the, -huge buildings and we've already got;them. (Discussion among Board - portion. inaudible) ' .Mr.. Gort: Home occupations in .resid6 if al'. Ms. Basila: That's permitted in,.any,residential: You :use-.25% of your.,home:.for office -,.can Ms. Baro:. Like real estate .office.' We Rio-_ ar` ... that . all :.the : time Basila: That's right. . 1� f m I :didn: t.'.unclerstand-.what ­the _$ar Quay, ';oh,; l Mr.' '_Mor'an, ;you need-.a�.ittle 'time? Mr..Moran -Ribeaux: Yes, l,et .me have a': sacond haxe,;p see Ms. Baro: Don't :you; want to ,haxamit.wi`�s�.,is Mr..Moran--Ribeau4x: I, can' C,,tal,k. to staff . �iY <t4l �y� :� v�r -A... .Q 4 �` ta, .3 -.�, ,. ', •,' .: * .'faro: � .. '. "- ::«xk�¢�•i''<�i `.u:' :,a„T- Ti�^.�a,`"st '�"t'�'a'�. xH < �w��?'fi', No, a lik o to li toO, to :then. . Qh, Glor*A, ; -:YQu. -ash; h t a J 404 ni Y.'T - _ } M1r .- ., ,. � .. ` .. t .. -"t ? . ... � L. " i U r fi__. > . -i 4 n.. a,.,i��^'t i } ` .�, � •�Y,p' r4= ,� :;;y,';a;i CiC.u. $wren Were , you. 'gworp :1x1�'a;v���'� �Pber .,raw . hither �yo.; wok a '.-Qno ;,.+_;ers..t H ys��n". Jatand up 43tha ti.m� when they were an .,if y►. �'�.- %:fs �rF _.- ,i \_ :,z�- 1`._' - -- _.� .t ;'Y;.: - �j.; •�, �-�e,_�:-i'�."'��-fit _- � � ��`•7.t:`:hy i�';. �'a i.. _ - _ _ _ - V J'sl.r z-e5....� ..N•.:. :eis. 'ft - • ' '-��- .t.w f - W N -!e, w. JiK ri - t>. Ms. Sato: All right. Mr. mrshbetg► My name is M. A. Hershbergt t live -` 'At1430 South Uygh6rd Drive. I was not sworn in. Ms. urm Okay, one question. That's what = '` 1 thought. (Secretary administered oath to Mr. Hershberg) : 4 1 �e Mr. Hershberg., I believe at the time when the plans were made to:eonvert South Ba ahore Drive into the status` of which it is now, that the plans were held up for a long time,' because we`°couldnt get permission and the owners of the property in question, they wouldn't give us permission unless we agreed that they'be allowed to build on that small piece of 'property' °the building that they have present. Isn't that correct, Mr: CampbellT Do you know that to be correct? Mr.� Campbell: You're talking about the Babylon? -Mr. Hershberg: I'm talking about the-Babylon.'�They ; wouldn't see the bulkhead rights at the time. -. Mr: 'Campbell: As I remember, the' Babylon did not `have rights to- the bulkhead at all. The... Mr., Hershberg: Does the Commodore have the rights? Mr. Campbell: I don't remember the exact dimension -.but myrecollection. Mr. Hershberg: You were the last one to see the -EVE bulkhead right, if I remember right. This -is not a new problem.. This problem came up in 1970, it's been coming up ever'siince'atrd ` =} our South- Bayshare Drive, which is the showplace of Miami, . we _ =, F- want it to be residential and we were promised it would be resi u' i g,ty, dential and at`°that time, i't was'"decided that busiiiess'iiiui'ldinas were 'not 'toy be built' mote than 300 feet from Brickell Avenue. I _don't know why (a) hardship ,cas.e should be allowed to convert this building 'in order .to make a business proposition` out `of pit': _ .. Ve :do= riot' have'= the same paring =facilities that we had at that time. They're much:worse. In those days, in 1970 ,when one devVloper; wanted to build­on� the -spot where 'the Babylon' now` stands• 'there was a lot of commotion, a lot of adverse publicity about it -and the developer withdrew the petition. ' Since that tune' _ sn�'; ``'`' �,; developer who has,' asked, about 'it, found out that there s a':411�C of ._ idvets`e, publicity about it. Today, there's much more traffic because of the .fact that you have three more ¢large .b ilpdings:.= that;:_`.,Et PY`. P r.< have been ;built'=and which' occu the`'total s act, on South � „ Seyshore Drive:. Mr. Taurig, who Iadmire `very much who oocupies 8n`office� on' 14-th,Street, ever time i-' ass his office I have walk out into the rosdwa bec u p ,> wa o y a se cars have to park .x the:'drlve- 8 There s: ab"solutel 'inp'sn=::,._; rvm_ way to his' off�,ce on the street; ' y _' another car to come in there. You haven't --if you-_ havean.;,'y';`=. ts}g office building in the Babylon, doctors, lawyers,don't fee heir patients iimmediately;= they're ;go. ng`:to beparked ewere...t�er�`, Tie r ' Qin to' rked on ''the tree t Parking in back of our house is- absolute c e F . y ot., M A+ida} 7Yf ',,'.,$:. ;; Tf• :ranges f - om vert cbl parking to horizontal park i$ e + yTM }` space is used up. We ask you to- do what _ the other ZQniz-xg 30 Ay nave done 'ihT the past, refuse this' a 'ppl-1cati.`ont, his . B ro : nk Th yoU a ', .six, ' - we're read now. Did you went to, share with us what,y6u' Mr. Moran-Ribeaux; No, h9 Madam � i �� smoke my, you- knoWi put any h '` cai bt b�caus ► _ . . -k ^ Mean I h +� go.five timos on the o ni ht ff ' a777 pt , tteih oros j ,,I 40 - i. P,?.ra:a�f.e '�i � a y kK ',�" e✓ , eta t" .sf ��,.'Hr" F�'�x:x ,i�Ft�u. -u •Si _ .+-4{;.r-6f:F .. t'.,�'..ai-..t A shouldou know i staywhat it is tight nowx, residential area and I happen •.`,'j ege, eope have the right, itts a beautiful, t ha�Peal to, share that with Basila and isorry, Traurigresidents tolike you a lot but i really think it should stay Ate we teady for a Motion then? s M tato • _ M' , Moran i�ibeaux: 1 make it a motion. `'rfk M9 • 'taro Are we ready for a motions Trauri Could you ask me one last question first` Mr . g _- ibeaux: Yes I will, sir. I withdraw the motion. Mr. Moran R opportunity u6t ^r.. T 6urig: That ' gives: me an °�k about their call your attention to the fact that when you.talk ,f residential. tteighborhood, you're talking about a distinct resi orhood that's well defined by this semicircle and we're dential neighb it comes up to it*doesn t come up to our property) artof this. We are in here and we on 14th Street, we are not a p tf`what you want to do is Pinstheethat neighborhood which ishexclusively' concur with,you,but we are i R-CB or SPi-5 and 'so if you illtbntheapr dominant and neighborhoodsingularneighborhood where of and if you want to use, then you ought to rezone this property make sure that ,South Bayshore Drhat's not involvedonthey curve of of offices, the only structure that's I'm not asking you to South Bayshore is Mr. Bliss's• Bliss and approve everything deny that portion relating to Mr. everything else fronts "callingto Your attention s R-eIse but I CB/SPI-5. 14th Street":and;everything on 14th tree Thank you. Thank YOU. Okay, we are now ready Ms: Baro: _ -4 far `that emotion. Moran-Ribeaux: I guess the City Commission will. Mr. have the 'last word on this. = "' Well, a motion to recommend to the - — j= Ms ' Barb . • na Remember it's City Commissio , a zoning change. Y _ •,.: - • Mora_ n-Ribeaux: No,. I didn't make that motion. t� 4 AMr • Ms . Baro No I'm saying when we move," we4A ommendin to our-`Cit y for rec g =la don't move for `approval, we move r a; f; th s'. w j Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: think it should stay I.still t that it stays resi-- .; a1 "and'' I' d i ike to make 'a motion r...'.,. residenti d 1 denlikes to tial if back it up- : ' t �.: r ,$omeboy That you recommend that it not 1S . Baro . A proved t Oran, And that hiss. P r Mr. which beautiful., think i t s4puld. s Cay the way it i s ' R }}�'�• All,, rigtlt �,nyl�ody sse#snd thai� .4� - ..� : 1't b .., (�j$".L. Barlt� • - i S. .J:,V second. that. 1. fi $asil.a: - MY 531. 'K MS • �7i.i 1M J. . atdr seconded - t r - d that3 Ms.- Basil.a: '3.1 seco# We're ready Mr. Forego . . a P71 Eat made y j y`il t �d'FSF, y.tt. . n.,.._.t^: eF:} k $.,aktµ_µ 4•^x, a� Y `_ t ma'. Basila . tilt call roll o t the motioft, tegiie AYES Bar t ' M . t3 and. . Moran=Ribeaux Mea�r�. fort and Romero { t�AYSS # - ASSENT; None: Mr. Pere �-Lugones: Motion to recommend denial fails, _ E It fails. It needs four votes, -therefore it is g� if it wereAL . eniel hl tyway = q4' h because we only have five peile• - . M Barb: Yeah; r • need motion on five just to"Aeep 1 , ",Mr:}:Perez"Lugones. I a jti on,,th ••il Mr. Romero, Ms . Baro : why don't you move. Mr. Romero- moves to recommend approval. Mr. Perez-Lugones: He moves to recommend approval. Mr..Moran-Ribeaux: No, it's failed.' It's failed. Mm'. perez�Lugones: No, no, no,. I'm talking about item number 5 which is the next over. Ohl I'm sorry. Ms. Baro: I recommend the same thing. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: No, --.:• Oh I see Did-iyou F _ Ms . Barb . , ,item 5? } �y t metiot? Did you.' come up` an° u with` thg _ . It needs -four -votes, "is what ° itY�ieeds - Ms. Basile~ . that o6rrt? f,r; c You need four votes. - =� Mr. Perez-Lugones : _ Will you explain that to the au,di-wide. Ms. Basila: Fk t a denial . Its automatically on item 5 now:Mr. Gort: a'<. a . , , � ... -Yes � but we're _ Ms,. Baro • So it's Mr. . Moran - which elated to 4 • on item 5 now is r item &w again an--Ribeaux• Right. 3 Ms. Basila, do you second y�e,• ? - 'i.' R,n•, - ° • t ( .' fie' i -y .,y `r 'S., 1-+` we •Ms'. B$sil$ Sure`.°- -: d . b$ �s.a ,. All right, seoondey � 1 _ rls . Baro: OtiBs • We have a: motiQ�n'.::'; k.� The motion Ita2';._ ..'F... . denial to the y , -fit C mmission. can thy' - , ..:' � •,. 1 11 cal ..tn� b Ms, Basil a. -and seconded y pXBS; Ms. Baro and Basila } Messrs. Moran•-Ri.beaux — r i ort and Romero '��1YBS* Messrs. r ,BBN Norte. ^N 'a Motion t000� zY� h 't _�`'` sip:iohe that m } i t 'kst.?+"yy� ^u`(`','^,y t ` ,�+�. •y'f54'-�4�.'S.:,��n+€'�.. Ms. taro: With two people voting O'do way, you can't get four, Mr. Perry never showed up, Mai Basila: I wish he would explain that to the audience4 I want them to know. Mr. Perez-tugotes: Gloria, do you want explained to ' the public ,that the motion failed, therefore, the recommendation stands ' f and that .is lthe way it is going to get to the City comm, i-Stioti. "Mai, ' Bato'. In other words, we teed four votes. The motioh.!Aieeda,we need four votes to approve or deny a motion, To approve--'a'motion, 'I'm saying and therefore,' with a 3 to 2 vote even if it, is -in favor, in other words, -a 3. to. 2 vote is not valid if we need four votes toapprove a motion. We don't have four votes right now so thereforel'it is automatically a denial. You know what I'm saying. Even though three people voted in favor of denying it, we need four. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: It's technically denied. Ms. Baro: We don't have —we can't use a 3 to 2 vote, it's got to be a four. One vote for a.4.to 2 Vote. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: Yeah, but it's technically denied. But it's denied. ,--Mr. Perez--Lugones: it is technically denied. s,_0 "Bar'o s Itl denied. Yes. ;:Mr'&-,Perez-Lugones: A-meafilii is not denied in the sense that it is going to.die-.here. Nothing .dies here because it .needs an ordinance and.ohl can an y­ -the, City Commission ca ordinance so the recommendation that the Zoning Board makes in the 'zoning cases is to thelkCity,-Commissionand,this recommendation is for denial a because of,the'technicality of the vote, didn't have the majority* It's neither approval nor denial. Mr. Moran-Ribeaux: But it's a technical denial. Mr. Perez-Lugones: It's a technical denial Ms. Basila: Now remember it does go to, the.Ci Commission so look out for your... Mr. Perez-Lugones: The decision is for the City C' in all cases. Ms. Basila: ***notices. Ms. Baro: It,comes up again before,thel Y, Ci Commission so that if you want to be heard, you better be there- 4­ nmM nr met 14.8.3 A I 7 Ai . 4.ur4b`mtt+�i-R+�tSB`x f 13 iJ ON 'CtIN(1DNIAL TO '�Nt'�'�C - COMMISSION, op .;A CHANGE OFZONING CLASSIPI OA'TICiN 'PROM R�5 (NIGH DENSITY MOLTIPLE) _.. TO iOD (RESIDENTIAL-OT'FICE)F18 THE SE 14 P� -:.�. ER'TY, LOCATED , 'AT APPROXIMATELY TERRACE, AND.- APPROXIMATELY �200 SE � 4�STRE�T ALSt� 1�EECRI ED AS LOTS 4, 5 , 6, 7 ► AND LESS, THE 85-' of LOT 30, LOCK 2, POINT -93) . RESOLUTION .TO RECOMMEND -DENIAL TO THE CITY COMMISSION OF A CHANGE OF ZONING CLASSIF.I- AL`RESIDENTIAL`TO va CATION, FROM -RG-3/7 GENER SP.I-5„-BRICKELL-MIAMI�rRIVER DZONING-ATLAS r i-OFTICE,ADISTRICT .IN THE OFFIC IAL OF ZONING ORDINANCE 9500 FOR THE PROPERTY:,.:. LOCATED AT APPROXIMATELY 185 SE 14"TERRACE AND APPROXIMATELY . 200. SE: 14 STREET, ALSO ry ='t -"' DESCRIBED AS LOTS 4, 5,, 6. 7, 8 AND 30 0 BLOCK 2; . POINT Mess .the:: E5.,''(..OF LOT 3 _. VIEW (2-93) ti! Y. J 4•3 w F J ki c 4 x31�z5t. .. 4 A roxittatel. 15B 14 Terraces„ A o ox matel` 2 0 ss 4 Bt t Lots 4, 6 t ', 3 and 30 less the f #Aoki. 30 4 alto - ko .` . Chatiige "cf honing Classification in the dfficial honing ,t .ss Of Genet Zoning UE Hance l to �500 fridential7officeabistrictnoraa lesser.$ Brickell-MiAti River Res . Classification. is referred to the Zoning Board for further study and This item was E n 03-1173, adopted by the City commission on „r F report by Motio fi"ecember 1 , 083. This case will be'considered at the City commission meeting of January 28, 1084 after 5:00 ptn. (Ord 5500, gection �513). Secretary filed proof of publication of Legal Noticeof thithis hearing and administered oath to all personstiyi meeting. " Cit • r Ms. Basila: What is it that the y Commission expects us to do tonight, just listen? Mr. Perez-Lugones: Just listen and if you have parties involved that you anything that --after listening to the w can recommend.to them... Ms • Basila• What.you're saying is the vote has already been taken, is that correct.? =w taken. Mr. Perez-Lugones: The vote has already been ;V2( ii What are we here for? -Mr. Gort: r -.Ms. Basila Well,�see that confuses me a little bit" as td 'why 'it's -,really ' back before -'this Board: • =s the Zonin. Board has' xr Mr. •Peve z-Lugones :. -The vote by g Teen 'taken b'tit the Commission•hasn't taken final action on thus •I =` and what you're doing --what you're going to do is just to y„ contribute 'your input towards•• that final- action 'this. time=ras your �- { view'=rather than a formal resolution by this Board wh.ch already r. r itzy, exists. sorxy Mr Gort:' T m :. r, M'. Ms, Baro: Okay, let's go with it. { � .. it's Monday And s kind { hard for 'one to.., : ter. here-Lugones; l' 11 refer_ this tq oar attQrn� y� far � r ;.. - M Maer: To clarity this, when,,. s J3 rr MX art: 1 �� to het i.0004. ak r ai .. Ave our,Tt ' t in her hinl�. eve e t y hmreta in• fr + nc to " 40'ry�s+��+r 't2eo `us expr ►8ed ° ho1W Wed - felt about #�j�p Q. 'rtg SorosWont. to ►r , yrti FCC Y #- Tr - -"x,�• Uzg — . 74 Sys YP _Afs�r�W.EK?`t"-�z1 i�,'.�iYfni4rykf 4i+... � - f - - - _ : ♦ $ Nfs. Maer What the Commission has done is � they have referred it back to the 20ning 80ard for further study ande�ort. the way that t see itr the honing guard has already noted on the formal Wiication; at this point in timer the r of ietg Board may listen to the presentation and the doffoonta by the.ge arttnent and rake WhatoVer ooMents or reaction the hoard } would like to make. it's not a rehearing of the original application in that the Board has already taken formal notion on that application. ''.: Mr. fort: 'You're telling me that the formal ; r, { action that Was taken by this soars can not be rescinded or a changed or... r Ms. Meer a Well it could be changed if that were the shard's v�ishes. I believe when the Commission sent it back here it was for further comment by the Board as opposed to the Commission rejecting your decision for some insufficiency and tellihq lou that you had to rehear the matter on the original s application. Mr. sort: Okay, thank you. Ms. Baro: Does that mean that we don't hear any comments from the public, we just listen to 'staff? — No,' no ! I' m sorry if I gave that ivis . areally ,the, .if anything, the opposite. The impression. Itsr- Commission has decided that they would like additional input and reaction on this item... _ Ms. Baru: All right. ' ...for that reason sent it. to the 'Maer : zoning*Board for additional study and comments. _ Ms. Baro: So we really listen to it'all over (again... Ms. Maer: Yes, ma' am. Ms. Baru: ...in the hopes that new ideas or new information comes -forth and we may have additional,. 'something,, additional statements to the City Commission? > _ Ms . _ Maer If this Board has such, yes, that's +� true. Ms. Baro: So it desires,,yes, all right We re readyl- question, this nation '+can.'`'`` Mr.- Gort : 'One last } _ only b taken' by` command or order of the City commission? j Mr. Perez—Lugones: Yes. C,ort:Okay. Oka we re ready i:. is Viet' in,::rv. Baro Y• ,: ao be" 'Mr. Wtiip,�le? fir. PP e or N mdhai:4 Whi,p: lei Piranning Vepartimeht. it att �r c�u ie o ,66iments which perhaps �ilii bring: _ 2 `.JanUOVY aK ro':�» ,.zy����r u�}'-f e __ - r �� �.zrM�a✓ >a K2r�� i 0 Number one, we had a petition some time ago, this Soatd stay remember# it was for a change of toning on the blue and yellow lots projected before you from an R-5 High Density Multiple to an RC-8 Residential office District and of course by those designations you understand it was before ordinance 9500, At that time, we had recommended denial of the item and before it could go very much furtherr we had Ordinance No. 9500. At that time, we had additional input and the reason the new ordinance went into effect was that there were numerous deferrals because of short board and for various reasons so that by the time we really got down to it, we had to go under ordinance or at least -- nor I'm sorry, not under Ordinance 9500 yetr but at least to an AC-8 and to an Spl-5, a combination. At that time, the Planning Department, and what I'm trying to do is to put our viewpoints in perspective to show you where the Commission is, at that point in time we changed our recommendation as being opposed to the RC-S and recommended•a portion of the rezoning to SPI-5. That portion was the three lots to the left at the top and the one immediately underneath and the blue lot and we had recommended denial of the southerly or bottom lot which is the lot commonly referred to as the Commodore Club. Subsequent to that recommendation, this item continued on to the City Commission and after much deliberation and harangue, the City Commission elected to change the zoning on lot 5 which is the lot in blue to permit with certain voluntary covenants proferred, the use .of that property for office use at the bottom level and residential use at the top level in it's present configuration.' Now, the problem with that change of zoning as approved And adopted by the City Commission is that in, at least in the Department's opinion, however, not substantiated through the other.administrative channels, is that is --could potentially be thought of as spot zoning.' When this was brought to .the -City - Commission, they,.said well, let's refer it back to the Planning Advisory Board, and I skipped one step there which I'll correct in;a minute, let's refer it back to the Planning Advisory Board. What was being recommended when it'went back to the Planning Advisory Board was not the SPI-5 but an RO-3/6. '.,In other words, this has -a similar type intensity but not as great as the SPI-5 -and that was the recommendation or suggestion going back to the Planning•Advisory Board. Now then, I think I corrected or I'm cortecting-it. When the Planning Advisory Board recommended :approval, in accord with our recommendation, our changed 'recommendation at that time 'which was for those upper most four yellow lots and the blue lot to an RO-3/6 that was Department recommendation, and that's the recommendation that.came out of the, Pianhing Advisory Board. We did not recommend lot 4 to be changed at 411 which is consistent with our previous recommendation. Now when that did get back to the City Commission,.tthey did adopt the RO-3/6 on the blue lot and that's where.our concern.came in about the spot zoning. 'I missed a step in the process there. -So now -again we point this out to the City Commission that this is a problem and we recommend that they rezone those other four lots to the RO-3/6 designation to be consistent and to be a proper zoning application so there's not one lot but that it would be five lots still excluding lot 4. That's what we think.;. is the necessaryaction and that's the action we recommended and that's the action we would suggest to this Board this evening although it is not as you viewed it originally for. -the RC{-B gnd for the SPI-5. This was a compromise position worked out 'in,part by the neighborhood and the community and there's.s�nly one `disagreement and they will speak before it tonight and that's th lot 4 because they have not been included and i think what l could suggest to this Board, seeing how the :City Comm ss,ion.,bas; wreatled .and wrestled with this# if you feel that's a compromise or a proper zoning, you might recommend that and. you Could: include or exclude lot 4 in your.suggestions for reconsideration. I know that's very confusing but that's the way the whole thing has been down the line. Bottom line fCOM the Department, we recommend the four, lots to 4Q to a . -3/� >� t as the lot in blue is presently Zoned key thy��tymiaeion ,n4 we have not recommended the inclusion of lot 4 at this f�gg 3 January i.b, 1984 r lte14 1, Zr 1pi. k ----------------- 1 ,. v OF Sam � : �} yy �y y� y� + p� y� yr� lots - ��pp yq �y � �y� i,r p �y y1{ i► y� ' t'a',-'�'..'.♦ Ms.GL W: -LhVse bout iota Qe llYli►WG6i7--hG1. are the numbers of those four lots? Five i' seven. . Sic seven# eight and thirty.KT s Mr. Perez-hujOnes r F-- Mr. Whippiea Six# seven, eight and thirty._ t4^ _ of ` because five was taken care P� Ms. Satos Oh, 9Y. by the City Commission. µto thirty y Mr. Whipple: Six', seven# efightr +•• Ms. tarot Six # seven, eight and thirty. Mr. Whipple: ...the blue lot is five. the one to the south or bottom end is lot 4# that's --the bottom lot is :t theCommodore Club# the blue lot's the Babylon building. ,r yt:'Jv+.i Ms. Baro: Yeah# well that I know the blue. (Small discussion between Board members discussing which lots are in question) <' Ms. Baro: Lot five they already approv+ed'# I see that. ` What i.s the present zoning on those r Ms.. B.asila: - lots? Ms. Baro: They approved it. Lot 4 is the. one*, . Ms. Basila: What As it as it stands today, what is it? Ms. ,Baro: I.know that., I'm not worried about lot 5• w Basila•• Spi. Okay, it's: all: 'a part:`of� SPI.. t '' Ms_. - - • SPI and --six, sevens eight and ='t 'Ms..Baro.LL ` thirty,. : Okay, those are those four, SPI, so it stands right now*,* Commission has approved 5, right? Yes.: Lot 5, Block 2,, that =A<: was changed' by the City Commission. (End of discussion) jYr e _ .Okay...__ ♦ , : Madam. Chairman' -; Mr. Perez-Lugones ,:before we:;. w Mae Baro: Yes. Per!�z-Lugones:. ' ...move. into, -:listening toy: those 3nterested:'partiea, I'd. like .to .,have for the recordwhetherwe � her the owners :or the legal re sesentative of lot . 4„an+d,nt have': a i h h p-' ' xr e t n k f. 7, S.. anr�. �0 her o fight? Mr. Bliss: Lot' 4. Mrs Perez-,Lugones:: We have lot 4,► Do we have h►bodr ots 6 7, 8 and -3Q?, representing 1 , R<, ' fir,-Lugones: we don'tY;bave . y e e _ 11 j ,3 Perez ' orb 30 if 1 `" 1 '�,': `• " s. Maex for: the .rec=♦ ';q barYBB.`� Ji r s4 4 t - r d dJ , 't.: �.� �'-'iS.r.,r �... _ i ..'-` :'- •'r #- t Ss`�i's w ��!: _r-4'n _ - _ - 1 � • G Y . " Ma. Maerg For the reaOtd, would You i"Peet 'Our file and tell theoni►g adatd whop at the time the represented those property owners who made 'f`= `w^ • application was, fade, f:z the application. ` Mr. �ete�•Lugones: For the record, Madam Chait't�arir the; file shows that Robert H. Ttaurig was the person... Barb! He was here. '• Mr. peret-Lugones: ... who, aceotding to the affidavits# represented all the interested parties which are the ,n basis of this application." Merl Can you tell us what those ots H Ms. in? - were that Mt. Traurig represented the owners 'Mr. Perez-Lugones: Those lots were 4... Ms. Met-. No, is £our Allen Bliss's? • Mr. Perez-Lugones: ... which later ton Allen he e Blisect that he assumed 'the responsibility and filed papers was going to represent himself but at the time of the application - and 30. those lots were 4', 5 ► 6, 7 • Okay. - If I may, I would like the Ms. Maer: record to reflect that upon the secretary requesting the '. applicants or their attorneys to stand up, Mr. Bliss stood up as the owner of lot4, is' that correct, Mr. ' Bliss? - Ms Baro : Yes. ___.. _ Mr: Bliss: That's correct. , Ms. Maer: Okay, and no one else has made.an r the re resentative for the owner for —_ appearance as the owner o P Y the.other lots•involved in the application. I dust want the` ;3s "record to be clear on that. Perez-Lugones: However, the record.,. Mr Traur ig • s . Baro ... , ' • Ms.. Basila: You're saying that Mr: Traurig is N z = no'•�li�riger' representing? s. ! '• + rya Mr. Perez-Lugones: •...we want to also the record to chap es in the applications:.as reflect that. there has been no, g filed` or any o.f the: offidavits' ash to who the legal represeriCative #ox lots 6'7, 8 and 30 is. At this point, Mc.rauriq rem ns Y } tk�e'' r!ecoras that' We have - as the legal representative 'thCt rots: Ms: Baro: He was just here a few minutes .a+�4•�t 'Did-, he leave? He was just hare. • '�- p �,Lu Qnes s Z -don t kno rI •' j Mtr• ere 9 know ` aether►e' .eft or.:iot. -s. leer: It's ,y Ong.. thtr 'ti9�rs@d �`ste in fact � fete nos�@nta b+�f+�r+� A th�` �t A�; @ i1� lon er represents. tt��+a+� other ` lot' t!► re i � f A y�A sg n{ that` {� .1 ht no in9this a Fl,ication. thi.nk,, its ► ;' : rt'Y > { to shQW frha4% p�i4! r�:�r'!ii h1►' q_q ax one would �at�de tblit +Ti w 7 - - ;, 3 retain d +ounseI to assist in mak a i etiQn „; jv YYQQ a.�eph! According- �}�R.. ��r7r!• to Qkue f ctl mhiv e f�� 7fold and FlQren a ItQbl i,na. .." r t 3� # Mr. Pere2-Lugonest Cary geld.., Ma. Maer: Cary Held is an attorney for... Me. Sarot They both are from the erickell"" from Traurig's office aren't they? Mr. Peres-Lugonest That is'eorrect. Ms. Saro: Norte of them are here. Okay. Ms. Coopert Madam Chairman, Janet Cooper, attorney with law offices at 169 East Plagler Street. 'Perhaps I Can help clear this up. At one of the earlier Commission Meetings, an attorney representing the owners of lots 6, 70, 8 and 30 stood up and identified himself orally on the record. I don't believe he slid it in writing but it was known to the Commission and too staff'at that time, that he was representing those lots and Mr. mra'urig was no longer representing those lots. At the last City Commission meeting, no representative from that firm or from the owners of those lots appeared and that was one of the reasons why the Commission decided not to take their final' action-. I.spoke to Sdie Laquer who is a real estate broker involved in the properties on 6, 7, 8 and 30. I spoke to her, .today.. She informed me that both she and a -main named Arthur killer who was involved with the developer on that property were aware of the hearing tonight and that they have decided to take - the position that.they are no longer concerned about what happene on that property and that is why I believe you are not seeing them represented tonight but I know that they are aware of the hearing.and that this is the -second time they have chosen voluntarily not'to appear.. They were also aware of that.".. Commission meeting, that they didn't appear at. ®. Ms. 'Baro: Okay: Ms. Maer: Let me ask one'more questimay? on,'if I Mt Baro: I don't hear you, Miriam. -Ms. Maer: I'm .sorry, I'd like to ask'one 'more question. then just .to make ' sure :that, •all, of this. -.information is =_ .F in fact clear in the record. To Aurelio.Perez-Lugone's,...was:. a ngticii.,mail:ed out of this meeting :tonight and .that .this item., would be on,the agenda? =` M;. , Perez-Lugones': Notice was mailed out: 'to.. these' Persons that . we have in' our- files 'as being involved' with tse:.:. =,4 Application. This. person who .showed. up at the hearing, ;lf, he dick i. is not a part -of what.. I have .in' . the f it so: even though ..they., may have been aware as... 14s. Baro They're not there. — Ar. Perez -Lug s; Ms Cooper was sa in ,,.::t s.r one y 9 they net; been officially'rtoti.f ied far thin tieax ink and ,the wil]: y -% be .offi0illy 'notified for the ;Co imission hearing`, because we aK, don't have their whereabrtuts. j .r Qy� j./�►/Ms,- Cooper: okay. I 'weat into your oi*fi�e;... 6 liVF 1�*�/.,41�Ay11 Okay,very +cad,. ' i►az s it 1*04, age a we `can't keep,., Okays .,iet'a go on th t owner of lot.4• 11P4 � 5tf5 M Mr, Bliss: All right. My name is Allen Bliss, r i�fi presently residing at 1402 SB Bayshore Drive which is the Iodation of the Commodore's property. This is a hard subject to bring up, we have-i-when the original plan was made, I wasn't in control of the property, it was owned by the people neat dour With the blue spot, the blue lines there, and it reverted to me through action of the appellate court.but whatever the objections were originally, which is over a year ago now, they're no -longer Valid, The red area th-it's directly'behind the condos -where the objectors live has been turned into 5pI-5 from highrise residential. The blue area has been turned to R0-6 (Mr. Bliss stated tha new zoning change incorrectly. It is R0-3/6).from residential. It was built as a condominium and they couldn't t make it as a condominium and they were allowed to change to Office. We, are presently zoned RG--7(Mr. Bliss stated the zoning t wrong. it is presently zoned RG-3/7) and we are willing to_,drop to the RO-6- (RO-1,/ 6) a- lowering in density to get the same office 1 as what's nextdoot bn the Babylon. The only objections that'seem to be are traffic and the fact that there's office buildings on the area. Right now the -cdhdos have the highest zoning of office directly behind them. They have the blue building which is less then 70 ft. from the first of the condos at the back area of it. The Commodore's area is only 23,330 sq. ft. altogether. It's a very small piece and j the City by their Comprehensive Zoning had said they wanted to turn that.Brickell area into an area that is used 24 hours a'day or at least a lot more than the 8 hours a day, have a day group .and a night group. if the Commodore's was office, it would not increase the density. The office people, in a small office building, would be coming in the morning when the'condominium -people have left, .would leaving in the evening when the --- w , condominium people need the outside parking areas. At the most, } we're.talking'about 30 to 40 automobiles pirobably, when diagonally across the street is an.area where there's going to be 600,000 sq. ft.•of 'building going'up with residential and office on'the same Bayshore Drive only at'.13th rather than 14th, the corner of -13th' `and 14th. .Furthermore, the current zoning of the Commodore's a allows'hotel. There is no question that with a hotel' there would be,greater-density, greater automobile traffic-.- So there',`,s no real -legitimate reason why the Commodore shouldn't be included as the'Babylon is in the office zoning. ' Another thing, the building to the south and the,..- bdil,d�ing.to.the north have both affected keeping the Commodore's „as,residential. The building'to. the south, Brickel'l Bay Towers, "has . a . parkih-g lot of 65 cars -.-directly to the ' south of it.. The . building is 300 ft. long and 130 ft. high. You have no ,.view ,.to the south , `eid the building ,being so high blocks the sun -off during the entire winter for most of the area and. nobody,wants a condo.that's inthe shade in the winter time. To the north,, you,'ve.allowed Bricke'll--well; it's been -allowed ,that the Babylon go to RO-3/6 office zoning which puts an office building ;le$s 'than 20 ft, # the building itself, from the line of the Commodore's So as fa a b ff d 't h • r s any u e , we on awe one, and , we should have,as much right to a buffer as anybody ,else does. There is m•.buffer to the south though with that huge parking Ylot and I would say the building, fo tlse south ii ' about ,120 J t�' away from -the , lot line . of .the' Commodore's. That's the main thing 1 have.`right now is the f&of that.. ttraffic? we're,not going to be a problem with 'traffi 4 Id tsin�lamily homes' highrisee are nhey ick . action kith trash 'pickup -and deliveries :is ark tiffioe, boil lirlyv wou d `do, 4 t4inly a =411 office buildinq .ik 'the ,> - C9=40rdore l s e 1'd like m few minutes ,for rebuttal if l .Reed its ank F� you , . or any questions. t v, se aR +fin thi,� item3 . , Anyone �'�• that is ,? s �an4�ary r - .. 'N Mr# Perot-Lugonest Madam Chairman, we have Mt. Campbell from staff that would like to address the board. Met baro: Mr, Catftpbelli Ma, Baro., Okay# Public Works. If I may? Mr, Campbell: For the record, George Campbell, representing the Department of Public works. We have, in the P&s,t.and in the previous fact sheets; indicated our concern about the -pot , entiall and this was in general when the entire, everyone was considering the whole group of lots there and a -matter of fact, I think.we raised this concern several times beforb'in similat situations in this area, in that, at present the sanitary facilities.w.pre'designed for the zoning which existed SoMe tiMe'r a906 It has,,been gradually upgraded and we have been gradually and continually waiving a flag, sort of speaks, to caution the - Board against this type of zoning.** Unfortunately, we,do not . prevail against cooler'heads and is now, generally the area is Whit SPI-7t I think? Mr. Bliss: Five. Mr. Campbell; Five, I can't keep track -of theta,, 'which is afairly high density designation. The RO-3/6 isr,l believej,actually less dense than the RG-3/7. It,allows for a lesserAevelopment which is not too bad. We are presently,, as the -Board: -and the Commission both have asked, we are presently working on .or or-in the throws of,, if you will., a study of the "airea. from-,15th Road to.SE 8th Street primarily because of our -concerns wIth-the sanitary facilities and the sanitary sewers.,. We have grade l'a,.P reliminary'.analysis,from 15th Road -north to the river, there_,arej,-and.east.of Brickellj'primarily there ar'e.some'areAs that t are --undeveloped. : There's some areas that ire,.-.,uhderd 446lo d -pe at ;.this_time, .,Out we have a lot -of'. -things that are ' coming .oh 'line either where .;._tIhere_, have been variances granted or. coning has been 'changidr_,where7-Ve have, gotten some kind of preliminary'ihijlgs through.-development,of regional impact.and our pr6j,66tion is that In.,,the .,._*next#,_ I.- think ,three years, assuming ,,that those things that are,on�.Jine,now.come,to fruition, :we're gonna have. a pr0bI-4i,: Not;_-:Just-_wej, -,the, -Departmentr ;but , the:.City, is., going o h "a a ., t serious '.:'*problem.'.,,We.are -'catagoricAlly,,:let's 'say oppose 0 ralsifig the standard or raising the zoning in this area. Wej, be6ause of_*the ;mature of the piece, ,we have no great probleM with; the RO-3/6 wings 'however, t:d'eXceed 'that- would merely bring the. - ultimate pr90lem;a,little closer. Mr. Bliss,has mentioned the -the 600,000 or whatever it traffic and v was square feet of office and apartment space,. to the north ,and,.east of him or northerly; of him. This is true, because of' --because of the zoning, we, the. Department,,p.. we: are, not involved . in the developmept of tb isj by, at,�qomes_on line the,°Way,.,­ -When'th ",-when,. something,. concretqo_x, something., Viable, I. should says,. is,. proposed, for tbAi,:'ArepL.�% pe seen ail;,. indo.. -of., interesting, things,,,, then, we.' will , t take=:A:very,;.­.-hard look and: it might _t be that we vj6ul 44 there be �'some vort of a delay. Ih- I sue -in' Ls -0 Perm, tor, _tjlj6r� U o'r" get, 0110.-, 6 uata.�twe,-�carl tw9in upov0o, the;sanitary; rade they., saft4taryzi syptem that, Area. y, jit,L'Qf a $J=ey, aid We b4ye,., checke it-poysi, #a notat -4v dAnc d us; lev j,qrq we re,, it aft taho t tw4,� the:�, Pi to�_ PCs vhat*:­ f instance, that area to the north' iW­eas 7jfj A9 forth I don ft: know many _Vehicle$ti because wo,44ye propo -:f*,r::-- it* Ne.:VAA 'poew bly h4ad 4o th4 Al r1illy affovt-O_qr, ty;#,f f1c Aitat- ii* 'An tA VAO nnst►►a :aid .414 -par "'. V-4 *�PQ4joje of, j*6 0 _ii . X- �40 - occupant at a bu Aq because tjx4build age M thot niqbt be it and we can work, a ti" r,4 2 stagoer" hourip S=ethinq 60 that :tlroffic 4-0 heavily* M I Y We would recommend that the RO-3/6 be continued Westerly of lot 5 and that the lot to the east remain toned approximately what it is now. Ms: nano: "thank you, Mr. Campbell. Okay, ehy6ha else to speak? Janet. to Ms. Cooper: Attorney Janet Cooper. Vitt here tight representing a group of homeowners called the PointVieW Assoeiation, Inc.' These- are the homeowners in this Poi.t►tview area. 1'tn going to point to the areas that their live its. (Ma. Cooper pointed to the areas on the projected map) When this application first came up over a year ago# the people felt very strongly that the area should rethain residential and the people have continued to feel that way through numerous hearings, numerous'presentati6ns by the various property owners. They have been down here in force to zoning Board meetings and Commission meetings ano the ones who live here who were not out of the country at the time, over three hundred of them'signed petition forms and I will pass these twenty'sheets around to you sio-y6u can see just how many were able to sign there names in opposition, to -any change of zoning. (Ms. Cooper handed the petitions to the Board) We had a very difficult situation with this application because it'.became very complex with three different property pwners and everyone wanting something different. We were able to resolve the issue of the Babylon which was an existing structure, through some very serious negotiation with the owner of that' .property#'and what we were able to accomplish on that property was a wonderful opportunity to provide a very good transition from residential to office. The SPI-•5, as you know, is a very high density office use and which occurs to the west of the. . properties that are being applied for and the property RG-3/7 is strictly residential. it continues the residential area of'- Br3ickelle Avt-hue . and' is a wholly r.'esidentiaf character. There's only two,ways to get to this property, that's`on 14th Street and 15th Street and on the 15th Street•.side# except for the corner which' -faces right on Brickell Avenue, it's all residential. 'It's. •realiy'a residential character. We're very opposed to'putting any.foem'of office in that area. The Babylon will have some office •use ,but it will �be restricted ' as to how much' of the 'building cin'-be used. We have restrictions such as: parking redti 4ctipnb;' restrictions on ,where the, signs can be, there can be=no'`signs placed on -'the South Bayshore side of that property or eveis'�visible `from that side of the property. Mdi. 'Basila: -.You're talking 'about 4ot 5? Ms•. Coopers- :I'm talking about lot 5. Ms. 'Basi�la: Thank you. Us Cooper: We put a lot of conditions,on there which have -been encompassed in a restrictive covenant whieh`has;" been recnrded''in the Dade'County records and which are Xecord'ara bi d i f thi t e rs i i d is 1 th t #� n ng or r y y a m n mum an we ee a even mor+W a4n the �'�-3/b _- iie.i:ng ` a transition type - of zoning, `the agr#ement tbat . we' have reached Qrt that propery makes it ah -even better treneition. if we were''to see° --office going the the reai.dehtiel $ice of that .-trahsiti.on, it would'defeat - the e`nt re purpose,off', ev�eryth`ing `that we worked for and that the Com�atis$on 4PPW�� . . of jm g •ving this `RO.03/6 xoning on that property :and 'a��rQvi�n���f the restrictive covenants as part of that approv�►1 of the_ oh g+e We have no problem and we definitely sup �t e Planning pmrtment and the `Public Wog ka_ Departtse�n 7 ! thoi�r r000pmendation of changing the four. Rots to . t, 'urger to 4iyo4d y .spot zoning Prok�leta tk�at the Citrhv bud we etrs?nglY _FpQ$e enyntrutiicsn c�rfti<ceVV e treffi °and i�r .ngi.ng t angore into the .neighbcrhoc�d T z�. S'rtz' Ya. v .. 7 kinds of other problems that We see With office Use into this fosidential area. Ono of the most important things is the traffic and one of the conditions that we were able to work out W I ith the Babylon people is that they would be paying,folti a traffic study to be done and any improvements that would be necessary- in order to prevent office traffic from coming on to South Rayshore Drive and as you can see, the area between lots 6 and 6 and I'm going to point to it in�just a tecando.provides a natural break between 14th Street which will be developed *ift.an office fashion because of the zoning already on that street and, Sbuth Bayahore Drive which is residential. I'm going to point to that now. This is residential and this is office and we think that it makes perfect sense because of the structure and the location of the property to retain the residential character of lot 4 and to allow the other proper ' ties to be used for offices. If you have any questions, I'll be glad to answer them but 11m tryinq.to keep it brief and to the point tonight. Ms. Baro: Do you have any questions before Mr.-Blisg has the chance to-rebutt? Anyone else speaking on this issue? Okays do you -have any questions before we have Mr. Bliss?. Nb'? All right, we'll hear from you now, sir. Mr. Bliss: Thank you. One I want to point out, there's several things, -one is that Sayshore Drive, as you know, . goes all the way,from 15th Road up to beyond the.Four Ambassadors, and'diagonally across the street is the area that I f. was talkin9 about where 500r000 sq. ft. of building is going to be put. Cars drive down Bayshore Drive from the Four Ambassadors All the time and swing around that curve just as easily as they can take a,right to 14ih Streete, but we're talking about a1ittle 'is piece of property, about a half -acre, and how that goifiig to. damage the wholeareathere. If it does damage it then what right -has anybody *to put an office building up aside of mine . where I am completely trapped between ween a huge condominium on one side and an'office building on the other. She said that the building will be both residential and office. 'Eighty percent of it is going to be office.- They're even hoping to increase the density by 5.,000 approximately square feet by enclosing their. - balconies. ..I've been approached to lease them seventeen extra 3, -pirking-spitces. So I meant it is an impropir thing that's being done. where they're trying to sacrifice the property of the. Commodorels*'to satisfy ,other interests' -and I don't think it is proper. When "those three hundred names or however they have there, were_ was -in January or December of,1�21.or January, ok'831 a, I" d - tdn I t have control of 'the property. - 'I went to tfie'' -first meeting- in _June' of thid"last summer. Before* that, .,Mr. Traurig,was.representing.our property operty 'and. be,fore. that the- red r 4 ti6nithat,you.see there -was. residential. ' Now ,.that section'is c d' he. i 16ss the,:highest office zoning going And that re area there than 100',ft. 'f tom All of the c"ondomini ums that Are objecting ,'to uji..and that area, .as you,ca'n see# is probably times, met's A 'size least twice the of the Commodore's area. The same with the yellow section -...to the north, northwest of. the . �Bab yloqg ..,that .,area i$_two-or three..times larger. People Are go ing to .6'a tfie'--` e rboy Ire city streets. The , residential people They're aic�sstreets. the'y ca !:!'that residential but they cause more density, -.;L' certainly, .,than a lot of small'.-Office buildigs. They patting fours -five -hundred cats"$"' at least three hdr0red carst% n,,, that area right, now every day. We're talking about,objean. ., 3�'IkS 31kl. forty: cars .then yo4l ve got a hinge building, as.,X say oat - --the ;'aunl iahtr blocks' to Ue, 60% out h tl 4'al il t 1A, i Pg la ft.. t,6., the north, that was th *11 114W$4. y1kriles and this 04MO, 0 Iani"Ltion that, is ' "QW4, Vent 14d4a =0 'wito 24r, aill th6se y4vi4a008 469A 'back -built ,Po withose, *.irii4c4i three or .four 0 f. a mind, to Make years 490 with a Very'defin purpose i 40 VeL a Ar we couldnIi;,_buiJ4,.,a larger conftminium on,our ,prop , % t two a#, TYh 4 0 'Y Zoning ad ............. -I NO �s.f a,• when they're trying to do this kind of Stuff and there's a lot Of r_ <x other things that we're doing involved with it too# but i �uat giant you to treat it as a small piece of property that# if it's _ 't=Y need buffer# you've got a buffer to the s£ruth Of' y _ unfair and they =' :- _. from the building and a huge .s cf a -65 ft, parking lot, 120 ft. building. To the north of me you've got an office building. .: Thereto no reason why we shouldn't have the same zoning`aft that >h, *t Vf the Sa'byloft. Thank you, j -' its. ®snot thank .you, Mr. Bliss. Okay# any - obt�aments on the Pfi of the Board? Any questions? BoYou need any itformation from staff? We have to makme s ott chanfed its.. #� � recommendation one way or the other. Staff hasg . ;y- Well? �y Mr. Dort: 'One more time for the record... r; - - - `?3 One more time# are we going to... . i Ms. Baro:. - Mr. Dort: I said it the first time it was in front of us in here.... <-- IF - Mg. Basil!: Can't hear you, Willy. - Ms. Baro: Turn on your mike Mr. Gort: The first it was here, if we're s— I think if we stop gonna do this, I think it should be uniform. at 5, allow 4 to remain would be unfair for this gentleman to develop you're talking about buffer zone, his property there. If >t: the n .existing building that is in there has got plety of land, and the parking structure on the north of it and west of it to :a maintain 'as' -a buffer zone. I'd be in favor of changing the whole thing, to RO-3/6. fir .. Romero is that a* motion? Baro No. • =; It' thought If they want it a - j:=s Mr. Gort: s my y-' 3 mo Lion '11 make it a motion. k 'Mr. Perez=Lugones: A transcript of -'`this wily be given." ;«a< -to, ,tie '-Cbmm imass3ion •for, theca you know`. 4r Ms; Baro• Yeah. Any other comments? Gina? - _No . I cons istently at' therery` < Ms. Basi:la. , o I feel that none of it !should have beginning voted against this., been changed, to'star with but since they have c3iangea it;: ° 4 ate ge ' ioii't` think that.t'=-should go any further myself, because I f+ae3..y99 it's a beautiful_ residential area and that it doesn't need to be -{& intruded upon "further. That's' `dust :ay` opinion. uus, Baro`: well I think onlyi- the lot 5 • was': " haried,►`" Ass'`! rasult, -I think 'the' staff ia' recommendi+ .tliast. tie ,r !theta be Changed now, 6, 7, 8 and 30. . Sas3iiat ' ;X*ve stated how f feel aboa►t � 3° arc; Okay* Anyone else? wellb+� , eua Aa wi, h 1 and 14r,. X6,r_ + x` I 'was one .Qf ti�� ones that voted t Gloria is not here s aga 3.nsst changing any of.' it, �t a��` Bhd ` ►�� . ;'�� � � '� r'�� .: &o what do we 'do nt�w, fir' l fan w t B*� � 1.`#+a a transcri t of tbia 4f4 tQ } µ �r6s.m�ly repeat and have Yy cs issl.00. fog'_ s to make the tinAl decaL6iOn car. 40 } r sp with aubt�er rec+�endation3 Aaw .,... , k #" +" • ; ci":"S" F r t �sd>ganciai:° toiNot r fi.^- -f. w. A�txnsSa-�7't. '1 tY k•.:..r"�{..-!.. ��'kP � "3, l.`.F° fu, s. t 'T-u) s 1 d - ,. r , � 'i•',tm:ni s�14t�4��- - -- - Miriam, Ms r `~ t believe the Commissift ,r V�� Meer: t m sottyr 1 v ould refeti a reco mendatio t from this Moatd. Ms Baro: ' he ' Would ptefet a rtco�9it' ,66ditio11? T +e way we at tight now, Well, I haven't heard +&usethfroi: Mr. gomeror } Mr. RomerOl I . have' the same feeling its Mt. Oort., ;. Msr Bato: Oh, he votes With Mr. GOrt, or than is how he .feels° and • what about Mr. beYurre? few words"* Inaudibi'er�`` Mr. DeYurre: (mumbled a 5; Ms.:: gato: What did you say? ., Mr.. perez••Lugones: Madam Chairman`? $f Ms. Daro: Yes? Mr. Perez-Lugones: The Board could.make a motion, :in this ,case, :that. the feeling of --in the view of the members IT you know, Whatever... • present, y .. Ms. Baro: All right, do you want a motion? Do: you::. want this' in form of a. -motion? • Perez�Ldgones� Well, 'it is' not a --let me "put, Mr. • + be . s akin ... this. --;way. YA$ you'. re goings to pe g ,p. ` :°�,•.., Ms Baro• or do you want a statement made to • feels? _- the effect::how 'the °Board Pere z-�Lugones:. Indi4idualYy, you 'have lretLay iA expressed :your': viewe..'. Hre • Yes. Ms . Baro . . -'record is ' Oin 4`t0:; z-Lu ones • :' `: and •:the 'rec g _ _. Pere • ,;,.;x - g at is oic to',:'be= given to th.^3_-R reflect4'that w in the =-t ariscript th '°9 9 ` e a but if -You want to go one step further, 'it is C'i y':FCommission - y a ..motion- that will supersede your previous one, that action: final, but » f''ybu :want to make; ;a recommendation to `the commission t F ri in form of $ -motion which will not supersede the previousone }yt b9 -Bari: •I don't understand because if we make a';rrecommendation... _ P. 'yy Mr. Gort; There's no way you... Ms Baros - .How can you make a - c mme A on . that will not ' ohange` r',Ou 1"@CO1pAleti�at`�. " � .., ;� �;`.� y x a�. dt?il'� k I ' dOlt 1 ? _ ` 1,,: 'n. Mr.,,pere��Lugones; : r aorry, but .are yt�u What .. you tdid before? Ids. faro: No, we want to Mow ox4gtly this we � f+�e�, the s+ifiy&, �. ,&cat*ioj ytop tak,+�.'. � Baer: Then .1 would ou goats t !lcr is and feel , � - ri a el a mat tip! stilly and a dqrSIX other ;WMbj*rj, poll 4. the Le +� ty y�rp i�Yc�'k^`+-t'1d i ' za 2. .,fz�"l, e=t�..,$'_• 't7' — I' { f - V _ .9 t i x � �t`Ms . �art5 ! Miriam►. ' ;t,A s Ms. I'ttt sore, i believe the COMItiasiOn Maere -: WoUl- prefer a recommendation frost this 130ard. T Ma. hero: They would prefer a fe�oittetldation? r 'eause the Way We atand right now, well, I haven't heard from Mr goittero I have' the same feeling as Mrs Mr. Romero.. Oh, he votes . G, with Mrort, or that Ms . Baro ! is how he feels" 1n&.. what about Mr. ntYurre? � • Inaudible.'= ir. .neYurre: (mumbled a few words. garo • What did you say? • Mr. Perez-Lugones:' Madam Chairman?. ' Ms. $aro: Yes? Mr. Perez-Lugones: The Board could .make a motion, .in this .case, ,that the feeling of the view, of the members y present,, you-Anow,-whatever... Ms, Bato; All right, do you want V: a motion? =' bo you `.want:this; in 'form of a ;motion? Mr: -Perez-Lugonest. Well, ,it is'not n1e this, ' way: As your" e- going. to be''speaking:.. } - Ms the. effect`;.hovr=: the Bart;: Or do you watit a statement 5 made to •feels?' Board -'r.Mr.,perez-Lugones: Individually, you'hae'alreay'' expressed :.'your : views:.: , Baro • = Ms. Yes. .:and the record''isgoin9' to a z Mr. Perez-Lugones.::.4 _ s oin to' be= given to' th , ect that =, in .the ''-ttranscript that - i 9 g ref l it .. to step further fission. but-, -`you want go one , is :not. `: ,'`:;:::p C :tyt Comm ��,�� on -that will supersede your previous one, that action is;r , t - - final, but°:f:'you :want to make. :a =recomaindation to Comnai'ssion in of amotian which will not supersede the rprevious ;one... form. era .v' r u .a M6.-.-Baron •I don't understand because if we. 3 $Y make a, ,recomia tion... k•r Gorts There's no way you... SAO -Mo. Baro • - ...iow can you make a µ #on :mat will not change°- our origi�ial tQn`n r. " rscommendat ;•„ _n r = ;:'M :y� ;•t''¢}`','j* s';�•; ... .., ., i _ x .;-5 .;` 'n t'_ c ,'✓" A. 3 2 re ' py� gonest- S don t;,,.._,Mon t.,:'3 ".Mi 1 '.�vAre'I�i'*tu •i`• �,s'S't$•3&�'+' 'A at db r- # , °X I m ~ sorry, taut are x w►t youdid before? 4_ x• i :, e ". :{. ; ., - h y� e� : 3 Yi , n 4 -.' f -� N-tsl 'f4 F Baro: I10 we want to ' now exe t . w AL ; Ms. , �pp =( t 4TI/ a !� ,s sct.n� to take this poi.nt,, we, tine ssy= �..;; $ Then .l wQU14 saggpv�* { his Haler: 144 i � WLIly and erg► ��►� .t b. " " -y4➢ .. , _I s ,.t k..k fi¢ s� a ,� nw � f � � ` -.k,• -he other x 3i y 12 ` /A� i��+{/ #. dK!, •^vo y, f' 1R�, !! 1 • v { 4 lion A v , 1 1. g tT h K4 s •'k,yxt v_ ptex��,ugbnass victor. t. . .was not here and he feels' thikt;' s� Baro: p thap wee should vt�te on maybe you shc�uid express yt�ur Opinion � - ,... } :. bBoau� we do deed to heat from the whole hoard, not Just from the Iby r ;of belurret well, the thing is, are we going to -' put this into a vote or not? Does ray opinion... -5 14s.Baro _ alter a vote? Mr. DeYurre! . • . gars: Let me explain that this came to us before and' we went through, we've listened to the --and we pit. a Mbtion denyfng, recommending denial., that's how it went s. Mthrow iugs —r to the City Commission. So we already voted tome back to. us for us to listen to more testimony.., Mr. Gott: And give our comments how we feel about ...and for . us to come back and give No . Sato, + them our thoughts on the matter. That's what the City .wants. Mr.. DeYurre : Okay, well if I' m the only 'one .; .eft,, I'd be in favor of changing 'it. I don't see any reason why ''root,' 'There' a lot of office buildings all. around that area -to begin with and I really don't see any reason why it shouldn't be +changed, sto S go along with Willy and Romero that it should b� _ changed. Sar the• consensus of, the Board :.isl: •- E ;. Ms. o: BO a feel hat :Mr.= Moran-1 mean, Mr. Gort, Mr.� Romero and Mr, 'DeYuri�. that there's nQ reason why the whole thing can't be-�in other r54 words, .they stand the way they stood before.l5 ` Ms. Mae r : okay. =a • at •the last meeting: Is . Baro: You remember d I stand pat on what the' "'= ``' They. have 'the same opinion and 'Gloria an arm-. 1::2< op3 pion was the last t M$, Maer:. :I think that.... r r-vv4 I feel that none of ld have: G' Mg Bas ila • • _ beenChanged.' a'_,�....,:. -- _- :.-ever ,In other words, the....,#;`, .. iMs , Baro: Mr. Gorr: No motion, move fit.. • _, s ls. Baro: ...Department is recsame►+ng' a t - 4 th t' and make these changes except for to► $:w-' ahead. -and Ws 90 rtent 'is recommending.. The City Commission alr+A+„:., the k� stand G10tia. and I stand on :ire sa es -what: r; action on lot 5. We r ..,. ea Well # you know, S, i - ;s. id ; Ms * Ma+er: Right, right. i und+�stand. � _ the ► }� x . - s .the same thou ne►_;:.;* B#0uld have -should be Changed at c y.c e Yr' 13 i' ��esf,.k - t;s sis." � t ^ r i ,+. , '�: ✓f � - � s, r K �' `"^��-�a}' a� — ln kFF , u_ - '{ ��t, s ,bl� � 7'4 k+t �s�FiC� „ •fir 'i _ n , r'? Rq 4.1 ', Ms r Meer Right, oki y. i thing that what the t Board has the option of doing is rescinding its prior action sr that's what the Board desires and making a new motion recommending approval or recommending denial or if the Board did {` not wish to rescind its prior action and would make a motion that ; has not inconsistent with its prior resolution which was sent to fpi the City Commission in the form of a recommendation, then the other,;: ws Board could pass such a motion. On the hand... — A` -: Mr. Gott: Madam Chairperson, let me save you _- 1 think to make some time. I'm not g-s oing to make any motions. -:- motion right now with a split Board and five members being here not going to pass, so what we're doing is expressing only its s our comments, the Commission's got our comments so 1 hope they 4.# 4 could stand on it6" f y 1 Ms. Maer: That's the third option that you "- `nave . - Ms. Saro: Well, that's what we're doing. Ms. Maer: if you don't wish to rescind you prior action and start over again and you don't wish to make _ another motion, then you just state your comments for the record -' and the transcript is forwarded to the City'Commission. ^ 4 ' M$. garo; Well we have. We have stated our r -; comments.' Even if we were to rescind and go back, we'd come out t. the same way, it would be 3 to 2 which be constituting denial _ again..`. - • Ms. Maer: Right. Ms. Aaroe ...so therefore, it's really _ useless to do it, all. So. they'll have to read the minutes from this meeting and take it: from there. Okay? Can, we go on to #-s item --what is it, three? four? _:� •. a '',i�'"'fib 17 j.. j 7' A a• a s X € { �i i 001 . - t' _ - "1.i '• J F'�{'i�5�- 4�.�Y GT'�, jqR Z 7�°•'SL f d-+i- _ Fd�� �4 ,y,, qy}§L-ixaiv{+'Y•z F.+� .. i� �' t fqL J ' i Cxe _,D ` CITY DK MIAMI, FLORIDA INTF-R-OFFICt MEMORANDUM • ' � � 5 1983 -- DATE: July ! ern: Howard. V. Gary ° City Manager SUt�,ECT: ORDINANCE - RECOMMENDE6 �ENIAL< CHANGE OF ZONING - OR0 950 AFFROX 185 SE •14 TERRACE AND : •.: ., F'; ` ,APPzoo SE -14- STREET Aurelio. E. Perez-LugoneS i� o• COMMI SSTON AGENDA - JULY, 28, 19 Director planning; and. Zoning Boards EN�b$�>:� PLANNING AN[``'ONING ITEMS dmi:riistration De artment uest It i s recortnnended. that a re q'M -- from RG-3/7 a for a. Chan a of Zoning 9 - _ w i :GENERA TAT.o SFT-5 .BRICKEI:L r MIAMI RIVER.RESIDENTIAL OFFICE DIS ' TRICT in the Zoning Atlas of Zoning a J Ordinance 9500 for the property located at approximately.185"..SE.14 { m:. Terrace and approximately" s �: t be denied..rr �� ree an ada►"isi}` -; 1983, Item':5, following T .. zoning goard'�at its meeting of July ll, in ;classifica i n Tile.: made a •lnoti on recomnendi ng 461 al of.. a change of zon g bearing, (rani::RG-3J GENERAL RESIDENTIAL to S* 5.:BRICKELL-MIAMI RiY R 1tES3DENTIAL iF�Ii~E i Ordinance:9500 =''for tr. pr p8rt loot , } -a flISTRTCT "in the•,'Zoning:.Atlas `of ZOn ng !x he y' tely 185 SE; l4 =Terrace and appmW.ta.te1y 2 0 SE 14 Sirreei:, al p d �Y ,g�►'' aPproxi may c i bed as 1 ots 4; :5, 5,: 7, � .8 � and 30 l esS , the E5' of Lot 30, Olocka,2, FOiN - Ayw4 which failed _ by a 310 2 vote, therefore. conSt, 4POg ,a►�1" !e ? h �f Beni al - t+ iat1 t €F"; R ` } :el _�bjecti ons re-ei ved i n the ma�i. l ; twenty:,,appanents preseht pit h# {' .,�.. lies i .favor received itt the mail two ro onents resent ate 1 -k e A P P::. O '�I�tO #" p r,review. rm�►tion AsiPdud6d, for �to�r re or 1 i•`i RD1�lA�IC o PfQVido for the as ve has been #�, p ansl sulrn�.1♦ •fir Consideration of thsi i�iiry � 4v one -ay"K4• t,1i 'vkt d - k. y„ 1 "' _ i 4 4 � -• �£ y s t+�.F"� 2.sr F� ' _ xs� '„ �' - -, Y�• i vi,,•, hit: •��.`yy:#tt e u,y..w�? �° y it '�- F' � j PROVA � 1 .s-� A .d;:: � .� _ $�.i�'F i'2 z, �" ` . t � of •n. - •4�.='�•sr� _�=y;.,+ ci"+ ,�.' S F �•,00% . v i 3'�,»" .•••�y;-n" T• n 4i- ....- t. °"' �• ,+rz .>;;,•!�:•,�r.rr.•, .,,_... ,:.?ig';s" ,. '�'re-`r`V'1 'y�„t:' :'i?;-� t: r,;: taa,t„ `:: Ci :�'i, .,2j'+'' �.�k� T, - :9�_ f..,a i,�.�zt-,c �;„n ,.i s�r:y, lr..{,:. :..., - '.':7y:- Yr'4:, ki,tili. :i=�°rrc :,,, n,wc,x ._'. .2 ;v".n2?-%t - :.5. ,.A.. .rau'�. s �'a%i: ,.z".. ..•rLL ,_ rE=e,s3. ;.,.u� ..,,.,. t:., t : ti'�,. x 1, . «�, ;, .,P,.r.. ax f ... ,.;, f,` rrf - 'F3, :.�,+:S�,ia,J�k,.a - - . is S A;,>�s. r, a fit:- ;, X• ` {:1' -'sic: ,i'i ,' , •+':;<; :,..:. =� .,>. 4' '!' - _ . ...- �$,�, Ill r 1' ia4�` - - j i i �'x"t . ,- t- .11'* Iy} _ - h 4 p? E. I I J ` zz,.,,.4v,', +:.- i . ,. - . ,f�y - ?'fir e`.,', _ �_ . -- i S2 ' , ? _ / I -,- y ,'t j. .:, ..! - _� _ .. _ - - - tx - _ _ sa ., a Z. i . - . ,- `-,. : I :1. � ,� . I � � 1. � . . 1. - I 1. , I -: I � r,,sommew-VRmand �'#' 11 I:- � �- . �,_- �ii- r rte ' tb fit priiif'tb 1,�+t fia �'i�id_t titt bi�ckell .Avi►d c : ,� i% h 0•�bee *bld for .�100:'`�dt 0�q ��� r� :- ' .� x. }` ` .::` j ...-' a , t j , III coinenta� ,Berk P�+oper �i ^: ? t , _ lht 'the ette �t>'i'E . .',•: - - f1;� . . - %�' . t .. - a - t' H' iiD� l .`M[i' �'.: • ill?" � '�$'• it - a � r s r iE`k-�y"v`..:'aYYkr -k�1 —ft { # i. . is .. - - } T - l } } _ � ` • _ i R ir3 3_ It 11 h cC. _ _ } '� =� y r r I*Y _'sj,'. - - _ - - cab _ _ 'Fs �' M r . F n g`,-*4 , § 11; �'t r t cx- kh' '.,dks'+'�a - - T - j xis?t r.1,t>�Ifi.# y, Lkµ , ' : �7 ':,�- �•-, e".'s'`r :'t .. - - - r r... +cam �, » - - 4-" ^5��v Nm • i� A; s 3� d 4t-ti�d N,3,'i°r 5'''t 4 ti N* ^ tk x 1' "• -q;{ �� ,r _ y� j 11 _ A- -F*, : nY `;.i aif- ' ?'�.a+�' f1F t p, +Sit &.' �'+j 'A ATRG i '?" i"?,, T _ ,-' M, t_'i K` 15't�, F� 1. ' " 8 #'yr",'..r"'r'.,"'`' - '`--'-... ._, ,._.,. ..,.. r •'4` r rda 'x s .ae".tnC, — Se'y� ? :ec. .-'r' r - a`ui � _ _ :;s . M + { a Y `r „� t-- F t `� T sil, 94 "j- ''4 _r,::r :tr-S �_ s ?a s `.rF'..,� -- a .t'�,lt -ds.,, - I - z 9 rP,S'.x k'' a t _ - F _ _ ��[,,,--'�, 4vY 4° z+ [j3 4 �, �f .A ,-r + "�,- , 7 wc.i:M ,ya}L1-. 4 c 9 sew -t a'`a'' a'i..s'.'t", Y .,'?'o- •,�! `ax`..Si. =loge -t .','.�- ,�#y- - �.. .#3*.•x.,.�-, q X r 77 v fi, {r LAW 0~Awe Xx�w IM WOW auILL7IRY' - ,ut ; lanuarjl 1, I9S4 1 3oGaroia.Pedrosa, City Attorney City of Miamillj Ilthlor Alfred I DuPontBuilding T.. 169 Let.1*iegle�r Street _ = Miamlo Florida 33131 ;. - Re: 3anuary 26, 19940 City Commission Meeting Item 20 Ordinances-Zoninit Atlas Amendment_Second Readinit Dear 3oses It pleases me that the City Commission resolved the Issue of the zoning on Lots 6, , 7, 8i and 309 In Point View. - deferral on As you recall, I Iam greatly disturbed, however, by the public hearing. LIt is my opinion that the '. strenousiy objected to the deferral at the pu , 8 }: action of the Commisslon In referring the matter back to the Zoning Board and re- ` scheduling .the mattes before the City Commission for a date certain, was merely a : subterfuge to avoid the result of Section 3513 "FAILURE OF THE CITY COM- MISSKON.-TO' ACTN As you know, that Section provides that when an application r h is riotbeen legislatively decided within the appropriate time period, it "shall be s deemed to have been denied". = Sinte Cammis the slon failed to legislatively decide the matter with regard to Lot 4 - h within :the time riod, and since the referral to the Zoning Board was a sham and s ., :. - eu1 attemptevadt Section 3313 of the zoning code, I am of the opinion that a Cour"t would find that the matter is now denied. a By copy of this letter to Ralph Ongie, City Clerk, and to Aurelio Perez-Lugones, Director Plann and Zoning Boards Administration De artment, I am asking that :..= fi= i. Ing P. his _letter be included In the already very lengthy record of this matter. Very truly yours, "� LAW OFFICES OF 3ANET L. COOPER .0 Fr JIANET L. COOPER 3ANET L. COOPER1b jL cilinw z ,t . • . Clerk � 4 : cc Ralph Or►gl, k 4 q i i � � Porex-Lu$ows84 -_ 00, .�+ 4....'` �, .04 +I To f- ^t:i,A,�'�. .'..':•t - ;•�b".-,X _ !' .v'pr!'�'i,u ^...t t : �it:.'a:.';''a•.�1 z;>k"__.', .-, `4ib''�3..`. � , ,`, .ry: L'":.,.'�? 'r;. _•; ` sue. � , d ��. _ `q• _ '' �� <�,y�F, ., ;@t�'•t'* t"ya`"#' '�• �' r ' t�i�. ���a _ - i i ' ,, ti.tr° -F ,� .i ef+t y�. ` -- - - _ .i'_„7 ��:. ,r.. = , _. , ._ '•-k'�»o rl ..�s"� ,t ,�3.: ... _ ..— - _ _ ,-..'4'a.,`• Y,. - ,+ ...�si'� .trr'c s 1 ,. - 1 s f } r g �. " I a OF ;j vu �r /s 1 , ...%fr1.1 - s �a i No•�� Ipi' !�^_. ad _.r. BE r I. WiAWIJ ON! � lol l- .. . AWWA It999 ft ...... , _ .., . sy, ... �6i.i..• � �� /� _ . ✓ ' -.. _ _Jim - Hk• 1 1,1111111 J � . � - /° Y; . r 3,i+; < l r..i,",., f --F-•ia,2'- - n.. ..-"'�•.- `. "}�.:..�. _..-n. ..:.[t•.. ... ." .. .. '.::�,.v,4.. "� ��!'•}-�,f.:"�vi�,Y : ".:_Y. - :i•' .`."'�.s-� :ti>jlfi,yr:i�>"k�'v- - 2�1:t. _ :. ?E vv';'�•Sy..y�,u,�,. �rA_I�i^.•-'-'}�. 33 For VFW, 21 c s:..: At THE UNDERSI.CNEN ALL RESIDENTS OE DAYSHORE DRIVE, OPPOSE THE RE4,20NINA OP THE COMMODORES CLUE TO OFFICE USE► WE URGE THE MIA II CITY COMMISSION TO DENY THE 90 EST FOR RE --ZONING. .` \rV1JVlcl4 1 WP1 NUMI NAMP, PpR�Nt�b SIGNATURE 3i $ AMA x:4 A`.vo'-tvF Z-r - •IAj44 ♦ %, .�. ' V *c —Z ♦ ! �407 'r N���Y _ c EP-� A 4 tc�o Lo Jam+- k 3 ''�"47-1 rA'SAA�b f. �Kl �A - '. - 71 MR. ^'HAS 1 a a } cy t WE, THE UNDERSIGNED, ALL RttIDENTS Or RAYSHORE DRIVE, GROW THE � RE -ZONING OP THE COMMODORES CLUB TO OFFICE USE. WE URGE THE MIA"1I i. r t CITY,COMMISSION t0 DENY THE REIUEST FOR RE�Of�IIN�,_ t �- �. L �f sc k t - V _ a ` _ -,j Oe �. �a too va4_ ,i � qd t . i t ati i Y Ce 77, a x n Y. 3� Y• i _ 1! 311 _ • C r �y �2 - - , f r -��... �`t•4"�'�y-'�_.,+y,=i-e?''°;"?s sic } ,�T _ j ,s 3-PAY,, _� A- lll_`, , , : •' ` wt , THE tIN� RSI. N��, pll. RESIDENTS OP 9AY5HORE DRIVE, OPPOSt THE R -N NG THE coMMOOORES CLUB iO OrFICE USE- tic URGE iH� MiAMt 4 CITY COMMISSION To DENY THE RcOuE5T FOR RE -ZONING. cart�����►�tt�t NAKt, PRT14TP SIGNAT R Aol 21, jJJy��yy// M r ',F. PREP i r .+,.�,{� , , :::2 ,,+'`.i"tlt Y_ ':1*b.- . - _ _ _�'f: � - f'� "ate-'•Y"'{:. i^,x..',Y•.Sf� ...f ' - 'air :;.l 9 TM W } 'H �INOERSIGNtDo ALL I� SIMNT9 Off` MYSHORE :DR Vt�:.,OPPOSE THE p20NiNC �'HLDMMDbS CLUB TO tlHi Usti tdE 11G 'iHEIA MI DDN'I�S -ON To b NY `SHE ���7li�ST r6k R�_ZDNtNCi - s s 7 --x .s. .+. MM ' ^`' $,X - `.;5„lea.�i•��.t;�=�fiix'�;':�i.iJ.'�ti� 77 U. 0 { -'d.A _ ST A�, V>j Al 76 WED k/ ­q, t iums Vit A C a 1P:e all owners and d r114 ve Odreub00660 theundersi,ned Miami-, rida 331 410 . tayghore give j Ogat ` thane Residential to Wic./totnediAl" �to Mini e -point �14 eW ate a This to tho- 8 and 3 0 the lots for Comisalon auiv P fore the Miami nitv it, 9 .beduled be bat ned do%4n by the'ZoninA 'Board on tur t w6ge 'WAS etted this renu NAVE. EM ?f 7 �j �.' 1A 0 A j6o 7- 205 ell W) .. .. .. .. .. .. .. _011._� poll 09- • • �•• , �'F ,:—ifs. � . y' r Sh ofeCondomlnlu'm­_­,,_ In" c 1440 S. Ba"ham 'ice •Anr, Alit Ot'R7ER5 AND I� SiUENTs OP CO:ISOt. RSO L SfIOR � 144 0 S. BAyanollt DR. 0 tt1AI,11 i PLA. 33131. WE ARB OtOUSD 0 THB OI'IING 0 3ANGB ROP.I RE51I7ETITIAL TO OPPICE/CO1.114E'i1C'At REQUESTED g' AND 30 IN TIDE BOIMT V1EiV AREA, THIS PERTAINS TO T'HB �'0i� tbTS 4, � r � �` � ' 1 AR IdG SCI �tL �'D REPO' I; THE IIIAI,i1 CITY COt,Tt�1 SS10Ir '0�� JULY 289 �. 83; THIS RB U STE CHANGB WAS TUMIEJ DOWN BY THE ZONING BOARD ON DULY •11p 1903 . COriDOt.11NIUM -m-M lY Rl�lra — r a►.ia� +++++ ,cn iv.4/1 n .%'/ SOLA.2 X -" ,o4 De , ai. il 10 ,� ... c 10eC j ,.•, 12 the 3 - - . -- - .�',.:,k.: + ._ xis'~ .f:;�'•3!�;� �� nt u f f �"f t s.'�,•ry'��a-,� _ fl-3}�+n?�k�e; - t" - 'w ,=ys ''� �Y - ' ��'�3`� � r � ''ay-ks'+s k::?',' ,,��'s`%� ,4Sukc �l`r�� � • �� ' � �� .d � n '� �'� _ � _ � � t, -^ty.v j �''+'.ro f �t,f .fi ',} �' +'fit t`�'; ;� '-'F°''.;.� r (' - ��_' .,� e'. - � � , ck'• �•-; - 777, jkWjjpjW 71 -t Jib a, :t sac .-r�..w}. �.1,.'k ... .4 .a• ., >....:?` .. ,. .�. # ._. - ,. _ - _ ...."t',+., ....,..f n r 'w'yi3 v,X - ... ,. ,> n ;•to- 4M -ryes i4� --- ASOCIA�`II lti BELLA COSTA 1+43t� g3iiUCh asy�hdr� 001VO� Mrrr,l �ior�dr , _ �_. { y'` dents of condominitma fit igned� all owners and residents Vol the enders acre Cosae.la,5 syshore Dr ` Nriami. , we ate o�0os*:Jve1+from Residential to ttffiee/Cot�nereial� �w.eer�est±d Rpr to the totting ehange— for lots is riertains to the 5 , 6 7in the 8 and �� point tr;t ew area , xh _ hearitig scheduled before the Miami City C'otrnnis$ion .or Jn1. = this rearrested change was to rued du�an by the �,onin Board on July NAWE EP.J CED_--- t- 6(AA0r 10e4A 49 •- AA�,z. NbP 14 cot 7DS L40 �Ii -il': 1/0 LE � h - - N w.ya. AN - ra .a . JWet 4 r YAW JOIN r� M o 40 10!, 3S COSTA BELL ASSOCIATION" i Abu ei-utti 06ybhdf'0 0"Vo. most 1. r-lao-iddo t§Ji:ji ItIC)ISIsil's are all owners and residents of condoninitma 144, theunderg I$ttled j Vo are. rive Florida 33131. 1450 8, Rdyahcore b U61- to of fide/ (1oftnercial-0eO dential change --from Resi to 6: to, the T rtains 'his 30 Ja the Point VIew atea fog' lots and juiv 28th-1 or nommissi sdhoduled before the Miami Citv hearfy' zoning Board On Julv d dom bit the this redUdsted change was tutqle T. P'RINTRD —NUMBER NAI0Aoff" Ir. eVR I aurz op ght FA ,/,o X061 1z rZ 14 C S k/ To /V WIER % A-Z, '101' IF 11111�1!? of 1 241, ------------ -If . ......... Wil ;t�A,.;5AXF 101,` A I;A _77777777 5A 4 I )0 COSTA B LLA ASSOCIATION 2-3 -Flarid6 14rzo oduth Wee the undersi 'node are all owners and residents of condomilliuma At- plorida. 33131. Ve are OPPON Costa rive, Miami. 1450 9. Bayabore D U /conmercial--Pec rom, Residential to Office. to the zoning chaDge—f view area, T big pertains to tht for lots 4j50667j8 and 30 in the Point or July 2Ath. Miami citV commission e the hearing, scheduled before this requested change was to on Ju1V Ill d down by the Zoning Board Co"pOMINIUM NA14F, 'Piz INTED . . 1710, 4K,:; 11 ( f 0 7 'Al f1d OMM - , A �MIUVIAMOV'T 1 "f� M - I : u T!'- �i as v r -a r+r tin .r . . . . . . . . . . rk � COSTA ��o �auth ��y�hot' G1r�v�i►awida * all owners and residents of Condominiums at. undersitnedi are .# tine Florida 33131. rrT1 �4ie are o�i������rrz;e Costa Eei1a, 1450 S. gayshore brine, Miami., Jz .. nffiCelCommeroial-.Penuested ar* Chan e�from Residential to -- to , -thy coning - �c��. 'Chia t�ertains to thp- area . ''w:{ , 8 end 3A in the Point ew ;;.:.:;.. -for,.. lots 4o506,7or Jv1 £� City' t'onnission v 2gth, tea ing selieduled before the Miami in - hoard 0n Ju1rt ':this equesta'd change was turned down by the 7,on f, 4. i Ct3NtJ(1MINIUM r!�r1ATly'�F.' NAME PPINTEb �--�- ti`) tit �c.t v Mmm — h ' . rgawl+ 3 ij F"SSrv'k'�x'C•� � � r,�...'S'..::^r''�� A": 'w'ar5�.'w-Ma`4w ✓ - .. = e,.. E M '�*,,. i '• - :i�hi ,t��s�i�'�w,rti��Y�^..zc+a ;ti.,. .�:-zs,M-,p, `,¢s» ;•�...- - S L� - �-� a�, y�•'•.a, x<s:.=a,, ilK,',tiA,?,',1':.rP �.��- � iyr. ;' ar�it" '`i�`,a n � - �,h..�' :�:t,p`�ti";t�-a •z r t _ r `:' ��'=: - t � z x its Ai s at Brickell B-4 TOWO-r n the undersi,,nel'# _re all owners and residents offi 00' i= Drive, yjmj , Florida V `ye aLre opposed to the 36 �Ayghor(a r lots 4. 6i jet/Condomin'%L. ".Requested fo Residential to Off alod bato" Ms pertjg '"to V and ift V111 point View' tLrea6 4 tjs he hoarift sahed, City coll-dasion for Ju3,v gEtho 1983; ttils rc-%iested chanCes was turned the MAMI d66% * the ZOr&n.- ward can 4uly 11 r..31 -qO tin A j0 V jot 41, da ,dN �t S� ANY ZONING f ANG FROM RESIDENTIAL FOR LOTS4, 5 , 6 ► � � �# AND : t14 Ttm POINT VIM BAy SHOrt, cOoPERAmsvV-► sNCo PORA�a s a ` IGNATURB S �.. AAo ol i — a Wlb . ,t.d � 3. 3 _ 3 F � d<d cl R r--v L MR. ko. it -- -�-1J Amk s dI i -- the Point View, BAYSBORN U Apt', NUMBER-, 77777777"r t)[-;RAT1 VE 1 NcollpbRATO -ec) L *40M AJ lAt V, C" 4A ..... .......... vti ' ,; ;j^^':F' •�A , jam- } i - '' i., ON10 O "or' L�"DENTIAL FORtOTS +4 ! 5 ► �s � `� � f:� Ate► PROM ftWE OPPOSE ANY O 14 TM, pOtNT 'VIEW DA y SHOM COOpEiATIVE, INCOkpOItA Yi WIT pp 91. 3 1 Mal � sCOSTA BELLA ASSOCIATIOR IN, E_ :r3 .f, ==f= `i �ii L��W�W �3�ytiMrrr+r OPIV t j, �Ir,rld• t"J >; - era and residents of condominiums We the utjd`ersipnedj are all own a Cosje Bede. 1450 S. $ayshote Drive) Miami. i "�lorida 33131 to the Zot►3:ttg Change -}from Residential to Cf. ioe/Commercial-010.eoues.ted. ` This nertaitts to. . -8 and 30 in the Point View area, for iota 4 i i i i ed before the Miami City COMMission for Juiv� 2Athi 19�:�.-� hearing scheduled this requested change was turned down by the Ronin Board on Ju1v CONDOMINIUM ,s , z NAF'�F PnNTBD cTt?�1A'rT1F " 4 Allt 74 COSTA B LLA-ASSOCIATION Mist"tj P1001iddl 1208) MIMS Iscuth 1a*y6ht3f%* we, the- undersinned, are all owners and residents of condominiums at. . Miami ida 33131 Fte are *p00s*'d-',"0 450 S. Bayshore Drive F10'r to the zoning change-wfrom Residential to nf ftee/nomere for lots 4,5,6,'7,8 and 30 in the Point V�•ew area. This oertaing to thy?'::`; , hearing scheduled before the Miami r-itv rOm'ss:Lon for Julv 26th this requested change was turned down by the Zoning Board on July 11,' CONDOMINIUM ,pT(1*1AT11RE MEW NApp, PRINTED E - a5 Nro % 0 &A01 77- DLA[ j I'V 4 -AM ME P/ 00 4'r )L A(F7rrpk,-r ze OF _7 A F= -A Ad :7 Noat W IR 777tZ• - "t 37 N -.1v dzi" 777= it 7T,77- �N' A .. ... ...... 9 �ii.iiy . � � " , ;Ai I;.J..,- ' •> "�: - vrt: .. }.:i�f,:'^� of-�`c�e` _ '�, {' 1 �"v ,.:i:j ,i'� .: ):,y.;' ;ivriS,�e i.': - 3'i`'y... ♦ ;14�i_: }mil K� —_s - y'.=+��t��; - � - �` i✓ ., - • +f - bf ,, t fF Lea J, i 4N. t VI't tt; 11`y O:d2NG C} NGI' t'ROM Rb6lDt-NTIAL POK 'LUTE- 14 5 - PAY i�ifi_il+ti" Ct)C)t'r1Li1'I'iiTk.♦ it`1C t� SI �.. a .. lbel - `t4 r. - rr 1 `t i t i x.,ty„ 5�f,yt n al 77 ,t. t ON a F �^ t,:1 f. • ; _ v ,,, f ` r ;,.,.'S s a c r' AY%g - L"i3°,g6 �k ,~,tE �J'N '+ -, is t = + !_` `� '"o _ a � <; r� a; . (_ � . ��s�3._:'�hr�,=�•F� slee,s�;} _ ,__ ','ay Z .�� �u2:. lE�:';�•, �,;,, ;; `:i p _ 4 C:d':,: axq - t.a - i .,., r ' _ Frog 6.« - 'a:i`�;t'i"!%'.Si%`i;"t''- r:' �i "f`� - F t i61 'Y h �, �1a 9t .Y ' r �,� R3 �'...R.t � yr' ��yY i+r�u�'x1 r..'� F { 'ky � � ' . , .. ; ,., .'�:; ',..' -'sM •M, ,i i���';$ - - - ' _ fi11 g• - OW��F t y liZ 91 OPY, cooPER TIVE i INC. ' - j`t t POR ANY ZOVI NG CHANGE P R+ _ L'IinTfAL POR LOTS 4t5a6t7t8t AND 30 � r ; 114 TIM POINT VIEW AREA . r SIGNA2't?RE - 9/83 e � SAY SHORE COOPERATIVE. INC. I/WE OPPOSE ANY ZONING CHANGE FROM RESYbENTIAL FOR LOTS 4t5.6t7t8t AND 30 I NTM POINT VIEW AREA. j , — APT. #� NAND r 31 9/83a n: -� BAY SHORE . C OOPERATIVE-. 1� gam I/WE OPPOSE A 1�Y 20NING C�i�AiaGE FROM RESIDEDITIAL FOR LOTS 4 t 5 :6.7 : 8 AND i 30 IN Tilk POINT VIEW AREA . ••►--- a APT. -� SIGNATURE':Yy - { 'S AT o i r4 ` r aham.S u. joyVT saw _sip ;tAVi a — ei }y' ,'t'.h"a`.ai""`y}id`,'+Fr.7�::;i::. r f,6 r� s+, .u. ':z �}� ,��air:3�.���.a:�F^.�:_ a : � �;� �. a a �• �" ` r �� ,��� �'.•�p'€ �W,�'E�.-,�y �„y .;a.� �3� y`i' '� _ 7, `� � S _ ;� � _f r e sT,,,L,y�,��x�n��" __ r . - BAY 8140M COOMATIVE, INC* I 14W OPPOSE ANY ZONI140 CHANE PROM REMENTIAL FOR LOTS 4 + 5 , 6 , 7 , 8, AND 30 IN THE POINT VIEW AREA. AEI'. NAME /Y.,�,�>' SIONAMIKE z /t 83 BAY SHORE COOPERATIVE, INC. I/WE OPPOSE ANY ZONING CHANGE FROM RESIDENTIAL FOR LOTS 4,5,6,7,8, AND 30 IN THE POINT VIEW AREA "_. APT. simea&?3 .1��4''��) -�hki S IGNA UREBan �i- d- ' SAY SHORE COOPERATIVE, rs I/WE OPPOSE ANY ZONING CHANGE F RESIDENTIAL FOR LOTS 4,5,6,7.6, AND 30£ q POINT VIEW AREA. IN THE -APT. # O 0 NAME SIGNp —_ - t i •€i __ - 3 £. ,� i a Bit . �"`- # ." �•,e� - ORR .bOQ" BAY sif I,Zon, NOhx fi eta, ASO F#/.4 - '.Si;:9' +;'vr:r-' csF ��s'r�i" s;r 't•{•`. APT . ,. y ? a *��� x r��9;e��•�'�,`�^f;�3„i'��`:;����s ;= �t'''a � _ s >� "t '�r ;t; },Mr���t�, �}}{ t'�.az i _- ''�� r�,�"`a�� liF1�: �r.a u;; ,x�.,;.,=?,� y x � , Y' s�' .'.i;:"�., -rc � � 'e'er �t+�s ir• I = t.: _ 77 Y'a} _ b;�'�`` ._',fliic' - - e Ps•} i t' �_ r,.''•. r � �;' , ?..: �J:: ''�s '�aMcyatk,,,'� � � i - C y - j5;5i3 9/0 41 COOPERATIVE INC. BAY SHORE kil CHANGE F x w ...k. .,•,. OPPO ANY: ZON1�1G _ SE 7,g'4.` s.b ::Ar1D=b�` f RESIDLNTIA`LT POW 'POSN'Y' r'`►is ; - N, V A �C ' Aii'. # u f 34� y .} a a.,, e,. `{ -' SEAR % QP ► f a e ;% '`s; -S, i =fr;- f'�y. ;�'�._;.•,':4r,~,�f.', .'ex t,..' _ yip.,. � fitt- Sis - �if :'�?t @' ° ." '.�x ." R MN THE'. Xs1r.' ° '1F '�d;y., s• y 4 3 y •M .¢n.S, - + #. A-t',nnr•,iefi _ LS t�s z� I...t_._S�,st'" Nt ,.t.� "s'' � 3>r J } •'.�-a• t' - E $ d - � rt _ _ r' � "T b�.s��Y�s b' k ei� ' Fst YArr rpL'i+`': yi%m'(.� .t...� .Ef' , '-d'F"'.i„titi+'wr, t$.. - _ '.""'gh. xti ,he;7c`i*F{ ,.,�,: - :,:<•s rf�-�t:;i ��r::'.=: ^��'.: �+;�'- �`-�'r..�,. v.ri. j :nj, ':$d .: Yu` pie, wi.: "!f.: !'•tiu'�:::i .4=,, '.z: ;f3'';p. ��e..,:.:: !r a''a ..� .� .,. .,.rn .,. ,..�a'��n.x��2.r.`i:�' _._.r. �.�i. r`..'�:.s� a� v�r ,"., nYr°:_ , ,� •_._- ,. , ,._ . _ - .. � _ � ,......, , ..., - sf :<,:��.�cas�. _. - TUR SX ONIA .10 tA Co SAY: SHORE COOPERATI 'Pik, 1-�4- -ANY,;..ZOMXNG�r �OPPOSE A 5, 6 7 8 "AND" RE SIDENftAL,-POW, IN POINT VIEW, AREA As" APT #7o,: L - %tid'A Ud M6 Am W, h39: :00- 4 t2ki;l - Rh4y ............. • "Jaw R19 slism IN W1,;, AIPTV Sri 4, 4 x -------------- ma MCImL �V?: ' YSk�'i�,5�1yd, 4 r L.. rY3>: �.m :°.+v-•.:`- v?..`'., tiv' / V• 9/6 w HNC Y EA"Y S ORS COOPENATM ONING CHANGE' }¢ +O . +OSL E ANY ZFOR LOTS �, ► S ►' ► AW .30 eJ THE POINT VIEW AitEA. ki IN�k » ►�! bo APT. SIGNATURE t 41 co ►� - 9/ 9 i` y SHONE COOPERATI�Is�; ` INC"• - w BAY ;• t i GE :p 1014 OPPOSE ANY . ZONING, CHAN 30 OR LOTS�5+6, 7 T S ANb ' 5- RESIDENTIAL F '°b a Ali,I SEW AREA 0 , ' �z IN THE r>r, APT. r isrt, t`s IaiT�1 i WA NDRB t COORkT 77 _ t B1�Y, O _ ; ;�:. opposs ANY I%NE.- SAL "R $ 4'5:RBSZIX i� _ THE POINT uilm PT i 77777 ljtv oMM-1, MP 01 OR - f y. n rh, IE } k"'G SL F4, , � Wit' - ` t i --- M1 't �, e .} ., ,(9vt , �- .)�; r ,fi »�fX�A �: �:� ?Yt+•.t.�iyF.%v. 'M1-3�. - -- - _— — 0 0 y }.da 15E�iAt�A'i�I��1 _l�F i�S'fi�lGT2bN9 KNOW ALL MN BY THESE PRiSENTS that the undersigned, being the owner. of the following described property, lying, being and situated in Dade County, Florida, to -wits Lot So Block 2, point 'view, according to Flat hook 2r Page 93, of the public Records of bade County ("the property"). in order to assure the City Commission of the City of Miami, r1orida, that,the representations made to it by the owner will be abided .by, voluntarily makes the following Declaration of Restrictions covering and running with the property, Notwithstanding the zoning classification of the propertys 1. The building presently existing on the property shall be preserved and shall not be structurally modified except as is necessary both internally and externally to convert said struc- ture into a building with a combination of office and residential uses, or to improve the landscaping or parking thereon; however, in all instances any modification must comply with all restric- tions set forth in this Declaration. .2. The property and the building may be used only for the following,uses: residential, offices (not selling merchandise on the premises), banks and savings and loan associations, subject to the additional restrictions contained herein. 3. -The top floor of the building shall be used for residential uses only. 4. The first (ground) floor of the building shall be used for parking only. s. No medical or dental offices or clinics shall be per mitted. 6.. Only that portion of the building may be occupied for which there is adequate parking as required or permitted by the PO 3/7 zoning classification as determined by the respective uses, within .the building. bJ via 7. There shall be a maximum of one (1) bank teller on the property, which shall be located within the building. 8. There shall be no, drive-in tellers, automatic or mechanical 4,:ller ,# 24 hQur.elers, ' 9. There shall be no signs on the South Bayshore Drive_' side of the building or on.the south side of the building. Signs and lights therefrom shall be limited to the S.S. 14th;Stre±st -aids of the . buiiding or property. k f 10 All exterior modifications of the building, ; incluai�nc structural changes and signs, must be approved by -IRV =ROAACB. ,As: A ,representative , of point View Association, Inc.=, or;, in the a` event of -his inability to serve in such capacity, aanother . Per ct to be designated by the Point View Association, Inc. No ,extertior modi.ficaations of the building may be made unlese apprQyed,..in writing in advance. Iry Korach or his successor may4,,.Xequ�,��e �,` change in the color of the exterior of the building to =a oQl�r � more .. in ' harmony with the colors of buildings in the �o ant :3Ti�w Asi'ghborhood. Approvals required hereunder may.. not bt baac44-+ 0PI-il j ably withheld. When the preliminary and final designs 40' r,;fie �. iy 12000 po'92417-0, exterior modifications have been submitted to MR. XORACH, or his successor, they must be commented upon and approved and/or disapproved within 14 days thereafter. Failure to make such comments within such period shall establish a conclusive presump- tion of approval of such proposals by the Point View Associations tine. 11, The landscaping of the property along South bayshore Drive shall be improved and maintained at a level at least con- sistent with the landscaping at the existing point View area residential buildings. 12. The owners of the property will contribute the sum of $10,000 for a neighborhood traffic study to be performed by professional traffic engineers to be chosen by the point View Association, Inc., which sum may also be utilized to implement the recommendations of such study. The owners shall also _-co erate with Point view Association#'Inc. by providing -information relating to the uses at the property and will cooperate in, seeking to accomplish the recommendations of the study, wtTi` t e specific understanding, however, that the owners shall have no additional expenses in connection therewith. Furthermore: A. It is understood and agreed by the undersigned that any,_official inspector of the City of Miami Building Department or zoning Department, or any agents duly authorized by the Director of those Departments may have the privilege at any time during normal working hours of entering and investigating the use of _the premises to determine whether or not the requirements of the building and zoning regulations and the conditions herein agreed to are being fulfilled. B. These restrictions during their lifetime shall be a restriction and limitation upon, all present and future owners of the above.-described.real property and for the public welfare, and shall -be enforceable by property owners within 375 feet of the. subject property, property owners on South Baysbore Drive between` South East .14th Street and South East 15th Road, Miami, Florida.,,.. - specifically including those who may be farther than 375 feet of - the -subject,. property; any condominium association in the above - described areas, the Point View Association, Inc., a not -for - profit Florida Corporation or its successor, or by the City of. Miami.. C. This Agreement shall constitute a covenant running with the land, shall be recorded in the Public Records of Dade County, -Florida, and shall remain in full force and effect and be. binding upon the undersigned, its successors and assigns until such time as it is modified or released in the manner provided herein. D. These covenants are to run with the land and 'shall be binding on all parties and all persons claiming under them for a period of 30 years from the date of recordation, after which time they shall be extended automatically for successive periods of- ten years, unless an instrument signed by a majority of the then owner(s) of the property has been recorded which changes or releases the covenants in whole, or in part, provided that the covenants have been released or the changes approved by the Mitt of Miami Commission after a public hearing. if the Zoning district or the regulations applicable to all the properties on r South Dayshore Drive between S. E. 1.4th Street and s. S. _15th' Rood should change to permit any structure within such arse t+b b+� used totally for offices, banks, or commercial uses, or oombina-.'_ Lions thereof, or if the permitted F4R applicable to such srs, nF 12000 ?tW f increases above that presently permitted, the subject property shall be relieved of the limitations contained herein which are more restrictive than the new district or regulations. The recordation among the Public Records of Dade County, Florida, of an Affidavit or Certificate from the City Attorney of the City of Miami that such changes in the City of Miami ordinances have been Made will be sufficient to place all persons on notice that such changes have modified these covenants. g, This Declaration of restrictive Covenants may be modified, amended or released as to the land herein described, or any portion thereof, by a written instrument executed by the then owners of the fee simple title to the lands to be affected by such modification, amendment or release, provided that the same has first been approved by the Point View Association, Inc., and then by the City Commission after public hearing. P. Should this Declaration of Restrictive Covenants be to modified, amended or released, the Director of the City of Miami Building a zoning Department, or his successor, shall forthwith execute a written instrument effectuating and acknowledging such modification, amendment or release. G. Enforcement shall be by action at law or in equity. against any parties or persons violating, or attempting to violate any covenants, either to restrain violation or to recover damages. If any suit be brought for such enforcement the enforcing party, if successful, shall be entitled to recover, in addition to costs and disbursements allowed by law, such sum as the Court may adjudge to be reasonable for the services of his attorney. H. invalidation of any one of these covenants, by judgment or Court, in no. wise shall affect any of the other provisions which shall remain in full force and effect. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the owner has caused these presents to be executed and signed in its name by its proper officers, and its corporate seal to be affixed hereto and atteste8 to by its Secretary the day and year set forth. WITNESSES: CUCUSA, r' MOD PL2472 STATE OP p'tOluoh y ss COUNTY or DADS day of �J+�i: • ► 19� I HERE CEATIPY that on this before -iris personally .appeared ttAY CORONA and RICARDO pr sidsnt and Secretary, respectively, of COCUSA, INC., a corpo- ration under the lawns of the State of Plorida, to me known to be the persons who signed the foregoing instrument as such offioers and severally acknowledged the execution thereof to be their free act and deed as such officers for the uses tandhe purposes u o l seal thereon in mentioned, and that they affixed then eto said corporation, and that the said instrument is the act and dc`ed of said Corporation. WITNESS my hand aforesaid. My Commission Expires: and official seal the day and year last APPROVED AS TO -FORM AND CORRECTNESS: O*A4�k-4 C .Attorney STATS O Prepared by: Janet Lenore Cooper, Attorney CES OF JAM L. COOPER LAW OFFI Suite 1020 169 East Flagler Street Miami, Florida 33131 f as w Y {T l il's J 1 i y n* - FL r ai{ AND DAILY MCORD Nbitthad Daily exes0t $atu►day. $uhdiy tltld � : Lb�ai Fifflitlayb �Y 4 ��T' t, ?- Miami, Dad6 Lbunty, Florida. _ Tom' •s 3 tMUWN DR DADft: tlitfi 0 the linditIPbd autlterity pbtstlilrllly appirircad ,'.r;,' _ to the stow, wtta ah bath tale the this it thb Abbibttaht to iha pubtlmw at ft Miami 1%6~ imid Daily MOW. a deity .. .: (aictsipt;8ilt jr._AunWy and U461 "Ida") h wtpaptr ` ifahafi tit IN W>rdd in D** County, Fl Wig #M *4 atlabhed J` irr ..- ab¢yti t101fafttafitalti, ti" a t,"pl AhwMbi�«t of Petke - a`:; fret t MW=No. 0701 v.t .......................... Court, t. wait th "m nawapapar Na in Itaura of pee Atflart hutMr stirs 04. de sold Miami Renew and gaol tiatotd ire publMlwd .at,idiami in Id Dada COW% pibsldw ;ind *aid;: "Ow"AW ha harratofon .ban . oantwroauih:pubibbad`in am Dadi f l M" aeh dh► . eatpt:abpd•y.`-t;unday,snd'.LapdCN�� tmd Na ban r 4 as 46*w': oiaal fmo _ maltor at poet ottioa In - .: Miainl' ,sbid fitda Cowdy f MI'la. for a period of are ysa " s aMpd": � 1ha. fh+tt; of tM atgated MINt'atlsaya am a4pun�Mai► #01und for the p1mme of snow" We TM 84 j vl * • pn0ao, t a at lafga 2. a: iG r} W " �h e tx r IV dK ,''?�:;a. ' : � . .� � e'%�z;?..p: �H: � s r _F _ fit- : {,, fi � j. �'�"s �,ry f:. '_�•'sa .�� � ;� �' I 6,.Mi r � ` Y"'' F ._t;k +•'t Y7 ry- : - it fxs,�tsrts;lS f4.`:;�1 <�-' ="a'''� :[.t. -( , _� •a ,x,^•,"- a } 3 - a�C�; *,`';�f'�"r'+f f,.•;�, s �, -,, - .:' t L :4 _"',x ,i .• :x.n+ x' } - x'' < �, -�^ L'f,^`•T,. Fi�<>'r.,`<r:'+t�'u "':g.: :r`-f�5 ,',.�'v.,...;t....`-`u#"T'7.: _. MIAMI REVIEW k A AND DAILY RECORD Published Daily except Saturday, Sunday and A Legal Holidays b Miami, Dade County, Florida. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF DADE, Before the undersigned authority personally appeared Karen Pellom, who on oath says that she Is Assistant to the Supervisor, Legal Advertising of the Miami Review and Daily Record, a daily (except Saturday, Sunday and Legal Holidays) N newspaper, published at Miami in Dade County, Florida; that the attached copy of adverilsomml, being a Legal AdWflaenwnt P of Notice In the matter of CITY OF MIAMI RE: ORDINANCE NO. 9791 V ........ . X X X Court, - In the ................................ was published in said newspaper In the Issues of - Feb.2, 1984 — Affiant further says that the said Miami Review and Daily Record is a nsw"M published at Miami In sad Dade County, Florida, and that tt he said newspaper has heretofore been continuously published in said Dada Coun , Florida, each City (except. Saturday, Sunday and of and has boon entered as sseond class er a post office 1n Miami in said Dade C py, Florida, for a thher of one nut t aireRani further tion j tho aft that paid nor any. discount, ;hil Secwirq this qL............ siQiserlboctbefore me this 2nd s',Fe .'.�t. A.D. to ... brooks is of Florida at Large (BE E �.�h►i��+�"►a June t, 1i107. rooks a of Florida at Large list', (SEAL) My Commission expires June 1. 1987. MR 68 Roo ORDINANCE NO. 9784 AN ORDINANCE PROVIDING FOR THE HOLDING OFASPE.r CIAL MUNICIPAL ELECTION IN THE CITY,OF MIAMI:4-FLOR-`.-'- IDA, ON MARCH 13,19841 WITH RESPECTi,-*TO.THB.ISSIJ�'`'.�- ANCE OF $35,000,000 PARK AND RECREATIOWFACILMES,:>- BONDS. ORDINANCE NO.9785. AN ORDINANCE AUTHORIZING THE TO THE' ELECTION HEREIN PROVIQFQrcTQF(--$ fZ- SOUTHEAST OVERTOWN/PARKW '? �, �, .......... oil &I k i It 14 ---------- A 4r; A., Vr.:mrr¢Ka�4[se ar eel S QRAN9� TIES. PROVlRIN ;QFITHS LO u p VA60R�M TS TO PA`l,S�CH,:lQ r ORQINANCE NO INC I`OR TMS Mo�OIN4 F�R:�,as ; AN QRQI�IANl PRQ�IR- k CIAI, M.UmIGIPAl; EIA TION tN TMIr aPF Q� M! 1 t 10A. ON MAMON WIT) I RS& SI E:OF 45 pm 000 MIAMI EANIZJ►TIONONp$f:. 4}gam, ZONING AN ORDIH#A Tk g-zo@ l 0001"Off HOC NI�NO 141 O.FMlAMl� �#�4RlRAr,�� Gl�A�1�ll����# FIGAT►ON O,AI f �..11AN 1ppI►�#s E�pppp l st'tl �l Ito �Ml " Fl4 PAN INA FINOIN�$. �F� - 44 A sPl OFF aIIi.<' PubIi aln Of 49 ':!0