Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutSubmittal-Elvis Cruz-PowerPoint PresentationSubmitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Morningside Park Shoreline Item PA-1 Personal Appearance by Elvis Cruz Miami City Commission Thursday, April 13, 2023 1 13034-Submittal-Elvis Cruz- PowerPoint Presentation Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Miami 21 Baywalk Ordinance 2 r • r . r .r. 7.4 }f 16 MAYBE 2F—,.. get e frreNg Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Miami 21 Baywalk Ordinance 1.10111•1•11.0 ♦ =s ♦ it ♦ t • t fw Fr • }i • ]t 1 �y� �m't b'� tY �1 •• r ZS' IV • 31 • —.•. �r�sp111 • it ♦ 16' Mill, FVFI MAYBE ♦ ffi e ICY ffi SUS ulgvR RAW N 23 feet inland 4 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 77 feet inland Ion Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Marked Agenda April 14, 2022 ',omm►`ssion NA - NON -AGENDA ITEM(S) DIRECTIVE DIRECTION BY COMMISSIONER RUSSELL TO THE CITY MANAGER TO BRING BACK AN ITEM REGARDING THE MORNINGSIDE PARK MASTER PLAN AND ITS SHORELINE FOR THE APRIL 28, 2022 CITY COMMISSION MEETING. RESULT: DISCUSSED 5 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk SHOREUNE TRNL STABIUZED AGGREGATE. 3D SHOREUNE PROTECTION SYSTEM. SECTION B SCALE: 1- = Page 31, CG-302 7 ets- EXISTING CORAL STONES TO REMAIN UNDISTURBED Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk EXIS11NG PROFILE GRADE UNE NOT TO BE DISTURBED. +3.14 DESIGN WATER TABLE * 0.00 NAVD EL -1.99' MLW THIS REM HAS BEEN DIGITALLY SIGNED AND SEALED BY R. HARVEY SASSO ON THE DATE ADJACENT TO THE SEAL PRINTED COPIES OF THIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT CONSIDER SIGNED AND SEALED MD SIGNATURE MUST BE VERIFIED ON MY ELECTRONIC COPIES. 100% DRAWINGS 12022.11.30 1' 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 SHOREUNE TRAIL STABIUZED AGGREGATE. 3D SHOREUNE PROTECTION SYSTEM. Page 31, CG-302 SECTION B SCALE; 1- = 4'-D 8 ets- EXISTING CORAL STONES TO REMAIN UNDISTURBED Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk EXIS11NG PROFILE GRADE UNE NOT TO BE DISTURBED. 0+3.14 DESIGN WATER TABLE 40.00 NAVD EL -1.99' MLW THIS REM HAS BEEN DIGITALLY SIGNED AND SEALED BY R. HARVEY SASSO ON THE DATE ADJACENT TO THE SEAL PRINTED COPIES OF THIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT CONSIDER SIGNED AND SEALED MD SIGNATURE MUST BE VERIFIED ON ANY ELECTRONIC COPIES. 100% DRAWINGS 12022.11.30 I' SHOREUNE TRAIL STABIUZED AGGREGATE. 3D SHOREUNE PROTECTION SYSTEM. SECTION SCALE: 1- = Page 31, CG-302 ets- 2.04' 9 EXISTING CORAL STONES TO Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk REMAIN UNDISTURBED EXISTING PROFILE GRADE UNE NOT TO BE DISTURBED. +3.14 DESIGN WATER TABLE * 0.00 NAVD EL -1.99' MLW THIS REM HAS BEEN DIGITALLY SIGNED AND SEALED BY R. HARVEY SASSO ON THE DATE ADJACENT TO THE SEAL PRINTED COPIES OF THIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT CONSIDER SIGNED AND SEALED AND SIGNATURE MUST BE VERIFIED ON MY ELECTRONIC COPIES. 100% DRAWINGS 12022.11.30 SHOREUNE TRAIL STABIUZED AGGREGATE. 3D SHOREUNE PROTECTION SYSTEM. SEC ION B SCALE 1' = 4'-0" Page 31, CG-302 10 ets- EXISTING CORAL STONES T REMAIN UNDISTURBED Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk EXISTING PROFILE GRADE UNE NOT TO BE DISTURBED. eli,+3.14 DESIGN 'WATER TABLE *0.00 NAND THIS I1EM HAS BEEN DIGITALLY SIGNED AND SEALED BY R. HARVEY SASSO ON THE DATE ADJACENT TO THE SEAL. PRINTED COPIES OF THIS DOCUMENT ARE NOT CONSIDER SIGNED AND SEALED AND SIGNATURE MUST BE VERIFIED ON ANY ELECTRONIC COPIES. 100% DRAWINGS 12022.11.30 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 15° YIN. BkAINIK :GATE MOE seawall • SHEETPILE wire 1 1 1 f 23 feet inland 12 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk r EXISTING CORAL STONES TO I IWJN UNDISTURBED EL +O.16' WHO/ 1 1 1 SALE 13 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for bcm(o) 9A.l , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk _ - ...- r• r r -. ,r r - r -. . - 1, C rr�rs--.r �-v eft- AMAM1_ 21i2.23 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , 4 3/. 02 . City Clerk r�- 1 /77&42- , 1 x 2. i2. 23' ¶:3& wiallittl Ia.-, � •. _.r.Ji.�'`4VV dI � loft.aillis -..-x.`cir, :',-- : 4, .._.1.1.11,,1"....."`PPasseer l'--------311"---mmt - 711"....-..m....=6;,(..-141111111111611111nnia-Villinir---"- A 1 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , n 4/1 21 3 . City Clerk ONCREIE BULKHEAD dN UNDISTURBED 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 , I • • REMOVE EXISTING -- SANITARY SLIVER MANHOLE AND EIOTIN0 B- wrier SEWER LINE. REMUaE EXISTING SANITARY SEWER MANHOLE AND EXISTING 8' SANITARY SEWER LINE REMOVE 704 IF OF SANITARY SETTER EINE AND 3 SANITARY NH. REMOVE ALL EXIST. WOOD BOLARDS WITHIN THE DEMOLITION ARM, TOP. SAW CUT & REMOVE 89 LF OF BEING CONCRETE CURDS WITHIN THE ENTRANCE ISLAND. SAW CIIT & REMOVE 66 LF OF EXISTING CONCRETE CURBS WITHIN THE CONSTRUCTKMl LMITS. 1/ EXISTING 8' SANIRATY LINE TO BE ABANDONED. CUT AT PLUG AT CONSTRUCTION Lr165, AND REMOVE EXISTING I" SANITARY SEWER UNE TO THE EAST OF THE CONSTRUCTION UNITS. 18 _ I f/ EXISTING VEGETATION, TYP. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk MHW LINE (+0.16' SAVDO PAC • A r r: Id I AS SHOWN WITHIN THE HARMONIZATION AREA AND THE SHORELINE PROJECT AREA. Z I1 11 PROPOSED HARMONIZATION AREA FROM THE SHORELINE PROJECT OONSTRUUCIIION LIMITS TO THE CONSTRUCTION REMOVE All EXIST. PAVEMENT, ASPHALT, CONCRETE, AND PAVERS, AS SHOWN WITHIN THE HARMONIZATION AREA AND THE SHORELINE PROJECT AREA. PROPOSED PARK IMPROVEMENT PROJECT. NOT A PART OF THE SHORELINE PROJECT. PROPOSED PARK IMPROVEMENT PROJECT. NOT A PART OF THE SHORELINE PROJECT. e 67, D-1( _ DEMOLITION PLAN - 1 SCALE I' = 20' 1■ ■ • • • • • THIS MEN FINS BEEN IACMALLY NCNB AM RAMJET STSO ON TTE DATE N)NCEN6 TO PINNED COPIES OF 1N6 DOLTYENE NNE IN SIGNED AND SEAM AND SIGNATURE MUST NM ELECTRONIC DIMES ONCREIE BULKHEAD dN UNDISTURBED 11 11 1r 11 11 ITTS 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 • • REMOVE EXISTING SANITARY SEWER MANHOLE AND ECIOTIN0 B• SANITARY SEWER LINE. REMOVE EXISTING SANITARY SEWER MANHOLE AND E70SHHG 8' SANTARY SEWER LINE. REMOVE 704 IF OF SANITARY SEWER LINE AND 3 SANTARY NH. REMOVE ALL EXIST. WOOD BOIAR05 WITHIN THE DEMOLITION ORFR, T1P. SAW CUT & REMOVE 89 LF OF EXISTING CONCRETE CURBS WITHIN THE ENTRANCE ISLAND. SAW CUT & REMOVE 66 LF OF E705TING CONCRETE CURBS WITHIN THE CONSTRUCTKMI LMITS. 1/ EXISTING 8' SANIRATY LANE TO BE ABANDONED. CUT AT PLUG AT CONSTRUCTION L1ITTS, AND REMOVE EXISTING B" SANITARY SEWER UNE TO THE EAST OF THE CONSTRUCTION UNITS. 19 f/ EXISTING VEGETATION, TYP. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk NNW LINE (+0.16' NAND) o REMOVE ALL EXIST. CONCRETE PAVEMENT AS SHOWN WITHIN THE HARMONIZATION AREA AND THE SHORELNE PROJECT AREA. PROPOSED HARMONIZATION AREA, FROM THE SHORELINE PROJECT OONSTRUCIION UNITS TO THE CONSTRUCTION REMOVE All EXIST. PAVEMENT, ASPHALT, CONCRETE, AND PAVERS, AS SHOWN WITHIN THE HARMONIZATION AREA AND THE SHORELINE PROJECT AREA. PROPOSED PICK IMPROVEMENT PROJECT. NOT A PART OF THE SHORELNE PROJECT. PROPOSED PARK INPNO'JEMENT PROJECT. NOT A PART OF THE SHORELNE PROJECT. e 67, D-1( _ DEMOLITION PLAN - 1 SCALE'. I' - 20' 1 1 1 A[ T,n 1 1Q z 2 r THIS HEN FINS BEEN DIGITALLY SIGNER A HARVEY SASSO ON TT DATE ADJACENT TO 1 PENNED COPIES OF EIS DOCTYEHE THE M &ONTO AND Wan AHO SENATLHE MUST me ELECTRONIC DORM t>• IR]1GYE ALL EMIET. PAYE4EMt ASPHALT, rnlCRET'' ME PAVERS, AS S THN WRWN THE HARNd PROJECT AREA MIO THE SH01&LNE PREJET.T MFA AN\ PROPOSED H4MGNffRflON NNNN FREN EIE SNEREANE PRGECT GCN5IRHGIgN lRillS TO THE CONSTRUCTOR PAOPC L NOT MITWINNOYF ENE 111E SHORELTN NOT A PARE OF 71E SHERFLNE PRGIECT. lE_age 68 D-1 PROJEL7. NOT A MU OF THE SHORELINE PRJIEGF. � 1 1 SCALE T• = zo'-E° yT ROJCNE EIISBNG SANBNRY giyEN WSE IE NNE FaISRNC 8- f' srwrzm sg1EI{ uxe, FEMME ALL DIT. 1Vore MUMS WT(NIN E OEMONNMI AREA, TYR. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk • a >FAGE RESERVE MOW 9 S"NRATt ENE TO BE A kADONED. CHIT AT PLUS AT CONSTRUCTION u41T, AND FROWNS DIETING B' ART SEVER LINE TO ITE H THE IT OF THE CONSTRUCTION LINTS • • CIO Dorm (I PARK 1 RENW6 To BE MIMEO, 111 REMOVE ELT EAST GDNHCRETE AS SITYON RTRIIN IRE EVRNONLATRNI ND AND TIE BHOREHNE PROJECT MR r; pp. AO\` PROPOSED HIDV ITDRTICN MET, FROM THE SIERFEINF PROJECT CONSIRHCIEON LINTS TO THE CCNSIIUCIION PENT ROJECT. PANN INISTOYF THE SPERU NOT IE ET. OF 11E SHDRFLNE PRWECT. e68, D J SCALE I• =111.111111111111111.1.111111111111 MINE ALL EMIST. PAYEDENT, ASPNEE E, MO PAVERS. PAYERS, AS 9RTPPNI N UN THE RAIsoatIDIN AREA NIB THE SHORELINE PROJECT AREA t>• i PIRA ELT. NOT A PARE OF 1HE SHORELINE PROJECT. ft yT R➢IQRE EXIllhl SANRNfY � XEAIPIDTE :DART EXOTIC 8- / srwrzm sq�R IDE /f RETIRE ALL DET. MICR BOLEROS WHIN THE WNDNI91 ILEA, TYR. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 1 a WAGE RESEPvc EOSTRJE R. ROMP UNE TO BE ABUBONEO. CUT AT PLOS AT CONSTRUCTION 114ID, AND REUPAE CDISTPE B' SE NTART SEWS LINE TO THE NMI OF THE CONSTRUCILDN U4I5. • • • ••• •••••. - 6 _ , • - • •••••.• • Mar- -4 *mow' qo • 111 • I • 4'. • • •161•.-- 22 4 4116, • , 4 ' - 1.4 Submitted into the p record for item(s) on 4/13/2023 . 4 - r • Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 City Clerk Submitted into the public record for ite t (s) PA.1 , on 4/13/20.3 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 27 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 15' MIN. BAYWALK BAYIIVALK. AGGREGATE 1 FINISH GRADE CS WI 82, WOO RAE MINN Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 29 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Existing trees to remain 41Kr .4.6. 3' wide Seawall, at 6 feet NAVD 6 foot wide path Area for picnic tables Berm, raised 2 - 3 feet Existing ground level 33 12 inch face Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Existing imestone blocks Add boulders Bay Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 2020, Pallot Park 34 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Sustainability & Maintenance Bryant Park - Lake Worth Lagoon, Palm Beach County: Completed 2012 Funded by Palm Beach County and National Endowment for the Arts 20 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Seawall Elevations and King Tides — 2070 with 24" SLR Planning Assumption: 21" — 40" of SLR by 2070 Seawall Height South of Rickenbacker 4.45 Causeway (6' NGVD29) (North of 3.45 Rickenbacker (5' NGVD29 Causeway) Current (2019) Conditions King Tide (10/5/2017) Avg high tide (MHHW) Avg low tide (MLLW) ALL DATA IN NAVD88 Year 2070 with 21" SLR Poial King Tides 4.03 Avg high tide (MHHW) Avg low tide (MLLW) Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk What do your constituents want? 38 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 2,1 00 petition s�aa,�ITTE���© a THE pTTED 0i signatures �n���J '� ©rni..w- - a, softball TO Preserve M is. We want it histoncagroun 11 fief , the way court OM next to the s, petition Side park d tennis convenient beach volleyball, etc. love Morning the basketball, an With cony undersigned, ant to kee loo for boats, We the un en it ,scenic launching tor mo pate t it redesi netl. We want lawn not want anal P eaSe tx an chicarea, boat ramp Signed �� Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Morningside Park Survey Q2. Should the perimeter fence that lines the north and west sides of the park be removed? Answer Choices Yes No 16.56% 83.44% Q3. Would you support additional parking on the swale along the west side of the park on 7th Avenue? Answer Choices Yes No 32.21% 67.79% Q4. Should the loop road remain as configured, or should it be the subject of possible redesign? Answer Choices Leave as is Possible redesign 58.82% 41.18% Q5. If a redesign of the loop road includes the relocation or removal of parking spaces, should the current total number of parking spaces within the park be maintained, reduced, or increased? Answer Choices Maintained 76.55% Reduced 19.31% Increased 4.14% 40 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Q4. Should the loop road remain as configured, or should it be the subject of possible redesign? Answer Choices Leave as is Possible redesign 01. 58.82% 41.18% 41 ark Amenities and Character Biscayne Bay Morningside Park - General Plan 1 Concepts Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Retain existinc r character of the park Keep boat launch ramp Repair/ renovated pool Remove bollards Add basketball court Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk PUBLIC WORKSHOP COMMENTS ark Amenities and Character ■ Keep park as is, but replace and repair as needed ■ Repair, renova e and reopen existing pool ■ Fix/improve existing restrooms ■ Remove wood bollards ■ Provide small dog park/run ■ Focus on waterfront uses No one asked for the seawall to be set back. 22 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk November 29, 2021 Community Meeting 90% voted to keep the loop road as is. 44 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk A new petition currently has 491 signatures. Petition To Keep Morningside Park's Facilities In Place The City of Miami's plan for Morningside Park would harm public enjoyment and waste money. We prefer: 1. Build a new pool in the same location as the old pool, to avoid demolishing, relocating and rebuilding eight other facilities. 2. Keep the existing double-laned loop road, parking Tots, picnic area restroom and palm garden right where they have been since 1953. 3. Place the new seawall bulkhead along the shoreline, with no marsh grass, to keep the existing open grassy picnic area along the waterfront, then a 6 foot -wide walkway. Name (please print) Address Signed Date 1 45 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Morningside Park Master Plan Survey 2022 Start: Saturday, March 05, 2022 End: Wednesday, March 09, 2022 We need your vote Go to poll page POLL DESCRIPTION: The Morningside Parks Committee has formulated a poll to better understand the views of MCA members on the conceptual park master plan, proposed by the City early this year in 2022, and posted on the MCA website HERE. The "Item" numbers referenced in the survey refer 46 Morningside Civic Association 2023 Board Election Results !.'1P7U PAOR3NRNGSZDE sr�.La C.N1G i�1! aS�t}C:IAT�},l "" District 1 2-Year Seat . 29-Jan ar y vote ata Gina Ragnono 5 3 - trict 2 (2 Year Seat) "Mimi. Andrew Parker 0 District 3 (2 Year Seat) Bette Ann Fialkov 1 5 trict 4 (2: Year Seat Daniel Maland 2 5 i■ i,iKr. Tatiana Loza 1 4 District 6 (2 Year Seat) Neil Robertson At Large [1 Year Seat) 3 4 Javier Fornaris-Pau 10 18 28 Lauren Desai 10 47 13 23 Nabil Haschemie 9 12 21 Jonathan Raiffe 10 16 6, Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk 35 total votes from 420 houses Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk A small minority wants the current plan. But Morningside Park belongs to the entire city, not just Morningside 48 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk The uses of the basin continued to evolve through the Virginia Key Masterplan. All master plans mention and/or provide recommendations that mention boating recreational infrastructure The restoration of the Boat Ramp will impact (removal) approximately 2,759 square feet of seagrass, 486 square feet of mangrove scrub, and 385 square feet of mangrove canopy. On February 17, 2021, the Miami- A.Pemas 10/ 18/2022 Miami Marine Stadium, PZ-22-14696 Page 4 of 6 Dade Department of Regulatory and Economic Resources (DERM) issued a 'Notice to File" on permit CLI- 2019-0115. On this notice, the Environmental Resources section noted the difficulties of mitisatin. these impacts due to "current site conditions", As such, Environmental Enhancement Trust Fund for the creation of enhancement of a marine habitat located within Biscayne Bay. Furthermore, a $7,200.00 mitigatfb`t1 bond is held by DERM. DERM accepted a contribution to the Biscayne Bay Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Morningside already has 2.5 acres of mangrove swamp in the middle of the park. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Daniel Maland Jonathan Raiffe 51 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk PROPOSED CONCRETE BULKHEAD +6.00 COASTAL & TIDAL PLANTS HYBRID SHORELINE — DISTANCE VARIES 52 EXIST. CORAL STONE BLOCKS TO RELWU UNDISTURBED KING TIDE +0.26' lift . �L1 198' M EXISTING SHORELINE Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Construction delay? • The City dragged its feet. • The City planned things the public did not ask for and does not want. • The plan goes against the City's own design concepts. • Not protect the shoreline or the concession building. • Prevent the new pool from being built in the same place. • Removes full grown trees. • Would be more expensive. • Higher maintenance. 54 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Getting it done RIGHT is much more important than getting it done right away. 55 Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Item RE-3: Funding, even though the City said they'd have another public meeting before moving forward with a plan. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 City Clerk Pass RE-3 with the requirements to: Put the seawall along the shoreline, with 3 or 4 access areas. Keep the loop road and pool location as is that's what your constituents want. Make the walkway 6 feet wide, to maximize Screen space. Submitted into the public record for item(s) PA.1 , on 4/13/2023 . City Clerk Thank you. 58