Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-89-0305i J-89Y-249(b) -� 3/7/89 RESOLUTION NO6 89-305 A RESOLUTION REVERSING THE DECISION OF THE ZONING BOARD AND DENYING A VARIANCE PROM ORDINANCE 9500 AS AMENDED, SCHEDULE OF DISTRICT REGULATIONS. PAGE 1 OF 6, MINIMUM OPEN SPACE REQUIREMENTS, TO ALLOW THE GARAGE ADDITION TO AN EXISTING SINGLE-FAMILY RESIDENCE PROVIDING AN INTERIOR SIDE YARD OF - l'1" (5' MINIMUM SIDE YARD REQUIRED) AND AN = OVERHANG. WITHIN '0'•1" OF. THE PROPERTY: LINE; (2'6" MINIMUM SETBACK FROM PROPERTY LINE REQUIRED) FOR _PROPERTY LOCATED AT 3893- PARK AVENUE (MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN), AS PER PLANS.ON FILE; ZONED RS-2/2 ONE FAMILY DETACHED RESIDENTIAL. _ i- = WHEREAS, the Miami Zoning Board, at its meeting of - February 6, 1989, Item 2, following an advertised hearing, adopted- Resolution ZB 19-89 by a nine to' -zero vote (9 - 0), granting a variance from Ordinance 9500, as amended,' the Zoning _ Ordinance .of the City of Miami, Schedule of District.Regulations Page 1`-of 6.Minimum Open Space Requirements,'to allow,the garage addition - to* an existing single-family residence providing an interior'.side yard of 1'1" (5'`minimum side yard required). and�'an - _ overhang within 011" of the property line (216" minimum setback from property line required) for property >''loCetedat 3893`Park Avenue, also described as Lot 9,'' BRAGANZA PARR, =. according'.. to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 76, at Page 17,.=-of the Public Records of Dade County, Florida; as per plans on file; zoned RS-2/2 One -Family Detached Residential, with - a. timet limitation of twelve (12) months in which a building permit ,must. be obtained; and WHEREAS- a citizen has taken an appeal to the City Commission from approval of the variance; and`^_ :the 'City ?Commissiony after careful consideration of, this matter and; notwithstanding the decision of the Miami Zoning ¢ . Board,. finds,• -that there are no peculiar' circumetance's .affecting >t A 3A- t !k *, � �yhyp�p; 1144i rt� 1 F j t 1 y 7 JF+ = ; = 1 this parcel of land nor any practical difficulties and unnecessary hardships which would impair the owner's right to the reasonable use of the property without the grant of variance as required) for property located Set forth; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OP THE CI TY. OF MIAMI, FLORIDA: Section 1. The decision of the Zoning Board in this matter is reversed and the request for variance from Ordinance 9500, as amended, the Zoning Ordinance of the City of Miami, Schedule of District Regulations, Page 1 of 6, Minimum Open Space Requirements, to allow the garage addition to an existing single - family residence providing an interior side yard of 1'1" (5' minimum side yard required) and an overhang within 0'1" of the property line (2'6" minimum setback from property line at 3893 Park Avenue, also sue; described as Lot 9, BRAGANZA PARK, according to the plat thereof, as recorded in Plat Book 76, at Page 17, of the Public Records-of 'Dade County, Florida; as per ,plans on file; zoned RS -2 One - Family Detached Residential, is hereby denied. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 23rd day of March ATT MATT HIRAI City Clerk .PREPARED AND APPROVED BY: Nitit A XI 0 1, G. MIRIAM MAER Assistant City Attorney APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS ataquitii .TORGE - L, F City Atto XAVIER L. SUARE • LOCATION /LEGAL ZONING FACT SHEET 3893 Park Avenue Lot 9 BRAGANZA PARK (76 -17) P.R.D.C. APPLICANT /OWNER Robert and Cindy Lederman 15020 SW 89 Terrace Road Miami, FL 33196 PZ17 ZONING RS-2/2 One Family Detached Residential.: REQUEST Variance "from Ordinance '9500,' as amendedthe Zoning Ordinance of the City of,.Miami, „Schedule of` District Regulations,,; Page 1 of 6;, #riip Open Space Requirements, ` to allow . the garage addition to, an, existing single familY on :.above' sit e, as per plans on file, providing. an interior side yard of 1'1 " (5' minima: side; yard required). and an overhang.within:; the property line . (2'6” minimum setback :`f property_ line required). RECOMMENDATIONS PLANNING DEPARTMENT DENIAL. There is no hardship to justify; : t he requested variance to allow the garage addition to the existing single family" residence. providing an interior side yard of . 1' --1 ": instead of the required five foot (5: -D ") ' minimt setback, and an overhang within 0° of property line, (2'-6" minimum setback' frets ., t '. property line required). There are no_,speci.al conditions and circumstances which are peculiar to the land or building involved which:-4 not applicable to other" lands or build :inga the same zoning district: conditions and'_ circumstances a0.4 dir ct' ire 1 from the actions " of ':"the petit ones :.interpretation _. of the : plrovi oiae ::Ordinance '9500' would of: nights commonly; enjoyed by o, d the same zoning dietr,.i this - Zoning Ordinance :" `;and iii unnecessary aa undo petitioner. Granting thy :')iar wool. .onfer`': 'o ::the ;petit. privilege: .:. ' .... { ".: Ordinance A • ■ , • • • • • • . . • . . • r PUBLIC WORKS • COUNTY TRAFFIC AND TRANSPORTATION No comment. No comments. _ ..-,.- • , , , • . . ZONING BOARD ; . At . its meeting • of February, 6 ,- ..-..:,:. -,-..,..,,,....:„ '-i.,,,:..,...... -._••.,, '. Zoning - Board adopted -'Resolution - ZB.:,19. 9 • . • •• • ,-_, by ::a 9 to tO vote, approving .' ...,. .• • ,...,:-.. -• -, -,: - . ,,..,„• ••:- F '/:k.::;<4,;-:,..+4',-:=_ -::-.-:: ' . .'.-: 5 ,-, . . • • - - - ' :- ` -:-, Two proponents and two-o.pponent:v ••••, ...• ,. • _ .. ••,....._ ••..,•,.._ ,": presenV-at_:-.the: ,... , ,_•,..„„.„,....,,, . - - ,.,,,,. • , t. , , , ,•C.Ti: ..,-•";',:,_ Two replies in favor five, objectio were received by ARPEAL. Letter dated February 21, 1989, from J = 11-...mcmastett.,. • • • . • . • • -1 • , • _ ■ " , v .. „;. "‘ • . • • • ' . ,. • " • a a —a te. 10 II CIRCLE , 15: • ;,' AOJ • B RAGANZA PARK A V • -a z3 39 110 9$ z 24 is 1113' 4t 144/ 1911117196 CD a 29 94 Cg 27 19 - nal to. et • ot • 1 • D ED • R E ET 'nu : S • List V 4 36 23 39 0 se " 107 12 • ROWELL • SUS. TR.1 — 13 ISO 30 S III 461. 4**1s 4 IS NA 114 LIPIA Itllat ill r �:7tiar ` >o ° x L i.I r IYY!°i— ii • t i . • PETITION FOR VARIANCE' �� ''�`' il ` ititlr bcr V— A variance is relaxation of the terms of the ordinance where such aeon leek t ,. / to the public interest and where, owing to conditions pecutior Sao ; property and not the result of actions of the applicant, literal iinforeernini y ordinance would result in unnecessary, and undue hardship on the property: this ordinance, a variance is authorized only for height, area, die of dimensions of yards arid other open spaces and of fstr set parking or requirements. (Section 3101) We , Robett Ledei non & Cindy S. Lederman' • hereby petition the ;City of Mimi �`Zflh Board tor. a variance. tram the • terms of ..the "Zoning Order of the Citjr. , ., affecting property located at-_ .38 Park Avenue, • specified below. In support of this application, the following materiel is submitted=with this°,appii� ..P Two,:copies of a survey. of by d =Stole Hof Hart Land Surveyor. 2. Four copies -of: the site plan showing (as. required) ;,af : any): and; proposed; ), ,parking, °landscaping and dimensions computation: of lot area (grass cndnet), ratios, and height envelope. 3. Affidavits disclosing ownership :of:•propertr covered of: interest form (Forms X83 and 4083, !attach to "eppl 'catkin ): 4. Certified list of owners of real essare .375':: radius: :from : .boundaries of property covered by this application. (Form.: c S. At least two photographs that snow the entire property (land cr t im 6. Other (Speci /y) 7. Fee of $ '00 ' to apply toward the cost of processin o)' RS, RC•1 For penetration of Plane by anteing and the like All other,applicatio4 for Ien1 L ,r.e�;.�_ 11 Ill IfL9NIVl�(6l -�7 & Tho . Vdirionce' requested is for relief from the provisions of Section • the City of Miami Zoning Ordinance as foliows: ;, A . , `l a F • ** Schedule of District Regulations, Page 1 of 6, Minimum Open Space Requirements: 5.0 feet required ,plc d }^ 1.0 inch requested for interior side lot line r ro ert s-o t+P ter I : A e ;. _z ".,�sT•.c� - •sf O Sz +Y;�c.k f / C C - ne.T G 14 =6.s r :d ) 9. In support , of this application, the applicant is prepared to offer evidence, on the point enumerated at Subsection 3103.1 of the Ci Zoning Ordinances Note : This application- cannot be accepted for ; Zoning : ..B following six: items are .completed. , X (a) Special . conditions and circumstances exist which are peculiar structure, or building ; involved ,and which are not ,applicable t structures, or buildings in the same zoning district In be produced and use additional° sheets, if necessary.) The unique character and peculiar shape of the lot :,( expanding pie wedge shape) significantly limits the bes of the land and restricts the nature and extent ; .of`'the, ments buildable to a lesser use than is reasonable for location of the property and the size of the lot. ;: Thene for security is not met by the current structure and arran LAO it III J III 01 - _® (e) The. variance, if granted, is the minimum.yari reasonable use of'the land, building,oriet Rather ' than ` demolish a . bedroom and ..reques petitioners could ive, made ,Pia _. to 'doh:. no structure ... e? t h two; `v4kr ances , :(f roi t To keep', the requestto'',a =r inimum, . petit one aadrifiOe ; axe.: existing `,b Broom e .uar aflc minimum needed to;tital a pose#. l' structure axid and .afro (d) Granting the variance requested will not confer on ,the the petitioner , any,speE jtil privilege that,.. is denied by the Zoning Ordinance to other lands, buildin or structures in the same zoning district in that: The petitioners, at sacrifice to themselves and the proper have formed plans . that only require a single :variance achieve' this, petitioners plans call for °. the :demolition �Yo bedroom in the structure Due to the unique, s nap. of the lot . and of 'the structure- petitioners require; the f :. requested variance. • Cr FlEt,P•' X (c) Literal interpretation of the provisions of the zoning ordinance would deprive . . the applicant otrrJghtsl q°i I enjoyed by other properties in the same zoning district der 'the terms of the zoning ordinance and would work unnecessary and undue hardships on the petitioner in that: The petitioners are unable to enjoy the full and..complet use of the property due to structural deficiencies impose by the shape limitations of the lot. The security . needs .,;; of the petitioners cannot be protected without the ~v'ariance requested. STATE OF FLORIDA) SS: COUNTY OF DADS ) • • COMMISSION EXP I R NOTARY PUBLIC. STAT' COMMSbiy1�1 J 3 `' 4 PT. U. � 9 K4r .�� TM'����� ,.0“,1*.xN�1u 4 X1 : : RobeT, Federman & Cindy S . Lederman �..' =lY : says Thar he is the Wwnei) tegiatiOnbeineCCOMMKerCiUtht real . p tt� answer to question d 1, above; that he has` read the foregoing esnevvars end this! true and complete; and Of acting as agent for owner) _that he has authority f petition on behalf of the owner. —i. X (f) The grant of the variance will be in i with the general In purpose of the Zoning . Ordinance, and- will not be Injurious ., ta neighborhood, or otherwise detrimental to the public welfare. The variance, if granted, will result in an enhancement o f,. the aesthetics of teh subject property and can only enhance the aesthetics and property values of the neighborhood in which. it is located. The granting of the variance will • enable the reasonable use of the property. * Note: AU documents, reports, studios, .artdbits or other submitted to the.Zoning Board shah be sttbmitt+id with I A LImi tv STATE OF =REA.) on= OF DADE ) Before me. the undersigned authority, this day personally appeared R o b ert- Lode an ari C ndy s. , who being by me first duly sworn, Lederman upon oath, deposes and says: 1. That he is the owner, or the legal representative of the owner, submitting the acc.. application for a public hearing as required by Ordinance No. 9500 of the Code of . the City of Miami, Florida, effecting the real e. Ly located in the City of Miami as described and listed on the pages attached to this affidavit and made a part thereof. 2. That all owners which he represents, if any, have given ;.heir Bill and complete permission for him to act in their behalf for the change or modification of a classification or regulation of zoning as set cut in the accompanying petition. 3. That the pages attached hereto and made a part of this . affidavit - contain the current names, mailing addresses, phone numbers and 1, descriptions for the real t ....r... !., which ' he is' the ; owner,. or, legal representative. . The facts as represented in the' application`.aad' doers subrd.tted in conjunction with this affidavit are true.and correct. • A. P F ta710i I "f Flirther Affiant sayeth not. Sworn . to . and Subscribed before me this `l. day of *tar ,ruf L9 . - 29/44- 1 1--ec- 6 41-1-14 " Notary . Public, Mate of . Florida at Large My Ccimtirsion Expires: NOTARY P . STATE Of FCORIEFL ' 61{ �;J,;I;alo.aq EXPIRC5:.SEPT. 2B. 1992.. • RONOLO TMRII aOTART , UMORRWRITRN 4 • Owner's Name MailingAddress telephone Number Legal Description: Owner's Name Mailing Address . Telephone Number Legal Description: Owner's Uame Robert _Lederman_ and Cindy . S. Lederman Mailing Address 15020 S.W. 89th Terrace Road telephone Number 305-595-1911 Legal.DesCriptiott: Lot 9, BRAGANZA PAM P. B. 76, Page 17 40 Any other real estate property owned individually, jointly, or severally (by corporation, partnership or privately) within 375' of the subject site is listed as follows: Street Address Street Address Street Address Legal - DesCriPtibnl:' ----- Legal Description OWNtR'S_IIST Legal Description • None y ru STA= OF FLORIDA ) SS: COCOA OF DADS 4 ") SIORM AND :a u before ma thin -3 day of: 50404y , ,i98 j. mass= ,i , 'I S $ otscitsura Or OWNEIVIIT STAITAw ' t S►Ql1;° 1. Legal description and street address of subject real r 'w r 4a,.ri Lot 9, BRAGANZA PARK, P. B. 76, Page 17 3893 Park Avenue 2. Owner(s) of subject real property and percentage of ownership. Note: City of Miami Ordinance No. 9419 requires disclosure of all parties aving a financial interest, either direct or indirect, in the subject matter of a presentation, request or petition to the City Commission. Accordingly, question 12 requires disclosure of all shareholders of corporations, beneficiaries of trusts, and/or any other interested parties, together with their addresses and r .... r ....tionate interest. Robert Lederman and Cindy S. Lederman, his wife - 100% 15020 S.W. 89th Terrace Road Miami, Florida 33196 3. Legal description and street adciresb of any teed pr.ope: t ( n ) owned by any party listed in answer to question *2, and (b) located within 375 feet of the, subject real property. c o— CWNER OR t&i..i.WAINC•L FOR Robert Lederman and Cindy S. Lederman , being duly sworn, deposes and says that ne is the (Owner) (Attorney tor Owner) of the real property described' in answer to question 41, above; that he has read the forego answers and that the same are true and omm lets; and (if acting as attorney, for owner) that he has authority to execute this Disclosure of Ownersh form on behalf of the owner. AEI • • CONS& i.Z . 1:0 P1 ITION 2 v FIWt'7 ALL MEN BY, THESE PRESENTS, that SAYMONO ROBINSON ana SUZY':, ROBT? +9G_ the owners and ., occupants of the .}.rope _•':y located,.dt;3895 tear); a vH: :ue, Miami, Florida. hereby . con. ent . ,to the., petit .c for filed by Roh : der]!an and Cindy 5..: respect to the props_ adjoining ours, . located ash. s3s: j . wherein a variance is Bought reducing the . interior side _l _ina _ :aetbnck from a requirement of 'five - feet to d minima z a't . * point of the cverhan , of one e tnph. ' Qatari this day of .%0 .._: R -inson Suzy Robinson .. „. 3' '�rn to and 41lbscribed before clay of 19 gots of Florida Wires Doc. 6, 1992 Tim Troy fain • Mows,* Ma 1 } a A/r4 Notary PUblic CONSENT TO PETITION FOR VARIANCE KNOW ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS, that RICHARD KILLIAN, the oWnet'and of the property located at 3875 Park Avenue, - Miami, Florida, hereby consents to the Petition for Variance filed i by Robert Lederman and Cindy S. Lederman, with respect to the , , property adjoining mine, located at 3893 Park Avenue, wherein a variance is sought reducing the interior side lot line setback hard Killian a: requirement of five feet to a miniinura, at one point. of Overhang, of one inch: . • , • _ • „ '• Dated this - . • • • . day of - s-/ P "41. , . • - „,. Sworn to and subscribed bettors, meOn this 1 day of /144 .IA4;1 1. 19 ! ROBERT LEDERMAN V./ Orr: n, ex,rxe! Dec. 9. 1011 4onam Oro Wary Crow 1001110111t11 LA diCiow., 15. 16. 17. ite Zdning hearing March 23, 1989 - City of Miami Propery at 3893 Park Avenue, Lot 9-Braganza Pk We, the undersigned, oppose the request by Cindy and Robert Lederman for variance at 3893 Park Avenue, Coconut Grov , Se;teet-i- m3 P apet e 4. ci ID V'6)-4 tw-c 31 4.aA PI_ 7 Aa 9a/ 6 otA.4.(0-fr- :? L31 a 39.7/ , # , .i4- 3t Panic, ewe_ 2955 3'q '4 3813 ' PaA lak) 0 FSD '3 9.TO Pctricke_. 18. <Z4-0-4--e-1-)<...., 5 fo/ 19. A4 -cesCA-14 20. (1)3144 39qt ace bear Sirs and Mesdames: I am opposed to the request by Cindy and Robert Lederman of 3893 Park Avenue for a zoning variance. I ask the City Commission to hear the opposition of the majority of the neighbors and to deny the Lederman's request. The ordinances exist to insure the integrity of the Grove an the privacy and value of our homes. The changes requested by the Lederman do mot justify a variance. Please help us preserve these ordinances designed to protect us from encroachment. March 21, 1989 Respectfully ; Doris..Prout 3921, Park ;Av- Submitted into the record in connection ltem9Z ' 17 : on of the zoning restrictions that exist to protect the neighbors' property values and to protect the integrity of the Grove. We welcome the Ledermans as neighbors — but not their garage. We ask the Commission to deny their request. To the Miami City Commissioners: It is time for the residents of south Coconut Grove to stand firm to protect our neighborhood. We need to stand together to say a loud "NO" to the erosion of the zoning laws that threaten our properties and their value. I am not moved by the request for a vatiance by the Ledermans of Lot 9, Braganza Park. They have not been faced with a sudden and pressing n eed to expand their home. They have bought a home and decided to expand it , in spite • March 22, 1989 Sincerely, Submitted into the public record in connection with item PZ - Ion 3101 3leg? Matty Hir City Cler Dear Sirs and Mesdames: I am opposed to the request by. Cindy and Robert Lederman of 3893 Park Avenue for . a zoning variance. I ask the City Commission to hear, the opposition of the majority of the neighbors and to deny the Lederman's request. The ordinances exist to insure the integrity of the Grove and the privacy and value of our homes. The changes requested by the Lederman do not justify a variance. Please help us preserve these ordinances designed to protect us from encroachment. Mak March 21, 1989 Respectfully,' Doris Prout. , 3921 Parklv• Submitted 'into the record in,-cOnnection iternVZ ' 17 On Matty. Hirai City Clerk To the Miami City Commissioners: It is time for the residents of south Coconut Grove to stand firm to protect our neighborhood. We need to stand together to say a loud "NO" to the erosion of the zoning laws that threaten our properties and their value. I am not moved by the request for a vatiance by the Ledermans of Lot 9, Draganza Park. They have not been faced with a sudden and pressing need to expand their home. They have bought a home and decided to expand it , in spite of the zoning restrictions that exist to protect the neighbors property values and to protect the integrity of the Grove. We welcome the Ledermans as neighbors — but not their garage. We ask the Commission to deny their request. •■■•■••=1,11•1•1.111=1 March 22, 1989 Sincerely, Submitted into the public record in connection with item lie svi !Ion 341 0 Matty Hirai City Clerk €39-3 March 20, 1989 Respectfully, As a resident of Park Avenue and of Coconut Grove, I ask the Miami City Commission to deny the request of Robert and Cindy Lederman for a zoning variance at 3893 Park Aveneue. Their arguements of hardship, security and aesthetics do not outweigh valid reasons for maintaining the present zoning restrictions. Submitted into the public record in connection with item " I 1_ on3lasIZI? Natty Hirai City Clerk 1 1 1 Dear members of the City Commicssion: I am opposed to the zoning variance being considered for Robert and Cindy Lederman at 3893 Park Avenue on the grounds that it encroaehes on another's property within one inch and that it would t a precedent e den ect within the neighborhood. No matter how "aesthetically pleasing" garage might be, it certainly could not possibly enhance the value of the adjoining property. I would be very upset if they were trying to build within one inch of my property line. If their request for a variance were approved, I feel that other neighbors would have the right to ask for variances. If we agree to this request, how can we reject other requests — especially those that show a greater need? I feel strongly that the clear opposition of our neighborhood should influence the committee to deny the Lederman's request for a variance. Submitted into the public record in connection with item92 -11 onja 3124 Matty Hirai City Clerk Sinc ely , oi t J. Trigg Adams March 19,1989 Since I am unable to attend the City Commission hearing on March 23,1989, regarding to request of Mr. and Mrs. Robert Lederman for a zoning variance on Lot 9, Braganza Park, I am writing to voice in objection and to ask the members of the commission to vote No. March 21, 1989 Submitted into the public record in connection with itemP? • 17 on3 l23184 Matty Hirai City Clerk Sincerely, 4,; Lucille B. Tinder 3750 Park Avenue RE ZONING PROPOSAL FOR 3893 PARK AVE To the Miami City Commission; As a concerned citizen and a supporter of the few zoning ordinances in Coconut Grove, I am firmly opposed to the variance requested by Mr. and Mrs. Lelereman at 3893 Park Avenue, Lot 9, Braganza Park. They are asking to build a garage out from an already existing garage that has been converted into a playroom and a maid's room. There are certainly people in the neighborhood who have more legitimate' reasons for changes than the Ledermans, but they don't request a variance because they know the neighboorhood would resent such a request or because they value the special nature of the "Grove. I suggest that the Ledermans reconvert the garage and build a playroom on the back if they need a garage so desperately. Their "need" does not justify a variance, and approval would open up doors that would be hard to close again. DB Flitman 3920 Park Avenue Submitted into the public record in connection with item PZ - " on S i2 V Matty:'Hirai City Clerk ri Miami City Commission: The request of Robert and Cindy Lederman for a variance at 3893 Park Avenue should be denied in order to guard the few zoning re- strictions applicable to Coconut Grove. Although I understand that the Zoning Board responds to each variance request individually, granting the Ledermans a variance would set a precedent in the neighborhood. By saying No to the Ledermans, we, the neighbors, are saying No to any other residents who may consider building past the minimal distance and setback regulations. Please deny their request. Respectfully March 20, 1989 Herbert Vogelsang:, 3835 Park Avenue Submitted into the public record in connection with item P2 I1 on,3iaa Matty Hirai City Clerk tt g ISM hi Jsfh..i�E: I have asked Mrs. Kitty Proenza to submit my vote against the proposed zoning variance by the Ledermans at 3893 Park Avenue. I authorize her to speak for me if you need my specific objections. March 20th, 1989 Glenn Long Submitted into the public record in connection with item t " tdatt1r Hir City Cler rtr; I March 20. 1989 foi"'"N I am opposed to the awing variance requested by Cindy and Robert Lederman at 3893 Park Avenue and I respectfully ask the Commission to deny their request. Submitted into the p record in connection wit item P " i i on • '3 Matty Flucti City Clerk ".■ VIEWS OF 3893 PARK AVENUE AND BUMMER CIRCLE FROM TEE 808TR BIDE OF PARK AVENUE Submitted into the public record in connectio wth itemf. on atty Hirai City Clerk • VIEWS OF 3893 PARR AVENUE AND SUMMER CIRCLE FROM THE SOUTH SIDE OF PARR AVENUE 1 AIMAIXO rcm 4 Z ee - 89-305 Submitted into the public record in connection with item P2-17 on. 3k Wri? Matty Hirai City Clerk .4 Submitted into the public record in connection with item P on 8 473/r/ Matty Hirai City Clerk a to