Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR-89-1168J-89-1102(a) 11/13/89 RESOLUTION NO. 89`1168 A RESOLUTION UPHOLDING THE ZONING BOARD'S AFFIRMATION OF THE PLANNING DIRECTOR'S DECISION TO APPROVE CLASS C SPECIAL PERMIT, FILE NO. C-89-1301, WITH CONDITIONS, FOR THE PROPOSED OFFICE BUILDING TO BE LOCATED AT 2701 DAY AVENUE, MIAMI, FLORIDA, (MORE PARTICULARLY DESCRIBED HEREIN), AS PER PLANS ON FILE, ZONED RO-2.1/6 RESIDENTIAL OFFICE AND ADOPTING AND INCORPORATING THE FINDINGS OF THE PLANNING DIRECTOR. WHEREAS, the Miami Zoning Board at its meeting of October 16, 1989, Item No. 2, adopted Resolution ZB 111-89 by a nine to zero vote (9 - 0), denying the appeal and affirming the Planning Director's decision of August 1, 1989, to issue a Class C Special Permit, File No. C-89-1301, as hereinafter set forth; and WHEREAS, the Apogee Association has taken an appeal to the City Commission from the Zoning Board's decision; and WHEREAS, the City Commission, after careful consideration of this matter, deems it advisable and in the best interest of the general welfare of the City of Miami and its inhabitants to confirm the issuance of said Class C Special Permit, File No. C 89-1301; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF MIAMI, FLORIDA: Section 1. The preamble of this resolution is incorporated and made a part hereof as though restated and set forth herein. Section 2. The findings of the Planning Director set forth in the Class C Special Permit, File No. C-89-1301, dated August 1, 1989 are adopted and incorporated herein by reference. r� y Section 3. The appeal from the decision of the Zoning Board to uphold the Planning Director's issuance of the Class C Special Permit, File No. C-89-1301, with conditions, for the proposed office building to be located at 2701 Day Avenue, Miami., Floridan cra CQ �Q METING DEC 1998 .AM. more particularly described as Lots 1, 13 and 14 and the S 1/2 of Lot 12, CORNELIA M. DAY, as recorded in Plat Book 3, at Page 16, of the Public Records of Dade County, Florida, as per plans on file, zoned RO-2.1/6 Residential Office, is hereby denied and the issuance of the Class C Special Permit, File No. C-89-1301, is hereby affirmed. PASSED AND ADOPTED this 14th day of December , 1989. AT T XAVIER L. S R Z, MAYOR HIRAI City Clerk PREPARED AND APPROVED BY: � \VA & r.". G. M RIAM MAER Chief Assistant City Attorney APPROVED AS TO FORM AND CORRECTNESS: 4 JO GE L. PER ANDEZ —� City Attorne —s GMM/rma/M1281 4 0 7 C ZONING FACT SHEET LOCATION/LEGAL 2701 Day Avenue Lot 1, 13 and 14 and the S 1/2 of Lot 12 COBNELIA M. DAY (3-16) P.R.D.C. RECOMMENDATIONS PLANNING DEPAUMENT Robert V. Fitzsimmons <i 501 Brickell Key Drive, Suite 505 Miami, FL 33131 Phone 358-7707 r F f R0-2.1/6 Ru3dentiat-Office. a Appeal by an aggrieved party of the 'Class' C' Special Permit C 89-1301 approved by ttte k Planning Director with conditions, to allow 'a proposed office building on above site, as per plans on file. .n UPHOLD ' THE DECISION' OF THE DLEZan OF T M PLANNING FMAN; s - -1 01 Spqk. Permit Application for a proposed aftias =�4 building in RO-2.1/6 district at 2701.Q4y-:; Avenuewas approved based on the following f indLnp s The plans for the proposed office build P P ing tinrs,.. reprieved by the Building andZog Qapa�ptptt �: and were found in cmdormance with all t � requirements on 6/29M. An intended d41i"4i* was rendered on, 8/1/99 subject to; showing the eat location of tress 17 21 Pis• L-1 and A�-2 in order to V*caia the trees and to ossurs t.tw corsuet . proposed Pam spencer asd a S' .�'. coeicrste wall. ' facag OeQte &treat to.+aek = t#+1 r Vt Wr fTOM iii; CA cowl Dspltt seat Q►, rt+�e�sodPtlti f+tltrd Re the 3 AuttftS streets.. That Lett .9igp' �t��.�_�� J_�_1 Y__ll rl ___ _�J; ii'_':f Y_J �`..•la&x. xsxs Ss,'3. - accepting the parking layout including spaces 19 a 20. x The modified plans were found acceptable by the p Planning Deparmsnt as they met the intent of-thet 1/6 zoning district. Conditions including the exact location of ttaes; a S` mine coocrata wall facing Day Avaaae;. and compliance with the Dept. of Public Works requirements }' regarding the 3 abutting streets, were imposed on, the applicant to sd.igate any negative impact ti to the adjacent Msidantial proparties. x2. .. :.;L PtTELIG StGN1CS No comment • i DUDE C0= TNAPFI No comment. -ARID TRANSPOETATION Y 8 At its meeting of October 16 1989 this Zoning Board adopted Resolution ZB 111- xs�s 89 by. a vote ' i f 9 to O, denying .the apP�ea`1 Y and, uphol d� ng' the deci Sion of .the . P�'annitg Director. f One Proponent was present at.the meeting; etd three Opponents were present. _ = " APPEAL 'Letter dated October.30, 1989 frppt Robert Y: Fitzsimmons. f - �, } ' it T 4j•. •:A ' IS r �� 't''d ••st �` ' '0.� � ..dc n #'• rr::, d�.,• .;• s :5 '�s��; t fi..t r--r'"�t.,:��a, �rt r.�.,,r�6e€ a Ft.�:"� ��,5. �_j. �f +�i+� ujty. s s-,W'i�et, ry t ..�?r.ie ��, j,�, Y i.,� f -:� �t .. �a'y1'�'"• ': - 1 y aid; i lye•% "'t M144N'",MC4wt C� ..e��c � J k� r � � 1 ev4 �V�=j s yi f;. -:' f � 'r � r .t1t• "a ,f-r'akr��ta :�.5 � 'yt'-L a `'".mot y -fie° � �k�' t ' � � t�� r 4`�`� t � ��;,' � ,av� t - � �"'✓' �i `��'r �;� �� al. ,: r r: ry ar rn'.. 3 - 1w,�:r► 1 . 22 3- 2 21 9 + Q (.L as Z0 2 1� Cce e 20 �� W 7 6 9 .a ,. i� '�s',l e ' . � +a` t .x '.4� � T ,/ •'tea ;« _ y�,k 1�.. �•' .Y •� �X� � � i. 1� Yw• "+�.. 12 Y 'A - y.{�'. ♦�1 4 _ �t _ �"y.+•� �(• •� _ \ ♦ a •` fir!_"'� = Y. tea, .T � ~ ��'��• •- �" ° *�^�.� ,t � � . � � L� i �' ws;' �:t -2 j`�� �M,4tj. +" �.a, ♦ � 1 � r.r-. Y "� •. , a - ' r. � .r � _ •� F' 1, - ).,� .'yi4� � a. � ..!°t •-., k•k. µ s � �\ry. ..r .•�. _ •R"'aNµt'�A� _ AbAbnMW re lk clu ORR a .} r-. �. �X~. - ..,. t- � • �� fay. • �. '... .$ ±'4. cn ,►'N,¢ ^• •� ^fits ri.*aM�• �.. rpA AYE ; ;e; �►, . �� _ � hei t • .r" � it }�4 •� •i " t ' r i� ♦ ^. - Nam 40, t •�' I Y t� ..r�l�"i�i' � t 1 _ r , • .:a — a t•AµP� e ..: is a1Mt t � • fF � rM +vrZMc�- r Ms....tGloria Fox City of Miami:Building.& Zoning Hearings Board 275.N,.W. 2nd',street Miami, Florida 33133 Dear Ms. Fox: Please accept this letter as a notice of appeal; pursuant' to: Article; e- k>of ordinance .9500, of th+a Zoning Board de+cis'ion Octoberl6, 1989,':denying Apogee Assocati�nsC89®301:� ,rendered. the issuance of a, Class 11C special Permit, ernt n the :,pr©posed construction at 2�,01,•" Day' Avenue. fihe regea�,g . basis °of the appeal.,. remains the same as outlined = 3n my August29,i�t 19 89. fetter . - • =4;u� �< ass f nd: enclosed an Apogee µAssociation, ;no.chechiing Ple" i the filing . fee for a t� the amount of $400. oo, representing end: All ­ ,.future . commuhi Qations-regardin4ti. appeal . Please' . e t r, Thank you,r = aPOfficsr w.� - s ..' �,.ei✓l 1 .'t' ,. s'+ .. 1. E xuly Very tyoua x % V, rat Robert Z�o�e . �x r $p Q f f3 +Y F RVf/td }p a r ZnclQSUrG fiz ! OVUM-. 4$JAi9 .pan ti�. sS¢_r.. .._ ,. _.c a ,_-.:, - '.J ..•: __,,..,..�..... .-:� .,_.� ., -_.. ._ .. ... ,i. ,.. ..,.. � 3�1 .d..t �. sus — — s� R.OBERT V. FITzsni ANs, P•A- A,rMV UT AT L►a TUN CovnvO=UM CU14TRZ Stwx 505 501 Btuczuz Zzr DRWO WI&Ma P't ounw 33131 (305) 358-7707 Fwu (305) 577.8527 Auqust 29, 1989 Ms. Gloria Fox City -of Miami Building & Zoning Hearings Board 275 N.W. 2nd Street Miami,' -Florida 33133 Dear'Ms. Fox:. Please accept this letter -..,as notice on b�shalf o! the Apo9eoa Assoeition° of an appeal'` of the Class "C'! , PsraRitV issued ost t . lg ; 1989 " 'for the property located at 2701 Day AVOAUG is Angus eel is the failure y' Coeornit Grove, Florida. The basis of this aPPk `of- th design ._P lens to incorporate the lot abutting 27th Avsaut, ausuff iCient- number : of parking `' spaces as rqu' .. by code and a strict ve' covenant< due` to the location of tzoos on the and;<the intrusion into.,the d3.att'.ct of pzoperty resident3.a]. :of f-street" p'a=king without" adequate . psotisctiori for, - L Y neighborhood. surrounding - .. , •..: ee Associ�tt..ior►�. � xAc. cluck in Please f ind enclosed an q .. fee for this th►s". amount• :�+ot:,;: S'406-4, , , rppros=ti}nq the "`,fii�ang fin „ check i..indudad : b ec �►Pp4a�.. ° iunclear Er auss it s whe QX aN; tF appeal fai is necassas't atYe this time R {� - oun.ctaonm :ao .myffw# k Plmass direct ail uture� G s -- e • ... is - - .. I • _ �., ?-�,:r,.c� fi - -`k{� - • - �� 1' - '1�3? ' '' �°:� yr'-;. r g , ...N� ,� :t•� �� so��r�.c.�fo�I • aF t."_���Yr.. ...1 - .,. i > t. � ,. .. 5, �.._ .< .. _. ". 5. i :.r ` '4•k'x4 `i pft ,,?�}* .. -- - - 77 • .YtiLL 2=14insa) I C-89-1301 ... .N ry--.I�r • 25.OF OWD QMVWM9500 Aim A. �/m' mm•_... , .aP. pmit-uv .� I, I' df C� � Ott of Pleading face al � C ZmjM • p isof AtticJa 23 5 a the City of Miatni- s of Prmpetty. 2701 - t &=XM of Psopoa U" 2: AtI& Suet 46 ZmUnq 00.2.1/6 mrFlC�•_ Naum of l :: .... � �� ar. ��i of this applicatianL ch I attathe LCcation Mep Y �r _ ° my and -per .a —,? ♦ AM ftUy dimwxicml p}OrA with rights of vW - ttAd in adat X= to the tM seta Om set of places shall be � set of. pass Will be LU the Pluming foot the boil t' gha^ s ca the PrLnt- file and,11 hmm no am Fee of Painting Ml is SM disttiCta).......... ....=.00 c i ' =i.yrScs�leof to.br es� r. • ..................... $40.00 • ....... • �.+.r ..463000 0.0 gaeti,olz 2003.6...............•:.:..'.....•..........:...... $00.00 FEs-1 ...............:.._1 ` .i,_�31 4 / / 6 71 + I Ks'-2.1, -Z:Z: z:. � F:s-1.1. .7ii , 16. 16.1, 1;.z. 17 .100 11. 12: • 1.3: 14. 14.1, 14.2, fo= of groin 18= Seeti=s 2014. i, 2510, ZSll� -pe°�t of Imic ty� build amar based u the def3sLi (Section 3602)..........................................6300.00 mizimsa...............*so ...... net lot area..$0 .015 pD.U, po-W, VD-M, pet of ..$f0.00 ...:.........................- Al4C=4rmmm as __ of the S1O0.00 aAddcss 30000 MMM AVEW _ :. ph=ms 446-0223 City, Stmer Up: � 6ina. Fb 33134 _. ... - pgWVa PWWS 446-02Z3 to %3.1 die Itt Cam O . Sri 1, t1m a e l P& iic N=my Seal i40. R 900 Swosa as sub ad before me this 3rd dar of. JUUjtj� - ( • IOttRt "Kx vitt of I Im"A K W OCIANS S= . Y1w.t =Wt fi tst s i lby (2ad Ito m° thecaCMMpw thl B1�i.Ldit>ri and Z , this f om a C f bftda P psstiaaiant. Bait P Mal bV VIN D of. the PlM3xt3 tt>a of a Clasp C t. mast be Fa?+ �. by the ram. and VOW ' With all xontssQ ,_•" And hozm MOT"l, Dubs z _eieY •f tf+� • ..+�...r..... c w.. mobw C-89.130 ' •'if :ry►w AR It is UmUSSIS /��i.t td thar -CJA �C��S� =4 jt l- PWM&ta b0 sergtiX0 i wl� sp�icii3ad to plamim poi3l - The Dir®ctcr of the DgMm of PI&vvL vq shall be 80161y rspc,'nsible fat =nsirdernim of f=.C.lass C Spacial Pesmita. #Me Dine = shall males ouch refeaals to ;rust officers oar deg n 1. III - Its as are ngzind by =: to the s *s-4CjIIArqpwjal pezmit and my msias other rerfaaals dammed necessary by l Im bef m a=:Lving at his dscisi,an. (Ssctica: 2301.3) I MTT V: Ths Eisele �'..W4gt4C0 of the PlateniMjUzw= my be ammeled to the zwIM Bonsd, by any aggcisved patty, within fifteen (15) days of the dots of iawanos by filing a writtm appeal and appfligri ftg fee with Hsazing Db Uicn. Building and ZcrdM . 275 N.W. 2nd Stsall �t. Miami. FL 33228 (OrdirMM 9500: Sec. Pals: Yee X No : L. - AW SAM -EA= Adjamm =pesty 06MCS • exact location of trees Conditicaza: Yes X _ ma � 1�-2 arc h :robs to= Joseph C,snu wdi - dated 08/11/89 •—32-1-1— the of pwdsq layo= +*,_ xU sp�soss 19 i 20=. a 5' mine h84c m comtats «all faciM DW Ave. to block the view f = the R-O-W= and campUm= with the Dept. of - R.O-W 3sgavv a f= the 3 abntt4 stre�e�ts. Findings: An Intended Declulml for appzw' with conditions wes z�eudsrred on 08/01/89. The qttsd P� the � eoasct 1=m4 R of trm as zugawtsd above. XnaOsm FEWEMM�Y a'awn "M notifisd by the am] 4 f-M. par flee m*x" of the PI=SM Depsrt�snt, soma ob jecti+ona have fob �a6 � � The,d ;� pwject masts ttes irnrent dtxtriet. --- �,�.. .. y Appmed With [4mriir.4= DWANd is tv Gg ffN at a E. ,'- • jr DAM- •rr.... M + •• daT � hei= tr Tee'fL-= dul7 swum. tip= oath. dues 8rd says: 1.- That ha is the aw'. or• tha• I azal easat�.4s of tlss ,»s ttis 2ZW 4 C=: = fat a IM3W is hglrl= as hp No. 9500 of the Coda of thS =67 of Miami. Fl=-ah. effeccl tha real locased is tft City of ;�Si= as dALsce.0 ad ard at•=chli to this afV dzvit a wade a � thereof • Listed oa the pages . Z. 'ice all. c he repr eat,:. � auvo rive Si-rm Lair _. t1su c�niate �- for him to a= in zhe.:s I y =cr' •..".s C: ... Ai owl fs or - -.. of ag zcadas Set ouc :m �r �v of a Chs a pctiti= 3 TbIZthe ,e attss�d hereto aad cads a p= of t� a z c�sia the c, z games. =U.4= acidt—==. Zh= dascr��riflas for the rest p tt s cmw ar leg�i *as t� a* and Wr= . an { this of 5 {-. r .. _... ,,. _.,- •��0 Mrs WAIT MUC STAR IF nO W „ Eifflii�z: IT mown►. Tq1►. •t11A r �.1 " ts�e •Y fttt 1 i nq Address Telaa�+one Numbest Legal Oestrittion: LeflP60 �ZXAQ&m Owner's HM Mg114nq Address Telephoae Number Laval Description: '�ez'6w7t7eL #I Owner's - Mai l i ng Address Teleo = Legal 0escrzpticn: ow era ned individually. Joi of the severally Any other real estate P y Privately) wi37S` ..by corporation, partners ; hip or P g-• site is listed as follows: Legal Descrittion Street AddressArm - :? H� Legal Description Street Address �t 1 dgal.Destr#oti�t. � Street Address Y r fi fi 1.. LagaL dr t'= and street acdnras of svoject MAI paMertT & ZW5 2. Oaarts) at subject reaL pmcerey an • percentaege of ownerShin. . mots-. City of Miami Ordinars a No. M19 reguires disrlovas of all parties Ea-uq a financial interest, either direct or inditecc# in the suoje= saner of a presentationg request or petition to the City Commission. Accordingly, qumstion 62 requires disclosure at all shareholders of corporations. bgjjj&cjacj" of t=ms. aWor any otbgr ==usted parties, together with their adsitesses x2d pro%o�orti==a interest. 3 00 ,��lGa ez Su-t I Uo wkeov-v ivOC /LiLto S,� S1 C.0 24L 64P., ► 2n•�.� : S H�22y��f�i2/'� � C: l 6 � �v sS"S � 3 Q 0 f. c4Rfz I zz rnn • r9tiv�� 5 S �� � S � �u ��.��,�- 3. Leyal 6rsettpti= and streat address of any t vtat proper,,-: t , owned by any pasty listed in answer to question, : mU i b ? ; C X=Sd U Ltb in 375 feet at the subject real property. .a.. -a.. G� rL; 9F.,ZAqVV0 b issg duly swots, depases and saint tW an is tea. twear I t ttorney roc Owmc y of the real property dela i bed is arstnetr to gw Wim U , abmat that - he .has• toad the f=m9ci q t and that tft sms an == and oomlettet and (it actl a - owner) that he has authority to wmatte this Dlac2osaeae of 04rACSb#: fo= = behalf of the Omer. 40 _bet • . of ect :eai 9r 1. &we=. arA st c ao�ce�ats of suoj z4k(,,,� zmnmar a of c es* hip Z. Ow�ar(s) of subject real PTopercy 'p,pstcies Noe:: City of Ijismi ordinance No. M9 rea Cites avid a financial interest• either direct = irAiTeeto is the �� est or petition to tha City Cameumion. matter of a preeencationt lders of AACcordia9ly, �� }Z requires disciosnre of all started wtiss• 11 carp • of Chests.dlor and otnes Wgwcbw Frith their Zoo ,� hIERsiftgum and FrpO0ztt1°ca=° s,ntes�est. 300 rdP•dGtl� /0070 C , NOIw oo C� �erL�c.co s�,' 2Nr,� - 402 d1Z S t Al aAJTmrLr and street address• of any t -sa L pr'ap 3. Wq� drsc i t to quesLian s � • atau �. b 1 .6 cxstmn u �.•W is ovmad by anY PAY .` 375 tees of the suoj=t Teal FMQM' /�o AYE % . -46. -41.. ...n Iy' I1 . • .i r im ftly MOM, &*am and t ae tas . �rner� i ttorney =os Or�aer) of fte d ih+rd is aw"r to cligtp,M il• awma: thm' he,bw sag an tree mid Via= and t ii oto ., . � 1�t to eraeot�t� this Ds.b•""� � G� oxe n) ttiat he h{�&=e.swthosi zy . am behaU af the A vow ' • ems. - L ` Ar no= rr or 4 { 'i2 /G 4<) , being duly a=& &wme w tnsc tse .�s ttze auiy teo the oawr of the real pa tY oeuzu�eo u� answer to ttsan i• atxt+s+et that bs bas read the toregoiM atts"sca s that the same Aft true W%d pietes end tat Ile has tbs auth=i`CY to ate this D of Oars ship tm on bahalf of the owner. *- Lon (SEAL) SAS TO AMID 50�. b� this dl� �• loom el ,�uouc. gsa=e l+osy3a at Loup f lOtAmulat STAR low. . EOf f i'loo i j �f • �z ^t 'z E f i+* A s Ev x � *t b N.}�M .. .2.. .>_ _• ,n_,+... ..r _. ... �2: r .. �+1 _. � j_ .. . r.,r . .. s .. . f;Y ..� ....M+t_a..,s a F.x x. .M*..re av7e.n i � _ �rsrlr.w• ` ' - — •. George ga=kat Offered the following Resolution and Kt� moved its adoption• RESOLUTION ZB 111=89£- RESOLUTION TO DENY APPEAL, BY AN AGGRIEVED PARTY OF THE CLASS C S NING IAL PED gECTOR9 WITH APPROVED BY THE PLAN CONDITIONS, TO ALLOW A PROPOSE01 D OFFICE BUILDING FOR TOE PROPERTY LOCATED AT +3+ 27AND D 14- AVENUE ALSO DESCRIBED AS LOT 1 + -- AND THB S 1/2 OF LOT 12, CORNELIA M. DAY (3_ } 16) p.R.D.C. AS PER PLANS ON FILE; ZONED RO- 2.1/6 RESIDENTIAL -OFFICE. Ms. Elba Morales, the motion was _ Upon being seconded by - passed -and adopted by the following vote: AYES: Ms. Basila, Morales andMoran-Ribeaux Messrs. Sands, Luaces, Alonso-Poch, Dunn and Barkst - NAPES: None. ABSENT: None Ms. Fox: Motion carries 9 to 0. f i "r rr . 4 R V q y }"A r�-�CGT �ijY G R